War of the Spark w/ Emma Handy & Cedric Phillips | Game Knights 26 | Magic the Gathering Brawl

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 3,1 тис.

  • @masterdisaster8311
    @masterdisaster8311 5 років тому +1552

    Can we just appreciate how much work these videos are for the editor(s) every week. All the camera angles, the litte interviews, the card closeups and all the effects in videos over an hour. Just wow

    • @subscribeandillbeyourdad4340
      @subscribeandillbeyourdad4340 5 років тому +31

      I think there's a video about how josh edited the game knight episodes, and how they filmed it. It really is took a lot of work, but he hired another editor, i think.

    • @masterdisaster8311
      @masterdisaster8311 5 років тому +7

      Fahri Saefudin do you know what that video is called?

    • @subscribeandillbeyourdad4340
      @subscribeandillbeyourdad4340 5 років тому +13

      this one: ua-cam.com/video/fj_zNNP1OwQ/v-deo.html

    • @joshmurphy484
      @joshmurphy484 5 років тому +38

      Thanks! We appreciate all the support. At the end of the day, these things take hundreds and hundreds of hours to make, but we think the outcome is certainly worth it :)

    • @Coltdogg
      @Coltdogg 5 років тому +1

      @@joshmurphy484 MURRRRRRPH!

  • @JustinWilliams-nt1zk
    @JustinWilliams-nt1zk 5 років тому +248

    Please ask Cassius Marsh to be on game knights again, those episodes are my favorite

  • @tetracuber8876
    @tetracuber8876 5 років тому +1217

    Big missed opportunity to have the mid game intermission when rakdos, the showstopper was played

  • @colinsipodmail2
    @colinsipodmail2 5 років тому +250

    Always so stoked to see more Game Knights content. Kind of disappointed we didn't get to see a Feather deck though after it's been so hyped up.

    • @BlaineTog
      @BlaineTog 5 років тому +10

      Oh, I'm sure they'll get around to it at some point.

    • @reachcole514
      @reachcole514 5 років тому +10

      That's because it's brawl.

    • @jaceradford5599
      @jaceradford5599 5 років тому +11

      I was hoping for feather and atraxa in a EDH episode lol

    • @lostingreenbay
      @lostingreenbay 5 років тому +13

      Rather see a proper feather deck, not some garbage neutered feather deck.

    • @Kattywagon29
      @Kattywagon29 5 років тому +1

      Yeah, was hoping for that.

  • @alexandersowa4106
    @alexandersowa4106 5 років тому +207

    Pushing Brawl so hard but not putting it where it's clearly meant for (Arena) still remains so baffling to me. Sure, Arena doesn't have multiplayer support, but the better question then is why doesn't it have multiplayer support, given that so many popular formats are multiplayer?

    • @Crowen.
      @Crowen. 5 років тому +1

      Why does it not have Multiplayer support? I’m not a game designer, but that seems like something they could implement

    • @alexandersowa4106
      @alexandersowa4106 5 років тому +6

      @@Crowen. I agree they could, and I'm not to privy to why they didn't- I am also not a game designer. I feel like it would be a ton of work to implement, plus you'd have to ask 3 different players if they had responses sometimes- I still think they should though, since it's better to do it now than later when it's more work

    • @JMSginoclave
      @JMSginoclave 5 років тому +3

      Even Magic Duels has/had 2-Headed Giant. Not having multiplayer considered beforehand is pretty baffling.

    • @dewolx7411
      @dewolx7411 5 років тому +3

      ​@@ForeverLaxx they don't even need multiplayer support, 1v1 brawl would be fine. For now, we have to settle for Singleton, but it's just not the same.

    • @LeBigsou
      @LeBigsou 5 років тому

      Isn't the game still a beta, technically? Maybe they'll add it in the future

  • @jeffreyedwards6402
    @jeffreyedwards6402 5 років тому +562

    You should have Cedric on more episodes. He might be my favorite guest you've had yet.

