She and her taxation, will be the downfall of bjp at center for next 20 years, few years back when some people say that she doesn't know, i thought no she will do it good, but now it's just q fall
Yesterday I paid 2000 in total as toll for 800 kilometres, 😢😢it’s open robbery going on the roads by the daaaku government 😢😢😢. This is on top of indirect and direct taxes I’m paying already 😢😢😤😤
And eat freebies like Pakistan, Afghanistan...chalo food, schools, health tk freebies chalte hai... But money, Free electricity,bus/metro ride etc jo mila le lo... We all chose to be beggars and beggars can't be choosers...
Salaries dont want any relief other than inflation pegged tax slabs and rebates pegges to inflation. Inflation is 15% which is govts miss management vut tax slabs remain thr same.
I tried to listen with open mind. Couldn't stand the arrogance and indifference in tone. Problem is with her knowledge, attitude, communication skills. Better get rid of her.
well buddy she is the worst FM of all time but we cannot deny the fact that things are not gonna change till the time people of India stop voting in the name of Free
We should support her....we are actually the main reason for our downfall..we want Free basics,we don't want to work,.So can someone tell me where this government gives us a free basis...???
Don’t know why I really can’t tolerate her. The moment I see her, I feel like breaking my phone but thinking about the tax on gadgets, I hold myself back😢
Salaried employees are the biggest victims in INDIA. We are more than happy to pay taxes and contribute to the development of the nation. But, as private employees have no job security, the government has any solution to the welfare of employees if they loose their job after paying good amount of income tax over years? As long as we earn, we pay tax, if we lose that income source for any reason, we are left on roads, which is unfair. With all due respect, I request if this is ever considered, especially the salaried employees of private sector, thanks
Even govt servants don't have security..... To reduce to expenditure on salary and pension govt has come with a innovative method ....hire contractual workers
@@manimalgaming17 What he meant is, pay taxes & work for the country who takes care of the middle class when he or she is in financial crisis.. In West, when the govt taxes you in big amount, when you are in financial crisis govt will take care of you.. Will that happen ever in India? We are more than happy to pay taxes but we want what we deserve. Here, if we go bankrupt, the govt won't pay any attention or consideration.. What are we paying the taxes for?
@@sawangupta123 I know what he meant but the problem is that everyone one is blaming more tax but no one is asking the reason. Freebies politics is making all this. In previous govt what we were enjoying in the name of subsidies is now what we are paying. Previous Govt took almost $400 Billion loan and where did it went? Tax was collected from the people who were earning 2.5 Lakh, where did it went? We were paying VAT as well as service charge which was more than GST where did the money went? Who'll pay the external debt? From where will the govt get money to fund $1 Trillion worth of freebies? Currently govt pays 27% of its revenue in interest and loan repayment. From where will this money come? Govt is giving subsidy and pension and salary to govt employees. From where will this money come?
@@manimalgaming17so what you are saying i clearly understand your genius knowledge what you said was true previous goverment bougth loan this goverment also bougth loan back than there are vat and cst which were single slab and they are 5 7 3 % which will be decided by stategoverment and cst is 2%collected by central goverment old income tax you should pay tax if you are earning more than 2.5 lakhs but there are more benefits which is not considered now as of now gst has six slab and even rice milk essentials are taxed even health insurance and mediclaims are taxed back then with low tax the economy was good what happening today why ruppe is falling against dollar can explain when western countries supports people its good goverment but if its happen in india you will call it as freebies go and get educated properly okay
Why leave the country, it's not nirmala sitharaman's country, we have every right to live here, like our forefathers did. Just need to get this FM out of the office. She is even making BJP voters like me to think about alternate parties.
She never elected by vote my brother she not even contest in any election though...she is selected by their internal party ...she only defeated ,if bjp is defeated...
All parties giving freebies . Salaried class people will only fight on Twitter .They cannot come on streets and fight for their rights . All Gov know this. Inflation is a big problem. No social security .No tax on rich farmers . No wonder people are leaving India .There is a need for Middle class tax payer party now in India. Middle and Upper middle class should stop / reduce buying things in India , plan for future etc. Decrease in consumption and GDP will ensure voices get heard.
We would also love to pay more taxes but there are below issues that tax payers are unhappy with - 1) "IF" and only "IF" it's not taken out of the system going down the drain due to corruption. 2) Businessmen earning 10times more and paying less taxes than Salaried people. 3) Paying taxes like developed countries and getting facilities like the poorest African countries. 4) Distributing Revdi to win elections out of our tax money 5) Extremely high Food inflation 6) Poor air quality 7) Lack of infrastructure 8) Extremely expensive Healthcare and Medical 9) Extremely expensive schooling and education
People are talking about income tax and she keeps talking about GST. The fact is that only 2 crore people are paying on behalf of 1.4 billion, is any government taking this up to make sure at least 40 crore people are paying income tax instead of 2 crore.
Shut up. Everyone is paying GST. Everyone is buying petrol, diesel, books, pens, foods. So, please don't say only tax is the income tax. Income tax only contributes 19% of total tax collection.
Also I need to remind you that the top 1% of rich people, hold 40% of the total wealth of India, the rest 99% of people only hold 60% of wealth. So, the top 2-3% of people paying income tax is very normal.
@SumanDewasi-fi9el , you can shut others up. Everyone is entitled to their opinion as you are also entitled to yours sir.discussion is about direct taxes and not gst or equitable wealth, we know that is already skewed so why not abolish direct tax and let everyone pay equally ., but that argument doesn't stand good either.
There are many in BUSINESS community (formal and informal business who can and should pay income tax but not, they very well know how to hide the same and cook their books
well then go and read their manifesto and you'll pray that congress never comes into power. They made a promise in their manifesto that they'll take everything from a person if they have a certain amount and will distribute it in the public. That means if they said 50 lakh then after that your money and land was their and they would've distributed it. They were about to introduce inheritance tax in which you had to pay 45% tax on the sale of your inherited property. So before saying the only reason go and read their financial understanding
@manimalgaming17 congress was in power say for what, 50 years? So they didn't introduce inheritance tax now they will do after coming into power... You are a strong Supporter of BJP and definitely a not a middle class salaried employee so you just want to defeat an argument...
