@@tinaa_808 we know she is not good yet, that's why we give her chance to practice more, we wanna see the improvement in this show. If u dont like her then just ignore
The other South East Asian girls in this show are performing next level vocals and she still has a better chance of debuting that all of them thanks to fan votes 😭
@@alsoleve99 yea the tell me tell me performance is scripted for exposure she's there for comedy, and might even debut, and another script where she got better in the future
@@rui__smIt was not scripted. This girl is genuinely lacking compared to other members. She can't speak Korean nor English. Thank God she's eliminated already. They're not that stupid to debut this girl. She was heavily criticised because of her high ranking coming from her superproud countrymen votes even though she sounded like that. If she ranks lower (as she should), people won't give a single fuck for her.
reason why she shouldn't debut. 1. She's still young, let her have childhood memory 2. Her vocal was unstable, I hate seeing people saying her vocal tone is unique while is definitely not, in my country her vocal tone was VERY VERY common 3. Her dance so stiff, she is lacking in energy, her footwork is just okay but kinda messy 4. Her stage presence.... blank, she already look tired before the stage start, I think cause this fancam it's just a Rehearsal fancam? Note :: Even though she's like that, I can't lie that her facial expression is very good, and she looks very confident with herself
@@ijanshaa2381 you should see her dancing the universe ticket song, she improved a lot, she is the most popular contestant and she already had her ads in Seoul train. You shouldnt judge base on 1 performance
나는 한국인인데 15살이라는 어린 나이에 우리 케이팝에 관심 가져주고 꿈을 위해 인도네시아라는 먼 곳에서 부모님이랑 떨어져서 혼자 왔다는게 너무 감동임. 엄마가 보고싶어서 매일 밤마다 울었다고 하는게 너무 마음 아팠음. 지금은 악플이 너무 많은데 보란듯이 실력 키워서 많이 늘은 모습 보여주고 꼭 데뷔했으면 좋겠다.
If everyone commented positively like you... Surely people would live their days comfortably without feeling stressed.. Indeed, Vanessya is not as good as the other participants. but I'm sure if he works hard, even if it's not a short time, he will get better. Thank you for the positive and constructive comments.. 🙏🏻 Sorry I replied in English because I don't speak Korean.
They always be trying to find a ways to hate on her. If it isnt her rap they'll say her vocal, if it isnt her vocal then they'll say her dance are stiff and kept mocking her. People are just so immature.
Yes even her dance is better than her haters and I saw a girl saying on yt ranking Tell me of wonder girls cover she ranked Venesya at the last and said who the hell made on the 3rd rank and I dont remember that girls name but yeah she rapped after Venesya her rap was more wrong but the girl said that she did a little mistake literally Double Standards with minnors
she still young, she have to traine more and more cuz all the competitors here are way above her....yall need to stop saying she had a good vocal or rap cuz shes not and she need to accept the fact but she could traine more...
I wish Indo fans will realize that by voting her aiming to have high rank, would only give her more hate and that will possibly affect the poor girl's mental state. I get all the "she will improve later on" and whatnots but in all honesty, she's not ready yet compare to other contestants. The "Tell Me" performance was an obvious set up to humiliate her by giving her the rap part knowing that she's not yet a fluent Korean speaker. Please set aside ya'll's national pride and think more of the girl's mental health. 🙏
Dia bilang saat perfom dia cuma latohan 2 hari, ge g tau y 2 hari itu latihan di lagu itu atau gimna, tapi dance nya hafal banget., jadi kemungkinan latihan vocalnya yg baru 2 hari yg s3rius, terus di haruskan tampil, gw g bener dukung dia b aja si, cuma kesian dia di hujat meskipun udah keluar dari nih acara
Sorry to say.. Bicara bahasa korea dia blm fasih, kualitas dance + nyanyi dia sekelas anak sma yang mau pensi, masih kalah sama youtuber cover lagu atau dance.. Aku tidak mengerti survival ini bisa menerima dia, padahal dia lebih baik ikut trainne saja.
Sepertinya dia dari keluarga mampu/kaya, jadi bisa bayar lebih ke pihak penyelenggara acara survival buat ikut serta dalam acara itu, hitung2 buat pengalaman dia kan, soalnya dia masih butuh pengalaman dan latihan lebih.
Strategi surfival kan gitu Banyak org indo yg ikut audisi yg lebih berbakat tapi emang dia yg kepilih Dari awal emang gk mau org indo debut Org indo dipilih karna buat rame aja yg nonton ni surfival Jadi bukan sepenuhnya salah si vanes
@@wadada999 iya juga sih betul, strategi buat menarik penonton dari indo, kalo aku sih lebih baik yg ikut di acara itu dari member jkt48 setidaknya mereka ada pengalaman nge dance sama nyanyi, kalo vanes masih blm siap
Ikr 😂 she's teribble and as an Indonesian I also feel embarrassed. It's not my country faulth... She is the problem... Idk why so many Indonesian people still support her and telling me she will improve... They are just overproud :"
Orang indo plis dia ga ada talenta sama sekali, dia kan masih 15 tahun, masih banyak waktu buat latihan, dia belum siap debut, dan apa kalian ga malu kalau yang merepresentasikan orang Indonesia kayak gini? Padahal banyak loh yang bertalenta di Indonesia, kalian jangan mikir yang penting ada orang Indonesia, vote orang yang benar2 ada bakat, kasian dia yang dihujat.
@@kathalinajuliasnah orang bebal kek lu nih yang malu2 in negara.. klo meniai itu yg objektif dan bijak.. tau kata "menilai" kan? Yah silakan menilai pakai mata otak dan telinga.. jangan buta fakta.. bukannya gk dukung negeri sendiri tapi ini tentang siapa yg pantas debut dan siapa yg bertalenta, abaikan negara.. silahkan bijak dan objektif sebagai penonton.. orang cerdas pasti milih mana yg bagus.. yg belum oke ngapain dipilih, logikanya ngapain makan daging alot yg belum matang.. bikin gigi patah aja.. alhasil selain jadi bahan tertawaan juga, nama kampung halaman jadi ikut diketawaain juga.. dia masih muda.. masih banyak waktu untuk belajar dan ningkatin skill.. dia terlalu bocil
@@kathalinajulias terus gunanya ikut acara kek gitu buat apa kalo bukan debut, Iya klo hoki hoki dia debut apa g nambh di hujat warga korea, itu resiko dia ikut survival kek gitu resiko yg harus di tnggung mau jd idol harus tahan kritik dri knetzen, plis klo kalian vt karna kasian justru mlh bikin beban dia rank tinggi tp vocal blm matang. FAKTA
@@kathalinajuliasini nih fans yg susah dibilangin. Sebagai netizen ya berbandingannya vanesya sm peserta lain yg ikut survival dong. Ga bermaksud nge hate vanesya nya, dia berjuang disana udah susah. Aku cuma ngehate orang indo yg overproud sama nationality nya.
Yang divote itu merepresentasikan negara kita loh guys, kalo bagus ya efeknya bagus ke negara kita, kalo kurang ya, siap2 dihujat warganet, bukan warganet indonesia tapi internasional
Dukung aja dulu, kalo di dukung si Vanesya seneng kagak ngedown, kalo seneng jdi giat latihannya dan kemungkinan bisa berkembang pesat dan makin pede. Liat dari sudut pandang yg lebih positif.
@@sriwahyuni6381harus objektif dong memberi dukungan pun, ini kompetisi ajangnya adu bakat. dengan ngasih masukan juga itu bentuk dukungan positif. vanessa mau jadi idol artinya mental dia harus tahan banting, jangan maunya apa-apa yang bagus-bagus aja komennya. jangan anti kritik. buka mata juga untuk kontestan lain yang lebih siap mental dan skills nya.
@@sriwahyuni6381mình nghĩ bạn nên vote một cách công tâm,thí sinh của quốc gia bạn có rất nhiều thiếu xót,nếu được debute thì sẽ ảnh hưởng tới những thành viên khác rất nhiều,thậm chí có thể flop
@@sriwahyuni6381cô ấy sẽ phát triển hơn nữa trong tương lai,nhưng bây giờ cô ấy có quá nhiều thiếu xót,đến với cuộc thi chưa chuẩn bị kỹ càng mà được debute nhờ số lượng vote là cướp đi mất cơ hội của một người xứng đáng hơn,mong bạn sẽ hiểu
jgn salain voter 100% yah, ada voter krn emg disuru vote kan yah, jadi kt ga bs ngatur voter itu harus milih siapa, yg harus di pertanyakan kenapa universe ticket, meloloskan vanesya ke korea, kl da tau skill nya blm cukup. itu harus dipertanyakan
Now that I'm seeing this, she was still so obviously underdeveloped and overhyped, but I've gotta give her credit for actually having some stage presence in this, especially in the beginning. I think the main problem is her vocal tone, nervousness, and lack of confidence on stage. And her dancing skill isn't that bad and has potential to be a lead dancer if she practices a lot more. The main reason she might be moving like that is so she can make herself stable, which is more harder to do when you have to do a low tone voice for the verse. She was dancing a bit better in the beginning when she wasn't singing even if it was mostly hand movements she was doing. If she can learn how to sing decently, (maybe rap too, since that's also her lowest skill), she could actually become an idol! She's also SO PRETTY!!! ❤❤ Hopefully I see her soon with a lot more improvement. THIS IS NOT HATE, it's just my opinion and view of this!
