- Stu in the fountain scene, when asked if he had met Casey, Stu said, Yes, for about two seconds. He was sent to the moment where Casey took off his mask. - Stu has a motive to kill Casey, Billy doesn't, Billy just doesn't need it. - The screenwriter of the scream confirmed that Casey killed Stu. - When Casey kicks the killer, a painful groan is heard, voiced by Matthew Lillard.
no, it was dated casey, not met, they worked together, like stu attacked sid, did he have a reason to kill her? No, he never actually confirmed it, infact the cast of scream asked kevin and he said he doesn't even know, the last point is a good point though
Yeah I've been saying it since the first time I watched it as well that Stu killed Casey and Steve and I'm unsure about Tatum tho but idk I feel like it might be Stu as well (not tryna glaze Stu here I mean I love him but personally I think Stu was behind most of the murders in 1996)
@@HURRIC4NEyt there is solid evidence that stu actually killed tatum, thats because billy wouldn't risk entering the house when he just comes around the side
well actually when casey is killed you can hear billy’s scream when he lifts the knife up and stabs her- you can recognize the scream bc of the end when he is throwing things and screaming
@@-_MSR_- The tweet wasn't fake, it was actually on Kevin's page back in 2009. I saw him back when he appeared. Also, none of the actors knows who killed whom. And Stu has more reason to kill Casey.
Yeah but anything wes says is the definitely true and pretty sure he said that u could tell the difference between the killers by the way they held their knifes when they were gonna strike
@@THESLAUGHTERCOUNTER-em6tm Wes never said that, especially since even the actors don't know who killed whom. The script generally confirmed that Stu killed Tatum, but some will prove that it was Billy. Stu killed Casey in the movie, there's a lot of evidence for that. Moreover, Stu also hits with one hand. He hit Billy with his left hand and it was exactly the same in the scene of the attack on Sydney. Moreover, the styles of murders that Steve and Casey were killed with are Stu's styles.
The KNB variant of the mask isn’t lore accurate, therefore it cannot be used as a way to debate or debunk a certain opinion. Also, the mask changes from the slow-mo chase scene to the choking so this is not canonically accurate.
Why I believe Billy killed Casey Becker: Btw i notice you said he choked sidney the same way he did casey stu did not choke sidney he was holding her down. 1.Billy out of the two has the best striking strength. 2. We can see that Billy's killing style is holding up his knife then the camera zooms in to it just like how he was about to do sidney 3. All of Billys kill presented in scream 1996 is all related to hangings 4. Billy also chokes his opponents like when sidney was in deweys cop car and in act 3 when he says say hello to your mother. Why I believe Stu Macher did not kill casey: If stu was to gut steve how would he be able to run around the entire house and come from out the window stu doesnt choke none of his opponents and is more capable of stunning his victims and he does not use his knife the same way with sidney because it wouldve zoomed in to the knife like how it did the first time as we know the ghostface costume has a small f.o.v meaning doesnt matter who's in the costume they will be clumsy like how billy went against tatum we can see that neither billy or stu is clumsy when they are in act 3 and out of their costume.
Just look how Ghostface holds Knife over his head with bith hands it's Stu's killing style. And how Ghostface holds knife at Casey Becker when she takes off his mask it's Billy's style.
Well how do you explain him getting knocked out the same way? Billy is way less clumsy and him holding the knife the same way doesn’t prove anything because Stu did the same. If you look at my comments even someone else said that the one who literally created the story confirmed that Stu killed Casey. Here is a direct quote from google, *In 2009, a Scream fan tweeted Kevin Williamson and asked, "Who killed Casey Becker? Billy or Stu?" and Kevin Williamson said Stu killed Casey.*
@@Rickkyy_. It is confirmed, do research. Twitter was made in 2006 so it’s probably unlikely someone would go upon that topic that soon. Even so your point which I find factual, I still stand my belief’s of Stu being the cause of Tatum Riley’s death.
- Stu in the fountain scene, when asked if he had met Casey, Stu said, Yes, for about two seconds.
He was sent to the moment where Casey took off his mask.
- Stu has a motive to kill Casey, Billy doesn't, Billy just doesn't need it.
- The screenwriter of the scream confirmed that Casey killed Stu.
