Air Dry Clay vs. Polymer Clay vs. REAL Clay -- which clay should I use?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 142

  • @PerfecltyxImperfect
    @PerfecltyxImperfect 3 роки тому +41

    Thank you for caring about my health! I want to make my own kitchenware, plates and mugs etc. I don't have a kiln so I was trying to take a shortcut and use air dry clay. After watching this I don't think it'd be a good idea to do so. So thank you! Loving your channel!

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому +5

      Of course! Maybe you can find a kiln near you :)

    • @1KITIG
      @1KITIG 3 роки тому +4

      Look for a studio near you, studios that host courses for the public are usually happy to sell individuals their ceramic clay in order for people to be agreed to fire pieces there.

    • @raven4442
      @raven4442 3 місяці тому

      ​@@PotterytothePeople Do you think air drying clay would work as balearic sling ammo? Does it dry hard and does it shatter?

  • @1KITIG
    @1KITIG 3 роки тому +11

    As far as I know, there are 2 main types of popular Air-Dry Clay:
    paper based which is a mix of polymers and‏ paper paste, very easy to work with. (example: Crayola)
    Clay Based which is a mix of polymers, clay paste (Earthware or Terra-Cotta), and air reactive substances that are used to actively dry the clay. I suspect the pale one has paper paste in it too which makes the material more workable than the Terra-Cotta Based one that drys out midst work. (example: Das)

  • @amypalladino2584
    @amypalladino2584 3 роки тому +10

    Glad to have found this video. I have never worked with clay before but I wanted to try and make some plant pots. Figured I'd start with something like air dry or polymer and move on to real clay if it's something I'm very passionate about

    • @kalpanaruhela
      @kalpanaruhela Рік тому

      Have you started making anything.?

    • @amypalladino2584
      @amypalladino2584 Рік тому

      @@kalpanaruhela norhing of substance unfortunately. I've had some medical trouble for the last year and I'm still not done sorting it out. I made a little bowl I put beads in. Lol!

    • @kalpanaruhela
      @kalpanaruhela Рік тому

      @@amypalladino2584 Okay. I hope you are doing good now. :) all d best on making the items.

  • @yourinfluencerimage7182
    @yourinfluencerimage7182 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you so much for laying it out easily!!! So hard to find these easy answers elsewhere. I'll keep watching. Thank you

  • @chaosGooseDE
    @chaosGooseDE 3 роки тому +9

    this video came right on time! i recently started working with clay, i bought some real clay for figure making, but i didn’t like the way it worked at all!
    i have now purchased fimo air dry & fimo soft, and i am already enjoying those so much more! this is a great guide for starting out, thank you so much :)

  • @nynasargent3988
    @nynasargent3988 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you for your care in distinguishing these 3 clays. At the end of this video, you asked for new things to make a video on and I was just curious if you knew about these small kilns that you use in the microwave…yes, the microwave! I have seen only a handful of videos about one particular brand I saw on Amazon. It seems like if you were making small things like a cup or jewelry or maybe the ceramic parts of a wind chime would do well. Now it might seem that based off of what I just wrote that I might already know enough about these kilns, but I like to see what seasoned artist’s takes are on different materials…it’s helpful especially when using mixed media, so that I can use each one properly…Of course, thank you ahead of time if you are able to dive into this 🤗 AND Happy New Year! 🎉

  • @officialfanofrichiebricker8324
    @officialfanofrichiebricker8324 9 місяців тому +2

    Polymer clay and air dry cay are both "hydroscopic" , it likes to absorb moisture and doesnt dry quickly like ceramic or other plastic s. They can develop dangerous molds, although there are no documented cases of illness, The potential is there

  • @quiltdimensions2046
    @quiltdimensions2046 2 роки тому

    I was just going to buy polymer to make plates. I'm so grateful to have found your video. Thank you so much.

  • @basesatya
    @basesatya Рік тому

    Thank you so much for all the explanations!! Special thank for not pushing people to use plastic and be careful about the tests in animals. I love your videos 💖💖💖

  • @rhythmic_seed
    @rhythmic_seed 11 місяців тому

    I loved 🥜
    And your teaching is understandable and pleasant. I was confused with all the kind of clays. I'm not anymore. 😂
    Thanks so much
    🙏🏼

  • @beckysamuell8969
    @beckysamuell8969 3 роки тому

    Wow. So much Info in a short video. This is how it’s done. Thanks so much!

