Two points: First, free speech is not an unequivocal right here. Being racist is a crime. Being homophobic is a crime. Being a nazi is a crime. Brazil is not the US and it's worked fine for us, just the same as much of Europe. Second, Twitter's ban here is about them operating without legal representation. Twitter can return to Brazil whenever they feel like, all they need to do is actually follow our laws
no, lady. They order to block profiles commiting CRIMES. And it's not the president who orders, it's Jusice. You got 3 powers wll defined in brazilian government. In the brazilian law you have free speech, but as any other crime if you comit a crime your right is suspended or cancelled. You have the right to circulate freely, but if you comit a crime and you go to jail your right is suspended till you pay for your crime. You got the right to drive but if you drive drunk and you crash, the justicer suspends that right. It happens everywere all the time.
@@gringossa crime of opinion? Because Alexandre de Moraes ordered the profiles of a teenager and a republican senator to be blocked, simply because they posted criticisms of his conduct. In addition to other profiles of right-wing politicians, organized crime, drug dealers and murderers can publish freely. And the most sinister thing is that he does this with the excuse that he is protecting democracy, but in reality he is defending himself.
@@gringossagood response! It beats me to see how much nonsense Fox spews at its audience. They do not even mention the actual reason for blocking X in Brazil.
Supporting censorship because it’s run by a guy you don’t agree with politically or like. If this was instagram or TikTok you wouldn’t be saying this. People supporting this are crazy.
I you only listen to American media. You don't know anything about the case, loll he insults the judge call him every siihhhtttt name American are so idiots
Eff off. The far right wants to prohibit same sex marriage , abortion, Marijuama, free speech ! Stop the nonsense. Far right wants to establish evangelical ministers in Brazil to legislate according to Their beliefs.
One of the stupidest, least informative videos I've seen about this issue. It's illegal in Brazil to publicly incite toppling democracy. These "opposition figures" Di Martino mentions are specifically people who were calling for that. Which in Brazil is a crime. Musk's refusal to ban these accounts which were committing crimes incited a fine, which he tried to evade by removing Twitter's legal representation in Brazil. You Can't operate in Brazil without legal representation (otherwise, how will the site be held accountable to local laws?) and Musk was warned of that and refused to appoint legal representatives in Brazil. That's why it was blocked, because once they removed representation, it was operating illegally here. As soon as he appoints a new legal representative and pays the fines for operating illegally, the site will be made available in Brazil again.
Most of those who write here and set themselves up as defenders of so-called freedom of expression do so by referring to the completely outdated American model of Yankee-style pseudo-freedom of expression. X is a danger to our society and should respect the laws of the countries countries where it operates. It is high time that those who propagate falsehoods on an industrial scale be made accountable in a court of law.
How dangerous it is for a country's democracy when a billionaire owner of a bigtech chooses a side and starts working to favor that side, which in turn also favors the billionaire's companies. In the USA, NASA started using its rockets, during the campaign Donald Trump announced that he will tax in 100% the chinese cars without any reason against free trade practices and minimal state intervention, which is the American custom. and even in Brazil, the electric car market has grown mainly due to billion-dollar investments from China, which is Brazil's largest economic partner, in addition to concessions to extract lithium made available to China (essential for batteries) So think carefully, reflect on what the billionaire has to gain and know that it is not freedom spech, because if he really cared about that he would give voice to his homeland Africa, which has experienced centuries of exploitation, misery and civil wars under the control of Europeans and Americans.
@@jamescrosby5893 talking about yourself ? Its not the first time USA overthrow a country power to put a pawn in their favor, the difference is that they no longer have the need to use military force, they just need to use social media to influence the people
Elon Musk nasceu em Pretória, na África do Sul. Naturalizado americano, ele é filho de Maye Musk (modelo e nutricionista canadense) e de Errol Musk (engenheiro eletromecânico, piloto e marinheiro sul-africano). Muito patriota, mas qual pátria USA, Canadá ou África do Sul? 🤦🏼♂️
@@Wkkwiwiwksoswo Fale por você. Eu quero viver em uma democracia com amplas garantias das liberdades individuais. Se você quer viver em um regime autoritário que censura as pessoas, Cuba e Venezuela é logo ali... bye bye
Elon Musk certainly is a citizen of the world. He can defend anyone he wants including presidents and whoever else you said he can’t defend. Come and get our free speech.
Other countries are using T.T. as a plat form to get money from Americans by exploitation of their children going hungry Because their government puts money into weapons instead of feeding their own people. WAKE UP!
You don't need to mention Tik Tok: since Ucranian war, all russian midia is blocked and forbidden in europe an US. You got on social midia alerts like "this content may be supported by russina government". You don't have it for any other sourse as Ucrain, Israel, US...
Absolutely political. Funny how the media is debating only the free speech issues. You guys need to start talking about all the other ways this judge is breaking our laws. He's out of control and Brazil needs all the help we can get on fighting this madman.
Pior é ver que um brasileiro esta a falar esse tipo de BS, demonstrando o nível de complexo de vira-latas que possui. Brasil tem leis e nenhum Elon Musk da vida pode manter uma empresa estrangeira funcionando sem CEO responsável por ela. Alexandre de Moraes esta fazendo o que deve fazer.Period.
