Palestinians have done everything they can to radicalize Israelis against coexistence. it's amazing to see the resilience and of the Israelis. on the other side I can't really say the same. the Palestinians claim all the land and not only refuse to let go of that delusion for their own sake.
@@jayfields7513 I will assume you mean Tantura. There is not a shred of comparison between violence committed in the chaos of war, and between consistent and unprovoked violence. Is it your position that Palestinians started a war in 1947, and because the Israeli army didn't have the total dominance needed to try to be the most moral army in the world, it's a "2 way street"?
please tell that to your people Bruine, we want to see more people like you who stand with Israel, I have been to Ireland Dublin and we suffered from extreme antisemitism there, we couldn't ride the buses, we couldn't walk in the streets because we are Jews
The average opinion of an Israeli citizen: We can and should live in peace through co-existence (either in a one or two state solution). The average opinion of someone from the west bank (or Gaza): Jews cannot be here and peace will not be achieved until they are gone from the land. Once Palestinians accept the idea that Israel is not going anywhere, they will be able to accept co-existence.
@h.singular9613 No, its the only realistic path to peace. The past 75 years have proven that "justice" won't solve the issue. This kind of thinking is what perpetuates the suffering of Palestinians. The Jews have given up on seeking justice for the holocaust, instead they realized that they need to focus on the next steps required to prevent another one from happening - this was to establish a sovereign Jewish state. Palestinians can similarly end their sufferingand live in peqce after they abandon the idea that Israel cannot exist.
The fake victims are arabs that invent their past, believe they are indigenous to Judea only know violence and the act of genocide. They are not partners for peace
That is not the average opinion of the Israelis. Virtually no one ever wanted a 1 state solution and a minority wants a 2 state solution. The majority want to either annex the remaining territory or keep the status quo going. All the polling has shown this for the past few decades. The only exception was in the early 2010s where both sides favored a 2 state solution. I really do wish Israelis though like you describe though. Btw do you think Palestinians have a right to a military in a hypothetical scenario where their state stops being occupied?
بعد صراع طويل و متعب و دموي .. سيقتنع الجميع أن العيش المشترك بحقوق متساوية في دولة مدنية ديمقراطية و ليست دينية أو عسكرية هو الحل الوحيد الممكن .. يجب على الجميع أن يساهموا في تقديم و إنجاح أفكار و مشاريع السلام
@@ayalaostrovsky9550@ayalaostrovsky9550 no, you are not suicidal, just delusional. How do people from all corners of the earth get to a different corner of the planet to tell the natives they need to move without any help or a way to live? Put their lives upside down just because you want to play colonizer?
I think you mean “They can under occupation” it’s easy to be on the side of the status quo when you’re the one with the finger on the trigger. Reverse the situation and the answers would flip
@ how did Israel shut of the power and water in Gaza? How come settlers don’t get in trouble for their extreme bigoted violence in the West Bank? Or as you would prefer, Judea and Sumeria?
Watch all of his other videos. And they always speak very clearly. They still have this fantasy of removing every last year from the land of Israel and they will never agree to peace. They say it clearly.
@@damer3016 I know many Places have been bought by jws when they come from Europe. But how much ? Also every day Isrlwli government steal land from West bank , do you also call this “ the owner giving “ . Why not honest in describing the situation?
the palestinians don't get a lesson to hate the Israelis I was born in 2000 and in 2009 I saw my self the 2009 war and hate the Israelis by own myself they see by themselves not one tell them
I don't think you've featured a more charming or cool interviewee than the guy @ 3:30. He's a great ambassador for Israel and a great example of a human being. I think you should go back and ask him more questions!
I dont say theyre wrong or something But theres huge diffrence between co existance and peace, peach is between goverments, in the palestinian side they dont hace free speech and basicly most of them support terrorism (so called resistance) and the minority that think else way cant talk freely. In israel we have our own problems but at least you can hear so many diffrent ideas and opinions
I live in ramle too, the guy is lying sorry to tell you, not once did arabs do complete rampage burning houses and busses in the main streets, i legit am scared to go out. Fuck this place im moving to jew only when i grow up
Arabs began paying attention to Zionism in the late Ottoman period. In 1899 , compelled by a holy duty of conscience , Yousef al-Khalidi , mayor of Jerusalem and a member of the Ottoman Parliament , wrote a letter to Zadok Kahn , the chief rabbi of France to voice his concerns that Zionism would jeopardize the friendly associations among Muslims , Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Empire. He wrote , ( Who can deny the rights of the Jews to Palestine ? My God Allah , historically it is your country ) , meaning that Khalidi is saying that the land belongs to the jews , according to Allah .... But Khalidi suggested that , since Palestine was already inhabited , the Zionists should find another place for the implementation of their political goals , and he added ( in the name of God , he wrote , let Palestine be left alone ) , meaning that in this case Khalidi prefers to decide by himself , instead of listening to Allah .... So Khalidi said in the beginning , who can deny the Jews to Palestine , and then turns to Allah , in Adding ( That Historically it is the land of the Israelites ) , but Khalidi is the one who denies it , as he says firstly , who can deny , and directly denies it from the jews himself... You see the Hypocrisy here , you see Arabs say one thing , and say that they believe in Allah , but a second after , they are the one's who deny his word , and prefer to take their own decisions for their political agendas , meaning forgetting Allah's words. And the same thing happened with Aj Amin al Husseini , and the father of all Muslim brotherhood ( Hassan al Banna ) , where both of those religious figures knew the truth , just like Khalidi , but their instant move was to oppose the Connection of the Jews to the land , and that Allah himself has signed the holy land for the children of Israel ( Surah 5 verses 20 to 26 , where in verse 26 , Allah Forbids them the entry for 40 years , 40 years , not 1 million years , and not 1 trillion years , just 40 years , and those 40 years have long passed.... You see the Hypocrisy , and since than Israelites have bloomed , while the Arabs of the land have Fallen , this is what happens when you deny the word of Allah .. Taqfiri ways didn't help neither , the Muslim brotherhood is responsible for all the Arab downfalls in the past century , from being once the most advanced and civilized Religion , to sadly becoming an abomination , just because of the Muslim brotherhood
There was no hypocrisy there. The thing that you missed in your interpretation of the verses in the Quran, is that the promise of the land was conditional. And when the conditions were not met and they repeatedly disobeyed him he exiled them all over the world. 40 years have passed, true, then why did he not return them to the promised land before even the Arabs came? Zionists simply used religion to push their agenda and create a secular state in the middle east. They could care less about what's in the holy books. And why are there still millions of Jews outside of Israel today even though there is a Jewish state? Why don't they all move back?
God didn't give you anything the entity you worship is a demon. Whatever it said to the Jews was not said out of kindness or love but aimed at making them bad people. And it worked.
From Canaanites to Hebrews to the first Christians, under Arab rule, most converted to Islam. God Promised the land to the Hebrews' descendants, not to people to convert to Judaism from other parts of the world. Immigrant Jews need to put themselves in the shoes of the "real chosen people, the Palestinians," and consider how the descendants of the authors of Judaism and Christianity are still very religious.
Quite a contrast to the same question being put to the Palestinians. Like the Israeli Jews I hope they can find a solution to this problem and for there to be a secure Israel and peace for both sides.
Question for 🇮🇱is: If Ham as was hiding amongst civilians in Tel Aviv, would you use the same warfare tactics to "eradicate Ham as" that are being uses in G@ za?
Yes, the difference would be that civilians would listen to the IDF warnings and they will be free to evacuate the area before the military operation without being trapped by Hamas.
@@milenaavesani7799 is that why they got bombed while they were moving to the safe zone? ls that why the marked (and actively communicated) aid vehicles with foreign nationals were attacked?
@jouilia536 you have no clue as to how much Israelis value life. The Hannibal Directive pertains to protecting IDF soldiers from being taken captive. IDF soldiers are tortured when they are captured and they do their best to prevent this.
Yes, I can. That's a basic answer to the question. How to achieve this needs more contemplation. I think some answers revolve around the meaning or importance of identity.
When I first went to Israel, I was honestly trying to convince my fiancé (now my husband), who lived here, to go away together to Europe, cause he has an Austrian passport and I am 50% 🇪🇸 50% 🇮🇱 (and a convert Jew, cause only my dad was). I love Israel but it really is difficult with an European mentality to make aliyah. It's not fot the weak... 🇮🇱
Yes, the Israeli mentality is unique. Not sure whether it is the compulsory military service that made them like that. Warm personality but too much abrasiveness and bluntness atimes.
@@Vocalhero-w9q Zionism is European. From Canaanites to Hebrews to the first Christians, under Arab rule, most converted to Islam; that is the history of the Palestinian people, and I am very sure they feel OK with how their people changed and survived in their loved ancestral homeland.
@@adrianabotello9911this is actually not the case. There's also examples throughout history or Mizrahi Jews attempting to return to their homeland. Even the Ethiopian Jews long to return. It's part of the prayers and everything, throughout all Jewish groups. Maybe the word "Zionism" as a defined movement originated in Europe, but within every Jewish population in every country there is a theme of wanting to go back to their native land, ever since they got kicked out in circa 70CE
@@saskiascott8181@saskiascott8181 Why can't genetics show connections between these groups and the Natuffians or Canaanites? I believe you that their books say so, but Palestinians inherited more than 80% of their genes directly from Canaanites; if there were more than some lines in some books, it would show. North African Jews are the only ones with some admixture, but how old is that? Sephardic Jews got all the way to America in the 1500s precisely in the contrary direction. Thank God for that.
As an Israeli, I find it harder and harder to imagine coexistence. There's coexistence with Israeli Arabs, which is fine and almost ideal. The problem is with the term "Palestinian", which is almost defined by its opposition of Israel. If an Israeli Arab refers to himself as an Israeli-Palestinian, I feel less comfortable around him. Peace? I can imagine it with strict separation. Gaza's population needs to be deprogrammed from the hate and jihadism. After that happens and Gaza has a normal leadership capable of healthy communication, then we can MAYBE consider Gaza to be an independent state and approach it as such, with strict borders, diplomacy, cutting the free aid we used to provide it so it learns to be self-sustaining, and hope that it ceases its hostility, allowing for careful peace. As for Judea and Samaria, I don't see the region becoming a separate state (they don't either), and I don't see the local population assimilating into Israel. If it does want to accept Israel and assimilate, it has to forgo the "Palestine" and "Palestinian" nonsense. If it doesn't, the population could choose to join Gaza or the already existing "Palestinian" state - Jordan. If they can't accept Israel, they don't get to live in the land of Israel. October 7 revealed a term in Israel: Conception. We held onto the idea of peace, that perhaps Hamas was actually becoming more moderate and that all those "attack Israel" drills and trainings were just for show, so much that it burst in our faces. Border security was reduced over the years, or it was automated or remote controlled. When the attack happened, the envelope was terribly unprotected. And that happened because of the conception, because we thought that the people in Gaza ultimately wanted to live peacefully, wishing for western values. And we were wrong. It's a bleeding wound that will take a LOT of effort to close and heal. Until then there will be no trust. And without trust, there will be no peace.
