Israeli society fractured due to military exemption on Haredi Jews: Military analyst
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 чер 2024
- The Israeli government is considering extending an emergency law, that delays the age military reservists can retire from the service.
That's as a committee is discussing making conscription mandatory for ultra-Orthodox religious students.
Exemptions to being conscripted in Israel, like those given the Haredi ultra-Orthodox Jews, are putting “a lot of pressure on Israeli society”, military analyst Elijah Magnier says.
Magnier added that 42 percent of those enrolled in the army, both professionals and reservists, “don’t want to join the army again; they want to leave” due to the army’s performance and the confrontation with “a strong non-state actor determined not to lose”.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#UltraOrthodoxJews #HarediJews #Israel #IsraelArmy #IsraelMilitary #Palestine #Gaza #GazaWar #IsraelGazaWar #IsraelHamasWar #Hamas #IsraeliArmy
Netanyahu’s son Yair is around 32 yo. Why isn’t that coward fighting?
Because he's busy studying the Talmud apparently. In his spare time when he's not partying, I mean studying the Talmud, he criticises the military leadership for failing
Why saudi arabia king's son don't fight in border you get my answer😂😂
Why are the leaders of Gaza not fighting?😂 just hiding in Qatar
@@Successful12344Stupidity at peak 😂😂
Why saudi should fight with zio nist terro rists...
@@Successful12344Saudi don't claim to be the so called only democracy in the middle East
What a sick, sick country.
There is no need to kill children with experiences soldiers. Only Jews think like this. Israel is a sick
Sick for surviving.
I guess we’re all sick then.
99 percent of those so called God's Children are sick!!!
God will do away with he's so called sick Children before we know it!!!
It is not a country though.
Israel is breaking up
Be nice, but I doubt it.
The government will break up but the Israelies are as united as they will ever be
Actually October 7th was the one thing that could unite us. Many were about to leave due to growing division. October 7th changed it all. United us against Hamas. Killing us makes us stronger... I think you should try peace got better chances of defeating us this way.
G O O D
@@slavy123you need to read a history book. Apartheid Israel have been persecuting Palestinians since the balfour declaration 1917.
Those who choose to go to jail over joining the IOF = brave ones.
From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free
Why should anyone lose their life for an apartheid state that doesn't care about their citizens. Nobody should be forced against their will to fight for any government/ country.
All religions are gross. Grow a brain and open a science book. Trust no one that tries to convince you of magical fairies and retarded flying chariots. Don’t be stupid
If they don’t join it’s because they rather go travel they could care less about your dump Gaza 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
They are totally racist and right wingers; they are just lazy
Is that Hamas rolls?😂
And us Americans we have to work until 64 they can retire at 41 and 50 cause they enjoying our money
Apartheid Zionist Israelis enjoy many rights denied to capitalist America's working class which has been so generous to that state for decades.
A minor cost of being the best.
@@RebeccaTurner-ny1xx A minor cost of being the best.
@@Hlth-cn4fhBest devils
Yes they also have free health care and free university education. All paid for with American tax payers money 💰
To be exempted from genocide duty, or not to be exempted from genocide duty…. that is the question 🤔🤔
Israel has lost the war, and the Israeli settler colonial project is failing.
💯
There are already settlers returning to their natives countries... After all who wants to have land where is no peace?
Palestinians are in much better situation, of course.
@@user-wq9eg3nm4cther are only losers here
As Gaza’s look out over their new car park😂
The Haredi jewish people are doing the right thing by not signing up, many Israelis don't want to participate in a genocide. This genocide will drag on, and so Israel will struggle with soldiers.
Many more IDF are being killed and injured than they are declaring.
Liar
If you cant handle the truth, then dont listen@@FncyPntsPikachu
You have no connection to reality, do you
Haredis don't care about Palestinians. They refuse to participate because of personal religious reasons.
@@talksmoke1190 stole the words out of my mouth
They say they wanted to defeat Hamas. How's it going so far?
даже во сне не могут победить
There is no need to kill children with experiences soldiers. Only Jews think like this. Israel is a sick
Not so hot, they have no idea what they’re doing
You can't defeat the idea of freedom from oppression
According to Al Jazeera Hamas has lost one man with a slight limp, so how would you know?
Looks like using civilians in uniform as shields....
Wow you sound so smart
average age of IOF casualties is 20y.o. Not even finished training. They use their own untrained children as an army of human shields.
@@christofthedead 💯
yes they are
Warmongers usually fall in the hole of his own creation...
Hopefully I would NOT go to war if sth. like this is happening in my country.
Thanx to all brave humans saying NO.
❤💐🕊️
“Israeli society fractured due to military exemption of Haredi Jews…”
“Entire world fractured due to perceived exceptionalism of all Jews.”
