The Fairy Bible sounds more like someone wanted to make a quick buck rather than do research and share solid information. The only thing that really surprises me is that they didn't list Wikipedia as a source. Thank you for sharing the other one - I get really excited at a bibliography list like that and footnotes! :)
I'm obsessed with your videos! You're so knowledgeable and ive learned so much from them!! Please keep making videos about fairies 💗💗💗💗 Lots of love from Argentina!
I own both books. I bought the Fairy Bible before I started doing a lot of research and I do "use" it for specific things- I ignored the Norse god etc as fairy, because I know they are not, and I took the Fairy Bible as more of a "glittery" happy reference book for fun, rather than definitive information on Fae. A lot of "young reader" books are often used as real info on fairies, but I use them mainly as fun reference especially with children, and or some holiday stuff. For example I do not see glitter as a "true" fairy thing, but do see it as a magical fun experience when creating happiness within others and sometimes myself. I do think the Fairy Bible has some useful info too, but I agree it is for sure not a main source for folklore- and "truth" so to speak. But I did enjoy reading through the Fairy Bible as well as the wonderful artwork. I'm currently reading John's book- I just picked it up at my local shop right before lock down here (thankful for that lol) and so far am really enjoying a lot of information in it. Granted I'm only a few chapters in. I have a true belief in fae, so it's possible that I'm biased to personal experience with fae as well as folklore and traditional insight of fae. I love reading his info so far and his upfront style stating he is pulling strictly from a specific set of faery information based in very specific places. Now that I've revealed I'm a believer, lol, you mentioned Froud's Fairies oracle- the book I don't think was written by him, but was under his supervision. While Froud may not pull academic info based on folklore (directly- not to say he hasn't read or is not proficient in it), I do believe his book could be used as an acceptable reference when dealing personal experience with fae. I would give weight to Froud and Faery. But I am not a fairy scholar or folklore based person, I'm your average everyday fae lover. So I'm giving this out there as my generic and limited opinion on the books and the authors that I've read. I'm also a Tinkerbell fan- so... I mean it could say a lot about me too. LOL I just enjoy fae- your book is actually next on my list, it wasn't available at my local shop so I'll have to order it when I can. Thank you for doing this video- i found it informative and engaging.
I'd certainly consider Froud's oracle a good source for personal experiences. And his (and Alan Lee's) book Faeries is a great source for folklore and accurate imo depictions of what fairies may look like
Thank you for taking the time to do this. I think the information you provided applies to all Pagan books. I don't see anything at all wrong with a book based on UPG and appreciate those willing to share their experiences, especially when it confirms my own or helps me sort though what's going on in my own practice. However, I truly wish they would clearly state that is where the information is coming from so that you could approach the material with that in mind.
I can agree with you when books are making a mockery of what the book is supposed to be a reading about its good to avoid those books. I had a book about runes and the book was talking in a few pages about Odin and the tree and stuff, but then it was making links with jesus and then the runes were explained in abrahamic matter every time. I could read a few pages about some runes and all but the book made me feel icky all over. 🥺
I like how thorough you are. Without knowing much about the topics in this video I figured the Fairy Bible wasn’t as credible because they spelled faerie as “fairy”. Not sure if I’m on to something with that but I associate “fairy” spelling with children’s fictional stories while “faerie” seems more authentic to the roots.
Hey Morgan! What are some fairy / elemental / nature spirits books for someone just getting into them (kind of, I’ve read a couple books already, and watched plenty of videos!) looking for some good books on them. Thank you!
Speaking of books I have yours on Irish Paganism noticed the pronunciation of Goibniu isn’t included. I’ve heard it said different ways and want to get it correct.
Oh, I'm disappointed to learn that Matthews' book is fiction. He must have included just enough material from Rev. Kirk and folklore - sure had me fooled into thinking it was nonfiction. Now I want to go back through it with a pen and make notes in the margins.