  • @tayloralvarez7268
    @tayloralvarez7268 3 роки тому +4

    So informative!! Thanks for doin the research and sharing! :)

  • @LisaAdams.75
    @LisaAdams.75 3 роки тому +4

    I'm just starting out with polymer clay & soon / later will want to be trying out porcelain. I am having a hard time finding a nice gold for polymer hence wanting to later delve into porcelain to use gold lustre. This could be a great subject too. Different golds and the applications. It took me a few videos to get through on YT and other blogs to realise, I can't use Gold Lustre in a regular oven... such a shame. I want to use polymer clay to achieve the look of porcelain, "fake it 'till I can make it", so to speak. A comparison could be great! Think earrings!

  • @wunwun3708
    @wunwun3708 2 роки тому

    You explained the differences so well - thank you!

  • @corryg6403
    @corryg6403 2 роки тому

    I work with polymer clay also, it is great for Christmas ornaments jewelry journal covers. I use mostly black or white and mica powders

  • @paintandpotterybymangala
    @paintandpotterybymangala 3 роки тому

    I think I should just send this video to those who ask me the same question 😄😄.Well done 👏👏👏.

  • @SadieSavestheDay
    @SadieSavestheDay 3 роки тому +2

    Oh this was really helpful. I wish I had access to a kiln, but this helps me understand the difference between the clays.

  • @jeningles
    @jeningles 3 роки тому +6

    thank you so much for the video!! so informative, you're making me want to start experimenting with pottery. also, i hope you don't mind me asking what breed your dog is- she's beautiful ! :)

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      That's great! She's a mixed breed rescued from the street-- no clue!

  • @cob4467
    @cob4467 7 місяців тому

    Thank you

  • @TheFlyingKiwyGirl
    @TheFlyingKiwyGirl 22 дні тому

    Just a question: polymer clay is not safe for food. But is it ok to fire it in the same oven in which I cook my food? Does it release fumes or stuff like that?

  • @shroomy350
    @shroomy350 3 роки тому +4

    what kind of clay should i use for ashtrays and incense holders?

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому +3

      I guess they will all work, but you won't be able to clean air dry clay. I wouldn't use polymer/oven bake clay because the heat might put off fumes. The best would obviously be real clay.

  • @bluewhale2575
    @bluewhale2575 2 роки тому +1

    Your pup is sooo beautiful. What kind is he/she?

  • @MrsWhatsername72
    @MrsWhatsername72 9 місяців тому

    Omg thank you so much!! I just started using clay and this answered all of my questions! This is very important to know, thank you very much once again 🩷

  • @shiroinekojulie
    @shiroinekojulie 3 роки тому +1

    I recently discovered that it's actually possible to fire and glaze clay in the microwave using a microwave kiln which is actually super cheap (~40$) but the size is limited. You should look it up, there are videos on youtube :)

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому +4

      This sounds sketchy AF, but I'm also curious AF. Thanks for the info!

  • @marwasalem1729
    @marwasalem1729 2 роки тому

    Thank u so much for gathering this much beneficial information ❤️

  • @ChosenByCover
    @ChosenByCover 3 роки тому +2

    Clicked for Peanut, stayed for the Info (and the end

  • @rosemariegrasberger5160
    @rosemariegrasberger5160 2 роки тому

    I been making Xmas ornaments using model magic clay it seems to be good for what I'm using it for

  • @marangjija
    @marangjija 3 роки тому

    I was confuse about all clay this video is helpful thank you

  • @zeynepozcan1347
    @zeynepozcan1347 3 роки тому

    Thank you for explaining! This sums up a lot

  • @denisegallant149
    @denisegallant149 3 роки тому

    Thankyou so much! You e answered all my questions

  • @ritaalexandra3193
    @ritaalexandra3193 2 роки тому

    Thank you for this video.
    Very useful.
    And when you cover with varnish? This is the last material that will be in touch with food... I wonder if you have a video with this information.

  • @adrianasilveira4561
    @adrianasilveira4561 3 роки тому

    Great video, thank you very much. Lots of explanation. Amazing

  • @shirleymccullough7313
    @shirleymccullough7313 Рік тому

    Most informative video I have watched 👍🥰

  • @melodyide2248
    @melodyide2248 2 роки тому

    I want to make a sculpture that will also be used as a candle holder. Which clay should I use if I don't have access to a kiln?

  • @sexsiren26
    @sexsiren26 3 роки тому +3

    I brought some oven bake clay from the 5 below store and made A ash tray had fun . so i decided to go to Michaels and brought Air dry clay not really A fan of it .

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      Yes I tend to prefer polymer too... Interesting to hear your feedback!

  • @HelloDallxoxo
    @HelloDallxoxo 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you for this video!