Why do you have to decide what the Arab population in Judea and Samaria want to do with their lives? Why even threaten them with forcible expulsion because they disagree with the State of Israel? The grandparents and great-grandparents of those Arabs were already living in that land before the State of Israel existed.
'Peace? I can imagine it only with strict separation.' Lmao, are you serious? Separation is were conflicts start, unity is were peace begins. Think about it again.
What peace??? After having killed this number of live you have proven that you are not human and cannot live with! You'll be expelled soon or late! You cannot live in a such hostile environment! The young generation will fight against you until the end! And not only the palestinians ALL the people in the region!!! Things could have been much easier and people could have lived together if only the strong (Israel) showed a bit of pragmatism and humanism, really! The jews have lived with muslims for centuries, but you showed that the contrary isn't possible! So prepare yourselves to leave! It is just a matter of time...but your fate is already sealed!
Zionazis that make up israeli society don’t believe in peace. Israelis actually envisioned a world where the Palestinians accept and enjoy being the slaves to the israeli Jews. Oct. 7th shattered that vision so the Israeli savages are going on their campaign of endless slaughter in the hopes that they’ll get the Palestinians to return to wanting to be their slaves. So you and the rest of the Israelis can go to hell.
The story you shared is a pivotal and deeply symbolic moment from the Mahabharata. It highlights Duryodhana's arrogance and unwillingness to compromise, which ultimately led to the catastrophic Kurukshetra war. Krishna’s peace proposal was a final attempt to avoid the conflict, underscoring his role as a divine strategist and protector of dharma. Despite the tragic loss of countless lives, including the children of the Pandavas, the Mahabharata teaches profound lessons about the consequences of unchecked greed, pride, and the importance of standing for righteousness, even at great personal cost. It’s a timeless narrative that resonates with the struggles between justice and injustice, peace and war. It depends which side are you and how you see the justice and injustice. Thats how indians understood this conflict
We have no choice but to live together in peace and security, and experience has proven that neither party can eliminate the other, but to live together without one party being superior to the other. Our children have the right to have a future free of fear and killing.
@dogbert52 This proposal is not fair. You come to us from different countries and ask us to leave. Our roots have been in this land for thousands of years and we cannot leave it. If you hesitate, then leave it. So your country is expanded towards Jordan and you ask them to leave to Iraq or Egypt, and then you expand towards Iraq and ask them to leave towards Sudan. Or Yemen, this represents true greed and the erasure of the other
@jehadasad1519 you know that many arabs migrated to the land to work. Islam isnt thousands of years old and the arab invasion of the levant didnt happen the seventh century. I don’t know why you are implying that Israel is expanding when it is the opposite. Israel looks like Swiss cheese and it doesn’t even look like a proper state because the Arab territory keeps eating at it. The only reason Israel keeps gaining land like the Sinai peninsula Gaza and the West Bank is because of the wars that the Arab started and lost. And even then, Israel gave back Sinai and Gaza, but Egypt wouldn’t take Gazza back. I feel like the Arab population doesn’t do enough of taking any responsibility and accountability for their part in preventing peace.
@jehadasad1519 if you wanna talk about erasure, why are there less than 20,000 Jews in the Arab and Muslim countries when there are 2 million Arabs living in Israel with citizenship
Most want peace, and don't favor evicting Palestinians. But when Shuster asks Palestinians in the West Bank, most say Israel must end, Jews must leave, it's our land, etc. Not at all equal...
The guy from Ramle has the best response ♡. Those advocating separation are sad to hear. Coexistence is the way, even though it is not easy, barriers and distances can disappear if all sides put effort with integrity and strong leadership.
That will never ever happen. Sorry to be a party pooper… in theory, I think it’s a wonderful idea and a beautiful thing to teach young people to give them hope. But Israel and Palestine will never be able to coexist… the best solution is for Israel to fully annex Gaza and the West Bank, and create autonomous regions similar to what the United States did with Puerto Rico. And the Palestinians need a king too, otherwise they splinter into groups. Just look at Gaza…
@@LinkinPark4694Israel has a sensitive case when it comes to demographics, Israel can't give its papers to the five million Palestinians, they are not Jewish
Israel has been built to be a home for my people from all over the world, a safe heaven, we have our unique identity, Israel is a Jewish state@@LinkinPark4694
Separation is the way of the world. Borders exist for a reason. Those railing against "separation" mostly just want to abolish Israel in favor of a Muslim-Arab state across all of former Mandate Palestine.
You think so ? So the Israelis jews don't have extremist that provoke ? The poorest family in my village turmussaya was kicked out their house not to long ago and taken over by settlers. They beat the father and sons and these people don't bother anyone. When their kids see this you want them accept you ?
I saw the one- “Israelis: Do you see non Jews as equal to you?” Lot of hate and supremacy there I ask you do the observant “good” Israeli settlers and hilltop youths have a RIGHT to drive West Bank Palestinians from their homes and lands?
The South Africans said the same about the blacks and anc . The Northern Ireland Protestants said the same about the Catholics and IRA. Once the oppression of the blacks and Catholics stopped peace was obtained Stop oppressing the Palestinians
See stupid bigoted comments like that are stopping peace and you blame us Palestinians? Same way I believe Mizrahi Jews are actually from the Middle East and names like kestenbaum, Friedman and silverstein are definitely not indigenous and the names of European colonizers
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Your mind has been begging questions or statements since you began trolling your anti Zionist crap October 7th. If you post on Al Jazeera they will welcome you. Otherwise you are just a troll that is very ignorant 🤥🥱👈
Please stop calling the Europeans, Iranians, Yemenis and Moroccons "Isrealis" Isreal is a prophet and God is not a land broker🤣🤣 those Palestinians belong to levant lands (yes surrounding countries d-umb ahh) more than the blonde "Russle" from Poland😂😂😂😂 most Surrounding countries called them Palestinians and "Isrealis" who were there before their fellow jews came literally had "Palestinian citizenship under the British mandate Palestine" ur not gna erase facts with ur "Godly" superstitions
@ There is no god, which makes the islamists, who have killed over 270 million infidels for their murderous psychopath pedophile all the more absurd. By the way d-umb ahh, jews are not the occupiers in this equation.
Palestinians as people were invented in 1964 by Arafat/KGB. Before "palestinian" was the adjective for people living in the region: palestinian Jews, palestinian Arabs, palestinian Christians ecc.
@@playdate8827 So if Palestinians live outside of their homeland for 200 years... Let's say they live in Europe and after 200 years, their descendants are blond, but they still speak Arabic, are they allowed to move back to Palestine still? Or are they too blond to live there now?
Uh, no they're not. The Romans renamed the land Palestine, but they never referred to Jews as Palestinians. They renamed the land Palestine after the Philistines, who were the Jews' mortal enemies, so why would they also refer to Jews as Palestinians? You've got your history all mixed up, I'm afraid.
2 state solution is the best solution for both sides. There are 5 million muslims in Palestinian territories ( West Bank , Gaza and East Jerusalem ) . And 2 million muslims are already in the internationally recognised part of Israel . If they will be united , this new country will be half jewish , half muslim country without dominant ethnic group. I think these two can't coexist together in the same country ( at least for now ) , because both sides want their own homogenous state ( in reality ) and doesn't accept the dominance of another . The ethnic tensions will always be present in this type of country. That's why it's better to give both sides their self determination right. So , the solution is the honest referendum in state of Palestine ( East Jerusalem , West Bank and Gaza ) . They probably would for the sovereignety of Palestine and it would be the best choice for both sides to reach the peace. I wish peace for all.
But the Arabs Israeli wants to be in Israel and enjoy democracy and freedom of speech not Sharia Law of Arabs governance. Arabs in Israel are happy and does not want 2 states other wise they will be kick out of Israel if the Israel will be divided into two, Arabs and Jews. One state is best all both Arabs and Jews obey one Law, be obedient and peace will come, there is no problems with the Jews, Arabs has a problems selfish and they do not want to be dominated, and Arabs does not like to follow Laws, they always want above the Law. If all Arabs will become a good boy, Peace will come.
@@gigiloveshongkong7133 I disagree with you. Israeli arabs and Palestinians are not the same. Plus , not all arabs live under sharia law. Palestinian Authority is secular and in fact opposes Hamas and only Gaza is controlled by Hamas , not the entire Palestine. Even the secular arabs disagree with the laws of Israel. They want their own country ( at least the ones in West Bank ) . Also , democracy needs to be voluntarily , not forced. Palestinians , just like any national group in the world , deserves the right of self determination. That's my opinion. I strongly oppose religious rule , but I still believe there's still hope for secular Palestine as an independent nation.
@dragon1715 Corey had ask many Arabs and they want in Israel, and they wants Jews go away, Arabs wants all Israel, they can not move on the 1948 independence of Israel, and if two states , ALL Arabs think they will be tricked and kick out of Israel like 1947, that's the answer of many Palestinian.
Palestine has never been an independent state, which means the residents who lived there never owned the land, the land of Israel wasn't owned by the Arabs
@MarkDenmark-nz2pz You still haven't figured out that the arabs living in Gaza, who aren't allowed to return to their ancestral homelands in surrounding countries colonized by the islamists, are pawns of the islamists in their quest to establish a worldwide caliphate. Wake up, kaffer.
@ I will never look to this conflict from religious perspective. Palestinians are Muslims , Christians, Druz and many even atheists. Same goes to Isrwlis .
@MarkDenmark-nz2pzbut the only place where Jews, Muslims, Christians and Druze live in safety and freedom is in Israel and in none other places in this area!! Israel is here to stay and it will be the end of the world before someone move them from here! There are 7 million Jews the majority born here, they are not going anywhere!
The hospitals in Israel are the best example of shared society. That's not accidental; Henrietta Szold believed deeply that Zionism should be focused on building a shared society for the benefit of all the land's inhabitants and she set up Hadassa hospitals and medical facilities with that top of mind.
There's an older video that has a similar question. "When you go to another country, do you tell people you're from Israel or Palestine?". The answer was mostly "depends what country i go to", if i remember correctly.
malik The two greatest Jews in modern history disagree with you, so would you have won an argument with Sigmund Freud and Einstein? but then again you maybe a Genius
you miss a point that many palastinians have Jewish mezrachi DNA being arab is not about DNA if u speak arabic you become an arab. ofc many arabs in palastine are arab but mostly they are a mix of jews and christians and arabs that stayed in that area
@malik stop saying shit you don't understand about people you don't understand. Arabs are a cultural linguistic group with several races and ethnicities inside. Also, the Juice have all the countries of Europe to return to and America, way more than 22.
Heartening to see that not every Israeli Jew rejects the notion of coexistence out of hand. EDIT... even though it is completely reasonable to believe that peace with the Palestinians of today is totally impossible.
