British Special Forces - Bulgarian-Ottoman Relations - Caporetto I OUT OF THE TRENCHES
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 січ 2018
- Ask your questions here: outofthetrenches.thegreatwar.tv
» HOW CAN I SUPPORT YOUR CHANNEL?
You can support us by sharing our videos with your friends and spreading the word about our work.You can also support us financially on Patreon: / thegreatwar
You can also buy our merchandise in our online shop: shop.spreadshirt.de/thegreatwar/
Patreon is a platform for creators like us, that enables us to get monthly financial support from the community in exchange for cool perks.
» WHERE CAN I GET MORE INFORMATION ABOUT WORLD WAR I AND WHERE ELSE CAN I FIND YOU?
We’re offering background knowledge, news, a glimpse behind the scenes and much more on:
reddit: bit.ly/TheGreatSubReddit
Facebook: bit.ly/WW1FB
Twitter: bit.ly/WW1Series
Instagram: bit.ly/ZpMYPL
» CAN I EMBED YOUR VIDEOS ON MY WEBSITE?
Of course, you can embed our videos on your website. We are happy if you show our channel to your friends, fellow students, classmates, professors, teachers or neighbours. Or just share our videos on Facebook, Twitter, Reddit etc.
We are also happy to get your feedback, criticism or ideas in the comments. If you have interesting historical questions, just post them and we will answer in our OUT OF THE TRENCHES videos. You can find a selection of answers to the most frequently asked questions here: bit.ly/OOtrenches
» CAN I SHOW YOUR VIDEOS IN CLASS?
Of course! Tell your teachers or professors about our channel and our videos. We’re happy if we can contribute with our videos. If you are a teacher and have questions about our show, you can get in contact with us on one of our social media presences.
» WHAT ARE YOUR SOURCES?
Videos: British Pathé
Pictures: Mostly Picture Alliance
Background Map: d-maps.com/carte.php?num_car=6...
Literature (excerpt):
Gilbert, Martin. The First World War. A Complete History, Holt Paperbacks, 2004.
Hart, Peter. The Great War. A Combat History of the First World War, Oxford University Press, 2013.
Hart, Peter. The Great War. 1914-1918, Profile Books, 2013.
Stone, Norman. World War One. A Short History, Penguin, 2008.
Keegan, John. The First World War, Vintage, 2000.
Hastings, Max. Catastrophe 1914. Europe Goes To War, Knopf, 2013.
Hirschfeld, Gerhard. Enzyklopädie Erster Weltkrieg, Schöningh Paderborn, 2004
Michalka, Wolfgang. Der Erste Weltkrieg. Wirkung, Wahrnehmung, Analyse, Seehamer Verlag GmbH, 2000
Leonhard, Jörn. Die Büchse der Pandora: Geschichte des Ersten Weltkrieges, C.H. Beck, 2014
If you want to buy some of the books we use or recommend during our show, check out our Amazon Store: bit.ly/AmazonTGW
NOTE: This store uses affiliate links which grant us a commission if you buy a product there.
» WHAT IS “THE GREAT WAR” PROJECT?
THE GREAT WAR covers the events exactly 100 years ago: The story of World War I in realtime. Featuring: The unique archive material of British Pathé. Indy Neidell takes you on a journey into the past to show you what really happened and how it all could spiral into more than four years of dire war. Subscribe to our channel and don’t miss our new episodes every Thursday.
» WHO IS REPLYING TO MY COMMENTS? AND WHO IS BEHIND THIS PROJECT?
Most of the comments are written by our social media manager Florian. He is posting links, facts and backstage material on our social media channels. But from time to time, Indy reads and answers comments with his personal account, too.
The Team responsible for THE GREAT WAR is even bigger:
- CREDITS -
Presented by : Indiana Neidell
Written by: Indiana Neidell
Director: Toni Steller & Florian Wittig
Director of Photography: Toni Steller
Sound: Toni Steller
Mixing, Mastering & Sound Design: www.above-zero.com
Editing: Jibran Khan
Motion Design: Philipp Appelt
Research by: Indiana Neidell
Fact checking: Markus Linke
The Great War Theme composed by Karim Theilgaard: bit.ly/karimyt
A Mediakraft Networks Original Channel
Based on a concept by Spartacus Olsson
Author: Indiana Neidell
Visual Concept: David van Stephold
Producer: Toni Steller & Florian Wittig
Social Media Manager: Florian Wittig
Contains licenced Material by British Pathé
All rights reserved - © Mediakraft Networks GmbH, 2018
The Bulgarian forces have fought together with Ottoman troops here and there, close cooperation was limited. The Bulgarians did clash with their ally, Austro-Hungary, in Serbia, and close, intensive cooperation with the Turks has been considered risky and not very wise idea. Makensen himself has been aware of the risks.
