Man United 0-3 Liverpool Player Ratings

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
  • Andy Mitten shares his player ratings for Man United 0-3 Liverpool in the Premier League at Old Trafford. Erik ten Hag’s Manchester United were well beaten after two first half goals by Luis Diaz and a second half goal from Mohammed Salah.
    UWS LIVE IN IRELAND w/Brian McClair: linktr.ee/uwsmag
    Subscribe to United We Stand fanzine here: www.uwsonline.c...
    United We Stand: The Manchester United Fanzine:
    First published in 1989 when Manchester United was very different to the corporate beast it has become, United We Stand is an independent voice of Manchester United supporters.
    The majority of UWS writers watch Manchester United home and away and the mag has long been established as one of Britain's best selling football fanzines.
    Influential, incisive, irreverent and proudly independent, UWS tells it like it is. You might not always agree with the opinions within, but you'll take note. #ManUtd #ManchesterUnited #Liverpool

КОМЕНТАРІ • 314

  • @unitedwestandmag
    @unitedwestandmag  14 днів тому +8

    Man United 0-3 Liverpool Player Ratings
    Live In Ireland w/Brian McClair: linktr.ee/uwsmag
    Subscribe to United We Stand here: www.uwsonline.com/subscribe.php

    • @Danny-iv5uu
      @Danny-iv5uu 14 днів тому +1

      Obama positioning for the third was shocking. I’d even say de he’s would’ve maybe got to the second as onana isn’t the best at getting down low

    • @BelfastManUtdTherapy
      @BelfastManUtdTherapy 14 днів тому +1

      Only found out tonight your in the Limelight here in Belfast on Friday Night with Brian McClair?, looking forward to it Andy. Good timing, Oasis played the Limelight 30 years ago this week, look how they exploded! Today was disappointing and in my opinion I feel the manager was more at fault than the team, Rashford shouldnt start every game. Garnacho and Amad should start every game for a good 7 games.. Casemiro was poor and deserved being taken off but shouldnt have been taken off for a kid.. Casemiro knows he was shit. Our midfield was a hole as it was last season. Zirkzee needs games. I got slammed for my criticism of Ten Hag last season, hes not the right person. See you on Friday sir 🙂

  • @anthonyjtracey
    @anthonyjtracey 14 днів тому +60

    Dropping Amad after he gets player of the month sends the wrong message. Reward success. Within 15 minutes of coming on he had the most touches in the opposition box…

    • @brianjacob8728
      @brianjacob8728 14 днів тому +1

      I think eth wanted out last spring. Should have pulled the plug then.

    • @milz97y
      @milz97y 14 днів тому +6

      There was a clamour for garnacho to start. Rashford hasn’t been fully dog shi💩 and is usually always a “big game player”
      That said diallo will show you through out the season that he will make that rw spot his
      It’ll be garnacho and rashford competing for lw

    • @diegosophie5125
      @diegosophie5125 14 днів тому +2

      Abysmal decision

    • @lukepatterson5367
      @lukepatterson5367 13 днів тому +1

      Absolutely crazy

    • @coconutzmilk
      @coconutzmilk 13 днів тому +1

      Tbf, despite scoring, Amad didn't have a great game last game or the one before. And Garnacho had the same impact as a substitute in the last few games and the clamour was on for him to start. Then he starts and does f all.
      It's probably an indication that both are more suited to impact substitute appearances right now.

  • @symmie666
    @symmie666 14 днів тому +25

    Thanks Andy. Tough day. I stood at FT until the stadium was nearly empty.. felt hallow.

    • @anthonywalker4616
      @anthonywalker4616 9 днів тому

      @@symmie666 as a die hard fan, I find it sad that Man Utd fans now stay until the end just to avoid the traffic.

    • @symmie666
      @symmie666 9 днів тому

      ​@anthonywalker4616 that's how bad it's got 😅

  • @souvikbhattacharya7695
    @souvikbhattacharya7695 14 днів тому +20

    Hi Andy, this is another tough day in what feels like a never ending cycle of hope and despair of United’s prospects. Thank you as always for your thoughts, it’s therapeutic

  • @Turdling17
    @Turdling17 14 днів тому +11

    Fair ratings as usual Andy. For me, (I know it’s an over simplification) we can’t beat Liverpool when we’re carrying Rashford and Casimero. We were down to nine men before the whistle signified the start of the game and too many players had an off day - again.

  • @tonykennedy2344
    @tonykennedy2344 14 днів тому +33

    Grim is the word. Running out of excuses for the Manager we don’t score enough and always look like conceding . Hard to point to anything that’s working. Jim Radcliffe had a face like thunder can’t see him sticking with ETH for long at this rate.