@@danielspivak3926 I am one, lived in Israel, have family and close friends there, mostly in the north, speak Hebrew pretty fluently, am no fan of John Oliver, and do my best to not prejudge people. You might want to try that last part. All I meant was it would be understandable for everyone to reject the notion of coexistence at this point.
most israelies don't reject it but unfortantley most of our neighbors do so when israelis are saying that they don't belive it's possible it's because of what we see, hear and expirenece from our neighbours you can think about it like you have a roomate you try to get along with but he keeps stealing from you and lie to you and gossip with the other neighbours about how bad of a roomate you are and when you confront him he threaten you and even hitting you but then he apologize once , you forgive him and after you forgive him and try to look into a solution he does it again so would you trust that roomate? , would you confidentely want to have a good relationship with this roomate that is keeping acting bad and react violentley when confronted or deciving you?
Never in history was palestinian poeple or nation called palestine. Palestine was geographic region name for the land its including jordan in the time off the british mandate also name trans jordan.palestine is latin name not arabic.the arabs take the palestinian identity in 1964 by yasser arafat egyptian man like many off these arabs caling themself palestinian came from.in the 19 centery 1878 the ottoman sultan bring arabs from the suranded arabs country as working immigrat.the same with.the british mandate in 1923.these are the arabs caling themself palestinian.you can tel wish arabs country the came from by the family name.el masry from egypt.el baghdadi from iraq.tamimi from saudia.jewish poeple was always in the land off israel.before 1967 west bank was jordan not palestine.the same with gaza was egypt before 1967.is many physical evidence this land belong to the jewish poeple archeologic.in the quran israel mention 43 time palestine 0 time.
You can imagine whatever you want, even three-headed unicorns that tell terrible jokes, sneeze glitter, and argue over which one gets to eat the last cupcake!
Don't mind but your surveys are far from reality. Because on ground reality, Israel is expanding it's territory even before oct 7. So, you should also have to represent the views of jews sharing common ideas of Ben Gvir and Smotrich.
What really surprised me-or what I find very interesting, viewed neutrally-is that the second group of people you interviewed, Israeli Arabs, said they are in favor of a one-state solution, meaning that everything should belong to Israel, including Gaza and the West Bank, or rather Judea and Samaria. I would say, at the moment, that this might not be a bad idea overall, but the people over there would have to accept it. It cannot just be imposed on them. Only if they themselves want it-in Gaza and in Judea and Samaria-could it be done through the right to self-determination of peoples. Otherwise, I would also say a two-state solution is necessary. However, Gaza and the West Bank absolutely need to be democratized, just as the Germans had to do twice in history. Once in West Germany after World War II and again in East Germany, in the former GDR, after 1989, following the SED dictatorship. That may take time, but then they could finally live in peace. Right now, the Palestinians in Judea and Samaria, in the West Bank, and in Gaza cannot freely express their opinions. If they speak out against Hamas, for example, or against the PLO, depending on which area we’re talking about-against Hamas in Gaza or against the PLO in the West Bank-and advocate for a two-state solution or peace with Israel, they can face serious problems repeatedly. This is why, when Palestinians are interviewed on camera, most of them speak out against Israel, simply because they are afraid. Unfortunately, this fear should never exist; no one should have to be afraid to freely express their opinion. This is true even in many democratic countries-Germany is the best example of this-but I hope you understand what I’m trying to say here. Shalom Aleichem. We want peace for everyone.
A one state solution is completely unrealistic and one that Israel can never accept. The reason is that Israeli annexation of the West Bank and Gaza will inevitably result in Israel no longer being a Jewish state or no longer being a democracy. If it would to maintain it's democratic identity, then the newly annexed Palestinians would become Israeli citizens and Jews will become a minority in Israel. If, on the other hand, Israeli would annex the West Bank and Gaza but wouldn't grant citizenship to the Palestinians, in order to maintain the Jewish identity of the state, it would become an apartheid state, and no longer be a democracy.
I'm not sure they meant governed by Israel but united. In Germany one country swallowed the other one up and it led to so much trauma and resentment. It is almost 35 years later and it still feels like an identity being robbed to many people from the former GDR and their children. They feel like second class citizen at times. And they never had such hatred about one another to begin with. Unification I therfore see only possible if 2 states next to each other without one wanting to kill and exile the other works. That has to be stable for at least a generation. Then maybe it's possible to unite. But not under israeli rule. Just think about cremea and Russia /Ukraine. And they were basically brothers with language and culture so aligned. Jews from the middle East and Arabs have a lot in common but the 40% ashkenazi are quite different. Not in a bad but noticeable way that complicates things further.
@@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz My question is pertaining to Iran, being that the rebels essentially fought their proxies and are or were Sunni fundamentalist with Iran being Shia, and I imagine after the Fact that the new Syrian gov were only even able to topple Assad because of Israel's complete anhilation of Hezbollah, and now that Israel has now destroyed most of their internal military capabilities. They may not want.a buddy buddy relationship with Israel, but they also likely don't want to poke the Bear. I can see them taking a route of neutrality and not making Israel an enemy either.
@@yelenas7923 you’re wrong, different lands speak different languages , hills of Galilee and Jerusalem speak same language as bakaa valley, Amman hills Damascus, Cairo , Baghdad etc
I believe that only an one state solution would lead to peace, because two states means separation again, thats where conflicts gonna starts, "this is only mine' kindergarten culture. Adults who want peace should share the land, Arabs and jews together, Arabic and hebrew in all schools.
and one state means no jewish state that would lead to more problems than there were. two states is the most realistic one with the right politicians on both sides
@linoyohana1186 what do you mean, why would one state mean no Jewish state? There can be both Jews and Palestinians in the government, I mean a mixed state, where everyone is protected by the law and be equal.
WHO ARE THE COLONISERS ? Clan / Family names of “Palestinians”: Al-Husseini, Al-Hassan, Hijazi, Tamimi, Erekat, Barghouti, Qureshi, Badawi - Saudi Yamani, Azad - Yemen Haddadins - Yemen (Ghassanids) Masri, Masrawa, Tartir, Bardawil, Fayumi - Egypt Abu Kishk, Shakirat, Zabidat, Aramsha, Abu Sitta, Abu Sutta, Shaalan - Egypt Turki, Sultan, Uthuman - Turkey Iraqi, Baghdadi, Faruqi, Tachriti, Zoabi, Abbas - Iraq Nashashibi, Hurani, Allawi, Halabi - Syria Lubnani, Tarabulsi, Sidawi, Surani - Lebanon Al Bushnak - Bosnia Al Khamis - Bahrain Al Afghani - Afghanistan Al Mughrabi - Maghreb Al Araj - Morocco Al Djazair - Algeria Al Kurd - Kurdistan Hindi - Indian Subcontinent Al Abid - Sudan Not very INDIGENOUS
Whatever happened to the Mizrahim black panthers? They finally accepted they’re inferior to the Ashkenazi? They and the Sephardim are nothing less than imported Arabs anyhow.
The people talking about this always seem to be sidestepping the crux of the issue, that in 1947-48 much of Palestine's Arab population became refugees and were never allowed back. They're saying "Yes, we can live together like we do now in Ramle" because Ramle is 20 or 25% Arab. But 80% of Ramle's Arabs were expelled by Yitzhak Rabin in 1948. So can there be peace with 5 times as many Arabs in Ramle, making Jews the minority? Most Israelis are a lot more hesitant if you make that part of the question. But without a right of return for refugees, there will never be an end to the conflict.
History is not your strong suit... First of all, Rabin was just an officer at the time and was appointed as chief of staff on 1963. As for the Arabs refugees, there war about 600,000 of them, from which about 400,000 settled in Jordan and got citizenship and some went to Gaza. The rest went to Syria and Lebanon. What you neglect to mention is how the Arabic leadership (who didn't accept the partition and actually started the war with intent to slaughter the Jewish population) told the Arab population to leave their homes because they were confident they will win the war and then allow them to return. For those who didn't flee, while there are cases of Israeli soldiers attacking the Arab population, it was a minority of individuals (I'm not justifying, but unfortunately it is like that in war sometimes) and by no means a deliberate policy. A lot of the Arabs who stayed later became citizens of Israel. If the Isreli Arabs would have Palestinians from the territories and Gaza be part of Israeli democracy as things are now (not that they want to), in a very hypothetical and not realistic scenario, they would pass rules to expel or kill every single Jew under the current leadership and the population's state of mind. Very sad but also very true. If there were to be a deradicalization process over a generation, living together might become an option. A two states solution will probably work better for now...
did you know that the Muslim countries expelled more Jews when Israel was created than there were Palestinian Arabs that left or were expelled? The problem is the refugee agency that makes them believe that they have a right to return, but that’s invalid because once you lose a war, you lose your territory. The right of return is a delusion. It’s perpetrated by people who make tons of money in this conflict.
No one expelled them. They were encouraged to leave by their leaders who promised them that they will be able to return. This is the first time when the Arabs started crying and it never came to an end. War isn’t a game. If you start a war no one can make you any promises. Be peaceful and nothing will happen
@@dolev2692 I literally read it in Leah Rabin's memoirs and Yitzhak Rabin's memoirs. He signed the expulsion order to kick them out of Lyd and was in charge of executing the operation in Ramle as well. Of course they justify it and say they had no choice because they had to secure the corridor from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, but they clearly said they did it. He wasn't chief of staff when he did it, of course. He was operations officer and second in command to Yigal Allon in that operation. There's a famous interaction between Yigal Allon and Ben Gurion, in front of Yitzhak Rabin, in which Allon asks Ben Gurion what to do with the residents of the towns. Ben Gurion waved his hand and said "Garesh otam" (expel them). After doing a little bit of research, I have discovered that in the Hebrew version of Rabin's memoir (published in 1979), the section about the expulsion of Ramle and Lydda's population was excluded by military censors. But in the English version, it's included. I'm not sure about the Hebrew version of Leah Rabin's memoir. The whole thing about the Arab leaders telling the population to leave isn't an important point. Even if they voluntarily left, they were never allowed to return. If someone leaves temporarily rather than participating in the war, they have the right to come back.
You know, adding more Jewish terms to your identity doesn’t make you more Jewish. if your mother and your mother’s mother, and your mother’s mother’s mother is not Jewish, you’re not Jewish. You are as much Jewish as I am Japanese.
Lol, the opposite Black Hebrew Israelites in Israel serve in the Army and Igbo in Nigeria all support Israel, not Islamist fanatic Palestinians. Palestinians are racist
Boy did the Palestinians in America fool you!!!😂😂😂😂 Palestinians and Arabs in general in the middle east hate black people they call them Abd or Akhdam in Arabic which means slaves in Arabic...look up in UA-cam Al Jazeera documentaries about racism in Gaza and Yemen against black Palestinians and Black Yemenis who like Black Americans are descendants of slaves but they were descendants of the Arab slave trade in East Africa which of course they don't teach you about
In the meantime, Tsahal continues his expansion in the north. But still Israël just wants peace, nothing more. Let's continue to make fun of people with this nice questions.
In the north, you mean in Syria? The entire area of Syria has been captured by different groups. Turkey occupies land in Syria, the Kurds occupy land in Syria, the US has military presence in Syria and so does Russia and Iran.Multiple Islamic organizations, some from within Syria and some from other countries like Iran and Iraq, also control parts of Syria. But what's the only part you mention? that's right - the small part on the border with Israel that it took for its own safety and already said it would return when Syria has a clear and stable regime. Why is that that you don't mind everyone else, only israel?