  • @degreeskelvin3025
    @degreeskelvin3025 5 років тому +348

    *something happens*
    Jimmy: This is looking really bad for the rest of us

    • @sunzet4640
      @sunzet4640 5 років тому +8

      It's always bad for Jimmy 😂

    • @gregtheveggieburger9543
      @gregtheveggieburger9543 5 років тому +19

      That's more like Josh.
      *Someone plays a land*
      Josh: This is NOT good.

    • @THElarry27
      @THElarry27 5 років тому +8

      @@gregtheveggieburger9543
      Jimmy: you guys are getting lands?

    • @Beelzebubba1983
      @Beelzebubba1983 10 місяців тому

      I love Jimmy

  • @jredmc1234
    @jredmc1234 5 років тому +1389

    Put brawl on MTG Arena or I will continue to complain into the void.

    • @asiniel23216
      @asiniel23216 5 років тому +23

      I don't think its possible. If I remember correctly Arena can't handle multiplayer because.... reasons.

    • @Yusei1Fudo
      @Yusei1Fudo 5 років тому +56

      @@asiniel23216 1v1 Brawl is a thing.

    • @dino-wer-kuh3498
      @dino-wer-kuh3498 5 років тому +31

      @@Yusei1Fudo you mean the format that got solved within a week to the point they had to emergency remove it from MTGO?

    • @richlisonbee2620
      @richlisonbee2620 5 років тому +26

      They would get more physical players if they did. The statement that they can't is just lazy and that they don't want to spend the money on updating their code.

    • @exsimon
      @exsimon 5 років тому +3

      @@dino-wer-kuh3498 yes, that one. We want it

  • @RobSomeone
    @RobSomeone 5 років тому +385

    I wonder if Cassius Marsh is ever coming back? I love how chill he is and he'll just bring in that NFL money level cards.

    • @Dracinard
      @Dracinard 5 років тому +30

      I'm sure he'll be back, he's been on more Game Knights than almost everybody else already (tied with Mel).

    • @jensklingenmaier1745
      @jensklingenmaier1745 5 років тому +1

      @@Dracinard i feel like i saw craig the most (*-*)

    • @Dracinard
      @Dracinard 5 років тому +1

      @@jensklingenmaier1745 Ah, fair. Only by one episode, though!

    • @tannerlawrence4287
      @tannerlawrence4287 4 роки тому +3

      Your wish has been granted.

  • @matthewwilson5578
    @matthewwilson5578 5 років тому +381

    50% of comments: complaining about how brawl should be in arena
    me: when is extra turns

  • @yugiohguy4543
    @yugiohguy4543 5 років тому +171

    Game Knights: **Hits with hastey blightsteel**
    Also Game Knights: **he has ELVESSSSSS**

    • @alexnumber24
      @alexnumber24 5 років тому

      @@Uhavefriendss I guess it's just for the giggles

    • @DogginsFroggins
      @DogginsFroggins 5 років тому +3

      Honestly elfball is one of the scariest things out there.

  • @Noah-tg3vf
    @Noah-tg3vf 5 років тому +5

    I got hyped for a new Game Knights, but it's brawl. I'd love to see actual Commander gameplay on this channel again.

    • @ElucidYT
      @ElucidYT 5 років тому +1

      This is only the second episode of brawl in like a year. Chill out

  • @Sethsters
    @Sethsters 5 років тому +14

    Cedric and Emma were great guests. Please bring them back whenever you get the chance.

  • @GROWLfactory
    @GROWLfactory 5 років тому +26

    The way Emma says "please don't lie to me" when she plays Kiora just defines me in a commander game.

  • @christianbergeron2519
    @christianbergeron2519 5 років тому +93

    When jimmy died, shouldn't niv-mizzet return under emma's control instead of the command zone ?

    • @karkius
      @karkius 5 років тому +31

      "Gain control" effect should have ended before exiling anything controlled by Jimmy. You are correct.

    • @valgeir80
      @valgeir80 5 років тому +8

      Yes sir.

    • @scarlethart7857
      @scarlethart7857 4 роки тому +1

      If it is a permanent that gave him control, then yes. If it is an instant or sorcery, then it goes to command.

