Vapour Permeability & The Truth About Stormdry

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
  • Roger carries out some tests to see if the claims made by Safeguard Stormdry are watertight.
    MORE ON STORMDRY
    Stormdry has been tested to EN ISO15148:2002 (E), demonstrating its effectiveness on concrete, mortar, brick, and sandstone.
    Stormdry masonry protection cream is applied to masonry in a single coat by means of brush, roller, or spray. Once applied, it penetrates deeply into the masonry before curing to form a colourless, breathable water repellent barrier.
    WHAT IS PENETRATING DAMP?
    Rain penetration through masonry (known as penetrating damp) is a common problem in buildings - particularly in the case of those of solid wall construction.
    The problem is also increasingly common in buildings of cavity wall construction where cavity wall insulation has been poorly installed or used in walls that are not suitable for cavity wall insulation.
    Other paths through which rain can cross through a cavity wall include incorrectly positioned wall ties and mortar obstructions in the cavity.
    Penetrating damp is caused by water permeating through walls from the outside. It can occur at all levels of a building but is more prevalent higher up.
    It is possible for damp to move within walls but this horizontal movement differs from the vertical movement of rising damp. Penetrating damp is usually caused by the following:
    Porous Walls - Aging bricks lose the ability to keep out rain penetration.
    Spalled Bricks & Degraded Mortar - Damage to brickwork allows water to penetrate.
    Building Defects - Defective guttering and downpipes, roof damage, dilapidated or poorly installed windows. In this case, fix the root of the problem before applying Stormdry to boost your protection.
    #Stormdry #VapourPermeability #Safeguard
    ===================================================
    Skill Builder Link Tree: linktr.ee/skil...
    Tell us what you like: skill-builder.u...
    Get in touch, send us your pictures and videos: skill-builder.u...
    Twitter: / skillbuilderuk
    Facebook: / skillbuilderchannel
    Out of respect to our channel sponsors and the wide variety of people who watch our videos, we will remove comments that do not follow common standards of politeness and decency.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 499

  • @markhaynes6410
    @markhaynes6410 4 роки тому +23

    Thanks for a great demonstration and the honesty to mention the "negligable" results from the independent test data. But mostly, thank you for bothering to take that extra step to re-assure not only the viewers but also yourselves in the face of questions. Open minds all round and always be prepared to change a viewpoint based on new info. Thank you.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому +4

      Mark
      The reference to 'negligible' is simply that the amount of moisture not escaping from the brick through evaporation is too small to make a significant difference.

  • @m4inline
    @m4inline 3 роки тому +7

    This channel is just bloody next level. Amazed at this stuff. Who needs school when you get content like this? Think i will just binge watch the whole channel history then print my own degree.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому +2

      That is very funny. We could issue diplomas.

    • @m4inline
      @m4inline 3 роки тому +1

      @@SkillBuilder and t shirts. "I watched everything on Skill Builder"

  • @GavinLawrence747
    @GavinLawrence747 4 роки тому +30

    The integrity of this channel is/was never in doubt. I think everybody agrees you are an honest and trustworthy channel. You gave me hope that there are still good tradesmen about.
    On the product, I certainly think there will be applications where this product is suitable. The problem is when people start using the wrong product to solve the problem.
    I think it probably works well on brick, but I do still have doubts as to anybody painting this on sandstone, especially in coastal areas!

    • @borodinskyful
      @borodinskyful 4 роки тому +1

      Except the dot and dab tiling that didn't get addressed

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому

      It did get addressed. You missed it. You can dot and dab and still meet the British Standard. No problem. The tiles are still there, no cracking or missing grout.

    • @stephencollins9062
      @stephencollins9062 Рік тому

      I am wanting to use it on a hard sandstone at the coast:/

  • @SavvasPapasavva
    @SavvasPapasavva 4 роки тому +16

    Lol - If you don't believe it, well you're never going to believe it... great final words of wisdom.

  • @ansaarscouts9644
    @ansaarscouts9644 Рік тому +9

    Have you done the same with a control sample? Without treatment showing water going trough? Would be good to see what head of water could be with held by a treated sample (without a positive pressure from in side). Other control I would like to see is two bricks saturated with water, then one treated one left untreated, and then left to air dry to see how long one takes to dry to the other. (Weight of brick dry and wet should measure how much water is locked in to the brick)

  • @TYLERCONSTRUCTION
    @TYLERCONSTRUCTION 4 роки тому +14

    Proof positive, stoomdry is breathable. Excellent video Rodger👍

  • @end-game2030
    @end-game2030 4 роки тому +105

    High quality way of silencing the keyboard warriors. Big up Skill Builder.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +12

      We will never silence those people who have closed minds. We know it works and does zero damage.

