Will Russia Win the Ukraine War in 2024? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 сер 2024
- Will Russia Win the Ukraine War in 2024? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Russian forces have captured the town of Avdiivka, its biggest victory since the fall of Bakhmut. Ukraine has blamed the loss of the town on the lack of Western aid. Will the crumbling Western unity work in Russia's favour? Will it win the war in Ukraine this year? Palki Sharma tells you.
---
Russia-Ukraine War | Avdiivka | Bakhmut | Western Aid | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#russiaukrainewar #avdiivka #bakhmut #westernaid #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
Don't miss out on the opportunity to be a part of Firstpost Defence Summit.
Secure your spot by registering at: www.firstpostdefencesummit.com
Zelenskyy rules Ukraine by streaming 😂😂
😂😂😂
Putin rules Russia by fear and by killing the competition.
Zelensky are a joke!
Zelenskyy dopey Muppet 😅.
Well Done Russia 🇷🇺 👏 👍 😊😊😊
our inflation now is up to 60% in america because of ukraine war
That’s why they changed how they measured inflation they saw this coming
And Americans suddenly owe more taxes this year out of nowhere
What on earth are you talking about? You must be a Russian bot or obtuse.
Do you mean.. the Caronia Vacation killings of the population.
america does not care about there own people and country, other countrys come first americans are last. american is shit and has been for decades. no money for medicade and medicare but 13 billion for another country.
All western media reported that Avdivika is not a strategic victory. Then why was it the most fortified city since 2014?
Ukraine ran out of ammo and was outnumbered. They were forced to withdrew .
If the bill to give aid fails in US House of representatives, Ukraine's fate is sealed .
Wiki has the answer: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda
Western media lies. These are feeding from the Russian sources. Don't believe everything you hear. Lol.
Well western media has been telling us every day from the start that Ukraine was winning the war which is bs
@@ananthu8534 My friend. I'm letting you know. The United States sent to Ukraine all the ammunition available in the Pentagon warehouses, including from Israeli stocks. In the United States, only 6 of the Pentagon's 86 military factories remain. Of these, only one in Ohio produces 300,000 artillery shells per year. There is also one tank factory in Lima, Ohio, producing 12 Abrams per year. The EU also produces 300,000 NATO-caliber shells per year. In Ukraine, the main artillery is of Soviet caliber and there is not a single factory producing these shells. At the beginning of the war, Ukraine had 2,040 towed guns, 1,067 self-propelled guns and 490 MLRS. NATO countries transferred 330 artillery systems and all Soviet shells from warehouses in Eastern Europe. For comparison, in 2023, Russia produced 4.5 million shells, 4 thousand artillery pieces and multiple rocket launchers (MLRS), artillery reconnaissance and counter-battery warfare, as well as more than 150 heavy flamethrower systems TOS 1, more than 4,000 armored vehicles (tanks and infantry fighting vehicles), 16,000 units of automotive equipment (here trucks, SUVs, buggies), 100 aircraft, 150 helicopters.
Is the Republican position more clear now? $60 billion will not help Ukraine in any way. NATO does not have such production facilities.
Once Putin said, you can't fight for long when depending on someone's help
Biden doesn't know he's president, that guy loves to sniff kids 😂, a disgrace to world leaders, just give him an ice cream and shut him up, also does he know his way off the stage yetA? how's that dementia? can he find the white house? Does he still think Modi us India president? Does he still think usa is defined as, and I quote "usa is the foot hills of the himalayas with Xi Jinping,"
@@monumentaltravel3745btw, just asking, what are your pronouns today 😅
@@monumentaltravel3745Does biden still speak gibberish? Does biden still think Rishi Sunak is a president? How's his health? Is his son still making millions in Ukraine? How many countries have Obama bombed again? 🤔
True
Said the man that is buying weapons from North Korea and Iran.
Over $200 billion in aid since February 2022 and you don't have enough shells 😅
More than Russia's entire military budget 🤣
Haha Russia is 26 times larger and still has to round up weapons from other countries. Just sad🤣
yes but Zelensky have more villas at least that counts🤫
@@dz7786Russia bought, ukraine begs 😂😂
Sadly the corrupt Ukrainian military is selling the weapons. A few months ago they were reporting Millions worth of weapons missing from their cache
Ukraine was tired of winning, so they withdrew from Avdiivka to save the Russians some face.
😂
😂
Really? Those who are lucky ran away to save their precious lives, others weren't so lucky.
I can hear you chalking with chest pains as you yawn out these words.
take heart.
Congratulations Vlandmir Putin on yr Truthful Stand. The Truth will always become Victory.
Underestimating Putin...is great mistake.
eh? who underestimated who? Wasn't that Ukraine that was supposed to be conquered in 3 days? Macron was literally begging Putin to not invade Ukraine for many hours, for many days on his knees.
Недооценивать русских,вот смертельная ошибка. Россию уже не остановить. И это при том,что Россия даже ещё не разозлилась. Русские очень терпеливы,ох как терпеливы. И запад это всегда принимал как слабость. И не дай Боже испытать на себе гнев и ярость России,это касается всего мира.
