Gravitas: India held talks with NATO in 2019
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 чер 2024
- India has confirmed holding talks with NATO officials late in 2019. Chinese state media criticised the talks saying NATO would trigger tensions and divisions in Asia. Palki Sharma tells you how India must deal with the alliance.
#Gravitas #India #NATO
About Channel:
WION The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
Love India from Scotland 🇮🇳🏴
Love Scottish from India
Give India a permanent UN security council seat. Respect from the Philippines🇵🇭🇮🇳
I don't see why not first listen to us we are the people not the government we need Donald Trump back in office this Government right now is not working for the American people we very much respect your value's and countries and I would love for you to have a seat at the table just know what the real people think and not what you hear from the media who can't seem to tell the truth
@@rosevitelli5814 Lol, she doesn't represent even 40% of the US, Trumpers just pretend they do, as though wearing merch and waving flags makes you a patriot. They hate/fear more than half the country
India cannot be in the permanent UN Security Council because India is a partner of the most dangerous country in the world right now and not matter the nature of the war crimes commit for Russia in Ukraine India is blind side and don’t want to see anything and continuing defending Russia no matter what because the number one priority for India is get the best Bussines for their country and do not matter to them that the gas and petroleum from Rusia they are buying and increasing day by day are full of Ukrainian blood, as you can see India is helping a terror state to commit genocide and impose a war with no sense to invade another country for honor Putin ambitions, and all of these is supported indirectly for India . Let see when tables turn on and some day China invade India if God may India pay and the whole work continuing buying from China because it’s cheap. Thank you
As an American... I cannot say more good things about the Indian people! ALWAYS the best people to be around!
It can be awesome or the opposite lol
@@hiddenleaf2 😂😂😂
As an American, indias constant habit of playing both sides, sickens me. They could smash anyone in Asia. Instead, they bend over for anything to avoid a fight. They're decent people, but, they're as "fair-weather" as it gets. They may be a large link in the chain of democracy, but time has proven again and again that their also the weakest one.
@@DansBuddhaBodega i'm sure you want India to "smash" Pakistan without understanding the consequences... do you even know what the taliban is? as if india wants a endless terrorism war.
@Kitty Cat 😠😠😠 Nani !!!!
From non-alignment ,we are moving towards multi-alignment which is great.
Yes but please let's not join NATO.
If you think you can play both sides you're in for a rude awakening.
Who is aligning with you?
@@aksbeixhev Russia was our ally and still holds strategic depth and india is coordinating with usa for mutual benefit. But for USA, they have always used other nations as proxies, in geopolitics everyone works according to interests,today we both need each other. So don't ask here for loyalty. Usa's hands are already soaked in blood.
@@aksbeixhev We don't play both sides. We engage with a broad range of partners on mutually beneficial strategic and economic platforms. But we are not and have never been a part of any military alliances. So kind of odd you think we are playing both sides. By joining NATO we are committing ourselves to others' wars which as an Indian citizen I will not support. And we have all seen what a pathetic and unreliable organization NATO is.
We have no enemies with India here in the US, I have no ill words either. Aside from the occasional spam call from India that your country also believes is a problem and goes after, I'm more then happy to be aligned with India as a American, my childhood doctor Dr Gupta was my favorite person as a child and a great person, if he can be viewed as a spokesman of the good in the people from India I think we could have a very long productive friendship!
Bro even we face the call spammers
Govt must catch them 😅😅
BRO i lost 33k INR
In India we have a very famous app called truecaller. I don't know if you people have that or not. But sometimes even truecaller can't filter those spammers out.
Hi! I’m from the USA. This may surprise you but we have a generally very positive view of India. India is a democracy, which we prefer. Many of us would like to see India experience an economic miracle similar to China, we would like to diversify our risk. And we have some shared values. There are American enterprises building factories in India. We respect that you have a remarkable and long history. My Personal opinion is that India should have a seat at the table economically and Geo politically. That doesn’t mean India should join NATO I just think they’re a substantial nation and should be included.
I would like to watch all the Western factories from China to go in India, India is not a threat for us, unlike China
Democracy has a week point
They grow slowly slowly brother.
@@RG-iw4c : slow and steady always wins the race
@@RG-iw4c Japan, south korea, Taiwan,
Americans are actually saying democracy is backsliding in India and India is an electoral autocracy. So keep your democracy drama to yourself. India will not become an American vassal.
Indian people are great human beings 👍🏼
Stop making these sort of statements. It's doesn't reflect well on Indians
That is why 70% of of population is still labelled as low caste and segregated against.
@aliya sulfi 👍👍
@@siempresonrie5924 can't judge entire nation of billion people with some unfortunate incidents.