    • @davezeraschi7936
      @davezeraschi7936 4 роки тому +3

      Skill Builder well proved mate I’m satisfied with that proof 👍🤘

    • @chrislyon8677
      @chrislyon8677 3 роки тому +5

      @@SkillBuilder A mind is like a parachute: it works best when it is open

    • @corindoyle
      @corindoyle 3 роки тому +2

      Keyboard warrior here, sorry I mean a time served fixing mason who practically repairs old houses and actually understand the fundamentals of what is happening because of education, training and experience. Your house needs to get wet and then dry out as it needs the water to repair the micro fractures caused by thermal expansion through calcification. It also needs to breathe in both directions because of condensation forming in the walls. The rate of permeability is also important for different stone/brick types to prevent the formation of gypsum or effloressence on the facade, among many other things that can rapidly deteriorate the fabric and affect its look. Permeability of lime mortar for those interested is roughly, complete saturation in 15 mins for hot lime, 30-35 mins for putty and 60-80 mins for NHL. I'd be surpised if this ever gets fully saturated, meaning the mortar will dry out and crumble instead of turning to mush.

    • @FromePublishing
      @FromePublishing 3 роки тому

      @Horatio Nelson who talks sense

  • @stinser
    @stinser 4 роки тому +34

    I used storm dry about 6 months ago on our house to treat penetrating damp. I've been monitoring the moisture content of our walls internally and externally since then, and it has been dropping to the point where I no longer have a problem. Prior to that, there was year round damp (somewhat variable with the weather, but always higher than satisfactory). It's great stuff if used for the correct application, if a little pricey.

    • @TurinTuramber
      @TurinTuramber 4 роки тому +1

      Where was the damp coming from?

    • @stinser
      @stinser 4 роки тому +5

      @@TurinTuramber Rain. We're in a fairly exposed spot. The house is from the 30's. It's lovely, but the bricks are very porous and there is no cavity. I spent a long time confirming the problem and researching solutions.

    • @stinser
      @stinser 4 роки тому +3

      I should also add that there are loads of products out there which absolutely would lock moisture in. They have other uses. It's all about doing your homework and finding the right solution for the right problem. To echo what Roger says in the video, the independent analysis is available and my personal experience backs it up.

    • @alanbentham3784
      @alanbentham3784 4 роки тому +9

      Our house is victorian with a gable end wall. Every time it rained we had huge damp patches showing at the gable with three distinct areas showing wet. Tried other products and no better. Finally used Stormdry and it cured the problem straight away. I cannot recommend highly enough.

    • @johnf3326
      @johnf3326 Рік тому

      A lot pricey! £120 for 5L.

  • @mpsymonds1
    @mpsymonds1 4 роки тому +9

    I use Storm dry and swear by it. The best product that I have been introduced too. I remember seeing how much it cost for the first time and thought it was an error. 😂 I took the plunge and its worth every shackle. I think even brick manufacturers rate it, and they normally hate anything being coated onto their precious brick. Looking forward to your new Damp videos. I get the odd call to look at problems caused by potentially penetrating damp, normally it's straight forward like a faulty Gutter or Drainage but it's an interesting subject especially if it's rising damp etc. 👍

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +1

      Thanks Mark. Nice to have your comment based on experience. As you say most of it can be fixed easily by sorting out gutters and pipes etc. This product is good for chimneys with no dpc.

  • @daves4026
    @daves4026 4 роки тому +6

    Brill wanted to see this for years
    We used this on 3 properties. Great stuff

  • @glynbritton9792
    @glynbritton9792 Рік тому +3

    Fantastic clear video, thank you Roger. I’ve only just discovered your videos on UA-cam this week and absolutely hooked and picked up so much useful information. Stormdry is on my list of projects to apply to my 1930’s house, just had the pointing done now for stormdry. Keep them coming please 🙌.

  • @mrsc3120
    @mrsc3120 2 роки тому +4

    One of the best products I've ever used. It worked wonders on the old stone chapel that I live in. Can't recommend it highly enough.

  • @frankklein4872
    @frankklein4872 2 роки тому +3

    I've just used StormDry on old granite/slate chase. Mortar was lime mix two weeks before. I'll go extra on the flashing, top cap, drip edge, shale rock and joints. Great video Wodgey Rodge, although on a chase the ability to expel trapped water is negligible. I shall report back....

    • @XRah-vr5sx
      @XRah-vr5sx 5 місяців тому

      Report back then

  • @Lord-Brett-Sinclair
    @Lord-Brett-Sinclair 4 роки тому +7

    We had a house that seeped in water in via porous brick, this treatment worked a treat

    • @classic1989mini
      @classic1989mini 3 роки тому

      Does it feel any warmer, as claimed?