  • @Ndpurc
    @Ndpurc 14 днів тому +10

    Of the two Dutch managers today, Slot is clearly the one with calm confidence and comes across as he knows what he’s doing, but most importantly he’s inherited a well oiled team, a squad with some depth and who have continued with the energy of Klopp, but with Slot’s tweaks they are more dynamic and ruthless. ten Hag lacks confidence, is awkward and uncomfortable when interviewed and his team is not a team and the squad is in the process of being rebuilt. But, this 4-2-4 system did not react to Liverpool’s tactics, ten Hag didn’t change his tactics to counter the Liverpool threat. Now we have half a team of Ajax players, no left back, a just arrived DM, injured striker and a few promising kids who need a break sometimes. And then there is Rashford, who, ever since he signed his £350,000 per week deal has gone and splurged on how many Lamborghinis, Bentleys, Ferraris, but has forgotten how to play football. WTF? It’s a bleeding mess and it looks. Like Liverpool got the right manager and United got the donkey☹️

    • @melishek0001
      @melishek0001 14 днів тому

      No extremes there then 😂😂

    • @panashephiri1912
      @panashephiri1912 14 днів тому

      I’d have more confidence with those Liverpool players. In what world would you have confidence in those United players that you’ve seen throughout the years something goods going to happen

  • @nicknewman7848
    @nicknewman7848 14 днів тому +62

    All 3 goals were conceded when the player playing the no'6 role gave the ball away too softly. We still haven't replaced Michael Carrick. It's depressing.

    • @grimjimbo2059
      @grimjimbo2059 14 днів тому +4

      No Liverpool are just better and more clinical simple.

    • @Chriztefur
      @Chriztefur 14 днів тому +12

      @@grimjimbo2059Both things can be true.
      They had 3 shots on target, 3 goals - so yes they were clinical, but we absolutely didn’t help ourselves with certain decisions.

    • @ushmush4074
      @ushmush4074 14 днів тому +5

      ​@grimjimbo2059 the two statements can both be true.

    • @BelfastManUtdTherapy
      @BelfastManUtdTherapy 14 днів тому +6

      but our manager isnt inspiring the players, hes a damp squib as my granny used to say. hes so hard to listen to. ehhhh yeeeh it is cleeeeeeeeeeeeeer hhhh ahhhh boooot eet is nuuuuut clllleeeeeeeeeeeeer . im sorry but in 20204 this manager cant inspire these kids

    • @nicknewman7848
      @nicknewman7848 14 днів тому +7

      @@BelfastManUtdTherapy I'm not really bothered about inspiration at the moment.. I'm bothered about defensive organisation and effective attacking. If those players can't inspire themselves on 150K and playing at Old Trafford every other week than they're in the wrong place. Inspiration doesn't help defend the back post, organisation and effort do.

  • @Tobias2549-TKB
    @Tobias2549-TKB 14 днів тому +5

    The tone in your voice is how I feel in my soul................ Dead!!!

  • @ushmush4074
    @ushmush4074 14 днів тому +12

    Think you're a bit harsh on the back 4. The other 7 were terrible, like 3/10. Except Amad maybe. But the back 4 did alright considering we had no outs.
    As a side note, Casemiro lost possession 15 times in 45 minutes, not 10. Shocking, 1/10.

    • @user-dz9gk1dj3x
      @user-dz9gk1dj3x 9 днів тому

      we conceded 3 goals, back 4 couldnt have been good

  • @creepingbrain
    @creepingbrain 14 днів тому +22

    He needs to change things quickly, but I don't think he knows how to. The problems we saw today with how the team was set up was just a repeat of what we saw all last season, but people got blinded to it by the FA Cup win. I can only see this ending one way.

    • @kangamangus95
      @kangamangus95 12 днів тому +1

      The FA cup! 10 more minutes and we would have lost that!

    • @jtmz87
      @jtmz87 11 днів тому

      @@kangamangus95 Saved by a toe nail against coventry. Some supporters were duped by a cup run. LVG got sacked for coming 5th on goal difference and winning the FA cup. Now we're supposed to give Ten Hag the royal treatment despite playing the worst football we've ever played for and coming in the worst position ever in the premier league era.

  • @absb1851
    @absb1851 14 днів тому +9

    Andy, think you were super emotional which has affected your ratings.
    We made 3 huge mistakes which was their 3 goals (3 shots on target from 8).
    Casemiro should’ve been 1!
    Once again too open on the attack got countered & didn’t get the ball into their box enough!
    When we did made 2 on target shots.
    Agree EtH needs to be more flexible in game as need to have 3 /4 styles as we seem to only have one

  • @stamfordplace5
    @stamfordplace5 13 днів тому +1

    Sensible (and fair) appraisal as always 👏👍

  • @MonktonJohn
    @MonktonJohn 14 днів тому +39

    Just can’t see EtH changing this shit

    • @BelfastManUtdTherapy
      @BelfastManUtdTherapy 14 днів тому +5

      im glad to hear someone say it, cos alot of us get hassled for it, i like him as a man, but hes not getting the team up for games, hes souless in a football sense, his communication skills arent great and in my opinion INEOS know that and Ruud will replace him.