In his telegram to the commander of III-rd Bulgarian army, Gen.Stefan Toshev, Makensen writes: _"The Turkish troops are good, but they are fit mainly for defense. They should be looked upon as the Bulgarian troops from second line and the Turkish troops to be used for defense."_
The Ottoman troops in times showed excellent defensive qualities indeed. Their co-actions with the Bulgarians mostly were expressed in either additive support for the Bulgarians, or Bulgarian involvement (under Bulgarian initiative) in case the earth beneath the Ottoman's feet gets too hot. An example for that is when (on 04.10.1916.) *Ivan Kolev's cavalry* has filled in the defense gaps of the *25th Turkish infantry division* during a successfull but short-lasting Russian penetration at the villages of Cumana (Mustafa Hacı) and Tataru (Azaplar) south of Constanta. And this is just one example.
Earlier, on 20.09.1916, evening, the *25th Turkish infantry division and battalions of 59 and 75 Nizam regiments* have been put under Bulgaria's III-rd army command, and deployed on the position between the villages of Azaplar (Tataru) and Erebler. The task given by the Bulgarian high command has been to counter any attack between the troops in Dobrich and the division of Gen.Ivan Kolev. The *15th Turkish infantry division* has been put under the command of the *25th Turkish inf.division's* leadership, and deployed on the same defesive line, just behind the right flank.
On 21.09.1916, morning, the Romanians (6th joint Romanian brigade, 5th joint Romanian brigade) attack the left flank of of the Dobrich positions, direction - the village of Engets, where the *74th Turkish regiment* is located. Accurate artillery fire has forced the Romanians to stop. During the day's second half, the Bulgarian troops in Dobrich, assisted by 6th Bdin, *25th Turkish* divisions and part of Gen.Ivan Kolev's cavalry division have launched counter-offensive, turning the Romanians into rout.
In the first and second battles of Cobadin, together with German aid for the Bulgarians, there were Ottoman troops too.
The mentioned Turkish divisions also have some significant notable accomplishments under their own initiative too, mainly after a successfull defense and counter-attack, but according to records, mis-organisation often halted a chase after Romanian forces in rout due to either lack of shells for the artillery or slow movement.
These are just few notes. There's a lot more that can be written. Entire battles are often recorded hour by hour in Bulgarian logs, or whole campaigns, assault after assault, defense after defense.
So, yes - The Bulgarian forces have had shared lines with the Ottoman ones, but not to a degree they've had with the Germans.
THANK YOU FOR THIS! I wish there was more info about wartime Bulgaria in English that was ratably available
Concerning the aggressive Canadian troops, I have heard this story. A German prisoner asked a Canadian soldier why they fought so fiercely. The soldier replied "The French and the British can go home for the weekend, we're stuck here for the duration".
allan lanktree A German veteran of world war 2 said the Germans feared the Canadian soldiers more then the Americans.
@@otakunthevegan4206 why?
Every time I watch 'Out of the trenches' I picture Flo behind the camera strumming his spanish guitar!
it's actually Toni playing but otherwise it's accurate
There is the diary of second lieutenant Mehmet Şevgi Yazman(1896-1974) who fought at the Eastern Front along with the Austrians.It is a 300 pages book and he barely mentioned Bulgarians and Bulgaria . He only mentioned:
" (...)we passed through Bulgaria(...) we stopped a station belongs to Bulgarians, went a restaurant and meals were so delicious etc."
Indy looks a bit tired in this video. Don't overwork yourself guys.
meh maybe had some vodka or schnapps.
Rude...
I love a report from one of the British commanders at Gallipoli where he in part credited a failed offensive which nearly succeeded on the lack of Gurkhas in his forces saying something extremely British like: On that mountainous ground those little fellows would have been at their jolly best.
I have mad respect for the Nepalese people, incredibly generous and hospitable when they want to be while being incredible fighters when they have to be.
Singapore even has special units of Nepalese police.
