Astroturf and manipulation of media messages | Sharyl Attkisson | TEDxUniversityofNevada

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
  • In this eye-opening talk, veteran investigative journalist Sharyl Attkisson shows how astroturf, or fake grassroots movements funded by political, corporate, or other special interests very effectively manipulate and distort media messages.
    Sharyl Attkisson is an investigative journalist based in Washington D.C. She is currently writing a book entitled Stonewalled (Harper Collins), which addresses the unseen influences of corporations and special interests on the information and images the public receives every day in the news and elsewhere. For twenty years (through March 2014), Attkisson was a correspondent for CBS News. In 2013, she received an Emmy Award for Outstanding Investigative Journalism for her reporting on “The Business of Congress,” which included an undercover investigation into fundraising by Republican freshmen. She also received Emmy nominations in 2013 for Benghazi: Dying for Security and Green Energy Going Red. Additionally, Attkisson received a 2013 Daytime Emmy Award as part of the CBS Sunday Morning team’s entry for Outstanding Morning Program for her report: “Washington Lobbying: K-Street Behind Closed Doors.” In September 2012, Attkisson also received an Emmy for Oustanding Investigative Journalism for the “Gunwalker: Fast and Furious” story. She received the RTNDA Edward R. Murrow Award for Excellence in Investigative Reporting for the same story. Attkisson received an Investigative Emmy Award in 2009 for her exclusive investigations into TARP and the bank bailout. She received an Investigative Emmy Award in 2002 for her series of exclusive reports about mismanagement at the Red Cross.
    This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at ted.com/tedx

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,1 тис.

  • @JDHD2
    @JDHD2 3 роки тому +479

    This video is more relevant now than ever before... explains the widespread banning of certain opinions on all these various platforms.

    • @robinnouri8335
      @robinnouri8335 3 роки тому +8

      Totally agree with you.

    • @richardkbreuer
      @richardkbreuer 2 роки тому +10

      Yep. It is key to understand what's going on right now.

    • @IntoTheBushSC
      @IntoTheBushSC 2 роки тому +3

      Yeah the republicans and conservatives are really going full on fascist.

    • @fouadmas5413
      @fouadmas5413 2 роки тому +5

      I wish they would censor opinions, they are currently Censoring FACTS

    • @sickofcrap8992
      @sickofcrap8992 2 роки тому +6

      Including utube, with it's bots that try to generate hatred for the people speaking the truth.

  • @shreyaveni9185
    @shreyaveni9185 3 роки тому +271

    "They start to question those who question the authority" I have never heard a more true sentence in my life! Great job Sharyl!

    • @methodicalmayhem5881
      @methodicalmayhem5881 2 роки тому +9

      I could be wrong and please correct me, but in my humble opinion it has always been the people in authority who have been responsible for hurting society on a large scale.

    • @methodicalmayhem5881
      @methodicalmayhem5881 2 роки тому +8

      Might I also add that questions don't kill people. Corrupt officials kill the people who are asking the right questions.

    • @tristramgordon8252
      @tristramgordon8252 2 роки тому +2

      "Authority" great word. But, I believe nobody, no group, no government, nobody has "authority" over you unless you consent. UK government private profit-making company, same with police, local "authorities" oops, see how it all works.

  • @najatm
    @najatm 9 років тому +999

    she's only touching the tip of the iceberg.

    • @Neo-pi7xd
      @Neo-pi7xd 9 років тому +30

      Najat Madry Still enough to woke up more people :)

    • @only1barbi
      @only1barbi 9 років тому +10

      EXACTLY - ALL IS NOT as it seems.

    • @only1barbi
      @only1barbi 9 років тому

      +NyxrheaFX yup

    • @kargs5krun
      @kargs5krun 9 років тому +1

      +Najat Madry or......"scratching the surface" (but who's 'surface/iceberg' begs the question?)

    • @bounchofbeaners
      @bounchofbeaners 9 років тому +20

      +Mark Wright no the whole ice burg being the banking elites wanting to rule the world and make the people slaves while giving up all our rights and creating a one world religion , one world government, and one world currency............

  • @hotwax9376
    @hotwax9376 5 років тому +499

    "If you don't read the newspaper, you're uninformed; if you do read the newspaper, you're misinformed." -Mark Twain

    • @leslielandberg5620
      @leslielandberg5620 4 роки тому +1

      And he didn't want all his papers published for 100 years! (it should have been 200 years.)

    • @Marzen01
      @Marzen01 4 роки тому +4

      @@rocinante8200 93.78% of facts are made up.

    • @ZigSputnik
      @ZigSputnik 4 роки тому +1

      @@rocinante8200 So who said it?

  • @cleitonsiqueira8769
    @cleitonsiqueira8769 2 роки тому +287

    This video was prophetic. Extremely relatable to what we are living right now.

    • @zenchristafarian4404
      @zenchristafarian4404 2 роки тому +9

      So true!

    • @mikeslemonade
      @mikeslemonade 2 роки тому

      It’s almost all come from the left with this fake news, manipulation, and corruption.

    • @tristramgordon8252
      @tristramgordon8252 2 роки тому +1

      This has being going on for the last 50 years at least, but people who "want", cannot think logically

    • @Anstreki323
      @Anstreki323 Рік тому

      only if you have zero iq

  • @BoiseG
    @BoiseG 8 років тому +1202

    Did this woman make it home alive after her speech?

    • @dwightehowell6062
      @dwightehowell6062 8 років тому +65

      +wBryang Yup. To many fools don't listen. They like the dark.

    • @eddiedevere72
      @eddiedevere72 8 років тому +72

      +wBryang gives me some faith in the TED talk organizers, that they would permit this. Unless of course it was just that they failed to read her transcript and then were just too gobsmacked - especially when she so eloquently exposes Wikipedia - to pull the plug!

    • @ianstewart8243
      @ianstewart8243 8 років тому +68

      Wikipedia is straight out of 1984

    • @m.x.
      @m.x. 8 років тому +19

      Or rather she's doing exactly what she's criticising and you're buying her eloquent shit. Check her CV and background, double check her sources and you'll see what I mean.

    • @dwightehowell6062
      @dwightehowell6062 8 років тому +13

      Ah.a Globalist here to share the gospel of one world big government run by the elites for the benefit of the elites.