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
I've never encountered such an abundance of nonsense in a video before. The NFL has nothing to do with this, and the problem is not with any specific US company other than X and maybe Starlink (if they don't block X in Brazil as requested). As a citizen, how would you react if a company blatantly disregarded the laws of your country? X's suspension is associated with multiple violations of court orders, all in accordance with the brazilian law. Daniel Di Martino's attempt to downplay the situation by comparing it to Bolsonaro and Trump's "stolen election" claims actually relates to the assaults on public buildings in Brasília, which caused millions in losses and exposed the radicalization of the movement in favor of former President Jair Bolsonaro (PL). On January 8th of last year, thousands of people went to Praça dos Três Poderes, invaded the headquarters of the executive, legislative and judiciary branches and destroyed everything they saw, acts organized by X and Telegram. Telegram complied with the orders and continues to operate. Regarding the NFL, it will be free of any violence. Brazilians become very enthusiastic about sports they enjoy and teams they support, so without rivalry, it will resemble a performance by a favored artist.
Oh no! Brazilian citizens will no longer be able to see Elon Musk's cringey, desperate attempts to be funny and stay relevant. How will they ever cope?
This guest called Daniel is deeply misinformed. How do they trust him? Almost all he said is LITERALLY wrong according to what’s actually happening here in Brazil. And I’m not defending A or B, I’m talking about what actually went down between the Supreme Court and X.
@@rnielvhinsieans.elpidama6935X was suspended for failing to comply with legal obligations that all companies that deal with information must comply with. If the company fails to comply with the law, it is notified to correct its conduct, and if it does not complies, is suspended from functioning. Have you ever thought if international companies could simply disregard court decisions without any sanctions?
@@rnielvhinsieans.elpidama6935 what happens was X didn't respect the laws, Brazil has his Internet Legal Act, all it was following the law, not just a political decision, last thing to do was blocked X. Nothing against free of speed but everything has limits, hate and content at level of Nazis won't be tolerated in Brazil.
@@Ahenkan460you can’t force US laws abroad. Free speech in Brazil aligns with that in Europe, free speech until it causes harm to other people. Musk isn’t above the law, the government asked him for months to close accounts spreading hate, misinformation and he denied. Months later we are where we are. I can’t stand Lula but this was one of the first time I agreed with him, who does Musk think he is? He’s not even Brazilian. Follow our laws and regulations or get out. Obviously there are always politics there, but it’s beyond what this idiot is saying on TV.
Eff off. The far right wants to prohibit same sex marriage , abortion, Marijuama, free speech ! Stop the nonsense. Far right wants to establish evangelical ministers in Brazil to legislate according to Their beliefs.
1:29 Elon doesn't care about free speech or democracy. He's quick to call a judge a dictator but doesn't call actual dictators in this world that and prefers to be friendly with them. This guy is only interested in one thing, money. The only reason Tesla and SpaceX did so well is because there's always been someone else running the business for him. There were struggles at Tesla but these seemed to get resolved once Elon got bored with interfering. Twitter is different because I don't think he'll ever get bored so it will either end up being a large money pit that could eventually collapse Tesla and all the other companies built around them by trying to keep it afloat while he continues to interfere instead of letting people who know what they're doing run the company.
Unfortunately, Mr.Martino didn´t do his homework before the interview, so too many opinions and lack facts about the democratic process and existing investigation.
This video is a true fallacy of lies and disinformation. 1º - As a Brazilian, let me explain some facts: Alexandre de Moraes has an exemplary legal career, in addition to being a great lawyer and professor of law at one of the best universities in Brazil (USP), he was also a criminal justice prosecutor in the largest city in South America, São Paulo, being invited and voted by the National Congress, by the elected Senators of Brazil, for a seat on the Supreme Court of Brazil, therefore, Mr. Alexandre de Moraes is not a simple Judge. 2º - X/Tweeter refuses to remove crime-related content when requested by the local legal system, including content that incites CHILD ABUSE, RACISM, VIOLENCE, NAZISM, and the list goes on. 3º - Here there is no prior censorship, which means that everyone can talk about everything, but there are laws. You can't incite crime and use free speech as a shield for your part in the consequences. We're not in the United States, where people can openly worship the Nazis and get away with it. 4° - If someone wants to have business here, they must know that they need to follow the laws and our Constitution, otherwise they need to face the legal consequences, which is what is happening now. 5º - Elon Musk thinks he can get around our law because he has a lot of money, in fact, he has some bad politicians in his pockets who would love to lick their boots for some money trying to destabilize our state. We are fighting against the tyranny of those who think they can buy anything, including our well-being. 6º - It is not only happening in Brazil, but all over the world, these unjustifiable billionaires are trying to buy political power to overthrow democracies. They control the media, they control communication, they know how we think and how we react, because we're using platforms like X, Facebook, and other social media by providing our preferences and letting them dictate how we interact with each other. 7º - And understand once and for all, X / Tweeter, was not banned, he was suspended for non-compliance with a court order, comply with the Law, put a legal representative in the country and block the profiles of users who are disseminating illegal content and that's it, you can return normally.
@@nicolaswirtz according to Brazilian history... During the military regime in Brazil, communists/terrorists were exiled from our country, but with the end of the military regime in 1985, these same communist guerrillas returned and became politicians and wrote a new Brazilian constitution in 1988 with corrupt laws. This is the reason why so many criminal politicians are arrested and then released from prison, it is the reason why Lula was released from prison...