@@RolfHartmann yeah I've seen it in the port of Singapore
As a guy who come from a Bulgarian family if Historians,I can tell You that (it is quite well known to be honest,We study it at school) The Ottoman Empire gave Bulgaria 2,500 square killometers of land in Trace (Trakia).And both nations were unhappy with the Balkan wars (Bulgarians mostly with the Second and the Ottoman Empire with the First).My Grandmother told me about my grand grand father (Her grandfather),who was taken as POW after the war (WWI) and taken to Romania.There were a LOT of deseases while in POW camp and most of the people who went there,died.Lice were basicly endemic and so was Typhus.
There're many anecdotes about Turks and Bulgarians in Mehmet Sevki Yazman's 'Kumandanım Galiçya ne yana düşer' (Where is this Galicia, commander?). They simply did not like each other and turkish soldiers passing by Bulgaria were concerned about their safety.
As I know, this book is available only in turkish and polish.
So my Great Grandpa was from Bulgaria (and is why I'm Orthodox) but his dad fought in WW1. Though I live in Texas. He told my grandfather that he hated the Turks and Germans equally. A lot of Bulgarian people hated the war in general. However they saw it as integral to the nation's survival.
you should come back here, in Bulgaria
come back to Bulgaria ! We will welcome you with open arms
yes, open bottles too, if you are into that sort of thing ;)
I'd love to go to Bulgaria and drink a few beers and some rakija!
call us up if you ever drop by sofiya
There's a website called literaly bulgarianhistory it's run by a group of highly motivated young people, they do research into exactly stuff like this. Like for example they had an article about a French soldier in WWI who's letters were found or captured I cant remember, describing how apparently they thought we were cannibals and were utterly horrified at the possibility of capture. I'm pretty sure they'd be willing to translate or at least point to sources were you to contact them.
Link me this site?
bulgarianhistory.org
Deathskull0001 thanks for the link!
1:30
"Winter was coming."
Bloody Starks. There're everywhere.
Best channel ever? Yes! Definitely! Thank you forever! Who else views chapters more than once?
We usually watch them more than once haha.
Many of the elite British units were in the BEF in 1914, and most had been killed by 1915.
Australian, New Zealand and Canadian troops were thus often considered fitter and stronger than their British Tommy conscript counterparts, and that’s why they were considered shock troops. They were also, in some cases, better led by tactical innovators rather than the crusty establishment British.
In addition, many of the conscript Tommies were working class, living and working in poor conditions at home and were not well fed.
One of the reasons why the British liberal welfare reforms were so popular in 1908 was that there was a big moral panic in the decades before the war that a large percentage of the British population were physically unfit for military service. Some of these troops would not have been accepted for service in 1914 but were conscripted later.
By contrast, the dominion troops often lived in superior conditions at home. By 1917 they were battle hardened troops.
Australia also never had conscription during WW1 and the vast majority of troops (80%+) from NZ and Canada were volunteers.
pretty sure indy also shares your opinion in this very clip. did you watch the whole clip solaris 24?
Julius Caesar once said "it is not these well fed long haired men that I fear but the pale and the hungry looking." The best fighters, in war and sports, almost always exclusively come from poverty or a life of hardship. Combat of any kind is usually more mental than physical, although the well fed long haired men do make impressive looking imperial guards!
Solaris 24, in intelligence reports captured from the Germans in 1918 and regarding the New Zealanders. The assessment was in specific comparisons to a British division next to it on the front. The things noted where the relative independent nature of the colonial British in comparison to divisions raised in Britain. The qualities of there training (specifically the number trained to use the lewis gun). And their level of motivation, I.e. my Kiwi forebears could be, to put it delicately, real haters... the assessment in summary stated that the New Zealanders where quantitatively and qualitatively superior to their British counterparts, and that they wanted to accurately define their location on the frontline.
Caesar wasn't talking about soldiers, but rather the capacity for revolution. Those who are placated are unlikely to rebel against authority.
Thanks for answering my question! Great answer.
Hi Indy and crew! I have a question regarding OOTT: do you really come up with the answers on the spot like it is shown in the video, or do you prepare your answers. I am extremely impressed that you would know that much simply off the top of your head.
I especially enjoyed the soft jazz guitar in the background
Ha, I just realised that!
Great episode! Thanks
Love this channel so much!
7:22 : British infantry tactics involved flying overhead in red airplanes?
I see it's the right link now. Love the show.
Great episode
Dear Indy and crew, thank you for maintaining a level of excellence and a plethora of historical insight delivered with panache and verve.
