JYJ-SM Lawsuit Series #1: How does SM work?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 112

  • @serenecitylights
    @serenecitylights 11 років тому +85

    It pains me to see how the Cassiopeia has split up and chosen sides like this. I have been a strong Cassie for 6 years now, so yes, I feel and understand the pain. But please, do not bash or take sides like this.

    • @dianab8110
      @dianab8110 11 років тому +22

      Tell that to anaethjado90 and to other crazy b*tches who think that they have the right to criticize JYJ because they left SM! So what if they did that? It was JYJ decision to fight for their freedom and for justice, and CM and YH fans should try to be more respectful because if it wasn't for JYJ, SM wouldn't have changed their slave contracts! I don't hate CM and YH, just that i don't care about them anymore...but you should see their fans, how they bash JYJ, how they try so hard to make the others to accept their ,,truth''. That ,,truth'' was told by SM, and i should be mentaly ill to trust that company!

    • @dianab8110
      @dianab8110 11 років тому +18

      ***** My dear, HOMIN's fans aggressively are blaming the three for ruining everything, but the only one to blame is SM for how he treated them! SM started all with the slave contract and the other things, JYJ only fought for their freedom. Is it wrong to aspire for a better future, away from SM's prison? I don't think so! And please, tell me, how they put the blame on CM and YH! And also, let's not talk about parents here, i have some things to say about HOMIN's fathers, but it's pointless to drag their fathers in this discution, from respect! And what interviews are you talking about, what lies? Girl, you need to read the interviews again, you clearly understood something wrong! I've read all their interviews and i can't figure out what are you talking about! To promote hate to HOMIN...gosh, i'm not like you,( to hate HOMIN only because they didn't leave with JYJ ), who hate JYJ because they left and didn't want to stay in SM's cave! And if you think that the chaos was created only because of JYJ, then i have nothing else to say to you! And look who talks about fans spreading lies...don't forget that was a HOMIN fan who get sued by C-JeS because he spread lies on the internet, and is also a HOMIN japanese fan who translate the lies that a weird japanese dude is spreading on twitter! Let's talk about this kind of fans, hun!

    • @Putri-ani
      @Putri-ani 6 років тому

      😭

    • @bastetowl3258
      @bastetowl3258 8 місяців тому

      changminand yunho are the ones that keep bashing jyj while jyj have only said nice things about them, so i’m going to choose a side. i also don’t want to support SM or yoochun financially, so i’m a jaesu fan now

  • @jeniization
    @jeniization 11 років тому +134

    This is an absolute impudence. I knew SM was terrible but this is making me speechless. How can they be so shameless? The fact that they have so much power over the broadcasts proves how dirty and despicable they really are. And now that I watched this video the only reason that comes to my mind why Shinee, Exo etc. are staying there must be because they are afraid to end up like JYJ. Being treated like outcasts by mass media and the TV stations. Besides, if I had children I would have never ever allowed them to be signed under such conditions. At that point I would mention JYP because he, like JYJ too, didn't give in to the agencies and was rebellious. He sometime mentioned that his artists can do whatever the hell they want to, because they are PEOPLE.

    • @valentinapino5855
      @valentinapino5855 10 років тому +13

      And now, Kris wants to leave SM because of this.. The story repeats..

    • @jeniization
      @jeniization 10 років тому

      For real? I didn't know about that. Where did you hear that from? :o

    • @jeniization
      @jeniization 10 років тому +15

      Alright, I looked it up. Honestly, I'm not really surprised that it's Kris who's the first in EXO to stand against this fucked up agency. BUT I'm surprised and somehow amazed that he opened up his eyes so quickly after debuting. I mean, it only have been hardly 2 years. I do feel sorry for the rest of the members because he was so talented. And sure, he could have told them beforehand but that wouldn't have changed their opinion about it "being a betrayal". But at the end of the day it's his own decision and everone knows how SM treats their artist. By the way, Kris never was the overly happy and excited guy. Just like he always told other people himself, it's not his 'style'.