    • @chrisbal4882
      @chrisbal4882 14 днів тому +1

      @@BelfastManUtdTherapyand when has that ever worked?

    • @User594gs57
      @User594gs57 14 днів тому

      @@chrisbal4882ole caretaker?

    • @panashephiri1912
      @panashephiri1912 14 днів тому +1

      @@BelfastManUtdTherapydidn’t you see what happened with OGS. It’ll be the same shit just different manager

  • @Arielle1309
    @Arielle1309 14 днів тому +7

    I couldn't even watch the whole 2nd half because I was sad of what I saw. How could we leave Casemiro as the only holding midfielder for such a game? Ridiculous and unforgivable of the ownership ...

    • @BelfastManUtdTherapy
      @BelfastManUtdTherapy 14 днів тому +2

      its the manager. just my opinion. the ownership were there today, our squad is better than what we saw.

    • @IH2K
      @IH2K 14 днів тому

      Stayed after the full time whistle and just soaked up the scousers taking the piss. Dunno why I’d torture myself but it was a very sobering moment that maybe this manager just ain’t good enough

    • @chrisbal4882
      @chrisbal4882 14 днів тому

      @@BelfastManUtdTherapyand who should he have played in that position genius?the fact he can’t play a player on 300k a week tells you enough about man utd problems

    • @ShaquilleOatmeal730
      @ShaquilleOatmeal730 14 днів тому

      ​@@chrisbal4882easy make sur kobee and bruno dont sprint away from casemiro when he has the ball. Kobee or bruno needed to play closer together

    • @jtmz87
      @jtmz87 11 днів тому

      @@chrisbal4882 It's not about who else should've played, but the tactical setup of the team and the instructions to the players. Casemiro is probably finished at the top level but you can't tell me the manager can't tell Mainoo and Bruno to stick closer to him and be more compact against tough opponents. Mainoo was also left all by himself in the 2nd half in that position, leading Liverpool to score their 3rd goal.

  • @ohheyitskevinc
    @ohheyitskevinc 14 днів тому +10

    Why we didn’t sign Amrabat for the £1.6m loan fee and £11m obligation he went to Fenerbahce for as a backup 6… I’ll never know. That said - we can’t score, so..

    • @eoghan1023
      @eoghan1023 14 днів тому

      We didn't sign Amrabat because he was terrible in 90% of games he played last season.

  • @raycookson416
    @raycookson416 12 днів тому +1

    Very balanced assessment. Well done.

  • @matthewleary1114
    @matthewleary1114 14 днів тому +5

    I'm a United fan and the one thing that stands out is in 5mins on Sky, Slot was able to tactical describe what they needed to do to win the game and the changes done during the game. Ten Hag hasn't ever been able to do that. I understand injuries last year but to get the fans on side he needs to be able to change games.

    • @jtmz87
      @jtmz87 11 днів тому

      He used to consistently do that in his first season, but for some reason after that cup win vs. newcastle all of his tactical acumen went completely out the window. First season, he tactically outsmarted Arteta at OT, Howe, we beat Barca pretty convincingly in the Europa league. But now almost a year and a half of dire football, saved by a fortuitous cup run. Should've been fired when we lost to Bournemouth at home by 3. That was his last game as far as I'm concerned.

  • @bargepoled
    @bargepoled 14 днів тому +4

    RVN will be manager by Christmas. No way ETH gets another transfer window.

  • @IH2K
    @IH2K 14 днів тому +4

    He might of not been at fault for their goals but Onana is a massive worry for me. His passing is shite, lost count how many times he’s just kicking it long or just holding onto that ball too long. When he passes to the midfielders he’s always putting them under pressure

  • @philipwilkinson988
    @philipwilkinson988 14 днів тому +4

    Midfield has been a massive problem for so long and still not been addressed.Hopefully ugarte improves us but I still think we need another 2 top players in that area.

    • @nightraveler
      @nightraveler 14 днів тому +1

      Ugarte will not fix it. He needs a lot of time to adjust to PL and he is less agressive defensively than Amrabat. We need agressive defensive middfielder to help Maino and Bruno play freely their attacking game just like Amrabat did at the end of last season when he finally started adjusting to PL play style.

    • @ShaquilleOatmeal730
      @ShaquilleOatmeal730 14 днів тому

      Bruno playing next to the striker is nuts

    • @dannymahon6929
      @dannymahon6929 13 днів тому +1

      If the 3 midfielders worked as a unit, it could work. But they don't. It's just a group of individuals out there.
      In fairness to Liverpool. I absolutely hate them. But they get the most out of their players because they work together, they work as a unit. Midfielders support the attack & the defence.
      Our whole team is so disjointed at times

  • @jonnyxification
    @jonnyxification 13 днів тому

    Cheers for the video Andy and reliving the pain of the game.

  • @denisomahoney5464
    @denisomahoney5464 14 днів тому +2

    The job is just too big for Ten hag ..and too many players letting him down ,also his tactics seem very confusing ..😡

  • @greatest7391
    @greatest7391 14 днів тому +4

    Onana for the 3rd goal!!!!