@@GarlickGG They left got elected, and you forgot to mention that the dictatorship in Brazil was financed by USA, and freedom of speech wasn't a thing during the regime. Also the prison of Lula was illegal using evidences adquired by illegal spying wich is a crime in Brazil invalidating the evidence.
@@GarlickGGThis disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
Daniel is not correct, he is just giving Fox's own view of the news, ignoring and adding many things, but in a very slight way. If a Bolsonarista, who is the equivalent of the Trumpistas in the US, saw Daniel's analysis they would say he is a communist.
@@andersonlavor idk about that, but Elon Musk is a manipulative billionaire that showed be banned. He acts like a victim of freedom of speech but he is just a bully and doesn't know when to shut up; he thinks he can one up everyone, like a true psychopath would think. This is why I called him evil, because he has a bad record to get where he is at.
@@amineantion Musk is a right wing extremist engaged in spreading his message globally. Brazil has its laws. Their country, their rules. Fu** Ellon Musk.
@@Junior_marsThank you for being a coherent person amongst thousands of idiots ! This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, gay rights, marijuana... The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the congress and the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their medieval beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense srory. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws about fakenews in Brazil, Europe or anyother country. No one is going to buy Musks or these far right leaning news company lies.
The rule of law of a country is decided by its people and their gov, not by businessmen from outside world. Can a Chinese billionaire challenge and disobey a US supreme court decision just because he doesn't agree?
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
Brasil IS not USA ....on Brasil we have law ...strangers most to Respecta this ...If this IS not ok...go to USA ..or to Place some sun dont shine...respect The constituicion and autonomi of Brasil .
To those claiming this is censorship: Freedom of speech is different from using social media to commit crimes, such as spreading fake news, abuse, incitement or glorification of violence and crime, scams, forgeries, threats, etc. Just because it's social media doesn't mean there are no laws. If a company is being notified about these 'crimes,' it must follow the law and act for the safety of its users and society as a whole. Elon Musk behaves like a child, making decisions based on what suits him, and thinks that just because he's rich, he owns the world and can't be contradicted.
The general point being made here (that this is undue censorship & an overreach) is somewhat sound. But, I feel like a key difference between this and, say, banning FB in the U.S. for comments made by Trump for example, is that 1) in the case of Mµ§K, he is such an illigitimate individual to be running a social media platform (as opposed to Zuckerberg who at least knows what he's doing), and 2) many of his investors are beginning to turn on him for having been been defrauded by him & his many failing companies, such that his clothing, as an emperor, is beginning to wear thin. Point is : I would consider the world has reached a point where some might consider it legitimate to remove at least some power from this dysmal individual, especially if he poses a threat to your integrity as a nation.
Zuckerberg admitted last week that he illegally censored Americans on behalf of the Biden administration and felt intimidated and coerced into complying with the government. Illegally censored Americans, his own words. So Zuckerberg clearly doesn’t know what he is doing or if he does he just committed millions of federal crimes to influence elections through illegal censorship.
I am Brazilian and our democracy is undergoing a process of erosion here. We are a few steps behind Venezuela, if we don't take care of ourselves we will have the same fate as them. In this specific case of X in Brazil, Elon Musk is doing what is right by trying to fight against censorship and defend freedom of expression. I personally hope that a future Trump government will help Brazil get back on track with democracy.
@@josebonifacio4555 Falou o bolsonarista... Vocês querem é rédea solta para poder difundir as vossas teorias da conspiração e esse vosso lixo extremista de direita. No Brasil mandam os brasileiros e o seu governo.
@@josebonifacio4555 If you think Trump & Musk are your free ticket to democracy as a Brazilian, all I can wish for you is Good Night, Cinderella. And don't forget your slipper.
Elon Musk, our deep gratitude from Brazil, a great and just man, with great moral and ethical, social, economic, technological, humanitarian and planetary awareness, a true democrat, responsible, a man of peace, of progress, and totally of "Good" 🗽🇺🇸⚖️👏👏👏👏👏👏💖👨🚀🚀🌟💫
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, gay rights, marijuana... The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the congress and the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their medieval beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense srory. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws about fakenews in Brazil, Europe or anyother country. No one is going to buy Musks or these far right leaning news company lies.
Republican system in Brazil is the biggest problem, these problems repeat constitution by constitution; Brazil already had 5 constitutions, 5 republics and all failed. Brazilian culture does not match with republican system, because it was imposed by a military coup in 1889 with some evil hands from UK and US to weaken the catholic culture, but our biggest problems can only be moderated and controlled as it was in the past by the Imperial Parlamentarism, which one day delivered to brazilian people a real unity, tranquility and freedom to build it's own future. After more than 100 years of republic, the systeam teached to all the generations of brazilians that our Imperial Parlamentarism was the hell and now we have ''democracy''.
Brazil is not anyone's poo poo background, especially if you have a character like Lula da Silva on watch. Follow the rules or leave. entitlement, arrogance and main character syndrome from Elon Musk
it isn't about misinformation, it's about a frustrated coup d'état that happened at January 8th last year and is under investigation by the federal police. know you're facts bro
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
Yeah yeah. Same as zh banned google and say will fine whoever access it. But their people access it anyway and gov must pay even more to google when ask them to do anything. So the lesson is if you want to ban anything you must have something to replace it first.
