Thanks Chris. Strange that the producers and writers used Henry so badly. The story is extraordinary in itself without the need for false tales of those brave men. We have so few heroes these days that it is well we remember our past ones as they were and not as mammon would make them. Rest well, Henry Hook; we remember you, too.
What a marvellous chap. Seriously maligned by the film, which is a real shame... no wonder his family walked out in disgust. Another masterly history lesson, Chris. Well done !
I have loved "Zulu" since the first time I watched it! Thanks so much for bringing the truth of this brave soldier to light. Dramatic license is one thing but this besmirching of Hook's reputation, especially while his descendants have had to live with the view portrayed in the film is quite unfair.
@TheHistoryChap Oh, without a doubt! I was delighted when the 50th Anniversary Blu-ray was issued. Wide-screen is the only way to go! "And a bayonet.. with some guts behind it!" 😉👍 BTW, have you done a video yet about Color Sergeant Bourne? I seem to remember reading somewhere that he wasn't awarded the VC as he opted for an award a step down and the Queen's Commission. "He lives twice who enjoys history." 😉
The truth isn't relevant and the film doesn't claim to be factual as i`m pretty sure there was no rousting rendition of Men Of Harlech either ....the real Hook was a hero but the film Hook imo was as well
Such a shame a very brave and courageous man was so wrongly depicted in a film that so many people have now seen and so many will see in the future! Thank you for another great story and stay well.
It really was outrageous when you think of it how they could malign such a decent hero, I have never liked that character in the film and I think it let it down. May you rest in peace you fine gentleman 🙏
The trouble is our usual love of the fairy story - the idea of the likeable rough diamond, come good in the end. The fact that he was a good guy to start with didn't fit that easy stereotype sadly, so the producers messed about with a decent man's reputation.
But the film inspires the audience to research the true histories. I am pleased the character is portrayed the way he is in the film. He has the greatest anti racist Line “Has a Zulu ever walked up the King’s Road”, questioning why the British were in SA. It is a Film! Not a documentary.
Is that a real picture of his funeral? Incredible. What a crowd for a sergeant who was still a private when he won his VC. Today a general couldn't draw such a crowd. It shows how much Britons valued their soldiers back then. We've fallen far since then...
Hitch's funeral was something else. He became a hackney carriage driver when he left the army and for his funeral, just about every London Hackney carriage took part in a miles-long cortege that brought the city to a standstill.
Thank you Chris number for setting the record straight with Private Hook. I am sure his spirit is looking down on you and smiling, thanking you for being one of the most ardent defenders. Truly I have always enjoyed your meticulous preparation and dedication to subject matter, bravo amigo 👏 🙌
He was the brother of my Grandmother Rose Hook grandfather from Stourbridge. His daughters attended the Zulu film premiere and were far from happy. Thanks for posting. I will share it with my family.
Such a wonderful film. I saw it first time with my Father, and immediately fell in love with the story. For Christmas, my Father presented me with a History Book, which gave a full account of the Battle and the men involved. Oh my goodness. I was heartbroken. Ye gods, to say the film had taken liberties was an understatement. Nevertheless, I still love the way the film portrays the tale. What harm is there in using a little fiction to embellish a true event? Thank you for this defence of Henry Hook.
"What harm is there in using a little fiction to embellish a true event? " ..... Hmmmmm... WHAT HARM is there in DESTROYING a man's reputation? Let's tell some "embellishments" about YOU and see how and your family like it.
@@williampawson5476 I get you. When did you learn the truth? I was 16 and it broke my heart. Yes, I agree with you. Most of the time a Film does not reflect actual history. Even the most accurate historical epics will distort the facts to build a better narrative. My rhetorical question was not to justify these acts, but to challenge how we learn history. Films are there to entertain, not to educate.
Gee, has been a few months since I first time saw the movie of 'Zulu' for myself at long last, gonna have to do so again, but in the meantime I certainly must thank you again for this great and very well done truth and honesty spilling history lesson on another great British military hero of the Battle of Rourke's Drift, Chris dear chap. Well it's no wonder Hook's two daughters walked outta the premiere of the movie when it came out, to have their dear dad portrayed like THAT, when you've given us the REAL Captain Henry Hook VC here, a man who sure was a true hero at the real battle that day in 1879, and continued to be a true Victorian gentleman in the years afterwards, AND a NON drinker unlike what the movie does rather dirty with. If ever we know someone who certainly knows EXACTLY what to give with certain need to know facts about British military conflicts and individuals who are true heroes indeed, it's YOU, dear boy 😊😊😊👍👍👍
Thank you very much. What I wanted to do was tell his real story. I do however, except that films or stories and they need human interest in them. Hooke was portrayed as a fallen character, who soared like an Eagle, when his comrades were in trouble
An extraordinary hero indeed, badly portraited in Zulu, but it was for "cinematic" sake, Hook was a great example of a man, for all times and ages. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you for the correct account of history. It is astonishing that most people take the film as the true account of what happened and throughout history this has happened time and time again
Great video, Chris. I knew that Hook had been maligned but good to see the full back story. I'm an ex-Loggie and always felt that James Langley Dalton didn't get a great shake in the film either.
@@josephturner7569 If my memory serves me well, Garnet Wolsley was less than impressed that Chard and Bromhead received VC's for just doing their jobs.
Why am I not surprised at the "Movie Industries" mishandling of the 'Truth'? It's what they do (Lies, make believe, & BS) Which is a shame, as the truth is often more exciting. Sadly they are unwilling/unable to do so. Thanks for setting the record straight.
Excellent video Chris. I think Cy Endfield wanted a lovable rogue character and got this completely wrong. Hook was a very brave man and his defending and saving patients in the hospital was magnificent. Also false, I believe, was the British soldiers singing! That said I still feel the hairs standing up on the back of my neck whenever I hear Ivor Emmanual (Private Owen) leading the men singing Men of Harlech as they face the Zulu charge. Fantastic moment. Fantastic film!
@@TheHistoryChap Yep Men of Harlech is never a British song as the lyrics are very much anti English and is still sung at Welsh sports fans today and by Welsh troops in the British army.
I did say the event did not happen but enjoyed the part of the film when true Welshmen faced Zulus not the English. I have the utmost respect for the Welsh servicemen and a highlight for me was when visiting the Somme battlefield I went to Mametz Wood. I felt privaleged to walk across that field past the 38th memorial and into the woods itself. Looking around imagining Welshmen fighting magnificently against a very strong German opposition. Welshmen are great fighters and I am glad they are on our side. @@timphillips9954
Also, of course, it wasn't a Welsh regiment. The '1st Warwicks' became 'The Welsh Borderers' some time after Rourke's Drift. There may well have been many Welsh in the regiment, but I doubt they would have been singing 'Men of Harlech!' But hey, it's a film, not history!@@timphillips9954
Thank you for an honest representation of Henry Hook. "Zulu" was in several respects historically flawed and often due to Stanley Baker's Welsh origins driving his personal preference. Nigel Green's portrayal of "Colour Sergeant Bourne" was another inaccuracy. However .... I do love the film !!! :)
@@TheHistoryChap Done. Over a year ago. One thing I can’t stand is a digital narrator. It’s so fake. I do love history so and you, sir, are my new favorite person to tell it. Back in the day, I enjoyed listening to Alex Scott and his narration of “Wings of the Luftwaffe”. Robert Powell is another fine gentleman of narration. We Americans sadly, don’t have a story teller that even comes close to your quality, sir. Peace be within thy walls.