@@karthikk6995 Congress itself spoke about inheritance tax ,Rahul made a speech on introducing new inheritance tax if they come in to power and would distribute it to poor. Congress didn't introduce khata khat in 50 yrs rule but they are promising now ,so it's in election manifesto
@kunalkashyap16 Not only money. I am talking about peace of mind. She has harrased so many people. A time should come when she has everything but no peace of mind.
If you are taking such huge taxes , then justify it by doing great work in India and implement all those money at right time and in right place 😶🙏 And for people who want to leave the country because of this and other reasons , it's our Nation it's our Country ....no need to leave our motherland because of those people ....we should be wise and vote for right person without being blindly biased towards any one political party .... This current tax system cannot justify themselves 😢
I am a middle-class citizen and a staunch BJP supporter. However, after reviewing BJP's 3.0 budget, I am ready to support any party that promises to eliminate Income Tax entirely from our taxation system, and I will never look back at BJP for the rest of my life.
@@mukeshtm1951 i am not responsible for the welfare of 110 crore people who dont pay tax and live off of govt welfare money which comes from the taxes I paid while i am travelling on potholes instead of roads, chocked sewers, completely built but non-functional waste management plants, air quality worse than a coal mine all while working my blood dry to get food on table of my family and dare to think of having a comfortable home so that i dont have to commute 50km everyday. if govt doesn't run on air then it should also not run on the hard work of 10% while the top 1% live as is they own the country
@@mukeshtm1951govt runs on indirect taxes such as GST, vat and excise. Income tax is a single digit income (if not less) in terms of percentage for the govt
You are wrong, Business people are struggling more, due to many new laws which is not in favour or any business people, many of the startups and old businesses are either struggling or have shut down, But if you are talking about big big guns businesses like adani and Ambani then I don't know
Corporate taxes are pretty high as well. But the fallacy here is that more corporate taxes will not do reduce the burden for the common man. Of course it will generate more income for the government and might lead to them lowering income tax, but the load of the corporate taxes will be passed on to the common man causing inflation to rise. Instead, the more practical solution is to broaden the tax base either by increasing productivity of people or by taxing a untaxed class(rich farmers). Either ways, the way out of this is to government borrowing, creating more jobs and increase wealth of Indians, not taxing the hell out of the middle class, especially if the government wants to boost consumption
This tax structure more similar to 1990's but inflation is going up every year. School fee, doctor fee, house rent, basic groceries, vegetable, petrol, electricity, onion tomato prices have all increased in 2025, but tax system is not changed. Consider GST refund for private employees who does not get any benefits. Tax slabs percentage should be directly proportional to inflation or petrol price, electricity bill,school fee, rice, tomato, onion prices.
This comes with power, arrogance, and with no powerful opposition; if the politicians actually pay the same taxes as we pay(road tax, electricity, toll tax, property tax, etc) - they will think of reducing taxes.
Praying tax 30% will be okay, when there's free medical services and education. In Bangalore it's terrible to pay medical Bill, and child education. For lkg students we are paying 2.5 lakhs per year, then school dress , books they're charging 50k.. so almost if you have two kids and salary is 25-30L and dependent parents, how to survive. All single tax brings tears in eye
Either they must apply direct tax or indirext tax for salaried guys. As it feels like double taxation when we go buy items with already taxed money and again get taxed on item we are buying.
GST has become a terror for middle class. Every thing we buy - like home, service etc the seller would say XXX + GST. Bhai GST Iis 18% which is ridiculous. A 1cr home (1.5 BHK in Hyderabad) becomes 1.18 cr die to this GST. And before people say 1cr home is “luxury” there’s nothing available for less in Hyderabad anymore .
Insensitive FM, India has ever seen. I pay a tax which is almost my 2 month salary. I bought a car of which 50% is only taxes. It means, am I doing job only to pay taxes? My neighbors ,who earn more than i do, just because they are not employees and enjoy income on agriculture and business get everything for free. I, like a stupid am forced to pay highest taxes. I have to borrow money only to pay taxes. And how about interest on it.
All parties giving freebies . Salaried class people will only fight on Twitter .They cannot come on streets and fight for their rights . All Gov know this. Inflation is a big problem. No social security .No tax on rich farmers . No wonder people are leaving India .There is a need for Middle class tax payer party now in India. Middle and Upper middle class should stop / reduce buying things in India , plan for future etc. Decrease in consumption and GDP will ensure voices get heard.
Reporter asked about job /income security for private middle class our FM didn't amswer it rather she is saying GST has reduced taxes...If question A is asked Z is question answer was given....govt sucks....
She very cleverly diverted the topic to GST. We wanted her response on why only meagre 2 to 2.5 crore people, mainly salaried class , are forced to pay tax out of 1.4 billion? Why retired people are forced to pay tax on their interest income out of their savings ? No answer. Abolish direct tax deduction from Salary or Interest income, increase it on expenditure.
Salaried person pays about 30% as direct tax and about another 15% (average) via indirect tax. 45% of tax given for bad infrastructure, corruption, inefficiency, etc. Why not tax rich farmers - those who own cars? Why not give the same exemptions of the business class to the salaried class?
sir only 60.81 lakh of total direct tax payers are in 30% tax bracket. Get your facts correct. They cannot give same exemptions like businesses to salaried person because businesses are wealth creators and generate employment. Their focus is to shift people to business class so that more private sector jobs can be created.
