Ranking AESPA in different categories (2021 version)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 вер 2024
- Today, I'm gonna rank AESPA in different categories (singing, rapping, dancing, visual, popularity, my bias)
I hope you like it ^^
TAGS (Ignore):
aespa
giselle
karina
winter
ningning
ranking
kpop
categories
rap
sing
dance
visual
2020
2021
yg
jyp
sm
![IVE VS AESPA [ VOCAL, DANCE, RAP, VISUAL & MORE'] 2021-2022 #IVE#aespa#kpop#ranking](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nF5gskjhK_Y/mqdefault.jpg)
MY OPINION:
RAP: Giselle
Vocal: Ningning
Dance: Karina
Visual (Korean Standard): Winter
Visual (International/ It girl): Karina
Stage Presence: Ningning
Expression: Giselle
Charisma: Karina
Most Biased in the fandom: Winter
Most popular: Karina
Swag: Giselle & Ningning
Elegance: Winter
Sassy: Karina
Bad bxtch: Giselle and Ningning
I agree with your opinion on stage presence. As I observe on GOT step back where winter pair wth wendy on tiktok she really look so stiff and no aura on her. No offense
what r u mean with'BAD BXTCH'
Agree
@@blackpinkfangirl938 bad bxtch energy or boss bxtch.....
@@blackpinkfangirl938 I heard ningning said Sh!t and WTF hahaha while Giselle even though she is not the Leader but she is like the Boss of Aespa
Ningning's visual is underated. For me she's the most beautiful 💜
She can be the most beautiful but according to the korean standard visual, Winter has the best visual
@@ssunniieh6994 majority of idols don't even suit in Korean standards. For me ningning's visual is unique 💜
Visual: 1-Winter
2-Karina
3-Ningning
4-Giselle
@@Mystarofficial1 respect others opinion too 😉
@@ssunniieh6994 Can winter stans shut up when someone just said their opinion? Y'all trying so hard to prove that winter is the prettiest when she's not!
Winarina is definitely the ace can sing can dance can rap and hv visual
Edit: ALL ACES IN aespa
ningning says hi
@@eulalia3468 Hi ningning🫠
@@whynot3275 yeah say hi to her cuz she's an ace herself who can compose and write lyrics to her own song
@@eulalia3468 ok shut up ill add her in the comment! u’ll be happy
@@whynot3275 loll
Aespa it's the best vocal girl-group in 4 generation, your vocalists is next level!
Not hating on aespa
But you should also not forget about purple kiss
@@pokemontech7393 Dreamcatcher debut in 2017. They are 3th generation group, not 4th.
@@pokemontech7393 Aespa is stronger than Purple Kiss
@@pokemontech7393 I don't think so, purple kiss have 2/7 who can do support while aespa have 4/4💁
@@jywvxz7302 We haven't seen their full potential yet so how can we judge
I think Chaein , Ireh and Jieun Also have great vocals But they haven't shown to us yet
Aespa is one of the best vocal girl group of 4th gen
Winter and Karina are distinguished how the Aces of the group and their fans are competing for who is better both are great, they love each other their fans should also do it alive the Winrina
Thanks for saying this 🙏🏻 Eventhough I am a winter bias, these discussions about who is aespa’s ace are just annoying
Actually NingNing is more of an ace than Winter
1- Karina
2- NingNing
3- Winter
4- Giselle
@@itzaxeeeeeeee She isn't though. Winter better dancer, Ningning better singer, both equally good in rap. Some can even say Winter is better at rap.
I agree with ranking
But in visual I think it’s
1. Winter/Karina(they both have 80% kbs, they don’t have golden ratio, amd their body type is debatable)
2. NingNing
3. Giselle
And popularity
1. Winter(she seems the most popular at the moment) Karina(or may be her, but I guess she was during NL era)
3. NingNing
4.GiGi
I'm 💯 sure Karina does have the golden ratio, her head it's too small for it to not be true 😂
@@bluequeen8022 if you measure it, its 7,5/8
@@bluequeen8022 I think her head looks small because of the surgeries, you can see some Karina's pre-debut photos and her head wasn't like that
@@gugsu I don't know how respond to this bcs tbh I always thought her head was smaller in her predebut photos
@@moonlightsunshine6 Winter isn’t 165cm so she isn’t 80%. Only 70%
Karina visual leader
Karina is the ECE Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub-Vocalist, Face of the Group, Stage Presence, Leader, And her Visual...OmG Queen Indeed...Love Them all
4th generation it girl.