Why such bad comments.....can anyone one of you people do a performance from that stage with confidence and get selected.... no isn't it then why hurting others instead Praise her for never giving up on her dream
I think Indonesian fans are too overproud and overestimate Vanesya even though she is less competitive than others who have prepared well. it's crazy hahaha😂
we supported her no matter what, she is only 15, and still has a long way to go, if she doesn’t make it here, she already had the experience to improve later🥰
aku baca komen org vietnam sama org korea aja mereka pada suportif, heran ini org satu negara malah ngebully, kalau lu pengen wakil indonesia lebih bagus knp bukan lu yg audisi sana
This is her introduction video?! This is the second clip I've seen of her. What is this?! This look like those kpop "performance" for a mall competition not an international competition on TV one. Girl bfr!
yang menjudge ga nonton pd101 s1 ada kim sohye yang gabisa dance sama sekali, vocalnya terbilang kurang bagus, sama sp nya juga... tapi dia bisa improve loh dan akhirnya dia debut juga. pd48 ada kim hyewon, vocal, dance, dan sp menurutku masih mending vanesya tapi dia bisa improve juga dan debut di izone. ini baru tahap 1 juga kan... udah lumayan bagus sih ini untuk ukuran yang mulai dari 0... gua lihat dia punya potensi dan kalau dilatih sama coach2 korea ni pasti bisa keluar semua bakat dia. SEMANGAT VANESYA!!!❤
@@nathalieathana2344hyewon debut krn visual menurut gue,emang dia agak gmn bakatnya tp diacantik bgt makannya habis izone disband dia jadi aktris kan.dan banyak pas zaman pd48 fans vote dia krn visualnya
@@nathalieathana2344lah hyewon debut karena dapetin hati knetz yang selalu ada kejutan setiap misi nya dari misi pertama ambil rap padahal gak ada basic, terus misi ke dua bikin lyric rap
vanesya harus kuat ya mentalnya, kita support kok asalkan kamu juga berjuang dengan serius dan buktikan peningkatan mu, belum terlambat, iyaa saingannya emang berat, tapi jadikan itu motivasi, jngan terlalu memaksakan diri jg yaa, lakukan dengan serius dengan caramu, untuk dirimu sndiri bukan utk kita, krna hanya kamu yang tau diri mu sndiri. jangan takut, walaupun mungkin lebih sakit hati baca komen warga sendiri tapi kamu harus tetap kuat ya, kita jg sulit membungkam mulut atau typing kotor mereka, jdi kamu buktikan aj dengan kemampuan mu nanti, tetap belajar kamu masih muda masih banyak kesempatan kok, santai ajaa let it flow 😎👍
Jujur aku kalo jadi dia, pasti uda keringet dingin, gugup, nangiiss karna deg2an.. Kamu hebat Vanesya, punya kesempatan dan berani sampai korea di usia 15th ikut ajang kek gini, itu aja uda hebatt lho..
Well today she is more popular than the show 😂😂😂You must be thankful for this girl because she's going viral and many people is getting familiar to what show it is.
I’m indonesian, but honestly we need to be realistic, vanesya still need a couple years more to practice. And other contestants is in another level than her🙏🏻
Là một người Việt Nam, tôi ủng hộ Vũ Linh Đan và cả Vanessa, dù Vanessa đến từ Indonesia nhưng tôi ủng hộ cô ấy vì bị thu hút bởi vẻ ngoài và biểu cảm của cô ấy, cô ấy thu hút sự chú ý của tôi, mặc dù giọng hát của cô ấy vẫn còn thiếu sót nhưng nếu cô ấy Tập luyện nhiều hơn chắc chắn sẽ hay hơn và đặc biệt là Vũ Linhdan, giọng hát của bạn rất hay nhưng biểu cảm còn thiếu sót nhưng tôi sẽ luôn ủng hộ bạn, mong các bạn có thể cùng nhau ra mắt
Aku heran pas audisi memang gimana, bukannya acara survival kek gini harus lolos seleksi audisi dulu. Padahal aku yakin di luar sana tu pasti banyak trainee atau dancer dari Indo yg di korea. Bukan maksud ngejelekin dia, tp kesannya jadinya orang luar yg nonton nilai, ohh gini kualitas trainee idol dari Indo, padahal aslinya banyak dari indo yg bakat dance sama nyanyinya bagus banget, tp napa pas di acara survival gini gak nemu yg bagus. Dulu aku cuma pernah nemuin trainee indo yg ikutan survival show di japan produce season 2, trainee nakamura toma bagus banget bakatnya orang bali dia. Nah maksud aku tu, kenapa gak yg bagus gitu yg di ikut kan survival show, jadinya kan orang2 gak nganggap remeh kualitas orang2 indo. Kyak Dita seandainya semisal dia ikut survival show kek gini, orang pasti bakalan kagum, ohh ni orang dancenya bagus. Tp untuk vanesya sangat di sayangkan si menurutku
Kayaknya dia beneran modal nekat ga sih? Tanpa prepare apa². Terus kayaknya kalau kontestan banyak gini tu milih random ga sih... Jadi kek ga disaring. Sedih banget liat fans nya toxic semua dan kata² andalan selalu "yang penting debut dulu"... I mean, so what exactly yang lo cari di idol indonesia? Cuma karna WNI? Ga butuh bakat?😹
tapi dia dancenya lumayan sih jadi paling kalo ga dapet disini dia bisa training di 1million studio, ntar jadi back dancer. biar setidaknya msh bisa berkarya di korea.
Dia jelas menarik, idol nggak cm didengar suaranya aja. visualnya, youthful nya, ekspresi mukanya juga jadi pertimbangan. Tolong jangan bandingkan dengan dita yg 10 tahun lebih tua, tentu aja dita sudah banyak pengalaman dan belajar formal tentng tari. Miyeon tidak kepiih jd membernya blackpink padahal dia cantik, suaranya bagus, nah itu udah menunjukkan bahwa debut menjadi idol itu banyak dipertimbangkan. Mohon disupport dan tidak menjatuhkan anak remaja umur 15 tahun ini.
you know guys just watch and enjoy let the girl shine her day .She may not perfect at her perfomance now but life is amazing just watch and enjoy what she got .
Bisa maju kaya gitu aja nggak gampang, ayo Vanesya lakukan terbaik dari diri kamu. Pengalaman itu Kamu yang punya, bukan orang lain. Jadikan acuan dek, jangan hiraukan perkataan mereka yang gak membantu kamu buat lebih maju. 🇮🇩
Y'all are defending her and saying she doesn't sound that bad and doesn't deserve the hate because she's 15 and inexperienced. I agree that she doesn't deserve the hate. She's very young and should not be put in such a bad situation at an early age. It's also not her fault that Indonesians vote for her. However, it's also important to realise that being an idol requires decent vocal skills. Yes, she can get better over time but she's not good at the moment. She can practice and hopefully debut later in the future, she's still a young girl and has time. But please y'all, don't vote for her because she's Indonesian. It's very biased, wasting talent of girls who are actually ready to debut.
Gini ya guys yg nge hate, dia masih 15 tahun, belum pernah trainee, bukan orang Korea, jadi dia harus menyesuaikan koreo + bahasa + suara + mengikuti kamera dan ekspresi nya. Dan gw lihat suara dia gak parah bgt + ekspresi nya juga gak segagal itu dan dia udah keren bgt. Jadi stop hate dehh, support aja teruss
Bener banget, harusnya di dukung bukan di hujat. Suaranya bagus kok, tapi mungkin harus lebih banyak latihan lagi, pasti akan lebih bagus. Lebih banyaknlatihanlah intinya. Yg udah terkenal aja conyohnya BP, BTS, dll, aja pasti masih ttp terus latihan, apalagi yg baru2 kyk gini.