    • @finnthuman6797
      @finnthuman6797 10 років тому +14

      jeniization You've notice EXO members who has an injuries, right? But, why are they still dancing or performing? I agree with you and, do not believe to the opinions of the other members of EXO, like Suho and Tao said that they are betrayed by Kris. How could they say that, right? It's only SME.

    • @lescarletheart
      @lescarletheart 10 років тому

      Finn THuman I think it's more so they feel betrayed as a team. They probably promised each other to stick it out together no matter how difficult it got for them.

  • @animefreak12375
    @animefreak12375 11 років тому +12

    Yes it is true that JYJ is not the first group to terminate their contract with SM. The first group was Shinhwa, but you are also forgetting that at the time that SHinhwa terminated their contract, SM was not fully solidified. In other words, SM was a new company and was still learning the ropes. This was also said by Shinhwa in their appearance in Beatles Code 2. This is the reason why Shinhwa was able to leave SM and still keep their name.

  • @william69494
    @william69494 10 років тому +67

    is really sad because JYJ are one of the most perfect group with a perfect harmony vocal and really good and beautiful songs ( produced by JYJ ) and the media make that crime, yes CRIME for then, exclude they are all variety shows ¬¬ But one thing SM can't make up. is in SALES! JYJ SALES VERY VERY, VEEEEERY WELL ^^ so... is sad for one side, but is great in other side because people who know JYJ, know that JYJ are great artists ( proof of this is a bigeast number of juniors that show a lot of respect to JYJ like BTOB, INFINITE, B2ST, 2PM, SHINee, B1A4 and others...

  • @aichan01
    @aichan01 10 років тому +43

    I used to think that JYJ was at fault but I've been searching information about the lawsuit and stuff now I think JYJ were right. They did it for their freedom. But it really hurts to see TVXQ not performing as a five. I hope they still meet each other 'cause their friendship was really amazing. I support both HOMIN and JYJ. If they were still together no doubt they would be no.1 All because of this stupid company! If SM only had changed the contract now all the fan wouldn't be so heartbroken. Because of the lawsuit SM would have lost some fame wouldn't it? Then why don't they change the contract now so they won't loose more talented artists. JYJ left, Hangeng left and now I heard about Kris too.When we see them on the camera they look so happy but on the inside everything is messed up! I'm really irritated now.

    • @venusluv-i1v
      @venusluv-i1v 10 років тому +4

      At the time both JYJ and Hengen won their case because this contract was the contract used before 2010. The illegal parts of it by law was that SM bound their performers to 13 years by contract which is illegal (7 years is the maximum number of years). Therefore SM had to pay those two. With Kris however, it may not be the same win, as SM Entertainment has changed their contract since then.

  • @violetray96
    @violetray96 10 років тому +86

    Successful company artists but yet the company fail in ethic and moral.

  • @milagros6699
    @milagros6699 9 років тому +23

    it makes me so angry!! sm knows that if they let them go to broadcast they will be 10000 times better than any other band in sm entertainment or any other company! they are afraid!! but it doesn't matter cause we will always support jyj!!! jyj fightingggg!!

    • @bastetowl3258
      @bastetowl3258 8 місяців тому +1

      yeah SM def felt threatened and didn’t want 2tvxq to be overshadowed, so they did everything they could to sabotage jyj

  • @dylanakent
    @dylanakent 11 років тому +12

    FYI: Article 2 would be difficult to hold up in the USA. It's a slavery contract and other artists in contracts like this have won their court cases (in the US). Indentured servants worked for 7 years, this contract is for 13 years PLUS. The buyout would never be calculated correctly without an extensive accounting. I've worked in the music business and this is probably one of the worst contracts I've ever seen. It's a shame for the talent. They deserve better.

  • @HanIn91kc
    @HanIn91kc 10 років тому +44

    I don't understand why some people even speak for SM everytime. OVERALL SM is terrible.

  • @ThinkingReed_
    @ThinkingReed_ 5 років тому +41

    It's 2019 now. Anybody still supporting Jaejoong?

    • @fyrzfwzy2252
      @fyrzfwzy2252 4 роки тому

      Sure!