  • @joshuasmith9251
    @joshuasmith9251 3 роки тому +98

    Everyone should watch this great presentation. Especially in these days of media manipulation and deceit.

    • @staho9796
      @staho9796 Рік тому

      Ten kto czyta Biblie nie musi , bo wie że tam jest napisane ....,, Serca synów ludzkich są pełne zła i głupota mieszka w ich sercach dopuki żyją!!!,, księga Koheleta starożytni to wiedzieli już 3 tys lat temu...

  • @FarmerBenny
    @FarmerBenny 9 років тому +675

    Question everything. Don't assume anything is truth. For everything you learn, consider its opposite. For everything you learn, consider who is benefitting from you learning this information - who is making money from you knowing this information?

    • @killyourtelllievision
      @killyourtelllievision 9 років тому +7

      well said. if the shame stream, criminal, corporate Zionnazi media pro pagan DUH media were also objective...they'd do their jobs as she does

    • @Trackstar2211
      @Trackstar2211 9 років тому +4

      FarmerBenny Good comment.

    • @thekeytothegate
      @thekeytothegate 9 років тому +7

      FarmerBenny Conisder the opposite! Yes sir, bang on, it's crucial for your survival!

    • @flanagan2k
      @flanagan2k 9 років тому +2

      +racist is code for anti-white lol you are a good example of what we are talking about.

    • @josephblow6654
      @josephblow6654 9 років тому +10

      +flanagan2k I have to agree with Adam. 99% of the time you hear "racism" mentioned it's about white people. Do you really think Whites have a monopoly on racism???

  • @MrCharlyAndy
    @MrCharlyAndy 8 років тому +414

    She really hit a nerve with this talk! I instantly found a website that did nothing but smear her character after she gave this talk. Think about the content. Does it ring true? Have you ever noticed the things she says? Bravo, Sheryl!

    • @scottfitness5693
      @scottfitness5693 8 років тому +5

      +Charles Crummer Spread the word Charles! Thanks.

    • @AndyJK45
      @AndyJK45 5 років тому +17

      Charles Crummer This business of refusing to address the data and making accusations like quack and crank is classic of people who know they do not have command of the facts, and have to resort to abuse.

    • @AndyJK45
      @AndyJK45 5 років тому +21

      Or to put it more concisely.
      JUST PLAY THE BALL
      If you have to attack the character of the speaker rather than address the facts, you have no facts of your own to rely on.

    • @Jleigh225
      @Jleigh225 5 років тому +12

      This is 100% true. This woman is brave and awesome for discussing!

    • @Dan-iy8ig
      @Dan-iy8ig 4 роки тому +1

      @J T I think you need to get in line for a new brain dude!!

  • @baconlatte
    @baconlatte 8 років тому +79

    "I recognized the phrase 'ask your doctor' as a catchphrase promoted by the pharmaceutical industry. They know that if they can get your foot through the door of the doctor's office to mention a malady, you're very likely to be prescribed the latest drug that is marketed."
    And there is our medical system in a nutshell.

    • @MizzoniDojo
      @MizzoniDojo 2 роки тому +14

      Much like how "safe and effective" is a catch phrase. A marketing slogan

    • @danawilkes6174
      @danawilkes6174 2 роки тому +1

      @@MizzoniDojo I hate that phrase as much as I hate the word vaccine!

    • @conradmbugua9098
      @conradmbugua9098 Рік тому

      @@danawilkes6174 more like quack_ccine or poisonation

  • @TheMagpiegal
    @TheMagpiegal 3 роки тому +8

    Real in the era of Cv19

  • @Beags0004
    @Beags0004 3 роки тому +59

    This should be taught in every classroom across the world and then every year after given as a refresher. In today's world of Covid it's more imperative than ever that we understand this. Question everything!

    • @userer4579
      @userer4579 Рік тому +6

      Ha! That would be ironic since the classroom has become one of the primary venues for "astroturfing" where myth and misinformation are being passed-off as fact.

    • @adararelgnel2695
      @adararelgnel2695 22 дні тому

      The classroom??? Lmao!!! The government funded, government run, lie filed classroom? You've got some growing to do.

  • @vaclavnovak9458
    @vaclavnovak9458 2 роки тому +23

    Flash-forward 2021, This one aged like a wine 🍷

  • @3chords490
    @3chords490 5 років тому +133

    “A nation of sheep will beget a government of wolves.”
    ― Edward R. Murrow

    • @Noor-jw2tn
      @Noor-jw2tn 3 роки тому +1

      Sheep live in fear of wolves all their lives. When in the end it's the Shepherd that eats them.

    • @rinzler9171
      @rinzler9171 3 роки тому

      McCarthy was right.

  • @iliveintheozarks
    @iliveintheozarks 9 років тому +387

    Instead of questioning authority,they question those who question authority. Brilliant!

    • @Matanumi
      @Matanumi 9 років тому +23

      believe in nothing, question everything

    • @furballbear
      @furballbear 9 років тому +22

      Sandra Priest Just like questioning NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden's motives rather than those of the NSA.

    • @iliveintheozarks
      @iliveintheozarks 9 років тому +12

      furballbear--yes,it is the future of the media,to condemn the ones who rightfully question and the public who so blindly goes along with it never asking the real questions. Language sorcery is my new term for it.

    • @louisvictor3473
      @louisvictor3473 9 років тому +13

      furballbear You can question both, you know.

    • @moushmoush
      @moushmoush 9 років тому +4

      Sandra Priest It's more the good old fashioned NLP - Neurolinguistic Programming

  • @NealFox
    @NealFox 9 років тому +84

    This should be part of everyones education. Great video.

  • @_ColdAssHonkey_
    @_ColdAssHonkey_ 3 роки тому +198

    Surprised this video is still on youtube. She spelled out the playbook of the game Big Tech and the mainstream media are playing.

    • @robertkratch8265
      @robertkratch8265 2 роки тому +4

      Now you know why Bill Belichek"s press conferences are so boring. He loathes the media.

    • @jfarr3760
      @jfarr3760 Рік тому +2

      Exactly!!!