    • @IH2K
      @IH2K 14 днів тому +1

      Starting position was shocking

    • @lukekingsland4813
      @lukekingsland4813 14 днів тому

      He could possibly have done better with the second. The third was poor and his distribution is poor also. No more than a 3

    • @greatest7391
      @greatest7391 13 днів тому

      @@lukekingsland4813 The 1st goal also, he is a poor keeper

  • @goalsforgeorge9096
    @goalsforgeorge9096 14 днів тому +2

    He just needed to use Antony to replace Mount to maintain the same shape with a false 9 and then drop Rashford and use Amad and Garnacho plus pair Collyer/Casemiro/Mainoo in midfield!If Bruno does not perform, bring on Eriksen.
    Mainoo must not start every game and should be subbed after 60 mins as he is a kid!

  • @deepjoshi9570
    @deepjoshi9570 14 днів тому +1

    its always the 3 season at manchester united that gets managers job im sure that is what gonna happen this season

  • @djcheetah2007
    @djcheetah2007 13 днів тому +1

    Valid mate!

  • @Redforever369
    @Redforever369 14 днів тому +5

    It's all over for Erik. Most of us wanted him gone after 8th place. I would make the change now.

  • @iMANC1966
    @iMANC1966 14 днів тому +3

    Football has changed over the years, but Utd haven't. Long gone are the days we could poach the best players from teams around the world. Clubs like City, Chelsea and Newcastle with their rich owners have overtaken Utd. Other clubs are rich enough to hold on to their best talent. Utd have relied on their status for far too long and that status has gone. We paid way over the odds for players who had lost their hunger and were coming for a pay day. This is one of the main reasons why we're in this state. Ten Hag is out of his depth. This is evident this season as we have started the new season with new players but the same old problems emerge on the pitch, plus he selects 2 out of form players in the starting 11, in Casemiro and Rashford. This indicates that Ten Hag cannot make critical decisions for the benefit of the team. No courage or appetite to drop big name players, even if they're in a poor run of form and detrimental to the team. Bad leadership at it's finest. Fergie would've tore a strip off them and put them with the reserves.

  • @platonic7272
    @platonic7272 14 днів тому +1

    United need to switch to 433..we need 3 ball winners in the centre and play with three attacking forwards not four! We cant afford to have so many attacking players on the field..we must control the middle of the park.

  • @Footballobsessed21
    @Footballobsessed21 14 днів тому +1

    I am the supporter of Eric Ten Hag but today I felt he is the answer for us...clueless after 2 goals down

  • @niallkeane1763
    @niallkeane1763 14 днів тому

    Fair as always, thanks Andy. We will be back

  • @SqueakyWeasel247
    @SqueakyWeasel247 14 днів тому +1

    Cheers Andy, I know it's tough recording after a defeat of that nature but if you're going to stream from SJR's executive OT toilet at least do that "wanna have a look where I am" thing and give us a panorama! The people you hear banging on the door and washing their hands in the background kinda added to the whole shit day theme! JE10 🤫

  • @user-jj7uy1ns5f
    @user-jj7uy1ns5f 14 днів тому +1

    Fair and circumspect, no drama just says it as it is

  • @ShaquilleOatmeal730
    @ShaquilleOatmeal730 14 днів тому +1

    A simple pass to zirkzee and he is through in the box but bruno goes to spray it left to rashford and it gets intercepted. Why would he not want to take easier route to goal

    • @user-dz9gk1dj3x
      @user-dz9gk1dj3x 9 днів тому

      typical bruno always going for the hollywood pass rather than the simple option

  • @andymanser1
    @andymanser1 14 днів тому +3

    Have feeling van nistelrooy be in charge just hunch

    • @SpireUtd
      @SpireUtd 14 днів тому

      🤔 Thomas Frank ? or .. Ryan Giggs 🎉

  • @KryptonitetoallBS
    @KryptonitetoallBS 13 днів тому +1

    Let's be honest that was woeful, however I can see 2 obvious reasons why and how we can deal with them and improve significantly. We played against Liverpool with 9 men from the start. Casemiro and Rashford may have well been down the pub watching the game.
    Firstly when Shaw and Hojlund are back after injuries it will make a massive difference. With Shaw @ left back, allowing Dalot to go back to his best position @ right back. Hojlund running tirelessly up front closing down the opposition defenders and stretching the play by running in behind, giving Garnacho, Fernandes and Amad more space in front of them.
    Secondly when Ugarte & Mainoo are in the middle it will make life much, much harder for opposition midfields.
    Today was terrible, but there is still great hope as long as we DROP Casemiro and Rashford. Personally I would have sold the pair of them along with the useless Anthony. If we don't do this regretfully Ten Hag will not be here by December. He must send Rashford and Casemiro away from the club. allow them to train in a gym elsewhere. They must NOT be allowed to meet or train with the first team squad or else MARK MY WORDS, the cancer will spread! GGMU. #GlazersOutNow

  • @Footballobsessed21
    @Footballobsessed21 14 днів тому +4

    I know the pain of being Man United fan ...I know our weekends are getting spoiled maximum of times ...Eric is clearly not the answer for us

  • @Suve35967
    @Suve35967 14 днів тому +3

    They get high wages.
    Why bother to try.