Finally someone that appreciates Giselle!!
Winter is considered as the ace of aespa. She is lead vocalist, lead dancer and visual. She can do rap.
All of them are aces.
Giselle, Ningning and Karina can do the same, too. I'm proud of Aespa for being multitalented.
@@cpaintransit86 winter is just like red velvet seulgi. How seulgi is treated as ace. Likewise same winter is treated. So in my mind she came as ace.
@@supremesubba5962 In my opinion, Wendy is the ace of RV and aespa's Karina
@@gugsu okay that's nice. I love winter that's why i considered winter as ace. It's okay to have own opinion. We always want our fav one to hype more.
fun fact: only karina was presented as ace
Fact: Karina was introduced as ace and all rounder by SM itself. At the very start she has been an ace.
Unpopular Fact: All of them is an ace, rather than comparing them who is an ace, appreciate them as Ace and all rounder GG.
Giselle and Ningning's visuals are a little underrated, but they're really pretty
Edit:.Wow, our ultimate bias on Aespa is the same
Karina
Jennie unnie(!) ??😱😱
@@lve5206 wtf you mean
Karina's visual is unreal 🔥🔥🔥
Karina the ace that you are today.
Karina the all rounder member sm introduced to us! The ace! The visual leader!! She is the whole package
no winter is
@@intiahmed6181 being an ace means u should come above average in all the category winter is below average rapper and she lacks in stage presence just look at itzy why yeji is ace why not rynjin coz rynjin has weak vocal
@@strawberryruiyang1792 oh… now I understand why people say Karina is the ace
Remember when SM introduce the members, Giselle rap,Winter sing, Karina dance,but Winter did nothing cause she can do everything
@@catherinelalnunfeli7285 but she has weakest stage presence and below average idol rapper. Sm just did her as a visual.
winter is seriously making me bias her so much lol
Stage Pressence
1. Ningning ( energy, facial expression, charisma, she hast it all )
2. Karina ( she's also great)
3. Winter/Giselle ( bland facial expressions, but over all still good)
Karina dancing 'Bola Rebola' is so perfect 💜.
Kkkkkkkkkkkkkk br crtz
@@mariajuliamenezessilva8966 Aqui e br kkkkkkkkkk
Sabia kakakakakakak
NingNing is the most beautiful imo and her stage presence is killer! 💖 Underrated ace 💖💖
My Opinion (Not based on my bias).
Vocal:
#1 NingNing
#2 Winter
#3 Karina (my favorite voice)
#4 Giselle
Rap:
#1 Giselle
#2 Karina
#3 Winter
#4 NingNing
Dance:
#1 Karina
#2 Winter
#3 NingNing
#4 Giselle (The dance that caught my attention at first when I saw Black Mamba's dance practice).
Visual:
#1 Winter
#2 Karina I think she's the It Girl and one of the prettiest girls I've ever seen in the 4th gen)
#3 NingNing
#4 Giselle
Stage presence (update)
#1 NingNing
#2 Giselle
#3 Karina
#4 Winter
Popularity:
#1 Karina
#2 Winter
#3 NingNing
#4 Giselle (The weirdest thing is that I heard about her long before I met Winter and NingNing, when I learned that she is the least popular, I was surprised)
Bias Ranking (But I'm OT4):
#1 Karina (was always the first in my heart❤️)
#2 NingNing (I'll admit I didn't like her at first, but later I found out she was cute!)
#3 Giselle (The second one I met and the first one that caught my attention when I saw her dance practice in BLACK MAMBA)
#4 Winter (When I met aespa I found her without salt, but in the Next Level and Forever era I fell in love)
mine:
(vocal)
1. ningning
2. winter
3. giselle/karina
(rap)
1. giselle
2. karina
3. winter
4. ningning
(dance)
1. karina
2. winter
3. ningning
4. giselle
(visual)
can't decide
(stage presence)
1. ningning
2. karina
3. giselle
4. winter
(bias)
ot4
Same Bias:
1.Karina (Why: already me too she has always had a place in my heart ❤️, her voice, her dance, her singing, her rap, her visual...
I love everything she does, she has pretty good facial expressions.)
2.Ningning (I find that we compare her a lot with Winter because she has fewer high notes.