Not really
If it wasn't for NATO Ukraine would probably have lost already
lol
@@johndicosta7993 I understand you disagree but could you explain more you may have valid points which I am totally open to
Totally agreed
It is the very reason why Ukraine is in trouble. The NATO expansion along the Eastern block is the reason that has caused so much trouble. And also it is natos unilateralism and revanchist nature that made it against Russia of today. After COLD War , NATO had no relevance. It should have been dismantled like warsaw pact
In 2008 we had Putin on record saying that all former Soviet States can join NATO. But later on he changed his statement because the NATO was making hypersonic missiles that would intercept Russia.
Russia had even asked to join nato
World should work for free Tibet and Hongkong
@Rahul Gandhi
Chaiwala Hei To Mumkin Hei. 🙏
and pakistan from pakistanis
Should also stop the continued genocide of the Uyghurs that china has been doing for the past five or so years.
World should intervene and save the Muslims from the genocide in Kashmir.
@@wanghui562 not just the western nations but the Middle East as well; after all they are their people and yet they side with the Chinese.
Only country on the planet who had both Russia USA UK and Israel as there strategic partners.... 🧡🤍💚 💪💪💪
We all know how desperate you want to be White and want to be seen at white.. 🤣
Shiyas s. Sir you💕🙏❤ are a clever 👍 man to give judgement about a nation in this universe. But why the people of this nation is always under poverty line with out proper food and health. So all the wealth is scandled by the political parties and corporate companies. So in the world most dangerous political leaders and the multy Millianers are in the that yr. Praise in your comment.
@@transmith5878 British looted 45 trillion dollars equalent resources from India during their colonial period. UK queen wearing world most priceless diamond on her crown that came from india... Colonial rule destroyed india killed millions .. they divided people in the name of religion.. they created pakistan and made sure india should never come out an armed conflict. Our defence funding is 2 lakh to 2.5 lakh crore per year... We have 2nd largest army and it's active for past 75 year... What if we pour that 2.5 lakh crore to our infrastructure development per year with in 10 years India could be impossible to match in development there will be no comparison... Just look at Pakistan.. they got free at the same time along with india. What is their current economic status nearly bankruptcy... Don't judge india man... We never went for conquering... We are conquered and ruled and looted... We will have many internal issue but as a nation we are one... Every indians are patriotic and gave thier life for country...i was lucky to born in here... If I have another life in that life too i want born and live here.
@@transmith5878 where are you from? Can you specify that if you are not ashamed?
self claimed lmao
I agree with everything but India need to start making their own weapons 70% of India weapons are Russian and we've seen how they perform in combat
Russian weapon work fine, but not with out western tech.. The Russian army has been cripled in accuracy by western sanctions since 2014 when they invaded crimea
exactly, it's clear the development money went to yachts instead of what was intended..
I could only imagine
India does make its own weapons, they make some really cool auto-loading artillery guns, they have a decent domestic arms industry
Being “neutral” is only possible if both sides agree to let someone be neutral… If one does not; well, Belgium can attest to what happens next.
It's more about size. If you are small, your fate will be in the hands of others. Big fish eat small fish, it is natural.
@@fungames24 You can try to tell Switzerland that! LMAO!!! 🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂
PS: If your statement was true, the world would have been united a looooong time ago! 🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂
How can Belgium attest to that? I'm really curious!
@@dirkgonthier101 if you think India is in the position similar to Switzerland; your not reading the room.
@@dirkgonthier101 During WW2 Germany went through Belgium to get around French defenses along the German-French border.
Tactically profound 🙏🏽
Respeito os caminhos que a Índia escolhe. Ela sabe os motivos dos diálogo com a NATO. Eu escrevi a tempos atrás aqui nos comentários sobre fagocitose relacionando a China.
Seja o que for que estiver por de trás das portas do futuro se estivermos juntos teremos chances.
Absolutely true mate
muito obrigado
Wat
We all need to stand together because people with too much power have a one-sided view.
@@savvys3768 ,,, because of this friendship and cooperation, Sri Lanka's scientist can be a "Taikonauts" in "China Space Station"😁❗👍👍👍
, India will be drooling with envy😭❗😁😂🤣
This makes sense. I'm grateful NATO and India are on diplomatic terms, talking about each others concerns and goals as well as being respectful to each other's position. Here's hoping a mutually beneficial course continues, blessings be from the U.S.A.
India is against NATO just like the US conservatives. NATO is globalism.
In any alliance there is the rider and the horse.can't remenber who wrote that.But there is alot of horses.
@@amossimon3438 true but nato comes with a lot of advantages for nations as well, as you said it comes with a lot of concerns but it brings strategic safety and allows countries to focus less on defensive roles and more in industry and commerce. It’s complicated
India was just talking shit about NATO not to long ago.
In my country we have a song that suits India "I have two loves but they are not the same, but I'm not sure which one I like more".
I hope you never have to decide.
