दीदी मैं पाकिस्तान से हूं और यह टिप्पणी गूगल से हिंदी में अनुवाद करके कर रहा हूं। मैंने कई प्रतिक्रियाएं देखीं, लेकिन किसी को शास्त्रीय गायन नहीं आता, लेकिन आप कलाकार लगते हैं।'
OMG! Miss A,D now you get the right thing, main pichlay 1 saal se intizar kr raha tha k aap jaisee classical singing ko samajhnay wali abhi tak naina moray song tak kew nahi pohnchi. mainay 1 year tak intizar kya tha or comment main request bhe ke the, thanks for pick this song. i am from lahore, pakistan
Among dozens of Coke Studio songs, this is the most favorite song of mine. What an arrangement. Forget about singing. What a reaction too! I am fast getting your fan Ananya. Please keep it up. Your contribution to Season 15 will be valuable 😊
This is why CS Pakistan is a class above. See how Raga Bhairvi is exhibited so subliminally by compounding a piece of thumri of Ustad Baray Ghulam Ali, a piece of qawali of Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and slow rock a la Pink Floyd by Amir Zaki's which was added later as he had sadly passed away. That's why some looked to the heavens to pay him respects.
Dear Ananya! I didn't read any comments here so I'm not sure if someone has mentioned that Akbar Ali is singing thumri originally sung by Ustad Barray Ghulam Ali Khan Saab and Javed Bashir is singing a very famous qawali originally sung by Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan Saab. Fusion of 2 different things is the beauty of coke studio Pakistan. Music was arranged by Jaffar Zaidi for this coke studio version. He is also playing guitar among the musicians in this performance.
I am surprised there is no mention of the composer of this thumru. This is actually a composition of Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan Saab of Patiala gharana, in raag Jangla bhairavi, indeed one of his most celebrated works. This interpretation of the is good, but then the original is unpareiled.
I just started watching your reactions. You are the best as you are the most knowledgeable and appreciative of the intricacies of the Indian music. I am learning a lot.
Aamir Zaki was not just a guitarist featured in this song, he's the best Pakistan has ever produced. That was respect given by CS Pakistan to one of its most underrated artists, Zaki passed away in poverty.
@@sa_zafeer Adnan Siddiqui, Xulfi and some other artistas had been helping him financially. His body remained in the mortuary for 3 days before Waqar Zaka and a few other artists brought it into everyone's notice. How rich is that?
@@Vladmir-Putin I am looking for any authentic reference regarding Aamir Zaki's death and post death matters but so far I have not found anything authentic, Waqar Zaki's news has no importance or status if you can help me with the right sources of information I will be very grateful.
Aadaab Mam! thoroughly enjoyed your reaction. Stay blessed you and your family! You know? Your reactions are not only "reactions" for me, these are the Master Classes of Music Language. For the Future, I am praying for you to turn to Coke Studio 6. The least I can say; those tracks deserve your precious opinions. Regards, A Fan of Yours P.S. I request all the viewers of Ms. Ananya's channel to share her videos. So, maximum number of people can learn more.
Always love your reactions and the way you feel and describe emotions and the technicalities. Also, love your passion for singing and the intensity you try to bring in. Keep it up. 👍 From Pakistan
I was looking for someone react on this master piece and after about a year i found you with the best reaction ... Stay blessed young lady.. lots of love and prayers for you
Greetings from Pakistan. I have been closely observing your reactions for quite sometime now. I must say that your command over the knowlege of music and singing is incredible and the way you react to the songs is just so original. Your originality makes this channel so special. I can only request you to increase the frequency of your reactions because one finds so much to learn through your reactions. I can recommend Rung by Rahat Fateh Ali Khan and Amjad Sabri from Coke Studio Season 9 as one of the songs where your reactions will definitely be icing on the cake. I wish and pray for the success of your channel. With warm personal regards.
Sister You Are Best Masha Allah. Apko Music Ki Or Musical Instruments Ki Knowledge Hy. To Mujhe Apka Reaction Completely Different Or Subse Alag Laga. Maza Aa Gaya. Really Appreciate You & So Much Love From 🇵🇰❤️💞❤️
Very valuable comments and review. Ap se har dafa kuch na kuch naya seekhne ko milta ha. It means keh aap itni bareeki se song ko sunti hen aur oske andar itne choti choti cheezen point out karti hen jinki taraf har insaan ki nazar nahi jaati. Secondly apke bolne ka andaaz bilkul soft urdu bolne walo jaisa ha jo k aik plus point ha. Yahi difference hota ha aik professional bande and non professional bandy ki review ma.
Hey Ananya amazing video. Thank you for making this. It helped me rediscovering the beauty of this great song again. Btw can you please tell me that is the "Mann Atkeya" part is also based in Raag Bhairvi?