If the business man are wealth creator it doesn't mean govt should loot middle class tax payers. Lots of salaried PPL who even earn 30 lakh per annum comes under 30 % bracket earning 30 lakh is no big deal specially in big cities
@@secularkeeda93 and how many live in those big cities? Do you know the number of Direct Tax Payers? How much population of India lives in Cities? The biggest problem is freebies. Corporate are getting taxed 25%. Go and look at the countries who tax corporates 30% and their condition. If they tax corporates 30-35% then that'll create a situation where businesses will start giving excuses of job creation. Businesses are not only wealth creators but job creators as well.
There are farmers who have 100 acres but with no water. There are farmers with 7 acres but plenty of water how will one evaluate their income. No income security every year.
@@kanwarpalsingh5378 every year 2.5 lakhs crore industrial or business loan is waived off, as far as the farm loan, after 2009 60 thousand crores, no farmers loan was waived off, and if it was waived off it was at state level waving. 75 percent tax money goes to pay govt servent salary.
I dont understand, if Military does surgical strike Modi gets celebrated but if FM screw up taxes year on year why to grill FM alone? He understands Radar Technology to guide Army but has no say in mismanagement of Economy?
"Raahat" will come only when freeloaders on the nation (like our Annadatas or any such exempt lobby) can be taxed.. more people paying can bring Raahat to existing taxpayers.
why only middle class is taxed heavily? think about it. other democratic nations tax everyone no matter the income range so that there is shared responsibility in nation building and they question the authority since they pay tax. poor people in india pay heavy indirect tax and not aware of it. they don't question the authority when bridges collapse and for poor infrastructure. India is heaven for the rich to make enough money to get foreign citizenship(their only goal) when poor are left powerless and voiceless while middle class are being fooled loosing their wealth and health for nothing in return.
I am yet to get a convincing answer of Question: Why a business for which 1) raw material is subsidized, 2) other consumables are subsidized, 3) utility bills are subsidized, 4) product offtake is guaranteed and 5) process is insured by Govt; Yet there is no income tax and they keep entire nation as hostage at their free will. Yes I am talking about Farming.. I am not talking about small farmers, but about those rich land lords who roam around in Fortuners and Scorpios, brandishing their wealth in NCR?
Yes big landlords always suppressed our farmers. But now Government of India already introduced Minimum Support Price (MSP) for small farmers so that they should receive fair price of their products produced
Everything is free for them here in telangana, infact money is given away by every government to repay loans, farming subsidies, free investment for every crop, free power etc. If agriculture is unsustainable, why encourage it by throwing hard earned money of tax payers to create disguised employment? Either make it profitable or move on to ease the pressure on govts especially middle class.
Only state government can tax agricultural income as per Income tax act 1961, ask Haryana govt to tax farmers but they cannot as only Gurgaon farmers are rich because they have rich clients who pay for their vegetables and fruits.. But rest of the haryana farmers are not that rich... Hope this helps
The worst part for this taxes case in INDIA is.....when we buy a vehicle, we pay life tax, road tax but still if you want to drive your vehicle on roads, we need to pay toll tax😂😂😂
Whenever these guys are cornered with a critical question they start blaming the previous government rather than answering the question on the current condition. This applies to both the major parties. While electing we have to choose between bad and worse now however even that identity keeps switching in these parties.
As a salaried middle class person myself, the frustration is not so much about paying taxes as it is about the poor quality of life and services we get in return. Even countries like Malaysia and Mexico have better infrastructure (city roads, traffic management, green spaces), cleaner air and water, etc than any Indian city. And i don't see any collective vision in our political leadership to address this holistically. Merely throwing money at the problem in schemes like Smart City don't have any meaningful impact. I have lost hope in my (Karnataka) state government, municipal corporation and MLA who just seem to exist without doing anything. Corruption continues to be high in state govt interactions (property registration, RTO, etc). Property prices, rents and school fees are increasing exponentially year over year, whereas salary growth is in single digit percentages. Hence, the easiest thing for the middle class is to blame the central finance minister and IT department for taxing us.
The problem here is not paying the Tax, what is the benefit that we are get by paying tax. Maybe you can consider providing free health care for taxpayers in salaried class etc. Which you dont want to do for sure.
I am not able to understand how come in a country of billions and country of trillion dollars economy have only few millions tax payers. When will the government be able to get tax from the rest of the country?
Since previous governments did nothing to collect taxes from non-payers, this government is likely to continue the same approach. I don't understand why Modi Ji isn't considering a change in the Finance Minister
30℅ tax in city with single income family is getting difficult to survive. Like USA we should have higer tax slab option for married person combined return fillings.
How shameful it's, charging 18% GST on Insurance is justifying?? People are buying insurance for their social security while Government failed to provide a better health facilities in the government hospitals 😔
Even if they are lapdogs at some point they will be forced to bark and bite their owners, now it's just barking tomorrow the situation will force them to bite. Truths cannot be hidden for so long.
All taxes paid by us going in corruption. I have seen same roads being reconstructed all over India again and again inspite of roads being in good condition. Modi ji, Request you to bring Young Educated Energetic bloods just like Trump bringing Ellon Musk, Vivek Ramaswamy, Ramakrishna, Tulsi, JD Vance. Also there is so much corruption & black money in real estate. One of my known Builder is filthy rich and every thing is in cash...
FM has incresed tax liability of Middle class and Senior Citizens to a large extent. She deferred the decision on GST on health insurance. Why can't she tax the business class who lives in luxury houses drives BMW/Mercedes etc and don't pay any income tax. Why an Individual tax payers are forced to pay higher tax than coroporates?????????
We are paying taxes but what about the services we get Roads Hospital Environment The person who is taking freebees sitting at home and doing small business without any taxes.. Finally atleast leave dead body without GST
bro till the time free politics is not ending things are not gonna change. Govt is distribution around $1 Trillion worth of free money or services and people are voting on the basis of who is giving us what free. So the things won't change till we stop voting for free.
For your kind information, if a person is investing in the stock market and if he incurs losses, even then he has to pay taxes in the form of STT, GST, etc etc.