    • @KimberlyBishh
      @KimberlyBishh Рік тому

      Celebrities politicians there's no difference anymore 98% of them all want the limelight that's all they're concerned about is being famous and having bodyguards to tell people to go away get away from them like they have real power they sure don't wield it right that's for sure.. It's the me me me me me politician we will never get rid of

  • @StephenBennettEsq
    @StephenBennettEsq 8 років тому +207

    Well done, Sharyl Attkisson! I especially like how you challenged Snopes. Bravo!
    My favorite line here is, "Instead of questioning authority, they question those who question authority."

    • @m.j.2939
      @m.j.2939 4 роки тому +19

      Still can't believe anyone doesn't understand snopes is a joke. Funded by Soros to debunk anything going against the agendas.

    • @FullMetalB
      @FullMetalB 4 роки тому +6

      @@m.j.2939 bahahahahahaha love how so many of you drone on and on about what's funded by George soros but don't say a peep about everything funded by the kochs.

    • @m.j.2939
      @m.j.2939 4 роки тому +2

      @@FullMetalB mmmm haven't heard that name. Going to look into them now. I'm not from America. I see they are big business, interesting.

    • @JazenValencia
      @JazenValencia 4 роки тому +7

      @@FullMetalB As though they're a difference. Coke and Pepsi.

    • @tristramgordon8252
      @tristramgordon8252 2 роки тому

      Ah, there is no authority, unless you consent to it.

  • @girohead
    @girohead 8 років тому +36

    Bravo, I've been complaining about This MISinformation Age for years, yet when I mention how Yelp and Wikipedia actually work and should be discredited or that 'there is no National sleep Foundation', I get ridiculed. The only irony is that Ted Talks are or can easily go down the same path: just put together a good presentation, usually emotional and tugging at the heart, and you have the same exact issue: they're out there. Question everything!

  • @channelfadge7438
    @channelfadge7438 8 років тому +37

    "they attack the people making the accusations instead of addressing the accusations themselves" now the media response to gamergate makes perfect sense

  • @roycameron2119
    @roycameron2119 9 років тому +34

    Thank you. You are just amazing. That was an excellent summary of the whole problem and why people, such as myself, tend to be treated with some hostility by people who don't understand that their own perspective was the result of a manipulation.
    Wikipedia has no excuse and must be denounced for what it is. The Philip Roth story is one that completely displays just how bad these narcissistic, self exalted experts are who run social media.

  • @seanfinlay4272
    @seanfinlay4272 8 років тому +50

    Brilliant!
    We need to bring this forward right now...because "“The further a society drifts from truth, the more it will hate those who speak it.” George Orwell.

  • @Redeemer_80
    @Redeemer_80 3 роки тому +14

    This aged really well. Prophetic almost

  • @IgorChudov
    @IgorChudov 2 роки тому +21

    Your lecture is just as prophetic ads the movie Idiocracy. Good ideas do NOT expire and your ideas expressed here will never expire also.

  • @ShaktaWizard
    @ShaktaWizard Рік тому +14

    I am so blessed to have found this video when I did. I was 25 y.o. attending college and I was already beginning to question things because I was beginning to see flaws in official statements and even my textbooks and tests. Then I came across this video and it all became clear to me. I can easily detect lies and half truths now. Thank you Sharyl.

  • @debbitwisdom4583
    @debbitwisdom4583 9 років тому +40

    Thank you Sharyl........you are a true honest journalist!

  • @maddalenagalanti2341
    @maddalenagalanti2341 3 роки тому +3

    i thought this was uploaded in 2021. it was 6 years ago. Now it’s worse than 2015. I am shocked. videos like these don’t make it anymore these days. bias everywhere!

  • @SpeedDeamon95
    @SpeedDeamon95 4 роки тому +42

    I think she perfectly described the media's stance with guns.

    • @JeazleWeasel
      @JeazleWeasel 4 роки тому +6

      Vaccines?

    • @alekm8294
      @alekm8294 4 роки тому +4

      Chris I'm not sure if I'm understanding your comment correctly, but there's astroturfing running rampant on both sides of US politics. Just like she said if they focus on smearing the other side there's probably an agenda. In this case one side says "libs want to take our guns" and the other is "conservatives are allowing school shootings" its two sides of the same coin.

    • @alekm8294
      @alekm8294 4 роки тому

      ​@CalvinSomething Not sure I understand your message here, but both sides stride for different freedoms so it's just a question of perspective. Google a political compass, in general liberals stride for political freedom while conservatives stride for economic freedom. If the government has neither it's considered authoritarian if it has both it's considered libertarian. I don't think being too attached to any political identity is healthy though. Don't let the news make you hate your neighbor, everyone wants what's best for their country whether you agree with them or not. It's really easy to get caught up in confirmation bias these days, but I can ensure you there are people manipulating the public from all angles and all parties.

    • @alekm8294
      @alekm8294 4 роки тому +2

      @CalvinSomething This is not my opinion, but I'll play devils advocate. Lets say, I'm an avid authoritarian and I want whoever is in control to have as much power as they please. Who are you to say that is "wrong." It's an opinion not a fact. And regards to astroturfing, lets take blacklivesmatter vs bluelivesmatter protests where a single group was traced to be setting up both sides of the protests on Facebook. Who was really fighting for liberty? Neither, because they were just puppets in someones game to pin people against each other.

    • @alekm8294
      @alekm8294 4 роки тому

      @CalvinSomething is it wrong to murder a serial killer?

  • @zacharymims4889
    @zacharymims4889 9 років тому +72

    GREAT VIDEO! ITS AMAZING THAT EVEN KNOWING THIS, PEOPLE STILL BELIEVE WHAT THE WATCH ON TV AND READ IN MAGAZINES

    • @aquamarine0023
      @aquamarine0023 9 років тому +13

      +Zachary Mims Exactly. People will watch this, plus they will read books like 1984, Brave New World and watch movies like The Matrix and V for Vendetta, plus hear about all the deaths caused by pharma drugs, but yet will STILL believe what the mainstream media tells them. They don't give a damn what is true, all they care about is believing in whatever is POPULAR.

    • @isays
      @isays 8 років тому

      +Zachary Mims did you watch this video and just believe it without looking into who she is and checking the (very few) sources she mentioned?
      If so, congratulations you're a victim of confirmation bias, you're part of the very problem she is talking about.