    • @Lord-Brett-Sinclair
      @Lord-Brett-Sinclair 3 роки тому +4

      Difficult to say, but it stopped the water which was a big relief.

    • @classic1989mini
      @classic1989mini 3 роки тому

      @@Lord-Brett-Sinclair that's all we need, cheers

  • @tomlee812
    @tomlee812 Рік тому +1

    Really interesting. We have damp penetration through our brickwork and I've ordered some Stormdry. Thanks for doing this to show me how it works.

  • @gpo746
    @gpo746 3 роки тому +2

    Thank you Roger. Your other stormdry video and this one is very informative and it will be a product I will use on our house .

  • @stuart.barkley
    @stuart.barkley 4 роки тому +8

    Roger’s done enough. He did the original video and there were doubters. Fair enough. He’s now done a fine job by going to the manufacturer and building an experiment to try and show the doubters that it does actually work. If this is not good enough then do the right thing instead of whingeing. Go out, buy the product yourself and demonstrate that it doesn’t work!

  • @manishpatel5236
    @manishpatel5236 3 роки тому +3

    Another Mic drop moment! Great video Roger! Well done and thank you for your video!
    What would be great is to see a video whereby there is damp whether that’s rising or penetrating and fixing the cause of it rather than masking the symptom... if you know what I mean. Thanks again! 🙌🏼👏

  • @SteveAndAlexBuild
    @SteveAndAlexBuild 4 роки тому +3

    Well I’m convinced Roger ! Great little demonstration 🧱👍🏽👌🏼

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +2

      Thanks 👍guys. This gets used on damp chimneys all the time.

    • @SteveAndAlexBuild
      @SteveAndAlexBuild 4 роки тому

      Skill Builder 🧱👍🏽

  • @tomlisi1561
    @tomlisi1561 12 днів тому

    I’ll be applying Stormdry to my house now … thanks for the great video

  • @shanehorton2047
    @shanehorton2047 3 роки тому +1

    This is brillant. I have a solid damp wall and when I watched your previous video this was my first concern but it's just confirmed its probably the right fix.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому +1

      It will do no harm which is reassuring.

  • @shaunglendinning
    @shaunglendinning 4 роки тому +2

    Great video Roger! Explained everything down to the tee! Cheers.

  • @kieronmorton8447
    @kieronmorton8447 4 роки тому +1

    Good vlog I,m a brickie and I,m always sceptical about these chemical products but this was a great test to show the product at work

  • @neilphilip2320
    @neilphilip2320 Рік тому

    A very convincing test to my eyes, thanks Roger!

  • @bitTorrenter
    @bitTorrenter Рік тому

    What a simple and great demonstration of the product.

  • @alanyoung7532
    @alanyoung7532 3 роки тому +1

    Thumbs up - Good to see you are open minded about these things as it is indeed necessary to verify the claims of manufactures. This demonstration was very interesting and does appear to support the claim that the coating is breathable. Strictly speaking however this demonstrated that air - rather than water escaping as water vapour - will readily passes through the sample under slight pressure. Would be illuminating therefore to seal water in the base of the container, place it in a dry place, and see how long the container takes to fully empty by simpler evaporation - maybe this has already been done?.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому +1

      Yes all those tests have been done but they are hard to film. There is no doubt at all that this coating is vapour permeable. If water turns to vapour the molecules are very fine and aren't trapped.

    • @alanyoung7532
      @alanyoung7532 3 роки тому

      Roger - just checked the Stormdry website and indeed they have done the water vapour test and found that the sample was, as you say, only slightly (10%) less breathable than the untreated sample and in many if not most cases this would be an acceptable reduction. If however the wall was damp due to internally generated moisture (eg condensation) a 10% reduction might be undesirable. Definitely learned something useful here, not least that it is necessary to track down the actual source of any excess moisturer before deciding upon a treatment method.

    • @alanyoung7532
      @alanyoung7532 3 роки тому

      @@SkillBuilder Roger - yep all accepted and an interesting demo.

  • @wade5941
    @wade5941 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent sir. I have an occasional problem with efflorescence on segmented retaining walls I construct. You gave some ideas for consideration.

  • @michaelhall5948
    @michaelhall5948 Рік тому

    Really interesting video, thanks for taking the time to do it. 👍🏻

  • @lazylad9064
    @lazylad9064 4 роки тому +14

    I like Rodger the scientists more than Rodger the skill builder😀.

  • @bisthebuilder8935
    @bisthebuilder8935 4 роки тому +2

    Good video Roger,
    Forget all the doubters.
    Tell them to go and use it.
    I have used this product for years on chimneys, single skin garage walls etc and never had a come back.
    There is the proof.

  • @martinbowker5920
    @martinbowker5920 3 роки тому

    Brilliant! ive just used this product on one of my Builds. It was astone property , with penatrating damp!