Kindly address the eliphant in the room we are not affected by the Income tax but we are more worried about the indirect taxes that are breaking our back.
Next time I will say, "I WISH to vote for you, but there are limitations. So I will press NOTA."
😂
Nice humor
98% population don't pay tax.... 2% tax paying middle class gives 30% of India's income 😢😢😢😢😢
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Nota is the only valid option
One woman I don't want to see is This Finance minister ... irritating person
Freebies killing development
Very irritating
She and her taxation, will be the downfall of bjp at center for next 20 years, few years back when some people say that she doesn't know, i thought no she will do it good, but now it's just q fall
Why do I pay, 18% gst on goods, then 18 % my income, then above all, all the other taxes
I mean I'm earning 100 after that almost I'm payin more than 75 in taxes
Yesterday I paid 2000 in total as toll for 800 kilometres, 😢😢it’s open robbery going on the roads by the daaaku government 😢😢😢. This is on top of indirect and direct taxes I’m paying already 😢😢😤😤
Wait sometime you will have to pay gst on Fast-tag recharges
State Governments are chota and CG is bada daaku, sharing the booty called Taxes both IT and GST we etc.
Great robbery
U know politicians are free to give any toll tax concept introduced by road minister
Also mention horrible roads we get after paying hefty tolls...
Pay taxes like a German, get services like an African
Pay taxes like a german, get services like somalia
And eat freebies like Pakistan, Afghanistan...chalo food, schools, health tk freebies chalte hai... But money, Free electricity,bus/metro ride etc jo mila le lo...
We all chose to be beggars and beggars can't be choosers...
Salaries dont want any relief other than inflation pegged tax slabs and rebates pegges to inflation. Inflation is 15% which is govts miss management vut tax slabs remain thr same.
Germany - 90% people pay income tax and 3% people pay income tax in India
@@ashokpasrija4428 bro do ur homework and come.... don't slam random whatsapp facts of WhatsApp university
Absolutely she can’t and didn’t answer the primary question of tax relief for middle class
I tried to listen with open mind. Couldn't stand the arrogance and indifference in tone. Problem is with her knowledge, attitude, communication skills. Better get rid of her.
Sh is saying "I am giving". Who the F is she. We trusted PM. He gave you power. She better learn to have humility.
Nirmala wrote book: How to be tone deaf and indifferent all the time.
well buddy she is the worst FM of all time but we cannot deny the fact that things are not gonna change till the time people of India stop voting in the name of Free
We should support her....we are actually the main reason for our downfall..we want Free basics,we don't want to work,.So can someone tell me where this government gives us a free basis...???
Don’t know why I really can’t tolerate her. The moment I see her, I feel like breaking my phone but thinking about the tax on gadgets, I hold myself back😢
😂
Salaried employees are the biggest victims in INDIA. We are more than happy to pay taxes and contribute to the development of the nation. But, as private employees have no job security, the government has any solution to the welfare of employees if they loose their job after paying good amount of income tax over years? As long as we earn, we pay tax, if we lose that income source for any reason, we are left on roads, which is unfair. With all due respect, I request if this is ever considered, especially the salaried employees of private sector, thanks
Atleast minimum security we required from government if something happened to job..
But she never giving answer to this question
Also our labour laws are worst
Even govt servants don't have security.....
To reduce to expenditure on salary and pension govt has come with a innovative method ....hire contractual workers
Correct bro
very much valid point...... As this is a genuine concern, wish some day it reaches the top level and some positive action is taken on this
18% GST on health insurance! WTF
Absolutely, why tax on the health insurance and essential services.😇
Tai Fuck 😂
That too when health insurance premium is increasing as much as 15% yoy
😢😢
@@karanj8914
Because the rich don't take any health insurance only the poor must need it.
middle class should act smartly while voting.
App ki vote nehidenese kuchbhi pharak hame nehi padega kyun ki hamara pass 80 crore raasan bala he.jinko ham srifi carbohydrates detehe or protein, vitamin nehi detehe islia unka dimak nehi hoga or o haane vote denge.
Voting wont work
Even BJP supporters don't accept this kind of income tax collection.
Absolutely spot on.
Yup I'm bjp support and i hate her
Yaa I hate her
Spot on. BJP is a free Market Hindu party this woman is clearly a Communist.
IT plus Service tax put together kills middle class
Leaving India is best option for Middle class
and where will they go? you are calling them middle class and then telling them to leave India? Logic?
@@manimalgaming17 What he meant is, pay taxes & work for the country who takes care of the middle class when he or she is in financial crisis.. In West, when the govt taxes you in big amount, when you are in financial crisis govt will take care of you.. Will that happen ever in India? We are more than happy to pay taxes but we want what we deserve.
Here, if we go bankrupt, the govt won't pay any attention or consideration.. What are we paying the taxes for?
@@sawangupta123 I know what he meant but the problem is that everyone one is blaming more tax but no one is asking the reason. Freebies politics is making all this. In previous govt what we were enjoying in the name of subsidies is now what we are paying. Previous Govt took almost $400 Billion loan and where did it went? Tax was collected from the people who were earning 2.5 Lakh, where did it went? We were paying VAT as well as service charge which was more than GST where did the money went? Who'll pay the external debt? From where will the govt get money to fund $1 Trillion worth of freebies?
Currently govt pays 27% of its revenue in interest and loan repayment. From where will this money come? Govt is giving subsidy and pension and salary to govt employees. From where will this money come?
@@manimalgaming17so what you are saying i clearly understand your genius knowledge what you said was true previous goverment bougth loan this goverment also bougth loan back than there are vat and cst which were single slab and they are 5 7 3 % which will be decided by stategoverment and cst is 2%collected by central goverment old income tax you should pay tax if you are earning more than 2.5 lakhs but there are more benefits which is not considered now as of now gst has six slab and even rice milk essentials are taxed even health insurance and mediclaims are taxed back then with low tax the economy was good what happening today why ruppe is falling against dollar can explain when western countries supports people its good goverment but if its happen in india you will call it as freebies go and get educated properly okay
@manimalgaming17 You are very intelligent 🏆. Happy New Year.