I think Henry's movie depiction makes him more memorable. He was definitely one of the stand out characters, if not the most, and a more historically accurate version may not have had this effect? Wonderful movie, and probably the reason why a lot of us are here
Great video. This is the type of situation where when you've never looked into the finer details, you don't know if the character was based on a real man or if he was a fictional character to engage with the historical figures. Great to know that he was real and even better that his true story be told. I listen to a variety of audiobooks, changing from one genre to another to keep things fresh. I'm currently listening to a book on the Lancaster Bomber, I've already listed to ones covering Bomber Command itself and one specifically on the Dambuster Raid. No man is perfect, but I hear some incredible stories from men who maintained a level of dignity under circumstances that would break a modern man. Many of those men were incredibly young.
I just thought Henry was a lovable person. He won the VC, so I just took his character in the movie as poetic licence. His courage did shine through in the movie at the end, saving his fellow soldiers. It's a movie, not a documentary.
I never knew the fact Henry was so misrepresented by the film, what a miscarriage of justice. The truth would have made an equally good story. I loved the passion and enthusiasm of the presentation. Thank you very much
I’m glad that I had already read about Hook and knew about his maligning in “Zulu” (still a superb movie!). Nonetheless, this was an excellent presentation…as usual!
Hi Ludwig, I’m glad you enjoyed the video. If you haven’t already, please do subscribe to my channel and maybe even sign up to my newsletter at my website.
David Rattray, who did the most stunning series of lectures on the Anglo Zulu wars all the way from Isandlwana to Ulundi, was the first one I heard undoing the damage the film did to his reputation and it is lovely to see this channel spreading the good word too.
This is my favourite video on UA-cam! The fact that Hook was a cook absolutely gob smacked me. Retired Canadian Forces cook, and him looking after his boys making tea after the battle is fitting.
Chris...once again, thank you so much for putting the reality of Private Hook FIRMLY at rest. My Great Grandfather...JOHN WILLIAM FIELDING V.C., (aka: John Williams), never mentioned Henry Hook, apparently, as ALL those at the Battle were there not only to save themselves but those unfortunate to be infirm, within the Hospital. My Great Grandfather's Hair actually turned SILVER/WHITE a few short Months after the Battle, obviously due to the actions endured. G.A.R.
Thank you Sir. Being a Yank I know very little about English millitary affairs except of course our Revolutionary War and the War of 1812. The movie Zulu has always been one of my favorites since I was a kid. And as always movies are rarely without their creative manipulations which spoils most films for me. Sooo that is why you are here to set the story straight. Thank you again.
Thanks so very much for this video Chris! As a high school-educated working man (now retired) with a passion for history, I am very grateful for your channel as it gives me an opportunity to learn more about British history. Whether civil or military, I watch all your videos when they post whilst catching up on your previous work! Thanks mate and keep it coming! 🇬🇧👍🙂
I knew his descendants were not happy with the films portrayal of Henry Hook. Makes you wonder why the filmmakers did this to such a fine gentleman, soldier and family man. God bless you Henry Hook VC. Fantastic video, many thanks.
A shame that the studio, writers, director, and all involved would allow such an historical, and personal, travesty to be put to film for generations to see.
Thank you, Chris, that was an amazing story, which I didn't know. I have watched the movie so many times, I've lost count. But I hadn't heard about Hook's life at Roukes Drift. Thank you again for another brilliant telling, Cheers
It is important to know the REAL Hook. But let's not get carried away. The film version of Hook was a highly flawed man who, despite all, emerged a hero who saved the lives of his mates...not bad at all...and let's not forget, the world knows who Hook is because of this characterization. Not many other Private Soldiers have his fame.
Thank you and I really enjoyed the video. I would have thought that the true story of Henry Hooks action would have been enough to satisfy the cinema goer. I wonder if the family ever got an apology from the film’s producers. It’s still one of my favourite films but I view it with a large pinch of salt.
Hi. I just found this video thank you for making this video. This man is actually a member of my family tree we still have the second name. And we are still extremely proud of our heritage. Very good video. 😊
Thanks so much for this wonderful (true version) story of Henry Hook's character and experience at Rorke's Drift in South Africa. I would never have guessed how differently his true person was to the movie's depiction. You have a very pleasant speaking voice and your videos are delightful and informative to watch. I'm glad your video appeared on the suggestion bar. Now subscribed.
Thank you very much for the subscription and I am glad that you enjoyed this video. Plenty more to come but in the meantime, please do check out my channel.
Dear Chris, as a 20 year student of the Zulu wars may I thank you for bringing Henry Hook's real story to the front. He was indeed a remarkable and brave man. I am sure you have read his own story but for viewers of this site, just before he died he was interviewed for Royal Magazine and the account of the battle - his very modest account - can be found online still (I believe because I read it many years ago) in 'Victorian Voices'. Also the account of Fred Hitch, another VC winner from the battle is there too. Maybe you could tell his story Chris, almost as remarkable a story after the battle as during it. And his grave, at St Nicholas, Chiswick is magnificent! Thanks again Chris. These were brave men, indeed.
Thanks for watching the video and I’m pleased you enjoyed it. I like your idea about Fred Hitch. I will add to my list. Please subscribe to my channel so you don’t miss it
A cup of tea after such trying experience must have tasted like nectar. Being old enough to remember seeing zulu at the cinema when it was new, the anti hero was a very popular development of the time, often used in different films of the period. The part of the Rorkes drift defence that always staggers me is that they knew over 4 thousand zulus were heading their way, so surely a retreat was in order? Call it running away, but no against all logic with no more than about 150 max they stood their ground & waited for the fearsome onslaught of a fierce & determined enemy, wow, beyond exemplary courage. Perhaps they had been ordered to hold the position or that they had a better chance in a defensive position of their choosing rather than engage in open country,without cavalry, Even so!
You raise a really good question, why stay I think the officers were persuaded by James Langley Dalton to stay because the Zulu would have overrun them if they were retreating in the open with the patients from the hospital slowing them down
Zulu is an amazing film, but I can never forgive the way they portrayed Private Hook. Thank you so much for telling his REAL story. Commissary James Dalton's heroism at the battle is also very badly served by the film, which barely features him at all. I'd love to hear you cover his story in a future episode.
Fun fact: while shooting Zulu by day James Booth was appearing in Hair in the evening, which is why how ever much you watch the film you will never see James Booth in an exterior shot.