🤣🤣🤣
LoL 😆😂
In my country there is a song which is the other way round it's like "everyone loves me and revolves around me and waits in line just get a chance to meet and talk" I think India is getting that important that no one can afford lose its side.
@@sourendutta8939 nope not yet............
I have many lovers. Everyone loves me.
Non-alignment may not remain possible to the same extent. Times change. India wants to be a great power.
yes india leans towards the west because russia does not have the same finances and technology like the west
India wants multipolar world, west dumbess have triggered it
I think India should have more of a voice and input on global powers as from an American perspective India is a rising power not just in its region but also on the global stage. Instead of putting its trust on western alliances it can forge it's own and cooperate with the west. Basically what I'm saying is that if China can do it India can to. Here and now India has the opportunity to shape the future of the indo Pacific in a far greater way than China ever could.
Well, I think you should know that India is already doing this in its Non - alignment movement but as of today some big powers are suppressing some developing countries like India by making bases and by trade war, so becoming a self - dependent country without initial support is kind of difficult.
Still seeking western validation, huh? Never listened to Modis speech yesterday?
China is a superpower, India is not.
We don't need nato..
Most Indian people dont want to be part of any western alliance.
NATO is not a reliable partner? NATO has been training the Ukrainian military before the war has started, NATO has supplied weapons worth billions and billions of dollars to Ukraine, and because of these trainings and weapon deliveries, Ukraine pushed Russia out of Kyiv and are slowing the Russian invasion down for 6 months. And this "Non-biased" reporter definitely know the reason why NATO is not sending live troops. Do your homework lady before you give non true reporting to the people, it's what you are suppose to do!
Russia invaded Ukraine....twice. Aid after deterrence fails isn't something to brag about. And NATO just means US. Europeans are lazy bums.
@@ramanareddy5831 You are right about the first part. But you are so wrong about the last part, unless you really wish for a nuclear holocaust.
@@pulse3554 So, then why can India act only on it's self interest but not NATO? It is simple facts that Ukraine got trained by NATO and has been supplied by NATO with billions and billions of dollars worth of weapons. It is also a known fact that because of NATO assistance, Ukraine has been able to hold the Russians off for so long and slowing down their progress massively. That is not setting a "narrative", these are just simple, well known facts. What this "reporter" says is that we haven't helped Ukraine out at all, which is blandly wrong. Also "NATO shouldn't use India, it should be the other way around" confirms how biased this "unbiased" news channel really is. I just didn't know these reporters could be so stupid that they would blandly say it out to the world like this 😂😂.
Didn't nato soldiers go to Afghanistan? Why didn't nato put it's soldiers in ukraine?
@@msdolly6101981 Due to the fact that smart people run NATO. Question: Why didn't Russia attack American and NATO military weapons transports BEFORE they entered Ukraine? Here is a hint, it's the SAME answer. Are there any intelligent people left on this planet?
I agree with Ms. Upadhay. India making friends with NATO - - nothing to gain and a lot to lose. India may not care about China, but don't antagonize Russia. NATO member countries have little interest in the Indo-Pacific, an area of main interest for India. Similarly, India has only a peripheral interest in European defense matters. So, forget about NATO and strengthen the QUAD. Don't drive Russia into a tighter Chinese embrace by making friends with NATO.
Nice to hear all your thoughts. We want the best for India. I think almost all countries think we'll of India and it's great people. Best to you, Dave
Russia also does military exercises with Porkistan. Then Russia doesn't antagonize India?
India should try to keep its neutrality for as long as it can, but I'm afraid that may not be possible given recent trends.
you know that NATO has binding contracts to help other NATO states in case of being attacked, right?
this help is not guaranteed if you are not part of this club.
INDIA SHOULDA KEPT ITS MOUTH SHUT. BUT WION, CRUX, HINDUSTAN TIMES, CNN INDIA GOT INDIA IN HUGE TROUBLE. GRAVITAS HAS PISST OFF CHINA RUSSIA PAKISTAN NORTH KOREA AND IRAN.
@@chickaboomboom2726 it is ok to piss them off.
@@stefanweilhartner4415 ok 👍
Save yourself first , attack on russia , if Russia attacks u,
First thing Nato don't have any big reach in Himalay and Indian Ocean . Except those who have ICBM,
Also in Himlayan high tech becomes useless, fighters jet can't fly above very convenient
Nato is paper tiger in Asian war,
@@stefanweilhartner4415 ,,, because of this friendship and cooperation, Sri Lanka's scientist can be a "Taikonauts" in "China Space Station"😁❗👍👍👍
, India will be drooling with envy😭❗😁😂🤣
“India must use NATO to further its interests and not the other way round”. I don’t think NATO will respond enthusiastically to such a game plan.
You want to treat India as chess peace and be pitted against china don't you? China just has to bid for time and it would soon outdo USA in pretty much everything but would USA allow it? India at 100 maybe should look a way to improve realtionship china and we can start with ending standoff in border.