In this ruling Era,
Middle class ❌ Poor class ✅
😢
You are asking someone who is unaware of tax system in India.
Like her leader Modi.
@@blackmomba3261 Absolutely True
English speaking is the only requirement in this un pad Mudi’s goberment
if a ranking is created for worst FMs of india/world , she will be top ranker
Manmohan Singh ji in last or fail
@@Official_somanath😂
True
Without Doubt!
Yes... She is worst finance minister ever
Robin Hood for Rich people 😂😂😂
Collects from middle class/ poors and distributes to elite class..
She is the reason for Downfall of Govt .
kaha downfall ho raha hai?
its bloody pappu party doesnt deserve it
She is just a puppet in the hands of Modi, she does what's being told
Lol so you are thinking she has the defacto power on budget? 😂😂😂 still so naive 😑
Pathetic finance minister. She is just a face, actually accountability is of Adani's broker Modi
True
With this highest tax regimes, Middle-class is forced down to poor-class.
I agree with you, but I didn't understand how?
$1 Trillion worth of free things are letting this happen. Stop voting for free things and the things might change
Exactly
@@manimalgaming17 middle class gets nothing free its just another jumla
@@Sakethram121 then y r u agreeing with him/her? If u don't understand 😂😂😂
We are just working to feed the government and but not feeding our families
I like her. She motivates me to leave this country 😂
😂🎉
Very good.. Don't come back..
Why leave the country, it's not nirmala sitharaman's country, we have every right to live here, like our forefathers did. Just need to get this FM out of the office. She is even making BJP voters like me to think about alternate parties.
@@HarishKumar-zf8qp . He didn't ask you and no one care about you ..... 😂😂
I have already left 😂
She should be ashamed of herself. Middle class peoples will never forgive you.
Don't worry, I will ensure no middle class is left, everyone will be in poor class and then enjoy free राशन
She is trying to convince but unable to achieve it. She is just rotating 😂
Vote for worst FM till date
a) Nirmala Sitharaman
b) Sitaraman Nirmala
c) all of above
C
C 💩
She never elected by vote my brother she not even contest in any election though...she is selected by their internal party ...she only defeated ,if bjp is defeated...
C
Chidambaram ka naam v lelo. A.Raja, Kanimozhi are inspired.😅
You should have invited modi too. The man. Myth and legend behind this GST tax increase.
They don't hv guts fr dt...they can just ask him"Aap thakte kyun nahi"😂😂
Thank you messi for supporting us
@@dr.a.m.5630they have guts but he dont have guts to face a non scripted interview
All parties giving freebies . Salaried class people will only fight on Twitter .They cannot come on streets and fight for their rights . All Gov know this. Inflation is a big problem. No social security .No tax on rich farmers . No wonder people are leaving India .There is a need for Middle class tax payer party now in India. Middle and Upper middle class should stop / reduce buying things in India , plan for future etc. Decrease in consumption and GDP will ensure voices get heard.
I am just surprised Godi media has dared ask even this much 😅
Guess they couldn't get any Moulana to invite for group discussion that day 😂
We would also love to pay more taxes but there are below issues that tax payers are unhappy with -
1) "IF" and only "IF" it's not taken out of the system going down the drain due to corruption.
2) Businessmen earning 10times more and paying less taxes than Salaried people.
3) Paying taxes like developed countries and getting facilities like the poorest African countries.
4) Distributing Revdi to win elections out of our tax money
5) Extremely high Food inflation
6) Poor air quality
7) Lack of infrastructure
8) Extremely expensive Healthcare and Medical
9) Extremely expensive schooling and education
If BJP at the center is going to fall, this madam would be the main reason for it
She does as her Master asks.
People are talking about income tax and she keeps talking about GST. The fact is that only 2 crore people are paying on behalf of 1.4 billion, is any government taking this up to make sure at least 40 crore people are paying income tax instead of 2 crore.
Unfortunately the rest are the vote bank
Shut up. Everyone is paying GST. Everyone is buying petrol, diesel, books, pens, foods.
So, please don't say only tax is the income tax.
Income tax only contributes 19% of total tax collection.
Also I need to remind you that the top 1% of rich people, hold 40% of the total wealth of India, the rest 99% of people only hold 60% of wealth.
So, the top 2-3% of people paying income tax is very normal.
@SumanDewasi-fi9el , you can shut others up. Everyone is entitled to their opinion as you are also entitled to yours sir.discussion is about direct taxes and not gst or equitable wealth, we know that is already skewed so why not abolish direct tax and let everyone pay equally ., but that argument doesn't stand good either.
There are many in BUSINESS community (formal and informal business who can and should pay income tax but not, they very well know how to hide the same and cook their books
Then ask all corporate schools to reduce fee.
Now a high end school for grade 1 wants 4.7 lpa including everything. Do u think this is correct??
Clueless FM..just a rubber stamp..no accountability as she is a Rajya Sabha member.. she is just talking bakwas..
empowerment bhaiya
No proper answer
"The middle class man has to work only feed the poor and the rich"___
Rich Dad and Poor Dad
mere ankhe khuli when I read this book in 2023.
Worst decision was voting for Modi ji. Suffering alot because of our clueless , statergyless , planning less Finance minister
The only reason why I wanted congress to win 2024 election was this woman
Congress is failing to put this issue in their agenda
@@karthikk6995 they want everything according to caste, if the taxation was according to caste then they would've included it.
well then go and read their manifesto and you'll pray that congress never comes into power. They made a promise in their manifesto that they'll take everything from a person if they have a certain amount and will distribute it in the public. That means if they said 50 lakh then after that your money and land was their and they would've distributed it. They were about to introduce inheritance tax in which you had to pay 45% tax on the sale of your inherited property. So before saying the only reason go and read their financial understanding
@manimalgaming17 congress was in power say for what, 50 years? So they didn't introduce inheritance tax now they will do after coming into power...