Girl i must say that you are not only a cute looking one with a pure heart that would love to admire anything that is appreciable. but i must mention that u 've got an amazing voice too .i carefully listened to ur own voice texture and singing tone and skills. I think u wont do justice to the talent God gifted u with , if u dont showcase ur talent ( recording ur own album) .. Girl i personally feel this place (youtube channel) is too small a place for u .. u r far better than hundreds of bollywood singers like neha kakar and blah blah . they are not even close to u .. I loved every bit of ur Flawless reaction. and yeah it was not electric , it was Lead guitar and Amir Zaki was one of the world most revered Lead guitarist. Love and respect from Pakistan.
Ananya Aapke Wajah se mera Song ko samjhne ka ausaaf jo hai theek hogya Mujhe Song Ka Matlb samjh nhi aata tha ziyadatar but Thanks ❤ Faida huwa apke reactions se 😊
*The original moray naina was sung by Ustad Salamt Ali Khan* *Search YT for this: "Sindhi Bhairavi, Thumri, Ustad Salamat Ali Khan & Ustad Nazakat Ali Khan. Live in India 1968.:*
Just to correct you, Amir Zaki's part was pre recorded before his death. It was later added and mixed with this track. That's why during his part, there is no one else on the set. It was added as a tribute to him.
दीदी मैं पाकिस्तान से हूं और यह टिप्पणी गूगल से हिंदी में अनुवाद करके कर रहा हूं। मैंने कई प्रतिक्रियाएं देखीं, लेकिन किसी को शास्त्रीय गायन नहीं आता, लेकिन आप कलाकार लगते हैं।'
bas ye comment dekhne ke baad ek baar phir se reactions start kar rahi hu me!😍
💘💙🖤ananya,ge,really we,love your,justification,of,every thing,shapeless🖤💙💘
OMG! Miss A,D now you get the right thing, main pichlay 1 saal se intizar kr raha tha k aap jaisee classical singing ko samajhnay wali abhi tak naina moray song tak kew nahi pohnchi. mainay 1 year tak intizar kya tha or comment main request bhe ke the, thanks for pick this song. i am from lahore, pakistan
Among dozens of Coke Studio songs, this is the most favorite song of mine. What an arrangement. Forget about singing. What a reaction too! I am fast getting your fan Ananya. Please keep it up. Your contribution to Season 15 will be valuable 😊
miss yeh gana main koi 50 dafa sun chuka hun , magar jo maza aap k saath sunnay main aya hay iss ke baat he or hay, i am from lahore, pakistan
OMG! Means alot for me
javed bashir and akbar ali goated together and in dono ne naina morey pehle bhi gaya hai BOHOOOT pehele
This is why CS Pakistan is a class above. See how Raga Bhairvi is exhibited so subliminally by compounding a piece of thumri of Ustad Baray Ghulam Ali, a piece of qawali of Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and slow rock a la Pink Floyd by Amir Zaki's which was added later as he had sadly passed away. That's why some looked to the heavens to pay him respects.
Dear Ananya!
I didn't read any comments here so I'm not sure if someone has mentioned that Akbar Ali is singing thumri originally sung by Ustad Barray Ghulam Ali Khan Saab and Javed Bashir is singing a very famous qawali originally sung by Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan Saab. Fusion of 2 different things is the beauty of coke studio Pakistan. Music was arranged by Jaffar Zaidi for this coke studio version. He is also playing guitar among the musicians in this performance.
Ananya....great reaction and analysis. This was perhaps Amir Zaki's last performance before he departed this World
दिल दिया ये ऐतबार की हद थी
जान दे दी ये प्यार की हद थी
मर गए हम खुली रही आँखे
ये तेरे इंतज़ार की हद थी 😍😍
I am surprised there is no mention of the composer of this thumru. This is actually a composition of Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan Saab of Patiala gharana, in raag Jangla bhairavi, indeed one of his most celebrated works. This interpretation of the is good, but then the original is unpareiled.
Theek farmaaya aap ne 🙏
Music ke samjh ho to easy MASTER PIECE samjh aaty hean.
You deserve such music.
Love from LAHORE PAKISTAN 💕✌️😎
Love from Bangladesh
Best reaction I have ever seen wow lot's of love and respect from Pakistan ❤️
I'm obsessed with your reactions aapi. Allah aap ko apne hifz-o-amaan mein rakhe. Ameen 🇬🇧🇵🇰❤️
Akabar ali ji 👌
awesome sir ❤️💖
Kya baat hai 👏👏
Aaja balam pardesi .........
Miind blowing ❤❤
I just started watching your reactions. You are the best as you are the most knowledgeable and appreciative of the intricacies of the Indian music. I am learning a lot.