- When Casey kicks the killer, a painful groan is heard, voiced by Matthew Lillard.
no, it was dated casey, not met, they worked together, like stu attacked sid, did he have a reason to kill her? No, he never actually confirmed it, infact the cast of scream asked kevin and he said he doesn't even know, the last point is a good point though
Yeah I've been saying it since the first time I watched it as well that Stu killed Casey and Steve and I'm unsure about Tatum tho but idk I feel like it might be Stu as well (not tryna glaze Stu here I mean I love him but personally I think Stu was behind most of the murders in 1996)
@@HURRIC4NEyt there is solid evidence that stu actually killed tatum, thats because billy wouldn't risk entering the house when he just comes around the side
Casey killed Stu 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
well actually when casey is killed you can hear billy’s scream when he lifts the knife up and stabs her- you can recognize the scream bc of the end when he is throwing things and screaming
The film's screenwriter Kevin Williamson confirmed that Stu killed Casey
Tweet could’ve been fake
@@-_MSR_- The tweet wasn't fake, it was actually on Kevin's page back in 2009. I saw him back when he appeared. Also, none of the actors knows who killed whom. And Stu has more reason to kill Casey.
Yeah but anything wes says is the definitely true and pretty sure he said that u could tell the difference between the killers by the way they held their knifes when they were gonna strike
@@Major1970- wes confirmed billy killed casey
@@THESLAUGHTERCOUNTER-em6tm Wes never said that, especially since even the actors don't know who killed whom. The script generally confirmed that Stu killed Tatum, but some will prove that it was Billy. Stu killed Casey in the movie, there's a lot of evidence for that. Moreover, Stu also hits with one hand. He hit Billy with his left hand and it was exactly the same in the scene of the attack on Sydney. Moreover, the styles of murders that Steve and Casey were killed with are Stu's styles.
Stu killed Casey cause he had reason
I think Billy did it, because Billy and Stun's masks are different and we see Billy's mask in that part.
The KNB variant of the mask isn’t lore accurate, therefore it cannot be used as a way to debate or debunk a certain opinion. Also, the mask changes from the slow-mo chase scene to the choking so this is not canonically accurate.
Why I believe Billy killed Casey Becker: Btw i notice you said he choked sidney the same way he did casey stu did not choke sidney he was holding her down.
1.Billy out of the two has the best striking strength.
2. We can see that Billy's killing style is holding up his knife then the camera zooms in to it just like how he was about to do sidney
3. All of Billys kill presented in scream 1996 is all related to hangings
4. Billy also chokes his opponents like when sidney was in deweys cop car and in act 3 when he says say hello to your mother.
Why I believe Stu Macher did not kill casey: If stu was to gut steve how would he be able to run around the entire house and come from out the window stu doesnt choke none of his opponents and is more capable of stunning his victims and he does not use his knife the same way with sidney because it wouldve zoomed in to the knife like how it did the first time as we know the ghostface costume has a small f.o.v meaning doesnt matter who's in the costume they will be clumsy like how billy went against tatum we can see that neither billy or stu is clumsy when they are in act 3 and out of their costume.
Just look how Ghostface holds Knife over his head with bith hands it's Stu's killing style. And how Ghostface holds knife at Casey Becker when she takes off his mask it's Billy's style.
And he strangled her like he did to Sydney
@@jessegates8487 True
Another reason I think he did it is bc it was stu’s ex so Billy didn’t really have a reason for killing Casey
Yes, but Casey escaped from Stu and knocked him out
Then Billy comes and jumps on her.
Billy didnt have a reason to kill himbry but he did
Billy is clumsy and Stu got knocked out by the phone
Billy holds the knife in the same way he holds into Sidney before get shot by Gale.
Well how do you explain him getting knocked out the same way? Billy is way less clumsy and him holding the knife the same way doesn’t prove anything because Stu did the same. If you look at my comments even someone else said that the one who literally created the story confirmed that Stu killed Casey. Here is a direct quote from google,
*In 2009, a Scream fan tweeted Kevin Williamson and asked, "Who killed Casey Becker? Billy or Stu?" and Kevin Williamson said Stu killed Casey.*
@@JugheadMalakai
Thats fake twitter bro
And who said Billy is less clumsy?
Watch Tatum kill scene
@@Rickkyy_. It is confirmed, do research. Twitter was made in 2006 so it’s probably unlikely someone would go upon that topic that soon. Even so your point which I find factual, I still stand my belief’s of Stu being the cause of Tatum Riley’s death.
That was billy charging his power into 1 last strike since he knew he was funna die
Billy and Stu are clumsier
Billy killed Tatum bro and i'm sure about it, Stu was in party scene @@JugheadMalakai
I agree bro
W opinion
agreed