You are a strong Supporter of BJP and definitely a not a middle class salaried employee so you just want to defeat an argument...
@@karthikk6995 Congress itself spoke about inheritance tax ,Rahul made a speech on introducing new inheritance tax if they come in to power and would distribute it to poor. Congress didn't introduce khata khat in 50 yrs rule but they are promising now ,so it's in election manifesto
Waiting for the day when she loses power and has to face the same struggle like a normal middle class family.
Koi farq nahi padega, she has made money for next 7 generations of her family..all black so no tax payment required 😅
@kunalkashyap16 Not only money. I am talking about peace of mind. She has harrased so many people.
A time should come when she has everything but no peace of mind.
She got great incentives by selling PSUs
She will get pension from taxpayers hard earned money
She knows nothing will happen. This arrogance comes only then. These guys live like kings on public money.
If you are taking such huge taxes , then justify it by doing great work in India and implement all those money at right time and in right place 😶🙏
And for people who want to leave the country because of this and other reasons , it's our Nation it's our Country ....no need to leave our motherland because of those people ....we should be wise and vote for right person without being blindly biased towards any one political party ....
This current tax system cannot justify themselves 😢
I am a middle-class citizen and a staunch BJP supporter. However, after reviewing BJP's 3.0 budget, I am ready to support any party that promises to eliminate Income Tax entirely from our taxation system, and I will never look back at BJP for the rest of my life.
I Agree
Government runs on air.
@@mukeshtm1951 i am not responsible for the welfare of 110 crore people who dont pay tax and live off of govt welfare money which comes from the taxes I paid while i am travelling on potholes instead of roads, chocked sewers, completely built but non-functional waste management plants, air quality worse than a coal mine all while working my blood dry to get food on table of my family and dare to think of having a comfortable home so that i dont have to commute 50km everyday. if govt doesn't run on air then it should also not run on the hard work of 10% while the top 1% live as is they own the country
@@mukeshtm1951 government is run by corrupt politicians who convert tax money into black money all over the country
@@mukeshtm1951govt runs on indirect taxes such as GST, vat and excise. Income tax is a single digit income (if not less) in terms of percentage for the govt
Why there is so many options given to business man for saving tax and not given the same options to salaried person?
You are wrong,
Business people are struggling more, due to many new laws which is not in favour or any business people, many of the startups and old businesses are either struggling or have shut down,
But if you are talking about big big guns businesses like adani and Ambani then I don't know
Corporate taxes are pretty high as well. But the fallacy here is that more corporate taxes will not do reduce the burden for the common man. Of course it will generate more income for the government and might lead to them lowering income tax, but the load of the corporate taxes will be passed on to the common man causing inflation to rise. Instead, the more practical solution is to broaden the tax base either by increasing productivity of people or by taxing a untaxed class(rich farmers). Either ways, the way out of this is to government borrowing, creating more jobs and increase wealth of Indians, not taxing the hell out of the middle class, especially if the government wants to boost consumption
Business people take risks and are hence incentivised to take the risk
This tax structure more similar to 1990's but inflation is going up every year. School fee, doctor fee, house rent, basic groceries, vegetable, petrol, electricity, onion tomato prices have all increased in 2025, but tax system is not changed.
Consider GST refund for private employees who does not get any benefits.
Tax slabs percentage should be directly proportional to inflation or petrol price, electricity bill,school fee, rice, tomato, onion prices.
Why she's so confident, like she's doing a great job😂
She isn't confident. She is arrogant.
This comes with power, arrogance, and with no powerful opposition; if the politicians actually pay the same taxes as we pay(road tax, electricity, toll tax, property tax, etc) - they will think of reducing taxes.
Smiling face on fake resume 😂
Most arrogant f she is
She is confident because she becomes a minister through the Rajya Sabha route. Completely ignoring the mandate of the people
Praying tax 30% will be okay, when there's free medical services and education. In Bangalore it's terrible to pay medical Bill, and child education. For lkg students we are paying 2.5 lakhs per year, then school dress , books they're charging 50k.. so almost if you have two kids and salary is 25-30L and dependent parents, how to survive. All single tax brings tears in eye
You can send your child in government school. Elite school not needed upto tenth standard. They are teaching nothing.
Here we are looted by state government 😅.
Central from salary 😅
Very true, daaku government 😢😢 imagine the situation for 2 kids
True
Either they must apply direct tax or indirext tax for salaried guys. As it feels like double taxation when we go buy items with already taxed money and again get taxed on item we are buying.
Please tax farmers earning more than 5 lacs like general public.
GST has become a terror for middle class. Every thing we buy - like home, service etc the seller would say XXX + GST. Bhai GST Iis 18% which is ridiculous. A 1cr home (1.5 BHK in Hyderabad) becomes 1.18 cr die to this GST. And before people say 1cr home is “luxury” there’s nothing available for less in Hyderabad anymore .
Only on this front I support Rahul who said Gabbar Singh Tax GST.
"I am giving", the statement itself shows, we have a wrong FM.
Wrong FM means, wrong PM too
Absolutely... even I was thinking the same thing... I is very big ..... it's not WE ...
Party funds should be taxed at 35% GST for the welfare of the country.
Insensitive FM, India has ever seen.
I pay a tax which is almost my 2 month salary.
I bought a car of which 50% is only taxes.
It means, am I doing job only to pay taxes?
My neighbors ,who earn more than i do, just because they are not employees and enjoy income on agriculture and business get everything for free. I, like a stupid am forced to pay highest taxes.
I have to borrow money only to pay taxes. And how about interest on it.
Exactly
Double tax for salaried person
All parties giving freebies . Salaried class people will only fight on Twitter .They cannot come on streets and fight for their rights . All Gov know this. Inflation is a big problem. No social security .No tax on rich farmers . No wonder people are leaving India .There is a need for Middle class tax payer party now in India. Middle and Upper middle class should stop / reduce buying things in India , plan for future etc. Decrease in consumption and GDP will ensure voices get heard.