Perhaps you may have mentioned it in your talks, but I feel this bears repeating: the Last Post Association in Ieper (Ypres) is the society that has the honourable task of maintaining the traditional sounding of the Last Post at the Menin Gate every evening, and an especially momentous ceremony there on 11/11/2018.
The Association publishes regular E-mail bulletins, and one may join oneself. There is even an app!
Thanks again, Indy, and I hope you get as much from this project as you give to us.
Three cheers for the TGW crew! Hip-Hip!
Hooray!
Hip-Hip!
Hooray!
Hip-Hip!
HOOPLAH!
Perhaps a fun anecdote for OOTT Guinness (as in the drinks company) had a small fleet of ships and one barge was commandeered for use in the great war and another was sunk, It would be interesting if you could find out more about their stories I couldn't find out what the barge was used for but the other ship I think just hit a mine.
Hey guys! You said to remind you about the German Asian Corps Special, so I was wondering in you still had plans to make it. Love your show! Keep up the great work! Greetings from México!! 🇲🇽
I remember watching a Canadian series called the Valour and Horror, which said that Australia and Canada were less industrialized than Britain or France during World War I, and so more of their troops were agricultural workers who were more prepared for trench life (digging, dealing with the elements, etc.) so they got a reputation as being superior troops (but that by World War II that had all changed).
"winter is coming..." 1:31
Do a special on Vladimir Vazov(and the Vazov brothers in general, they are all great men that have influenced our culture a lot )
Nice video. Nice job.
Hey Indie and crew, I have watched your show for a year now, and I believe I have a good understanding of the war and it’s been a while since you’ve done a special on the actual trenches of the war. Could you cover how men put them together, kept them from caving in, etc.
Like the Regimental Kukri in the background.
Indy and guys love your work! amazing stuff
but please make sure you take care of yourselves, you look tired Indy and im sure everyone here will understand if you guys are a day or two late with an episode just so you can rest
It was generally said that the Dominion folk were accustomed to looking after themselves in the outdoors, as well as having practical experience with guns and horses, compared to the average soldier from the UK ☆
Except of course that most of them were urban or sub-urban, not that being a hardy outdoorsman will help you much in an arty barrage or in the muddy trenches of ww1.
It would be cool to have a ticker tape scrolling along the bottom updating us with extra facts and figures, as well as a blow-by-blow of the action on the western front, even when quiet.
The face expressions and clothes hasn't changed since 1914
Hey Indy, would you ever consider making an episode about the newfoundland regiment? Keep up the great work!
Steve Kaczynski I know. Out of over 800, around 180 made it back, very tragic. We lost so many in one day.
Howdy, Indy and team! I and many others would love to hear you tell us the story of the French Blue Devils. What were they equipped with? What was their purpose? Were they really the equivalent of German Sturmtruppen? I would be delighted to hear Indy explain that. And a little post-scriptum, because Indy butchered my surname a bit last time, it is pronounced like "Vatslavik" Cheerio, fellas.
if you give us photos of these guys and a good English source, your video will be ready in no time
The Great War Unfortunately, I know no sources of information regarding them. I only know that they were a part of Chasseurs Alpins and took part in the Battle of Yser. Unfortunately I don't know any book about them, but there should be scraps of info online.
I'm disappointed you guys are not coming to the States, but I cannot say I am surprised. It seemed a ridiculously expensive proposition, especially in proportion to the role of the U.S. in the war. I wish I could go to one of your Europe meet-ups.
Oh, believe me-I know that! I'm American and grew up in military communities. Russia going out of the war without the U.S.A. coming in could well have handed victory to the Central Powers.
Nearly 800k now
You put the wrong link at the end, that's sends me to the video on the red baron. Interesting as it is, it's not the video that you plugged at the end.
Outside of that, great video as always
Did Indy just say "Winter is coming"
Hello team again. Always make it to every video within 30 mins lol
Methinks Indy is more than a little bit hungover here :D
Regarding British elite units, one cannot completely dismiss the Royal Marines, although not often used, they did have a few raids, that would be considered actions of elite units.
Hey Indy could Bulgaria have stayed out of the war and if so would that have made a difference. Love the show keep up the great work.
if Bulgaria took Entente side , it would have made big difference with COnstantinople/Istanbul issue. The Ottoman empire would be overwhelmed because it would not have Bulgaria (as an ally) as a barrier to guard their Western border and Istanbul would have probably been captured !
Question for Out of the Trenches: I know that alcohol was very important to troop morale on the front lines. And that back home it was viewed as an impediment to the war effort. I was wondering the role of soft drinks during ww1. Keep up the good work!