They are good people, but no manners and not cultured people...
There is no morality only interest matters
Playing both sides, sooner or later this will backfire, when you need real allies, not strategic ones
I think India would eventually have to choose a side, but not any time soon
It is not mandatory to join sides where both sides not worth joining.
The same thing I'm worried about.
There is no such thing as real allies only mutual interest. Any country can betray another if it suits there interest. We will likely see this play out with the fight over the Artic
They have always tacked advantage of both sides
So basically what India talked about in 2019 and they shunned it now facing same exact problems India actually warned about. Lol.
What problem ? India is not facing any big problem from China or Pakistan .
@@herronwaskiadn8301 bro he or she might be pakisthani or a hater ignore this guy
@@ujaanpramanik1379 I think Palki is a she. Am I wrong?
India and Taiwan should establish a formal alliance with each other!【 Long live our fearless alliance of democracies, now and forever! Let us fight for justice and freedom together, my friends! USA 🇺🇸 India🇮🇳 Japan🇯🇵, Australia 🇦🇺 And Taiwan🇹🇼。】
India does not have that guts. It fears tension with china, that's why china is provoking it at the border
Why? India doesn't benefit from allying with Taiwan, only Taiwan does....
@@blahz7152 we will, actually. Taiwan has immense know-how in microprocessor manufacturing. Not even mainland China or the US can compete with the advanced chip manufacturing Taiwan has developed. The only question is whether we can afford it. I personally want my tax money being spent within the country before thinking about international aid.
Sure, only India can fight China for the free world!!
@@PlaYer-sn5or India only fights for itself because of its border problems with china.
I have learnt so much about geopolitics from wion. I don't even like watching news but wion is not boring and easy to understand.
Much love to India.
❤️🙏
Thank you 😊
Well said!
You want to play both? Goodluck🤣..🇺🇦💛💙💯🇹🇼🇵🇭
Indian squad up with NATO that’s some big news I think it’s a great idea
Yes true!!!
Well said. Thanks
It’s a great opportunity for India to work together with NATO alliance, theres a lot of technology and goods that can exchange hands enriching both.
USA and NATO are not reliable.look what they did with Ukraine.
Yes, emphasis on your last word "both."
It's all fun and games until China /Russia kicks in the door then everybody's wanting to know where America's at all of a sudden
China might try but never Russia.
like Ukraine is wanting to know, like kurds wanted to know and like Taiwan will soon want to know.
@@akshaypradeep5079 I agree it was definitely BS trump turned his back on the Kurds Ukraine on the other hand I'm not sure what you mean we have definitely sent a ton of assistance. Taiwan I would say it wouldn't surprise me if we actually send troops to help Taiwan
😀 poor Ukraine, trying exactly that , last 5 months
@@msdolly6101981 Ukraine has greatly embarrassed Russia. Indian government officials have admitted that Russia looks weak.
We must engage with all.
Great report. Thank you.
Ukraine has benefitted massively from being a NATO partner. They would be a Russian territory without NATO equipment and intelligence. NATO is reliable but specifies it’s commitments.
NOPE only USA weapons making Giant(company) get benefitted At every war USA is the one who got benefitted ultimately (" _ ") 🙂
Right?! I was like huh?? What is she talking about?! NATO literally was training the Ukrainian army before the invasion. There is a reason why after half a year, they are still able to fight and why they were also able to push the Russians out of kyiv.
She doesn't know what shes reporting..
When it comes to europe she often has no idea what she is talking about. Having said that, nato is north atlantic and defensive and should stay away from asia pacific. China is indias problem. India should understand that asias problems are not the worlds problems.
The reason the Ukraine is getting invaded and destroyed is 'cuz of NATO and it's carrot approach towards them,NATO and U.S is using Ukrainians only as cannon fodder to weaken Russia you think rest of the world don't see it? Lol
India doesn't have to choose any side they should pave their own path. Stay stro go your'e own way don't ever be colonized again .Russia has never done india wrong hope they remember that NATO is USA controlled and they're strongest ally is UK
Except Russia has proven to be treacherous and broke their agreement with Ukraine to not invade but secretly invaded in 2014 and then admitted it later. Russia has a history of invading its neighbors not too far from India. Remember that.
@@eminencerain848 russia has done treacherous things but so has the west, from indian point of view, both are the same in the treacherous sense, and russia has never harmed us and has even come to our aid when the us and uk sent their warships to intimidate/attack india, it is the us/west who backed, funded and armed pakistan for decades as pakistan tried to invade india several times and commits constant terrorist attacks against India, and china is the problem it is today because the west chose to use an communist authoritarian regime as a manufacturing hub for profit which led them to be the threat they are today, it is the west who has to earn indian trust first
@@eminencerain848 India has been "safe" relatively speaking by not having a border against Russia. Then again, the bordering countries between India and Russia arn't very strong if Russia would grow an appetite in that direction. Lately they have been busy elsewhere though. India already got China as a conquest hungry neighbor though.