X blocked me. I don't know why and I can't get unblocked because I have tried to follow the instructions, bit it says to sigh out and then back in and then it comes up with the message that I am blocked. eithth
A X que a maioria dos brasileiros nem sabe o que é, e não era tão utilizada, a não ser pelos extremistas de extrema direita, não fará falta, desculpa te decepcionar, mas a maioria da população nem está ligando e a outra maioria nem sabia o que era e os extremistas estão chiando para chamar atenção na midia😂😂😂😂
Freedom of speech is under attack. First Amendment: Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or of the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for redress of grievances. Vote for Trump to preserve our freedoms.
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
This Daniel is so wrong 😂 X was suspended for failing to comply with Supreme Court rulings several times in a row, and only after being notified several times to adjust his conduct. There is no political charge in the decision. It is clear that the interviewee has a polictical side, and the mistake was not that, it was interviewing him as if he representes the average Brazilian.
Can we stop calling it "formerly known as twitter"?
Everyone knows it's officially called "X, formerly known as twitter"
It's now Ex-twitter.
formerly known as Twitter
Xuitter
The website formerly known as X
Kinda like prince
It's definitely annoying to hear formally Twitter
Elon - Block Starlink for all of Brazil - your accounts are frozen - so freeze their internet.
😂😂😂😂🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
the 0,08% of the brazilian service? yes, close it, who cares?
Brazils president is more concerned about being offended than free speech??
Two points: First, free speech is not an unequivocal right here. Being racist is a crime. Being homophobic is a crime. Being a nazi is a crime. Brazil is not the US and it's worked fine for us, just the same as much of Europe.
Second, Twitter's ban here is about them operating without legal representation. Twitter can return to Brazil whenever they feel like, all they need to do is actually follow our laws
no, lady. They order to block profiles commiting CRIMES. And it's not the president who orders, it's Jusice. You got 3 powers wll defined in brazilian government. In the brazilian law you have free speech, but as any other crime if you comit a crime your right is suspended or cancelled. You have the right to circulate freely, but if you comit a crime and you go to jail your right is suspended till you pay for your crime. You got the right to drive but if you drive drunk and you crash, the justicer suspends that right. It happens everywere all the time.
@@gringossa crime of opinion? Because Alexandre de Moraes ordered the profiles of a teenager and a republican senator to be blocked, simply because they posted criticisms of his conduct. In addition to other profiles of right-wing politicians, organized crime, drug dealers and murderers can publish freely. And the most sinister thing is that he does this with the excuse that he is protecting democracy, but in reality he is defending himself.
Before commenting nonsense, read about the reason why X is blocked.
@@gringossagood response! It beats me to see how much nonsense Fox spews at its audience. They do not even mention the actual reason for blocking X in Brazil.
Supporting censorship because it’s run by a guy you don’t agree with politically or like. If this was instagram or TikTok you wouldn’t be saying this. People supporting this are crazy.
Indeed true.
I you only listen to American media. You don't know anything about the case, loll he insults the judge call him every siihhhtttt name American are so idiots
Eff off. The far right wants to prohibit same sex marriage , abortion, Marijuama, free speech ! Stop the nonsense. Far right wants to establish evangelical ministers in Brazil to legislate according to Their beliefs.
One of the stupidest, least informative videos I've seen about this issue.
It's illegal in Brazil to publicly incite toppling democracy. These "opposition figures" Di Martino mentions are specifically people who were calling for that. Which in Brazil is a crime. Musk's refusal to ban these accounts which were committing crimes incited a fine, which he tried to evade by removing Twitter's legal representation in Brazil.
You Can't operate in Brazil without legal representation (otherwise, how will the site be held accountable to local laws?) and Musk was warned of that and refused to appoint legal representatives in Brazil. That's why it was blocked, because once they removed representation, it was operating illegally here. As soon as he appoints a new legal representative and pays the fines for operating illegally, the site will be made available in Brazil again.
Most of those who write here and set themselves up as defenders of so-called freedom of expression do so by referring to the completely outdated American model of Yankee-style pseudo-freedom of expression. X is a danger to our society and should respect the laws of the countries countries where it operates. It is high time that those who propagate falsehoods on an industrial scale be made accountable in a court of law.
Thank you very much for your report. We, the Brazilian people, appreciate it.
Countries that do not have X: Russia, China, Iran, North Korea, Venezuela and now Brazil.
That says a lot!
X has become a cesspit of right wing racists and xenophobes.
Brazil has it laws.
Their country, their rules.
Brazil like the UK has been overthrown by Globalist Terrorist pretending to represent the people.
All communists, no free speech. Some of it comming to U.S. if vice Flip Flooper wins.
Thank God, i hope it last forever
How dangerous it is for a country's democracy when a billionaire owner of a bigtech chooses a side and starts working to favor that side, which in turn also favors the billionaire's companies. In the USA, NASA started using its rockets, during the campaign Donald Trump announced that he will tax in 100% the chinese cars without any reason against free trade practices and minimal state intervention, which is the American custom. and even in Brazil, the electric car market has grown mainly due to billion-dollar investments from China, which is Brazil's largest economic partner, in addition to concessions to extract lithium made available to China (essential for batteries) So think carefully, reflect on what the billionaire has to gain and know that it is not freedom spech, because if he really cared about that he would give voice to his homeland Africa, which has experienced centuries of exploitation, misery and civil wars under the control of Europeans and Americans.