A wonderful video, thank you for telling the true story of a humble hero. Why are we not hearing from the young society of today for an apology...no doubt because it it isn't PC
I absolutely love your program. I think it's really cool that in this day and age intelligent people are able to put things together and put it out for everyone to see instead of the usual crap you get from the corporations of public broadcasting or whatever
Thanks for clearing his name. And apologies from this American for the way the film industry treated him. They call it 'artistic license'. I call it dishonest. God save the King.
Regarding the film Zulu; in the pop culture of the time, the anti establishment 'rough lad' was very popular after films like 'Saturday night and Sunday morning' etc and even Michael Cain later playing 'Alfie'. I think they wanted a character like that in the film and Henry Hook just drew the short straw.
Thanks for this video. I felt sad hearing his fate, dying of TB after such long service, and a little angry at how badly the film had represented him, but you did Henry Hook's memory proud with this fine account. It seems that the film makers thought another straightforwardly heroic character would be uninteresting - CSM Bourne and, to some extent, the two commanding officers already play that role. But the historical character of Henry Hook is much more compelling to me than his unattractive screen portrayal, in part because it is authentic.
I assume you saw the documentary on "Zulu." I loved that documentary and you could feel for Hook's daughters. I also got a crack how Stanley Baker's son was in Star Wars. They paid homage to Baker by giving his son a line. Great stuff as always, Chris.
'Zulu'' 'The Great Escape', and many other movies based on history, great license is taken with the script. Maybe it is the price to be paid to get the movie made and people into the theater. The drama of the malingerer becoming the hero simply had more appeal than the real story. Such is life and the movie business.
You have some great books in the background there! Thanks for this insightful video. I loved Zulu but irs ashame the writers felt the need to fictionalise Hooks experience.
Does anyone know the reason why Hook was portrayed as he was in the movie Zulu? Did the producers or director of the movie ever explain this and did they ever apologize to the Hook family? Did they not know the real history of him? Well done to The History Chap for correcting this awful mistake done to this man.
I think they did it purely for the drama of the malingering, selfish lay about suddenly transformed into the brave and courageous Saviour of the injured.
It's for dramatic reasons. If everyone in a movie is an all-action, sparkly-toothed hero with flowing locks and a winning smile, it all becomes a bit samey. Hence you need 'characters' to make it work. If you can have a "bad boy made good" story in there as well, so much the better. Hook just happened to be the one who got the short end of the stick in that regard. Mind you, some of the others didn't do so well either. Poor Hitch is portrayed as something of a cross between Rodney Trotter and Private Pike, yet his courage, determination and tenacity during the battle (despite being seriously wounded) was legendary! And Christian Schiess just sort of wombles around whacking the odd Zulu with his crutch, wheras the real Schiess jumped off the barricade, down and in amongst the Zulu to clear them away from a strategic point, and then climbed back up and in again. We just have to remember that it's not a documentary!
I’m sure they knew the real story, but as some other people have pointed out in these comments, he might of come across as a much more boring character, find a fallen angel in the film
This is a copy of a post I've just made: Regarding the film Zulu; in the pop culture of the time, the anti establishment 'rough lad' was very popular after films like 'Saturday night and Sunday morning' etc and even Michael Cain later playing 'Alfie'. I think they wanted a character like that in the film and Henry Hook just drew the short straw.
Amazing damn film although it’s a classic tarnished Hooks real actions thank you sir for giving us this insight into his past and his heroic actions ❤ My mother said people with a kindly face and humbleness about their lives suffer the hardiest latter life. Ur carry on with a smile❤
I heard that it took a very long time for men to return from the Zulu war. Nowadays I believe it takes 7 years for a legal presumption of death. Hook was a Sergeant in G Coy 1st VB Royal Fusiliers in 1903. Headquarters Fitzroy Square. The battalion sent 650 men to camp at Shorncliffe for 14 days in 1902 and performed the usual drill and musketry. It had a machine gun team, cyclist company, signalling section and transport section. Also an excellent brass band with a strong muster of drums. The annual sub for Sgts was 7s 6d. This included membership of the Regimental club at HQ and Battersea with the use of billiard room, canteen and recreation room. Strength at the end of 1902 1056. The images of Hook wearing his VC show him in the uniform of the Royal Fusiliers, apparent from the distinctive collar badges.
Brilliant documentary as always! As someone becoming increasingly interested in the 19th century, I’ll definitely consider learning more about the Anglo-Zulu War! On the other hand, that’s quite the massive book collection behind you! Would you please make a video showcasing your book collection? Thank you!
I’m glad you’re enjoying my work. I’ve never thought about sharing my books on a video. You will have a real laugh if you saw my really poor standard of catalogue Ing them together!
Even in the film Hook wasn't a really bad guy. His character was rebellious, but when needed he did everything that was asked and more. His character had a great redemption arc. The movie wasn't a documentary.
Excellent! I heard about this man and was to put it politely furious about the way he's portrayed in the movie. I see they weren't overly generous either, he should have been given a pension after his service. There's a saying that I heard some time ago but I don't know where it originated, it goes "when wars are won and wrongs are righted, the soldiers forgotten and often slighted. RIP 🙏 🕯 Mr Hook.
Lots of inaccuracies in this film: 1. At the time of the Zulu wars (and Rorke's Drift) the 24th Regiment of Foot was the 2nd Warwickshire Regiment - 2/24th - (pronounced 'Wor-ick-sher' for our American friends) and was not the South Wales Borderers. Some years after the film's events the Army reorganised it's regimental numbering system and the regimental number '24th' was allocated to the South Wales Borderers. The film's Producer, Stanley Baker, a fanatical Welsh Nationalist, decided to make the Warwickshire Regiment a Welsh Regiment for the film and with a fake Welsh Choir. 2. The singing of Men of Harlech never happened. The Zulus singing at the end did not happen either. 3. The Boer named Adendorff that the film had advising Bromhead and Chard was not present at the battle. He was a real character, but he fled from Isandlwana just before the battle, and fled from Rorke's drift just before the battle. He was eventually caught and hanged. 4. The missionary, de Witt, left Rorke's Drift before the battle, and he was not a drunk. 5. Bromhead was not a young aristocrat. He was elderly for a lieutenant, had a bushy beard, was pretty deaf, and was considered a duffer by the regimental officers, which was why he was left at Rorke's Drift. 6. The historical Colour Sergeant Bourne was 24 during the defence of Rorke's Drift (Nigel Green, who played him, was 40). There are many more inaccuracies in the film, which also allowed Michael Caine to virtue signal in his autobiography; however it is an excellent and exciting film, and was one of the first two films my father took me to see in the station cinema in Manorbier Camp when I was 7. The other film was The 300 Spartans, and both inspired a lifelong interest in history. However, both films prove that you should never learn history from Hollywood (or the BBC)!!
Thanks for taking the time to share your insights and comparisons. On a minor point, most historians nowadays agree that Ardendorff was there. He was actually mentioned in Chard’s report of the battle.