    • @RodMartinJr
      @RodMartinJr 8 років тому +1

      +isays And if not, he may be merely assessing his own experience. Not all confirmation of physical or social phenomena is biased.

    • @Guitarplaya668
      @Guitarplaya668 8 років тому +5

      +Zachary Mims It'a a good thing you typed in all caps so everyone could hear you.

    • @SignedOff402
      @SignedOff402 8 років тому +4

      +Zachary Mims I have met many seniors, 65 and older people whom do not use computers and have no interest in it, tragically. 6 o'clock news and maybe talk radio. Newspapers are going the way of the dinosaurs. It's a matter of controlling the conversation. I tell everyone now whether they want to hear it or not - Obamacare has opened up many eyes. Trump fans reflect that the Sleeping Giant has awoken.

  • @RodMartinJr
    @RodMartinJr 9 років тому +71

    CIA Director William Casey told President Reagan, February 1981, "We'll know our disinformation program is complete when everything the American public believes is false."

    • @Spazzboy911
      @Spazzboy911 5 років тому +3

      operation mockingbird

    • @HuntingTarg
      @HuntingTarg 5 місяців тому +1

      I can't imagine Reagan taking that mildly. He made some poor decisions, but he was _pro populi_ , he was nothing like the political fatcats or the financiaI or inteIIigence elites.

  • @CavinB
    @CavinB 4 роки тому +14

    This is so relevant to our current events with COVID.

  • @VI-cb7eu
    @VI-cb7eu 3 роки тому +5

    exactly what is happening now.

  • @dudechallenger
    @dudechallenger 4 роки тому +20

    This is exactly what is happening now with this new virus. Damn you corporate America.

    • @jacobblanton5179
      @jacobblanton5179 3 роки тому +2

      "Corporate America" lol. No, this time it was at least 75% Communist China

    • @jlhumor1565
      @jlhumor1565 3 роки тому +1

      Trust the science.

  • @AOMartialArts
    @AOMartialArts 9 років тому +219

    Only 266k views.... NEEDS MILLIONS!!

    • @BuddyGLee
      @BuddyGLee 8 років тому +12

      people don't wanna think too hard

    • @showmequick2245
      @showmequick2245 8 років тому +2

      +BuddyGLee or maybe UA-cam is editing the title to something else to chase them away!!

    • @zaag94
      @zaag94 8 років тому +2

      +ShowMeQuick lol, you were applying the knowledge way too fast. Got to praise you.

    • @monchan54
      @monchan54 8 років тому +2

      +Rob Hodge Aahh...482K as of my writing this. Question is, how many of the viewers have taken the time to SHARE this within their own networks? The social phenomenon called FACEBOOK is a prime example of how worthwhile information such as this can be disseminated far and wide with the least amount of effort by every individual who is AWAKENED and cares enough to share with others. Have you done your part?

    • @bammyshore7392
      @bammyshore7392 8 років тому +9

      +monchan54 I've just come across this and done my part. But be aware that all these social networks actively suppress videos like this...

  • @NeilRoy
    @NeilRoy 9 років тому +247

    150 paid agents clicked dislike for this. ;) Great info, thanks!

    • @friendlyanalyst273
      @friendlyanalyst273 8 років тому +4

      +Neil Roy LOL, indeed

    • @UltravioletHeather
      @UltravioletHeather 8 років тому +10

      +Neil Roy I'm so glad people are starting to wake up to the manipulation. It is a breath of fresh air

    • @n.manning4443
      @n.manning4443 7 років тому +1

      And look at all thew paid shills that liked this nonsense!

    • @billjoe39
      @billjoe39 7 років тому +9

      n manning > oh, so people who question power are the shills ? here's a piece of cow dung for your cleverness

    • @n.manning4443
      @n.manning4443 7 років тому +1

      No - people who buy into conspiracy theories and are too uninformed to realize how little they truly understand. Plus, I guess you sort of missed the point. Typical. You probably think the earth is flat, too - and why wouldn't you? I mean, it is on youtube! And it is anti-power!

  • @krystalwagstaff1038
    @krystalwagstaff1038 3 роки тому +16

    Admire your brave commitment to honest journaling!

  • @1000bouddhas
    @1000bouddhas 3 роки тому +4

    As this video is more relevant than ever, TED seems to have remove it from their website.

  • @Jarrodotus
    @Jarrodotus 3 роки тому +5

    2020 in a nutshell

  • @Neceros
    @Neceros 8 років тому +51

    Your reality is paid for.

    • @valleystina
      @valleystina 8 років тому +12

      +Neceros What she is saying was true before the idea even came to her head. The almighty dollar and power have been the engine and fuel for ages upon ages. What's the difference? The internet and how people get their information. If you think that you can't be manipulated, than you are being naïve. There is an ongoing joke that says, "If it's written down, then it must be true". Then TV became the norm, so the joke went to, "If it's on TV, then it must be true." Now we have the internet, "If you read it on the internet, then it must be true." As far as I am concerned, the current truth written or is on TV or is on the net belongs to those who have the resources to continually pay for it to be repeated enough for it to become the current "truth" (whether it's truth or not).

    • @alberto2469
      @alberto2469 4 роки тому

      GOD and i thinking the other comments where awesome! xD

  • @cityguy0189
    @cityguy0189 4 роки тому +8

    i have always had a hunch that wikipedia had it's own agenda

  • @freedomdove
    @freedomdove 9 років тому +32

    This excellent video should have more views than it does. Great information for newbies who are just waking up.

    • @BibleNutter
      @BibleNutter 9 років тому

      +freedom dove Are you going to heaven? If not then you're still a "newbie" yourself. No offence but true.

    • @freedomdove
      @freedomdove 9 років тому

      +Adam B What does heaven have to do with being unaware or asleep? "Heaven" is likely just another manipulation in and of itself, so I really don't see your point.

    • @BibleNutter
      @BibleNutter 9 років тому

      freedom dove Look up the video of the conspiracy way to get to God. Go to my channel too. I've done all the research and I know what's at the end of the rabbit hole. I've found that the only thing that really matters is that you get saved by accepting Jesus Christ as your lord and savior and once you do that try to help other people get there too.,

    • @freedomdove
      @freedomdove 9 років тому

      Adam B
      You have my sympathies.