Pootin?
Effects of having a comedian as your president,now Ukraine is destroyed to ashes
Yes, but he's just a puppet. That's why he gladly throws in his own people into the meat grinder.
Lol
Imagine Ukraine if Russia treated people and countries like Israel.
Will be done with 48 hours
@@deemma4486they didn't do that at start, if they done that most of ukraine will be empty by now .., they consider ukraine as a brother , and mostly ukriane was a part of soviet union...
@@deemma4486 les
In this case, it was Russia and Palestine who started killing people.
So the scenario is actually, imagine what would happen if Palestine was a Superpower and Israel was Ukraine.
But I digress, Russians have pushed the narrative that they are the most powerful nation in earth, last time I checked the actual most powerful nation on earth did not take 2 years to reach the capitals of other countries and toppled entire governments.
Every single country the US invaded were forced to remove their uniforms and hide behind women and Children and resort to suicide bombers because they know they can’t win in a conventional war.
Meanwhile here we are 2 years later and Ukraine is still fighting a conventional war
That actually crossed my mind a lot
I hate euphemism!
Russia is bleeding out Ukraine, they have absolutely no interest in winning this war fast. Most of the people are really oblivious about Russia's strategy since the beginning.
Some still are, it's mostly the media. Even the analysts seem to know they're just spouting a narrative.
To be honest Zelensky helps Putin a lot. Due his arrogance and incompetence Ukraine already lost most of it's youth. Average Ukrainian soldier is 43 now. It means that younger people are either dead, seriously wounded or fleed abroad to save their lives.
Putin. Russia's pride.
Thank you 🙏 Palki you are a true Journalist. You always bring us a good news 🙏👍🏻💪🇷🇺
Во время штурма Авдеевки, в городе оставалось жить более 1 000 гражданских лиц - старики, женщины, дети. Они с благодарностью встретили русскую армию после оккупации Авдеевки Украиной с 2014года.
Unlike other leaders of the world.. Putin has a PhD in economics. He understands supply and demand, supply chain, and war time economy. While Ukraine was begging for aid, Russia was mobilizing not only manpower but the entire might of Russia military industrial complex for protracted war.. while doing financial engineering to protect against potential sanctions scenario.. Russia GDP for 2024 is projected to be higher than G7/USA less China and India by IMF, result speaks for itself.. I will bet my money on a president with a doctorate in economics vs an actor who was elected to be president..
He got a PhD when he was rising up the ladder
And?
Compare him to Joe Biden who probably can't even order 3 courses off a menu on his own
genius KGB
Haha
I made a comment here about Biden being unable to order 3 courses off a menu by himself and UA-cam removes it
SHAME ON YOU UA-cam
In other words, it's impossible to win a war when you depend on other countries to supply you weapons
Yep, Putin was eight, if there were no nato aid then ukrain would fall in two weeks, also, good on Russia on burning out nato weapons and money, over 180 billion so far, that's crazy, now the west is weaker than before.
Insulting your benefactors also isn't the best thing to do. I know it may seem strange but if you insult them they can get angry and stop supporting you. Zelendky learns that hard way.
@@lukasz.adamski Putin was right after all. Neither the Western public nor the Western politicians have the guts, the production capacity or the attention span to stay committed as soon as a quick victory became impossible. Especially Europe.
If Ukraine hasn't made any progress with the first 200 billion dollars, they're not going to do anything with another 60 billion. This is a lost cause. Zelensky needs to suck up his pride, surrender and come with Negotiations.
400 billion American wasn't the only one who donated
@@glintongordon6811 that's true.
Zelensky doesn't solve anything! He is a puppet in Washington's hands
России уже не нужны переговоры. Время переговоров прошло.Пусть запад вложит в Украину хоть все деньги мира,русских уже не остановить. И это при том что русские даже ещё и на разозлились. И не дай Бог ощутить на себе ярость России. Это касается всего мира.
What do you see as progress? The funding is to prevent the Russian gov overthrowing the Ukrainian gov. So at the moment the funding is doing exactly that. Once the next 60 billion is used up more will be sent
I support the Russians because they are the Indians' best friend
As an american I support Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@SmokestackOGI no problem because that is your right 😂😂😂😂
Thanks for delivering this important lesson. As a proud Indian🇮🇳, I really love ♥ and have a lot of respect for the incredible work of Palki's highly captivating story regarding How British looted 45 trillion from India which unquestionably stands as a masterpiece of the highest quality. The content of the reporting is truly inspiring, and I thoroughly enjoyed watching it. The dedication, talent and hard work poured into the video are greatly appreciated by many. The Indian Union Public Service Commission has delivered a remarkable report titled संघ लोक सेवा आयोग How Britishers killed 1.8 billion Indians. Chronology of British Raj's exploitative policies | UPSC," is equally astounding. The Indian government consistently produces insightful and thought-provoking articles of the utmost caliber, and I sincerely hope they continue to produce such interesting exceptional work. Can it even get better than that? It should deserve an award for best report of the year. Thanks for telling the truth. Your show was really entertaining. I adore your passion
The two main policies that wiped out 1.8 billion Indians are:
1: Allocation of food: Since the British were at war all the time, they didn't have people to do the farming. They made India do agriculture and then take it away. causing a massive famine every week.