Another excellent video. Glad to hear you're also a fan of Flashman, one of my all time favourite characters!😀 And I notice you also have a lot of Bernard Cornwell books on your shelves, particulalry his famous series about Sharpes rifles who many people will know from the TV series with Sean Bean. N.B For anyone interested some other good authors of historical fiction from this period of history include: - Allan Mallinson and his stories of his hero Matthew Hervey in the Light Dragoons. - John Wlicox and his hero Simon Fonthill. - Iain Gale. For stories about the Royal Navy many people will be aware of: - C.S Forresters famous Hornblower series, also made into a TV drama - Patrick O'briens Aubrey/Maturin series, one of which was made into the film 'Mater & Commander' with Russell Crowe and Paul Bettany. Two other naval authors that are less well known and I consider just as good are: - Alexander Kent's Richard Bolitho series. - Julian Stockwin's Thomas Kydd series. There are also many excellent historical fiction authors covering different periods of history, especially the roman empire, but many other historical periods too.
Gosh, thanks for that list of historical writers. It would be quite good to make some videos comparing the stories to historic facts. Maybe one for the future
@TheHistoryChap looking forward to the episode, Cheers! It's great learning about the real life characters . The film is really nostalgic for me and I love the history of the Zulu Wars
It’s been a mad one so far for me, setting up the live, writing my weekly newsletter for my mailing list (join at my website), to UA-cam shorts, and a visit to the bank!
I heard the true story of ‘Hooky’ on a guided tour of Rorke’s drift, he, like the others, except Bromhead and Chard, were top class professionals, thank heavens for Colour Sergeant Bourne
I heard a tale that the portrayal of the cook in Zulu by Kerry Jordan "Shall I put the soup on the fires, Sir"? , was a nod in the direction of the true character of Henry Hook VC.
I've watched Zulu numerous times and wondered. If Hook was such a self centered skiver and did what he did during the attack in the hospital. It didn't make sense. You have answered my doubts. Thank you.
A similar character assassination happened to the character of Commander Denniston (played by Charles Dance) in The Imitation Game. It is a knave's trick to play fast and loose with facts in order to tell a good tale. I loved both films, but they leave a bitter taste in the mouth.
Thanks Chris. Strange that the producers and writers used Henry so badly. The story is extraordinary in itself without the need for false tales of those brave men. We have so few heroes these days that it is well we remember our past ones as they were and not as mammon would make them. Rest well, Henry Hook; we remember you, too.
They wanted an anti-hero who redeems himself.
Thanks for taking the time to both watch and then comment. If you haven’t already, please subscribe to my channel so that I can grow here on UA-cam.
My all time favourite film, saw it when I was eleven. Most of it not accurate, a figment of baker's imagination!
A Tee Totalling Soldier was just boring. This was Hollywood
His great grandsons a right lickle tinker by all accounts 😮
What a marvellous chap. Seriously maligned by the film, which is a real shame... no wonder his family walked out in disgust.
Another masterly history lesson, Chris. Well done !
Thank you so much for watching and I’m glad you enjoyed it
Should be a floggin offence , maligning good ole Hooky @@TheHistoryChap
What exactly did Hookie do in the movie to get punished? He sent money to his Wife?
Pretty Polly Perkins didnt ripen at noon@@tomtaylor6163
Family should have sued???
I have loved "Zulu" since the first time I watched it! Thanks so much for bringing the truth of this brave soldier to light. Dramatic license is one thing but this besmirching of Hook's reputation, especially while his descendants have had to live with the view portrayed in the film is quite unfair.
Still a great film though
@TheHistoryChap Oh, without a doubt! I was delighted when the 50th Anniversary Blu-ray was issued. Wide-screen is the only way to go! "And a bayonet.. with some guts behind it!" 😉👍
BTW, have you done a video yet about Color Sergeant Bourne? I seem to remember reading somewhere that he wasn't awarded the VC as he opted for an award a step down and the Queen's Commission.
"He lives twice who enjoys history." 😉
The truth isn't relevant and the film doesn't claim to be factual as i`m pretty sure there was no rousting rendition of Men Of Harlech either ....the real Hook was a hero but the film Hook imo was as well
@@wildfire160defamation of caricature
Love a young Michael Caine! My youth was watching classic movies while my parents had embassy dinner parties.@@TheHistoryChap
Such a shame a very brave and courageous man was so wrongly depicted in a film that so many people have now seen and so many will see in the future! Thank you for another great story and stay well.
Thanks for watching and for taking the time to comment
It really was outrageous when you think of it how they could malign such a decent hero, I have never liked that character in the film and I think it let it down. May you rest in peace you fine gentleman 🙏
Thanks for watching my video and for taking the time to comment
The trouble is our usual love of the fairy story - the idea of the likeable rough diamond, come good in the end. The fact that he was a good guy to start with didn't fit that easy stereotype sadly, so the producers messed about with a decent man's reputation.
But the film inspires the audience to research the true histories. I am pleased the character is portrayed the way he is in the film.
He has the greatest anti racist Line
“Has a Zulu ever walked up the King’s Road”, questioning why the British were in SA.
It is a Film! Not a documentary.
Loved the character and love just finding out the truth and what kind of person he really was!
Is that a real picture of his funeral? Incredible. What a crowd for a sergeant who was still a private when he won his VC. Today a general couldn't draw such a crowd. It shows how much Britons valued their soldiers back then.
We've fallen far since then...
Yes, that is a picture of his real funeral cortege
@@TheHistoryChap amazing.
great episode setting the record straight on Hook. thanks for telling the story.
Hitch's funeral was something else. He became a hackney carriage driver when he left the army and for his funeral, just about every London Hackney carriage took part in a miles-long cortege that brought the city to a standstill.
@@TheHistoryChap One notices the difference in how he was honoured after death compared to life.
@@aaropajari7058 that's a thing too
Thank you Chris number for setting the record straight with Private Hook. I am sure his spirit is looking down on you and smiling, thanking you for being one of the most ardent defenders. Truly I have always enjoyed your meticulous preparation and dedication to subject matter, bravo amigo 👏 🙌
I’m glad you found it interesting. Thanks for watching Harry.
He was the brother of my Grandmother Rose Hook grandfather from Stourbridge. His daughters attended the Zulu film premiere and were far from happy. Thanks for posting. I will share it with my family.
Always good to find family connections. Someone related to Fred Hitch VC has commented on one of my other Rorke’s drift videos to
Such a wonderful film. I saw it first time with my Father, and immediately fell in love with the story. For Christmas, my Father presented me with a History Book, which gave a full account of the Battle and the men involved. Oh my goodness. I was heartbroken. Ye gods, to say the film had taken liberties was an understatement. Nevertheless, I still love the way the film portrays the tale. What harm is there in using a little fiction to embellish a true event? Thank you for this defence of Henry Hook.
Glad you enjoyed this video, and I am glad that you are a fan of Zulu. It is still a great film.
"What harm is there in using a little fiction to embellish a true event? " ..... Hmmmmm... WHAT HARM is there in DESTROYING a man's reputation? Let's tell some "embellishments" about YOU and see how and your family like it.