    • @NE0Nwhip
      @NE0Nwhip 8 років тому

      +Adam B Search Abraham Hicks - Jesus on youtube.
      You're welcome.

  • @jeffaddiego3740
    @jeffaddiego3740 3 роки тому +10

    During times of universal deceit, truth is a revolutionary act!!

  • @kateknight2992
    @kateknight2992 8 років тому +32

    Well we know at least 209 people are paid to "AstroTurf" 😏

    • @MrSteMitchell
      @MrSteMitchell 8 років тому +4

      Shut it, you quack! ;)

    • @kateknight2992
      @kateknight2992 8 років тому +3

      +Steve Mitchell so......which special interest do you represent? 😎

    • @daniellabaker9045
      @daniellabaker9045 8 років тому +2

      232 now :)

    • @OwayneKhoo93
      @OwayneKhoo93 8 років тому +2

      I did a bit of looking, and apparently, its actually that 9 out of 10 medical entries contain errors. Thats absolutely not 90% inaccurate. SHES the astroturfer. I'm a medical student and I use wiki all the time, and yes, I do see the occasional inaccuracy here and there, for example the wrong specific value of an investigation, or an outdated entry, but its definitely accurate when I compare it to my textbooks.

    • @kateknight2992
      @kateknight2992 8 років тому +8

      +Owayne Khoo I would not tell any of your future patients about that. I know many folks, including myself, who would prefer their doctor not get ANY kind of information, let alone medical info, from Wiki or any page like it.... Just my opinion

  • @mchume65
    @mchume65 3 роки тому +13

    I read the Wikipedia article on her. It started out fine, then it turned into a hit piece.

    • @HuntingTarg
      @HuntingTarg 5 місяців тому

      After the assault she made in Wikipedia, there's hardly a better way to prove her point.

  • @mimib2887
    @mimib2887 4 роки тому +17

    This is what they're doing with Covid 19.

  • @LettyK
    @LettyK 2 роки тому +4

    I'm amazed TEDx allowed this talk and YT the video.

  • @jillianelise5
    @jillianelise5 4 роки тому +10

    Bless and protect this intelligent woman.

  • @Joefest99
    @Joefest99 7 років тому +73

    One of the most important videos in existence.

    • @kevincory777
      @kevincory777 7 років тому +2

      A flipping MEN!

    • @okli686
      @okli686 7 років тому +1

      and almost 1 million views..yay

  • @Nath5000
    @Nath5000 9 років тому +145

    This reminds me of a comment I made to a Huffington Post article about GMO labeling disclosure. I basically said that consumers would be better off knowing if a product contains GMOs and in a free market we shouldn't have to purchase GMO products if we don't want to, regardless. Nearly everyone who commented with skepticism about GMOs was personally attacked, painted as uneducated, ignorant, and uninformed. We were told that all forms of GMO are no different than basic agricultural breeding techniques that have been around for centuries.
    I specifically said that I was a true skeptic and not against GMO, but I wasn't entirely convinced that it was good in all cases, especially considering the profit-seeking interests behind the use of GMO technologies, I said people have the right to be skeptical and as consumers they should be free to choose not to purchase something that they weren't convinced of. I was attacked by multiple people who flat out told me that I wasn't a true skeptic. Someone even replied to my comment and said that I was basically a fruit and vegetable racist.(Astroturf fail?) I asked this person who they were, and why they are so passionately in favor of something that benefits corporations over consumer rights. That's when they stopped replying. Their Facebook profile itself looked like a shell to me, weird public posts with one or two likes each going back for several months. Watching this TEDx talk, I get it now.
    Can you blame people for going overboard when it comes to skepticism about things that seem like common sense to everyone else when large powerful special interests are actively trying to deceive them from a position of academic, social, economic and political authority? This type of deceptive influence is in many ways more dangerous than blatant coercion because we believe we have freedom of choice. "The cage is good for you" is what we're hearing instead of "Get into the cage or else". Sounds like a dream come true, tyranny has never been easier, apparently..

    • @Joe11Blue
      @Joe11Blue 9 років тому +14

      +Nathan Adams Those attacking you were paid trolls. That is why comment sections are getting shut down, because paying all of those trolls is expensive, and it's easier for them to just deny your voice an outlet.

    • @Yatukih_001
      @Yatukih_001 9 років тому +7

      +Nathan Adams Exactly. These pro gmo retards tried to paint me in a negative light when I discussed gmo´s with people, I reacted by blitzkrieging them until they realized they couldn´t present me with any evidence suggesting that gmo´s and non gmo´s are the same thing.

    • @Neceros
      @Neceros 8 років тому +3

      +Nathan Adams What about GMOs do you hate?
      Nobody here was talking about that, by the way, but I'll debate with you.

    • @Nath5000
      @Nath5000 8 років тому +7

      Nobody here was talking about it, but it's a perfect example of what this video speaks of.
      I primarily dislike how when 80% or more North Americans want GMOs labeled, democratic consensus is overruled by technocratic elite, pushed on us through corporatocratic industry lobbying, and ultimately supported by plutocratic investors, the primary benefactors of GMO crops.
      I'm not a fan of industrial agricultural biotechnology that puts profits before everything else, including democratic consensus and consumer concern. In a true democratic and capitalistic society we should be able to choose to avoid those products for whatever reason.

    • @Neceros
      @Neceros 8 років тому +5

      Nathan Adams I agree with you on the need for our government to become as transparent as possible. Far more than they are willing to tell us now.
      I think requiring people to tell us what we are consuming is a great idea. However, the issue I have is GMOs are not bad. It's a scary word hurdled around (ironically, an astroturfed thing).
      Everything we eat today has been genetically modified.
      That said, I agree that we should go back to democracy. I'm really tired of this Oligarchy.

  • @flywesleybyrd
    @flywesleybyrd 2 роки тому +7

    Hmmm... vaccines anyone?!

  • @charbeltannios546
    @charbeltannios546 3 роки тому +5

    The reality is paid 👍👍👍

  • @tessrio
    @tessrio 2 роки тому +6

    It has been though… like finding a needle in a haystack! Very good insight. Thank you.