gw bukan haters dia, tp buat apa support pake embel2 "biar org indo yg jd idol makin banyak", meanwhile bakat nyanyi dan dancenya masih kek gitu. ini acara survival loh. masa nyanyi kek orang pilek ama dancenya yang detailnya aja ga dapet dilolosin... WKWKWKWK
@@kpopaddict1436 kek orang pilek?? Padahal gw dengar suara dia gak seburuk itu. Kalau nonton survival sebelum2nya pasti tau dulu ada peserta diawal gak mau nyanyi, ada yang suara + ekspresinya lebih parah dari Vanesya ini tapi bisa debut dan karna di trainee ya skill nya jadi makin jago. Kalau gak bisa support ya minimal jangan hate atau ngata ngatain kayak Lo ini
Many people are talking about how she's gonna debut soon and how good she is , so I got curious ,,, 🫨🫨🫨 all I can say is SHE HAS POTENTIAL BUT SHE'S NOT READY YET,HER SINGING AND DANCING ARE JUST SOSO ... there's still room for improvement Just my opinion though~
Kok gw kesel yah banyk yang nge hate dia dan dibandingin sama peserta lain.....si vanes bukannya bener2 dari 0 dan gak ada basic trainee yaudah sih gw liat disini dia gak jelek2 banget masih singkron 😂 gw liat nya dia malah grogi gw tau kalo orang indo kalo dilatih bakal improve.ini baru test pertama udh banyak yang ngehate😂 kalopun dia masih dihate udah karir aj diindo yang ada kamu lebih di bagusin di tarik suara. Gw ngeliat auranya udh superstar
pdhal peserta lain ada yg jelek juga performnya, tp gaada dihate kayak disini ga sih, malah disitu dimaklum2in gitu karna inilah karna itulah, disini yg ngasi semangat sama bilang mau vote aja disalty in wkwkwk
@@Lingqi7yap betul saya smpe scroll semua .. ada juga yg ekspresi kurang, ada yg suaranya betul2 getar ada yg juga lemah nari nya, komennya gk gini... oiya ada komen dri org luar (entah betul irg luar atau jelmaan😅) awalnya ada komen yg muji ehh tau2 ada yg bles itu org luar dia pokoknya intinya pnmpilan jelek. N itu gk cuma²
@@resepibuktiti2505 sbnernya kalau cuma ngasitau kurangnya dimana gamasalah sih, ditambahin saran gitu kedepannya bagusnya gimana, tp kalau yg udah ngarah ke hate ya heran sih emg, dan ngehatenya juga pada ngotot gitu semua bilang gaboleh vote lah, gaboleh dukung lah, kek apasi dukung doang apa salahnya, lagian ini juga belum mulai survival shownya, belum tentu debut juga, udah ngehate segitunya mereka
@@Lingqi7 Dia masih 15 tahun kalopun gagal jg gak jadi masalah dia bisa belajar lagi, dikira audisi pertama langsung bagus gitu yah...kan pasti ada prosesnya, orang indo jg tau kok yang mana talentnya gak berkembang dari awal sampe akhir, secara neti indo seleranya lebih tinggi. Produk yang dari audisi di indo mana ada produk gagal yang ada produk bagus2 semua dan berkarakter, kita tau kok mana yang layak dan tidak layak. Gw aja masih liat nih kan baru showcase pertama belum showcase berikutnya jadi menurutku dia masih ada kesempatan. Dia tinggal dance skill sama suaranya dibulatin. Kita liat kedepannya dia bakal ada peningkatan atau enggak, yang sekarang secara keseluruhan dia punya stage present yang bagus dan punya karakter sih menurut gw. Semangat sih jangan malu2 she really great!
@@unicorn-nx3rj benerr bangett, bahkan ini acaranya belum mulai loh, ini juga cuma cut fancam performancenya aja, fullnya keknya nunggu november dulu pas acaranya dah tayang, masih lamaa, org2 mah pada ngeduluin hate mulu, ada yg nyalahin viewnya banyak juga, ya gimana ga banyak toh dari indo trus pada komen2 mulu ya makin naik lah kan ya videonya, heran aku sama org2 itu wkwkwk
Bruh saw ep 4 and I'm shocked that she even made it back in the show because of fan ticketing.... Judges very wisely chose the members but yall fans ruined opportunity for the ones who actually deserved it like yeojin, xiaoyu, linh dan, yukino, seungbi
I wasn’t expecting these comments. At least she didn’t forget her korean like the tell me performance. She has good stage presence as well. I’m not saying she should be apart of the lineup but she’s only 15. Imagine seeing all of these people hate on you online😢
if i’m being honest compare to other contestants.. i feel sorry for her. she’s not ready. and this is the worst way of represent a country, i know indonesia has a lot of talents that is ready to compete. why would choose someone who is not ready? i feel bad. all the other contestants especially koreans are ready lol. she’s the only indonesian in here and she is not, definitely not ready. if this is a way for them to make other countries lose then idk what to say. edit: this one user named @.nosugarnoprob is incredibly annoying. does anyone know how to ban someone from commenting on this comment section? this person can barely read yet barks at everyone. imma have to warn you, but if you still wanted to have a little talk with this user, good luck with engaging in a pointless argument. i’m out 😂
Do indonesian government involved to choose her to REPRESENTED her country. NO. You sound too serious talking 15yo girl. she just following her dream, she is young and brave enough to go to foreign country.
@@rxxsxhux9710 lol that’s not what i meant, don’t take my words like that and made it stupid as if i was attacked this girl. it’s a talent show where you all compete against each others. the problem here is that she was NOT ready. do you really look at other contestants? that’s what i meant. everyone from different countries especially koreans are already prepared. almost every one of them. if they’re not dance that well, they all sounds amazing. when it’s aired on TV people will ask “who is this girl?” “ah she’s indonesian” she wore the flag and you have no option but represent to those who don’t know. however, SBS need a reason to choose which i was confused by looking at this. have you ever notice how hard it is for a group like secret number to shine in korea just because one of their members are indonesian? they are talented af but still was not appreciated that much. ok now set aside the country issues because it’s not the only concern in here. this poor girl was clearly NOT ready. she’s hella brave ofc! but this is not a performance you’d like to cheer on. by this clip she wasn’t well prepared, no matter how hard you’re trying to give her compliments it doesn’t change the fact that she was not ready YET and is concerning. remember that time when soyeon was mad because of 2 gilries sing and dance horrible on stage yet everyone give them applause? “why would you choose people to compete when you know they were not dance or sing that good?” and it reminds me of this. it’s obviously not the girls fault. i just hope that they took the audition seriously because out of all performances, we can tell that she was not ready. i still don’t know where this show lead us to. it’s better be a “learn and improve” show than just a regular competition because it’s not fair if it is. i’m still looking forward and hope she’ll gets even better in this show tho.
kamu orang Indonesia kan, kalau mau komen menjatuhkan ga usah pake bahasa inggris please, kelihatan banget kamu pengen orang luar ikutan menilai dia buruk. Pake bahasa Indonesia aja biar orang Indonesia trying to fix your inlander mentality, lagian disini kebanyakan yg komen orang Indonesia semua kok😂
@@blue.6096 beside, Kpop is not all about talent, lots of senior idols cannot sing well, lots of survival contestant did worse, and maybe singing is just not her thing, but Vanesya has that “idol charm”, if she cannot make it here, she might find her luck elsewhere, and remember she is just a 14 yo girl with a long way to go, why would you break this poor little girl’s dream. I see you are trying to look “wise and righteous” from the way you type, but no, not at all🙏🏻
Yell stop hating shes just a teen. Have you seen her other performances in the final rounds? No? Thats cause ypuve only seen this and tell me, you have not taken the time to watch her other group performances
lawannya memang berat , tapi harapan pasti ada . semangat !!! jadikan pengalaman untuk terus mengasah diri sampai km bisa debut dan tampil di INDONESIA !!!
Klo dia nggak debut, lepas pasar indonesia 😁. Nggakpplah klo suara bisa di improve, apalagi suaranya udah unique idol. sakura veteran j-idol aja suaranya gemeter, nah momo tu juga hahaha. muka visual udah dapat kok.
Kalo yg udh sering nonton PD101/PD48 atau acara survival idol lainnya bnyk yg tadinya gabisa nyanyi/dance pas d trainee jadi improve & lebih percaya diri kaya bae jin young/lai guan lin/sakura, asalkan mau tekun belajar pasti vanesya juga bisa
As a one of yang sering nonton acara survival, emang ada kontestan yang awalnya ga bisa apa² kek dia. Super weak, jadi lebih improve nantinya. Tapi, ada juga yang tetap weak. Nah point disini tuh, harusnya kita karna udah tau dia disini weak jangan di vote dulu dong? Ntar kalau dia udah improve baru di vote, why? Karena yang lain that better than her deserve di vote. Bayangin aja, kalian dari awal disini vote dia terus. Terus MISALNYA dia tetep weak kedepannya tapi tetep debut gara² vote kalian, apa ga jadi punching bag?
@@adoreroseanne tapi kan survivalnha juga masih berjalan/malah belum mulai eps ny kita liat aja nnti ada kemajuan atau engga, netizen juga bisa menilai sendiri untk skrng dia masih butuh support, untuk sampai disokor juga dia butuh usaha yg mana kita sbg penonton saja gatau sebesar apa pengorbananya, disini aku cuma mau coba support & hargai usahanya dia ga ada salahny, kemungkinan juga ttp knetz yg ambil andil lbh bnyk votenya
@@adoreroseannekamu kok dari kemarin2 maksa banget ya??? hak orang dong mau vote siapa aja... kemarin aja vote nya masih di bawah top 20. orang2 kalau vote pasti ada beberapa pertimbangan bukan cuman lihat dari negara mana dia berasal, kemampuan vocal dan dancenya doang. please ga usah atur2 orang mau vote dia apa nggak.
Are people who are voting for her in their right mind??? What is she even doing in the show if she can't sing???a lot of talented people got eliminated yet someone like her is still rising in ranks??!!? This show is ridiculous.