  • @paulramos5373
    @paulramos5373 Рік тому

    Thanks for this and all your other content Roger. I'll certainly be giving it a go.

  • @paulwalsh3848
    @paulwalsh3848 3 роки тому +3

    Quality product. Just applied some at high level and can see this being utilised much more frequently because of the Government's 2050 building regs.

  • @Samfarrelly
    @Samfarrelly 4 роки тому +2

    Nice one Roger!

  • @thecuttingsark5094
    @thecuttingsark5094 4 роки тому +14

    This is like the rain jacket breath ability debate. It’s basically plastic with holes (goretex etc.) the holes are too small for water but big enough for air and water vapour. The same as Tyvek.

    • @dreadlysmellybum
      @dreadlysmellybum 4 роки тому +1

      Exactly, some people do not understand this though...

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +3

      Dave 101. Spot on, it shouldn't be that hard to understand

    • @michaelballinger6419
      @michaelballinger6419 4 роки тому

      I wonder how well it performs after a number of years with a build up of dust etc from the environment. That's where water proofing on breathable substrates are less effective, but here I'm thinking of gortex which is undoubtedly completely different to brick. That was a fantastic display of the product in action, well done skill builder team!

  • @ianhenson724
    @ianhenson724 2 роки тому

    This is another great video, i purchsed this and will do again it is super stuff, you can feel the difference when inside it is like having new windows for the first time.

  • @matthumphries4208
    @matthumphries4208 4 роки тому

    Nice to see now i will use it on any cement mortar wall. Thanks for the info.

  • @ajr3553
    @ajr3553 Рік тому

    Thanks Roger, That has convinced me it works.

  • @pamvarnsverry2444
    @pamvarnsverry2444 Рік тому

    Thanks for the clarity

  • @adamflint2060
    @adamflint2060 4 роки тому +4

    Great video, and fair play for testing the products you've promoted and putting them under scrutiny. It takes balls as it may put future sponsors off but if everyone done this then hopefully, in the long run, lead to a higher standard of products across the board. I like the look of this product and I'm definitely going to try it, however, when the water was poured in you could see air bubble rising from the brick. That suggests that the water is penetrating the brick and forcing the air out? So maybe the brick is breathable because it isn't sealed by the product???

  • @liammullan2197
    @liammullan2197 2 роки тому

    This was really useful, thanks Roger

  • @enquire422
    @enquire422 2 роки тому +1

    Back in the early 80's they gave us an option, play rugby(in the freezing cold) or learn a skill. I chose the skill route and didn't look back but it was a shame we didn't have the Skill Builder channel in those days!

  • @TheSD2289
    @TheSD2289 11 місяців тому

    Very clear to anyone with half a brain that it works!! Well done, really good quick video !!

  • @jaredlogan1676
    @jaredlogan1676 2 роки тому +2

    Well dude it’s obvious the haters don’t know what they’re talking about. You don’t want to lock in moisture but that’s why you didn’t put it on the inside of the house lol. You did exactly what you want to do!

  • @lonniei1606
    @lonniei1606 Рік тому

    Wow! Great demonstration Roger. 🤓

  • @Southpoint2019
    @Southpoint2019 3 роки тому

    I have been using this stuff for years and it is incredible

  • @martinkiely3147
    @martinkiely3147 3 роки тому

    Great video thanks for making it as I am about to use this on a customers house and will also show them this video 👍

  • @vasvlogs8667
    @vasvlogs8667 15 днів тому +1

    Can I use this on brickwork that is painted ? The paint is quite old and is discoloured from damp..

  • @thehigman
    @thehigman 4 роки тому +1

    Hi Rodger thanks for the experiment. Scientifically though, you would need a control brick which hasn’t been treated with the storm dry. That should show water ingress. That said, clearly breathable. Cheers..

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому

      We will do more on this with a control sample but the test results are all there for public consumption.

  • @Investor_2000
    @Investor_2000 3 роки тому

    Utopia, excellent presentation! Well done that man 👍👏

  • @user-cn1em2qx6f
    @user-cn1em2qx6f Рік тому +1

    can you do some tests with acrylic masonry paints that claim to be breathable? and upload a vid would be good

  • @completepreservation
    @completepreservation 4 роки тому +2

    Well done Roger👍 Stormdry is a fantastic product which is proven over time, and has a BBA certificate. It isn’t like Thompson’s water seal either that isn’t uv resistant 👍

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +2

      Thank you Ross. At last someone who knows something about the product. So many people condemn it without every using it.

    • @completepreservation
      @completepreservation 4 роки тому +2

      Skill Builder keep up the good work Rodger 👌👌👌

  • @KyleBevis-u7j
    @KyleBevis-u7j 11 місяців тому +1

    People who question this don’t understand primary school science. Water = big droplets. Steam = tiny droplets. Tiny can leave through tiny pores. Big can’t enter through the same tiny pores. It’s literally some of the most basic stuff we teach children about water.