  • @NeonAtary777
    @NeonAtary777 3 місяці тому

    Thank you very much. Very noce video. I really wanted to do pottery qmd mqke mugs for me and my friends but I think where I live it would be a little difficult to find a close kiln 🥹 but I considered using air dry clay since it's the most accessible until I get a little better.

  • @stuckinlimbo8242
    @stuckinlimbo8242 3 роки тому +2

    Awesome video! But I wanted to ask, what about plant pots? Could you maybe use the polymer clay to create plant pots (maybe glazed) that you can use?

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому +1

      I imagine it will be ok, but I would ask a plant expert if they will leech any bad chemicals into the plant.

    • @kristenjarvis7319
      @kristenjarvis7319 3 роки тому +2

      You can use it as a cache pot!!

  • @sarahnelson-praiseparodies7272
    @sarahnelson-praiseparodies7272 7 місяців тому

    Awesome, thank you for sharing!! So, can polymer be thrown on a wheel?

  • @TheSlightlyCurious
    @TheSlightlyCurious 3 роки тому +2

    Perfectly explained 🙌 clay is definitely my bais too 🤭

  • @moriamsel7043
    @moriamsel7043 3 роки тому +13

    I started pottery again because of your videos, and started looking for a kiln, and then thought, what the heck, and now, we are turning it into a corona-safe event by doing a pitfire :-) So, you don't need a kiln, just an empty field far off from habitation... Erm.

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому +2

      Amazing! That is cool to hear. I would love to see your results. I tried a pitfire once and it wasn't effective at vitrifying my clay. Need to do more research next time ;)

  • @Mp0mp
    @Mp0mp 3 роки тому +2

    Hi there!
    Where can I find real clay?
    I’m starting with air dry clay but in the future I’d love to start with real clay.
    Thanks in advance xx

  • @gwchomperz6471
    @gwchomperz6471 Рік тому

    Can I use air dry clay for experimenting, making 1:12 scale miniatures on a mini pottery wheel?

  • @catherine159
    @catherine159 Рік тому

    Hi! I have strenght issues with my hands and I was wondering is paper air dry clay like DAS is as soft and manageable than real clay? Thanks!

  • @karenroosevelt7450
    @karenroosevelt7450 8 місяців тому

    I have a ceramic christmas tree that someone had glued back together badly. It has cracks that i want to fill in with fimo air clay. What are your thoughts on this?

  • @nikoliniolnc
    @nikoliniolnc 3 роки тому +2

    Great video what about plaster? Do you think its good for jewellery? Or clay its better im so confused thank you

  • @child_of_god5430
    @child_of_god5430 3 роки тому +3

    For actual ceramics when you say use only real clay is it because it’s the only food safe type????

    • @ryanmcdonagh2082
      @ryanmcdonagh2082 4 місяці тому

      Thank you for the advice.All I wanna do

    • @ryanmcdonagh2082
      @ryanmcdonagh2082 4 місяці тому

      I wanna see.I wanna see clear paths made outdownload palmer play if you could do more on the bill dolls

  • @Rommana1994
    @Rommana1994 Рік тому

    Can you shape real clay with hands ? Or only with the spinner thing?

  • @sarahqueelaxa4764
    @sarahqueelaxa4764 3 роки тому

    Very helpful thankyou so much❤️🥰

  • @DesertBloomVines
    @DesertBloomVines 10 місяців тому

    Thank you! What are your thoughts about Silicosis?

  • @IAMGiftbearer
    @IAMGiftbearer 3 роки тому

    I have several bags of different ceramic clays that have dried out. Can they be rehydrated?

  • @ShannonYearwood
    @ShannonYearwood 3 роки тому +2

    thanks for the video! would you say that polymer clay or air dry clay is suitable to make candle stick holders?

  • @stevew585
    @stevew585 Рік тому

    Great video Thanks. I want to do portrait busts, around 1/2 size, would Polymer clay be ok?

  • @lisamzzetta1488
    @lisamzzetta1488 Рік тому +1

    Well you can make a fire 🔥 outside and put you clay pots. There are videos you can watch ⌚️ how to do that

  • @pamcullen537
    @pamcullen537 3 роки тому

    Are air dry clay/polymer clay able to be immersed in an epoxy mould & if so would it have to be sealed first to avoid air bubbles leaking out 🦆💕

  • @timucinbahsi445
    @timucinbahsi445 3 роки тому

    Thank you. Very nicely explained. Iamma use clay to make molds quickly because i find it very easy to handle and i can just fill it with hot glue and make a wheel for a robot, or if i need something more rigid, i can directly sculpt as is . Since it's gonna be a small portion of what i wanna accomplish i would rather use one that doesn't get my hands dirty as much. So polymer sounds fitting for gelling ready relatively quickly and supposedly being water resistant. Do you have any recommendations? Or maybe i am missing something? Cheers. Again great video.