    • @freshlyexisted
      @freshlyexisted 4 роки тому +3

      202p and i'm still supporting both side, *no matter what*

    • @jajasatorashi136
      @jajasatorashi136 4 роки тому

      I'm here

    • @yunheeflower5191
      @yunheeflower5191 3 роки тому

      Nah! People who make fun about corona for april mop is not a human. His face save everything

    • @blavkhaert
      @blavkhaert 3 роки тому +1

      it's August 2021, and I'm still here to support Jaejoong, and of course Yunho, Changmin, Junsu and Yoochun

  • @mariogautama6497
    @mariogautama6497 7 років тому +19

    BRAVO SM.....
    THAT IS WHY SM ARTISTS do not look that well-off (rich) despite that much popularity and album sales. because SM took all the money.

    • @jae_xx9296
      @jae_xx9296 6 років тому

      Mario Gautama I notice that too

    • @bastetowl3258
      @bastetowl3258 8 місяців тому

      yes jyj earned way more 1 year after they left compared to the 6 years they worked for SM

  • @danaliu3295
    @danaliu3295 11 років тому +43

    OMG I just burst out laughing...how can you omit one of the 2 main characters from a movie trailer??? that's ridiculous!

  • @dylanakent
    @dylanakent 11 років тому +10

    You have to figure that artists in the US or in Europe at the same level of success are living in mansions, not dorms. They don't have to beg their cameramen or producers for money or food. They get song writing credits (even if they don't write most of the song). They are members of BMI, ASCAP or SESAC and get royalties. It appears to be very different for most Korean artists.

  • @blavkhaert
    @blavkhaert 3 роки тому +2

    it's August 2021, and I'm still here to support Jaejoong, and of course Yunho, Changmin, Junsu and Yoochun too

  • @Cloudetower
    @Cloudetower 2 роки тому +2

    I learned so much from this so wait. If Shinee didn't go on the Japanese tour after Jonghyun died and have time off to grieve SM would request 3 times the investment of the tour.Btw how did Jessica not go bankrupt after SNSD?

  • @Mememeep
    @Mememeep 8 років тому +21

    It's like North Korea. All is for show.

  • @jjchastity8902
    @jjchastity8902 7 років тому +14

    I think it's pretty stupid those who trusted S.M. although it's clear how manipulative they are to their artists.
    JYJ is not at fault. They're fighting for their rights and get tripped down over the years as the consequences.

    • @bastetowl3258
      @bastetowl3258 8 місяців тому

      yeah why would you support a big corporation over an artist?it’s like david and goliath

  • @kn8510
    @kn8510 11 років тому +4

    A 13 year contract! And 3 times the investment + twice the potential lost profits for breach of contract! Holy... I can see why sm would do that - they have to recoup the costs for all the trainees but still...Hopefully JYJ and Hangeng leaving has made sm contracts less ridiculous..

  • @funkyhaha11
    @funkyhaha11 9 років тому +6

    Woah, so if trainees don't debut, they have to pay back money to the company??

  • @TieraFF
    @TieraFF 11 років тому +11

    JYJ knew it would be real hard for them but they stood firm and opened the eyes of many. So, I think JYJ should be at least thought of kindly by the other SM artists because they now have better and fairer contracts.

    • @bastetowl3258
      @bastetowl3258 8 місяців тому

      they were ready for the possibility that they would never be in the korean entertainment industry again 😢

  • @PumpkinJuice93
    @PumpkinJuice93 11 років тому +15

    What a vile working ethic this company has.
    How were you able to obtain this information, what were your sources?
    I'm currently writing an essay on the ethics of music contracts and this would be greta to add in.

    • @danaliu3295
      @danaliu3295 11 років тому +6

      probably from the lawsuit...if you search it up you should be able to find it. JYJ3 has old sources from the lawsuit...but it's most likely biased so look in other areas too :)

  • @zinnwenwehtun6051
    @zinnwenwehtun6051 6 років тому +6

    At first I am one of international fan of TVXQ cause of Jaejoong but after lawsuit our Jaejoongie and JYJ members can't get perform in broadcast I don't watch and I will never watch in the future korea dramas and variety shows and Idols group or artists from SM

  • @AaA-lk8kx
    @AaA-lk8kx Рік тому +2

    And now exo-cbx is suing Sm

  • @gloriana7777
    @gloriana7777 6 років тому +5

    Usually I try and get both sides of the story but you would have to be blind not to see that sm has a problem. They always, always have such suits. With power comes great responsibility. SM is not allowed to use their powers to bully and disrespect individuals because their voice is not as loud or as strong. I am happy that recently other companies have been successful in debuting groups with just as much if not more success than SM so that they know they are not 'absolute' and treat their artists well. Bye.