  • @grotekleum
    @grotekleum 3 роки тому

    Well, if you don't believe it now you don't want to believe it. Thanks for taking the trouble to show this stuff in action, as they say a picture (or video) says a thousand words.

  • @johnf3326
    @johnf3326 Рік тому +1

    Now try the experiment with brick treated with 'ordinary' silicon liquid. You are applying air pressure to one side that would not normally occur in real life situations. It would be interesting! Storm dry is about £120 for 5L so how much would be needed to treat a house? The savings in heat loss would have to be very significant to justify the cost, though if you have a damp problem, obviously the dual benefits of stopping that AND heat loss would make it worth the cost

  • @eelm2079
    @eelm2079 3 місяці тому

    awesome, thanks very much this is perfect

  • @NickBhat12
    @NickBhat12 4 роки тому +2

    Another great job chap! Wish my beer would retain co2 like that.

  • @robmaule4951
    @robmaule4951 4 роки тому +9

    Excellent Rog. Two fingers up to the keyboard warriors

  • @jimmy4952005
    @jimmy4952005 8 місяців тому

    well done and thank you on with a renovation at the moment the house is 1800 if not before all old sand stone with some damp going to paint the sand stone with this

  • @RB-qg1qx
    @RB-qg1qx 3 роки тому

    Great demo thanks!

  • @metal_loz
    @metal_loz Рік тому +1

    I'm so glad I found your channel this week. I bought Thompsons waterproof sealer as I have a small patch of penetrating damp from rain coming through 1920's brickwork. I was waiting for a dry weekend to apply it but have now gone out and bought stormdry understanding that Thompsons can lock in moisture. Wondering what I should do with a full 5L of Thompsons now...any suggestions for applicable uses?

  • @JakeBM4
    @JakeBM4 4 роки тому +11

    Interesting would have liked to see a control. Since the cavity was under pressure I don't think the water would have gone down either way.

    • @BAYUMBE
      @BAYUMBE 4 роки тому

      you are right.

    • @Heaveho120
      @Heaveho120 4 роки тому +3

      It would have when there was no pressure, at the beginning. The pressure is not contained as we saw, so particles are free to move, hence the bubbles. Air will escape anyway it can so as soon as pressure is applied its instantly released through the brickwork. Water is denser than air and will sink due to gravity. It didn't sink all the way thru into the cavity in this case. But a control is always handy.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +1

      OK Jake that is an easy demonstration to make. It works in the same way that Gortex works. Vapour passes through. If the water wanted to get in it would simply by displacing the air. Think about it and you will appreciate that it is not possible for the air to keep the water out if the air passes through the brick which it clearly does.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +1

      Spot on HunGrLow you have a brain which puts you in a minority here.

    • @JakeBM4
      @JakeBM4 4 роки тому

      @@SkillBuilder perhaps you are right, I'm no expert. Clearly don't have a brain either! But you should have had a control to illustrate your point.

  • @Youtubeuser1_me
    @Youtubeuser1_me 6 місяців тому

    Thank you Rodger

  • @stevendouglas3860
    @stevendouglas3860 4 роки тому

    Looks good, Roger .

  • @callumjohnson9433
    @callumjohnson9433 4 роки тому +2

    Love the channel been watching a while now. Always interesting. I have never used this product nor am I a builder but I do believe a better test needs to be done. In no situation would this stormdry be under pressure. When the little chamber was pressurised higher than the atmospheric pressure air is very likely to find its way through. In order for it to be a true and honest result the pressure both sides if the brick need to be equal as it would be in a real world building brick.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +4

      Callum
      This was not a test, it was a demonstration to show that air and vapour can pass through the Stormdry and it can therefore not trap moisture. We know that because the tests on this product have been carried out by several reputable labs across the world and they are published for public consumption. As for pressure in buildings if you assume that water vapour is passing through the building and there is sunshine on the wall which, even in the winter, will warm the wall up any moisture locked in that wall would certainly be under pressure but it is not necessary to apply pressure for the moisture to escape. Things dry out in the sun very easily so if there is a pathway through for air there will be one for water vapour. There is a lot to discuss when you start looking at the way vapour travels through a building and if you are interested in knowing more I will find you some good bedtime reading.

    • @callumjohnson9433
      @callumjohnson9433 4 роки тому

      @@SkillBuilder thankyou for the reply. Every episode I watch is lesson that I enjoy keep them coming :)

  • @Skleponline
    @Skleponline 3 роки тому +1

    There is pressure in the bottom chamber hence there is no chance of water getting down. But yes, looks like it allow air to pass through

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому

      Water is heavier than air. It is very simple science.....for some people.