Well otherwise I LOVE HER SWAG she has stage presence of sick 😧)
3.Giselle (They say she dances badly (not everyone) but singing rapping and dancing at the same time must be very hard and she's doing really well I say keep it up my beautiful)
4.Winter (So how can I say so as not to offend people already, I don't send hate, she dances very well, she sings and raps very well, but it's finally her expressions that bother me outside of everything concert she is rather cute she is full of expression finally several and when she arrives on stage very little, as I explained it is hard the job of Idol but take example on Giselle and Ningning they dance less well but we even much more expression when they dance.
Why just when she dances because when she just sings Winter has expressions in Forever she has plenty of them.
Well here I am not saying all this with hatred but each AESPA member has a potential that is what we must not forget. ❤️
Ik its ur opinion but 2 me the secoond of stage prensece should be giselle .
And Gisele done well in coachella
No hate 2 karina I 💞her
And I agree with the rest
aespa have the best 4th gen vocals as an overall group and it’s not even close !
Visual
1-Ningning
i think giselle i grt in vocal. we just havent listened more of her
she's great but karina is still undoubtedly better than her
@@karinano1stan y
Vocal:
1. NingNing
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Rap:
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. NingNing
Dance:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. NingNing
4. Giselle
Visual:
1. NingNing & Winter
2. Karina & Giselle
Bias:
1. Giselle
2. NingNing
Visual 1.karina my queen!!
1 karina❤
2 winter
3 giselle
4 ning ning
I know ningning has got a perfect voice,but I personally prefer Winter's vocals, they're so good to listen
i think in dance, ning ning should be number 2 bcs her timing and her detail at dance are so great
Stage presence
1)Ningning
2)Karina
3)Giselke
4)Winter(she improved her stage presence sence step back perfomance )
I'm not a fan of aespa but I really like WINTER'S voice and dancing skills
I LOVE YOU WINTER 😘😁😁
Vocal:
1)Ningning
2)Winter
3)Karina
4)Giselle
Rap:
1)Giselle
2)Karina
3)Winter and Ningning
Dance:
1)Karina
2)Winter
3)Ningning
4)Giselle
Visual:
1)Ningning
2)Karina
3)Winter
4)Giselle
Bias:
1)Ningning
2)Karina
3)Giselle
4)Winter
Ace:
1)Winter and Karina
2)Ningning and Giselle
ACE RANKING
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. NingNing
4. Giselle
What is ACE ?? Sorry I'm French and I don't understand 😩
Karina and winter have to be around the same level or karina is higher than winter because karina is a better vocalist than winter is at rapping
@@rinelgeorge5620 yea true
@@rinelgeorge5620 I think it’s quite equal tbh, winter is far better at singing than Karina, she’s closer to ningning than Karina if you get what I mean, and imo I think winters dancing is as good as karinas but karinas rapping is deffo better and beauty again is subjective, so it is debatable but imo I think it’s winter tho I understand if people think Karina is ace cuz in their views she is just as good
@@rensunlife dancing i dont think so??? go to got the beat step back dance practice she was lacking energy and she was overshadow so clearly Karina is The Ace
My opinion:
Vocal:Ning Ning
Rap:Gissele
Dance:Karina
Visual:Winter,Karina
Stage presence:Ning Ning
Popularity:Karina/Winter
My bias: AESPA
😍
My favorite member is Winter
It’s honestly downright demeaning how y’all dislike Giselle for no good reason. Like it’s so sad to witness really, what has the poor girl ever done to y’all? She’s always ranked the last in every single thing and gets the least amount of love. People even go as far as giving her stupid comments like “oh she’s good but so & so is absolutely much better” the girl doesn’t ever seem to do anything right in your sights. It’s sad to see really. I love you so much Giselle and always will
she's my bias tho
I’m not referring to you tho, just the very disgusting comments under this video targeted towards her.
aespa is literally such an amazing group, like they are the most well rounded group ever and if they had more stage presence, they would, dare i say, be the most talented kpop group ever.