Sounds like your brainwashed
@@jamescrosby5893 talking about yourself ? Its not the first time USA overthrow a country power to put a pawn in their favor, the difference is that they no longer have the need to use military force, they just need to use social media to influence the people
God bless you Mr Elon Musk A True patriot
Patriot for whom? For Brazil?
Bolsonaristas are really idiots
He is from South Africa...
Thank God X isn't part of Tesla and Space X.
No one cares if X disappears.
@@carloseduardorigamontefran5663he’s an American non genius
Elon Musk nasceu em Pretória, na África do Sul. Naturalizado americano, ele é filho de Maye Musk (modelo e nutricionista canadense) e de Errol Musk (engenheiro eletromecânico, piloto e marinheiro sul-africano). Muito patriota, mas qual pátria USA, Canadá ou África do Sul? 🤦🏼♂️
A Great American Elon Musk and Family
Who cares then don’t go to Brazil
Brazilians care.
@@hotcold9690 I hope so
@@Matthew-v6zolha Ninguem liga ta todo bem sem x n toda população alienada n precisamos da sua visita aqui
@@Wkkwiwiwksoswo Fale por você. Eu quero viver em uma democracia com amplas garantias das liberdades individuais. Se você quer viver em um regime autoritário que censura as pessoas, Cuba e Venezuela é logo ali... bye bye
@@hotcold9690 no, we dont care, we are loving bluesky
Elon Musk certainly is a citizen of the world. He can defend anyone he wants including presidents and whoever else you said he can’t defend. Come and get our free speech.
I want to have a job like Daniel: have no ideia of what I'm doing and still get the money. Damn this guy knows nothing of what's going on in Brazil.
What about ban on Tik Tok? Is this censorship?
Other countries are using T.T. as a plat form to get money from Americans by exploitation of their children going hungry Because their government puts money into weapons instead of feeding their own people. WAKE UP!
@1924Furacao which democratic country in the 21st century would think let alone discuss censorship on Tik Tok?
You don't need to mention Tik Tok: since Ucranian war, all russian midia is blocked and forbidden in europe an US. You got on social midia alerts like "this content may be supported by russina government". You don't have it for any other sourse as Ucrain, Israel, US...
If the NFL allows the football game to go on, it's time to boycott the game and NFL. Never should have scheduled a game in that country to begin with.
That's the way more freedom of speech and protest
Absolutely political. Funny how the media is debating only the free speech issues. You guys need to start talking about all the other ways this judge is breaking our laws. He's out of control and Brazil needs all the help we can get on fighting this madman.
Pior é ver que um brasileiro esta a falar esse tipo de BS, demonstrando o nível de complexo de vira-latas que possui.
Brasil tem leis e nenhum Elon Musk da vida pode manter uma empresa estrangeira funcionando sem CEO responsável por ela.
Alexandre de Moraes esta fazendo o que deve fazer.Period.
Billionaire with good intentions in Brazil, no he doesn't want natural resources and a very nice guy.
What goooood bilhonaire baby
He's got nefarious intentions.
Jesus Christ Loves you Sir Elon Musk and Family
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
I've never encountered such an abundance of nonsense in a video before. The NFL has nothing to do with this, and the problem is not with any specific US company other than X and maybe Starlink (if they don't block X in Brazil as requested). As a citizen, how would you react if a company blatantly disregarded the laws of your country?
X's suspension is associated with multiple violations of court orders, all in accordance with the brazilian law. Daniel Di Martino's attempt to downplay the situation by comparing it to Bolsonaro and Trump's "stolen election" claims actually relates to the assaults on public buildings in Brasília, which caused millions in losses and exposed the radicalization of the movement in favor of former President Jair Bolsonaro (PL). On January 8th of last year, thousands of people went to Praça dos Três Poderes, invaded the headquarters of the executive, legislative and judiciary branches and destroyed everything they saw, acts organized by X and Telegram. Telegram complied with the orders and continues to operate.
Regarding the NFL, it will be free of any violence. Brazilians become very enthusiastic about sports they enjoy and teams they support, so without rivalry, it will resemble a performance by a favored artist.
This Daniel is misinformed or has bad intentions.
i bet 2º one
I came here to write the same thing
Yes...he just know nothing...hahaha
fox...
Oh no! Brazilian citizens will no longer be able to see Elon Musk's cringey, desperate attempts to be funny and stay relevant. How will they ever cope?
I would love to see the post from X that supposedly started all this.
It’s not 40 million users. It’s 40 million citizens and about 16% are users. That’s not news.
You are wrong. Brazil has more than 200 millions citizens. It is 40 million users.
You are just stupid. Easily checkable fats that Brazil has 215 million people. The size of X is 20 million tho.
I am Brazilian and I can tell: Brazil is with Musk.
Lol!
No we're not
Nope we are not
I only feel bad for the people that made money out of X. I'm definitely *not* with Musk.
Só você querido e o grupinho (como dizem vocês) do "mi mi mi"
Doing this and making it big news is probably doing more damage
This misleading guy commenting with a strong Spanish accent is a real serf of the banana empire!!
This guest called Daniel is deeply misinformed. How do they trust him? Almost all he said is LITERALLY wrong according to what’s actually happening here in Brazil. And I’m not defending A or B, I’m talking about what actually went down between the Supreme Court and X.
What is your point of view as to what happened?
what actually happen and what's the sentiment of Brazilian citizens?