  • @animefreak12375
    @animefreak12375 11 років тому +1

    Well we need more people like you to continue to spread the truth then. I think that if these lie are nipped in the bud Yunho and Changmin and other SM artists will receive less unwanted and unnecessary hate from fans. (There will always be anti's no matter where you go) I think over time things will slowly change since one cannot easily change the mind of a loyal and dedicated fan. I commend you for steeping up for your favorite idols.

  • @eirarosli
    @eirarosli 5 років тому +12

    and now, all I can say that JYJ stand strong by their own. They have so much fame and more important is, more money for them.

    • @tienqin96
      @tienqin96 4 роки тому

      Agree... But, they are still labelled traitors bcoz they betray Ho Min for no reason... Only plastic JYJ fans will say that they are doing this for their own good...

    • @yunheeflower5191
      @yunheeflower5191 3 роки тому

      And what about now? With yoochun and jaejoong build more and more scandal every year? Junsu is the clenn one

    • @aizjyjh1290
      @aizjyjh1290 3 роки тому

      @@yunheeflower5191 scandal is part of their life as an artist.....they may have a lot of scandal esp yoochun but as long as they have strong fans they will do good....

    • @yunheeflower5191
      @yunheeflower5191 3 роки тому

      @@aizjyjh1290 You mean to make jokes about being infected with corona and raping people in the toilet is save? Yoochun career already death.. And jaejoong? His face save everything..but we already know people's snort at him when he appear on tv. Let's admit it junsu is the clean one

    • @blavkhaert
      @blavkhaert 3 роки тому

      @@yunheeflower5191 Are you sure the artist you are supporting is clean? No one is completely clean. I who followed Yunho, Jaejoong, Yoochun, Changmin, and Junsu from long ago knew exactly what happened (with their case). You don't even know what you're saying. Korea is not as clean as it seems, everyone is trying to find scandal, their words can be twisted (Jaejoong most often), even a small scandal can become big when the buzzer intervenes. Even Jaejoong's case is not as serious as the case of other Korean artists (young artists who violated and gathered in bars during the early days of Covid) but everyone took it as a very serious matter than murder. Because Jaejoong made people aware of the dangers of Covid (at that time) and made TV shows that invited many artists were postponed because it turned out that many of the artists were affected by Covid.
      Junsu is the cleanest? People snort at him? Which people? I wanted to laugh reading it. But I won't tell you what happened. BELIEVE WHAT YOU WANT TO BELIEVE. But don't argue with me about the five of them.

  • @animefreak12375
    @animefreak12375 11 років тому

    I hope that your wish to have fans see Yunho and Changmin in a different light is fulfilled. You have already changed one person's mind. There will be a lot more to follow. :)

  • @kazasagisan
    @kazasagisan 10 років тому +2

    I still firmly believe that HoMin stayed behind because Yunho is known as "the one who keeps all promises" and it wasn't his personality or character to leave, and Changmin stayed bc, well, Changmin is Changmin. But please remember, Yunho did say they'd stand on stage together again one day. Maybe he's planning something, no?

  • @herpardra93
    @herpardra93 10 років тому +6

    Consumer issue (crazy fans) and management issue. Fans need to chill out and stop getting into celeb's privacy. Understand that they are human beings, who get sick, get hungry, desire privacy, and can be torn down!! Management needs to give consumers chill pills instead of forcing celebs to meet the stupid consumers' and fans' dumb demands.
    Hate reading about stupid netizens freaking out about kpop celebs on everything. Give them a break!!!!