    • @rdckrson
      @rdckrson 4 роки тому +8

      Arrennia that’s not correct. The effect is ended, and the creature returns to its owner’s control. It’s under rule 800.4a. Only permanents OWNED by the losing player are removed from the game, not permanents CONTROLLED by the losing player.

  • @marcoriley9116
    @marcoriley9116 5 років тому +10

    Awesome vid! The tension was HIGH, thanks for showing Brawl some love, miss that format

  • @MrMe2459
    @MrMe2459 5 років тому +45

    do i care about brawl? no
    was this episode very entertaining because of the guests? yes

  • @JonaxII
    @JonaxII 5 років тому +17

    Mistake at 54:50 Niv was grabbed from the Battlefield, so the moment the control effect ends, he goes back to Emma. He should only get exiled/commandzoned if he came into play under Jimmy's control, so there isn't an original controller to go back to.
    Edit: see comp rules 800.4a

    • @HamburgerTime_
      @HamburgerTime_ 5 років тому +3

      Came in here to mention this too. Emma may have won by having another body on the field.

    • @DerLhurgoyf
      @DerLhurgoyf 5 років тому +1

      Only dug through the comments to find someone mention this.

    • @JmLyan
      @JmLyan 5 років тому

      That rule only applies to continous and temporary gain control effects (like mind control and act of treason mentioned in the examples for that rule). Entrancing Melody on the other hand is a one-shot effect, it happens once and then the game no longer acknowledges its existence. It is not something that can "end" at a later time.

    • @JonaxII
      @JonaxII 5 років тому

      @@JmLyan that is not true, look at the rules notes for Melody.

    • @JmLyan
      @JmLyan 5 років тому

      My apologies then. Still find it weird that the examples of rule 800.4a mentions every other type of gain control effect, but not the one-shot types, especially since its quite an obscure rules interaction that doesn't work how most would expect it to.

  • @linkolncolon5959
    @linkolncolon5959 5 років тому +5

    Great episode, guys! I really loved the guests and the format! Thanks so much for making these videos for the MTG community, we really do appreciate seeing such high quality gameplay videos.

  • @Xgya2000
    @Xgya2000 5 років тому +17

    Sometimes, you just want to win in an old and tried way. By turning creatures sideways and pointing them at the opponent.
    Awesome game.

  • @bladerz1191
    @bladerz1191 5 років тому +179

    I would've played Nicol Bolas, Dragon God super friends.

    • @clickonthedingo
      @clickonthedingo 5 років тому +11

      I play that in brawl myself, put the elderspell in and its a one turn win ;)

    • @bladerz1191
      @bladerz1191 5 років тому

      @@clickonthedingo Exactly.

    • @Tuturial464
      @Tuturial464 5 років тому +10

      There’s a problem. Nicol Bolas has no friends

    • @tigerwarrior1787
      @tigerwarrior1787 5 років тому +1

      @@Tuturial464 You're right... he only has... dare I say it? Slaves... he has slaves... look at Lilliana... well, before she turned back.

    • @somethingorother8794
      @somethingorother8794 5 років тому +3

      @@tigerwarrior1787 so Nicol bolas super slaves?

  • @ImSquiggs
    @ImSquiggs 5 років тому +8

    The Hostage Taker pirate stealing Treasure Map sums up everything I love about Commander. I think it was done because it was ideal, but whether or not it was the right move or the wrong move, it was the Commander move.

  • @randomaether
    @randomaether 5 років тому +5

    15:17 the way he pronounces besties wow, impresive

  • @jawbraker999
    @jawbraker999 5 років тому +97

    You guys should do an oathbreaker episode

    • @isaacminer3384
      @isaacminer3384 5 років тому +2

      Kaya Walsh this please!

    • @lukestange
      @lukestange 5 років тому +1

      Amen!

    • @JamesSamson487
      @JamesSamson487 5 років тому +1

      I honestly thought this would be the oathbreaker episode. After all, no better time for it.