    • @Skleponline
      @Skleponline 3 роки тому +1

      When pressure is built up - then weight do not matter at all.

  • @CP-du3ci
    @CP-du3ci 4 роки тому +2

    Good demo but what happens when the pressure in the bottom of the flask is lower than the pressure above the brick, i.e instead of pumping air in, suck it out. At what differential pressure will the water above the brick seep through? As a scientist Roger you should test all possible scenarios:-) Great chanel you and Robin do a great job both as tradesmen and UA-camrs.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +1

      I am not a scientist and there is nothing to be gained by sucking water through the coating. The suggestion was that the coating is impervious and this experiment, suck or blow proves it will allow vapour through. How will you see the vapour if it is being sucked through water to end up in the bottom. We all know that a vacuum will draw the moisture through the brick. That tells us nothing.

    • @CP-du3ci
      @CP-du3ci 4 роки тому +1

      @@SkillBuilder I know your not a scientist Roger, however it would have been interesting to see the pressure differential at which the coating failed to keep water from penetrating the brick from the outside, you know the job it is sold to do. And that is the point of sucking water through the coating. I am sure the detail is in the technical specs but your demos are so effective at letting us know the effectiveness of a product in real life I am just sceptical about this one. For example if you buy a tent they will give a measurement by which the fabric will resist water ingress, pointless for anything other than direct comparison between products, it would just have been interesting to see the same for this product. Also while your demo showed the product let air through the coating, in real life the pressure differential inside and outside a building is negligible as I understand it and so the test is not indicative of the product in use. If, as I suspect, water will penetrate the product equally well in both directions then there needs to be a different mechanism than just pressure as you demonstrated.
      You do a great job as I said and I am certain the product is worthy of use but be careful about the demos you put your name too, they may prove misleading.

    • @josepeixoto3384
      @josepeixoto3384 2 роки тому

      @@CP-du3ci if the pressure dif.is nill, does it still matter ?

    • @samuelfulbrook6776
      @samuelfulbrook6776 Рік тому

      The product is supposed to be reapplied after so many years from my understanding. Also that level of pressurised water saturation of an external wall isn’t likely, unless you think you’re going to use storm dry to waterproof a swimming pool.

  • @rikardsaje
    @rikardsaje 3 місяці тому

    Fantastic! I need to coat my chimney.

  • @kevinthepilgrim5441
    @kevinthepilgrim5441 9 місяців тому

    You could also conduct a Karsten tube test.

  • @michaelinkster4977
    @michaelinkster4977 3 роки тому +2

    Would you apply Storm Dry to a Sandstone building?

  • @CheeseToasties
    @CheeseToasties 3 роки тому

    Thank you for this video !!

  • @AltaMirage
    @AltaMirage 3 роки тому

    Cheers mate. Great vid.

  • @DonovanLee
    @DonovanLee 7 місяців тому

    Quality work here

  • @GedandMichele
    @GedandMichele 4 роки тому +5

    Hi Roger.Reference your comment on more videos on damp, I've got a damp wall I need to sort out if you want to use it for demo purposes.I'm just up the road from Robin if that works for you?

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +1

      Hi Gerard
      I would be interested in looking at it and seeing if there is something we might do.

    • @GedandMichele
      @GedandMichele 4 роки тому

      @@SkillBuilder Great. My email address is gerard.cox@hotmail.co.uk and I'll share my phone number with you

  • @johnbell7552
    @johnbell7552 4 роки тому

    A great demonstration & a conclusive result 👍 but I bet you’ll still get a few sceptics 😉

  • @G_Grip
    @G_Grip 6 місяців тому

    Difference between storm dry and storm dry max? Does the max still dry without changing the color of the brick?

  • @jamesjm1987
    @jamesjm1987 4 роки тому +1

    I'm a BCO and we can accept this instead of a cavity tray if theres a good reason one can't be installed.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +1

      Hi James
      I must admit if I have seen that kind of penetration over an opening that has no tray I have recommended a coating of Stormdry but, obviouly, if a tray can be fitted it should be.

  • @namenotavailable11
    @namenotavailable11 4 роки тому

    The theory is sound. Water vapour is a much smaller molecule than a liquid water molecule. You can make products that allow water vapour (a gas) pass through but a water molecule (liquid) can't pass because of it's larger size. Gortex fabric does the same thing. You can stand in a shower with a Gortex jacket on and not get wet, but it allows your body to breathe (pass water vapour) so you don't feel clammy.

  • @johnmorrissey1675
    @johnmorrissey1675 3 роки тому

    This would be ideal for houses in flood area's to keep the foul water from penetrating deep into the walls , maybe ? good video 👍🇮🇪🍀

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому +1

      Check out their website where they show that very application with a cavity pump.