  • @tigerob65
    @tigerob65 14 днів тому +3

    Awful again, I’ve never been one to call for a managers head, but ETH just doesn’t seem to be able to get a team that can play, be competitive and look like they know what they are actually doing. His tactics are non-existent

  • @Arielle1309
    @Arielle1309 14 днів тому +13

    Kobbie is being overworked and we cannot blame the poor young lad for this loss.

    • @chrisbal4882
      @chrisbal4882 14 днів тому +1

      mainoo has been terrible all 3 games now,his defensive abilities are not good enough,and he gave the ball away for brighton 1st goal and today he did it again

    • @milz97y
      @milz97y 14 днів тому +2

      No sane United fan blames Kobbie. In an ideal world, he isn’t our starter and can be brought on off the bench and play cup games

    • @ShaquilleOatmeal730
      @ShaquilleOatmeal730 14 днів тому

      He is a number ten

    • @Pid75
      @Pid75 14 днів тому +1

      No one is

    • @Arielle1309
      @Arielle1309 14 днів тому

      @@milz97y Kobbie is a starter and not only for cup games.

  • @philiprobinson9015
    @philiprobinson9015 14 днів тому +2

    Let's be fair. The whole team were an embarrassment. And, as usual, five Hag is out of his depth. He'll be gone once in the relegation places

  • @craigfirmstone9687
    @craigfirmstone9687 14 днів тому +15

    Casemiro 3?! Rashford 4?! He tried. My arse.
    😂 oh Andy. Rashford should have been out ages ago.

    • @craigfoulkes
      @craigfoulkes 14 днів тому +4

      He should have had 2 assists from 2 Great crosses.

    • @jriggz
      @jriggz 14 днів тому

      @@craigfoulkes if he grabs 2 assists yesterday these people would be the ones saying he's back 🤣

  • @moorzymoores
    @moorzymoores 14 днів тому

    Good honest recap

  • @keithstitt9532
    @keithstitt9532 13 днів тому

    That 3 man midfield was shocking. We haven't got a wide player who can go past a player and chance creation is limited.

  • @MadLFC
    @MadLFC 14 днів тому +5

    Sir Alex Ferguson spent 20 years inflating this giant trophy winning balloon...then all it took to burst it was a needle called David Moyes. Liverpool had the same thing happen to them when Dalglish left in 1991 and Souness came in. The difference is that the modern Liverpool FC has a club structure and system in place that between Klopp and the owners, ensured that this wouldn't happen again. Liverpool are not just about the managers anymore. It's a collective effort of owners, clever business people, managers, coaches and players ALL pulling in the same direction. United have none of that.

  • @JungleUTFR
    @JungleUTFR 13 днів тому

    3 bad errors in midfield, but we should still be able to recover the situation without singling out individuals for criticism !
    I thought Dalot was a 6 out of ten, the rest 5, with young colliyer getting a 7 for effort. Poor all round and no goals scored again

  • @fabshop6359
    @fabshop6359 14 днів тому +1

    Cheers, Andy, I feel your pain. 🤦

  • @automatedcryptoapp4573
    @automatedcryptoapp4573 12 днів тому

    Switching off after hearing Onana was not at fault for any of the goals despite offering Salah 3/4 of the goal.

  • @bassman5948
    @bassman5948 14 днів тому +1

    With all the money spent our selection choices at full back are so poor, there are championship teams with better than us 😢

  • @ClintOnYouTube
    @ClintOnYouTube 14 днів тому

    We are only 3 games into new season, but despite new signings we're playing the same football we were last season. Little to zero improvement.
    Starting to all feel very hopeless.

  • @user-bh5zg2bn9p
    @user-bh5zg2bn9p 14 днів тому +14

    TEN Hag gone by Christmas

    • @dendog13
      @dendog13 14 днів тому +2

      Hopefully not 😵‍💫

    • @RoyHodgson97
      @RoyHodgson97 11 днів тому

      Unless you have Southgate lined up and ready please keep ETH, us rival fans loves him so much🤣🤣🤣 And please give him another 600M to spend on Ajax🤡 players.

    • @anthonywalker4616
      @anthonywalker4616 9 днів тому

      @@user-bh5zg2bn9p one thing that must not happen is what happened to Liverpool in the 90’s by having a revolving door of managers, a revolving door of expensive, average players and fans that live in the past saying things like: “Fergie wouldn’t have put up with this”. That’ll never happen!