  • @TerrierToughGuy
    @TerrierToughGuy 7 років тому +10

    Ever notice there are always around 200-300 thumbs downs to things we know we all think re good on UA-cam? I saw this same number on a video about Pedophiles and Heroin Addiction and a few others. It makes you wonder.

  • @jcole3614
    @jcole3614 4 роки тому +15

    whatever we aren't allowed to question is questionable...

    • @FanceeName
      @FanceeName 4 роки тому +6

      J Cole
      You mean like, everything MSM and the Democrats say or do?

    • @jcole3614
      @jcole3614 4 роки тому +3

      ​@@FanceeName i mean pretty much everything.

  • @charleskiplinger9904
    @charleskiplinger9904 4 роки тому +17

    This sure falls in line with the climate change narrative.

  • @SMOspider
    @SMOspider 9 років тому +79

    Thank you! Wonder if astroturf is defined in Wikipedia :-)

    • @mladenstific2459
      @mladenstific2459 9 років тому +2

      Why not go check, instead of wondering?

    • @SMOspider
      @SMOspider 9 років тому +4

      I did not feel like it. :-)

    • @mladenstific2459
      @mladenstific2459 9 років тому +5

      I guess that's an effective way of maintaining the impression you want to have of Wikipedia.
      It kind of sucks to see that instead of mobilizing people to fix a corruption problem in pharmacology and medicine, which spend 99% of the time helping people in ways they take for granted, the speaker encourages us to give equal credence to people who spend 99% of their time endangering our health for profit. Yay.

    • @mvolpe998
      @mvolpe998 9 років тому +4

      *****
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astroturfing

    • @Frodojack
      @Frodojack 9 років тому +3

      Mladen Štifić
      No, that's not what she said. She basically said that we need a dose of healthy skepticism, and the example is relevant since pharmaceuticals can and do change people's lives. Sometimes the new, hyped drugs are no more effective than the older drugs, but cost much more. That affects people's pocketbooks. Other drugs can affect their health when the side effects are worse than the positive benefits, but the prescribing doctors didn't warn of the side effects since the pharmaceutical companies dismissed them as insignificant when they weren't. On the other hand, no one is saying that the pharmaceutical companies don't do a lot of good too. I wouldn't be alive today if not for their discoveries. We just need to be wise consumers and part of that is seeing past the hype and the "astroturf."

  • @ryanp123456
    @ryanp123456 9 років тому +8

    8:52 I love the fact that she used air quotes when she said "seasoned" journalists. They are "seasoned" at following the script that someone puts in front of them and putting on that ridiculous "news voice" but that's about it.

  • @anynamebutmyrealone
    @anynamebutmyrealone 8 років тому +11

    Usually when you are trying to find specific data and it does not exist, you are sure to be onto something.

  • @user-pw6qe7ur4q
    @user-pw6qe7ur4q 2 роки тому +4

    I am amazed UA-cam hasn't taken this down yet. I hope she also posts this on Rumble.

    • @Neojhun
      @Neojhun 6 місяців тому

      Oh that's ironic. I found @RealReaper which is just a store brand copy of Critical Drinker. The propaganda machine is soo lazy now with their astroturf.

  • @protokevinleversee975
    @protokevinleversee975 3 роки тому +2

    Now apply this to today's insanity over the jab and lockdowns

  • @aaronbrown8377
    @aaronbrown8377 2 роки тому +3

    Almost all grassroots campaigns are astroturfed. A couple red flags are...
    1. Too expensive
    2. Too coordinated
    3. Supported by the media, government, and/or big business
    4. Rioters are not arrested or given only a slap on the wrist
    5. Protesters in a non English-speaking country write their signs in English.
    That last one is rather important and telling once you notice it.

  • @bobcarpenter5056
    @bobcarpenter5056 9 років тому +8

    Absolutely outstanding, Sheryl! Thank you. I have observed this for many years and am so glad that you have managed to make it public. You're making a great contribution to necessary public awareness. Thanks again!

  • @paula3280
    @paula3280 6 років тому +6

    Thank you Sharyl! Outstanding and yet so sad that it has come down to this. I am so tired of our own government and all these huge conglomerates lying, falsifying, and deceiving humanity. Where's our protection, where's the integrity and where's our constitutional rights?

  • @thefraug3827
    @thefraug3827 2 роки тому +4

    What a year of awakening. My gratitude to Sharyl Attkisson and ROSA KOIRE who recently passed away for opening my eyes

  • @johnnyViDeO
    @johnnyViDeO Рік тому +2

    PlanPanic is a perfect example. TRUST THE SCIENCE!!!

  • @BombalurinaAI
    @BombalurinaAI 9 років тому +150

    Gamergate summed up right here.

    • @FightersHeart
      @FightersHeart 9 років тому +61

      Yes: Anita Sarkeesian is propped up by ABC News, MTV, the Colbert Report, etc. She's the quintessential mouthpiece for the powerful, yet they pretend she's "grassroots.

    • @Targa7W
      @Targa7W 9 років тому +9

      ***** you forgot intel

    • @FightersHeart
      @FightersHeart 9 років тому +13

      Targa7W Exactly. And all the media companies who pay her tens of thousands of dollars to indoctrinate their employees, such as EA Sports.

    • @Targa7W
      @Targa7W 9 років тому +10

      or pay her to not talk and further a victim narrative.

    • @colepram2171
      @colepram2171 9 років тому +40

      You beat me to it. You can tell who's astroturfing against GamerGate. I see someone go, "What is GamerGate?", immediately followed by one of the people that have been constantly against us for the last six months going, "read the Wikipedia page", as though Wikipedia is some authoritative source.
      READ the wikipedia TALK page. Editors are battleing it out with each other against several entrenched anti-GamerGate editors. Some who were topic banned, and Ryulong, who was site banned, who was taking money to edit the artilce. Now he's on RationalWiki instead and they're getting fed up with him too.

  • @MrTrangen1
    @MrTrangen1 8 років тому +12

    Sharyl Attkisson is soooo HOT! did you know she's also a Karate Black belt???

    • @jgassman
      @jgassman 7 років тому +3

      I'm taking her words very seriously. However, it is hard not to notice how right you are.