Visual
1. Winter
2. Karina
3.Giselle
4.Ning Ning
Karina is the ace✨❤
Rapper _ Giselle
Dancer_karina
Vocal_ningning
Visual and bais __winter 🥰
🔥
@@kimadihaz4600 Nice My bais Both Karina & Winter
My opinion Visual
Karina🔥
My bias ranking:
1. Winter
2. Karina/Giselle
3. Ningning
My opinion visual
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
My opinion visual
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.Ningning
4.Giselle
Remember when SM introduce the members. Giselle rap, Karina dance and Ningning sing but Winter just did nothing because she slay everything beyond being the visual. She got into SM for her dance skills and even passed the audition for actress because of her beauty and now she's this talented vocalist. I didn't like her at first,i find her ordinary and average since SM didn't let her stand out like Karina. But she literally outshined everyone by pure talent,charisma and visual. The other members are hella talented as well,but Winter nailed every category,she could be main in everything
your seriously delutional sm says Karina is the idol that can dance and rap and sing. it means all rounder.
stop being blind accept the fact. go to got the beat step back dance practice winter was lacking energy in her dance and she was overshadow.
@@foodiepotato74 is that why she got the most views on their fancam,she literally blew up lol
@@catherinelalnunfeli7285 visual as usual. she's cute right? right
@@milesstone1834 exactly
Fact - Ningning is the youngest kpop idol in sm
I love how Karina sings tbh
@wendy island so what?
Winter is no 1 visual. She fits KBS perfectly and also have SM type of beauty. Karina on the other hand like Jennie, the prettiest for international fans and face of the group.
Visual(Korean Standard):Karina No.1
From your rankings I can say that you're a true MY! Finally someone who rank objectively
I literally realized that Karina is my fav in everything (except stage presence cause Winter)
Yea! Winter kills me with her charisma on stage.
But Karina is my all-rounder, she does everything and the still beautiful! She's ACE and It Girl from the 4th gen.
@@meldiasdiary There's no way Winter has stage presence sorry.
@@moonlightespt3818 Okay, Winter wins in stage presence, but I still think Karina is the ACE.
Karina:
Vocal #3
Rap #2
Dance #1
Stage presence #3
Visual #2
Popularity #1
Winter:
Vocal #2
Rap #3
Dance #2
Visual #1
Stage presence #2
Popularity #2
@@meldiasdiary I don't think Winter is better than Karina in stage presence. If you compare them in their recent perform (Got the beat). Winter has blank expressions, even Wendy overshadowed Winter. Karina stands out the most with her stage presence while Winter got overshadowed.
Winter have no stage presence tho tbh
My bias is winter. She is cute! 😍🤩💜💙❤
My bias of aespa is winter . She is ace of the group . She is very pretty.
Vocal: Ningning >> Winter > Karina >> Giselle
Dance: Karina> Winter>Ningning >>>Giselle
Rap: Giselle >Karina>>Winter/Ningning
Visual: Karina >Ningning >Winter>Giselle
Stage presence: Karina/Ningning >Winter/Giselle
My bias is Winter😊 she is just amazing
mine opnion
VOCAL
1.NINGNING
2.WINTER
3.KARINA
4.GISELLE
RAP
1.GISELLE
2.KARINA
3.WINTER
4.NINGNING
DANCE
1.KARINA
2.WINTER
3.NINGNING
4.GISELLE
VISUAL
1.WINTER
2.KARINA
3.NINGNING
4.GISELLE
POPULERITY
1.KARINA
2.NINGNING
3.WINTER
4.GISELLE
BIAS
1.WINTER
2.KARINA
3.NINGNING
4.GISELLE
That my opinion too
Giselle is just amazing ❤❤❤❤😭😭😭
giselle swag and vibe is sth i aspire to have
i recently got into aespa and the way i’m obsessed w giselle is unhealthy
same
Winter is the IT girl of 4th generation
@@monyb3740 LOL It's Winter tbh, If you watch every eras of fancams, Winter always get the most highest views, Korean and International fans all agree that Winter is the real Ace and IT girl, Karina is face of the group and center, just dumbass China toxic fans saying Karina is IT girl
Yes
@@monyb3740 u need some therapy
@@littlepear6728 akgae ew
@@littlepear6728 Crazy :)
Vocal
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Karina
4 Giselle
Rap
1 Giselle
2 Karina
3 Winter
4 Ningning
Dance
1 Karina
2 Winter
3 Ningning
4 Giselle
Visual
1 Karina
2 Winter
3 Ningning
4 Giselle
Popularity
1 Karina
2 Winter
3 Giselle
4 Ningning
Stage performance
1 Karina
2 Ningning
3 Giselle
4 Winter
Karina is my bias
My bias is ningning and my bias wrecker is giselle
My opinion:
Vocal
1.Winter
2.Ningning
3.Karina
4.Giselle
Visual
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.Ningning
4.Giselle
Rap
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.Winter
4.Ningning
Dance
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.Ningning
4.Giselle
I think Ning2 is my favorite in everything except from rap
No. 1= 4 points
No. 2= 3
No. 3= 2
No. 4= 1
Vocals:
1. NingNing
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Rap:
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
Dance:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
Visual:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Stage Presence:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle and Ningning
4. Karina's Hair
Vocal
1.Ningning
2.Winter
3.Karina
4.Giselle
Rap
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.Winter
4.NingNing
Dance
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.NingNing
4.Giselle
Stage presence
1.NingNing
2.Karina
3.Winter
4.Giselle
Visual ( *Biased* )
1.NingNing
2.Karina
3.Winter
4.Giselle
Bias
1.NingNing
2.Karina
3.Winter
4.Giselle
My opinion:
Rap - Giselle
Vocals - Ningning & Winter (personally, I prefer Winter's voice)
Visual - Winter & Karina
Stage Presence - Karina
Bias: Winter
As New My's I'm shocked because their 4th vocalist actually can pull Lead Vocal position...