  • @rachelembleton6071
    @rachelembleton6071 2 роки тому

    Hi iv just tuned into your video cos i needed to know the diffrence between airdry clay and real clay as a beginner i am making a very special peice for someone and it turns out you say this Airdry clay is not ideal for outdoor use or did i misshear i am makeing a plaque to go in the Garden i have no way of making it with proper clay as also have no kiln or use of!!!! Will i still be able to make this plaque and make it more durable by painting it once its dried??...varnish laquer etc??... please advise or have u made a video on this whats one thing ppl want to make its plaques surely like door numbers door signs letterbox or garden signs??

  • @billy6367
    @billy6367 3 роки тому +1

    Hi. Great video - very informative! I was just wondering which of these clays (real, air-dry and oven-bake) can be used on the pottery wheel? Thank you.

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      Hmmmm maybe all? I've only ever tried real clay on the wheel.

  • @marylloyd2342
    @marylloyd2342 3 роки тому

    Great lesson. Thank you.

  • @LongTrout
    @LongTrout Рік тому

    Good vid.

  • @shoot2killfilms
    @shoot2killfilms 2 роки тому

    Thanks for the great video😊

  • @artfullivingwitharlene
    @artfullivingwitharlene 8 місяців тому

    He’s so cute or is it she? Thanks for the info. I’m just now starting to try out clay.

  • @claudialozano969
    @claudialozano969 Рік тому

    This was very helpful thank you!! I did have a question If you use polymer clay ‘oven baked clay’ would it be strong enough to make plants pots with it?

  • @MehakGulzar
    @MehakGulzar 3 роки тому

    Can u make the video how to make real clay process of making for pottery

  • @hotbecky880707
    @hotbecky880707 3 роки тому

    Is terracotta a real clay? Does it behave the same as ceramic?

  • @edilenenegrini8525
    @edilenenegrini8525 2 роки тому

    Thanks a lot

  • @zobiyafatima7238
    @zobiyafatima7238 3 роки тому

    Do you think air dry clay would be more durable and suitable for charms and decorative pieces if I apply clear nail polish over it?

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      Yes probably, but I can't say for sure since I haven't tried. Make an experiment :)

  • @dttec7660
    @dttec7660 3 роки тому

    Nice and helpful

  • @ruinmi4297
    @ruinmi4297 2 роки тому

    Thank you so much I showed my mom this video and she bought me some air dry clay and I got to make cows✨😁

  • @dilekats957
    @dilekats957 2 роки тому

    Hi thanks for the video ! What kind of clay should I use for keychains ? Like I want them to be strong so it will not break with the keys around !

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  2 роки тому

      The best would be real clay because that would be the strongest. If you can't find somewhere to fire real clay, oven-bake clay is the best alternative.

  • @uthrasundar3296
    @uthrasundar3296 3 роки тому

    Hey! I am planning to get into ceramics and I binge watched every video of your so helpful!! I am planning to make handmade mugs out of stoneware clay. Since I don’t own a kiln myself I am planning to glaze bone dry mugs ( dried for 8-10 days) and the fire it at the end. I’m not sure if I have to use a particular glaze for single firing. What are your thoughts about that? It would be really helpful to have your opinion on it !!

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      Sorry, I don't know much about single-fire ceramics, but use that as your keyword and there is loads on info on the internet. There is also a single-fire ceramics facebook group :)

  • @comfortosei3578
    @comfortosei3578 3 роки тому

    Good information

  • @denisegallant149
    @denisegallant149 3 роки тому

    Have you ever used precious metal clay?

  • @masonbrowne6796
    @masonbrowne6796 Рік тому

    Can I use polymer clay on a wheel and shape it? I want to make bonsai pots :)

  • @Xiliket
    @Xiliket 3 роки тому

    Cool!
    Would you show us how to make a tea pot? :))))

  • @gabyteixeirarte
    @gabyteixeirarte 3 роки тому

    there is some impermeabilizant/varnish for air dry clay that make them safe to eat/drink on?