@@catanace1741 and you are being too nice calling it small. it's really nothing if you compare to what the others are taking. Turkey even said they were going to annex what they occupied, while netanyahu said it's only temporary. People is gonna hate us for whatever. we don't even need to give them excuses, they will invent them if we don't give one to them
Hear that Palestinians? If you don't interrupt Israelis, you too can have your own state. Unless you're in the Golan Heights. In which case might makes right.
@SnowsStorm1 It's all territory of Israel Sherlock. The point being made is that none of it should be and that the actual natives ought to have self determonation.
@SnowsStorm1 It shouldn't be under international law. The position that the annexation of the Golan Heights is illegal is accepted by the vast majority of the world.
The first government of Israel actually considered that as a potential name for the new Jewish state, since the region was named Palestine and all the Jews were Palestinian citizens. They had several options for names, but they eventually voted against calling the new country Palestine, since they assumed the Arabs would accept the 1947 partition plan and would establish their own country named Palestine. They also rejected the name Judea, because the region of Judea would be in that new Arab country (what's known today as the West Bank). And they voted against the name Zion, because mount Zion is where Jerusalem is, and it was supposed to become an international city controlled by the UN. In the end, they voted for the name Israel, after the first ancient Jewish kingdom.
@AndreyKrichevsky yrah ask israelis today though....ofc they didn't accept a partition that gave the minority population majority of the land. Everyone would reject that partition lol
Israel took the lives of 5 journalists yesterday Which brings the number to over 200. 200 journalists in less than 2 years. I don't know how you're still making justifications at this point. The world is waking up to this brutality
@@seanmurphy7953 reciting historical facts doesn't justify anything. It's just that - facts and history. Like the fact that the name Palestine was given to the land as an act of Imperialist Colonial Occupation by the Romans in the second century, after they crushed a jewish revolt. Why would the Israelis today want to embrace a name given to them by people who colonized their land and displaced them. You wouldn't expect the Palestinians to accept the name Israel for their land, would you?
@AndreyKrichevsky Palestinians didn't colonize and displace them though. Palestinians did t choose the name, they just have it. You just said they were going to accept it, but the arabs ruined that. So what point are you making again?
I i.agine a state controlled by a minority that being the jews but it be a one state united with jordan and lebanon all minprities rights are cafantered, but they hafto learn hebrrew, the ning wpuld be a hashemite but marred to a jewiah woman
@@dogbert52you mean the document supposely written when Islam was being born and of which the authenticy is still debated? Well, I am laughing at the "open mindness" of today's Muslims.
@@keepussafeUSAthe charters of Hamas (both of them) are available in English for you to read and acculturate yourself. But I think you didn't want to ask me.
For Hashem's sake... Folk need to get a grip pronto that the situation has nothing to do with Israelis and Palestinians... The problem is within the ridiculous fairytale of Apostle Paul and Muhammad's equally insane reaction to the fairytale in Islam.
Do you really believe there is such a thing called "Palestine"?! And if so, then let's see if you pass the test of the 3 simple questions in front of you. 1. Can you give me the name of a prime minister, or king, or president of Palestine before 1948? One member of parliament? Maybe the names of the ministers? Where was the parliament?! Or the king's palace?! Maybe what is the name of the coin? 2. Could you give me the name of a "Palestinian" historical figure from 1000 years ago or maybe 500 years ago, or even 200 years? 3. Can you tell me what the word "Palestine" means? 4. As we know in Arabic there is no letter 'P' the correct word is palleshyttina, the Romans called the Land of Israel by this name because the Jews rebelled against the Romans. The Arabs say falestin or flistin, or filistin, and if they speak in English then they say balastine or balistin In conclusion: no one has any answer to all the questions. The truth is that before 1948 the land was called Palestine by the British, when there were both Jews and Arabs. Golda Meir had a Palestinian passport. And there is even a Palestine soccer team from 1939 that is all Jewish. The currency that existed here at the time of the British was the Bank of Palestine Eretz Israel, which was a Jewish bank. And he issued a currency called Palestine lira Eretz Yisrael. Today the bank is called Bank Leumi. National Bank.
There was a chance till not to long ago that a two state solution, and peace was a possibility.... But given the vileness of the last year... Not any longer October is a huge weight for israelis... But the genocide of the last year is treated with complete nonchalance.... How sick and lunatic is that....!!!!!
It seems that the answers are slightly different depending on local geography. Thank you as always. You are a real mensch.
Thanks! Your work is so inspiring and important
Palestinians: What do you think of Assad's downfall?
Israelis: What do you think of Assad's downfall?
I'm Israeli and I think it's a very good thing. But I worry for the minorities in Syria.
Good question
Very good question.
@@dee74raz free Arab people first step to leberate Palestine
@@dee74raz as an Israeli, I am happy for Syrian people. But I worry about Druses and Kurds and I hope it won't be another Islamictic jihadistic regime
Palestinians have done everything they can to radicalize Israelis against coexistence. it's amazing to see the resilience and of the Israelis. on the other side I can't really say the same. the Palestinians claim all the land and not only refuse to let go of that delusion for their own sake.
Both have done each other. It definitely a 2 way street. U watched tarantula documentary?
What chutzpah. Disgusting
“Palestinians claim all the land” they’ve been occupied since 1967
@@jayfields7513 I will assume you mean Tantura.
There is not a shred of comparison between violence committed in the chaos of war, and between consistent and unprovoked violence.
Is it your position that Palestinians started a war in 1947, and because the Israeli army didn't have the total dominance needed to try to be the most moral army in the world, it's a "2 way street"?
Palestinians are baby murderers. They are in league with hamas.
Fuadih
Palestine as a nation is a fiction invented by Arafat in 1964. Greetings from Ireland. 🇮🇪
Finally, a non drunken person from Ireland
please tell that to your people Bruine, we want to see more people like you who stand with Israel, I have been to Ireland Dublin and we suffered from extreme antisemitism there, we couldn't ride the buses, we couldn't walk in the streets because we are Jews
You're not irish
He is a sane person@@ravisingh7928
@@Itsdifferent-wv4jo WTF, No one support terriorist state, he is just a troll from Tal Aviv
The average opinion of an Israeli citizen: We can and should live in peace through co-existence (either in a one or two state solution).
The average opinion of someone from the west bank (or Gaza): Jews cannot be here and peace will not be achieved until they are gone from the land.
Once Palestinians accept the idea that Israel is not going anywhere, they will be able to accept co-existence.
You're surprised that the victim bears the scars and the pain.
Peace without justice is the peace only tyrants dream of.
@h.singular9613 No, its the only realistic path to peace. The past 75 years have proven that "justice" won't solve the issue. This kind of thinking is what perpetuates the suffering of Palestinians. The Jews have given up on seeking justice for the holocaust, instead they realized that they need to focus on the next steps required to prevent another one from happening - this was to establish a sovereign Jewish state. Palestinians can similarly end their sufferingand live in peqce after they abandon the idea that Israel cannot exist.
@h.singular9613 the creation of israel was an act of justice for the jews
The fake victims are arabs that invent their past, believe they are indigenous to Judea only know violence and the act of genocide. They are not partners for peace
That is not the average opinion of the Israelis. Virtually no one ever wanted a 1 state solution and a minority wants a 2 state solution. The majority want to either annex the remaining territory or keep the status quo going. All the polling has shown this for the past few decades. The only exception was in the early 2010s where both sides favored a 2 state solution. I really do wish Israelis though like you describe though.
Btw do you think Palestinians have a right to a military in a hypothetical scenario where their state stops being occupied?
بعد صراع طويل و متعب و دموي .. سيقتنع الجميع أن العيش المشترك بحقوق متساوية في دولة مدنية ديمقراطية و ليست دينية أو عسكرية هو الحل الوحيد الممكن ..
يجب على الجميع أن يساهموا في تقديم و إنجاح أفكار و مشاريع السلام
Have you seen democratic arab state in our region?! We (jews) are not suicidal.
@@ayalaostrovsky9550 according to ur logic the Jewish satanic-baraya-genocdial state is "democratic"?
Wtf!
@@ayalaostrovsky9550@ayalaostrovsky9550 no, you are not suicidal, just delusional. How do people from all corners of the earth get to a different corner of the planet to tell the natives they need to move without any help or a way to live? Put their lives upside down just because you want to play colonizer?
Let's hope the region will see something that could be considered (at least a period of) permanent peace in the near future.
@92RedRevolver no peace within occupation
Palestinians: No, they need to go
Israelies: Yes, they can stay
Did we watch the same video? Looks like pretty much everyone who said the other needs to go was a Jewish Israeli
I'm with Palestinians
I think you mean “They can under occupation” it’s easy to be on the side of the status quo when you’re the one with the finger on the trigger. Reverse the situation and the answers would flip
@@tobysmith2081 What "Occupation"?
@ how did Israel shut of the power and water in Gaza? How come settlers don’t get in trouble for their extreme bigoted violence in the West Bank? Or as you would prefer, Judea and Sumeria?
try and ask this to palestinians
He has. All negative answers.
Watch all of his other videos. And they always speak very clearly. They still have this fantasy of removing every last year from the land of Israel and they will never agree to peace. They say it clearly.
A thief would easily accept to divide what he has stolen if get caught but the real owner would never agree. Simple.
@MarkDenmark-nz2pz you wouldnt call him a thief if the owner gave it to him...
@@damer3016 I know many Places have been bought by jws when they come from Europe. But how much ? Also every day Isrlwli government steal land from West bank , do you also call this “ the owner giving “ . Why not honest in describing the situation?
I have been watching your youtube clips for years. You are s great human being who has always advocated for reconciliation and co existence.
Get some sponsors Corey. Someone, sponsor Corey. He's great 👍
Bedankt
Those are some awesome Israelis
Thank you. Such an important work
Thanks!
the palestinians don't get a lesson to hate the Israelis
I was born in 2000 and in 2009 I saw my self the 2009 war and hate the Israelis by own myself
they see by themselves not one tell them
I don't think you've featured a more charming or cool interviewee than the guy @ 3:30. He's a great ambassador for Israel and a great example of a human being. I think you should go back and ask him more questions!
He always ask several questions and compile video with one question only, so stay tuned.
Love the guys at 3:18 and 7:00 . They get it.
I dont say theyre wrong or something
But theres huge diffrence between co existance and peace, peach is between goverments, in the palestinian side they dont hace free speech and basicly most of them support terrorism (so called resistance) and the minority that think else way cant talk freely.
In israel we have our own problems but at least you can hear so many diffrent ideas and opinions
I live in ramle too, the guy is lying sorry to tell you, not once did arabs do complete rampage burning houses and busses in the main streets, i legit am scared to go out. Fuck this place im moving to jew only when i grow up
The kind of content we need. Maybe the "there will never be peace. everybody thinks so" is a big fat lie that too many people fell into ;)
Arabs began paying attention to Zionism in the late Ottoman period.