Yes one day we all dream to live like Russia....NOT
As a matter of fact, after colonisation India's technology and knowledge rocketed forward, whilst they were taught a way of central democracy management allowing the country to unite and develop rapidly.
china : we have rahul in india, call him he will speak our voice >>>>
French resident here, India bought fighter jets from France recently,
Ukraine is a perfect solution for stopping Russian threat. India also is the perfect solution for the west to handle Chinese threat. No nukes landing in European and US homelands if worst comes. US think tanks openly talk about it.
And then Americans ask that why India doesn't take their side against Russia.
Exactly, this is the reason, almost all Indian govts since 47 did not trust US or NATO, as they do fight great wars valiantly, but are not ready to sacrifice their people to win. Now, as per US think tanks and Marco, India can be used as a platform to HANDLE China, and if time comes it will be India who will take all the casualties and most chances are it will elevate to nuclear war 🧐
Growing clout of India & Indo-Pacific interests would take the cake.
We should hold regularly to know each
Long Live Democracy and India
China said the truth. India should not allow Asia to be divided and used by NATO.
China is challenging and trying to divide any country or alliance around its borders, that s what USA is so much praised now, Chinese troll
NATO is not dividing Asia but China ! China want Taiwan, they want isles owned by their neighbours ... they want eveything, it's called 'expansionism' they are the biggest threat in Asia, do you prefer be used by CCP ?
Yeah so let it be ruled by china.... Lol
Never trust someone that's playing both side!
India is not playing, as India don't join NATO. India doesn't want to win NATO trust.
India has own ground,
Its europe who is buyung the Russian gas and fertilizers and to help the ukraine😂
What do u called it??
Thats why no one here trusts the US. Coz it was playing both sides when it comes to India and Pak for over 4 decades.
Amen 🙏
Great!
I always smile at how in Chinese media India is depicted as a clumsy anxious elephant. It's ignorant at best, condescending at worst. Just to add, elephants are neither clumsy, nor anxious. They can be a brute force, but can be as sophisticated as to be able to paint and caring and societal just like humans.
I always smile when India is depicted in Indian media and social media as a 'superpower'. On what basis, I ask myself. Then I remember some people are prone to exaggerating and emptily boasting. So, that is OK. Makes them feel less inadequate. Cool.
@@k.k.c8670 i always smile when I read such comments of ccp fanboys and think do they even have uncensored internet access in their country.
@@k.k.c8670 try searching for 'tiananmen square june 4th 1989' if you don't believe me.
@@kruttichhwas right after you try searching for 'Gujarat 2002'
@@kruttichhwas I am sitting on my modern high tech toilet replying to you. Do you have a toilet yet or do you still do your business in the open?
India has succeeded with its non aligned policy since it’s independence from Britain, it wanted to forge its own path in the world and not be dominated or reliant on America or the West in general, however that policy was made over seventy years ago, the world is vastly different place now. Indias attempts to play both sides, has in the past worked well but to continue supporting Russia when it has invaded and occupied a sovereign nation, slaughtering men, women and children in the process is, I believe reprehensible and very short sighted. Russia is now a dictatorship, as is China. India can not keep living in the past, it has an important roll to play as the worlds largest democracy. Wake up India and earn your place at the top table and get off of the fence.
It is not short sighted. People were getting slaughtered in iraq and Afghanistan but western nations made it their playground. So please don't preach when someone does the same to you.
The best example of western hypocrisy is eastern Pakistan which later became Bangladesh.
When india helped Bangladesh win its independence you should see which side of the ugly history all these holier-than-thou western nations were, especially usa
India and indians would do best to never forget the history and learn from the past
Hahah yeah policy for india? Let’s just give it some toilets instead
@@Aftermath-News lol policy 😂 🤣 you are woefully misinformed.
Do you know that indian defence attaché has unescorted access to pentagon. No other country in the world has such access. Not even the air force chief of usa has such access.
So, india is winning in its diplomatic policies in all fronts. Quiet literally.
India doesn't need to earn its place at top table. India is at the top table and no country had the power to ignore it. No matter how much they may wish it.
As for the toilets , what's wrong in providing our poorest of the poor sanitary access. its how welfare schemes work. It's government job build up the nation. The government did marvelous job of it.
Even US killed women and children in Iraq Syria Libya Afghanistan. Nobody asked India to stop supporting US
And USA has not done such invasion? Your country has bombed more than 20+ countries
The Vice President of the USA is of Indian descent. You won’t ever find that in China or Russia. Some talk the talk but only one walks the walk.
Friends of enemies are enemies
China repeatedly forgets India is an independent country,and not a province of China
yes aunty they are so arrogant
China can't defeat Taiwan, forget India.