    • @PlutoDarknight
      @PlutoDarknight 5 років тому +1

      That is, if WotC sponsors them to do one. Otherwise, not likely

    • @friedpinnapple
      @friedpinnapple 5 років тому

      Twisted Fate maybe for extra turns? if that show isn’t dead....i hope not i liked those videos the decks seemed more powerful

  • @cinammonstyx7622
    @cinammonstyx7622 5 років тому +92

    You should invite Commander's Quarters onto the show.

    • @nathanfriedman7367
      @nathanfriedman7367 4 роки тому +11

      Mitch would destroy them with budget options

    • @maxmartinez2032
      @maxmartinez2032 4 роки тому +4

      wayfarer's bauble is too much to handle

    • @Oopsall
      @Oopsall 4 роки тому +3

      Only took them a year, but they did it!

  • @nomatyx5789
    @nomatyx5789 5 років тому +13

    How many of us forgot Brawl was a format until this came out?

  • @p.dephile2724
    @p.dephile2724 5 років тому +47

    Shoulda done Oathbreaker instead.

  • @008TheDen
    @008TheDen 5 років тому +9

    Cedric was such a fun guest! I hope you have him back.

  • @deinemam7115
    @deinemam7115 5 років тому +34

    that kayas wrath was the worst boardwipe my eyes ever witnessed

    • @johnkon292
      @johnkon292 5 років тому

      ya as she did it i just thought: i hope she loses! it was just stupid

    • @KostasTheDark
      @KostasTheDark 5 років тому

      Welcome to the worst board wipe in the history of recorded magic, folks.

  • @thedanielmaki
    @thedanielmaki 5 років тому +40

    Hey, wasn’t the Finale of revelation exiled when Jimmy targets it with Flood of Recollection at 44:09 ?

    • @978night
      @978night 5 років тому +2

      It should have been

    • @alexyoung8628
      @alexyoung8628 5 років тому +25

      It got Spell Swindled

    • @thewhiteknight3945
      @thewhiteknight3945 5 років тому +20

      Yeah, it was countered, so it never got exiled. Josh is the only one who cast it successfully

    • @thedanielmaki
      @thedanielmaki 5 років тому +4

      Alex Young yep, I forgot it

  • @enrif3099
    @enrif3099 5 років тому +4

    I love that you give brawl another shot. It also showcases more of the cards of the newer sets then a normal commander game would

  • @bagurom
    @bagurom 5 років тому +6

    I think the only people playing brawl is you guys and wizards.

  • @brentcherrette5933
    @brentcherrette5933 5 років тому +5

    “Everyone is playing a new planeswalker commander today.”
    New guest: Imma break the rules boii

    • @Blademaster145
      @Blademaster145 4 роки тому +2

      jimmy didn't play a planeswalker friend

  • @ejphilla2300
    @ejphilla2300 5 років тому +5

    Jesus. Just play your own commander decks like you used to. We miss the old, genuine content.

  • @thisdude430
    @thisdude430 5 років тому +9

    Has anyone noticed the copious amounts of salt on the unstable box behind them when theyre talking nice touch game knights respec

  • @Chalky2023
    @Chalky2023 5 років тому +134

    I See ral.
    I See josh is playing it.
    I really hope josh just does an infinite copy loop to win the game...

    • @misthelix617
      @misthelix617 5 років тому

      same

    • @mcintyre0591
      @mcintyre0591 5 років тому

      Need 2 copies of expansion/explosion. Brawl is a singleton format

    • @Jahsart23
      @Jahsart23 5 років тому +2

      I think they avoid loop combos because it's such an underwhelming way to win in casual play. they also avoid spells that slow the game ie. Sensei's top, Lim Dul's Vault Pillow fort strategy and so on

    • @Rol4nnd
      @Rol4nnd 5 років тому +4

      @@mcintyre0591 I think with -2 Ral, Doublecast and expansion you can still go infinite

    • @IlluminatiHottie
      @IlluminatiHottie 5 років тому

      I doubt he put the cards in the deck and if he did he wouldn't go infinite on the show

  • @TeaHauss
    @TeaHauss 5 років тому +7

    Dang, I did not expect that ending. That being said, woot woot! My favorite card from WotS representing!