Reporter asked about job /income security for private middle class our FM didn't amswer it rather she is saying GST has reduced taxes...If question A is asked Z is question answer was given....govt sucks....
Should be credited with moving middle class to BPL class.
After more than 10 years of Government Nirmala ji trying to reduce the tax amount.....what a joke Madam....😅😅
She very cleverly diverted the topic to GST. We wanted her response on why only meagre 2 to 2.5 crore people, mainly salaried class , are forced to pay tax out of 1.4 billion? Why retired people are forced to pay tax on their interest income out of their savings ? No answer. Abolish direct tax deduction from Salary or Interest income, increase it on expenditure.
Put her in jail for silently killing middle class...
Actually hard fact is that no body want her as finance minister.
Give him another ministry but not finance.
Salaried person pays about 30% as direct tax and about another 15% (average) via indirect tax. 45% of tax given for bad infrastructure, corruption, inefficiency, etc. Why not tax rich farmers - those who own cars? Why not give the same exemptions of the business class to the salaried class?
Rich farmers Sarpanch log Black money people -Sucking blood and IT after 5% honest people
sir only 60.81 lakh of total direct tax payers are in 30% tax bracket. Get your facts correct. They cannot give same exemptions like businesses to salaried person because businesses are wealth creators and generate employment. Their focus is to shift people to business class so that more private sector jobs can be created.
If the business man are wealth creator it doesn't mean govt should loot middle class tax payers. Lots of salaried PPL who even earn 30 lakh per annum comes under 30 % bracket earning 30 lakh is no big deal specially in big cities
@@secularkeeda93 and how many live in those big cities? Do you know the number of Direct Tax Payers? How much population of India lives in Cities? The biggest problem is freebies. Corporate are getting taxed 25%. Go and look at the countries who tax corporates 30% and their condition. If they tax corporates 30-35% then that'll create a situation where businesses will start giving excuses of job creation. Businesses are not only wealth creators but job creators as well.
U just put it so perfectly..this is what India is...unfortunate and we are not able to do anything about it...
😢😢 aakhome pani aa gaya. Kitna sochte hay e log middle class ka lie. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
RICH FARMERS SHOULD BE TAXED TO EASE THE PRESSURE ON MIDDLE CLASS
There are farmers who have 100 acres but with no water. There are farmers with 7 acres but plenty of water how will one evaluate their income. No income security every year.
Yes, we should also know Sohan ji how much farm loan is waived and how much NPA waived from other industries...that's also where taxes are going.
@@StrongVenusNot rich farmers.
Wealthy people should be taxed
@@kanwarpalsingh5378 every year 2.5 lakhs crore industrial or business loan is waived off, as far as the farm loan, after 2009 60 thousand crores, no farmers loan was waived off, and if it was waived off it was at state level waving. 75 percent tax money goes to pay govt servent salary.
Thanks@@StrongVenus
@sohan 9020 ji & 51 others, if u need hindi or any translation pls let us know
Just put one tax that is 5 % on every class (lower middle and rich) and on every item on every business. Everyone would be happy to pay tax.
Question kuch or puch rhi hai . Answer kuch or hi de rhi hai sit ram 😂😂😂. Final score of test paper is 0. Sitaram fail ho gyi😮😮😊😅😅
logo ko.beffkuff bna rahi hai
@DavinderKumar-u8t yes..
I dont understand, if Military does surgical strike Modi gets celebrated but if FM screw up taxes year on year why to grill FM alone? He understands Radar Technology to guide Army but has no say in mismanagement of Economy?
True
"Raahat" will come only when freeloaders on the nation (like our Annadatas or any such exempt lobby) can be taxed.. more people paying can bring Raahat to existing taxpayers.
why only middle class is taxed heavily? think about it. other democratic nations tax everyone no matter the income range so that there is shared responsibility in nation building and they question the authority since they pay tax. poor people in india pay heavy indirect tax and not aware of it. they don't question the authority when bridges collapse and for poor infrastructure. India is heaven for the rich to make enough money to get foreign citizenship(their only goal) when poor are left powerless and voiceless while middle class are being fooled loosing their wealth and health for nothing in return.
6:00 - Question is on IT. She’s answering it on GST. 🤦♂️
I am yet to get a convincing answer of Question: Why a business for which
1) raw material is subsidized,
2) other consumables are subsidized,
3) utility bills are subsidized,
4) product offtake is guaranteed and
5) process is insured by Govt;
Yet there is no income tax and they keep entire nation as hostage at their free will.
Yes I am talking about Farming..
I am not talking about small farmers, but about those rich land lords who roam around in Fortuners and Scorpios, brandishing their wealth in NCR?
Yes big landlords always suppressed our farmers. But now Government of India already introduced Minimum Support Price (MSP) for small farmers so that they should receive fair price of their products produced
Exactly All know these Sarpanches , Netas and contractors on Fortuners 😮
But farm laws are opposed by Opposition and no one wants to support that. Is that not shame on indian citizens?
Everything is free for them here in telangana, infact money is given away by every government to repay loans, farming subsidies, free investment for every crop, free power etc. If agriculture is unsustainable, why encourage it by throwing hard earned money of tax payers to create disguised employment? Either make it profitable or move on to ease the pressure on govts especially middle class.
Only state government can tax agricultural income as per Income tax act 1961, ask Haryana govt to tax farmers but they cannot as only Gurgaon farmers are rich because they have rich clients who pay for their vegetables and fruits.. But rest of the haryana farmers are not that rich... Hope this helps
The worst part for this taxes case in INDIA is.....when we buy a vehicle, we pay life tax, road tax but still if you want to drive your vehicle on roads, we need to pay toll tax😂😂😂
She is living in her own world only seing goods in her deeds
Middle class is becoming poorer, while poor class is getting all the Government benifit
Whenever these guys are cornered with a critical question they start blaming the previous government rather than answering the question on the current condition. This applies to both the major parties.