Now we know what the problem is.
True
The real jews are chosen people have many slaves fight for them.
ZIONAZIS
The US had a Big Jew Problem. In saying that as a Liberal. They heard their Wealth and Keep It thru Nepotism.
I steal is losing too many foot soldiers. Their army as a whole seems to have encountered a 'Hadrian's Wall" or 'Jebusites in the Mountaintops' situation. They've encountered an unwinnable battle that is
sapping their reservist pool and conceived a Jezebel-like desire for another man's field and life. It's an untenable position.
The IDF enjoyes a conscript policy. They enlist 30,000 new soldiers every year.
Against their will@@ravidlivne7317
Seriously? The pm gets elected. Most volunteer for service. The IDF is the most superior army in the world. Hamas is being destroyed. Hezbollah is next. Islam is now recognized as a terrorist organization. Israel is strong and isn't going anywhere. Protests have not stopped Israel. Media has not stopped Israel. Nothing can stop Israel. God bless Israel. ❤
Hard to do that when 500,000 Israelis have already left.
I guess they're delaying the age and widening the scope of transcription because they have TOO MANY soldiers huh?
@@zahraabdullahi1601 I bet you got that number from a UA-cam video, didn't you?
In reality however, every war and every round (including of course the current one) only increases Israel's population.
It was already broken
עם ישראל חי❤❤
eventjes maar nooit in rust en vrede en veiligheid
@@IlonaG-ib5byyour days are numbered
@@jamiehardcastle4999😂😂😂😂❤❤❤🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
I am a Palestinian. I used to live in Gaza before my house in Gaza was destroyed. I have four children. When the Israeli army bombed my house, I was alone in it. Thank God I survived, but my right foot was amputated. I am now in Egypt and my circumstances are very difficult because I cannot work because of my foot. I have four children and I have no income. Please help me or refer my case to any charitable organization. Do not leave my children
Western hypocrisy🔥🔥🔥💯
Sorry, I couldn’t see your comment for the number of Muslim countries coming to Gaza’s aid. What were you saying?
What stops the arab countries? why did they become like this as soon as mainstream islam was enforced in 9th century? Nobody stopped the genocide in Palestine despite it was done by empire’s own foreign troops.
How do know Israel are no longer the chosen people ? By thier actions .
Chosen? by who? some cartoon character god?😂😂
Was Ghengis Khan and his army the chosen people ? Who made the Israelis the chosen people. They made themselves chosen and idiots go along with the nonsense. Was the Nazis chosen over Jews and others?. Was the USA chosen to do whatever they desire to the rest of the world?. Were the Europeans chosen to perpetuate havoc and genocide all over the world . Were the Moslems chosen to enslave Africans. This chosen nonsense must stop, it is idiocy. Why is it the chosen ones are the ones commiting all manner of evils against everyone they desire?
Their man-made God chose them.😂😂
God is very very real , I know that to be a fact . And at one Israel where chosen for a purpose .As was Noah , but we don't need to keep biukding arks over and over again. Purpose achieved. Israel can't even remember what its purpose was , but it was fulfilled and achieved 2, 000 years ago . Israel has stagnated but Gods purpose is always moving forward leaving Israel behind to take care of itself .
Some good genuine advice..if you refuse to serve and go to jail go to jail in a different country it will be much safer there🙏
Are people with dual nationality leaving.
roughly estimated to 500.000 today...upon a gross population of 9 millions, BUT, among which, are roughly a litlle more than 2 millions arab-israeli "second zone" citizens... that makes a lot of people, dual citizens mostly, and mostly economicaly wealthy people, and those who can afford fleeing this crappy land, eg well trained people like doctors... the end will come...who would have bet on the collapse of the "iron curtain" in 1988??? not so many people...bit it happened next year...
Yes
Forced serving in the military is not going to work in the long run.
Yeh, they’ve only been doing it for 76 years😂
@@jonnyh9388 And they are tired of it.
These guys are short sighted, how long do they believe this is gonna last ?
say what...?! Oil...?!
Ils ont raison de ne pas se battre, ce n'est pas une cause juste.
So if Haredi community dont work but are rapidly increasing how will Israel support them?
US, UK taxpayers' money, land robbing etc.
The same way America supports apartheid Israel 😊
The jews are chosen. People don't work and have so many slaves to work for them.
Isn't it good for the Arabs? Should encourage them to give birth to drain more resource. Just like how Palestinians don't work as well.
And what about Netanyahu’s younger son Avner? What’s that wimp doing? Not fighting, I assure you.
What a ridiculous name 😂
@@jake751why?