@@y1ng_163 well at least she got eliminated tho I hope to see her again but better than now she's still young there's a lot chances for her especially when she improves her skills!!
As an Indoesia person, I don't really think she's ready for her debut yet like she needs practice! Plus, if people keep on voting her, not only she's gonna be a representative of a country but she will also embarrassed herself in the public! Give her time to practice and vote on another person that has actual talent and ready for their debut. It's clear that she needs practice. Her voice isn't bad, but if she practice, her voice might get better! (Not hating on her, I actually like her. I just think it's not fair on the voting).
ekspresi dah bagus, dance lumayan, tinggal vokalnya aja yang perlu dilatih lagi, semangatt vanesya edit: yg nanya kenapa vanesya liatnya kebawah pindah2 juga ngeliatnya, itu kamera utamanya disitu, yang rekam ini cuma buat fancam aja, liat aja fancam trainee lain, emgnya ada yg ngeliat ke kamera? gak ada weh
@@duniarania247 hahhaa hampir rata2 idol kpop apalagi yg orang sono tu sengau suaranya 😂 hampir rata rata ya bukan semua tapi kebanyakan orang korea emng sengau ,😂 cuma mereka menang di fisik
Chill guysss... she got into the competition via audition.. that means she's chosen for her ability and skill. She got the talent but i guess she's just extra nervous...
@@adoreroseannethen it's not her fault thay she was randomly chosen either. It's literally a survival show and it's still too early for you to cry about it. At this point, just enjoy the show and vote for your fav, not spamming under a fancam of a contestant you dislike. Dont take kpop too seriously unless you are working and getting paid by kpop industry.
anyone can be admitted to the survival show as long you're eligible. 1. dance, singing, visuals, acting. you don't need all 4 of them, but if you're just pretty and asian you'll be admitted to most of survival shows@@farnm9985
![[ 유니버스티켓 | UNIVERSE TICKET 2023] 82 CONTESTANTS PROFILES [77 ONLY, I FORGOT 5 GIRLS] #universeticket](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z-zMe101FvE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#콜렉습🗃️] D즈니 공주 실사판 그 잡채 유니스(UNIS)의 아우라 담당👑 젤리 당카 모음.zip](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/W-S3kh8i5mI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[페이스캠4K] 베이비몬스터 아현 'CLIK CLAK' (BABYMONSTER AHYEON FaceCam) @SBS Inkigayo 241110](/img/n.gif)
I don't get her hype, are her supporters deaf or just ignoring the fact the girl isn't ready to debut yet like come on y'all
They're all ain't ready to debut thats why they're in this survival. Atleast she tried, you haters.
Coz theyre all indonesians
@@rxxsxhux9710honey usually people are at least average when they are chosen for survival programs. She's an awful singer
Funny how u don't get the hype? Try to close your eyes and listen to her voices
@@mgunawan9527 I did and it's bad even if you record her voice in the studio it won't get better wake up
Now at this point she is more popular than the show 😂
For the wrong reasons.
@@jtsdheYep, the first thing i noticed from this is her, not the show😂
@@kaniafaris me to
I know this show from her in YT Shorts
Yup I have no idea what this show even is but I know her..
I beg y’all…. Please vote wisely. Do you really want this kind of standard to be in the final lineup??
they're not gonna listen to you,they are indonesia they want a indo pride even there contestant is sucks😅
true true 😂
that's why judges' inputs should always be a prio than these fan votes. 😅
you beg people for vote wisely? lol we wont even know/watch this show if it’s not for Vanesya. Let alone voting.
@@nosugarnoprob indo fried check🔥🔥💩
Not even 5 seconds in she already sounds like she's been dancing for 30 min straight 😭 wtf
her voice sounds bad bc shes flu.
You know That's just bullshit reasoning her other performances are the same 😂😂😂@@suprayitno7003
SHUT UP
@@suprayitno7003jyp가 말했다 몸 관리도 실력이야 그리고 바네사의 tell me를 보고도 그런 말이 나와?
The best part of her performance was the instrumental
How I sound like in the shower.
Omgg😂😂😂😂😂😂 real
FR
LOLLL
hahahah this comment, SLAY
LMAO FR
yall need yo save her from hate before she debuts pls she is not really ready and we know kpop community
We Know KNETZ. They easily make an idol got cancelled.
it's her choice participating, she knows that hate will pour on her someday and yet she picks the path of a kpop idol.
@@amma_kjyeah true
She got elliminated she wont debut
@@Xi4nPhithat doesnt justify anything. shes still young, all this hate will probably impact her badly.
there's no way ya'll gonna vote this oneTT I mean let's be real here. i know she can get better, but her improvement is way too long to goTT
Everyone has right to vote. If you dont like her then dont vote her. Simple
@@sriwahyuni6381yall are like voting for like nationality LIKE BFFR SHE ISN'T GOOD she can improve later on
@joelrayfanggamanggribethangga💀
@@tinaa_808 we know she is not good yet, that's why we give her chance to practice more, we wanna see the improvement in this show. If u dont like her then just ignore
do not be rude. You have no right to control everyone 🙄
The other South East Asian girls in this show are performing next level vocals and she still has a better chance of debuting that all of them thanks to fan votes 😭
she got eliminated haha
@@preeeeepppyylovesthank god bro finally😭
bro she from Indonesia..
@@LeroyJohn Thats in South Asia iirc
@@jjais964 i know.. but my point is Indonesia is big ass country so you got my point
She sounded like she's trolling lmao
She’s literally the comedic relief. That’s her role in the group.
@@alsoleve99 yea the tell me tell me performance is scripted for exposure she's there for comedy, and might even debut, and another script where she got better in the future
@@rui__smIt was not scripted. This girl is genuinely lacking compared to other members. She can't speak Korean nor English. Thank God she's eliminated already. They're not that stupid to debut this girl. She was heavily criticised because of her high ranking coming from her superproud countrymen votes even though she sounded like that. If she ranks lower (as she should), people won't give a single fuck for her.
@@rui__sm lol that's such a huge cope coming from you because of your national pride, she's just awfully bad and there's nothing more to it
@@rui__sm thanks god she was eliminated
reason why she shouldn't debut.
1. She's still young, let her have childhood memory
2. Her vocal was unstable, I hate seeing people saying her vocal tone is unique while is definitely not, in my country her vocal tone was VERY VERY common
3. Her dance so stiff, she is lacking in energy, her footwork is just okay but kinda messy
4. Her stage presence.... blank, she already look tired before the stage start, I think cause this fancam it's just a Rehearsal fancam?
Note :: Even though she's like that, I can't lie that her facial expression is very good, and she looks very confident with herself
You are from Malaysia, that’s why you are talking like that😅
@@nosugarnoprobshe's just telling the truth
@@nosugarnoprobfact tho it's not about country it's about talent!!
@@ijanshaa2381 you should see her dancing the universe ticket song, she improved a lot, she is the most popular contestant and she already had her ads in Seoul train. You shouldnt judge base on 1 performance
@@ijanshaa2381 and let me correct you, survival show is not about talent, it’s about popularity
is her nose blocked?
no. its her vibrato
😂😂 not the rhinitis
Lol😂
@@ryanmillerrr baby that isn't what vibrato even is
I like how you look like you're genuine about that 😂😭
She really took "Stayc girls it's going down" way too seriously and now stayc girls are really going down.
LMAO💀
😂
just like my mom would say, words can be prayers.
나는 한국인인데 15살이라는 어린 나이에 우리 케이팝에 관심 가져주고 꿈을 위해 인도네시아라는 먼 곳에서 부모님이랑 떨어져서 혼자 왔다는게 너무 감동임. 엄마가 보고싶어서 매일 밤마다 울었다고 하는게 너무 마음 아팠음.
지금은 악플이 너무 많은데 보란듯이 실력 키워서 많이 늘은 모습 보여주고 꼭 데뷔했으면 좋겠다.
If everyone commented positively like you... Surely people would live their days comfortably without feeling stressed..
Indeed, Vanessya is not as good as the other participants. but I'm sure if he works hard, even if it's not a short time, he will get better.
Thank you for the positive and constructive comments.. 🙏🏻
Sorry I replied in English because I don't speak Korean.
다른 좋은 애들 많은데 바네사가 랭1이라는게 말이됨? 랩도 이미 망쳐놓음.. 알고 말하셈요.. 그러고 엄마 보고싶으면 아예 오질 말든가 해야지.. 그렇게 따지면 바네사 데뷔하면 우리도 실력없이 데뷔할수있는거임
똑같이 먼곳에서 온 베트남인 다른 참가자는 실력, 외모를 포함해서 모든 면에서 완벽한데 투표 덜 받았다고 억울하게 떨어졌습니다. 그녀의 이름이 부린단이에요. 한번 부린단 영상 보시고 우리가 왜 이러는지 이해하실 겁니다...
Stop hating her guys she is just a child
fr omg, i mean it's fine if ppl don't like her but hating is NEVER OKAY + she's just a minor making me sad😢
Yeah she is even kind Ive seen her insta she post every thing which her fans draw
They always be trying to find a ways to hate on her. If it isnt her rap they'll say her vocal, if it isnt her vocal then they'll say her dance are stiff and kept mocking her. People are just so immature.