@@rnielvhinsieans.elpidama6935X was suspended for failing to comply with legal obligations that all companies that deal with information must comply with. If the company fails to comply with the law, it is notified to correct its conduct, and if it does not complies, is suspended from functioning. Have you ever thought if international companies could simply disregard court decisions without any sanctions?
@@rnielvhinsieans.elpidama6935 what happens was X didn't respect the laws, Brazil has his Internet Legal Act, all it was following the law, not just a political decision, last thing to do was blocked X. Nothing against free of speed but everything has limits, hate and content at level of Nazis won't be tolerated in Brazil.
@@Ahenkan460you can’t force US laws abroad. Free speech in Brazil aligns with that in Europe, free speech until it causes harm to other people. Musk isn’t above the law, the government asked him for months to close accounts spreading hate, misinformation and he denied. Months later we are where we are. I can’t stand Lula but this was one of the first time I agreed with him, who does Musk think he is? He’s not even Brazilian. Follow our laws and regulations or get out. Obviously there are always politics there, but it’s beyond what this idiot is saying on TV.
they are afraid of the liberal expression .Why?
Eff off. The far right wants to prohibit same sex marriage , abortion, Marijuama, free speech ! Stop the nonsense. Far right wants to establish evangelical ministers in Brazil to legislate according to Their beliefs.
Because Musk is political figure in the US, I don’t think I can get the whole story. The right and left present different stories!
This guy is saying bullsh$t. The entire supreme court validated his decision.
The entire court? All 200 of them?
1:29 Elon doesn't care about free speech or democracy. He's quick to call a judge a dictator but doesn't call actual dictators in this world that and prefers to be friendly with them. This guy is only interested in one thing, money. The only reason Tesla and SpaceX did so well is because there's always been someone else running the business for him. There were struggles at Tesla but these seemed to get resolved once Elon got bored with interfering. Twitter is different because I don't think he'll ever get bored so it will either end up being a large money pit that could eventually collapse Tesla and all the other companies built around them by trying to keep it afloat while he continues to interfere instead of letting people who know what they're doing run the company.
Unfortunately, Mr.Martino didn´t do his homework before the interview, so too many opinions and lack facts about the democratic process and existing investigation.
Yes...he sounds really stupid.
LIES, LIES AND MORE LIES 😪
That's FOX.
this social network adds nothing to Brazil this businessman has companies in Brazil he has to respect Brazilian laws
This video is a true fallacy of lies and disinformation.
1º - As a Brazilian, let me explain some facts:
Alexandre de Moraes has an exemplary legal career, in addition to being a great lawyer and professor of law at one of the best universities in Brazil (USP), he was also a criminal justice prosecutor in the largest city in South America, São Paulo, being invited and voted by the National Congress, by the elected Senators of Brazil, for a seat on the Supreme Court of Brazil, therefore, Mr. Alexandre de Moraes is not a simple Judge.
2º - X/Tweeter refuses to remove crime-related content when requested by the local legal system, including content that incites CHILD ABUSE, RACISM, VIOLENCE, NAZISM, and the list goes on.
3º - Here there is no prior censorship, which means that everyone can talk about everything, but there are laws. You can't incite crime and use free speech as a shield for your part in the consequences. We're not in the United States, where people can openly worship the Nazis and get away with it.
4° - If someone wants to have business here, they must know that they need to follow the laws and our Constitution, otherwise they need to face the legal consequences, which is what is happening now.
5º - Elon Musk thinks he can get around our law because he has a lot of money, in fact, he has some bad politicians in his pockets who would love to lick their boots for some money trying to destabilize our state. We are fighting against the tyranny of those who think they can buy anything, including our well-being.
6º - It is not only happening in Brazil, but all over the world, these unjustifiable billionaires are trying to buy political power to overthrow democracies. They control the media, they control communication, they know how we think and how we react, because we're using platforms like X, Facebook, and other social media by providing our preferences and letting them dictate how we interact with each other.
7º - And understand once and for all, X / Tweeter, was not banned, he was suspended for non-compliance with a court order, comply with the Law, put a legal representative in the country and block the profiles of users who are disseminating illegal content and that's it, you can return normally.
Vou copiar isso e colar sempre que alguém defender o "Elão", parabéns pelas explicações 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Respect our laws or get away.
Corrupt laws
@@GarlickGG according to?
@@nicolaswirtz
according to Brazilian history...
During the military regime in Brazil, communists/terrorists were exiled from our country, but with the end of the military regime in 1985, these same communist guerrillas returned and became politicians and wrote a new Brazilian constitution in 1988 with corrupt laws. This is the reason why so many criminal politicians are arrested and then released from prison, it is the reason why Lula was released from prison...
@@GarlickGG They left got elected, and you forgot to mention that the dictatorship in Brazil was financed by USA, and freedom of speech wasn't a thing during the regime.
Also the prison of Lula was illegal using evidences adquired by illegal spying wich is a crime in Brazil invalidating the evidence.
@@GarlickGGThis disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
Daniel di Martino lies
I follow elon musk because of his integrity to free speech and his appreciation of professional work and the fact that nobody can buy him.
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
President of the World
I pray for you Mr President Elon Musk and Family
Eron ban the Starlink for Brazil Army.
Brazil, the new North Korea 🤡🙄🤦
Daniel is not correct, he is just giving Fox's own view of the news, ignoring and adding many things, but in a very slight way. If a Bolsonarista, who is the equivalent of the Trumpistas in the US, saw Daniel's analysis they would say he is a communist.