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c sounds like the name of a farm animal. i bet they have the same intelligence level as farm animals. all well off peoples brains stop developing in toddlerhood after all
only love, forgiveness and justice to neighbors will bring PEACE.
Netanyahu’s Sohn sollte dabei sein ! 😅
The occupation economic plan for Gaza.
Real Estate. Google Gaza 2035.
Build the Ben Gurion canal and port on the Gaza land the alternative route to the Suez canal.
Produce oil and gas from Gaza land.
Google, Gaza oil and gas.
Russia has it all as targets for Ukraine, lol. Gazprom is in ICU and hence Chechnya is very close to getting back their oil field. Israel will be completely unsafe if they don’t let the palestinians stay.
Netanyahu son should be on front line
Soon there will no Millitary and No country 😂😂😂
PALESTYNIEN WILL TAKE BACK ALL THERE LAND FREE FREE PALESTYNE
Didn’t you say that on Oct 7?
Palestine existed before Judea and Samaria.
David 921 BC killed Goliath Jalut Palestine King and occupied Palestine. Nebuchadnezzar liberated Palestine.
Google, who was Goliath.
These people have no problems with Israelis Palestinians not having to serve. That just shows the bigotry and apathied of the Israeli society. One rule for Palestinians one for Europeans. Why is it Israeli Palestinians are not force into the army like all other citizens. Why are they treated differently? Are the Israeli Palestinians not citizens of Israel?. The Israeli government should explain why. The Palestinians who are called citizens of Israel are not seen as citizens by the Europeans of Israel.
First of all, there are Druze, Bedouin serving in the army. As for Palestinians with Israeli citizenship: if they were called up to military service- they would find themselves at one point fighting against other Palestinians. How would that work out..
If Israel send Palestinians to war, they will be fighting their own families possibly. Is that bigotry?
Is that why there are Arab MPs and Supreme Court judges in Israel? You really are clutching at straws
Why? Have they usedup all the merican forces?
The mercians? What are they doing there?😂
does the kids of rulers benefit of military exemption?.
*The dua/dhikr for the victory of the Arab guerrilla groups: LAA HAWLA WALAA QUWWATA ILLA BILLAH. Let's recite it at least 100 times every day. It is also one of the Jannah's portals (Tirmidhi).
Hubaib bin Salamah (may Allah be pleased with him) used to recite "Laa Hawla wa Laa Quwwata illa Billaah" when facing an enemy or besieging a fortress.
It is said that one day he surrounded a fortress belonging to the Romans so that he was desperate, then the Muslim army recited the dhikr, finally the fortress was destroyed. An extraordinary experience was also told by Abu Khair, Ishaq Al Gharawi. He recounted that they were once attacked by an army with eighty elephants. As a result, their troops, including the cavalry, fell apart.
This event, Abu Khair said, made Muhammad bin Qasum panic. Seeing this condition he then recited "La Hawla wa La Quwwata Illa Billah" many times.
Shortly afterwards, the elephants suddenly scattered in search of a water source. Their handlers were unable to control the strange behaviour of their pet elephants. It turned out that Allah swt had given the elephants extreme heat and thirst.*
If it is a democracy, then why is there forced conscription? People should be free to choose whether they want to serve or not.
Are those politicians exempt from serving in the IOF?
The heredim should serve all hands on deck. Joshua did not have exceptions in his army of conquest
Israel's society is fractured. Everything being done to keep Netanyahu's government in power. The internal division between secular and religious Israelis is profound.
Forced conscription is fascist.
They’re not the only ones who can leave. AntiZionism praxis.
Imagine forcing your women to join the military? what a sick society.
But details.. There are reported cases of mentally instables within IDF... Israel state hides this kind of info from the public opinion...
No. The public knows it
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c what? 👀
I said the public knows it. Because families have soldiers back home, dealing with post trauma, other mental issues. There are hotlines. Various medical, psychological services, rehab for maimed soldiers and such.
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c you did not understood my irony... The Israel goverment hides the cause...
There is in fact a systematic brainwash for years... And not only in IDF...
Damm.. They Sound like Like they in trouble..😂 Sorry not sorry..
Holier than thou
If you people are so sure about all this then why cry about the war .dont worry about isreql
zijn zoon van alle leiders
all jews need to go to army with nataniaHUJ as a general
lmaoo theyre blocking roads too
Over a million and counting are already mobile and looking for greener pastures then living the life of a desert Bedouin 😁😇
The chosrn People are Palastine, 😮
🇱🇧🇾🇪🇵🇰🇵🇸🇮🇷
الله أكبر زندہ باد فلسطین آف پاکستانی عوام❤
Free Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ♥️ 🙏
I am a Palestinian. I used to live in Gaza before my house in Gaza was destroyed. I have four children. When the Israeli army bombed my house, I was alone in it. Thank God I survived, but my right foot was amputated. I am now in Egypt and my circumstances are very difficult because I cannot work because of my foot. I have four children and I have no income. Please help me or refer my case to any charitable organization. Do not leave my children
The israeli are intelligent people,they know that sometimes when it rains it pours and its best to look for better shelter " elsewhere" if need be😅😊
They have slogans to "tourists," ... Your land by others lands, helps us and we promise that you will have your own land...