Yes even her dance is better than her haters and I saw a girl saying on yt ranking Tell me of wonder girls cover she ranked Venesya at the last and said who the hell made on the 3rd rank and I dont remember that girls name but yeah she rapped after Venesya her rap was more wrong but the girl said that she did a little mistake literally Double Standards with minnors
Ikrrrrr she has improved please go see that you guys just blindly hate a child! This is bad
she still young, she have to traine more and more cuz all the competitors here are way above her....yall need to stop saying she had a good vocal or rap cuz shes not and she need to accept the fact but she could traine more...
I wish Indo fans will realize that by voting her aiming to have high rank, would only give her more hate and that will possibly affect the poor girl's mental state. I get all the "she will improve later on" and whatnots but in all honesty, she's not ready yet compare to other contestants. The "Tell Me" performance was an obvious set up to humiliate her by giving her the rap part knowing that she's not yet a fluent Korean speaker. Please set aside ya'll's national pride and think more of the girl's mental health. 🙏
Don't worry, I'm Indonesian and I'm not voting for Vanesya 😁
@@Akenjinn1me to
shes violating islam religion muslim girl wouldn't do that
Dia bilang saat perfom dia cuma latohan 2 hari, ge g tau y 2 hari itu latihan di lagu itu atau gimna, tapi dance nya hafal banget., jadi kemungkinan latihan vocalnya yg baru 2 hari yg s3rius, terus di haruskan tampil, gw g bener dukung dia b aja si, cuma kesian dia di hujat meskipun udah keluar dari nih acara
Aku tidak tahu acara ini ada klo dia tidak viral hahaha
Capek setelah nyanyi❌
Capek sebelum nyanyi ✅
nerveous si keknya
@@ranggaadinata semoga yang terbaik aja buat vanesya
Deg"an kayaknya
DIA LAGI FLU
Justru kalo udah bagus diawal bakal bosen liat nya, justru nilai jual dr survival gini itu liat perkembangan nya.
Sorry to say..
Bicara bahasa korea dia blm fasih, kualitas dance + nyanyi dia sekelas anak sma yang mau pensi, masih kalah sama youtuber cover lagu atau dance..
Aku tidak mengerti survival ini bisa menerima dia, padahal dia lebih baik ikut trainne saja.
Sepertinya dia dari keluarga mampu/kaya, jadi bisa bayar lebih ke pihak penyelenggara acara survival buat ikut serta dalam acara itu, hitung2 buat pengalaman dia kan, soalnya dia masih butuh pengalaman dan latihan lebih.
Visual kak
@@nazhly__9372visual dia juga kebanting kalik kalau sama yang lain
Strategi surfival kan gitu
Banyak org indo yg ikut audisi yg lebih berbakat tapi emang dia yg kepilih
Dari awal emang gk mau org indo debut
Org indo dipilih karna buat rame aja yg nonton ni surfival
Jadi bukan sepenuhnya salah si vanes
@@wadada999 iya juga sih betul, strategi buat menarik penonton dari indo, kalo aku sih lebih baik yg ikut di acara itu dari member jkt48 setidaknya mereka ada pengalaman nge dance sama nyanyi, kalo vanes masih blm siap
나무심하네요.어떻게 한국에 와서 참가하게 되었죠? 인도네시아에 춤노래 잘하는애들 많은데
It's a mistake😂
@@Ryeo_unaayup
Ikr 😂 she's teribble and as an Indonesian I also feel embarrassed. It's not my country faulth... She is the problem... Idk why so many Indonesian people still support her and telling me she will improve... They are just overproud :"
ㅇㅈ
Omg when koreans do comment... I know it would be damn scary 😂
Very clear and stable and beautiful singing! Very pleasant to hear ❤ lets debut vanesya 🎉
This has to be ironic right😭
this is her account
Orang indo plis dia ga ada talenta sama sekali, dia kan masih 15 tahun, masih banyak waktu buat latihan, dia belum siap debut, dan apa kalian ga malu kalau yang merepresentasikan orang Indonesia kayak gini? Padahal banyak loh yang bertalenta di Indonesia, kalian jangan mikir yang penting ada orang Indonesia, vote orang yang benar2 ada bakat, kasian dia yang dihujat.
kamu emang punya talenta apa?? coba buktiin kekorea trus bisa ga masuk ke acara itu ?
@@kathalinajuliasnah orang bebal kek lu nih yang malu2 in negara.. klo meniai itu yg objektif dan bijak.. tau kata "menilai" kan? Yah silakan menilai pakai mata otak dan telinga.. jangan buta fakta.. bukannya gk dukung negeri sendiri tapi ini tentang siapa yg pantas debut dan siapa yg bertalenta, abaikan negara.. silahkan bijak dan objektif sebagai penonton.. orang cerdas pasti milih mana yg bagus.. yg belum oke ngapain dipilih, logikanya ngapain makan daging alot yg belum matang.. bikin gigi patah aja.. alhasil selain jadi bahan tertawaan juga, nama kampung halaman jadi ikut diketawaain juga.. dia masih muda.. masih banyak waktu untuk belajar dan ningkatin skill.. dia terlalu bocil
@@kathalinajulias terus gunanya ikut acara kek gitu buat apa kalo bukan debut, Iya klo hoki hoki dia debut apa g nambh di hujat warga korea, itu resiko dia ikut survival kek gitu resiko yg harus di tnggung mau jd idol harus tahan kritik dri knetzen, plis klo kalian vt karna kasian justru mlh bikin beban dia rank tinggi tp vocal blm matang. FAKTA
@@kathalinajuliasini nih fans yg susah dibilangin. Sebagai netizen ya berbandingannya vanesya sm peserta lain yg ikut survival dong. Ga bermaksud nge hate vanesya nya, dia berjuang disana udah susah. Aku cuma ngehate orang indo yg overproud sama nationality nya.
@@kathalinajuliasdia perlu berlatih lagi... Acara begini bagusnya untuk orang siap debut
Yang divote itu merepresentasikan negara kita loh guys, kalo bagus ya efeknya bagus ke negara kita, kalo kurang ya, siap2 dihujat warganet, bukan warganet indonesia tapi internasional
Dukung aja dulu, kalo di dukung si Vanesya seneng kagak ngedown, kalo seneng jdi giat latihannya dan kemungkinan bisa berkembang pesat dan makin pede. Liat dari sudut pandang yg lebih positif.
@@sriwahyuni6381harus objektif dong memberi dukungan pun, ini kompetisi ajangnya adu bakat. dengan ngasih masukan juga itu bentuk dukungan positif. vanessa mau jadi idol artinya mental dia harus tahan banting, jangan maunya apa-apa yang bagus-bagus aja komennya. jangan anti kritik. buka mata juga untuk kontestan lain yang lebih siap mental dan skills nya.
@@sriwahyuni6381mình nghĩ bạn nên vote một cách công tâm,thí sinh của quốc gia bạn có rất nhiều thiếu xót,nếu được debute thì sẽ ảnh hưởng tới những thành viên khác rất nhiều,thậm chí có thể flop
@@sriwahyuni6381cô ấy sẽ phát triển hơn nữa trong tương lai,nhưng bây giờ cô ấy có quá nhiều thiếu xót,đến với cuộc thi chưa chuẩn bị kỹ càng mà được debute nhờ số lượng vote là cướp đi mất cơ hội của một người xứng đáng hơn,mong bạn sẽ hiểu
jgn salain voter 100% yah, ada voter krn emg disuru vote kan yah, jadi kt ga bs ngatur voter itu harus milih siapa, yg harus di pertanyakan kenapa universe ticket, meloloskan vanesya ke korea, kl da tau skill nya blm cukup. itu harus dipertanyakan
Now that I'm seeing this, she was still so obviously underdeveloped and overhyped, but I've gotta give her credit for actually having some stage presence in this, especially in the beginning. I think the main problem is her vocal tone, nervousness, and lack of confidence on stage. And her dancing skill isn't that bad and has potential to be a lead dancer if she practices a lot more. The main reason she might be moving like that is so she can make herself stable, which is more harder to do when you have to do a low tone voice for the verse. She was dancing a bit better in the beginning when she wasn't singing even if it was mostly hand movements she was doing. If she can learn how to sing decently, (maybe rap too, since that's also her lowest skill), she could actually become an idol! She's also SO PRETTY!!! ❤❤ Hopefully I see her soon with a lot more improvement. THIS IS NOT HATE, it's just my opinion and view of this!
Why such bad comments.....can anyone one of you people do a performance from that stage with confidence and get selected.... no isn't it then why hurting others instead Praise her for never giving up on her dream
Why should we praise her? 💀 she literally can't sing.
omg I love❤❤❤ how she sang the first part. Can't stop watching. she is so talanted and has a stable voice even while she is dancing
guys I didn't ment that. This is not What I want to say to her. I thought I was typing in another short
lol @@Yelena575
I think Indonesian fans are too overproud and overestimate Vanesya even though she is less competitive than others who have prepared well. it's crazy hahaha😂
tbh, most of indonesian people also think that she still needs to train
we supported her no matter what, she is only 15, and still has a long way to go, if she doesn’t make it here, she already had the experience to improve later🥰
I'm Indonesian and I'm really hate abt that things too🤣🤣🤣
aku baca komen org vietnam sama org korea aja mereka pada suportif, heran ini org satu negara malah ngebully, kalau lu pengen wakil indonesia lebih bagus knp bukan lu yg audisi sana
@@nosugarnoprob sape lu nyuruh nyuruh? Brisik.