@@williampawson5476 I get you. When did you learn the truth? I was 16 and it broke my heart. Yes, I agree with you. Most of the time a Film does not reflect actual history. Even the most accurate historical epics will distort the facts to build a better narrative. My rhetorical question was not to justify these acts, but to challenge how we learn history. Films are there to entertain, not to educate.
Gee, has been a few months since I first time saw the movie of 'Zulu' for myself at long last, gonna have to do so again, but in the meantime I certainly must thank you again for this great and very well done truth and honesty spilling history lesson on another great British military hero of the Battle of Rourke's Drift, Chris dear chap. Well it's no wonder Hook's two daughters walked outta the premiere of the movie when it came out, to have their dear dad portrayed like THAT, when you've given us the REAL Captain Henry Hook VC here, a man who sure was a true hero at the real battle that day in 1879, and continued to be a true Victorian gentleman in the years afterwards, AND a NON drinker unlike what the movie does rather dirty with. If ever we know someone who certainly knows EXACTLY what to give with certain need to know facts about British military conflicts and individuals who are true heroes indeed, it's YOU, dear boy 😊😊😊👍👍👍
Thank you very much. What I wanted to do was tell his real story. I do however, except that films or stories and they need human interest in them. Hooke was portrayed as a fallen character, who soared like an Eagle, when his comrades were in trouble
Hook was never a Captain. That is not to take anything from him both as a soldier and a man, but he was not commissioned.
An extraordinary hero indeed, badly portraited in Zulu, but it was for "cinematic" sake, Hook was a great example of a man, for all times and ages. Thanks for sharing.
I tend to agree with you. At the end of the day, it was a film, not a documentary, and the story of Hook in that film is a story of redemption.
Thank you for the correct account of history. It is astonishing that most people take the film as the true account of what happened and throughout history this has happened time and time again
I’m glad you enjoyed this video. If you haven’t already, please do subscribe to my channel.
Great video, Chris. I knew that Hook had been maligned but good to see the full back story. I'm an ex-Loggie and always felt that James Langley Dalton didn't get a great shake in the film either.
He actually took charge of the action being a veteran regular and the officers being actually useless.
Maybe I should do a video about Dalton too
@@josephturner7569
If my memory serves me well, Garnet Wolsley was less than impressed that Chard and Bromhead received VC's for just doing their jobs.
@Wotsitorlabart the government decided they needed hero's after Chelmsfords disaster earlier getting a regiment and it's attached troops massacred
Why am I not surprised at the "Movie Industries" mishandling of the 'Truth'? It's what they do (Lies, make believe, & BS) Which is a shame, as the truth is often more exciting. Sadly they are unwilling/unable to do so. Thanks for setting the record straight.
Thank you for taking the time to watch my video
Excellent video Chris. I think Cy Endfield wanted a lovable rogue character and got this completely wrong. Hook was a very brave man and his defending and saving patients in the hospital was magnificent. Also false, I believe, was the British soldiers singing! That said I still feel the hairs standing up on the back of my neck whenever I hear Ivor Emmanual (Private Owen) leading the men singing Men of Harlech as they face the Zulu charge. Fantastic moment. Fantastic film!
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. By the way, if you enjoy my work, please make sure you subscribe to my channel.
@@TheHistoryChap Yep Men of Harlech is never a British song as the lyrics are very much anti English and is still sung at Welsh sports fans today and by Welsh troops in the British army.
I did say the event did not happen but enjoyed the part of the film when true Welshmen faced Zulus not the English. I have the utmost respect for the Welsh servicemen and a highlight for me was when visiting the Somme battlefield I went to Mametz Wood. I felt privaleged to walk across that field past the 38th memorial and into the woods itself. Looking around imagining Welshmen fighting magnificently against a very strong German opposition. Welshmen are great fighters and I am glad they are on our side. @@timphillips9954
Also, of course, it wasn't a Welsh regiment. The '1st Warwicks' became 'The Welsh Borderers' some time after Rourke's Drift. There may well have been many Welsh in the regiment, but I doubt they would have been singing 'Men of Harlech!' But hey, it's a film, not history!@@timphillips9954
@@georgepayne9895 Usually an Englishman with an inferiority complex brings up this point, lol.
Thank you for an honest representation of Henry Hook. "Zulu" was in several respects historically flawed and often due to Stanley Baker's Welsh origins driving his personal preference. Nigel Green's portrayal of "Colour Sergeant Bourne" was another inaccuracy. However .... I do love the film !!! :)
Still possibly my favourite war movie, although Khartoum is pretty good too
What a delightful story. Mr. Green is a captivating storyteller. His accuracy and attention to detail is uncannily. Well done, History Chap!
Thank you so much for that compliment. I don’t know if you have already, but please do subscribe to my channel
@@TheHistoryChap
Done. Over a year ago.
One thing I can’t stand is a digital narrator. It’s so fake.
I do love history so and you, sir, are my new favorite person to tell it. Back in the day, I enjoyed listening to Alex Scott and his narration of “Wings of the Luftwaffe”. Robert Powell is another fine gentleman of narration. We Americans sadly, don’t have a story teller that even comes close to your quality, sir.
Peace be within thy walls.
I think Henry's movie depiction makes him more memorable. He was definitely one of the stand out characters, if not the most, and a more historically accurate version may not have had this effect? Wonderful movie, and probably the reason why a lot of us are here
Yes, it’s interesting, I bet most of us can’t name all the other VC recipients because some of them weren’t as colourful as Hook in the film
Aye, just bitterly brave men, known but to family and God...and their mates.
Thank you for putting the record straight.
You tell these important stories very well and have me captivated.
Very kind of you. If you haven’t already, please do subscribe to my channel.
Great video. This is the type of situation where when you've never looked into the finer details, you don't know if the character was based on a real man or if he was a fictional character to engage with the historical figures. Great to know that he was real and even better that his true story be told. I listen to a variety of audiobooks, changing from one genre to another to keep things fresh. I'm currently listening to a book on the Lancaster Bomber, I've already listed to ones covering Bomber Command itself and one specifically on the Dambuster Raid. No man is perfect, but I hear some incredible stories from men who maintained a level of dignity under circumstances that would break a modern man. Many of those men were incredibly young.
Yes, we forget just how young some of these men were. When you look at the photos, they seem older than their years
I just thought Henry was a lovable person. He won the VC, so I just took his character in the movie as poetic licence.
His courage did shine through in the movie at the end, saving his fellow soldiers. It's a movie, not a documentary.
Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts
Another excellent production, and thank you for setting the record straight for Henry Hook. Keep up the good work.
I’m glad you enjoyed it
I never knew the fact Henry was so misrepresented by the film, what a miscarriage of justice. The truth would have made an equally good story. I loved the passion and enthusiasm of the presentation. Thank you very much
I’m glad you found it interesting, and thank you so much for taking the time to comment
I’m glad that I had already read about Hook and knew about his maligning in “Zulu” (still a superb movie!). Nonetheless, this was an excellent presentation…as usual!