Hi Indy. Have you ever heard of the incident during the ruso japanese war with the british fishermen? i know its out of the scale of the war but it was something our history teacher loved to bring up.
Essentially what happened was that the russian baltic fleet was required in the sea of japan so it made it long journey around. as it got to the north sea the baltic fleet spotted small vessels in the distances and somehow thought they were japanese warships, (submarines i think he said). so the fleet enaged them and took outa few ships before realising that it was a british fishing ship.
The press found out about this and the major nations closed their ports to the baltic fleet, so not only could they not go through the suez canal, they had to go around the cape of cope hope on coal fumes no chance of making port to refuel. so by the time they arrived in the sea of japan they were in no fit state to fight.
its not that relevant but its one of those moments which oyu see in the great war were nothing went to plan and people to eager to fight and make mistakes.
anyway love the chanel, keep it up :)
Captainflake99 The Baltic fleet being late and undersupplied played a major role in Russia losing the war, which of course helped set up Russia's position to start the Great war
Captainflake99 It almost led to war especially both empires are in a state of Cold War in Central Asia and in China also. The british public especially in the newspapers were calling the Russians “Drunk as usual” and other anti Russian sentiments. However, the Russians were the first ones who approach them and apologise to the British goverment and pay compensations to the families of the British fishermen who are involved in the Dogger Bank incident. The British also were held back by their new entente cordiale which was also an ally of Russia. Which was France
Kevin Philippe C Santos that's it I remember my teacher saying that the sailors were drunk hence their mistake. But you are correct they were hesitant about accepting the compensation as they were also in a defensive alliance or something or other with Japan. When I tell other people about this no one has ever heard of this.. I'm glad a few people did 😀
Weird Al Spank a Bitch absolutely. Perhaps if this didn't happen the war on the eastern front would have been different and even if the war had proceeded as it did up to 1917 the sailors of Kronstadt involvement in the revolution may not have been as significant
Captainflake99 interesting story.
Four Cheers For Flo!
Was this the first episode to have background music? I spent half the video pausing it trying to find the source of it until I decided it was actually coming from the show. :)~
Hey TGW crew I have a question for OOTT. What sort of music was popular with troops, during ww1?
5:22 never change Indy ❤
I have a question for OOTT. My grandmother told me that her grandfather served in the German army on the Eastern Front, and was taken prisoner at some point. He was moved to a POW camp in Siberia, but because he was a carpenter, nearby farms would often "borrow" him for work, so he apparently remembered his time in Siberia fondly, with decent food and a sleeping place near the stove. My grandma said that he didn't return home until the early 1920s though, and apparently by initially travelling east to Vladivostok and then back to Germany by boat.
My question is this: what do we know about what happened to Central Powers POWs after the Russian Revolution? Was there some sort of coordinated return of prisoners, or did they just sort of get lost in the chaos of the civil war to make their own way home, as my great-great-grandfather apparently did? Thanks for doing this show guys, and keep up the good work!
Indy will you do a special episode for Estonia because it's gonna be the 100th birthday of Estonia on the 24th of February?
Love your videos, keep up the grat work
I hope you still plan to do another video about Czechoslovak legions.
we do
Great. I am looking forward to it :)
Hey super Indy and crew! I've got a burning question for months now: Did music play a big role during the war? Were songs used to boost morale? Were there like hits throughout the trenches? I'd love to know. Keep up the good work comrades!
I can't wait for your video specials on Indochina and French colonial Africa.
Nice background music
I did read a few months ago about the British coming up with the idea for special forces prior to WW1 but they did not follow it through. Having said that WW2 saw the SAS, the SBS, Army and Royal Marine commandos along with the paratroopers, as well as other specialist groups. So when we got there we did not mess about.
Also many British regiments were elite forces, such as the Highlanders. The Highlanders were one of the few that the German Prussian regiments did not like to face.
So apparently the red baron really influenced the evolution of British infantry tactics?
That's RIGHT you better answer all my questions about the First World War! Rawwwrr!
I'd suggest that dominion troops may have been more agressive due to their upbringing. A lot of ANZAC soldiers came from rugged rural environments and thus grew up active and vigorous, that paired with a desire of both men and officers to prove their worth as equals with the British.
In reality, most ANZAC where not rugged rurals, that is a myth, then as now, the Australian population was mostly urban. As so their army was also mostly urban.
