@@ryankilbylicious It is very good but the contrast between the greatest of John Lennon's output and some of his worse 70s output is quickly apparent. To be clear: I'm comparing her to John Lennon, not Foo Fighters. This is a masterpiece, but it's already not as good as "Sawdust and Diamonds."
I really don't think there has ever been a songwriter that has come even close to Joanna's talents. This is one of a handful of songs she has written that are entirely untouchable; a devastatingly beautiful, lyrical epic. She is just unlike anyone else. Beautiful.
my Soul is happy to find such beautiful people, and artists that make our stay on this Planet just really really pleasant : ) thank you! and thanks for this recording!
And Emily i saw you last night by the river, i dreamed you were skipping little stones across the surface of the water, thrown in at the angle where they were lost and slipped under forever, in a mud cloud mica-spangled, like the sky’d been waiting for a mirror. Anyhow i sat by your side by the water, you taught me the names of the stars over head that i wrote down in my ledger. All I knew of the road the universe were those Pleiades loosed in December. I promised I’d set them to verse so I’d always remember.....MOTHER OF GOD
+Ducktapeglamorous You just found Joanna?!?! You lucky duck...tapeglamorous! ;) Start from the beginning and ENJOY! I've been listening to her for at least a decade and every song gets better with every replay, especially this masterpiece. She's a true poet. And oh! OH!!! As far as a live performance, search for Joanna's "Good Intentions Paving Company" on Austin City Limits. It's probably the best 10 minutes of video on the WHOLE WIDE INTERNETS!!!
omg omg im from philippines and i am broke as a rat, omfg i will never be able to see joanna live in this lifetime omg omg, i cant breathe, i failed in life omg omg
@moceanu I'm sure they were not happy. But I hope that someday, the two nations will be wise enough to reach a peace agreement and live in peace side by side (because together it does not really working) and Palestinians will come to Tel Aviv to see performances and Israelis can see shows in Ramallah. It would be a wonderful day for me. I hope it will be a wonderful day for you too
@JonahLindelof אם כבר שאלת, אז באותו ההקשר - בתחילת ההופעה מישהי צעקה משהו (אולי אותה אחת עם הbring your boyfriend) וג'ואנה חייכה ולחשה למקרופון "yes". יש למישהו מושג מה היא אמרה? אפילו יש לי את זה מוקלט אבל אי אפשר לשמוע מילים שלמות עם הצעקות והמחיאות כפיים מסביב... וגם - ניסיתי להקליט את כל ההופעה עם הMP3 הכושל והמיושן שלי, ויצא ממש גרוע. אם למישהו יש הקלטת סאונד סבירה של ההופעה, או יכול להפנות אותי להקלטה כזו, אני אסגוד לו לנצח.
Probably because when she recorded this song her voice wasn't ultered by surgery that she had to undertake. Therefore, she needs to find a way to phrase the notes similar to how she could when her voice was more...strange? But probably more amazing.
Easily one of the greatest songs ever written
i agree. dream language. perfect and personal words to everyone but to everyone its meaning is different, thats big medicine, strong poetry magic. 😀
@@ryankilbylicious It is very good but the contrast between the greatest of John Lennon's output and some of his worse 70s output is quickly apparent. To be clear: I'm comparing her to John Lennon, not Foo Fighters. This is a masterpiece, but it's already not as good as "Sawdust and Diamonds."
@@gibberconfirm166 I'd say it is at least as miraculous as sawdust and diamonds.
I really don't think there has ever been a songwriter that has come even close to Joanna's talents. This is one of a handful of songs she has written that are entirely untouchable; a devastatingly beautiful, lyrical epic. She is just unlike anyone else. Beautiful.
and some even have the nerve to compare her with late bush
I mean, it's her and Dylan, then a vast gulf to everyone else. Emily is Visions of Johanna for the 21st century.
Obviously Dylan, but yeah no one else really
I love the expression on her face when the audience applauded as she began the song.
Everyone gets so excited when she starts and it's so raucous, and then get suddenly quiet to listen. It's great.
I love everything about this song. Every detail, every note, the lyrics, the harp, the violin and the trumpet. It's pure magic.
I love how the lyrics paint images in your imagination. What a beautiful song
This is storytelling and poetry of the highest highest level. Sublime!
So lovely. Her parents must be so proud :)
best song ever written. you are very lucky to see joanna live.
Joanna wrote the history of music with this piece and with the intire ys album.. and this performance is just.. ah
3:07 absolute favorite part, everything about this song is so enchanting 🤍✨
She is absolutely gorgeous, and her songwriting is ridiculously good. I would love to meet her.
Had to call in and let my boys down. this put a crack in my foundation.
my Soul is happy to find such beautiful people, and artists that make our stay on this Planet just really really pleasant : ) thank you!
and thanks for this recording!
My favorite song of all time. Such genius
AHHH, this is so sick!!! My favorite song by her performed incredibly by everyone. Magnificent.
This song is perfect
Gave me chills. She's a goddess.
The instrumentation on this song (and the whole album) is fucking ace
An audience who know how to give the music some respect. Lovely to see.