You are an OLD Soul, young girl. luv
Aamir Zaki was not just a guitarist featured in this song, he's the best Pakistan has ever produced. That was respect given by CS Pakistan to one of its most underrated artists, Zaki passed away in poverty.
It is absolutely false that Zaki died in poverty, can you prove your claim about him?
@@sa_zafeer Adnan Siddiqui, Xulfi and some other artistas had been helping him financially. His body remained in the mortuary for 3 days before Waqar Zaka and a few other artists brought it into everyone's notice. How rich is that?
@@Vladmir-Putin
I am looking for any authentic reference regarding Aamir Zaki's death and post death matters but so far I have not found anything authentic, Waqar Zaki's news has no importance or status if you can help me with the right sources of information I will be very grateful.
Akber Ali has so peaceful voice ❤
Amir zaki was one of the best guitarist
Kia bat hy pehli bar itna mature r itna maloomati review dekha❤❤literally yeh song mra apna fav hy
16:46 aap ki bak bak bohat achi lagi, your reaction videos are some of the best, with such detailed commentary.....
Yes this the magic of ahad nayani (drummer)
Never thought what a drummer can do in Sufi music
Amazing fusion
Aadaab Mam! thoroughly enjoyed your reaction. Stay blessed you and your family! You know? Your reactions are not only "reactions" for me, these are the Master Classes of Music Language. For the Future, I am praying for you to turn to Coke Studio 6. The least I can say; those tracks deserve your precious opinions.
Regards,
A Fan of Yours
P.S.
I request all the viewers of Ms. Ananya's channel to share her videos. So, maximum number of people can learn more.
Thank you so much for such a well thought and kind comment!
@@unplugged_ananya 🙂 You are welcome. Pleasure is all mine.
@@unplugged_ananya Check out Rabba Ho - Saeen Zahoor, Sanam Marvi Coke Studio Season 6
again watching your Lovely reaction
Jeeti raho baitaa ... Dil khush hota hai aap kay reactions say. You should collab with Waleska and Efra ❤❤❤
Spot on review.... we are lucky to be alive in the era of Javed Bashir Sahab
Apke sath ye gaana sunne ki meri khwahish aaj poori hogai....thank you jee
Always love your reactions and the way you feel and describe emotions and the technicalities.
Also, love your passion for singing and the intensity you try to bring in.
Keep it up. 👍
From Pakistan
ye gana pehle b kai martba suna tha lekin aapke reaction / wazahat ne aur b mazedar kardea.
sahi kehte hen, sun'na b aik art hai.. zoqq salamat..
Speechless. Beautiful amalgamation of raga with qawwali.
Aap buhat khoobsoorat review dytee hay main buhat muttassir Howa
Oh
Great reaction!!! I always look forward to your reaction videos. Thanks 🌸🌸🌸
Nice singing of Jawad bashir and also Akbar Ali very talented classical singer ....very good reaction
I was looking for someone react on this master piece and after about a year i found you with the best reaction ... Stay blessed young lady.. lots of love and prayers for you
Ananya, you understand music very well. You have explained it perfectly. Keep up the great job.
Your reaction is fantastically beautiful along with your voice!
Greetings from Pakistan. I have been closely observing your reactions for quite sometime now. I must say that your command over the knowlege of music and singing is incredible and the way you react to the songs is just so original. Your originality makes this channel so special. I can only request you to increase the frequency of your reactions because one finds so much to learn through your reactions. I can recommend Rung by Rahat Fateh Ali Khan and Amjad Sabri from Coke Studio Season 9 as one of the songs where your reactions will definitely be icing on the cake. I wish and pray for the success of your channel. With warm personal regards.
Mam beautiful reaction as always!!!!! God bless you.....
for me its the after kaale baadal baras gaye harkat on aaja balma pardesiii 🔥
💘💚💖ananya,ge,are you so,lovely great personality very deep looking💖💚💘
The way you explain!! Hats off!!!
Epic music. You are right, no matter how many we listen to the song brings up some fresh aspect.
Thanks for reaction on this video kiun k apky reaction ki waja sy pta chala k coke studio ny ye masterpiece bi banaya tha
I see people doing reaction videos but I found you the real one who know what is going on and what is under discussion.
I appreciate your classical knowledge and reaction. Thanks.
Your experience to justify and judge the song is phenomenal...