  • @hitmonchampion9287
    @hitmonchampion9287 3 роки тому +1

    Came back to this after over a year. Still one of my favorite episodes, and I don't even play Brawl(because who does nowadays?)
    "I don't need saving.." That line still cracks me up. Cedric is the best lol

  • @tiagodutra6044
    @tiagodutra6044 5 років тому +15

    Thanks for the video, I enjoy you guys’s games, I know you guys are getting a lot of flak, but I just enjoy watching you guys play!

  • @jakubburian8874
    @jakubburian8874 5 років тому +4

    Just a quick rules call, the Mizzet should have returned under Emma's control after Jimmy died as stated in:
    800.4a When a player leaves the game, all objects (see rule 109) owned by that player leave the game and any effects which give that player control of any objects or players end. Then, if that player controlled any objects on the stack not represented by cards, those objects cease to exist. Then, if there are any objects still controlled by that player, those objects are exiled. This is not a state-based action. It happens as soon as the player leaves the game. If the player who left the game had priority at the time he or she left, priority passes to the next player in turn order who’s still in the game.

  • @NolalanD
    @NolalanD 4 роки тому +3

    You know, when Jimmy did the too doodle oo Zelda noise I had to laugh! They make these games fun to watch.

  • @Fives-oy8du
    @Fives-oy8du 5 років тому +6

    Man, I can't wait till brawl comes back in some way. There's a game there, and I am keeping my scorpion god brawl deck just for it. This video keeps my hopes up

    • @DreadPirate321
      @DreadPirate321 5 років тому

      Nice to see some love for the scorpion god! He was the second commander deck I ever built and he's one of my favorites.

    • @Silver_light77
      @Silver_light77 5 років тому

      isn't amonkhet block out of standard?

    • @Phelddagrif1998
      @Phelddagrif1998 5 років тому

      Silverslipstream yes it is, that’s really 😆

  • @DogginsFroggins
    @DogginsFroggins 5 років тому +4

    This was actually awesome, I play commander all the time so it's good to get away from some format staples and see some standard shenanigans.

  • @auroralee
    @auroralee 5 років тому +6

    "You see that? Its called good deckbuilding"

  • @michaelmurray3766
    @michaelmurray3766 5 років тому +3

    I think this was my favorite episode ever. Great demo of the new cards. Cedric and Emma had amazing plays. Josh had best mat ever. Jimmy. Well I don't know what Jimmy did in this episode.

    • @lexluthor9279
      @lexluthor9279 5 років тому

      43:57 He is thinking: WTF are you doing? Thanks for asking, see also Telepathy´s flavor text (Ninth edition)

  • @Leeroth123
    @Leeroth123 5 років тому +11

    Niv Mizzet should have returned under her control after Jimmy died

  • @reverendvile777
    @reverendvile777 5 років тому

    I have never had so much fun watching tabletop magic as I have watching this channel. You guys rock!

  • @MaNU7908
    @MaNU7908 5 років тому +22

    If only we could play Brawl in MtgArena...
    hahaha that would be nice
    Your content, is so great all the time guys, youre awesome

  • @jjkwak4838
    @jjkwak4838 5 років тому +1

    lot of people whining about brawl and downvoting the video not seeing how amazing the content and the production quality is...

  • @LifeAura123
    @LifeAura123 5 років тому +10

    Wait are the card sound effects from the Shandalar MTG PC card game? They sound very similar

  • @nilsjonsson4446
    @nilsjonsson4446 5 років тому

    Love that you’re playing brawl! Much more fun to see so many new cards rather than just another Commander game with new commanders.

  • @mkol1998
    @mkol1998 5 років тому +17

    Josh at the start of the video trying to say brawl without barfing.

  • @velkejkoren
    @velkejkoren 5 років тому +4

    Incubation druid had a couter so it cant be adapted

  • @LeftyRedd
    @LeftyRedd 5 років тому +12

    I can't get into brawl. Keeping up with standard rotation is lame.

    • @JohnSmith-ty9cr
      @JohnSmith-ty9cr 5 років тому

      I always have trouble understanding this. Is it really that bad to change up your deck once in a while? Doesn't it get boring playing the same cards constantly?