They are very democratic 🤗
Adapting Ukraine 🇺🇦 systems 🤔
Blue star is reaching out around the world from Ethiopian jews to french mercenary...to fill this void
They have sterilized Ethiopian Jews without their consent...so, noone to fight for them
Escribí tres reino por cuatros veces UA-cam es un dictadura
Its an arab world in that corner israel is out numbered and not following Gods commands so...😢😅
🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢
Does this reporter have any hostages in his home
@talksmoke no he doesn't,blue on blue
Do you?
Yes, your mum
There is no need to kill children with experiences soldiers. Only Jews think like this. Israel is a sick
Put that crack pipe down, smokey.
What they went through was 2 horrible. Israel USA Supports You!!! 😢😢❤🙏
Only the government and right wing media
And brain-washed people.
@@jake751 It's left wing like these that become mujihadeen. God is Great!!!
@@Escape_The_Mundane
Horrible is what Palestinians are going thru. Stop the genocide
@babhag5481 what about the evil Yahya sinwar! He took 6 people but they let him escape prison for the heroic Gilad. Now he do invasion of israel just to harm his own people! What about the Iran nuclear program? What about the evil hegbollah and Damascus, Syria governat?. Isis houthi in yemen? Evil balochistan, laiksha e taiba? Stop being brainwashed, the heroic Us marines went to Iraq and Afghanistan after 9/11 2001!
Thank you, aljazira, for ignoring all the problems in the world and helping analyze israeli internal issues.
Some might think it is a deliberate Qatari strategy to make the world ignore some bad things that are happening.
You think this is not important? you are ignorant
This is one of the most important problems in the world today, perhaps second only to climate change.
@@RebeccaTurner-ny1xx why exactly? The number of the victims is much less than in any of: Syria, Sudan, Yemen, Ukraine...
Bc she hates Jews
@@themipu didn't you hear Al Jazeera has a 'no jews no news' policy?
From river to the sea, Israel will flee!
Exodus 2.0
Praying for ISRAEL
Praying what exactly?
You relize the fairy tale God from the book of fables has turned his back on Zionist isreal, just like isreal turned its back on the son of the fairytale god
lol country 😁😁😁fake county...
Apartheid vibes for sure.
עם ישראל חי
In your dreams
There is no need to kill children with experiences soldiers. Only Jews think like this. Israel is a sick
@@gogreengardening448 I am a Palestinian. I used to live in Gaza before my house in Gaza was destroyed. I have four children. When the Israeli army bombed my house, I was alone in it. Thank God I survived, but my right foot was amputated. I am now in Egypt and my circumstances are very difficult because I cannot work because of my foot. I have four children and I have no income. Please help me or refer my case to any charitable organization. Do not leave my children
Israhell is lost.
אני יהודי 🇮🇱❤
Not Jewish only zoinist
There is no need to kill children with experiences soldiers. Only Jews think like this. Israel is a sick
@@gogreengardening448not all Jews are Zionists, I'm Jewish and I support palistine being free from the Zionist KAPOS
My advice is that Israel after this war you need more than a friend, you must locate your brother's I mean Jews in west Africa that despise terrorist Hama's and Iran will understand the difference between white and black and the reason why the black fighters was named buffalo soldiers in world war 2.
...didn't they sterilize those west Africans women? 🥱
The persian proxy issue is older than islam. Iran doesn’t care about hamas.
From the river to the sea, Palestine is almost free of the baby osamas
Baby Osama > baby hitlers
In your dream
@@slaw7263 yours dream
Free Palestine
@FncyPntsPikachu Flee Flee Galillee
Israel jewish Netanyahu undemocratic 👇
@MetalGear1 хотя я вырос не в Газане/Палестине, но судя по тому, что я видел и слышал. да, это меня кормит, я не против умереть, я просто жду последнего черного флага, когда это произойдет, не только я, многие другие придут, если это время придет. даже камни будут «ГОВОРИТЬ», за мной прячется еврей. написанное, мы знаем, как выглядит будущее «еврейского» народа.
😂😂😂😂😂
Free phelestine from India
The heredim should serve all hands on deck. Joshua did not have exceptions in his army of conquest
Netanyahu is not Joshua!