“STACY GIRLS ITS GOING DOWN” is iconic and no one can tell me otherwise
She made the universal ticket popular😅
When she said “STAYC girls~” I’ve heard enough…
Fans nya susah banget sadar
....
Lu susah banget sadar lonte kalau gak bisa jadi idol wkwk
Bocil semua bng soalnya
Yoi batu semua
Yall can say whatever but her stage presence is actually really fun to watch
리사의 'Money'를 부른다면 이 목소리가 더 좋을 것 같아요. 목소리가 소연이랑 좀 비슷한데 보컬보다는 랩을 맡아야 할 것 같아요
She need an improvement
니키가 생각나는군요. 니키는 목소리가 짧지 않았나요? 지금은 자기 그룹의 래퍼야 ㅋㅋㅋ
@@AhyeonChoiDo u mean is Niki from I-Land?
Sure, she is 15, she have time to improve all around
she said she wanted to be “rapper” and this song is not her choice, so let’s see how she raps🥰🫶🏻
This is her introduction video?! This is the second clip I've seen of her. What is this?! This look like those kpop "performance" for a mall competition not an international competition on TV one. Girl bfr!
yang menjudge ga nonton pd101 s1 ada kim sohye yang gabisa dance sama sekali, vocalnya terbilang kurang bagus, sama sp nya juga... tapi dia bisa improve loh dan akhirnya dia debut juga. pd48 ada kim hyewon, vocal, dance, dan sp menurutku masih mending vanesya tapi dia bisa improve juga dan debut di izone.
ini baru tahap 1 juga kan... udah lumayan bagus sih ini untuk ukuran yang mulai dari 0... gua lihat dia punya potensi dan kalau dilatih sama coach2 korea ni pasti bisa keluar semua bakat dia.
SEMANGAT VANESYA!!!❤
😄❤️
hyewon debut kan karna rigged 😂
@@nathalieathana2344hyewon debut krn visual menurut gue,emang dia agak gmn bakatnya tp diacantik bgt makannya habis izone disband dia jadi aktris kan.dan banyak pas zaman pd48 fans vote dia krn visualnya
@@nathalieathana2344lah hyewon debut karena dapetin hati knetz yang selalu ada kejutan setiap misi nya dari misi pertama ambil rap padahal gak ada basic, terus misi ke dua bikin lyric rap
Wadaw makasih hari gini masih ada yg mengenal Sohye cewekku 😊👍 Btw mulut & gigi Sohye & Vanesya mirip ya 😁
Her dancing: 😍😍🥰🥰
Her vocals: ☠️☠️😢😢
vanesya harus kuat ya mentalnya, kita support kok asalkan kamu juga berjuang dengan serius dan buktikan peningkatan mu, belum terlambat, iyaa saingannya emang berat, tapi jadikan itu motivasi, jngan terlalu memaksakan diri jg yaa, lakukan dengan serius dengan caramu, untuk dirimu sndiri bukan utk kita, krna hanya kamu yang tau diri mu sndiri. jangan takut, walaupun mungkin lebih sakit hati baca komen warga sendiri tapi kamu harus tetap kuat ya, kita jg sulit membungkam mulut atau typing kotor mereka, jdi kamu buktikan aj dengan kemampuan mu nanti, tetap belajar kamu masih muda masih banyak kesempatan kok, santai ajaa let it flow 😎👍
Vanesya Let’s go! (Home)
😂😂😂LMAOOOO
Underrated
stayc gewrl😍 is goeing dauwn!🤪🙌
Indonesia pride 🤣
All her hate comments aside, her dance is good., Keep it up!❤
Jujur aku kalo jadi dia, pasti uda keringet dingin, gugup, nangiiss karna deg2an..
Kamu hebat Vanesya, punya kesempatan dan berani sampai korea di usia 15th ikut ajang kek gini, itu aja uda hebatt lho..
STAYC GURLS IS GOING DAEWN
what a move😢😂
She’s not ready to debut. People or her fans should realize that.
She's Funny, I'm Liking Her.
SBS Picked Her,, So I'm With SBS In This.
As Long As You Keep Fighting, I'm With You Vanesha ❤
ATEEEE
we stan a young, talented, slaying, beautiful girl who doesnt care one bit about the racist anonymous losers on the internet
@@yukikahoney PERIODD she dont gaf and that made me stan her more
Well today she is more popular than the show 😂😂😂You must be thankful for this girl because she's going viral and many people is getting familiar to what show it is.
I’m indonesian, but honestly we need to be realistic, vanesya still need a couple years more to practice. And other contestants is in another level than her🙏🏻
Me wasting a hour in the shower trying to speak Korean:
애들아 현명하게 투표해라 케이팝 이미지를 망치지마 😂
이건 서바이벌 프로그램이야. 너는 어떤 프로그램이라고 생각해?
Acara ini tanpa viewer dari Indonesia juga ga da apa2nya
@@vioyuki2596meh, there will still a lot more viewers from other countries. So they will be find without Indonesian
😂
@@vioyuki2596its funny that you really think only indonesians watch this? She needs to go back to your country
I swear if she debuts i might just go there and try 💀💀
She got eliminated on ep6
😊🤫StaYC GiRls😁 iS gOiNg DoWn😊😆
Là một người Việt Nam, tôi ủng hộ Vũ Linh Đan và cả Vanessa, dù Vanessa đến từ Indonesia nhưng tôi ủng hộ cô ấy vì bị thu hút bởi vẻ ngoài và biểu cảm của cô ấy, cô ấy thu hút sự chú ý của tôi, mặc dù giọng hát của cô ấy vẫn còn thiếu sót nhưng nếu cô ấy Tập luyện nhiều hơn chắc chắn sẽ hay hơn và đặc biệt là Vũ Linhdan, giọng hát của bạn rất hay nhưng biểu cảm còn thiếu sót nhưng tôi sẽ luôn ủng hộ bạn, mong các bạn có thể cùng nhau ra mắt
very nice and supportive comment 👍🏻, hope both of them can debut 🥰❤️
aku harap mereka bisa debut bersama
Terima kasih telah mendukung❤
both are also my pick
Aku heran pas audisi memang gimana, bukannya acara survival kek gini harus lolos seleksi audisi dulu. Padahal aku yakin di luar sana tu pasti banyak trainee atau dancer dari Indo yg di korea. Bukan maksud ngejelekin dia, tp kesannya jadinya orang luar yg nonton nilai, ohh gini kualitas trainee idol dari Indo, padahal aslinya banyak dari indo yg bakat dance sama nyanyinya bagus banget, tp napa pas di acara survival gini gak nemu yg bagus. Dulu aku cuma pernah nemuin trainee indo yg ikutan survival show di japan produce season 2, trainee nakamura toma bagus banget bakatnya orang bali dia. Nah maksud aku tu, kenapa gak yg bagus gitu yg di ikut kan survival show, jadinya kan orang2 gak nganggap remeh kualitas orang2 indo. Kyak Dita seandainya semisal dia ikut survival show kek gini, orang pasti bakalan kagum, ohh ni orang dancenya bagus. Tp untuk vanesya sangat di sayangkan si menurutku
Kayaknya dia beneran modal nekat ga sih? Tanpa prepare apa². Terus kayaknya kalau kontestan banyak gini tu milih random ga sih... Jadi kek ga disaring. Sedih banget liat fans nya toxic semua dan kata² andalan selalu "yang penting debut dulu"... I mean, so what exactly yang lo cari di idol indonesia? Cuma karna WNI? Ga butuh bakat?😹
tapi dia dancenya lumayan sih jadi paling kalo ga dapet disini dia bisa training di 1million studio, ntar jadi back dancer. biar setidaknya msh bisa berkarya di korea.
Dia jelas menarik, idol nggak cm didengar suaranya aja. visualnya, youthful nya, ekspresi mukanya juga jadi pertimbangan. Tolong jangan bandingkan dengan dita yg 10 tahun lebih tua, tentu aja dita sudah banyak pengalaman dan belajar formal tentng tari. Miyeon tidak kepiih jd membernya blackpink padahal dia cantik, suaranya bagus, nah itu udah menunjukkan bahwa debut menjadi idol itu banyak dipertimbangkan. Mohon disupport dan tidak menjatuhkan anak remaja umur 15 tahun ini.
simplenya sih berarti yg disebut itu ga pada daftar buat ikut audisi ini
Dance lumayan? Bagusan juga dance para tiktokers wkwkwk
you know guys just watch and enjoy let the girl shine her day .She may not perfect at her perfomance now but life is amazing just watch and enjoy what she got .