VERY ACCURATE RANKING
AGREED TO ALL.
My bias NingNing Love
Imo
Vocal
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Karina
4 Giselle
Rap
1 Giselle
2 Karina
3 Winter
4 Ningning
Dance
1 Karina
2 Winter
3 Ningning
4 Giselle
Visual
1 Karina
2 Ningning
3 Winter
4 Giselle
Most biased
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Karina
4 Giselle
My bias
1 Karina
2 Ningning
3 Winter
4 Giselle
(But i love all)
Bias:
4.Winter
3.Karina
2.Giselle
1.Ningning
Giselle should be at 3rd place in vocal🌞
Karina is better
My bias:
1. Winter & Ningning
2. Karina & Giselle
Karina
Dance- 1
Visual- 1
Rap- 2
Vocal- 3
Winter
Visual- 1
Vocal- 2
Dance- 2
Rap- 3
For me they are both equally talented
カリナ
歌-3
ダンス-1
ラップ-2
ビジュアル-1
人格-1
人気-1
ウィンター
歌-2
ダンス-2
ラップ-3
ビジュアル-2
人格-4
人気-2
カリナ>ウィンター
Aespas vocals and giselles rap skills are on the next level
I think giselle is a good dancer considering she only trained for a year
Popularity
1)karina
2)winter
3)ningning
4)giselle
But......
Most biased
1)Giselle
2)winter
3)Ningning
4)karina
my bias is Giselle♥♥♥♥♥♥
Karina is a really good ace winter is an all rounder but not an ace Karina is good at a lot of stuff while winter lacks more in stuff but Karina can do it all pretty well I love them both but Karina is a true ace
On my perspective;
DANCE RANKING
#4 - Giselle
#3 - Ningning
#2 - Winter
#1 - Karina
VOCAL RANKING
#4 - Giselle
#3 - Karina
#2 - Winter
#1 - Ningning
RAP RANKING
#4 - Ningning
#3 - Winter
#2 - Karina
#1 - Giselle
VISUAL RANKING
#4 - Giselle
#3 - Ningning
#2 - Winter
#1 - Karina
MY BIAS
KARINA
NINGNING (Bias Wrecker)
But still they are all deserve to be in Top 1, no matter what their rankings is. 🤍
My bias is Karina!!!💜
My favorite bias giselle
My visual list
1)Karina
2) NingNing
3) Giselle
4) Winter
(2)
My bias will forever be giselle
OMFG WE SHARE THE SAME BIAS AND BIAS WRECKERS I LOVE YOU-
Vocal:
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Rap:
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
Dance:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
Stage presence
1. Ningning
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Winter
Popularity:
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
Biased (most)
1. Winter
2. Karina/Ningning
3. Giselle
JYP- Let's find pretty girls and train them.
SM- Let's find talented girls and make them pretty
I think it's the other way around considering that SM casts most of their trainees when they are like 8-11 and the fact that they cast both Karina and Irene at first because they were pretty
It’s the other way around. Lol. We all remember Momo’s encore. Love Momo tho, she has great vocals but it’s underutilized in most of their songs :/
Is it possible to have even line distribution for 9 member group? But they have their positions...