While electing we have to choose between bad and worse now however even that identity keeps switching in these parties.
No answer for proper social security to the tax payers…
The new saying(real) Pay tax like German, get service like India(not Africa)
Still cars price different in each state..!!
GST actually more than vat that used to be..
New tax regime has not reduced any tax from last 6 years
As a salaried middle class person myself, the frustration is not so much about paying taxes as it is about the poor quality of life and services we get in return. Even countries like Malaysia and Mexico have better infrastructure (city roads, traffic management, green spaces), cleaner air and water, etc than any Indian city. And i don't see any collective vision in our political leadership to address this holistically. Merely throwing money at the problem in schemes like Smart City don't have any meaningful impact. I have lost hope in my (Karnataka) state government, municipal corporation and MLA who just seem to exist without doing anything. Corruption continues to be high in state govt interactions (property registration, RTO, etc). Property prices, rents and school fees are increasing exponentially year over year, whereas salary growth is in single digit percentages. Hence, the easiest thing for the middle class is to blame the central finance minister and IT department for taxing us.
The problem here is not paying the Tax, what is the benefit that we are get by paying tax. Maybe you can consider providing free health care for taxpayers in salaried class etc. Which you dont want to do for sure.
I RESPECT NIRMALA MA'AM. VERY UNDERRATED FM. AFTER SHE WILL GO, WE WILL KNOW HER VALUE. MARK MY WORDS.
Upcoming tax updates:
1. Farting - 5 %
2. Pee/poop - 18 %
3. Sleeping more than 7 hours - 28 %
And enjoyment with legal wife 40 percent and if illegal 55 percent 😅😅
Fucking 5%
Vegetables, rice, wheat, salt, sugar these basic products price should be under 10rs
If you have GST, remove income tax. We are paying anyhow.
I am not able to understand how come in a country of billions and country of trillion dollars economy have only few millions tax payers. When will the government be able to get tax from the rest of the country?
Not even million bro.. just 2 Crore..
Heard of indirect tax? Even a beggar pays tax.
@@MahboobIslam Salaried people paying Direct taxes + Indirect taxes....
Good Sarcasm....
Since previous governments did nothing to collect taxes from non-payers, this government is likely to continue the same approach. I don't understand why Modi Ji isn't considering a change in the Finance Minister
Middle class families will die due to these taxes ... 😢😢
What about wealthy agro incomes
Middle class are crying and dying with these taxes. Unable to live
This should be the last term of BJP, because of their finance budget
30℅ tax in city with single income family is getting difficult to survive. Like USA we should have higer tax slab option for married person combined return fillings.
How shameful it's, charging 18% GST on Insurance is justifying?? People are buying insurance for their social security while Government failed to provide a better health facilities in the government hospitals 😔
Literally VASULI in name of tax.
Not convinced by the minister's answer at all.
I'm surprised to see navika asking bit bold questions to FM...of BJP.... mostly she is experiencing tax heat first hand .😅
Even if they are lapdogs at some point they will be forced to bark and bite their owners, now it's just barking tomorrow the situation will force them to bite. Truths cannot be hidden for so long.
@@TheSanalrajanI will vote BJP
@@Juniordatascientist-k8dAll the best🙌🤣
Shame on minister people with non salary income can buy luxury without paying a penny. Here it has become difficult to pay school fees.
At least A health security card to be introduced to the high tax payers of this country
Predictable Response from Nirmala FM 98.3
Worst PM ever, she has no clue about finance, she will be the biggest reason for bjp's downfall.
For 10L Car Ex Showroom, almost 7L-8L is only Taxes alone.
Middle class dream of Car is gone
All taxes paid by us going in corruption.
I have seen same roads being reconstructed all over India again and again inspite of roads being in good condition.
Modi ji,
Request you to bring Young Educated Energetic bloods just like Trump bringing Ellon Musk, Vivek Ramaswamy, Ramakrishna, Tulsi, JD Vance.
Also there is so much corruption & black money in real estate. One of my known Builder is filthy rich and every thing is in cash...
Are you living in another world or coma ?
Modi is the leader of all corruption.
Our problem is why only few percentage of people are responsible to pay taxes, why not others tax them too or else don't tax anyone
She will bring the downfall of BJP
Worst worest and woresth FM OF INDIA😂😂
FM has incresed tax liability of Middle class and Senior Citizens to a large extent. She deferred the decision on GST on health insurance. Why can't she tax the business class who lives in luxury houses drives BMW/Mercedes etc and don't pay any income tax. Why an Individual tax payers are forced to pay higher tax than coroporates?????????
Plain popcorn.....5% gst, salted popcorn....12%....sugar popcorn....18%....
Wow, what a country
We are paying taxes but what about the services we get
Roads
Hospital
Environment
The person who is taking freebees sitting at home and doing small business without any taxes..
Finally atleast leave dead body without GST
bro till the time free politics is not ending things are not gonna change. Govt is distribution around $1 Trillion worth of free money or services and people are voting on the basis of who is giving us what free. So the things won't change till we stop voting for free.
For your kind information, if a person is investing in the stock market and if he incurs losses, even then he has to pay taxes in the form of STT, GST, etc etc.
Madam, please bring gst bills to be claimable under 80G
You keep giving free ration,freebies to poor and zero benefits,no free insurance, no investments,nothing to middle class, why always we should suffer.
Kindly address the eliphant in the room we are not affected by the Income tax but we are more worried about the indirect taxes that are breaking our back.
Only 1.6% are paying income tax and all these are GOV , PRIVATE sallery people.
Modi should wake up.
In modi era we have the best External Affairs minister and the worst finance minister. Fact
True that
Both of them wrost
@@anjalialam1431Based on your name we understand your frustration.. you will only love Taliban regime - even if they do halala 😂😂