She's so beautiful...
i cant belive she came to my country and performed here and i didnt know about it im so upset now
CD (Ys) in my bookcase, vid in my favs. Thanx!
thank you :-)
nice Photo of rollins, he is the best
nirs1975 Henry is a Genius! Thanx 4 vid Friend :-)
amazing!! She's the best!!!!!!!!!!!!
that must be fucking spiritually moving to perform
Enough to make you fall in love
And Emily i saw you last night by the river, i dreamed you were skipping little stones across the surface of the water, thrown in at the angle where they were lost and slipped under forever, in a mud cloud mica-spangled, like the sky’d been waiting for a mirror. Anyhow i sat by your side by the water, you taught me the names of the stars over head that i wrote down in my ledger. All I knew of the road the universe were those Pleiades loosed in December. I promised I’d set them to verse so I’d always remember.....MOTHER OF GOD
עשית לי את השבוע!
תודה על האפלואודס
beautiful. u can tell the band was pleased.
I genuinely think she’s a five thousand year old bard who’s been reincarnated
She has something of the Divine about her. I love her even though I do not know her personally. Is that not the essence of divine love?
how lovely she is
5:24
I wasn't expecting those high notes. Beautiful.
I heard this today in music class and my teacher said her voice is like a dieing cat because of her tambour but I think she is so good
+Ducktapeglamorous You just found Joanna?!?! You lucky duck...tapeglamorous! ;)
Start from the beginning and ENJOY! I've been listening to her for at least a decade and every song gets better with every replay, especially this masterpiece. She's a true poet.
And oh! OH!!! As far as a live performance, search for Joanna's "Good Intentions Paving Company" on Austin City Limits. It's probably the best 10 minutes of video on the WHOLE WIDE INTERNETS!!!
tell your teacher he will be a dying cat if he continues talking about Joanna like that
+Ducktapeglamorous "Timbre", not "tambour"
your teacher is full of shit. newsom is masterful
She sounds kind of like a playful exuberant wood pixie.
Lost for words. Incredible.
i know what you mean.. i love how the audience quiets down every single time she's on stage & begins playing.. it's so damn rare to see.
I love Joanna Newsom
how can one person have so much talent
blessed thy ears
HOW DOES SHE REMEMBER THE WORDS
I actually listened to the album 50 times and I remember all the words, like 10 years ago.
gibberconfirm cool. thanks for sharing!
@@eternodisperare so awesome you got the chance to come back to this video 8 years after making your original comment
When Joanna was younger she would memorize poems for fun that's why ☺️ maybe you've already found you answer but if you haven't here!
She’s a pro
7:39 Incredible.
Thanks so much for sharing this!!!
omg omg im from philippines and i am broke as a rat, omfg i will never be able to see joanna live in this lifetime omg omg, i cant breathe, i failed in life omg omg
Holy moly.
Joanna is so fucking awesome, can’t believe no ones commented here in so long
미쳤다 미쳤어....
Amazing. Still, I don't think any live recording can ever capture the sheer majesty of 10:47 on the original recording.
This is far from the best version I have heard. Backing instruments overwhelming the vocal
Just so great! :D
Spellbinding. Brilliant! A Kate Bush for the new Millennium :)
Song and artist of the Century.Broadcast this to the Universe.
An amazing performance.
@moceanu
I'm sure they were not happy.
But I hope that someday, the two nations will be wise enough to reach a peace agreement and live in peace side by side (because together it does not really working) and Palestinians will come to Tel Aviv to see performances and Israelis can see shows in Ramallah.
It would be a wonderful day for me.
I hope it will be a wonderful day for you too
ow shit 😍😍
my roman empire
@JonahLindelof
אם כבר שאלת, אז באותו ההקשר -
בתחילת ההופעה מישהי צעקה משהו (אולי אותה אחת עם הbring your boyfriend) וג'ואנה חייכה ולחשה למקרופון "yes". יש למישהו מושג מה היא אמרה? אפילו יש לי את זה מוקלט אבל אי אפשר לשמוע מילים שלמות עם הצעקות והמחיאות כפיים מסביב...
וגם - ניסיתי להקליט את כל ההופעה עם הMP3 הכושל והמיושן שלי, ויצא ממש גרוע. אם למישהו יש הקלטת סאונד סבירה של ההופעה, או יכול להפנות אותי להקלטה כזו, אני אסגוד לו לנצח.
dat jawharp doe
Hello
Unions Unions Unions.....😭😭
@ma5t1ka That's absolutely true! :-)
"Tales From Topographic Oceans" ambitious.
@kitchenfloorblog
בשמחה :-)
@JonahLindelof
לצערי לא, העלתי את כל הקטעים שצולמו (מגבלות בטרייה וכרטיס זכרון, לצערי)
@TheVescanesca
Me too :-)
Yeah, 'to remove nodules from her vocal cords'. Bjork recently had surgery too, her voice is also different.
Andy Samberg is one lucky bastard
@ma5t1ka me too
Probably because when she recorded this song her voice wasn't ultered by surgery that she had to undertake. Therefore, she needs to find a way to phrase the notes similar to how she could when her voice was more...strange? But probably more amazing.
Why, she wrote them!
@snigguh4u
true
@snigguh4u
oh yeah...
the number of likes on this video is officially 666 nobody move
trombone rocks
@moceanu i guess that's too bad isn't it?
Freestyle
I didn't know she had surgery
Joanna Newsom >> The Beatles
And its not even close
@purplequail i bet the palestinians weren't pleased! you can't be pleased when you're not free
I wonder how many harps she has
she actually rents a harp in ever city she goes to when she tours!
a me invece mette un po' di paura, pur bravissima, ma...
i like the enthusiasm but i think you're pushing it dude
she's great, but when she sings the high notes she sometimes sounds like ling ling from drawn together. isn't that strange?