Stop Elon Musk's influence ✊. He's a narcissist.
Build a multi-billion dollar company like SpaceX or Tesla and then maybe you can talk. Until then, no one cares that you think he's a narcissist
@@PUA-Dude you sound half witty and no one is trying to shut you down. Learn to live with different ideas and opinions.
@@andersonlavor idk about that, but Elon Musk is a manipulative billionaire that showed be banned. He acts like a victim of freedom of speech but he is just a bully and doesn't know when to shut up; he thinks he can one up everyone, like a true psychopath would think. This is why I called him evil, because he has a bad record to get where he is at.
@@amineantionI care 😂
@@amineantion Musk is a right wing extremist engaged in spreading his message globally.
Brazil has its laws.
Their country, their rules.
Fu** Ellon Musk.
and how will the Brazil government stop the broadcasting of "X" via Starlink global internet service?
Já está banido! A Starlink cumpriu as regras do país como todas as operadoras e bloqueou.
they have allready comply. And Starlink is 0,08% of the internet in Brazil. Almost nothing.
I wonder if this has anything to do with the upcoming @nfl game? Players are told to stay inside the hotel.
Boycotting the game.
No!
what??
I am Brazilian and I affirm that everything that was said is a lie, a newspaper with no commitment to the truth.
@@Junior_marsThank you for being a coherent person amongst thousands of idiots ! This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, gay rights, marijuana... The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the congress and the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their medieval beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense srory. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws about fakenews in Brazil, Europe or anyother country. No one is going to buy Musks or these far right leaning news company lies.
X IS X that's it stop with FORMALLY so you won't be currently known as IGNORANT!
Elon Musk should cut off Starlink to Brazil.
This will make a huge difference for us😒
and Ukraine.
Governo br ja bloqueo aqui n precisamos disso
@@hotcold9690Brazil is not Ukraine 😂 wtf does Ukraine have to do with this???
you're really think Brazil only uses this starlink? sure cut it I wouldn't care. it's better than a billionaire running my country
LiveNow, please call Mike Benz to talk about the censorship industrial complex that affects not only Brazil but the entire world.
They dont want people to have a voice quite they people rule the nation
If he can ,install communications to Ukraine,quickly after Russia pulled them down,come on🙄
The rule of law of a country is decided by its people and their gov, not by businessmen from outside world. Can a Chinese billionaire challenge and disobey a US supreme court decision just because he doesn't agree?
is the lighting so bright mr. reporter?
FAKE NEWS FAKE NEWS
Hahahahaha hey Brazil if I wanna go on *X* I will do so freely!!!
We are loving Bluesky.
The real world hates X and the USA platform of lies and spitefullness. It won't be missed.
who cares anyway
@@leogama3422 anyone who cares about freedom of speech that is who
@@waguinfp right
You are Welcome Elon Musk
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
What makes them think they can tell a US company what to do? It’s not going to end well for them.
Thais IS not true
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
Brasil IS not USA ....on Brasil we have law ...strangers most to Respecta this ...If this IS not ok...go to USA ..or to Place some sun dont shine...respect The constituicion and autonomi of Brasil .
Dumb.
Wrong informations
The citizens will like to voice their concern freely.
To those claiming this is censorship: Freedom of speech is different from using social media to commit crimes, such as spreading fake news, abuse, incitement or glorification of violence and crime, scams, forgeries, threats, etc. Just because it's social media doesn't mean there are no laws. If a company is being notified about these 'crimes,' it must follow the law and act for the safety of its users and society as a whole. Elon Musk behaves like a child, making decisions based on what suits him, and thinks that just because he's rich, he owns the world and can't be contradicted.
Thank you ! A coherent person amongst thousands of stupid misinformed people.
LiveNOW from FOX, i subbed to ur channel
What a waste. All the spew is lies and division.
He butched the judge's name. It hurt my ears.
The general point being made here (that this is undue censorship & an overreach) is somewhat sound. But, I feel like a key difference between this and, say, banning FB in the U.S. for comments made by Trump for example, is that 1) in the case of Mµ§K, he is such an illigitimate individual to be running a social media platform (as opposed to Zuckerberg who at least knows what he's doing), and 2) many of his investors are beginning to turn on him for having been been defrauded by him & his many failing companies, such that his clothing, as an emperor, is beginning to wear thin. Point is : I would consider the world has reached a point where some might consider it legitimate to remove at least some power from this dysmal individual, especially if he poses a threat to your integrity as a nation.
Zuckerberg admitted last week that he illegally censored Americans on behalf of the Biden administration and felt intimidated and coerced into complying with the government. Illegally censored Americans, his own words. So Zuckerberg clearly doesn’t know what he is doing or if he does he just committed millions of federal crimes to influence elections through illegal censorship.
I am Brazilian and our democracy is undergoing a process of erosion here. We are a few steps behind Venezuela, if we don't take care of ourselves we will have the same fate as them. In this specific case of X in Brazil, Elon Musk is doing what is right by trying to fight against censorship and defend freedom of expression. I personally hope that a future Trump government will help Brazil get back on track with democracy.
@@josebonifacio4555
Falou o bolsonarista...
Vocês querem é rédea solta para poder difundir as vossas teorias da conspiração e esse vosso lixo extremista de direita.