Very kind of you. Thanks for watching. If you haven’t already, please subscribe to my channel
Thank you Chris for this important piece of history! These small details make a lot more interesting I say !All the best from Northern Germany Ludwig.
Hi Ludwig, I’m glad you enjoyed the video. If you haven’t already, please do subscribe to my channel and maybe even sign up to my newsletter at my website.
David Rattray, who did the most stunning series of lectures on the Anglo Zulu wars all the way from Isandlwana to Ulundi, was the first one I heard undoing the damage the film did to his reputation and it is lovely to see this channel spreading the good word too.
A great storyteller
This is my favourite video on UA-cam! The fact that Hook was a cook absolutely gob smacked me. Retired Canadian Forces cook, and him looking after his boys making tea after the battle is fitting.
I’m glad you enjoyed the video, thanks so much for watching
Thank you for making this video. It is a wonderful thing you are doing bringing the true stories of these courageous men to light.
Glad you enjoyed my video
Good that some one has set the record straight. Thank you.
Thanks for watching my video
Chris...once again, thank you so much for putting the reality of Private Hook FIRMLY at rest.
My Great Grandfather...JOHN WILLIAM FIELDING V.C., (aka: John Williams), never mentioned Henry Hook, apparently, as ALL those at the Battle were there not only to save themselves but those unfortunate to be infirm, within the Hospital.
My Great Grandfather's Hair actually turned SILVER/WHITE a few short Months after the Battle, obviously due to the actions endured. G.A.R.
So pleased that you enjoyed watching this film. Is the pub named after your great grandfather still open?
@@TheHistoryChap It most certainly is, Chris. WETHERSPOONS own and maintain it. Stay safe friend...G.A.R.
Thank you Sir. Being a Yank I know very little about English millitary affairs except of course our Revolutionary War and the War of 1812. The movie Zulu has always been one of my favorites since I was a kid. And as always movies are rarely without their creative manipulations which spoils most films for me. Sooo that is why you are here to set the story straight. Thank you again.
I’m glad you enjoyed this video, many thanks for watching
Thanks so very much for this video Chris! As a high school-educated working man (now retired) with a passion for history, I am very grateful for your channel as it gives me an opportunity to learn more about British history. Whether civil or military, I watch all your videos when they post whilst catching up on your previous work! Thanks mate and keep it coming! 🇬🇧👍🙂
Many thanks, glad you enjoyed my video.
I knew his descendants were not happy with the films portrayal of Henry Hook. Makes you wonder why the filmmakers did this to such a fine gentleman, soldier and family man. God bless you Henry Hook VC. Fantastic video, many thanks.
Thank you for watching and for taking the time to comment. If you haven’t already, please subscribe to my channel.
A shame that the studio, writers, director, and all involved would allow such an historical, and personal, travesty to be put to film for generations to see.
Thank you for watching my video and for taking the time to comment
'This week' in british history always gets me thinking about the bigger picture.The most interesting history lesons in the world.Fair play.
Doing another one on Friday at 11am (UK)
Thanks for setting the the record straight on this remarkable gentleman.
My pleasure thanks for watching
This is one of the things that you are introduced through film and then you find out the true story is so much better a man among men rest in peace.
Thanks for watching my video
Thank you for sharing this. What a magnificent hero truly done wrong by a movie. It's great you are here to inform us and present it so well.
That’s very kind of you. If you enjoy my work, please make sure that you subscribe to my channel for more videos.
Thank you Chris for this most needed and timely reckoning.
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for watching.
Thank you, Chris, that was an amazing story, which I didn't know. I have watched the movie so many times, I've lost count. But I hadn't heard about Hook's life at Roukes Drift. Thank you again for another brilliant telling, Cheers
Glad you enjoyed it
The conflict was “Rorke’s Drift.” And why did you not know the full story beforehand? It has been well documented.
It is important to know the REAL Hook. But let's not get carried away. The film version of Hook was a highly flawed man who, despite all, emerged a hero who saved the lives of his mates...not bad at all...and let's not forget, the world knows who Hook is because of this characterization. Not many other Private Soldiers have his fame.
I tend to agree with your point of view
I doubt his ancestors would agree with your languid shrug of the shoulders.
@@Avid_Fan And Hook isn't being honoured by anyone's self-righteousness.
And surely you mean descendants.
Thank you and I really enjoyed the video. I would have thought that the true story of Henry Hooks action would have been enough to satisfy the cinema goer. I wonder if the family ever got an apology from the film’s producers. It’s still one of my favourite films but I view it with a large pinch of salt.
Yes, a large prints of sort it is still a great film and let’s not forget it has got so many people interested in the Zulu war
Wonderful work - yet again - most informative and enlightening. Thank you, Chris.
Many thanks, Peter
Hi. I just found this video thank you for making this video. This man is actually a member of my family tree we still have the second name. And we are still extremely proud of our heritage.
Very good video. 😊
Thanks for watching my video & for taking the time to share your family story.
Thanks so much for this wonderful (true version) story of Henry Hook's character and experience at Rorke's Drift in South Africa. I would never have guessed how differently his true person was to the movie's depiction. You have a very pleasant speaking voice and your videos are delightful and informative to watch. I'm glad your video appeared on the suggestion bar. Now subscribed.
Thank you very much for the subscription and I am glad that you enjoyed this video. Plenty more to come but in the meantime, please do check out my channel.
Dear Chris, as a 20 year student of the Zulu wars may I thank you for bringing Henry Hook's real story to the front. He was indeed a remarkable and brave man. I am sure you have read his own story but for viewers of this site, just before he died he was interviewed for Royal Magazine and the account of the battle - his very modest account - can be found online still (I believe because I read it many years ago) in 'Victorian Voices'. Also the account of Fred Hitch, another VC winner from the battle is there too. Maybe you could tell his story Chris, almost as remarkable a story after the battle as during it. And his grave, at St Nicholas, Chiswick is magnificent! Thanks again Chris. These were brave men, indeed.
Thanks for watching the video and I’m pleased you enjoyed it. I like your idea about Fred Hitch. I will add to my list. Please subscribe to my channel so you don’t miss it
A fantastic story, thanks for sharing the truth about this valiant man😊
My pleasure, thanks for watching
Wow! Thank you for sharing this.
Glad you enjoyed it!
A cup of tea after such trying experience must have tasted like nectar. Being old enough to remember seeing zulu at the cinema when it was new, the anti hero was a very popular development of the time, often used in different films of the period.
The part of the Rorkes drift defence that always staggers me is that they knew over 4 thousand zulus were heading their way, so surely a retreat was in order? Call it running away, but no against all logic with no more than about 150 max they stood their ground & waited for the fearsome onslaught of a fierce & determined enemy, wow, beyond exemplary courage.
Perhaps they had been ordered to hold the position or that they had a better chance in a defensive position of their choosing rather than engage in open country,without cavalry, Even so!