+LtKharn. What you say is entirely true, but it obscures the nature of the urban development at the time. My own father, born 1912, used to trap and shoot rabbits as a youth around places as close in as Marrickville (the Warren is still a location) and Earlwood in Sydney. Similarly named the Rabbitohs of South Sydney. Many urban dwellers still had easy access to lots of outdoors activities, hiking and camping being very popular pastimes.
At first I thought a bit the same thing. Life in Canada in the early 20th century was not easy, many people were working as lumberjack in the winter. My grandfather was in the army in WWII and had still had worked as a lumberjack most of his life. He camped under a tent in winter in Québec City and that was one of his best memories as one of the best winter he had. Thought conditions breed though men.
The thing is that about half of the men of the canadian contingent in 1918 had been born in the british isles so I'm not sure to what extend the harsh living conditions influenced the toughness of the men. It could be true for some regiments like the 22nd since it was made up of french canadian, thus born in canada and had endured harsh conditions in their daily life but even if the physical conditions of the men were superior, poor moral would have made them poor fighters.
Maybe the dominion troops felt like they were seen as inferior by their british counterpart and felt the need to prove themselves.
Around 7:09 there's a picture of british troops. One of the soldiers has what looks like a roman horsehair crest on his helmet. What's up with that? I'm trying to think of reasons for it beyond decoration and I can't. Not only that but it would be such an unusual decoration that I'd wonder that the officers let him get away with it (unless he is an officer?) and would be more likely to draw unwanted enemy attention and fire.
Maybe he was just horsin around
I can answer one thing for certain, he is definitely not an officer, although it is true that many officers adopted the uniforms of their men in some respects in order to be less identifiable, they would not have carried the amount of equipment that this soldier is carrying, the full webbing and marching order kit etc...an officer kit was generally consisted of, a sam browne belt with revolver and holster, a case for binoculars, a map case and a canteen.
With regards to what is on the mans helmet, the helmets generally had a cloth covering on them in order to prevent sunlight reflecting off them so they wouldn't stand out more than what they already were and for camouflage purposes, so its possible it is merely the cloth covering that has somehow come loose and just been folded back for the time being, just a theory on that last part though but possible.
It appears to be an air burst of an artillery round. The soldier's head is covering up the lower part of the blast.
Hi Indy I have a question for out of the Trenches. My Great Great grandfather was an officer in the Royal Italian engineers during the war and lost a leg in the fighting. What function did the engineers play on the Italian front, what were the duties of an engineer officer, would he have seen combat or mostly been assigned to duties behind the line?
Hey Indie I love the show and have a question for out of the trenches about communication during the Great War. Since Radio wasn’t used at the time how would pilots communicate with each other in Ariel combat?
Love the chanel. Could you ask your neighbour to st,.op practicing the guitar while you are recording.
Sorry I want to share but I cant find the concept section, can someome help?
About Bulgarian - Ottoman troop relations issue: from the book "Commander, where is Galicia?" by Şevki Yazman (a WW1 turkish officer that served in Galician Front): "Neither us, nor the Bulgarians could see each other as friends. But being allies, they provided supplies for us." I didn't read the book (it's old and hard to find these days), just found some passages after a quick net search. It seems there was dislike between Ottoman and Bulgarian troops but no major bad behaviour against each other. The governments had already quickly put aside the hostilities of Balkan Wars I suppose, for Bulgarians wanted to capture Greek-Serbian-Romanian territory and Ottomans wanted to take Egypt from Britain and Caucasus from Russia with no rush for any Macedonian territory. So both governments had different priorities by that time, causing no conflict.
Take care
He said "Winter is comming" without any special Voice or Gesture :(
First of all he said "Winter was comming", secondly as "everybody" knows: winter is already here...
This could be an out of the trenches question
"Hello indy and crew,
I was wondering what if any, was the availability of religious services on the western front.Thank you so much for the amazing work you(indy&crew) are doing. I really hope you continue post 1918.
I am sure Indy can probably give a better answer than myself and am sorry if I am spoiling the fun of it, but in the British Army at the very least, most battalions at some point or another when they were being rotated out of the trenches would be made to attend a church parade where they would be given a service by a military chaplain, and military chaplains were on hand in many cases just behind the lines and even in the trenches to administer to the spiritual needs of the men and comfort the dying and even writing letters for the wounded when they were not able too.