    • @MrTrangen1
      @MrTrangen1 7 років тому +9

      Yeah, she is EXCELLENT Journalist / Reporter, she was forced out of CNN because of her "Honesty and Integrity" she would only do 'real investigative journalism' and they didn't like that so they forced her out, plus there was the "FAMOUS CASE" where the NSA had 'bugged her PC' and it was all over the news that her PC was hacked with listening software and she sued which ended her career; so not she just does 'independent journalism' news. But she has lots of 'integrity and credibility' in addition to her incredible beauty. Not to mention again her 'Black belt Karate' LOL LOL

    • @georgeworthmore
      @georgeworthmore 4 роки тому

      so was elvis

  • @TerenceKearns
    @TerenceKearns 8 років тому +8

    THIS SHOULD BE COMPULSORY VIEWING for every social network user on the planet.

  • @louisalivingstonetherealone
    @louisalivingstonetherealone 9 років тому +8

    Essential viewing - thanks for making this video. Everyone is continually being deceived and this video shows how it's being done - and helps us see the signs

  • @stottyMAW
    @stottyMAW 4 роки тому +6

    "question those who question authority" - talk about a statement that summarizes the modern American lefty

  • @robertquirke6110
    @robertquirke6110 2 роки тому +3

    Very good, people should always think for themselves. First follow the money, and secondly have a good look at any group that you can’t question and or critique.

  • @larrykiehl2457
    @larrykiehl2457 Рік тому +4

    I sure needed to hear this! You took the astro-turfing a layer deeper than I was already considering. Thanks so much.

  • @bobplatt5172
    @bobplatt5172 8 років тому +28

    Great video, the only bad part is that people WANT to be propagandized to reduce their cognitive dissonance.

    • @martamiron7548
      @martamiron7548 8 років тому +1

      right-in order to reduce my cognitive dissonance ,have a hollistic perspective ,after digging hard on internet for about a month, about gmo, chemtrails, martial low in usa , clones, human meat and adn found in meat people consume today, fake food as eggs and vegetables mades in china, nwo, my country politics , american elections, russian position ,ascension and shift of consciouness ,black goo, morgelons desease and race extinctions, multiple universes , flat earth , nanotechnology , transhumanism and so on ,many contradictory news, this post popped out in the right moment i guess.
      it s like i hear an orchestra and the individuals, of course the orchestra will grow as i spend more time on internet, so my belif right now is i live in a virtual reallity and i try to figure out how to escape from

  • @reggierico
    @reggierico 7 років тому +5

    I remember when Sharyl first started at CNN in 1990. We were deployed overseas, in Saudi Arabia ramping up for the Gulf War. CNN was on 24/7. I was immediately smitten by her beauty, posture and clear voice. Soon, I became aware of something else about Sharyl. She was incredibly bright, well spoken and oh so intelligent. Her honesty and integrity have at times necessitated her leaving her job due to corporate interests, and the bureaucracy of generating profits and not stepping on toes. To me, she is one of the most admired women in this country. She is a true patriot and she is still as beautiful as the first day I saw her on CNN all those years ago sitting in the sand in the middle of the Arabian Peninsula..

  • @AndromedaImagination77
    @AndromedaImagination77 8 років тому +87

    attacking the people asking the questions, instead of the issues in question, is ALSO how Governments work, and it works like a charm may I tell you. In Latin America worked perfectly for POPULISM (a far worse version of socialism)

    • @chuckles1954
      @chuckles1954 8 років тому +10

      +Andromeda Read "Rules for Radicals" and you have the Democrat playbook and required reading for "Community Organizers". I don't even like Trump, but just look how he was treated for suggesting we slow immigration until we can verify who they are. People with common sense would agree if it weren't so politically correct to bash Trump. We put ourselves, our children, and neighbors at risk, just to try to look like we are "tolerant". Carter threw out the Iranians and stopped them from coming in, FDR stopped immigration from Germany and Japan, and put the Japanese in camps. Wilson stopped Germans from coming while he segregated whites and black. All Democrats. Trump suggests a slow down and he's Hitler. I'll be voting for Cruz, but you can bet he has a whole network aimed at destroying him also. Even women curse and spit when Fiorina speaks, but coo when Hillary mumbles some lie about some scandal she is in right now. She doesn't even know what her husband is doing, let alone what Putin is doing. Wait till she tries to explain Bills trips to the Caribbean with a pedophile. BTW, Hillary's college thesis was on Saul Alinsky, the author of Rules for Radicals. She went to him and spent time with him while she wrote it. She was his personal student learning at his feet.

    • @AndromedaImagination77
      @AndromedaImagination77 8 років тому +8

      On that note, I recommend you read Edward Bernays book "Propaganda" also try to find the series of documentaries "century of self" specially watch "Happiness machines"... the masses have been artificially programmed for a long time, that's why crazy governments, crazy movements, false flags, false news, etc. work like a charm... they already know people's reactions to anything, they know when to scare you, when to make you complacent, when to make you feel compassion (it's a false compassion... people rather go with a like on facebook and change their profile pic to some flag, than go to Kenya and actually feeding a hungry kid) That's why I love House of Cards... it pretty much shows you how hypocritical people are, therefore, how can you not expect a psychopathic leader?

    • @colpopcorn
      @colpopcorn 7 років тому +9

      Yes, the left condemns vetting possible immigrants to see if they could be dangerous but openly demands we investigate citizens that want to buy a gun. Would they then insist that vetting one of these immigrant's wanting to buy a gun as discriminatory

    • @LloydStewart333
      @LloydStewart333 6 років тому +6

      The left condemns vetting immigrants? Where'd you get that one?

    • @MWcrazyhorse
      @MWcrazyhorse 6 років тому +6

      Populism is just the will of the people. South Americans have a propensity to be very far left. But populism is just the opposite to authoritarianism. And both are independant of a particular ideology. They are just basic philosophies of where the power is wielded.

  • @GruntProof
    @GruntProof 5 років тому +5

    Ironic that all the hippies that love her have no idea how much she has helped expose the left 😂

  • @NoPhame
    @NoPhame 8 років тому +13

    They don't make women like her anymore.

    • @roseguber3240
      @roseguber3240 8 років тому +5

      They do, and men also..few, but they exist.. have faith, and maybe you are one also...

    • @ianstewart8243
      @ianstewart8243 8 років тому +9

      The media don't like em so they don't show em so we have less a chance to know em

    • @m.x.
      @m.x. 8 років тому +1

      Luckily.