You raise a really good question, why stay I think the officers were persuaded by James Langley Dalton to stay because the Zulu would have overrun them if they were retreating in the open with the patients from the hospital slowing them down
Zulu is an amazing film, but I can never forgive the way they portrayed Private Hook. Thank you so much for telling his REAL story.
Commissary James Dalton's heroism at the battle is also very badly served by the film, which barely features him at all. I'd love to hear you cover his story in a future episode.
Thanks for watching and I’m glad you enjoyed this story. If you haven’t already, please do subscribe to my channel.
Thank you for great video again and giving the correct story of this fine man.
Salute
Many thanks, and I’m glad you enjoyed it
You know, I don't think I've seen the film, but you make all these stories so fascinating, well done
That’s very kind of you. Thanks for watching my videos and for supporting my work.
Why haven’t you seen the film? Why didn’t you watch it when it was released in 1964?
Good on you for setting the record straight! A most enjoyable talk.
Really glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for watching please do subscribe to my channel if you haven’t already so you don’t miss future videos
@@TheHistoryChap subscribed when I first came across your excellent videos!
New to your channel,and wow, i really enjoy listening.This story about Hook was really touching.
Thanks, glad you enjoyed it.
Thank you so much for this Chris
My pleasure! Thanks for watching
Fun fact: while shooting Zulu by day James Booth was appearing in Hair in the evening, which is why how ever much you watch the film you will never see James Booth in an exterior shot.
Interesting. Thanks for sharing.
A wonderful video, thank you for telling the true story of a humble hero. Why are we not hearing from the young society of today for an apology...no doubt because it it isn't PC
Thank you so much for taking the time to watch my video and also to post a comment
James Booth used to come in to the cafe I worked in in London back in the 90s! A very nice and humble man!
Nice little story, thanks for sharing
I absolutely love your program. I think it's really cool that in this day and age intelligent people are able to put things together and put it out for everyone to see instead of the usual crap you get from the corporations of public broadcasting or whatever
That’s very kind of you. If you haven’t already, please make sure you subscribe to my channel.
Thanks for clearing his name. And apologies from this American for the way the film industry treated him. They call it 'artistic license'. I call it dishonest. God save the King.
I’m glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks very much for watching.
Regarding the film Zulu; in the pop culture of the time, the anti establishment 'rough lad' was very popular after films like 'Saturday night and Sunday morning' etc
and even Michael Cain later playing 'Alfie'. I think they wanted a character like that in the film and Henry Hook just drew the short straw.
That’s really interesting observation, thanks for taking the time to share
Correct I think but why malign someone in the process? why not just make up a character?
Thank you for sharing this insightful story.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Thanks for this video. I felt sad hearing his fate, dying of TB after such long service, and a little angry at how badly the film had represented him, but you did Henry Hook's memory proud with this fine account. It seems that the film makers thought another straightforwardly heroic character would be uninteresting - CSM Bourne and, to some extent, the two commanding officers already play that role. But the historical character of Henry Hook is much more compelling to me than his unattractive screen portrayal, in part because it is authentic.
I have made a video about CSM Bourne. Have a look for it on my channel.
Hi Chris , wow whot a great story about the real truth ... Whot great work chris , thank you ... Cheers Si
That’s very kind of you, thanks
I assume you saw the documentary on "Zulu." I loved that documentary and you could feel for Hook's daughters. I also got a crack how Stanley Baker's son was in Star Wars. They paid homage to Baker by giving his son a line. Great stuff as always, Chris.
I’m glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching and for your support
Actually the truth of Hook was far more interesting than what was portrayed in the film despite how much i enjoyed it.
Thank you for taking the time to watch my video
That was an amazing and enlightening story thank you
My pleasure. If you haven’t already, please subscribe to my channel.
Love any content related to this battle!
I’m glad you enjoyed it
'Zulu'' 'The Great Escape', and many other movies based on history, great license is taken with the script. Maybe it is the price to be paid to get the movie made and people into the theater. The drama of the malingerer becoming the hero simply had more appeal than the real story. Such is life and the movie business.
At the end of the day, filmmakers need to get as many people watching as possible
First saw Zulu living in Japan..went with friends...what a cool movie
Still one of my favourites after all these years
An accurate portrayal of Zulu would be a documentary as is this. One must remember this was a film and a damn good one at that .
At the end of the day, films of stories, not documentaries
Fantastic as ever. Such a great channel thank you.
I’m glad you enjoyed it. Please make sure you subscribe to my channel if you haven’t already
You have some great books in the background there!
Thanks for this insightful video. I loved Zulu but irs ashame the writers felt the need to fictionalise Hooks experience.
I can’t get enough of history books wish I hadn’t thrown some of my old ones away
Does anyone know the reason why Hook was portrayed as he was in the movie Zulu? Did the producers or director of the movie ever explain this and did they ever apologize to the Hook family? Did they not know the real history of him? Well done to The History Chap for correcting this awful mistake done to this man.
I think they did it purely for the drama of the malingering, selfish lay about suddenly transformed into the brave and courageous Saviour of the injured.
It's for dramatic reasons. If everyone in a movie is an all-action, sparkly-toothed hero with flowing locks and a winning smile, it all becomes a bit samey. Hence you need 'characters' to make it work. If you can have a "bad boy made good" story in there as well, so much the better.
Hook just happened to be the one who got the short end of the stick in that regard.
Mind you, some of the others didn't do so well either. Poor Hitch is portrayed as something of a cross between Rodney Trotter and Private Pike, yet his courage, determination and tenacity during the battle (despite being seriously wounded) was legendary!
And Christian Schiess just sort of wombles around whacking the odd Zulu with his crutch, wheras the real Schiess jumped off the barricade, down and in amongst the Zulu to clear them away from a strategic point, and then climbed back up and in again.
We just have to remember that it's not a documentary!
I’m sure they knew the real story, but as some other people have pointed out in these comments, he might of come across as a much more boring character, find a fallen angel in the film
This is a copy of a post I've just made:
Regarding the film Zulu; in the pop culture of the time, the anti establishment 'rough lad' was very popular after films like 'Saturday night and Sunday morning' etc
and even Michael Cain later playing 'Alfie'. I think they wanted a character like that in the film and Henry Hook just drew the short straw.
@@shirleymental4189 Ah, now that's a very well thought-out idea. I think you might well be right.
Amazing damn film although it’s a classic tarnished Hooks real actions thank you sir for giving us this insight into his past and his heroic actions ❤
My mother said people with a kindly face and humbleness about their lives suffer the hardiest latter life. Ur carry on with a smile❤
I’m glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for sharing your mothers words of wisdom too
I heard that it took a very long time for men to return from the Zulu war. Nowadays I believe it takes 7 years for a legal presumption of death.
Hook was a Sergeant in G Coy 1st VB Royal Fusiliers in 1903. Headquarters Fitzroy Square. The battalion sent 650 men to camp at Shorncliffe for 14 days in 1902 and performed the usual drill and musketry. It had a machine gun team, cyclist company, signalling section and transport section. Also an excellent brass band with a strong muster of drums. The annual sub for Sgts was 7s 6d. This included membership of the Regimental club at HQ and Battersea with the use of billiard room, canteen and recreation room. Strength at the end of 1902 1056. The images of Hook wearing his VC show him in the uniform of the Royal Fusiliers, apparent from the distinctive collar badges.