  • @yuukichan0007
    @yuukichan0007 11 років тому +1

    i hope u got my answer from my previous post. YH n CM decision i dunno why n i dn wana make delusional conclusion so for now i am just fustrated over the fact that despite loosing the lawsuit and being ordered to remove bad on JYJ, they still cannot perform in their own country and receive unfair treatment like how SBS cutted Junsu's whole performance for airing despite attracting all fans to buy the ticket and simply saying it was an boardcast error.

  • @jkj3259
    @jkj3259 9 років тому +1

    its so funny how they try "test the limits of their "artist"" and yet artistically they dont excel. you can only name a few who actually gives effort

  • @jowaller4051
    @jowaller4051 6 років тому +2

    JaeJoong🦋재중

  • @33Meru
    @33Meru 10 років тому +2

    ok, so the video is suposed to give us facts about SM Entertainment but the first fact is already wrong.. because SM in the name doesn't stand for Lee SooMan anymore, but Success Museum
    no wonder people always say it wrong

  • @daisytai7502
    @daisytai7502 9 років тому +6

    actually LSM isnt really behind all this idk but my babies really respect LSM I am not sure who is behind all this right now but I am THINKING that it isnt LSM

    • @jaena88
      @jaena88 7 років тому +3

      parkjeon it’s not LSM.. sure he has some share in the issue but mostly it’s the former CEO, Kim Young Min to blame

  • @allforonekpop1140
    @allforonekpop1140 7 років тому +1

    0:01 THATS RIGHT, SM IS SO CARELESS

  • @colormiisky
    @colormiisky 5 років тому +1

    Sulli! 😭😭😭😭 Jonghyun! 😭😭😭😭

  • @seramusiclover
    @seramusiclover 12 років тому

    Owners of this video, can I share this (all the three video) on my blog? I did not earn anything. just wanna share with my readers.. can I? ^_^

  • @kayaraya1689
    @kayaraya1689 4 роки тому

    and i see ex exo's members treating like jerk too by SM ent.
    exo's chinese members : kris,Luhan,Lai? i dont stand them but i just heard about this.why SM treating people like a monster?

  • @cabalenabella53
    @cabalenabella53 9 років тому

    0:57 video link plssssssss

  • @animefreak12375
    @animefreak12375 11 років тому

    Again I apologize for the mistakes I have made and thank you for correcting them. I understand that you are very passionate but I do not wish to go back and forth with you. It is very clear that I am misinformed but please can you stop chewing my head off.

  • @yuukichan0007
    @yuukichan0007 11 років тому

    but i am not talking about shinhwa here.. and as shinhwa is my favourite group i know about their stuff.. my point is if SM was really right why did the Korean Law korean court verdict that JYJ received unfair work contract acc to korean work law?? and its not the first time.. Hangeng got verdict which shows they had that much amount of evidence to prove themselves.. if not SM could easily defend themselves cuz we know they are not small company to be defeated by mere boys in 20s

  • @LEEWONJIN897
    @LEEWONJIN897 7 років тому

    엑소도 동방처럼 3명의 중국인이 탈퇴를했죠... 그 경우는 H.O.T때와도 비슷해서 SM의 안타까운 징크스입니다

  • @yuukichan0007
    @yuukichan0007 11 років тому

    As for CJes knowing the stuff about junsu not being boardcasted.. just shows how much they were desperate to be able to perform infront of public.. and Cjes a small company cannot in any way defy to SBS and say no i am not going to do it cuz in the end of the day Cjes is the one who is gonna get dammage..
    and i dunno where this stoory is heading cuz u support ur ideas n i do mine so.. i will stop answering cuz there is no point is arguing with insufficient information..

  • @animefreak12375
    @animefreak12375 11 років тому

    You're welcome.

  • @xXxBlackConversexXx
    @xXxBlackConversexXx 11 років тому +1

    Damn...

  • @yuukichan0007
    @yuukichan0007 11 років тому

    so do YOU know the ABSOLUTE TRUTH? did SM provided any justification about it to you or your believer that you think the JYJ fansites are lying?? what makes you so different from them when you urself believe whats not been confirmed just because your bias is on the other side??