  • @TheNightMammoth
    @TheNightMammoth 13 днів тому

    I don't think Kobbie was poor aside from the 3rd goal, which was way more the product of 'pool's tactics to press him and Casemiro than it was a bad individual mistake. Rashford as well was not quite on it but is in a hopeless position out there as a pure winger. We need to scrutinise what Ten Hag is doing more specifically because both these players are being asked to do things that don't suit them and they're struggling.

  • @Arielle1309
    @Arielle1309 14 днів тому +4

    Martinez was poor but you're right, he needs more time to get up to speed. We need consistency and to have others like Rashford dropped for the next 2 games. No more excuses from EtH as to why he won't drop underperforming Rashford.

  • @joeleaton8752
    @joeleaton8752 14 днів тому

    “How to throw my digital season ticket on the pitch…” easy two words : Burner Phone

  • @anthonywalker4616
    @anthonywalker4616 14 днів тому +1

    Cheer up Andy lad. It wasn’t 7 or 5 this time. Onwards and upwards.

  • @Wrioncnkiye
    @Wrioncnkiye 14 днів тому +1

    I keep saying last November that I don't see how ETH can turn it around. He is just not good enough, no matter what. I can't imagine that he can see the Christmas tree.

  • @bigron7009
    @bigron7009 14 днів тому +2

    This 424 does not work. It's s half decent if you play with a false 9 and no striker...but we are too exposed playing this. Whoever is in midfield suffers and is overwhelmed...we had a season of this folly last year. Have ETH & coaches learned nothing? Kamikaze football

  • @RandomVideosFirst
    @RandomVideosFirst 14 днів тому +1

    The team
    Just Seemed to collapse after Casemiro mistakes , Mctominay , 1 on 1 Bissaka would have been needed for this sort of game , would have been perfect for this game . At first I thought they will wait for sacking ETH by say Xmas but now thinking he won’t last that long. I think he could be gone early by October . Rashford should have been sold in the summer along with Casemiro .

  • @umairkhokhar8000
    @umairkhokhar8000 14 днів тому

    We needed proven goalscorer, new LB and Def mid. We didn't get a proper killer goalscorer, bought a RB which deploy dalot to LB and Def mid we left it late to get him for start of season

  • @philtaylor8863
    @philtaylor8863 14 днів тому

    You can’t see us scoring any goals 1 or none per game is not going to be enough.. There is a massive contrast with the academy teams who are delivering top performance week in week out.

  • @vixantenna
    @vixantenna 11 днів тому

    Hopefully RVN will be more ruthless with Rashford. We need to try something different.

  • @adammulvey9456
    @adammulvey9456 11 днів тому

    Ten hags the worst gaffa post fergie but everyone still loves him its literally insane.

  • @andrewmorton6241
    @andrewmorton6241 14 днів тому +1

    Went today sadly but stuck it to the end. Too many young fans leaving as early as 60 minutes. They would have walked out at the Nou Camp in 99 too. Booing Amad substituting Garnacho does nothing to help Rashford’s confidence either. I heard a numpty on 606 calling for Southgate and Mainoo as captain, sorry it’s been a bad day.

  • @robatkin7580
    @robatkin7580 14 днів тому

    We have no cover in midfield, what happens if this Ugarte doesn't work? Or is suspended or injured? Who comes in?

  • @FostaJuliano
    @FostaJuliano 14 днів тому

    You still managed to squeeze in a 10 for Jonny Evans! 😂😂😂

  • @rosseardley4863
    @rosseardley4863 14 днів тому

    Here to share in the pain. We were all over the place again which is down to the manager not for the first time.

  • @NICKin3D
    @NICKin3D 14 днів тому

    Old Trafford mood unsettled me a little yesterday. Feels like there's a shift in support for the manager now.

  • @Sdeteflon
    @Sdeteflon 14 днів тому

    we have been so desensitized to bad losses, fans are just brushing aside losses like this like any another day.
    Atleast the team had standards back in 2016 when lvg got sacked after winning same FA cup

  • @chrisclassical7
    @chrisclassical7 14 днів тому +1

    3 shots, 3 goals. united need 50 chances to score 1 goal. the issue is united can't score. all liverpools goals came from man utd assists, casemiro 2 and moinoo 1. eric ten hag needs to manage the team and not his system

  • @mrbobajango7482
    @mrbobajango7482 14 днів тому +1

    Ineos have got themselves into a horrible situation. Fresh ideas were needed in the summer to give everyone who planned to stay a fresh slate. Now if they do sack ETH this year you've got a bunch of Eric's ex Ajax players stuck at a club playing for a manager they didn't come for 😔

    • @SpireUtd
      @SpireUtd 14 днів тому

      🤔... Thomas Frank ?

    • @mrbobajango7482
      @mrbobajango7482 14 днів тому

      ​@@SpireUtd My personal choice would have been De Zerbi

  • @leedavis6000
    @leedavis6000 14 днів тому

    Ugarte not going to sort this I feel. This is why we needed de jong so badly.
    He’s got till Christmas’s he has to turn this around.