There were no Great War equivalents to the SAS in the British army,though there were elite regiments such as the Guards regiments the Grenadiers or Coldstreams,and the Highlanders who were generally the shock troops of the British army since the union of 1707,if the British needed an enemy shifted they generally put the jocks in first,but the Anzacs and equally the Canadians and Newfoundlanders were formidable in ww1.
the dominion forces wewre all volunteers, by this point of the war the UK forces had conscripts in them andi t resulted in a lower quality. As for british SF. the overall sense of a 'game' meant that most troops were capable of a raid, the playing wizard jpes on the enemy-tactics in a raid weretoss a few bombs in and rush in and grab the survivors. if you read the autobiographies of men like Robert graves, Basil Rathbone and Harry Drinkwater you get a feel for the idea that nay soldier could be expected to, and carry out raids without extra training.
Good Day to Indy and his fellow informers. I have a question for OOTT, would you please give a little background knowledge to the role that the new Emperor of Austria and King of Hungary Karl I played during the war and his role during the sixtus affair, there doesn't seem to be much written on Karl and I would appreciate your thoughts on him and his role during the war.
Thank you and I hope this makes it onto the show, keep up with all the splendid work that you do and looking forward to all the spiffing future episodes! Pip Pip!
Maybe the reason why Canadian and Australian forces were more perceived as Shock Troopers is because they had a different way of fighting then typical European style or more of incorporated European training into the style of fighting that is used in fighting in the environments of the countries. I mean, personally as a Canadian myself, the style of warfare that is based in Canada throughout the wars such as the war of 1812 and the way Canadian hunters hunted animals is different compared to European style. Keep up the good work on the videos though!
I wonder if Indy could talk about the border regiment. More specifically the second battalion. I'm trying to find some ancestors one of which being 202856 J. Grisedale but I'm having problems pin pointing any specific battles. God bless.
I have a question what happened to soldiers who where sick? Did they still have to fight or not?
Hi Indy! I have question, if you had to fight on one of the three major fronts (Western Front, Italian Front and Eastern Front) which one would you choose? And do you think Italy should have been treated better in the Treaty Of Versailles?
Just FYI, the link you have in the tag at the end is of the Red Barron, not of British infantry tactics as Indy says. Not a big deal of course, but if you want to fix that, I thought I'd point it out.
fixed now, thanks Jeff.
Indy I have heard that that the Australian troop when on strike because of the continued use of them as shock troop is this true. Love the channel
For the love of god, do a video of BF1 Rising Tides!
Question for Indy and the team. What is your plan for the future after the end of the war? Other than the Treaty of Versailles, will you do the Russian Civil war or The Second World War? I know that the latter is a stretch but I’m sure that I and many countless of others wouldn’t mind that it wouldn’t be recorded 100 years later. Keep up the good work!!!
I know I'm posting late, but you guys should do a special on Momčilo Gavrić, the youngest soldier in the war.
High guys I have a question for out of the trenches. What was the first marine corps reserve unit deployed to Europe? Keep up the good work.
Indy, it looks like you just finished a four-day bender of drinking energy drinks, playing Super Mario Bros. 3, and not sleeping.
Hy Indie and the Crew, I wanted to ask you what your favourite/in your opinion best Bolt action rifle (Exept M98 and German Weapon) of the war was. And what do you think of the Steyr Arms (because i am from Austria this would interrest me). You and all of the Crew ceep up the great Work because you are really talented in it.
frag mal lieber Othais oder Ian, ich bin mir ziemlich sicher, dass noch niemand in unserer gesamten Crew jemals ein Gewehr aus dem 1. Weltkrieg in der Hand hatte.
The Great War Ja aber sie werden sich doch sicher ein wenig auskennen oder?! Das sind doch Historisch bewanderte Leute die sich für den Krieg interresieren da Sind doch Gewehre ein wesentlicher Faktor!
Do one on the Polar Bear expedition. That shit was cool as hell, allied coalition face of against bolshevik forces in east siberia.
Hey Indy, I have just recently (past month) watched a whole bunch of your videos and I truly enjoy them. My question is, during and after the Christmas truce of 1915 and seeing their enemy, laugh with them, sing with them, believe the same god, why would they go back to killing them. Even after seeing that they are just like them, human.
Is whoever strumming those jazz chords in the not distant enough backround play a Hötzendorfer?
Hey guys i have a question for out of the trenches how was retreating done in trench warfare was it as simple at running to the next trench or was it like going over the the back of the trenches
Love the show keep up the great work
Hey are you guys gonna do videos for the new battlefield 1 trailers?
i have a question for out of the trenches: I know that nations experimented with all sorts of weapons. But how did a soldier on battlefield got to use it? Were THE soldiers chosen randomly or were they trained to handle such weapons. And when they used it, were they giving any feedback to high command? Thanks for answer. Keep up the good work!