@@blzy404 I think they are talking about Momo's vocals
@@bluequeen8022 ikr. so i just ask randomly expecting someone could answer.
My bias:🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
1.Gisella😘😘😘😘😘
2.Karina😍😍😍😍
3.Ningning😊😊😊
4.Karina😄😄😄😄
My biad karina
Because karina is main Dancer
and she is good rapper
And she us soo beautiful ❤
Imo
Vocal
1.ningning
2.winter
3.karina
4.giselle
Rap
1.giselle
2.karina
3.winter
4.ningning
Dance
1.karina
2.winter/ningning
3.giselle
Stage presence
1.ningning
2.karina
3.giselle
4.winter
Visual
1.all💕🫶
Giselle 🤟
My opion
Vocal
Ning Ning
Winter
Karina/Giselle
Rap
Giselle
Karina
Winter/Ning Ning(illusion best 👍)
Dance
Karina
Ning ning
Winter
Giselle
Stage presence
Ning Ning
Karina
Giselle/Winter
Popularity
Karina
Winter.
Ning Ning
Giselle
Visual
Winter
Karina
Ning Ning /Giselle
My bias
Ning Ning
Karina /Giselle
Winter
(MY OPION)
Giselle is my bias too☺️
tbh i would put winter #1 in dance ranking. even when karina is the main dancer and she got the stamina when she dance, her movements are messy. winter movements are clearest/cleanest, you can see that she's a perfectionist + also she got a good stamina.
Messy? Karina is the only member who does not cut the moves whenever they dance and does them fully. The most detailed. She has the best lines, angles, and isolation out of them all, which are clean btw. Her body control is great, esp her on arms and lower body. Learn how to state your opinion without having shit and biased reasonings.
@@akhinayui8732 yesss u tell them 🤣✨
@@akhinayui8732 lmao winter is not even my bias, is ningning. you kiddos these days can't take opinions.
@@leuvsemats I said your reasonings are biased, never did I say Winter is your bias. Where's your reading comprehension, oldie?
@@akhinayui8732 I admit Karina is a good dancer and she deserves her main dancer position, but let’s be honest winter is literally just as good. I think why some people think winter is better is because winter is neat, and karina likes to make big moves, sometimes making big moves makes it look…idk how to explain it a bit, I guess a tiny bit messy. The only reason I agree karina deffo deserves her main position is because winter lacks energy, ok so she’s neat but that’s about it, she’s really clean and precise but I don’t see any energy. So yeah I like winters dancing more but if she had more energy and better stage expressions she would have been on the same level as Karina, like in ALL dancing aspects
I personally think Karina hasn't shown us her true vocal potential. I think she can do better in the future.
based on my pure opinion not based on my bias
vocal:
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning & Winter (can’t choose who is the best because there is only a few chances for them to show their rapping skills)
dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
visual
1. Karina
2. Winter, Ningning & Giselle (they are pretty with their own aura but Karina is totally a visual leader for 4th generation)
people who are salty with my statement they can’t accept other’s opinion. 🤟
My bias 1 Karina 2 Winter 3 Ningning 4 Giselle
My opinion (note I'm just seeing in real life just from the fancam or what else)
#Vocal
1Ningning
2Winter
#Rap
1Gissela
2Karina
#Visual
1Winter
2Karina
#Dance
1Karina
2Winter
#popularity(just by watching all the fancam, who's got the most view)
#Winter always the first
#Karina
Note that's just my opinion don't confuse
My Bais
4# Ninging
3# Giselle
2# Winter
1# Karina
Visual Winter, 98% Karina 96%
My ranking and I’m not biased at all except for visuals and vocal tones.
Vocal Technique : 1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Karina
4 Giselle
Vocal tone: 1 Ningning
2 Karina/Giselle
3 Winter (Piercing, annoying to listen to)
Rap: 1 Giselle
2 Karina
3 Ningning
4 Winter
Stage Presence (if not lipsyncing): 1 Ningning
2 Giselle
3 Karina
4 Winter
Stage Presence (lipsyncing): 1 Ningning
2 Winter, Karina, Giselle
Visuals : 1 Ningning
2 Karina
3 Giselle
4 Winter
bye
Winter , Ningning , Karina 😍
Giselle>>>>>