In 1899 , compelled by a holy duty of conscience , Yousef al-Khalidi , mayor of Jerusalem and a member of the Ottoman Parliament , wrote a letter to Zadok Kahn , the chief rabbi of France to voice his concerns that Zionism would jeopardize the friendly associations among Muslims , Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Empire.
He wrote , ( Who can deny the rights of the Jews to Palestine ? My God Allah , historically it is your country ) , meaning that Khalidi is saying that the land belongs to the jews , according to Allah ....
But Khalidi suggested that , since Palestine was already inhabited , the Zionists should find another place for the implementation of their political goals , and he added ( in the name of God , he wrote , let Palestine be left alone ) , meaning that in this case Khalidi prefers to decide by himself , instead of listening to Allah ....
So Khalidi said in the beginning , who can deny the Jews to Palestine , and then turns to Allah , in Adding ( That Historically it is the land of the Israelites ) , but Khalidi is the one who denies it , as he says firstly , who can deny , and directly denies it from the jews himself...
You see the Hypocrisy here , you see Arabs say one thing , and say that they believe in Allah , but a second after , they are the one's who deny his word , and prefer to take their own decisions for their political agendas , meaning forgetting Allah's words.
And the same thing happened with Aj Amin al Husseini , and the father of all Muslim brotherhood ( Hassan al Banna ) , where both of those religious figures knew the truth , just like Khalidi , but their instant move was to oppose the Connection of the Jews to the land , and that Allah himself has signed the holy land for the children of Israel ( Surah 5 verses 20 to 26 , where in verse 26 , Allah Forbids them the entry for 40 years , 40 years , not 1 million years , and not 1 trillion years , just 40 years , and those 40 years have long passed....
You see the Hypocrisy , and since than Israelites have bloomed , while the Arabs of the land have Fallen , this is what happens when you deny the word of Allah ..
Taqfiri ways didn't help neither , the Muslim brotherhood is responsible for all the Arab downfalls in the past century , from being once the most advanced and civilized Religion , to sadly becoming an abomination , just because of the Muslim brotherhood
Coz Zionist Nazis started to attack us that time
There was no hypocrisy there. The thing that you missed in your interpretation of the verses in the Quran, is that the promise of the land was conditional. And when the conditions were not met and they repeatedly disobeyed him he exiled them all over the world. 40 years have passed, true, then why did he not return them to the promised land before even the Arabs came?
Zionists simply used religion to push their agenda and create a secular state in the middle east. They could care less about what's in the holy books.
And why are there still millions of Jews outside of Israel today even though there is a Jewish state? Why don't they all move back?
God didn't give you anything the entity you worship is a demon. Whatever it said to the Jews was not said out of kindness or love but aimed at making them bad people. And it worked.
Lmao where exactly did Allah draw out the borders? Elaborate please!
From Canaanites to Hebrews to the first Christians, under Arab rule, most converted to Islam. God Promised the land to the Hebrews' descendants, not to people to convert to Judaism from other parts of the world. Immigrant Jews need to put themselves in the shoes of the "real chosen people, the Palestinians," and consider how the descendants of the authors of Judaism and Christianity are still very religious.
Quite a contrast to the same question being put to the Palestinians.
Like the Israeli Jews I hope they can find a solution to this problem and for there to be a secure Israel and peace for both sides.
Einat Wilf interviews are good.
Question for 🇮🇱is: If Ham as was hiding amongst civilians in Tel Aviv, would you use the same warfare tactics to "eradicate Ham as" that are being uses in G@ za?
Yes, the difference would be that civilians would listen to the IDF warnings and they will be free to evacuate the area before the military operation without being trapped by Hamas.
@@milenaavesani7799 is that why they got bombed while they were moving to the safe zone? ls that why the marked (and actively communicated) aid vehicles with foreign nationals were attacked?
@metadata5760 often Hamas fires on its own to inflate their casualties and to force their human shields to stay in place.
Hannibal detective is answering your question and how they value human lives
@jouilia536 you have no clue as to how much Israelis value life. The Hannibal Directive pertains to protecting IDF soldiers from being taken captive. IDF soldiers are tortured when they are captured and they do their best to prevent this.
Yes, I can. That's a basic answer to the question. How to achieve this needs more contemplation. I think some answers revolve around the meaning or importance of identity.
When I first went to Israel, I was honestly trying to convince my fiancé (now my husband), who lived here, to go away together to Europe, cause he has an Austrian passport and I am 50% 🇪🇸 50% 🇮🇱 (and a convert Jew, cause only my dad was).
I love Israel but it really is difficult with an European mentality to make aliyah.
It's not fot the weak... 🇮🇱
Yes, the Israeli mentality is unique. Not sure whether it is the compulsory military service that made them like that. Warm personality but too much abrasiveness and bluntness atimes.
I live in israel, it is really challenging, for someone who is European… everything is so middle eastern, not in the best sense
@@Vocalhero-w9q Zionism is European. From Canaanites to Hebrews to the first Christians, under Arab rule, most converted to Islam; that is the history of the Palestinian people, and I am very sure they feel OK with how their people changed and survived in their loved ancestral homeland.
@@adrianabotello9911this is actually not the case. There's also examples throughout history or Mizrahi Jews attempting to return to their homeland. Even the Ethiopian Jews long to return. It's part of the prayers and everything, throughout all Jewish groups. Maybe the word "Zionism" as a defined movement originated in Europe, but within every Jewish population in every country there is a theme of wanting to go back to their native land, ever since they got kicked out in circa 70CE
@@saskiascott8181@saskiascott8181 Why can't genetics show connections between these groups and the Natuffians or Canaanites? I believe you that their books say so, but Palestinians inherited more than 80% of their genes directly from Canaanites; if there were more than some lines in some books, it would show. North African Jews are the only ones with some admixture, but how old is that? Sephardic Jews got all the way to America in the 1500s precisely in the contrary direction. Thank God for that.
As an Israeli, I find it harder and harder to imagine coexistence. There's coexistence with Israeli Arabs, which is fine and almost ideal. The problem is with the term "Palestinian", which is almost defined by its opposition of Israel. If an Israeli Arab refers to himself as an Israeli-Palestinian, I feel less comfortable around him.
Peace? I can imagine it with strict separation. Gaza's population needs to be deprogrammed from the hate and jihadism. After that happens and Gaza has a normal leadership capable of healthy communication, then we can MAYBE consider Gaza to be an independent state and approach it as such, with strict borders, diplomacy, cutting the free aid we used to provide it so it learns to be self-sustaining, and hope that it ceases its hostility, allowing for careful peace. As for Judea and Samaria, I don't see the region becoming a separate state (they don't either), and I don't see the local population assimilating into Israel. If it does want to accept Israel and assimilate, it has to forgo the "Palestine" and "Palestinian" nonsense. If it doesn't, the population could choose to join Gaza or the already existing "Palestinian" state - Jordan. If they can't accept Israel, they don't get to live in the land of Israel.
October 7 revealed a term in Israel: Conception. We held onto the idea of peace, that perhaps Hamas was actually becoming more moderate and that all those "attack Israel" drills and trainings were just for show, so much that it burst in our faces. Border security was reduced over the years, or it was automated or remote controlled. When the attack happened, the envelope was terribly unprotected. And that happened because of the conception, because we thought that the people in Gaza ultimately wanted to live peacefully, wishing for western values. And we were wrong.
It's a bleeding wound that will take a LOT of effort to close and heal. Until then there will be no trust. And without trust, there will be no peace.
Why do you have to decide what the Arab population in Judea and Samaria want to do with their lives? Why even threaten them with forcible expulsion because they disagree with the State of Israel? The grandparents and great-grandparents of those Arabs were already living in that land before the State of Israel existed.
'Peace? I can imagine it only with strict separation.'
Lmao, are you serious? Separation is were conflicts start, unity is were peace begins. Think about it again.
@@robtoYou're incorrect. This has never been about land. This is about radical islam's ambition to establish a global caliphate under sharia law.
What peace??? After having killed this number of live you have proven that you are not human and cannot live with! You'll be expelled soon or late! You cannot live in a such hostile environment! The young generation will fight against you until the end! And not only the palestinians ALL the people in the region!!! Things could have been much easier and people could have lived together if only the strong (Israel) showed a bit of pragmatism and humanism, really! The jews have lived with muslims for centuries, but you showed that the contrary isn't possible! So prepare yourselves to leave! It is just a matter of time...but your fate is already sealed!
Zionazis that make up israeli society don’t believe in peace. Israelis actually envisioned a world where the Palestinians accept and enjoy being the slaves to the israeli Jews. Oct. 7th shattered that vision so the Israeli savages are going on their campaign of endless slaughter in the hopes that they’ll get the Palestinians to return to wanting to be their slaves. So you and the rest of the Israelis can go to hell.
The story you shared is a pivotal and deeply symbolic moment from the Mahabharata. It highlights Duryodhana's arrogance and unwillingness to compromise, which ultimately led to the catastrophic Kurukshetra war. Krishna’s peace proposal was a final attempt to avoid the conflict, underscoring his role as a divine strategist and protector of dharma.
Despite the tragic loss of countless lives, including the children of the Pandavas, the Mahabharata teaches profound lessons about the consequences of unchecked greed, pride, and the importance of standing for righteousness, even at great personal cost. It’s a timeless narrative that resonates with the struggles between justice and injustice, peace and war. It depends which side are you and how you see the justice and injustice. Thats how indians understood this conflict
No body understands Hinduism here ...
The matter discussed here is among people of Abrahimic faiths.
@@Sandra_6 try; it does make a point. (Christian here)
Very cool to hear some of your wisdom as a Hindu/Indian person applied to this conflict, thank you
We have no choice but to live together in peace and security, and experience has proven that neither party can eliminate the other, but to live together without one party being superior to the other. Our children have the right to have a future free of fear and killing.
No choice? There are 22 ar ab is lamic states.
@dogbert52 This proposal is not fair. You come to us from different countries and ask us to leave. Our roots have been in this land for thousands of years and we cannot leave it. If you hesitate, then leave it. So your country is expanded towards Jordan and you ask them to leave to Iraq or Egypt, and then you expand towards Iraq and ask them to leave towards Sudan. Or Yemen, this represents true greed and the erasure of the other
@jehadasad1519 you know that many arabs migrated to the land to work. Islam isnt thousands of years old and the arab invasion of the levant didnt happen the seventh century. I don’t know why you are implying that Israel is expanding when it is the opposite. Israel looks like Swiss cheese and it doesn’t even look like a proper state because the Arab territory keeps eating at it. The only reason Israel keeps gaining land like the Sinai peninsula Gaza and the West Bank is because of the wars that the Arab started and lost. And even then, Israel gave back Sinai and Gaza, but Egypt wouldn’t take Gazza back. I feel like the Arab population doesn’t do enough of taking any responsibility and accountability for their part in preventing peace.
@jehadasad1519 if you wanna talk about erasure, why are there less than 20,000 Jews in the Arab and Muslim countries when there are 2 million Arabs living in Israel with citizenship
@@magenta.indigena Do you believe all of the local Arabs are foreigners? Or the majority? What happened to all of the natives before the Arabs?