No Brasil mandam os brasileiros e o seu governo.
Communist
@@josebonifacio4555 If you think Trump & Musk are your free ticket to democracy as a Brazilian, all I can wish for you is Good Night, Cinderella. And don't forget your slipper.
Elon Musk, our deep gratitude from Brazil, a great and just man, with great moral and ethical, social, economic, technological, humanitarian and planetary awareness, a true democrat, responsible, a man of peace, of progress, and totally of "Good" 🗽🇺🇸⚖️👏👏👏👏👏👏💖👨🚀🚀🌟💫
Bye bye musk
Hes not going anywhere bud
@@kourtlandperry1698 oh yhea he is this is just the beginning look how they attacked trump.
typical liberal. Your wasting are good air!
Really good assessment! Thank you for bringing it to light! I’m a brazilian myself.
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, gay rights, marijuana... The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the congress and the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their medieval beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense srory. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws about fakenews in Brazil, Europe or anyother country. No one is going to buy Musks or these far right leaning news company lies.
How are they going to find out exactly if they used a VPN?
Republican system in Brazil is the biggest problem, these problems repeat constitution by constitution; Brazil already had 5 constitutions, 5 republics and all failed. Brazilian culture does not match with republican system, because it was imposed by a military coup in 1889 with some evil hands from UK and US to weaken the catholic culture, but our biggest problems can only be moderated and controlled as it was in the past by the Imperial Parlamentarism, which one day delivered to brazilian people a real unity, tranquility and freedom to build it's own future. After more than 100 years of republic, the systeam teached to all the generations of brazilians that our Imperial Parlamentarism was the hell and now we have ''democracy''.
Brazil is not anyone's poo poo background, especially if you have a character like Lula da Silva on watch. Follow the rules or leave. entitlement, arrogance and main character syndrome from Elon Musk
Want to know what a loony billionaire car crash looks like?
Elon is a sign of what billionaire means. I don't care if I lose money, it doesn't matter to me.
Im so sick of government telling u whats misinformation while sending misinformation to the world
it isn't about misinformation, it's about a frustrated coup d'état that happened at January 8th last year and is under investigation by the federal police. know you're facts bro
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
In Brazil there will be no way to put a chip in anyone's brain
Put it in their BBL.
x will kick you off - if you get ahead of the narrative - connecting it all together
Yeah yeah. Same as zh banned google and say will fine whoever access it. But their people access it anyway and gov must pay even more to google when ask them to do anything. So the lesson is if you want to ban anything you must have something to replace it first.
I wonder what Democrat is paying Brazil president.
X blocked me. I don't know why and I can't get unblocked because I have tried to follow the instructions, bit it says to sigh out and then back in and then it comes up with the message that I am blocked.
eithth
Maybe no bueno... lol God bless Donald Trump and The United States of America 🇺🇸 from Sandsprings Oklahoma USA 🇺🇸
Brazilian, say goodbye to FREEDOM. Bye, Bye. I feel sorry for them. God help them
A X que a maioria dos brasileiros nem sabe o que é, e não era tão utilizada, a não ser pelos extremistas de extrema direita, não fará falta, desculpa te decepcionar, mas a maioria da população nem está ligando e a outra maioria nem sabia o que era e os extremistas estão chiando para chamar atenção na midia😂😂😂😂
What if Elon put servers in orbit so we can connect via Starlink.
Wouldn't that make it out of reach for sencorchip and be a victory for free speech?
HESITANT TO USE THE C WORD R U IN KINDERGARTEN?
Why
And they are not cltlzens of the world ether.
What is that popping noise
Elon should shut down starlink in Brazil.
Starlink didn't even exist until a couple years 😒
This true capitalism 🤫
They suck and they no it😂
...... wow
You countersue so they will get nothing
Brazil the next North Korea 🪦👿
Come on
Freedom of speech is under attack. First Amendment: Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or of the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for redress of grievances.
Vote for Trump to preserve our freedoms.
Oh dear cultust. You don't get it the world doesn't want your version of free speech or a dictator keep hateful X in the USA.
sorry if you already knew that, but the US constitution is only valid in US soil
Large fine! Sounds more like a" death sentence." Trump/Vance & Elon😂🎉2024🎉
Good Lock Congratulations Elon Musk thank you.God for everything
This disgusting habit of the far right dreaming about establishing a goverment that forbids ftom women's rights, lgbt rights, marijuana to abortionn and everything they deam imoral according to their medieval beliefs . The far right in Brazil wants evangedicals in the Congress, the Senate and the Judiciary to legislate according to their insane beliefs. Stop this stupid nonsense story. What a bunch of liars ! Elon Musk has to respect the laws against the spread of fakenews in Brazil, Europe or any other country. No one is going to buy Musk's or these far right leaning News Companies' lies.
ELON POWER💪
Sure if you like devils in disguise.
@@Itsallillusional well if I liked devils in disguise I would be voting for vice Flip Flooper Kamala and Timmy boy
Are you going to invade them?
its the money they are looking for lol
The World Loves you Mr Elon Musk
This Daniel is so wrong 😂 X was suspended for failing to comply with Supreme Court rulings several times in a row, and only after being notified several times to adjust his conduct. There is no political charge in the decision. It is clear that the interviewee has a polictical side, and the mistake was not that, it was interviewing him as if he representes the average Brazilian.
Wrong.