  • @animewitchdayflower6672
    @animewitchdayflower6672 2 роки тому

    Could you please link some actual food safe clays to buy online. I’m new to pottery and I’ve looked up ‘food safe clay’ , ‘ceramic clay’ and polymer clay just keeps coming up claiming to be food safe

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  2 роки тому +1

      Search online for "ceramic supplier" in your native language. It doesn't make sense for me to recommend you my supplier unless you are in germany. ;)

  • @clairevautour432
    @clairevautour432 2 роки тому

    Damn it! I bought clay that said natural clay thinking it was ceramic clay but I think it's just air dry clay. It will still be find for what I was gonna make but it is not what I thought I was gonna buy

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  2 роки тому +1

      thats too bad! but you can still use that clay for non-functional stuff :)

  • @elenakistner666
    @elenakistner666 3 роки тому

    Thx 😁

  • @carmelamarchese507
    @carmelamarchese507 3 роки тому

    Are there any cheaper alternatives to baking real clay instead of having to buy a kiln

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      Rent a kiln from a local potter ;)

    • @carmelamarchese507
      @carmelamarchese507 3 роки тому

      @@PotterytothePeople thanks for the suggestion I figured out this old lady I pull weeds for has a kiln she would make dolls in

  • @Nana_Waffles
    @Nana_Waffles 2 роки тому

    If it has any glue products in it, then the glue might have animal products in it. Thank you for all your help, I hope to find a local shop that will help with firing my ceramics.

  • @lisamzzetta1488
    @lisamzzetta1488 Рік тому

    I live in a city and there isn't even a.kilm in my whole state which I find crazy. I was thinking 🤔 if I break down and get one maybe I could make my money 💰 back by rent time out for people to use the k!lm

  • @jaenafrye2971
    @jaenafrye2971 Рік тому

    So....I find your video very informative however...u can make tableware from air dry clay as long as u coat it in food safe resin:) which they make:) it would be hand wash only and not dishwasher or microwave safe, but it IS food safe;) 😉

  • @anandi483
    @anandi483 2 роки тому

    You are very cute and confident person 🤗inspiring

  • @Darth_SurgeYo
    @Darth_SurgeYo Рік тому

    So these artisan mug makers are killing us!?

  • @4everArtista
    @4everArtista 3 роки тому

    Great information! I want to make my own cement garden statues. What is the best clay to use for sculpting and making the initial molds?

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      For a large outdoor statue I would use a stoneware with lots of grog!

  • @Rachel-nc8tr
    @Rachel-nc8tr 3 роки тому

    I felt as though she came across a bit condescending when talking about children using air dry clay and how she played with oven baked clay when she was a kid emphasizing that fact. She uses "real clay" and that's great but who the fuck can afford or have room for a kiln?!

  • @ab3585
    @ab3585 3 роки тому +2

    The animal products that they could use is probably cartilage

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      oh my...

    • @LilyUnicorn
      @LilyUnicorn 3 роки тому

      Vegans consider honey an animal byproduct so honey clay (a type of air dry clay thats mostly korean and japanese brands) are considered non vegan. Anything even MADE by an animal is considered non vegan. So silk threads and honey beware.

  • @jupiter-uw8nx
    @jupiter-uw8nx 3 роки тому

    This might be a dumb question but could I eat from air dry plates or mugs if I used a food safe paint and coating

    • @melodyide2248
      @melodyide2248 2 роки тому

      At the end of the video she said that no, it does not work like that unfortunately.

  • @VintageMe23
    @VintageMe23 3 роки тому

    Why would you do a video on clays that you have no experience with?
    Some air-dry clays are very durable, but you wouldn't know that because you haven't tested them!

    • @PotterytothePeople
      @PotterytothePeople  3 роки тому

      thanks for the feedback! Can you please name some brands that are more durable? I'm just speaking from my own experience but of course I can't test every clay available across the world! It would be great if you can share the more durable clays so folks can look them up if they're interested.

    • @LilyUnicorn
      @LilyUnicorn 3 роки тому

      Worked with all clays except monster clay. Air dry clay is by far the weakest. How can you comment on its strength when you clearly never used ceramics in large quantities.

    • @LilyUnicorn
      @LilyUnicorn 3 роки тому

      You should have mentioned plasticine (what i use) or monster clay being good for reuse, messing around, never drying and most of all...mass production. These 2 clays are typically used to make molds of highly detailed sculptures. Though plasticine has soft, medium and firm...and firm is often used for clay animation.

  • @shidiskas
    @shidiskas 3 роки тому

    I started to listen but as soon as I've heard about using "sustainable energy" I quitted..... should I then move from the place I live currently, buy a house next to a river, build my own water power station and then I can listen to the lady?

  • @ummdontknow4904
    @ummdontknow4904 3 роки тому

    Thank you