    • @LeftyRedd
      @LeftyRedd 5 років тому +1

      @@JohnSmith-ty9cr I can't speak for everyone else, but my friends and I are real casual players. We each have several decks and with commander having 100 card decks, it always feels different no matter how many times certain decks are played against each other.
      Plus, keeping up with standard can get pretty expensive for me. I usually just use cards that I have.

    • @JohnSmith-ty9cr
      @JohnSmith-ty9cr 5 років тому +1

      @@LeftyRedd Fair points. Though I think the cost wouldn't be such an issue for Brawl. Feels like you could just dig through the $1 bin for each new set and come up with something sweet (and if you do go for something pricier, you need only one copy) I could be wrong though.

    • @LeftyRedd
      @LeftyRedd 5 років тому +1

      @@JohnSmith-ty9cr I gotta admit, also good points.

  • @boombox_up_to_11
    @boombox_up_to_11 5 років тому +6

    @The Command Zone 37:23 Evolution Sage (3/2) + 2 +1/+1 counters = 5/3?

    • @voldemort008
      @voldemort008 5 років тому +1

      Shawn Karber yeah I was wondering about that myself lol.

  • @leminhtam786
    @leminhtam786 5 місяців тому +1

    After watching everything of Command Knights, and going back to these older episodes, I miss when they built decks like these instead of playing only with precons

  • @shellder11
    @shellder11 5 років тому +6

    Emma and Cedric were great guests! Great job and thanks for more great content.

  • @dakotamcintire7419
    @dakotamcintire7419 5 років тому +1

    Jimmy: you know what, how about my lazotep just not working?
    Nicol Bolas: Know that feel bro.

  • @amingsus5831
    @amingsus5831 3 роки тому +1

    39:03 Cedric has a vanifar on his battlefield and in the graveyard

  • @deanm8408
    @deanm8408 4 роки тому +2

    41:21 I didn't know ladee danger was already knighted twice!

  • @warstallion6729
    @warstallion6729 5 років тому +9

    Well the one guy who plays brawl still must be happy

  • @sushimartyr6311
    @sushimartyr6311 2 роки тому

    I kinda love the circular structure of Cedric starting off by calling card draw the best part of the game, and then after having his faith in it tested for a few turns after that board wipe, it ultimately became how he won. It feels satisfying, from a narrative standpoint.

  • @leobozkir5425
    @leobozkir5425 4 роки тому +2

    5:55 She looked like the prof from Tolarian Community College for just a split second

  • @japesgrapes1196
    @japesgrapes1196 4 роки тому +1

    the best part of magic is actually winning from cards you draw into

  • @burnpisces7733
    @burnpisces7733 5 років тому +4

    Why do I feel like Cedric is an absolute buffoon for letting his opponent that he intended to 1v1 draw 6 cards with that much mana? Like I feel like that was a really really dumb play to get rid of jimmmy because he didn’t even seem like a threat at all. I mean eh. Not my game but I could feel Jimmy’s frustration.

    • @kevins9148
      @kevins9148 5 років тому

      I legitimately yelled damnit Cedric when that happened

  • @DarkSoulHarvester
    @DarkSoulHarvester 5 років тому +1

    At 51:20 She traded with the Hostage Taker, meaning Cedric gets the map back.

    • @JmLyan
      @JmLyan 5 років тому

      Hostage Taker only gives back what it has stolen if that card is still exiled. If you cast it before then, you will get to keep it when Hostage Taker leaves.

  • @NoobFish23
    @NoobFish23 5 років тому +3

    The way he says “besties” at 15:17 makes it sound like he’s pronouncing some great final judgment upon her soul.

  • @Cbaoth65
    @Cbaoth65 5 років тому +4

    Don't blame the command zone for the brawl....blame wizard of the coast for trying to keep alive this born dead format
    😉
    Nice épisode anyway

  • @54m0h7
    @54m0h7 5 років тому +1

    Nice to see Brawl. Hoping it's not dead, but we'll see. Adding it to Arena will make a big difference.