  • @indianatone218
    @indianatone218 2 місяці тому

    Thanks for showing us roger question tho ? can yo put masonry paint over the coating ?

  • @christopherhughes2848
    @christopherhughes2848 7 місяців тому

    Can ‘Stormdry’ be used to ‘tank’ garage wall from the inside?. To stop water penatration.

  • @alan36753
    @alan36753 3 роки тому

    Great channel, great product and I need to waterproof a wall but the price...!!! Wow

  • @o04n7h0n90o
    @o04n7h0n90o 3 роки тому

    Great video!!!

  • @djgoody1210
    @djgoody1210 Місяць тому

    Quick question…… can this be applied onto brickwork after it’s been cleaned using Disclean or similar?

  • @dougal8812
    @dougal8812 4 роки тому +6

    Air (predominantly O2 and N2) are smaller molecules than water (H2O) so this doesn't necessarily show us that it will let the water out of the wall. A better test would be to have a brick with stormdry only on one side, then put the water on the side *without the stormdry* and see if the side with the stormdry gets damp/is more humid. If it is damp/humid on the stormdry side then it is letting the water though the brick and vice versa.
    I would note that breathability has multiple meanings, in the case of letting old buildings breath people obviously mean allowing water to pass while I suspect the breathability stormdry are talking about, and what you have shown with that experiment, is air breathability which is kind of beside the point.

    • @ricos1497
      @ricos1497 4 роки тому

      That's a very good point. I'd be interested to hear Roger's thoughts on it. I'm guessing if water can't come in, it likely can't go out either. But if there was never water in the cavity, then wouldn't the breathable air flow be enough to prevent condensation?

    • @tobsco2
      @tobsco2 4 роки тому +2

      Water is actually smaller than oxygen (O2), the hydrogen atoms are tiny so even though there are more atoms, the molecule is smaller. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_diameter

    • @dougal8812
      @dougal8812 4 роки тому +3

      @@tobsco2 Ooooooh, that's interesting! I haven't heard of that before!
      Though, I think it would be worth doing the experiment as I've described to see what would happen because it's a more realistic simulation then pushing air through a brick.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +5

      Edward you are not seriously suggesting that water vapour is unable to pass through the same space as air. Water vapour, is way finer than droplets and will pass through almost every kind of building material. That is the whole reason we end up with interstitial condensation and the reason that vaoour barriers are installed.

    • @dougal8812
      @dougal8812 4 роки тому +1

      ​@@SkillBuilder Well obviously! 😭😭😭 Of course water can pass through almost every building material, if it didn't then dpcs and things like stormdry wouldn't be needed. That's obviously not what I am saying.
      All I'm saying is we want the product to allow the water in the building to escape, and the better way to asses that is to do the experiment as I described above. i.e. wet/damp brick with stormdry on one side, check if the brick is releasing water from he stormdry side (which is the way I was thinking when I was talking about humidity on the stormdry side of the brick in the original comment)

  • @alanmorgan1389
    @alanmorgan1389 3 роки тому

    Interesting - well Roger, you have clearely demonstratd that air molecules under pressure can be pushed up through the brick sample but surely, that is not the same as water vapour (so larger molecular sizes?) under just atmospheric pressure being able to do the same? PS I'm not a chemist or physicist, just a curious bod. And I've only just started to watch your channel and I love the stuff you're doing so please don't take my comments as a criticism.

  • @tam2083
    @tam2083 4 роки тому +1

    Try it with no ayr in the bottom chamber and water in the top chamber and see what happens ayr pressure keeping the water from penetrating

    • @lameduck3630
      @lameduck3630 4 роки тому

      But most people have air pressure inside their house

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому

      @@lameduck3630 In Scotland they have Ayr pressure

  • @peteh1942
    @peteh1942 3 роки тому

    Just had my roofer endorse the product 100%

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  3 роки тому

      people who have used it tend to like it a lot, people who haven't seem to know all about it.

  • @alpachino468
    @alpachino468 Рік тому

    I need some advice please to anyone who is kind enough to help.
    We have a (196sq m) detached house built around 2005 with a 100m cavity and fibre insulation. Our house is always cold and never retains any heat at all. Today, we had an insulation company visit to do a brief inspection and to provide a quote for replacement insulation, but the removal/adding in of new polystyrene ball insulation is very pricey at around £16k. Their other solution was to spray the walls with Stormdry, which is a 3rd of the cost and they say will allow the existing fibre insulation to dry out - as they suspect it might have gotten wet and isn't working effectively any more. They reckon we can get up to around 80% efficiency with the existing insulation and the Stormdry working in tandem together. I'm really not sure if what we've been told will work for us and need some advice please.