Thank you for taking the time to add this valuable information
Really enjoyed this interesting and informative video. Shows you never stop learning the truth from myth. Thanks.
Glad you enjoyed it
Brilliant documentary as always! As someone becoming increasingly interested in the 19th century, I’ll definitely consider learning more about the Anglo-Zulu War!
On the other hand, that’s quite the massive book collection behind you! Would you please make a video showcasing your book collection? Thank you!
I’m glad you’re enjoying my work. I’ve never thought about sharing my books on a video. You will have a real laugh if you saw my really poor standard of catalogue Ing them together!
Even in the film Hook wasn't a really bad guy. His character was rebellious, but when needed he did everything that was asked and more. His character had a great redemption arc. The movie wasn't a documentary.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on the film and Hook’s character
Thanks for this. How they portrayed Hook was despicable.
Thanks for watching my video
Excellent! I heard about this man and was to put it politely furious about the way he's portrayed in the movie. I see they weren't overly generous either, he should have been given a pension after his service. There's a saying that I heard some time ago but I don't know where it originated, it goes "when wars are won and wrongs are righted, the soldiers forgotten and often slighted. RIP 🙏 🕯 Mr Hook.
Thanks for watching my video and for taking the time to post a comment
Wonderful thanks for sharing the story of this amazing man.
Thanks for listening
My Dad had a Zulu Wars VHS documentary. It had dramatisations, one of which showed Hook, sitting by candlelight, reading his Bible.
I haven’t seen that one, very interesting
That was super interesting, great job
Glad you enjoyed it
Lots of inaccuracies in this film:
1. At the time of the Zulu wars (and Rorke's Drift) the 24th Regiment of Foot was the 2nd Warwickshire Regiment - 2/24th - (pronounced 'Wor-ick-sher' for our American friends) and was not the South Wales Borderers. Some years after the film's events the Army reorganised it's regimental numbering system and the regimental number '24th' was allocated to the South Wales Borderers. The film's Producer, Stanley Baker, a fanatical Welsh Nationalist, decided to make the Warwickshire Regiment a Welsh Regiment for the film and with a fake Welsh Choir.
2. The singing of Men of Harlech never happened. The Zulus singing at the end did not happen either.
3. The Boer named Adendorff that the film had advising Bromhead and Chard was not present at the battle. He was a real character, but he fled from Isandlwana just before the battle, and fled from Rorke's drift just before the battle. He was eventually caught and hanged.
4. The missionary, de Witt, left Rorke's Drift before the battle, and he was not a drunk.
5. Bromhead was not a young aristocrat. He was elderly for a lieutenant, had a bushy beard, was pretty deaf, and was considered a duffer by the regimental officers, which was why he was left at Rorke's Drift.
6. The historical Colour Sergeant Bourne was 24 during the defence of Rorke's Drift (Nigel Green, who played him, was 40).
There are many more inaccuracies in the film, which also allowed Michael Caine to virtue signal in his autobiography; however it is an excellent and exciting film, and was one of the first two films my father took me to see in the station cinema in Manorbier Camp when I was 7. The other film was The 300 Spartans, and both inspired a lifelong interest in history. However, both films prove that you should never learn history from Hollywood (or the BBC)!!
Thanks for taking the time to share your insights and comparisons. On a minor point, most historians nowadays agree that Ardendorff was there. He was actually mentioned in Chard’s report of the battle.
@@TheHistoryChap Ok, I am in error, but always good to know so thanks for that.
Wonderful tribute to a solid Victorian soldier. Thank you.
My pleasure thanks for watching
Visited Henry Hooks grave in 1999 and when doing my family tree found my Great uncles Wife lived next door to him when a child in 1851. Rob White.
Fascinating, thanks for sharing
As always a very well told story,well done sir!
That’s very kind of you, thanks. Not sure if you have already, but please subscribe to my channel
Another excellent video.
Glad to hear you're also a fan of Flashman, one of my all time favourite characters!😀
And I notice you also have a lot of Bernard Cornwell books on your shelves, particulalry his famous series about Sharpes rifles who many people will know from the TV series with Sean Bean.
N.B For anyone interested some other good authors of historical fiction from this period of history include:
- Allan Mallinson and his stories of his hero Matthew Hervey in the Light Dragoons.
- John Wlicox and his hero Simon Fonthill.
- Iain Gale.
For stories about the Royal Navy many people will be aware of:
- C.S Forresters famous Hornblower series, also made into a TV drama
- Patrick O'briens Aubrey/Maturin series, one of which was made into the film 'Mater & Commander' with Russell Crowe and Paul Bettany.
Two other naval authors that are less well known and I consider just as good are:
- Alexander Kent's Richard Bolitho series.
- Julian Stockwin's Thomas Kydd series.
There are also many excellent historical fiction authors covering different periods of history, especially the roman empire, but many other historical periods too.
Gosh, thanks for that list of historical writers. It would be quite good to make some videos comparing the stories to historic facts. Maybe one for the future
He was a great character in Zulu but the film was unfair to the real Henry Hook
Yes, on both counts
@TheHistoryChap looking forward to the episode, Cheers! It's great learning about the real life characters . The film is really nostalgic for me and I love the history of the Zulu Wars
I have lost count how many time's i've seen this film, now Hook was not a lazy drunk😡 one of my number one film.
Thanks for watching my video
The day just got interesting😁😁😁
It’s been a mad one so far for me, setting up the live, writing my weekly newsletter for my mailing list (join at my website), to UA-cam shorts, and a visit to the bank!
I heard the true story of ‘Hooky’ on a guided tour of Rorke’s drift, he, like the others, except Bromhead and Chard, were top class professionals, thank heavens for Colour Sergeant Bourne
Thanks for taking the time to post your comment.
I heard a tale that the portrayal of the cook in Zulu by Kerry Jordan "Shall I put the soup on the fires, Sir"? , was a nod in the direction of the true character of Henry Hook VC.
Thanks for your feedback
I've watched Zulu numerous times and wondered. If Hook was such a self centered skiver and did what he did during the attack in the hospital. It didn't make sense. You have answered my doubts. Thank you.
Thanks for watching my video, glad you enjoyed it.
Superb work Sir. ... A sad legacy of Hollywood
Thank you for watching and also taking the time to comment. If you haven’t already, please make sure you subscribe to my channel
Nicely constructed piece.
Thank you very much
The movie really did him a disservice and blighted the historical record of a true hero.
Thank you for taking the time to watch my video
Thanks for this informative video
My pleasure
A similar character assassination happened to the character of Commander Denniston (played by Charles Dance) in The Imitation Game. It is a knave's trick to play fast and loose with facts in order to tell a good tale.
I loved both films, but they leave a bitter taste in the mouth.
Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts. Merry Christmas