  • @u10722u
    @u10722u 14 днів тому

    Where do the goals come from ?

  • @StanKPhlaps
    @StanKPhlaps 14 днів тому +2

    Im sorry but its still the same problems as the whole of last season. We rush everything, we throw 6 players forward everytime we get the ball, when we lose possession the number 6 (whoever plays there) is exposed. We CHOOSE to do this. This isnt an accident. We purposely make the game chaotic and frantic. Our shape is always awful when defending.
    This is not a personel issue. It doesnt matter who plays in the team. New players, older players, young players, experienced players. It the same story everytime.
    Its a coaching issue. It was a coaching issue all of last season too. The fact that McClaren and van der gaag have been replaced, as well as half the squad, leaves the blame at the feet of one man. The manager.
    Is he so stubborn and arrogant in his belief that sooner or later it will start working??? There's never been any sign to suggest it will. How can we commit 6 players to every attack but score so few goals?

    • @alanobrien3252
      @alanobrien3252 14 днів тому

      We're like a basketball team

    • @StanKPhlaps
      @StanKPhlaps 14 днів тому

      @@alanobrien3252 only in the running up and down. Certainly not on the scoring lol

  • @BoomyMcBoom
    @BoomyMcBoom 9 днів тому

    Onana 5? 3 shots on target and 3 goals conceded… I’m really surprised with how much Onana gets away with from pundits and fans I think he’s a huge huge problem! Can only remember Scholes highlighting this fact in the media so far he’s been a terrible buy and his distribution has been woeful even though that’s the primary reason he was brought in he slings it out of play with every other kick out it seems

  • @richyclubsport5155
    @richyclubsport5155 14 днів тому +4

    14th place Liverpool fans taking the piss Liverpool would struggle without Klopp, embarrassing ETH won't last long, no style, questionable signings

    • @Capri-x8m
      @Capri-x8m 14 днів тому

      And how much have United spent and how many top managers have been there since Fergie retired? Liverpool do things right.

    • @richyclubsport5155
      @richyclubsport5155 14 днів тому +1

      @@Capri-x8m unfortunately I can't argue with that comment

  • @lokicats
    @lokicats 14 днів тому

    Is there a way to find out of players like Casamiro are directed to play high risk passes or choose to? Hate to blame the wrong person for that performance. He was targeted tactically as a weak spot, important to know if he was implementing the game plan.

  • @tommyknockers5492
    @tommyknockers5492 14 днів тому

    The dropoff was clear last season. Why have we bought players like mount and Zirkzee when we need a Eriksen/Pogba replacement

  • @amfitness5598
    @amfitness5598 14 днів тому

    That was a tough watch only bc we gave them those 2 goals in the first half. Bad decisions by 18 unfortunately he maybe done…not sure what ETH will do to handle that situation.

  • @kercysmetalhand
    @kercysmetalhand 14 днів тому +11

    Tough watching Casemiro out there. Squad depth looks worryingly thin already. McTominay being sold also looks like a really poor move right now.

    • @chrisclassical7
      @chrisclassical7 14 днів тому +8

      to build a new house you first have to tear the old house down. me circa 2024

    • @steve0ization
      @steve0ization 14 днів тому +6

      Mctominay would do nothing, but Casemiro has to go now

    • @Brawlypython244
      @Brawlypython244 14 днів тому +4

      Wanna bring back wan bissaka then aswell? He’d have locked down Diaz for sure, and Varane wouldn’t have conceded those goals, and martial would have finished zirksees chances I’d say, and I’d even suggest that pogba wouldve helped us control the game more. Do you see what I’m getting at?

    • @melishek0001
      @melishek0001 14 днів тому +1

      What a bunch of doom merchants. It's a game.

    • @melishek0001
      @melishek0001 14 днів тому

      Martial that never played...Varane that was injured ..pogba that played 1 in 5?​...😂😂...your point is? .@@Brawlypython244

  • @RizZy28
    @RizZy28 14 днів тому

    Winning the cup final did a lot of work to keep EtH in the job, I think he's eroded a lot of the good will that he got from it already this season. I like him & want him to do well, but we just keep making all the same mistakes.

  • @garyobrien2395
    @garyobrien2395 14 днів тому

    Loves Maguire 😂😂😂🤦‍♂️

  • @kangamangus95
    @kangamangus95 12 днів тому

    Will Sir Jim take the hit, Sell off (almost) the lot, Invest as much as they can and ensure a plan with a solid manager and coaching staff. This is too ugly to salvage.

  • @punctualwizard
    @punctualwizard 14 днів тому

    Case was a great player, but it’s clear he’s in the twilight of his career. Last season, as a 6 or a cb, his decision making building up and without the ball was questionable and costly. This season after 2 decent games, it was more of the same vs Liverpool. Bruno and the forward line misfiring only made the mistakes more glaring.
    I knew there would still be days like this, and I understand people’s frustration, but being reactionary after 3 matches isn’t how we change our fortunes.