  • @chrissyjames7711
    @chrissyjames7711 Рік тому

    ok the big question for me is
    why they sell the repointing additive doesnt the cream do the whole job ?
    videos of product in action show just brick not brick and cement , found one video showing additive used in conjunction with cream , result seemed to show positive results , but the grey area for me is ................ why the pointing additive for extra protection doesnt help with lime though ? Roger the adverts use the words " storm dry " but all their products are called storm dry ... so in theory they dont have to say use storm dry pointing additive and use cream ...100% the key is inspection of the pointing as it will leak through there.

  • @Nickpaintbrush
    @Nickpaintbrush 4 роки тому

    Looks great!

  • @ranxxerox6407
    @ranxxerox6407 7 місяців тому

    Roger Bisby is…. The Science Guy!

  • @davidreece1642
    @davidreece1642 3 роки тому

    How about applying negative pressure ie a vacuum rather than positive pressure via the hand pump. If the water is sucked thru' the brick slice ie downwards then that would show porosity. The positive pressure prevents any water from flowing downwards into the lower chamber.

  • @ttfweb1
    @ttfweb1 4 роки тому +1

    Great video. My dad was a mason for 50 years, and maintains you should never paint anything on brickwork. And with the technology he lived with - good idea. New tech can change things - this looks great.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +1

      Respect for your Dad but there are plenty of products that can help to prevent rain penetration. Chimney stacks are particularly prone to damp being wicked down into the bedrooms. They used to use linseed oil to try and reduce this. The only trouble it that the starlings love it and peck away at the mortar.

  • @billyarnold1578
    @billyarnold1578 10 місяців тому

    Thank you Roger I have a cavity extension and room is cold so I will definitely try this to see would it help keep cold out
    Slso I will be doing in side plaster walls on termalite water coat paint
    Regards
    Billy Arnold
    Ireland

  • @george-1961
    @george-1961 4 роки тому +1

    I wanted to use this in a job but the customer was not prepared to pay the price of that product

  • @triedzidono
    @triedzidono 6 місяців тому

    How many coats before it blocks the pores?
    very thin wafer of brick
    is the surface of the brick a surface edge or cut edge?
    I'm not a skeptic but I find the test a bit rushed, still planning on trying the stuff.

  • @Benchandbeyond
    @Benchandbeyond Рік тому

    I am not dispiting that Stormdry works but the test presented seemed floored because air was pumped into the bottom chamber so the air pressure would pressure would of prevented the water seeping in. Would be good to see the test done again but with the pumps tube removed.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  Рік тому

      The test had nothing to do with whether Stormdry repels water, there is no argument about that. The point of the test was to show that even though it is waterproof it still allows air (and therefore water vapour) to pass through. This means it can't trap moisture in the wall.

  • @davidstevan1
    @davidstevan1 4 місяці тому

    I and my roofer are struggling to identify the source of water ingress that is causing a damp patch where an upper bedroom ceiling meets the short side of a chimney. My roofer has done all he can to ensure the roof around the external chimney stack is water tight but the problem still persists. The external chimney stack is rendered with no obvious and easily seen cracks but the the thinking is that this render must be in some way degraded and allowing water to pass through onto the mortar which is then making its way down or accross to cause the damp patch described. Having watched this excellent video about Stormdry I wondered if that might help. Unfortunately the render on the stack has previously been painted and I understand Stormdry would not work in that situation, it needs to penetrate the brick (and mortar?). Is there another water proofing product you would recommend for application to render that has previously been painted? Kind regards and thanks for this and all your other videos, a great source of honest information and opinion.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 місяці тому

      You can try a silicone paint but it may not cure the problem. It is possible that the ceiling is sucking water out of the brickwork. If there is warm moist air rising inside the chimney it will condense on the brickwork as soon as it hits the unheated area of the chimney. This will soak the brickwork and the warmth of the house will draw it back in, It is often worse on the North side of the stack. That is why we ventilate the chimney stack when it isn't used.
      I am not saying that is the only cause but I have seen peotngple spend thousands on a chimney stack and still have that nagging bit of damp. I would recommend cutting a slit in the plasterboard and filling the gap with a waterproof caulking. At least that will break the link and allow the plasterboar to dry out.

    • @davidstevan1
      @davidstevan1 4 місяці тому

      @@SkillBuilder Thank you for taking time to reply, much appreciated. Yes, ££££'s already!!!! Back to the drawing board!

  • @falfield
    @falfield 3 роки тому

    Very inventive demonstration. Belzona make something similar - also very expensive. But sprayed on, so much quicker application and greater reach from single position. Less easy to see the bit you've already done than with Stormdry. but this only a drawback if you are haphazard.

    • @lksf9820
      @lksf9820 10 місяців тому

      You can spray Stormdry on too.