Most want peace, and don't favor evicting Palestinians. But when Shuster asks Palestinians in the West Bank, most say Israel must end, Jews must leave, it's our land, etc. Not at all equal...
They have been brought up that way, just like in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Iran. One dominant group and the rest are worthless dreck.
The guy from Ramle has the best response ♡. Those advocating separation are sad to hear. Coexistence is the way, even though it is not easy, barriers and distances can disappear if all sides put effort with integrity and strong leadership.
That will never ever happen. Sorry to be a party pooper… in theory, I think it’s a wonderful idea and a beautiful thing to teach young people to give them hope. But Israel and Palestine will never be able to coexist… the best solution is for Israel to fully annex Gaza and the West Bank, and create autonomous regions similar to what the United States did with Puerto Rico. And the Palestinians need a king too, otherwise they splinter into groups. Just look at Gaza…
@@LinkinPark4694Israel has a sensitive case when it comes to demographics, Israel can't give its papers to the five million Palestinians, they are not Jewish
Israel has been built to be a home for my people from all over the world, a safe heaven, we have our unique identity, Israel is a Jewish state@@LinkinPark4694
@@LinkinPark4694puerto Rico citizens own American nationality
Separation is the way of the world. Borders exist for a reason. Those railing against "separation" mostly just want to abolish Israel in favor of a Muslim-Arab state across all of former Mandate Palestine.
8:46 💯 such a well spoken gentleman. כבוד.
The only way there will ever be peace is when all the haters learn to accept Israel.
You think so ? So the Israelis jews don't have extremist that provoke ? The poorest family in my village turmussaya was kicked out their house not to long ago and taken over by settlers. They beat the father and sons and these people don't bother anyone. When their kids see this you want them accept you ?
@@jayfields7513It's not their house, it's not their land, it's not their village, it's our ancestral land
Why don't the Jews accept to live in the middle east peacefully
Are the palestinians occupy you or you occupy PALESTINE?
Ask Israelis :Do these extremist settlers have a right to violently drive Palestinians from their homes and land?
No! They are a disgrace.
He probably already did it, but you won't search, it's just about whereaboutism and vomiting your hate.
I saw the one- “Israelis: Do you see non Jews as equal to you?” Lot of hate and supremacy there
I ask you do the observant “good” Israeli settlers and hilltop youths have a RIGHT to drive West Bank Palestinians from their homes and lands?
Now ask the Palestinians the same question.
They want their land back 🤷🏼♂️
Forget thier so called land it is not worth beheading babies.
@
Tell me the year it was their land? The ruler?
Give me the borders?
Or do you just repeat leftist and Is lambs propaganda?
@
Tell me the year it was their land and their founder? Tell me the names of all the other people you deny their historical homeland other than Jews?
It's not their land. Whay can't you get?@texasdude1
All parties can live together without quarrel IF there is ACCEPTANCE OF THE TRUTH AND OF LOVE.
Hamas has vowed never to show acceptance.
The South Africans said the same about the blacks and anc . The Northern Ireland Protestants said the same about the Catholics and IRA. Once the oppression of the blacks and Catholics stopped peace was obtained Stop oppressing the Palestinians
🎯
None of the oppressed group you mentioned above had a leader whose charters (both) are repeatedly stating the will of exterminating all the Jews.
They are not oppressed, they are violent
How?
How about Palestinians stop attacking Israel
Its about future of peace between Jews and arabs/muslims, not between Jews and "palestinians"(1964).
See stupid bigoted comments like that are stopping peace and you blame us Palestinians? Same way I believe Mizrahi Jews are actually from the Middle East and names like kestenbaum, Friedman and silverstein are definitely not indigenous and the names of European colonizers
In the state of Tel Aviv and in general, there are people who have not yet reached reality and are living in dreams.
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Your mind has been begging questions or statements since you began trolling your anti Zionist crap October 7th.
If you post on Al Jazeera they will welcome you.
Otherwise you are just a troll that is very ignorant 🤥🥱👈
@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings No no no no and no.Enough for you bot?
@@EvantropTruth may hurt, but it's the truth.
The ICC and the ICJ are going to get all eventually.
Amazing how some j ewish israelis still didnt understand october 7th and the is la mic celebrations around those horrors
@@Evantrop, tantrums will get you nowhere.
Peaceland
The Land of Brotherhood and Sisterhood previously known as Israel/Palestine.
It would be so beautiful! Let's be best friends. Hugs
Unfortunately the Arabs made clear that it will never happen with the 3 big NOs of Khartoum: NO PEACE, NO RECOGNITION, NO NEGOTIATIONS.
Please stop calling the Arabs from surrounding countries that settled in Gaza, Palestinians. Palestinians were how the Romans referred to jews.
Please stop calling the Europeans, Iranians, Yemenis and Moroccons "Isrealis" Isreal is a prophet and God is not a land broker🤣🤣 those Palestinians belong to levant lands (yes surrounding countries d-umb ahh) more than the blonde "Russle" from Poland😂😂😂😂 most Surrounding countries called them Palestinians and "Isrealis" who were there before their fellow jews came literally had "Palestinian citizenship under the British mandate Palestine" ur not gna erase facts with ur "Godly" superstitions
@ There is no god, which makes the islamists, who have killed over 270 million infidels for their murderous psychopath pedophile all the more absurd. By the way d-umb ahh, jews are not the occupiers in this equation.
Palestinians as people were invented in 1964 by Arafat/KGB. Before "palestinian" was the adjective for people living in the region: palestinian Jews, palestinian Arabs, palestinian Christians ecc.
@@playdate8827 So if Palestinians live outside of their homeland for 200 years... Let's say they live in Europe and after 200 years, their descendants are blond, but they still speak Arabic, are they allowed to move back to Palestine still? Or are they too blond to live there now?
Uh, no they're not. The Romans renamed the land Palestine, but they never referred to Jews as Palestinians. They renamed the land Palestine after the Philistines, who were the Jews' mortal enemies, so why would they also refer to Jews as Palestinians? You've got your history all mixed up, I'm afraid.
2 state solution is the best solution for both sides. There are 5 million muslims in Palestinian territories ( West Bank , Gaza and East Jerusalem ) . And 2 million muslims are already in the internationally recognised part of Israel . If they will be united , this new country will be half jewish , half muslim country without dominant ethnic group. I think these two can't coexist together in the same country ( at least for now ) , because both sides want their own homogenous state ( in reality ) and doesn't accept the dominance of another . The ethnic tensions will always be present in this type of country. That's why it's better to give both sides their self determination right. So , the solution is the honest referendum in state of Palestine ( East Jerusalem , West Bank and Gaza ) . They probably would for the sovereignety of Palestine and it would be the best choice for both sides to reach the peace.
I wish peace for all.
But the Arabs Israeli wants to be in Israel and enjoy democracy and freedom of speech not Sharia Law of Arabs governance. Arabs in Israel are happy and does not want 2 states other wise they will be kick out of Israel if the Israel will be divided into two, Arabs and Jews. One state is best all both Arabs and Jews obey one Law, be obedient and peace will come, there is no problems with the Jews, Arabs has a problems selfish and they do not want to be dominated, and Arabs does not like to follow Laws, they always want above the Law.
If all Arabs will become a good boy, Peace will come.
@@gigiloveshongkong7133 I disagree with you. Israeli arabs and Palestinians are not the same. Plus , not all arabs live under sharia law. Palestinian Authority is secular and in fact opposes Hamas and only Gaza is controlled by Hamas , not the entire Palestine. Even the secular arabs disagree with the laws of Israel. They want their own country ( at least the ones in West Bank ) . Also , democracy needs to be voluntarily , not forced. Palestinians , just like any national group in the world , deserves the right of self determination. That's my opinion. I strongly oppose religious rule , but I still believe there's still hope for secular Palestine as an independent nation.
@dragon1715 Corey had ask many Arabs and they want in Israel, and they wants Jews go away, Arabs wants all Israel, they can not move on the 1948 independence of Israel, and if two states , ALL Arabs think they will be tricked and kick out of Israel like 1947, that's the answer of many Palestinian.
What about giving the Palestinians a home I your country? It's very big
Palestine has never been an independent state, which means the residents who lived there never owned the land, the land of Israel wasn't owned by the Arabs
That ramle guy is boss
Never forget. 10 7
10 7 is a Jewish propaganda day to justify Gaza-holocaust
Never forget nakba and never forget genocide of 2024 in palestine by Zionist colonial project
There was Germany version 1944.
There is Israel version 2024.
Both will be remembered as the most evil countries of their time.
after the genocide in palestine nobody care about oct 7
And they can't forget 1948 and animals are looking at you laughing
Danke!
A thief would easily accept to divide what he has stolen if get caught but the real owner would never agree. Simple.
@MarkDenmark-nz2pz You still haven't figured out that the arabs living in Gaza, who aren't allowed to return to their ancestral homelands in surrounding countries colonized by the islamists, are pawns of the islamists in their quest to establish a worldwide caliphate. Wake up, kaffer.
And yet the Al-Aqsa Mosque is built on the ruins of the Jewish Temple and not the other way around, so who is the thief here?
@ I will never look to this conflict from religious perspective. Palestinians are Muslims , Christians, Druz and many even atheists. Same goes to Isrwlis .
@MarkDenmark-nz2pz We get it, you hate jews.
@MarkDenmark-nz2pzbut the only place where Jews, Muslims, Christians and Druze live in safety and freedom is in Israel and in none other places in this area!! Israel is here to stay and it will be the end of the world before someone move them from here! There are 7 million Jews the majority born here, they are not going anywhere!
Israelis: What do you think of Isreal closing their embassy in Ireland?
The hospitals in Israel are the best example of shared society. That's not accidental; Henrietta Szold believed deeply that Zionism should be focused on building a shared society for the benefit of all the land's inhabitants and she set up Hadassa hospitals and medical facilities with that top of mind.
I would like to ask Arab-Israelis of they identify as Palestinian.
So yes, many dont
There's an older video that has a similar question. "When you go to another country, do you tell people you're from Israel or Palestine?". The answer was mostly "depends what country i go to", if i remember correctly.
Israel belongs to Jews and Arabs have 22 countries.
malik The two greatest Jews in modern history disagree with you, so would you have won an argument with Sigmund Freud and Einstein? but then again you maybe a Genius
you miss a point that many palastinians have Jewish mezrachi DNA
being arab is not about DNA
if u speak arabic you become an arab.
ofc many arabs in palastine are arab but mostly they are a mix of jews and christians and arabs that stayed in that area
@malik stop saying shit you don't understand about people you don't understand. Arabs are a cultural linguistic group with several races and ethnicities inside.
Also, the Juice have all the countries of Europe to return to and America, way more than 22.
Yes but the colonists want to cleanse israel out of j e ws...... just like they did in the 22 other countries.
Israel does NOT belong to Jews
6:57 Bassem, the Palestinian guy, speaks lovely Hebrew....I can understand every word! Hurrah!