Question for OOTT
Which country had the best automatic weapons, I know the vickers and MG08 are based on the Maxim gun,(from what im hearing if there is any difference please let me know) but outside of the Maxim design for example the german mg15, or the british lewis gun, or any other weapons from other countries that are not based on the Maxim design, were they better than the countries who based ther machineguns on the Maxim gun?
The MG15 is a MG08 adapted for plane (the waterjacket has been replaced by an empty jacket with holes for air cooling, and there are a few ergonomic adjustments).
If you want to compare weapons, you have to compare them in their roles. For instance, the Maxim (and its variants) is used to deliver high and sustained volume of fire from a fixed position. It can't really be compared to the Lewis and the Madsen, which were designed to be portable and to be moved where it was needed during an assault, or to the BAR and Chauchat, which were designed for "walking fire" (then pushed in the same role as the Lewis when they realised it was a bad idea), but should instead be compare to guns like the Hotchkiss 1914 or the Browning 1919.
Even then, most weapons are mainly equivalent with trade offs (e.g. the Hotchkiss uses 30 rounds metal stripes, which are shorter but cause less problems in heavy rain or cold than the 200+ rounds cloth belt of the Maxim), and the skill of the crew will be a bigger factor (especially since they will be probably killed by artillery or gas anyway...)
(That said, they are weapons that are worse than others, even in their roles, like the "American" Chauchat in 30-06 versus the BAR and the regular Chauchat, or like the steampunk beauty Modele 1907 St Etienne versus the Maxim.)
Dominion troops had lower numbers of conscripts, more ardent imperialists and a higher percentage of rural troops who required self motivation in their civilian lives.
*Indiana Neidel*
I really hope TGW does a profile on John Monash as he seemed to be a great example of a properly modern WW1 General.
Great War crew, could you try to get into contact with Dan Carlin from hardcore history? Love the show and hope that two of my favourites hosts could meet
At 7:08 the second fellow from the right, carrying an entrenching tool and a rifle, appears to be wearing something on his helmet. (Looks to me like an Ancient Greek style adornment) I know it was common for soldiers in the trenches to modify their equipment, is it possible for anyone to share some insight into wether soldiers would decorate their helmets like this?
Dear Indi,
I was interested in your comments about the Commonwealth troops having a reputation of agressiveness and being regarded as Shock Troops. As an Australian and Great War historian I am familiar with these storiies. I am also lead to believe that due to a number of issues the Commonwealth troops felt a need to prove themselves. Remembering that the attitude to war was ,especially at the beginning, that it was the proving ground for the worth of a nation. Australian federation was in 1901, New Zealand 1906 and Canada in 1867.., all young countries. As for command of these national forces and the easier relationships between ranks (particularly in the AIF) because the class system of Britain was not strictly adhered to in these nations. Do you agree with this assessment?
Can you make a video about Argentina as neutral nation during the war please?
I would like it very much
Dear Indy and crew, hey it's me again I have a very interesting question for out of the trenches. For years my grandpa, a Vietnam vet told me stories about his time in the war before he died. One of the stories he told me was a rumor when he was station in the south was one of the tortures the Vietcong did to POWs was they would force you to eat the meat of your fellow dead comrades all though he told me it was a rumor and was probably not true it got me thinking was there any incidents of cannibalism in war. Especially during wwi during the winters like in the mountains when the Russians and there enemies had short food supplies. Also on a side was it true that Russians had to fight off wolves during the war.
Thanks for the hard work I been a fan since cody for alternate history hub show me your channel
Indy will answer the part in regarding the war I am sure, but I can tell you that in the Russian civil war there was definitely episodes of cannibalism, especially in places like Ukraine, which until 1918 was the breadbasket of Russia, but when the Bolsheviks requisitioned most of it for their war against the various white forces, it led to massed starvation and famine, much as it did when Stalin did the same 20 years later.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_famine_of_1921%E2%80%9322
i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/12/30/12/3BB6B4F200000578-0-image-a-22_1483101155805.jpg
Don't look at the second image if you don't like the idea of seeing human suffering or are of a nervous disposition.
Jake Jackson, thanks I hope Indy answers this in out of the trenches
Indie , you should continue after 1918 and do the post war and the Second World War