    • @jeffbeck6501
      @jeffbeck6501 8 років тому +1

      She is a shill dumbass. If she were real, she would talk about the jews but she does not.

  • @BretSimmons
    @BretSimmons 9 років тому +8

    Great job! The media is so manipulated...

  • @johnnymentero6313
    @johnnymentero6313 2 роки тому +2

    Instead of question authority, they start to question those who question the authority"
    JULIAN ASSANGE...

  • @Avogadro602E21
    @Avogadro602E21 2 роки тому +4

    The ‘pandemic’ in a nutshell

  • @robinnouri8335
    @robinnouri8335 3 роки тому +9

    Hi, thank you for this eye-opening talk. It is very surprising to see this matter happens right now on our actual topic over Covid-19 and how the main stream media and other news producers wants to convince people about only one side of the coin and try not to mention anything or saying the counterpart is fake or they are conspiracy theorists.

  • @BeatdownAMT
    @BeatdownAMT 3 роки тому +3

    5 years later and its gotten exponentially worse...

  • @StJoseph777
    @StJoseph777 8 років тому +26

    I have seen multiple of these astroturfed group. Some even are paid to harm actual, real grassroots efforts. Seen that too.

    • @artsHscience
      @artsHscience 8 років тому +1

      She doesn't differentiate between grassroots movement and astroturfing.
      She specifically lumped in the Redskin grassroots movement into corporate astroturfinig.

    • @svetovid5897
      @svetovid5897 8 років тому +2

      is veganism astroturf movement? They go on yapping about how we should drive all cows extinct cause cow's farts are causing the global warming, yet asking them how many of them drive EV ends up in them asking "what's EV?"

    • @THAdiabeetus
      @THAdiabeetus 7 років тому +1

      svetovid lol of course not. there's a significant $30k barrier to entry for driving an EV, but anyone can go vegan if they're concerned about their health

  • @MarcoStarink
    @MarcoStarink 2 роки тому +3

    Hello… 2020 has been waiting for you

  • @hunglikehorse4339
    @hunglikehorse4339 4 роки тому +4

    William J. Casey, "We'll know our disinformation program is complete when everything the American public believes is false." I think they might be close to done.

  • @GruntProof
    @GruntProof 5 років тому +9

    This should be titled: "Leftism 101"

  • @mollesjohn
    @mollesjohn 9 років тому +28

    Sharyl is explaining better than I can, what I have known for a long time. And we have an example of what Sharyl is talking about right here in ProgressiveTruth. Instead of his arguing on the merits, he uses derision and marginalizing tactics to defend the astroturfing. But truth is truth, and knowing how to find it is what Sharyl teaches and it's all good. Everyone should learn how to do it.

  • @luis-alvarez929
    @luis-alvarez929 2 роки тому +2

    Yeap she said it: " Artificial Paid For Reality" exactly what we have right now

  • @HR2635
    @HR2635 3 роки тому +1

    SO important. Now everyone go use this way of looking at social media "news" and "facts".. even mainstream media... and be critical. Not everything you see or read is correct. Not even 50% of it.

  • @LettyK
    @LettyK 2 роки тому +7

    This is very relevant to what we have been living through the last couple of years. All the silencing of dissenting voices of the mainstream narrative on the so-called 'pandemic'.

  • @hargobindsingh2012
    @hargobindsingh2012 8 років тому +6

    I have not been to a Dr. since 1995. I am 61 and in excellent health because I know how to take care of myself. I do yoga every morning, drink ro water, eat good food, get proper sleep, etc... Dr. Bernard Jensen said: "If you don't know how to take care of yourself by the time you are 40, then you deserve the doctors and the hospitals." I have certifications in Ayurveda, Natureopathy and Kundalini yoga, so that helps.

    • @cshook123
      @cshook123 8 років тому

      +Hargobind Singh That's all witchcraft.

    • @richardhill3531
      @richardhill3531 8 років тому +4

      +Hargobind Singh
      Good news there. Am happy for you.
      I haven't had any flu vaccine in over 50 years. The human body already has systems to take care of influenza.

    • @scottfitness5693
      @scottfitness5693 8 років тому +3

      +cshook123 Seriously....you are now acting like the trolls described in the video you just watched (or did you even watch it???)

    • @mvmlego1212
      @mvmlego1212 6 років тому

      +Richard Hill -- I imagine some, such as you, do, but plenty don't. A couple hundred years ago, influenza was a common cause of death, so it's incorrect to assume that all humans can deal with it.

  • @zenchristafarian4404
    @zenchristafarian4404 2 роки тому +3

    LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this presenter! Thank you Ms. Attkisson.

  • @AndyJK45
    @AndyJK45 7 років тому +2

    Everything she says is true. It is extremely difficult for us even as professionals to see whether what we are being told is true or not. I have seen many new drugs introduced into Medicine in Australia with a huge fanfare as to their safety and effectiveness. Only later has that initial information proven to be false. It usually takes a few deaths to make people sit up and think.

  • @btumminaro
    @btumminaro 3 роки тому +2

    It's as if this woman was able to see 2020 media and democrat rhetoric back in 2015.

  • @LanceKingvox
    @LanceKingvox 4 роки тому +4

    THANK YOU for saying that in such a way that it's hard to argue against it... TRUTH!

  • @born2lol
    @born2lol 8 років тому +6

    She's talking about shills.

  • @NealFox
    @NealFox 9 років тому +4

    Excellent talk! Everyone needs to be armed with this information.

    • @sallynutterutube
      @sallynutterutube 9 років тому +2

      This is awesome!
      This needs to be known by ALL!!
      We need to know how to tell the difference between the truth and the bull...

  • @GreatWhite7
    @GreatWhite7 9 років тому +1

    Sounds like a crazy conspiracy realist, what with all these facts and such. Anyone would think we live in a world where bad people exist and even have learnt how to lie and exploit others. SMH.

  • @Londonfogey
    @Londonfogey 3 роки тому +2

    'an epidemic of sleeplessness so serious we don't even know we have it...' hmmmm that reminds me of something else in the news these last few months...

  • @Xander785
    @Xander785 2 роки тому +3

    2020/2021 … 😃