"India must use NATO to further its own interest and not the other way round" interesting!!! After bashing the west because of their own interest now she wants to do what she doesn't want the others to do.
"Hypocrisy" isn't that her favourite word!
She thinks that India looks smart by buying cheap gas from Russia while Europe is spending trillions to stop financing Russia war as fast as possible.
Why use one another, can't the two pursue the common interests
LMAO and people say it's unbiased journalism.
NATO isn't easy to be manipulated as she thinks, and western powers have much experience in getting things done
You got it right.
Super 👍👍🇮🇳🤝🌎🤝🌍🤝🌏🇮🇳👍👍
India must never fall to NATO.... this is the lands of the God's ... not the creatures of earth to destruct India culture
In China, (1) the state can force Chinese nationals at home and abroad to carry out military activities in their respective countries (National Defense Mobilization Law, effective in 2010); (2) the state can force Chinese nationals at home and abroad to do spy activities in their respective countries. (National Intelligence Law, effective 2017). Chinese citizens who do not follow the instructions and orders of the Chinese government will be arrested and have no option to decline.
Together, these two laws create the most dangerous security situation for every country.
There are at any time 25,000 Chinese professional spies in Japan. 🇯🇵🇺🇦🇹🇼🇺🇸🇯🇵
In 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre, China leaders ordered to kill thousands of student democracy demonstrators. 🇯🇵🇺🇦🇹🇼🇺🇸🇯🇵
Chinese agents contacted a Chinese democratic activist living in the US repeatedly warning they were tracking her every movement. They threatened to kill her and harm her family in China if she didn’t stop criticizing China’s leaders. 🇯🇵🇹🇼🇺🇦🇺🇸🇯🇵
Ukraine didn't want to become a NATO partner, only a EU partner, Russia attacked and invaded because they thought Ukraine would join NATO. India doesn't have to join NATO because they have their hands full at it is, what they need is to reinstate SETO and become a partner to maintain peace and security among it's boarders with other SETO members. If Taiwan, South Korea, the Philippines, Japan, Hawaii and Australia to join SETO do joint missions and training, China won't stand a chance.
Ukraine is a dead man walking.
Hawaii?? Hawaii is a US state..lmao 🤣😂
Zelensky was confident of joining NATO even after Russia invaded Ukraine.
You don't follow the news at all. Or you follow the news but choose to falsify it and spread lies.
We could trade them out for state to be named later. Say maybe British Columbia.
This channel is |ndias mouthpiece .. will always respect UK
Dear Palki, one should be careful that others do not begin to feel like they are being used. That could be very unfortunate for the country that one day made need a friend, and the friend is not there. This may be happening in the world today. Best to you, Dave
Taiwan and the U.S knows what you are saying. If it gets to hot in the kitchen Taiwan your on your own. We will sit back and judge your effort. Must be nice not having any skin in the game. Not very noble thow.
India need to find allies not partners!!! Cause Nato anytime will give you back if USA see more Indias success.
India needs to pick sides if they want allies
@Bigman hr India itself is like a world.
India is more interested in better India than interfering in other's matter.
So there is no threat here.
This mentality is visible everwhere in every Indian.
India's biggest threat is those who live inside but want to fight for petty politics.
what is india doing with NATO?
We have to do meeting for free Hongkong
What???
India is global leader 🙂
They have the right to chair a meeting.
@@ganeshrawat2198
G0di Media will screw up your Gobar brain. 🤣
India should be stay neutral nver go Russian or Americans GODBLESS India
Well, the enemy of my enemy…
When a nation invade an other to political and financial gain, should be stoped.
So let me get this straight NATO offered India the alliance India don't want to join the alliance but they want to benefit from NATO's alliance no it doesn't work like that 👎🏽
India does not want to upset Russia or China
India don't want to get benefit from NATO.
NATO alliance is a joke, look what happened to Ukraine. Better be self dependent than rely on others
@@venatorgamer5051 India cannot defeat China without NATO
@@Papa.y0gi Ukraine is not a part of NATO so what do you mean look at Ukraine NATO was trying to be helpful and help Ukraine out and give them weapons they didn't have to give them nothing they was just being polite because Russia was trying to be the bully but to be honest NATO doesn't have to help Ukraine they're not in the alliance so what do you mean when you say look at Ukraine that doesn't mean anything that you're saying Ukraine is not a NATO partner and if it wasn't for NATO Russia would have been took over Ukraine
Wow. India ❤️ NATO. We need this alliance.
There is no such thing as "true" neutrality. It's fun to posture like some kind of moral-elite by "not taking sides", but both action and inaction have consequences. Further, neutrality only works when you are in a "winning" position --- as soon as India requires help, it will be remembered as a nation that chose to isolate itself for either entirely self-serving interests (i.e. leveraging NATO), or to hold some sort of artificial moral superiority. The former is insulting. The latter dispels any sympathy. Whether they take the side of NATO or Russia is for them to research and decide, but don't pretend that India doesn't share this world with the rest of us.