Sister You Are Best Masha Allah. Apko Music Ki Or Musical Instruments Ki Knowledge Hy. To Mujhe Apka Reaction Completely Different Or Subse Alag Laga. Maza Aa Gaya. Really Appreciate You & So Much Love From 🇵🇰❤️💞❤️
Waaahhh kamal singing,,
You introduced me to a new song, which is a solid rock, unmatchable, and thanks for even breaking down for us with your music knowledge.. luv it
My favorite thing ♥️ so beautiful 😍
I have to say i do love your singing. ❤
Ananya, I'm really impressed with your extreme knowledge based analysis and immense level of praise
so nice of you mam apka content bohat acha hai good. love from Pakistan
Indians really love music.thanks for ur love
Really impressive reaction to a difficult song
very well spoken and to the point reviews.very well ananya
Very valuable comments and review. Ap se har dafa kuch na kuch naya seekhne ko milta ha. It means keh aap itni bareeki se song ko sunti hen aur oske andar itne choti choti cheezen point out karti hen jinki taraf har insaan ki nazar nahi jaati. Secondly apke bolne ka andaaz bilkul soft urdu bolne walo jaisa ha jo k aik plus point ha. Yahi difference hota ha aik professional bande and non professional bandy ki review ma.
Ji Shukriya! 🙏🏽
excellent singers
That is reason i hear ustad bashir back to back ,
My favorite as well
Awesome wow 👏
Yrrr issy reaction kah lo ya jo marzi but tum sb bohat achy se sunti hoo and you see almost each piont of the song, that's I really like 👍🏻❤
AMIR ZAKI WAS 1ST GUITARIST HE IS ON STAGE 2 HOUR ONLY PLAYED AND PEOPLE JUST LISTEN AND HIS CIGARETTES
i am here for Aamir Zaki ❤❤
Thanks for being the bridge between the singer or production and us as a consumer. I value your comments and learn from them
Hey Ananya amazing video. Thank you for making this. It helped me rediscovering the beauty of this great song again.
Btw can you please tell me that is the "Mann Atkeya" part is also based in Raag Bhairvi?
Everything that they’re singing is within the Bhairavi scale
@@unplugged_ananyanoted, thank you
Girl i must say that you are not only a cute looking one with a pure heart that would love to admire anything that is appreciable. but i must mention that u 've got an amazing voice too .i carefully listened to ur own voice texture and singing tone and skills. I think u wont do justice to the talent God gifted u with , if u dont showcase ur talent ( recording ur own album) .. Girl i personally feel this place (youtube channel) is too small a place for u .. u r far better than hundreds of bollywood singers like neha kakar and blah blah . they are not even close to u .. I loved every bit of ur Flawless reaction. and yeah it was not electric , it was Lead guitar and Amir Zaki was one of the world most revered Lead guitarist. Love and respect from Pakistan.
The way u react on this Video is More Awesome than song😊
VERY NICE REACTION DIDI
Mashallah bohat Acha reaction daiti hai ap .....very nice
Ananya Aapke Wajah se mera Song ko samjhne ka ausaaf jo hai theek hogya Mujhe Song Ka Matlb samjh nhi aata tha ziyadatar but Thanks ❤ Faida huwa apke reactions se 😊
Genuine Reaction ❤
I want to see your more reactions to understand the music and singing ❤️
Did you watch both singers perfoming in indian program janun kuch kr dekhanay ka
waqai mein javed basheer sab ki voice bilkul different hai
He belongs to family of vocalists
Bohat deeply ap observe karti hai ....
Deep analysis, not an ordinary reaction video. Happy to see true music admirer
Jo qawali he javed ji ki woh jonpuri raag men he aur thumri bhervi raag men he Sindhi bhervi men mix kiya hoa he
Thanks thanks finnaly you did this
You're my favorite UA-camr
I'm waiting for your next reaction video
Aadaab! boht umda review dya hai
please make more video on cokestudio previous season songs
Aapka Mutual Pakistani Fan Shezz Sindhi ❤😊 GOD Blessed you
No words
Most fvt line " kash aisy gany India me b banty "
Kash indo pak ki separation hi na hoti
10:09 This is a perfect detailed reaction video 🫡 Do consider coke studio season 6 .. ( way ahead of its time ) 🎉
Waiting for your more reaction on coke studio music.
Masterpiece
2 pauses in amir zaki solo 🎉🎉
If you haven’t seen coke studio bangla. Can I suggest start with the last of their release, nodir kul.
*The original moray naina was sung by Ustad Salamt Ali Khan*
*Search YT for this: "Sindhi Bhairavi, Thumri, Ustad Salamat Ali Khan & Ustad Nazakat Ali Khan. Live in India 1968.:*
Legend Aamir Zaki
If you choose this song. You are a legend. Amazing song ❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
Just to correct you, Amir Zaki's part was pre recorded before his death. It was later added and mixed with this track. That's why during his part, there is no one else on the set. It was added as a tribute to him.
Ohh yeah….I didn’t notice…thanx
Nice one Waseem tahir Nottingham uk 🇬🇧
Did u hear Coke studio bangla? 👀
Daarale duarey and Deora are recommended 👀🫶🫶
u did almost justice. khabram raseeda by freed ayad also coke studio u gona like that