Kpop standards really went down lmfao.... And ppl are telling me this gurl is ranked 3rd😭😭😭😭🤣
They ain't lying tho
you guys have to vote wisely to save this girl from being humiliated. it's too early for her now.
Bisa maju kaya gitu aja nggak gampang, ayo Vanesya lakukan terbaik dari diri kamu. Pengalaman itu Kamu yang punya, bukan orang lain. Jadikan acuan dek, jangan hiraukan perkataan mereka yang gak membantu kamu buat lebih maju. 🇮🇩
😊❤
Namanya jg baru, masih grogi kali, kalau aq malah ngak keluar suaranya kali😂😂😂
jujur keren bgt. Dia pasti tau kemampuan dia masih blm mateng, tp dia berani & percaya diri buat nyoba. bener2 mental orang sukses@@rinaamrinah8666
@@rinaamrinah86662in segini dia udh hebat banget 😭
😊😊
I love her confident and how energetic her. And suprisingly her vocal improved now! Im proud of her!
Y'all are defending her and saying she doesn't sound that bad and doesn't deserve the hate because she's 15 and inexperienced. I agree that she doesn't deserve the hate. She's very young and should not be put in such a bad situation at an early age. It's also not her fault that Indonesians vote for her. However, it's also important to realise that being an idol requires decent vocal skills. Yes, she can get better over time but she's not good at the moment. She can practice and hopefully debut later in the future, she's still a young girl and has time. But please y'all, don't vote for her because she's Indonesian. It's very biased, wasting talent of girls who are actually ready to debut.
Finally someone who addresses defenders and reasons rather than memes
Gini ya guys yg nge hate, dia masih 15 tahun, belum pernah trainee, bukan orang Korea, jadi dia harus menyesuaikan koreo + bahasa + suara + mengikuti kamera dan ekspresi nya. Dan gw lihat suara dia gak parah bgt + ekspresi nya juga gak segagal itu dan dia udah keren bgt. Jadi stop hate dehh, support aja teruss
Percuma dijelasin, haters mah cuma ngiri. Biasa lah anak gen z😂
Bener banget, harusnya di dukung bukan di hujat. Suaranya bagus kok, tapi mungkin harus lebih banyak latihan lagi, pasti akan lebih bagus. Lebih banyaknlatihanlah intinya. Yg udah terkenal aja conyohnya BP, BTS, dll, aja pasti masih ttp terus latihan, apalagi yg baru2 kyk gini.
Dia orang mana?
gw bukan haters dia, tp buat apa support pake embel2 "biar org indo yg jd idol makin banyak", meanwhile bakat nyanyi dan dancenya masih kek gitu. ini acara survival loh. masa nyanyi kek orang pilek ama dancenya yang detailnya aja ga dapet dilolosin... WKWKWKWK
@@kpopaddict1436 kek orang pilek?? Padahal gw dengar suara dia gak seburuk itu. Kalau nonton survival sebelum2nya pasti tau dulu ada peserta diawal gak mau nyanyi, ada yang suara + ekspresinya lebih parah dari Vanesya ini tapi bisa debut dan karna di trainee ya skill nya jadi makin jago.
Kalau gak bisa support ya minimal jangan hate atau ngata ngatain kayak Lo ini
Many people are talking about how she's gonna debut soon and how good she is , so I got curious ,,,
🫨🫨🫨
all I can say is
SHE HAS POTENTIAL BUT SHE'S NOT READY YET,HER SINGING AND DANCING ARE JUST SOSO ...
there's still room for improvement
Just my opinion though~
She's already got eliminated
No hate but I totally not finding him calming, good voice either vibes on it
Guys she’s now ranked No.1 🤣🤣🤣
She killed the solo 🤠
In a bad way. 🫤
She would be a great floptropican mayor
Kok gw kesel yah banyk yang nge hate dia dan dibandingin sama peserta lain.....si vanes bukannya bener2 dari 0 dan gak ada basic trainee yaudah sih gw liat disini dia gak jelek2 banget masih singkron 😂 gw liat nya dia malah grogi gw tau kalo orang indo kalo dilatih bakal improve.ini baru test pertama udh banyak yang ngehate😂 kalopun dia masih dihate udah karir aj diindo yang ada kamu lebih di bagusin di tarik suara. Gw ngeliat auranya udh superstar
pdhal peserta lain ada yg jelek juga performnya, tp gaada dihate kayak disini ga sih, malah disitu dimaklum2in gitu karna inilah karna itulah, disini yg ngasi semangat sama bilang mau vote aja disalty in wkwkwk
@@Lingqi7yap betul saya smpe scroll semua .. ada juga yg ekspresi kurang, ada yg suaranya betul2 getar ada yg juga lemah nari nya, komennya gk gini... oiya ada komen dri org luar (entah betul irg luar atau jelmaan😅) awalnya ada komen yg muji ehh tau2 ada yg bles itu org luar dia pokoknya intinya pnmpilan jelek. N itu gk cuma²
@@resepibuktiti2505 sbnernya kalau cuma ngasitau kurangnya dimana gamasalah sih, ditambahin saran gitu kedepannya bagusnya gimana, tp kalau yg udah ngarah ke hate ya heran sih emg, dan ngehatenya juga pada ngotot gitu semua bilang gaboleh vote lah, gaboleh dukung lah, kek apasi dukung doang apa salahnya, lagian ini juga belum mulai survival shownya, belum tentu debut juga, udah ngehate segitunya mereka
@@Lingqi7 Dia masih 15 tahun kalopun gagal jg gak jadi masalah dia bisa belajar lagi, dikira audisi pertama langsung bagus gitu yah...kan pasti ada prosesnya, orang indo jg tau kok yang mana talentnya gak berkembang dari awal sampe akhir, secara neti indo seleranya lebih tinggi. Produk yang dari audisi di indo mana ada produk gagal yang ada produk bagus2 semua dan berkarakter, kita tau kok mana yang layak dan tidak layak. Gw aja masih liat nih kan baru showcase pertama belum showcase berikutnya jadi menurutku dia masih ada kesempatan. Dia tinggal dance skill sama suaranya dibulatin. Kita liat kedepannya dia bakal ada peningkatan atau enggak, yang sekarang secara keseluruhan dia punya stage present yang bagus dan punya karakter sih menurut gw. Semangat sih jangan malu2 she really great!
@@unicorn-nx3rj benerr bangett, bahkan ini acaranya belum mulai loh, ini juga cuma cut fancam performancenya aja, fullnya keknya nunggu november dulu pas acaranya dah tayang, masih lamaa, org2 mah pada ngeduluin hate mulu, ada yg nyalahin viewnya banyak juga, ya gimana ga banyak toh dari indo trus pada komen2 mulu ya makin naik lah kan ya videonya, heran aku sama org2 itu wkwkwk
Vanesya is going down 👇🏻!!😅
She is not ready yet she needs more practice guys!
VANESYAA FIGHTING!!💛
Gue YG stan, menurut pandangan gue, ni anak punya potensi, bisa di kembangin, tipe anak yang bakal terus berkembang gitu bakatnya😌🙏
Apa urusannya sama yg stan😂
@@naylafebrisa4612 gada😂😭🙏 introducing aja kak😭🙏😂
@@naylafebrisa4612dia hanya perkenalkan diri😌
@@naylafebrisa4612mbk nya alumni survival YG 😭 pandangannya kek babeh yang hyunsuk gitu
@@yuliafitriani06 siape😭😭
Bruh saw ep 4 and I'm shocked that she even made it back in the show because of fan ticketing.... Judges very wisely chose the members but yall fans ruined opportunity for the ones who actually deserved it like yeojin, xiaoyu, linh dan, yukino, seungbi
Stayc girls is going dawwnn💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻
Its like if she closed her nose and sang 😅😅😅
I wasn’t expecting these comments. At least she didn’t forget her korean like the tell me performance. She has good stage presence as well. I’m not saying she should be apart of the lineup but she’s only 15. Imagine seeing all of these people hate on you online😢
Comes with the territory unfortunately.
Without her the show wouldnt be popular tbh ;-;
if i’m being honest compare to other contestants.. i feel sorry for her. she’s not ready. and this is the worst way of represent a country, i know indonesia has a lot of talents that is ready to compete. why would choose someone who is not ready? i feel bad. all the other contestants especially koreans are ready lol. she’s the only indonesian in here and she is not, definitely not ready.
if this is a way for them to make other countries lose then idk what to say.
edit:
this one user named @.nosugarnoprob is incredibly annoying. does anyone know how to ban someone from commenting on this comment section? this person can barely read yet barks at everyone. imma have to warn you, but if you still wanted to have a little talk with this user, good luck with engaging in a pointless argument. i’m out 😂
Do indonesian government involved to choose her to REPRESENTED her country. NO. You sound too serious talking 15yo girl. she just following her dream, she is young and brave enough to go to foreign country.
@@rxxsxhux9710 lol that’s not what i meant, don’t take my words like that and made it stupid as if i was attacked this girl.
it’s a talent show where you all compete against each others. the problem here is that she was NOT ready. do you really look at other contestants? that’s what i meant. everyone from different countries especially koreans are already prepared. almost every one of them. if they’re not dance that well, they all sounds amazing. when it’s aired on TV people will ask
“who is this girl?”