  • @nwenwehtun8361
    @nwenwehtun8361 6 років тому +2

    I hate that LSM

  • @Juju-nr7cb
    @Juju-nr7cb 9 років тому

    i hate SM so much you won't believe but i have a question why do these "idols" that we know and love like exo and such sign this contract from the start? why did they even agree to work with all these rules? why can't they find another company? or do something else. and from what i know american celebs are the richest in the world and yet they don't sign these contracts and they get to do what they wish with their lives so why SM can't do what america is do? they will be rich but not like this and even with all this hard work they're still not as rich as an american movies star or a singer in like 2 years they make more than what exo makes
    i know i keep saying exo but only coz they're the only SM band i listen to ;$

    • @EiriSenna
      @EiriSenna 8 років тому +1

      probably because debuting under the big 3 can ensure fame and success?

  • @KrnDarcy
    @KrnDarcy 11 років тому +1

    Dude, seriously calm down, not all fans bash Yunho and Changmin and not all fans go to their videos to say controversial stuff so please, for all the fans (including me) that haven't done anything, stop the freakin offended/angry comments. And I'm about to generalize just as you did, so you can see how freaking irritating that is: I hate THAT ALL OF YUNHO AND CHANGMIN'S FANS come to JYJ's videos to pick a fight!
    See how annoying that is? Then please don't.

  • @Elowai
    @Elowai 10 років тому

    Lol now we look at Kris' lawsuit hahahaha.

  • @alena3670
    @alena3670 9 років тому +12

    Tbh, I know I might get hate, but I don't really find SM a bad company, it's just that they have this unique way of trying to make the best out of all their artists, which is probably why almost all SM artists gets popular//SM tries to push all their artists to the limit, which is probably why most leave, but I can understand why they push them

    • @user-wo8yd3sn8e
      @user-wo8yd3sn8e 9 років тому

      +EXOTIC KPOPPER YES YES

    • @redimen5ion526
      @redimen5ion526 8 років тому

      -____- .... I mean I guess

    • @Elizabeth-hp1hr
      @Elizabeth-hp1hr 6 років тому +8

      Yeah pushing them to the point of their artists fainting on stage and getting IV drips in the hospital and even when they're sick and vomiting having them perform 2 hours later. Also making them perform with fractured foot and injured leg. Yeahhh SM isn't bad at all.

    • @Elizabeth-hp1hr
      @Elizabeth-hp1hr 6 років тому +4

      @Star Moonlight it's inhumane. Sm only cares about money but should care about their artists' health.

    • @Nirrini
      @Nirrini 6 років тому +4

      Elizabeth Don’t forget SM forgets about their own idols after 2 years, then makes a new group and forgets about them too after 2 years > repeat cycle all over again.

  • @yuukichan0007
    @yuukichan0007 11 років тому

    another thing.. neither jyj nor Homin has clarified anything about it.. so like u said people are spreading lies about HoMin people are spreading lies abt JYJ too saying they are greedy liars who does not deserve to perform.. don't think HoMIn is the only one suffering.. I dunno who is exactly at fault neither do u so, its kinda irony that you are asking people to stop making stuff about only HoMin not JYJ too.. I personally wish all the best to all 5 boys n hav a special place for Junsu's Voice

  • @animefreak12375
    @animefreak12375 11 років тому

    Ok thank you for clarifying that for me. However, I would very much appreciate it if you did not sound so vulgar in your response. I understand that you are merely correcting the mistakes I made but taking such an approach will only cause arguments. I see nothing wrong in you informing people but your delivery is very wrong. Please keep this in mind and again thank you for clearing up the misunderstanding.

  • @yuukichan0007
    @yuukichan0007 11 років тому

    omg u need to go see doc... or seriously put yourself in cjes or jyj's shoes..
    i do understand that people bashing on yunho and changmin is bad which i dont i only do korean fucked up industry n sm interference.. but u do realize that even JYJ get a lot of hatred for accusing on how they were greedy n all.. as i said at very first comment. none of DBSK member have clarified on why their thoughts split up so it wrong to make out victim ourself.. since i loved DBSK as 5 i support as separate 2

  • @auksebarak760
    @auksebarak760 11 років тому

    well, if you think western music companies are better, think again. I watched Artifact a couple of days ago and boy is the music industry fucked up in the west as well~