  • @spliffi869
    @spliffi869 4 роки тому

    Haha that moment when Cedric is rooting for the coin to be in his favor made me laugh out loud.
    Nice round again and nice vid as always! ty for the quality content @ the command zone team

  • @mr.mammuthusafricanavus8299
    @mr.mammuthusafricanavus8299 5 років тому +8

    Does anyone else think it's weird that MTG Arena doesn't have a Brawl/EDH mode? ;)

  • @14Blackspirit
    @14Blackspirit 4 роки тому

    That was an awesome episode btw. A lot of back and forth and everything could happen at any moment.

  • @flailingweasel8541
    @flailingweasel8541 5 років тому +4

    Brawl should just be Kaladesh forward. The rotation is what's killing it.

    • @Tuturial464
      @Tuturial464 5 років тому

      Flailing Weasel I say return to Ravanica forward.

    • @PlutoDarknight
      @PlutoDarknight 5 років тому

      Why not start at Magic Origins?

    • @dakotacampbell9936
      @dakotacampbell9936 5 років тому +2

      Just start at alpha. Then since there are so many cards make it 100 card decks. And pump up the life to 40. Ohhhh wait

  • @jkattack2640
    @jkattack2640 5 років тому +11

    Brawl works fine for people who go on shows like this and build new decks every month. Where it doesnt work is the real world where people build 1-3 commander decks in a year...

    • @JohnSmith-ty9cr
      @JohnSmith-ty9cr 5 років тому +2

      I don't get that line of argument. Why does rotation scare people so much? Brawl decks are cheap. You need only one copy of a chase rare and you can even get by just with draft chaff tier rares if you want.

    • @rhealastname266
      @rhealastname266 4 роки тому

      @@JohnSmith-ty9cr I find rotation to be cheaper myself. A budget standard deck is like 40 bucks. Some pauper decks are more expensive! Lmao. I agree with you completely.

  • @justinanderson2631
    @justinanderson2631 5 років тому +7

    Over 30 planeswalkers!...except dack fayden. Sorry we can't have 3 izzet planeswalkers

  • @bobfigget6690
    @bobfigget6690 5 років тому +3

    51:03 "I just need to make sure that I DO. DIE."
    Me

  • @Slo-Mode
    @Slo-Mode 4 роки тому +3

    Love the personalities in this one! I found it really entertaining

  • @Philson
    @Philson 5 років тому +5

    Planeswalkers should be allowed to be Commanders by default....

  • @joshmcdermott9000
    @joshmcdermott9000 4 роки тому +1

    JLK got the best play mat on this one

  • @MrBe56
    @MrBe56 3 роки тому

    This episode is everything I ever wanted to see from magic, since Rabnica is my favorite place.

  • @AeileonNOTW
    @AeileonNOTW 3 роки тому

    Ok that untap at 56:25 was super smooth

  • @NakedBandito247
    @NakedBandito247 5 років тому +3

    Jimmy: “I think I’m still in this game.”
    Also Jimmy: “I’m dead aren’t I?”

  • @erikaangelatumaliuan8280
    @erikaangelatumaliuan8280 5 років тому

    I love that my favorite merfolk, Tatyova, got to make multiple appearances in this episode :)))

  • @alfonsonebaracca4871
    @alfonsonebaracca4871 5 років тому +4

    Brawl 😞

  • @KomoliRihyoh
    @KomoliRihyoh 5 років тому

    56:25 that was such a *smooth* untap step

  • @holden4412
    @holden4412 5 років тому +13

    Really wish you guys didn't do brawl.

    • @genie7190
      @genie7190 5 років тому

      What's wrong with Brawl?

    • @Sniperfuchs
      @Sniperfuchs 5 років тому +1

      @@cubingexpress8875 I mean... In a set which introduces more than 30 planeswalkers, it does kind of make sense to use a format like Brawl to showcase that.

    • @hummer_1041
      @hummer_1041 5 років тому

      The limitations and rotation of sets make it hard to keep up with rather build voltron than a brawl deck
      Tbh oathbreaker is even better than brawl but they dont wanna cover it

    • @Deathkeeper43
      @Deathkeeper43 5 років тому

      Another Game Knights wasted.