  • @iany8230
    @iany8230 14 днів тому

    You sound fed up as me Andy! No good performers, although Amad at least tried to take players on. Good summary. Enjoy Ireland!!

  • @jamesfagan7823
    @jamesfagan7823 14 днів тому

    Ten Hag has to go immediately the team haven’t made 1% improvement under his tenure nothing absolutely nothing will change while Ten Hag at helm

  • @ahernb1
    @ahernb1 14 днів тому

    Grim. Enjoy the trip to Ireland Andy ☘️

  • @bobvickers9387
    @bobvickers9387 14 днів тому

    That’s a fair verdict

  • @garypentecost833
    @garypentecost833 14 днів тому

    Totally understand how you’re so low ,my anxiety has hit the roof , Im struggling to see any pattern or shape from game to game , Erik is under immense pressure after 3 games ,it doesn’t bode well ,personally I can’t see him getting thru October ,I’m just thinking is that the reason for bringing in Hake and Rudd , or have I lost the plot like Erik

  • @TonyField
    @TonyField 12 днів тому

    Hi Andy, Onana is not good enough for this club or for the premiership. He's not been near any goal conceded this season

  • @willlloyd9480
    @willlloyd9480 14 днів тому

    I’m sorry but to give Casemiro at 3, and mainoo a 4 is incredibly harsh for mainoo

  • @deadred99
    @deadred99 14 днів тому

    Onana. Think you need to rewatch the third

  • @matt6477
    @matt6477 13 днів тому

    Keep your head up. Most Ute players were a 6, but most Liverpool players were 8s

  • @daviddunne4737
    @daviddunne4737 14 днів тому +1

    Three times the ball was ' donated ' to Liverpool , result 3 goals . No defensive cohesion . No protection for defence . Midfield got mobbed by Liverpool and had no answer . Casemiro is out of his depth , no pace . Mainoo not as alert as usual . Garnacho is a luxury player , whenhe is good thats fine but when he is off the pace he is a passanger . Rasford is dead weight at the moment . No focal point up front . Rasmus Højlund is badly missed despite what some people think . We have no cover for Rasmus . Bruno is finding the going tough with the players around him . Zirkzee is stange , I dont know what his position is or will be . Still no left back . We are a disorganised wreck . Very poor bench .
    If we finish 8th this season and win the FA Cup I would be thrilled . I had a look at the table , I got a shiver , because I clearly remember April 27th 1974 . Yes anything is possible because we are so bad and a lot of players are not with the programme . Ralf Rangnick was right Open-Heart Surgery' . we are still on the NHS waiting list . Cheers Andy . Enjoy Ireland .

    • @languageoffootball
      @languageoffootball 12 днів тому

      There’s no chance of relegation in this day and age except if there was some sort of financial impropriety

    • @daviddunne4737
      @daviddunne4737 12 днів тому

      @@languageoffootball Modern times ' anything could happen at anytime and anywhere' 😊. Yes I do take your point. Regards. 🥃

    • @languageoffootball
      @languageoffootball 12 днів тому +1

      @@daviddunne4737 at least relegation presents a kind of release and rebirth. It’s almost more depressing where relegation isn’t on the menu of options because there’s a sense of paralysis and purgatory!

  • @durthacht
    @durthacht 14 днів тому

    Fair marks, Andy. Maybe a little generous.

  • @danielbrowne3596
    @danielbrowne3596 14 днів тому +9

    Onana is horrible for the 3rd goals watch it againn were is he

  • @cpm8889
    @cpm8889 10 днів тому

    It was a crap performance, we were out played, bullied and little thinking by the manager. The directors have a lot to answer for.

  • @cursedchild3639
    @cursedchild3639 14 днів тому

    I think Andy is too kind to these players, the ratings are too high.
    Onana 0 ( can't make a single save, who the hell have we bought?
    Mazraoui 3
    De Ligt 4
    Martinez 3
    Dalot 4
    Casemiro 0
    Mainoo 1
    Bruno 0
    Garnacho 1
    Rashford 2
    Zirkzee 0
    Ten Hag 0

  • @vaughnlee136
    @vaughnlee136 14 днів тому +1

    Eth put all this on himself poor poor poor performance poor poor subs poor poor shot everything there's no way he stays no way he be here Christmas this job is too big for him 3 season now got players he wants and still can't see a pattern of play.
    Slot in 3 games in and can see a style

  • @WayynePain
    @WayynePain 14 днів тому

    We also just signed Kone. Casemiro should be 3rd choice now. Ugarte, Kone then Casemiro in that order.

    • @barrylynch5066
      @barrylynch5066 14 днів тому +1

      What about collyer?

    • @Draper99
      @Draper99 14 днів тому +1

      @@barrylynch5066 He’s nowhere near good enough

    • @Draper99
      @Draper99 14 днів тому +1

      Behave! Have you even seen Kone play?? You certainly haven’t seen him play against top class opposition .
      Casemiro was clearly finished last season