@@MorganDaimlerfairies Besides Kruse's book (which I note you are co-author of, right?), are there other books which you would suggest re: faeries? If I'm going to make notes in the margins of Matthews' book, I think it would help to have a better understanding of what he got right and what he made up. About the only other book I have which *might* be useful is Lady Wilde's "Legends, Charms, and Superstitions of Ireland."
I wrote the foreword for Kruse's book Faeries, but the book itself is all him. :) I'd suggest anything by Katherine Briggs as a solid resource. Kruse has various other books as well. Lecouteux is good, as is Cowan & Henderson's Scottish Fairy Beliefs This might help clarify some of the issues with Matthews book specifically lairbhan.blogspot.com/2017/10/a-critical-look-at-secret-lives-of.html?m=1
I feel that if you call or refer to any God or Goddess as a Faerie then that might be an insult to that particular deity. Anyone agree? I understand that there MIGHT be some wiggle room with the Irish Pantheon specifically because of how the religion of Christianity pretty much demoted those deities to that level over time but still.
@@MorganDaimlerfairies I feel that any God or Goddess regardless of Pantheon would not enjoy being seen in a diminished status, they are probably used to it due to time passing since Christianity took hold in Europe. The only real way to know is to ask the Gods themselves and be open for an answer. Anyway, I enjoy your videos and your books. Your books are hard to put down once I start reading, I even have your most current work, the faerie encyclopedia. (blanking on actual the title currently due to being tired.) Thank you for all you do and thank you for responding to my comment. Be safe and stay healthy, I just hope our state does not end up like NYC.
I usually steer clear of any esoteric books with 'Bible of' in the title🙄🤣
Lol! 😂 I also thought this at one point, “bible”?? 😂😂
Odin the air fairy lol
The Fairy Bible sounds more like someone wanted to make a quick buck rather than do research and share solid information. The only thing that really surprises me is that they didn't list Wikipedia as a source. Thank you for sharing the other one - I get really excited at a bibliography list like that and footnotes! :)
I'm obsessed with your videos! You're so knowledgeable and ive learned so much from them!! Please keep making videos about fairies 💗💗💗💗
Lots of love from Argentina!
“Very skimpy…anemically sad bibliography…” I swear you throw the best shade at bad sources of Faerie info and folklore. ♥️
Thank you for sharing the information & do what you need to for staying safe
I own both books. I bought the Fairy Bible before I started doing a lot of research and I do "use" it for specific things- I ignored the Norse god etc as fairy, because I know they are not, and I took the Fairy Bible as more of a "glittery" happy reference book for fun, rather than definitive information on Fae. A lot of "young reader" books are often used as real info on fairies, but I use them mainly as fun reference especially with children, and or some holiday stuff. For example I do not see glitter as a "true" fairy thing, but do see it as a magical fun experience when creating happiness within others and sometimes myself. I do think the Fairy Bible has some useful info too, but I agree it is for sure not a main source for folklore- and "truth" so to speak. But I did enjoy reading through the Fairy Bible as well as the wonderful artwork.
I'm currently reading John's book- I just picked it up at my local shop right before lock down here (thankful for that lol) and so far am really enjoying a lot of information in it. Granted I'm only a few chapters in.
I have a true belief in fae, so it's possible that I'm biased to personal experience with fae as well as folklore and traditional insight of fae. I love reading his info so far and his upfront style stating he is pulling strictly from a specific set of faery information based in very specific places.
Now that I've revealed I'm a believer, lol, you mentioned Froud's Fairies oracle- the book I don't think was written by him, but was under his supervision. While Froud may not pull academic info based on folklore (directly- not to say he hasn't read or is not proficient in it), I do believe his book could be used as an acceptable reference when dealing personal experience with fae. I would give weight to Froud and Faery. But I am not a fairy scholar or folklore based person, I'm your average everyday fae lover. So I'm giving this out there as my generic and limited opinion on the books and the authors that I've read.