He’s such a sweetie. We need more people in general like him
Takk!
Heartening to see that not every Israeli Jew rejects the notion of coexistence out of hand. EDIT... even though it is completely reasonable to believe that peace with the Palestinians of today is totally impossible.
Perhaps you should not get your information about Jews from John Oliver
Many more Israeli 's feel this way compared to Palestinians
@@danielspivak3926 I am one, lived in Israel, have family and close friends there, mostly in the north, speak Hebrew pretty fluently, am no fan of John Oliver, and do my best to not prejudge people. You might want to try that last part.
All I meant was it would be understandable for everyone to reject the notion of coexistence at this point.
@@8aNda1d Not much of a competition! I've spent 14 months looking for anything to grasp onto from the Palestinian side, and there ain't much.
most israelies don't reject it
but unfortantley most of our neighbors do
so when israelis are saying that they don't belive it's possible it's because of what we see, hear and expirenece from our neighbours
you can think about it like you have a roomate you try to get along with but he keeps stealing from you
and lie to you and gossip with the other neighbours about how bad of a roomate you are and when you confront him he threaten you and even hitting you
but then he apologize once , you forgive him and after you forgive him and try to look into a solution he does it again
so would you trust that roomate? , would you confidentely want to have a good relationship with this roomate that is keeping acting bad and react violentley when confronted or deciving you?
The diference beetween the isareli and the palestinians is sttagering...go see th eother episode to compare the poor innocent palestinians view....
Never in history was palestinian poeple or nation called palestine. Palestine was geographic region name for the land its including jordan in the time off the british mandate also name trans jordan.palestine is latin name not arabic.the arabs take the palestinian identity in 1964 by yasser arafat egyptian man like many off these arabs caling themself palestinian came from.in the 19 centery 1878 the ottoman sultan bring arabs from the suranded arabs country as working immigrat.the same with.the british mandate in 1923.these are the arabs caling themself palestinian.you can tel wish arabs country the came from by the family name.el masry from egypt.el baghdadi from iraq.tamimi from saudia.jewish poeple was always in the land off israel.before 1967 west bank was jordan not palestine.the same with gaza was egypt before 1967.is many physical evidence this land belong to the jewish poeple archeologic.in the quran israel mention 43 time palestine 0 time.
Israel was invented in the 19th century. It's just another colony from European fascists who stole a piece of land from the arabs
We’re not buying what you’re selling buddy. Free Palestine!
@@weeshirley5934no buddy
You want ethnic cleansing of Jews
You can imagine whatever you want, even three-headed unicorns that tell terrible jokes, sneeze glitter, and argue over which one gets to eat the last cupcake!
Wait, you're saying he's not real???
@@AndreyKrichevsky
No, not necessarily i have one in my garage, do you have one as well?
@untitled7184 No. But one of them has me...
@@AndreyKrichevsky
😱
Don't mind but your surveys are far from reality. Because on ground reality, Israel is expanding it's territory even before oct 7. So, you should also have to represent the views of jews sharing common ideas of Ben Gvir and Smotrich.
What is the size of israel?
How did it change over the years?
What is the size of the ar ab countries?
He asks random people, what is your point?...
Nope
No way ......never togheter again !
Exactly, not after the genocide that’s happening in Gaza
I agree with second person the Arab Muslim woman
corey your naivete is amazing.
How? My impression is that he plays dumb in order to get people to answer more clearly.
He asks what he is been asked to by his audience. It had nothing to do with his opinion and/or beliefs
Peace?????😂😂😂😂
Never hepoend war it big money..
What really surprised me-or what I find very interesting, viewed neutrally-is that the second group of people you interviewed, Israeli Arabs, said they are in favor of a one-state solution, meaning that everything should belong to Israel, including Gaza and the West Bank, or rather Judea and Samaria. I would say, at the moment, that this might not be a bad idea overall, but the people over there would have to accept it. It cannot just be imposed on them. Only if they themselves want it-in Gaza and in Judea and Samaria-could it be done through the right to self-determination of peoples. Otherwise, I would also say a two-state solution is necessary.
However, Gaza and the West Bank absolutely need to be democratized, just as the Germans had to do twice in history. Once in West Germany after World War II and again in East Germany, in the former GDR, after 1989, following the SED dictatorship. That may take time, but then they could finally live in peace. Right now, the Palestinians in Judea and Samaria, in the West Bank, and in Gaza cannot freely express their opinions. If they speak out against Hamas, for example, or against the PLO, depending on which area we’re talking about-against Hamas in Gaza or against the PLO in the West Bank-and advocate for a two-state solution or peace with Israel, they can face serious problems repeatedly.
This is why, when Palestinians are interviewed on camera, most of them speak out against Israel, simply because they are afraid. Unfortunately, this fear should never exist; no one should have to be afraid to freely express their opinion. This is true even in many democratic countries-Germany is the best example of this-but I hope you understand what I’m trying to say here. Shalom Aleichem. We want peace for everyone.
A one state solution is completely unrealistic and one that Israel can never accept. The reason is that Israeli annexation of the West Bank and Gaza will inevitably result in Israel no longer being a Jewish state or no longer being a democracy. If it would to maintain it's democratic identity, then the newly annexed Palestinians would become Israeli citizens and Jews will become a minority in Israel. If, on the other hand, Israeli would annex the West Bank and Gaza but wouldn't grant citizenship to the Palestinians, in order to maintain the Jewish identity of the state, it would become an apartheid state, and no longer be a democracy.
Uh...a one state solution would not be majority jewish, and therefore, it would be more of a Palestine than an Israel ;)
I'm not sure they meant governed by Israel but united. In Germany one country swallowed the other one up and it led to so much trauma and resentment. It is almost 35 years later and it still feels like an identity being robbed to many people from the former GDR and their children. They feel like second class citizen at times. And they never had such hatred about one another to begin with. Unification I therfore see only possible if 2 states next to each other without one wanting to kill and exile the other works. That has to be stable for at least a generation. Then maybe it's possible to unite. But not under israeli rule. Just think about cremea and Russia /Ukraine. And they were basically brothers with language and culture so aligned. Jews from the middle East and Arabs have a lot in common but the 40% ashkenazi are quite different. Not in a bad but noticeable way that complicates things further.
@@benjamingoldstein6298and not democratic because eventually there is no arab democratic state anywhere in the Middle East
More pessimism than I'd hoped
King of expected. The question is asked in the middle of a war, started by the most brutal attack on the country in history...
They attack their neighboring countries yet wanna be the victims 😂😂😂😂
Americans showing their ignorance is the best show in town.
Lay off the za lil homie you soon wont have any braincells left
There is no victimhood amongst Israelis but attitudes have become negative toward a solution and movement to peace.
Correction we defend ourselves from attacks from neighboring countries
What victims? Israelis pride themselves for working hard in any situation, they are not eternal refugees and victims like the Palestinians are
@@somegirl4631hence why crying and shutting down an embassy because a country told you no murder.
Truly, not professional victims @ all.
For bath Palestinians and Israelis - Now Assad is gone, should the new Syrian gov continue to be an ally with Iran.
Not with Iran but sure not with the Israeli occupation
@@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz
What islamic occupants dont like occupation
Weird
@@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz My question is pertaining to Iran, being that the rebels essentially fought their proxies and are or were Sunni fundamentalist with Iran being Shia, and I imagine after the Fact that the new Syrian gov were only even able to topple Assad because of Israel's complete anhilation of Hezbollah, and now that Israel has now destroyed most of their internal military capabilities. They may not want.a buddy buddy relationship with Israel, but they also likely don't want to poke the Bear. I can see them taking a route of neutrality and not making Israel an enemy either.
بينما استمع لما يقولون ، لمحت الأرض و الحجر و الشجر في الخلفية ، تذكرت أغنية الفنان سيد درويش : الأرض بتتكلم عربي
I don't think the Earth speaks in a particular language. Is your remark a common idea among Arabs?
Everyone hears what they want. I heared Hebrew
Arabic? That earth was speaking hebrew thousands of years before Arabic arrived there via colonialism
@@Shie67 prophet Abraham lived and died stranger in the land of kanaan , it’s well known Palestinians descendants mainly of kanaanites
@@yelenas7923 you’re wrong, different lands speak different languages , hills of Galilee and Jerusalem speak same language as bakaa valley, Amman hills Damascus, Cairo , Baghdad etc
I believe that only an one state solution would lead to peace, because two states means separation again, thats where conflicts gonna starts, "this is only mine' kindergarten culture. Adults who want peace should share the land, Arabs and jews together, Arabic and hebrew in all schools.
and one state means no jewish state that would lead to more problems than there were. two states is the most realistic one with the right politicians on both sides
@linoyohana1186 what do you mean, why would one state mean no Jewish state? There can be both Jews and Palestinians in the government, I mean a mixed state, where everyone is protected by the law and be equal.
@@jouilia536because 56 is la mic countries eint enough.... i hope you learn from a 7th of october soon
As an American, I think we realized that “separate but equal” is a farce.
Unfortunately the Arabs made clear what they want with the 3 big NOs of Khartoum: NO PEACE, NO RECOGNITION, NO NEGOTIATIONS.
"If I don't steal it then someone else will"
- Fat Yakob the settler from NY
ahahahah fu
This bot works 24/7
WHO ARE THE COLONISERS ?
Clan / Family names of “Palestinians”:
Al-Husseini, Al-Hassan, Hijazi, Tamimi, Erekat, Barghouti, Qureshi, Badawi - Saudi
Yamani, Azad - Yemen
Haddadins - Yemen (Ghassanids)
Masri, Masrawa, Tartir, Bardawil, Fayumi - Egypt
Abu Kishk, Shakirat, Zabidat, Aramsha, Abu Sitta, Abu Sutta, Shaalan - Egypt
Turki, Sultan, Uthuman - Turkey
Iraqi, Baghdadi, Faruqi, Tachriti, Zoabi, Abbas - Iraq
Nashashibi, Hurani, Allawi, Halabi - Syria
Lubnani, Tarabulsi, Sidawi, Surani - Lebanon
Al Bushnak - Bosnia
Al Khamis - Bahrain
Al Afghani - Afghanistan
Al Mughrabi - Maghreb
Al Araj - Morocco
Al Djazair - Algeria
Al Kurd - Kurdistan
Hindi - Indian Subcontinent
Al Abid - Sudan
Not very INDIGENOUS
so ridiculous you are😂😂😂@@dani-ks9cg
@@dani-ks9cg Exactly. Arab colonization must be stopped.
Whatever happened to the Mizrahim black panthers? They finally accepted they’re inferior to the Ashkenazi? They and the Sephardim are nothing less than imported Arabs anyhow.
Least racist arnab:
They can only fool the fools
We intelligent people know exactly what the Jews want to do with the blood of the nation
Good luck with believing conspiracies
@@danielspivak3926 Intelligent? You''re funny!!!