The thing is that now India could make a good impression with little effort, no one pretends that India fights against Russia. India should start by condemning the invasion of Ukraine as that is a independent and free country that is bombarded by neighbor Russia.
Virtue signaling....what does this accomplish? Europe didn't condemn Pakistan when it invaded India. It didn't condemn Jihadists when they attack Israel. They say nothing about China.
Let Europeans fight their own wars.
First of all, do not lecture us and tell us what to do. We are also a sovereign nation. Not a puppet like NATO and Ukrainian nazis who only follows US orders. Russia wouldn't attack Ukraine if it wasn't for NATO'S expansion. Ukraine had a chance to avoid it. But zelensky ignored what happened Georgia.
We are Still Purchasing cheap Russian Oil which one Of Reason Our Inflation Is less than Most Developed nation America, and Fall Of Rupee Is Still Better than Yen, Pound or Euro.
Russia is our all time loyal and trustworthy ally and we dont need a selfish jerk like NATO to play politics..
India has been asking Ukraine and Russia from the beginning, to sort it out peacefully. Russia was also ready for talks, its only demand was that Ukraine maintained neutrality!..
Chinese can play chess ,they have to realise originator of chess was India. India is having the support of both King and Queen but Chinese have the soliders to follow it.Soliders are helpless.We followed non alignment in the past now we will follow multi alignment.
Keep digging Palki! 😄
India should be there and be playing the nonsense game of let's sit and watch.Its only a matter of time before they are brought to their knees and begging for help
75 years ago when the Btitish siphoned out whatever we had after 1000 years of invasion and choas we were nothing.
We Indians still face a hell lot challenges but compares to others whatever we achieved was our own effort.
Indians dont beg for help
This is interesting
NATO and India need each other
Never in history has playing both sides ever ended in a win. If China invades India, I’d let to hear from you that playing both sides was a good strategy.
If China invades India then we will take them down.More than anyone Chinese knows it .
Well who invades their biggest customer
The world is circular not two dimensional and I am the centre.
they will never do this because it would be suicide for China.
@@pulse3554 Yes. Trusting in criminals like Putin who bomb maternity wards as a war strategy will end in a win.
Choose NATO- Change the Govt! As simple as that! We Indians shudnt sit back like Ukrainians n see our soil n people turned to proxy war zone...
Good stand India
Anything for peace is worth doing
Countries remaining neutral is best option for example Switzerland has never had a war and its the peaceful country on earth
They all have guns bunkers in most households and explosives on all bridges, definitely not peaceful, more like passive aggressive.
@@pulse3554 Britain had colonies all over the world. Many European countries like Spain, Portugal, France etc had colonies in Asia, Africa and South America.
@@superiorSam9718 Being neutral with strong military is the best option in current world because some countries escalate wars knowing other members in security alliance will help like how USA does and NATO is backing
@@superpoorpakistan7072 so it's time for European countries understand that those colonies are now independent, Europe should not intervene in their policies
@@mujunifred4757 Asian countries are fighting each other. Look at China, Pakistan and India. Now Taiwan will be forced to fight.
Why would NATO defend India if they're jus a partner and not an actual member? You have to choose a side sooner or later or both sides will both be coming for your head. I think we(USA) should stop military exercises with India, i dont like how they are knowing our military TTPs and not allied with us. Trusting a man hiding behind a mask is dangerous.
I agree we cannot trust them they will sell sensitive info to the Russians because they like them alot
India is powerful enough to defend itself from China I think its US which needs India to remain at least relevant in the Indo-Pacific.
Americans tasting their own medicine
Your name justifying your unsocial comment
I agree! They are not a trustworthy nor reliable ally
and this is how russia india friendship broke up
Palki sharma madam the best in explanation of world affairs ❤❤❤❤❤
India has been the recipient of highest aid from United States. The amount of economic aid, adjusted to inflation then, was reported to be USD 65.1 billion. India get help from other countries
Shove ur aid up urass
That is not aid, it's remittance from indian community working outside and sending some money back to their relatives in india.
@@S1996V HE IS ABDUL
Nope and lol and I bet 99% of money went to the USA.
Lol
NATO and India will never be a partnership. Primarily because of the idea why NATO was formed in first place, Russia. India has never ever seen Russia as a problem which is the whole basis of NATO. Having dialogues helps in understanding the views of other side. India has signed military logistics agreement with several countries bilaterally, but never with a block. So it's not a big deal.
India becoming rich and powerful favors the world.
A brainy, God gifted intellectual. How spontaneously with common, soft words she can explain issues I wonder. Vagaban daughter. M R Chowdhury Bangladesh
India should visit Taiwan to show that your really with NATO and allies.