I'm also a Tinkerbell fan- so... I mean it could say a lot about me too. LOL
I just enjoy fae- your book is actually next on my list, it wasn't available at my local shop so I'll have to order it when I can. Thank you for doing this video- i found it informative and engaging.
I'd certainly consider Froud's oracle a good source for personal experiences. And his (and Alan Lee's) book Faeries is a great source for folklore and accurate imo depictions of what fairies may look like
Thank you for taking the time to do this. I think the information you provided applies to all Pagan books. I don't see anything at all wrong with a book based on UPG and appreciate those willing to share their experiences, especially when it confirms my own or helps me sort though what's going on in my own practice. However, I truly wish they would clearly state that is where the information is coming from so that you could approach the material with that in mind.
I admit I bought The Fairy Bible, but only for the art
Thank you Morgan
Excellent ~ thank you
I can agree with you when books are making a mockery of what the book is supposed to be a reading about its good to avoid those books. I had a book about runes and the book was talking in a few pages about Odin and the tree and stuff, but then it was making links with jesus and then the runes were explained in abrahamic matter every time. I could read a few pages about some runes and all but the book made me feel icky all over. 🥺
I like how thorough you are. Without knowing much about the topics in this video I figured the Fairy Bible wasn’t as credible because they spelled faerie as “fairy”. Not sure if I’m on to something with that but I associate “fairy” spelling with children’s fictional stories while “faerie” seems more authentic to the roots.
💚💚💚💚
Hey Morgan! What are some fairy / elemental / nature spirits books for someone just getting into them (kind of, I’ve read a couple books already, and watched plenty of videos!) looking for some good books on them.
Thank you!
Hi, what is the chief academic text on fairies, if such even exists? Thank you.
anything by Katherine Briggs would be considered an academic standard
Speaking of books I have yours on Irish Paganism noticed the pronunciation of Goibniu isn’t included. I’ve heard it said different ways and want to get it correct.
Do you know where I can get that book for under 100.00 it is very expensive when I look it up. Thanks
Oh, I'm disappointed to learn that Matthews' book is fiction. He must have included just enough material from Rev. Kirk and folklore - sure had me fooled into thinking it was nonfiction. Now I want to go back through it with a pen and make notes in the margins.
I encourage you to. It's cathartic.
@@MorganDaimlerfairies Besides Kruse's book (which I note you are co-author of, right?), are there other books which you would suggest re: faeries? If I'm going to make notes in the margins of Matthews' book, I think it would help to have a better understanding of what he got right and what he made up. About the only other book I have which *might* be useful is Lady Wilde's "Legends, Charms, and Superstitions of Ireland."
I wrote the foreword for Kruse's book Faeries, but the book itself is all him. :)
I'd suggest anything by Katherine Briggs as a solid resource. Kruse has various other books as well. Lecouteux is good, as is Cowan & Henderson's Scottish Fairy Beliefs
This might help clarify some of the issues with Matthews book specifically lairbhan.blogspot.com/2017/10/a-critical-look-at-secret-lives-of.html?m=1
@@MorganDaimlerfairies Thanks for the information! Looks like I've got a few new books to add to my wishlists on Amazon and Thriftbooks.
I feel that if you call or refer to any God or Goddess as a Faerie then that might be an insult to that particular deity. Anyone agree? I understand that there MIGHT be some wiggle room with the Irish Pantheon specifically because of how the religion of Christianity pretty much demoted those deities to that level over time but still.
I guess that depends on why you consider it insult.
@@MorganDaimlerfairies I feel that any God or Goddess regardless of Pantheon would not enjoy being seen in a diminished status, they are probably used to it due to time passing since Christianity took hold in Europe. The only real way to know is to ask the Gods themselves and be open for an answer. Anyway, I enjoy your videos and your books. Your books are hard to put down once I start reading, I even have your most current work, the faerie encyclopedia. (blanking on actual the title currently due to being tired.) Thank you for all you do and thank you for responding to my comment. Be safe and stay healthy, I just hope our state does not end up like NYC.