    • @hummer_1041
      @hummer_1041 5 років тому

      Sniperfuchs but brawl doesnt focus on walkers its just standard edh and you CAN have your general as a walker but oathbreak makes you use a walker as your general and a spell so its even better in war cause some walkers have x card like Domri and Domri’s ambush so you can really hit some nice flavor with the deck you build.

  • @EldritchelAngel
    @EldritchelAngel 5 років тому +2

    Did Jimmy cast Finale of Revelation? If so, it gets exiled after it's cast, so Flood of Recollection wouldn't have been able to return it to his hand.

  • @ZoblinZobZob
    @ZoblinZobZob 5 років тому

    I was really expecting Josh to be rocking Feather the Redeemed. I thought you guys were gushing about him.

  • @thenightwolfrs4607
    @thenightwolfrs4607 5 років тому +3

    Can't believe no one noticed Finale of Revelation exiles itself so Jimmy shouldn't have been able to return it to his hand

    • @SunshineYelos
      @SunshineYelos 5 років тому +4

      Finale of Revelation was countered, so nope, Jimmy could take it i guess

    • @TuberTugger
      @TuberTugger 5 років тому +1

      I thought this too but it never resolved so it never exiled itself.

  • @leonmercury3732
    @leonmercury3732 5 років тому +1

    Late-game:
    Emma - I'll pretend that I'm a threat so Cedric kills my stuff instead of me
    Jimmy - I'll pretend I'm nonthreatening so nobody kills me
    Cedric - I'll just keep countering my enemy who counters me so maybe I can keep something on the board
    Josh - I'm dead

  • @dillpickle694
    @dillpickle694 5 років тому

    The subtle face change made me laugh at 22:36
    I did not see that the first couple of times I saw this episode

  • @LizardKing1470
    @LizardKing1470 5 років тому +2

    When you don't want to be a jerk and take two extra turns 25:24

    • @Depp0vom0Dienst
      @Depp0vom0Dienst 4 роки тому

      Since that was not his turn, he couldn't use Ral's ability to copy Karn's Temporal Sundering.

  • @Legeden
    @Legeden 5 років тому

    Really good game despite it being brawl it was very commander-like. Only thing I can't get behind in this format is basically card rotation, but feel free to make more brawl videos, it's entertaining to watch.

  • @raiga2
    @raiga2 5 років тому +4

    Man they missed a chance to do oathbreaker but instead brawl T-T

  • @Kazz1187
    @Kazz1187 5 років тому +2

    How come Niv-mizzet reborn goes back into Emma’s commandzone after Emma kills Jimmy. Since niv-mizzet was on the battlefield, doesn’t it go back to its owner’s control on their side of the battlefield?

    • @huckasex
      @huckasex 5 років тому +2

      the played that wrong, yes

  • @wolf22051997
    @wolf22051997 5 років тому +6

    It's so cool seeing you play dead formats.

  • @561fergie
    @561fergie 4 роки тому

    Still can't wait for the Game Knights episode where we get Cedric and P-Sully as guests and everyone is really rocking sports jerseys 🤣

  • @joakimbergh5647
    @joakimbergh5647 5 років тому

    Not gonna lie; I couldn't guess who would take the game. The variables of MtG just don't let guesses assume the winner. This game knight episode was a tasty, spicy treat that I'm gonna share with my non-magic-players friends. This is what magic is about! Constructed chaos and lots of fun with friends!

  • @MJVelascoSalvador
    @MJVelascoSalvador 5 років тому +1

    On 24:00, doesnJosh really get 7 treasures? Isn’t finale of revelation’s cmc actually 2 because X is 0 or does that change when you cast the spell?

    • @GoliathGTX
      @GoliathGTX 5 років тому

      It is CMC = [total mana to cast it] when it's on the stack. It is CMC 2 outside of the stack.

  • @anselally4408
    @anselally4408 5 років тому

    No one is more of a heavy hitter than Cassius Marsh.