The people talking about this always seem to be sidestepping the crux of the issue, that in 1947-48 much of Palestine's Arab population became refugees and were never allowed back. They're saying "Yes, we can live together like we do now in Ramle" because Ramle is 20 or 25% Arab. But 80% of Ramle's Arabs were expelled by Yitzhak Rabin in 1948. So can there be peace with 5 times as many Arabs in Ramle, making Jews the minority? Most Israelis are a lot more hesitant if you make that part of the question. But without a right of return for refugees, there will never be an end to the conflict.
History is not your strong suit... First of all, Rabin was just an officer at the time and was appointed as chief of staff on 1963.
As for the Arabs refugees, there war about 600,000 of them, from which about 400,000 settled in Jordan and got citizenship and some went to Gaza. The rest went to Syria and Lebanon. What you neglect to mention is how the Arabic leadership (who didn't accept the partition and actually started the war with intent to slaughter the Jewish population) told the Arab population to leave their homes because they were confident they will win the war and then allow them to return. For those who didn't flee, while there are cases of Israeli soldiers attacking the Arab population, it was a minority of individuals (I'm not justifying, but unfortunately it is like that in war sometimes) and by no means a deliberate policy. A lot of the Arabs who stayed later became citizens of Israel.
If the Isreli Arabs would have Palestinians from the territories and Gaza be part of Israeli democracy as things are now (not that they want to), in a very hypothetical and not realistic scenario, they would pass rules to expel or kill every single Jew under the current leadership and the population's state of mind.
Very sad but also very true.
If there were to be a deradicalization process over a generation, living together might become an option.
A two states solution will probably work better for now...
did you know that the Muslim countries expelled more Jews when Israel was created than there were Palestinian Arabs that left or were expelled? The problem is the refugee agency that makes them believe that they have a right to return, but that’s invalid because once you lose a war, you lose your territory. The right of return is a delusion. It’s perpetrated by people who make tons of money in this conflict.
No one expelled them. They were encouraged to leave by their leaders who promised them that they will be able to return. This is the first time when the Arabs started crying and it never came to an end. War isn’t a game. If you start a war no one can make you any promises. Be peaceful and nothing will happen
@@dolev2692 I literally read it in Leah Rabin's memoirs and Yitzhak Rabin's memoirs. He signed the expulsion order to kick them out of Lyd and was in charge of executing the operation in Ramle as well. Of course they justify it and say they had no choice because they had to secure the corridor from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, but they clearly said they did it. He wasn't chief of staff when he did it, of course. He was operations officer and second in command to Yigal Allon in that operation. There's a famous interaction between Yigal Allon and Ben Gurion, in front of Yitzhak Rabin, in which Allon asks Ben Gurion what to do with the residents of the towns. Ben Gurion waved his hand and said "Garesh otam" (expel them).
After doing a little bit of research, I have discovered that in the Hebrew version of Rabin's memoir (published in 1979), the section about the expulsion of Ramle and Lydda's population was excluded by military censors. But in the English version, it's included. I'm not sure about the Hebrew version of Leah Rabin's memoir.
The whole thing about the Arab leaders telling the population to leave isn't an important point. Even if they voluntarily left, they were never allowed to return. If someone leaves temporarily rather than participating in the war, they have the right to come back.
@@dolev2692you don't even read your own historians lol.
One name: Benny Morris.
You would have to be pretty naive to think coexistence is possible in this absolute zero sum game.
Black hbrew Israelite Jews and lgbo Jews stans with Palestine 🇵🇸✊🏿
You know, adding more Jewish terms to your identity doesn’t make you more Jewish. if your mother and your mother’s mother, and your mother’s mother’s mother is not Jewish, you’re not Jewish. You are as much Jewish as I am Japanese.
Palestine is a fictional place. It doesn't exist.
Haha potato 🥔 head. You have nothing to do with the tribe of Judea or any other tribe Israel 🇮🇱
Lol, the opposite Black Hebrew Israelites in Israel serve in the Army and Igbo in Nigeria all support Israel, not Islamist fanatic Palestinians.
Palestinians are racist
Boy did the Palestinians in America fool you!!!😂😂😂😂 Palestinians and Arabs in general in the middle east hate black people they call them Abd or Akhdam in Arabic which means slaves in Arabic...look up in UA-cam Al Jazeera documentaries about racism in Gaza and Yemen against black Palestinians and Black Yemenis who like Black Americans are descendants of slaves but they were descendants of the Arab slave trade in East Africa which of course they don't teach you about
First
In the meantime, Tsahal continues his expansion in the north. But still Israël just wants peace, nothing more. Let's continue to make fun of people with this nice questions.
☪️ will never win
Bullshit. Hezbollah attacked Israel first.
In the north, you mean in Syria?
The entire area of Syria has been captured by different groups. Turkey occupies land in Syria, the Kurds occupy land in Syria, the US has military presence in Syria and so does Russia and Iran.Multiple Islamic organizations, some from within Syria and some from other countries like Iran and Iraq, also control parts of Syria. But what's the only part you mention? that's right - the small part on the border with Israel that it took for its own safety and already said it would return when Syria has a clear and stable regime. Why is that that you don't mind everyone else, only israel?
@@catanace1741 You didn't know? It's only bad when Israel takes land.
@@catanace1741 and you are being too nice calling it small. it's really nothing if you compare to what the others are taking. Turkey even said they were going to annex what they occupied, while netanyahu said it's only temporary. People is gonna hate us for whatever. we don't even need to give them excuses, they will invent them if we don't give one to them
Hear that Palestinians? If you don't interrupt Israelis, you too can have your own state. Unless you're in the Golan Heights. In which case might makes right.
"Hear that Palestinians?"
They can't, genius
Power's out in Gaza remember?
Golan heights is a territory of Israel
@SnowsStorm1 It's all territory of Israel Sherlock. The point being made is that none of it should be and that the actual natives ought to have self determonation.
@@SuperKripke who are you to say it should or shouldn't be. It's strategically valuable
@SnowsStorm1 It shouldn't be under international law. The position that the annexation of the Golan Heights is illegal is accepted by the vast majority of the world.
One state called palestine? Ask that question xD
The first government of Israel actually considered that as a potential name for the new Jewish state, since the region was named Palestine and all the Jews were Palestinian citizens. They had several options for names, but they eventually voted against calling the new country Palestine, since they assumed the Arabs would accept the 1947 partition plan and would establish their own country named Palestine.
They also rejected the name Judea, because the region of Judea would be in that new Arab country (what's known today as the West Bank). And they voted against the name Zion, because mount Zion is where Jerusalem is, and it was supposed to become an international city controlled by the UN.
In the end, they voted for the name Israel, after the first ancient Jewish kingdom.
@AndreyKrichevsky yrah ask israelis today though....ofc they didn't accept a partition that gave the minority population majority of the land. Everyone would reject that partition lol
Israel took the lives of 5 journalists yesterday
Which brings the number to over 200. 200 journalists in less than 2 years. I don't know how you're still making justifications at this point. The world is waking up to this brutality
@@seanmurphy7953 reciting historical facts doesn't justify anything. It's just that - facts and history. Like the fact that the name Palestine was given to the land as an act of Imperialist Colonial Occupation by the Romans in the second century, after they crushed a jewish revolt.
Why would the Israelis today want to embrace a name given to them by people who colonized their land and displaced them. You wouldn't expect the Palestinians to accept the name Israel for their land, would you?
@AndreyKrichevsky Palestinians didn't colonize and displace them though. Palestinians did t choose the name, they just have it. You just said they were going to accept it, but the arabs ruined that. So what point are you making again?
I i.agine a state controlled by a minority that being the jews but it be a one state united with jordan and lebanon all minprities rights are cafantered, but they hafto learn hebrrew, the ning wpuld be a hashemite but marred to a jewiah woman
The Muslims are much more open minded. Segregation is not the way
😂😂😂😂😂
What are "pact of omar laws"?
@@dogbert52you mean the document supposely written when Islam was being born and of which the authenticy is still debated?
Well, I am laughing at the "open mindness" of today's Muslims.
@@milenaavesani7799tell me about the Hamas charter. What is the goal of Iran regime?
@@keepussafeUSAthe charters of Hamas (both of them) are available in English for you to read and acculturate yourself. But I think you didn't want to ask me.
For Hashem's sake...
Folk need to get a grip pronto that the situation has nothing to do with Israelis and Palestinians...
The problem is within the ridiculous fairytale of Apostle Paul and Muhammad's equally insane reaction to the fairytale in Islam.
Shmà Israel... OPEN UR EYES !!!
The Arabs are not going anywhere, so we need to be hopeful yet very careful.
Do you really believe there is such a thing called "Palestine"?! And if so, then let's see if you pass the test of the 3 simple questions in front of you. 1. Can you give me the name of a prime minister, or king, or president of Palestine before 1948? One member of parliament? Maybe the names of the ministers? Where was the parliament?! Or the king's palace?! Maybe what is the name of the coin?
2. Could you give me the name of a "Palestinian" historical figure from 1000 years ago or maybe 500 years ago, or even 200 years?
3. Can you tell me what the word "Palestine" means?
4. As we know in Arabic there is no letter 'P' the correct word is palleshyttina, the Romans called the Land of Israel by this name because the Jews rebelled against the Romans. The Arabs say falestin or flistin, or filistin, and if they speak in English then they say balastine or balistin
In conclusion: no one has any answer to all the questions.
The truth is that before 1948 the land was called Palestine by the British, when there were both Jews and Arabs. Golda Meir had a Palestinian passport. And there is even a Palestine soccer team from 1939 that is all Jewish. The currency that existed here at the time of the British was the Bank of Palestine Eretz Israel, which was a Jewish bank. And he issued a currency called Palestine lira Eretz Yisrael. Today the bank is called Bank Leumi. National Bank.
The Hasbara aren't sending their best.
Best of luck in the ICC and the ICJ.
Okay free Falastin
Come on, I honestly don't think anyone can live in pe ace with J s!!
@@ClaudioM-s2f so, the answer to antisemic people like you is simple. We have our own state. Don't f*ck with us
Because you are as evil as it can be
Ireland love Palestine🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Answer me a question.
Ireland also loved Hitler....so what?
You love colonizing arabs of ancient Judean land.
Source ? @@MrPickledede
That's why the only democracy in the middle east took away their embassy, because they can't tolerate love and freedom of speech 😂😂😂 very funny
Outsiders telling Palestinian natives wtherthey can stay😂
Well 60 % are middle eastern Jews , 20% Arab and majority of them are born in Israel
There was a chance till not to long ago that a two state solution, and peace was a possibility....
But given the vileness of the last year... Not any longer
October is a huge weight for israelis... But the genocide of the last year is treated with complete nonchalance.... How sick and lunatic is that....!!!!!
How shall Israel react to October 7th and secure its citizens and bring back the hostges?
Pajeeet already spotted😂
@@Itsdifferent-wv4joGo back to Poland, if you stole a home, you going to be faced with consequences
@@malikbilal-of9nv I'm not Indian but I like Indians because they don't invade others privacy
Who will punish me, no one can hurt a finger, we can do whatever we want whenever we want Wherever we want in the way we want@@malikbilal-of9nv
Thanks!
Thanks!
Thanks!
Thanks!
Thanks!