“ah she’s indonesian”
she wore the flag and you have no option but represent to those who don’t know. however, SBS need a reason to choose which i was confused by looking at this.
have you ever notice how hard it is for a group like secret number to shine in korea just because one of their members are indonesian? they are talented af but still was not appreciated that much.
ok now set aside the country issues because it’s not the only concern in here.
this poor girl was clearly NOT ready. she’s hella brave ofc! but this is not a performance you’d like to cheer on. by this clip she wasn’t well prepared, no matter how hard you’re trying to give her compliments it doesn’t change the fact that she was not ready YET and is concerning.
remember that time when soyeon was mad because of 2 gilries sing and dance horrible on stage yet everyone give them applause?
“why would you choose people to compete when you know they were not dance or sing that good?” and it reminds me of this.
it’s obviously not the girls fault. i just hope that they took the audition seriously because out of all performances, we can tell that she was not ready.
i still don’t know where this show lead us to. it’s better be a “learn and improve” show than just a regular competition because it’s not fair if it is.
i’m still looking forward and hope she’ll gets even better in this show tho.
@@blue.6096you are trying to make indonesian don't give votes to her, thats what you do.
kamu orang Indonesia kan, kalau mau komen menjatuhkan ga usah pake bahasa inggris please, kelihatan banget kamu pengen orang luar ikutan menilai dia buruk. Pake bahasa Indonesia aja biar orang Indonesia trying to fix your inlander mentality, lagian disini kebanyakan yg komen orang Indonesia semua kok😂
@@blue.6096 beside, Kpop is not all about talent, lots of senior idols cannot sing well, lots of survival contestant did worse, and maybe singing is just not her thing, but Vanesya has that “idol charm”, if she cannot make it here, she might find her luck elsewhere, and remember she is just a 14 yo girl with a long way to go, why would you break this poor little girl’s dream. I see you are trying to look “wise and righteous” from the way you type, but no, not at all🙏🏻
Yell stop hating shes just a teen. Have you seen her other performances in the final rounds? No? Thats cause ypuve only seen this and tell me, you have not taken the time to watch her other group performances
lawannya memang berat , tapi harapan pasti ada . semangat !!! jadikan pengalaman untuk terus mengasah diri sampai km bisa debut dan tampil di INDONESIA !!!
Loh ngapa jadi tampil di Indonesia, ya di korea lah, dia mau jadi idol kpop, bukan ipop
yg lawa merata dapat, bakat penting dalam industri kpop
lawan mainnya rata² berbakat semua, 😂
Klo dia nggak debut, lepas pasar indonesia 😁. Nggakpplah klo suara bisa di improve, apalagi suaranya udah unique idol. sakura veteran j-idol aja suaranya gemeter, nah momo tu juga hahaha. muka visual udah dapat kok.
@@Jk07994kagak masalah daripada loe udah kagak bisa kagak modal lagi😀
Kalo yg udh sering nonton PD101/PD48 atau acara survival idol lainnya bnyk yg tadinya gabisa nyanyi/dance pas d trainee jadi improve & lebih percaya diri kaya bae jin young/lai guan lin/sakura, asalkan mau tekun belajar pasti vanesya juga bisa
As a one of yang sering nonton acara survival, emang ada kontestan yang awalnya ga bisa apa² kek dia. Super weak, jadi lebih improve nantinya. Tapi, ada juga yang tetap weak. Nah point disini tuh, harusnya kita karna udah tau dia disini weak jangan di vote dulu dong? Ntar kalau dia udah improve baru di vote, why? Karena yang lain that better than her deserve di vote. Bayangin aja, kalian dari awal disini vote dia terus. Terus MISALNYA dia tetep weak kedepannya tapi tetep debut gara² vote kalian, apa ga jadi punching bag?
@@adoreroseanne tapi kan survivalnha juga masih berjalan/malah belum mulai eps ny kita liat aja nnti ada kemajuan atau engga, netizen juga bisa menilai sendiri untk skrng dia masih butuh support, untuk sampai disokor juga dia butuh usaha yg mana kita sbg penonton saja gatau sebesar apa pengorbananya, disini aku cuma mau coba support & hargai usahanya dia ga ada salahny, kemungkinan juga ttp knetz yg ambil andil lbh bnyk votenya
@@adoreroseannekamu kok dari kemarin2 maksa banget ya??? hak orang dong mau vote siapa aja... kemarin aja vote nya masih di bawah top 20. orang2 kalau vote pasti ada beberapa pertimbangan bukan cuman lihat dari negara mana dia berasal, kemampuan vocal dan dancenya doang. please ga usah atur2 orang mau vote dia apa nggak.
Sakura udah pengalaman jadi idol kalee sebelum izone
@@adoreroseannenihh orang siapa dahh?? Kamu iri bgt keknya
Are people who are voting for her in their right mind??? What is she even doing in the show if she can't sing???a lot of talented people got eliminated yet someone like her is still rising in ranks??!!? This show is ridiculous.
Agreed. She doesn’t deserve all the votes, in my opinion
@@y1ng_163 well at least she got eliminated tho I hope to see her again but better than now she's still young there's a lot chances for her especially when she improves her skills!!
I hope she would train for 4 years straight. I think she will improve by then.
Shame on all indo who voted for this😂😂😂😂😂😢😢😢😢
true
As an Indoesia person, I don't really think she's ready for her debut yet like she needs practice! Plus, if people keep on voting her, not only she's gonna be a representative of a country but she will also embarrassed herself in the public! Give her time to practice and vote on another person that has actual talent and ready for their debut. It's clear that she needs practice. Her voice isn't bad, but if she practice, her voice might get better!
(Not hating on her, I actually like her. I just think it's not fair on the voting).
What is she doing??💀 Guys wake up why would you vote for her? she'll get severe hate after debut ☠️
:" she'll get bigger as the haters grow I suppose huhu.. hope she'll improve soon
VOTE WISELY
ekspresi dah bagus, dance lumayan, tinggal vokalnya aja yang perlu dilatih lagi, semangatt vanesya
edit: yg nanya kenapa vanesya liatnya kebawah pindah2 juga ngeliatnya, itu kamera utamanya disitu, yang rekam ini cuma buat fancam aja, liat aja fancam trainee lain, emgnya ada yg ngeliat ke kamera? gak ada weh
ekspresi dah bagus? 😂😂😂 kocaaak biawak
@@lilstarfilms5059 yaudah ganti lumayan deh, gitu amat biawak🙄
@@lilstarfilms5059 lebih kocak lu babi hutan 😂
Baiklah pak dewan juri renahan
@@bangajieh apasih sok asik
aaa vanesya grogi ya? suaranya gemetar gtu😢 tapi ekspresi nya bagussss ness gk kliatan kakuu
Ky sengau gt ga sih suaranya
@@duniarania247 hahhaa hampir rata2 idol kpop apalagi yg orang sono tu sengau suaranya 😂 hampir rata rata ya bukan semua tapi kebanyakan orang korea emng sengau ,😂 cuma mereka menang di fisik
Sengau itu apa?? Idol kpop sekarang mah Visual nomor 1, Nomor dua baru suara. Kadang mereka jg sering Lypsing
@@duniarania247vanesya kayakny pake nasal voice sih kalau menurutku
@@duniarania247Suaranya aja bengek, mending operasi hidung dulu deh biar suara nya gak bengek² bazah gitu wkwk
Stacy gurls, it's gOing DoWn 👃🏻
Overflowing guts beyond her audacity.
Let's go vanesya! (TO home)
😂😂😭
Yessss girl ❤❤❤❤
Chill guysss... she got into the competition via audition.. that means she's chosen for her ability and skill. She got the talent but i guess she's just extra nervous...
The fact that not all contestant that we saw in survival show are chosen for their talent but just RANDOMLY chosen😔
@@adoreroseannethen it's not her fault thay she was randomly chosen either. It's literally a survival show and it's still too early for you to cry about it. At this point, just enjoy the show and vote for your fav, not spamming under a fancam of a contestant you dislike. Dont take kpop too seriously unless you are working and getting paid by kpop industry.
anyone can be admitted to the survival show as long you're eligible. 1. dance, singing, visuals, acting. you don't need all 4 of them, but if you're just pretty and asian you'll be admitted to most of survival shows@@farnm9985
she looks really cuteee
i want to see the judge's reactions 😭
Did she join the program as a joke bc if I were her I would've cry if my performance was like that 💀💀😭😭😭
You have great talent 🤩 keep it hidden 🤩
She CAN improve..lets not hate her alot and yes she does deserves to be eliminated but she might improve
I do always sound like that in the shower😂
You’re suppose to sound better in the shower, not worse.
@@alsoleve99 exactly yeah better than her🤩
That's how I sound when I close my nose while singing at my bathroom 🤣
my ears are bleeding with this cold voice
Lets go vanesya!! ❤🎉 Pls debut! Supporting hwaiting!!!!
If she debuts I'm going to Korea to apply
The show is over and she was already eliminated and theres already ones who debuted