Taiwan is China and we dont want to join NATO. AND your NATO will never set a foot on our grounds
Indian politics and people are good people. But they soft and neutral. I'm sorry but that's how they play. If it's a duck call it a duck
Once Europe is off of Russian oil and gas, any country buying Russian oil and gas may possibly be sanctioned as well. I don’t see the West letting India use both sides. India think that the West needs them and I guarantee as a result of their actions, the West will find a way to work around India. They are not a reliable partner or ally.
Europe wants india regardless
That will never happen, india is the only one in the region who is big enough and has a large enough military force in the region to face china, by going against India, the west would end up pushing india, china and russia together
Well your geopolitical analysis is weak sister 😂
@@avi......2091 not weak, realistic
@@courtneyadkins1580 first of all it will take a lot for europe to get rid russian oil and gas cause pipelines takes more than 5 years sometimes 10 years to ve built
Even after getting rid of russian oil and gas west wouldn't be able to sanction india s-400 is an example , sanctioning indian will led to a great alliance of china-india-russia and other USA hating countries which will be deadly for west
And how can we forget that the west does so much of trade with india , if they sanction they will probably loose the biggest market, and their economy will suffer to ,
SISTER , sanctioning everyone is not a solution specially not india cause india is the only entry point for west in indian ocean and have many bases , there are multiple reasons too but i am not going to mention since its already a big reply
HERE'S A CORRECT ANALYSIS FOR YOU white madam
Never bet against the greatest idea of modern civilization! It is advancing while you contemplate.
Every time I answer my phone and I hear an Indian accent I hang up my phone
We can play both sides with our hands tight behind our backs and we gave Chess to the world, remember? we're the grandmasters in playing both sides 😉
Playing both sides can come back and bite you in the ass . . India . . . Whether it's America or China . . . And China has had run-ins with India before and I'm pretty sure it's just going to get worse or as time goes by .
Ok why are India so poor if u people are smart and don’t tell me uk stole all ur money lol
@@hahdhsh401 I mean which developing country is rich?
@@MILPICS saoudi
@@hahdhsh401 who else? Were it your grandsfathers then? Sometimes stupidity of westerners tend to surprise me more than when i realised India has been wealthiest nation in the world till 17th century till looters from U.K arrived here.
NATO is the most powerful military force the world has ever seen, and China is growing stronger
Playing both sides could be dangerous.
India should be wide awake in order not to be used and dump by NATO, and should beware of NATO's division in the South East Asia
What ?
Yep I agree.
It's not being used cause after all both sides would benefit from their partnership and this is politics remember, "not permanent friend nor enemy but permanent interested" it is not dumping it just politics and India would do the same should US be of no use to them
If India joins NATO, India would be untouchable. It's a massive security shield.
India should criticise Russia, nato is helping Ukraine, don't spread biased news .. .. if India wants to counter china , India should trust NATO, but not for ever. 🇮🇳🙏
Nope nato is a bigger snake than China.
India should trust india. By now they are powerfull enough to keep china at bay. I hope.. Nato, help ukraine as much as possible but stay out of asia.
How is Nato helping Ukraine? By sending weapons? The motive is not to help Ukraine, but to sell weapons to surrounding nations by showing Russia as a threat.
Its a proxy war America and some of the Nato countries waging against Russia.
Russia is not a democracy, but it is not an expansionist like China. Russia doesn't want Nato on their doors. Why can't America give that commitment to Russia and move on. So that Russia cannot have any reasons to attack Ukraine. And current dispensation in Ukraine is playing the American side instead of proper diplomacy with Russia. All wars are fought for selling weapons. If peace prevails, the arms industries will crash.
@@janvandermeer6159 for once India should not rely on Russian weapons anymore ;)
@@srinivasavaradhansudarsana7207 I disagree with you on various things, first whatever the reason the west has,
Wion needs to decide whether NATO is doing enough or not enough. We hear NATO is not helping , then NATO is doing too much, back to NATO doesn't do nothing.
Why are you implying that NATO is not helping Ukraine? enough, do you not recognize the threat of escalation and nuclear war?
I think India should revive SEATO l, and become it's leader. A neutral military alliance who shares point of view of India. A defensive military alliance to protect each other from aggressors. China, Russia, USA, Europe shouldnot join.
This is how we think. We dont want to have alliances with westerners or the us
if india was the leader of the free world, then all statements made would make sense. But its not.
The place is barely running and is a step away from being the next sri lanka.
playing both sides will leave india taken advantage from all sides and not progress at all.
NATO's partners are showing up for a chance of freedom and democracy.
If its all about business, then "BRICS" away... learn how russia plays with their friends.
One day, India will understand what would happen when they side Russia. Yurt Bezmenov…….
NATO - India looks Great.
Make it a leverage India.