2: Plundering of India's natural resources The British forced Indians to mine all the natural minerals in their country and carry them to the ports to be shipped back to England every day. extremely dangerous jobs, and these poor Indians weren't fed, and hundreds of millions succumbed to the exhaustion.
The whole of India was ruled by only a handful of Britishers. Why India chose to never fight back baffles many to this day. Maybe India is just obedient by nature.
India holds the largest surrender record in world history with a billion of them surrendering to 300 British sailors for 211 years.
Drawing upon my expertise in the behaviors and nesting habits of Indians, I can definitively state that Indians did not resist the invaders; instead, the invaders, including the British and various others, eventually withdrew when there is nothing left but a population of one billion Indians grappling with poverty and illiteracy-a challenging situation that nobody was eager to tackle.
The 45 trillion dollars that were taken mainly consist of natural resources. If you look at India's current mineral deposits, most are completely depleted (that's why India imports their minerals instead of producing them themselves; they have nothing left). The British forced Indians to mine and carry those minerals and resources to the sea port so they could be sent back to England every single day for 200 years. The U.S. and U.K. infrastructure was pretty much built from not only India's natural minerals but also India's blood, sweat, and even lives (countless Indians died working in the mines all day with less than a portion of grain in their stomachs).
1.8 Billion makes sense. India today on average loses 10 million people per year due to natural cause or illness. So in 200 years they would lose 10million x 200 years = 2 billion people. Imagine 1757 - 1947 times when India didn't have any healthcare like today and life expectancy was much much shorter with mass malnourish (Bengal Famine + 15,763 other major famines) and were forced to work to their very bones losing their lives in the process.
After Bakhmut, Russia captured Marinka. Avdiivka and Mariinka are of strategic importance in logistics, as they open a highway from Russia through Lugansk to Donetsk and further south to Zaporizhia along the entire length of the front. Now Russia has the ability to transfer reserves along the entire front line several times faster than Ukraine.
Ukraine, a story written with the ink of courage on the pages of history.
*stupidity
Written in Western history books. Some of us won't believe Western lies
At the rate Russia is going, there won't be a Ukraine to right lies about.
They didn't retreat, they escaped the Russian hell power😢.
Any man born by a woman cannot defeat Putin and his Russia. Putin I wish to see u face to face and shake your hand one day. You are really a leader that speaks truth and love people. I'm behind you physical, spiritual and everything.
It is foolishness to be fighting a war with the hope of another man's assistance
i don't knbow where that brand of foolishness is being manufactured
More than 30 countries vs Russia n still Russia kicks ass😂😂😂
doubt that
either Ukraine wins or it will be a forever war. Pretty sure Ukrainian soldiers have more willpower than Russian soldiers when it comes to the war. The Soviet Union has a bigger population and they still lost to Afghanistan pretty sure we might have a similar situation like that.
@@chadbrad8100the truth is always bitter
Kicking ass?
- Ukraine is better armed now than at the start of the war
- Finland and Sweden joining Nato
Ukraine started on route to join EU
- Failing Russian economy (GDP of whole of Russia is less than New York)
- Thousands of intelligent Russians have left the country
- Tens of thousands of Russians dead
- Can’t travel abroad except for places no one wants to go
- Western brands and tech have left and now you are driving Ladas with 1990s technology or over priced Chinese cars
- Russian public and convicts being called up to fight
- Wagner coup
Russian flagship sunk
- Have lost 50% of territory gained
No real freedom of speech. Can’t protest or even stand on Red Square with blank piece of paper without being arrested
Government controlled media
Only Russia ‘friendly’ countries are either afraid of Russia or taking advantage to grow their own economy
Out of control inflation and interest rates
No democracy. You can vote for Putin or Putin. All of the competition is in jail or died in mysterious circumstances
In my opinion Russia has already lost.
@@Richoright nonsense 😂
@@chibykecollins122 Good factual response.
This is just said. After all the people who died.
They should have just did peace talk. Oh well we got the benefit of hindsight now
Bravo Almighty Russia.
Viva Russia.
Glory be to Russia.
i thought that Russia was already out of ammuniton 😂.According to the British intelligence
It's the magic shovels
Russia 🇷🇺 has won long time
Win what?
400000 plus deceased Russians is not a win🤡
Your numbers according to western propaganda 😅😅😅@@dz7786
@@dz7786 *4000000000000 🤡
@@dz7786 ~ "Tell me you watch only Ukrainian TV, without telling me that you watch only Ukrainian TV"
Honestly Ukraine was never match for Russia on the battle field.
Since the start of war Russia won , even NATO knew this, they just wanted to sucrifise , Ukraine solders
As a American we are tired of give away money 💰 our country is open borders inflation is high so Europe has to step up about the Ukraine now
We tanzania 🇹🇿 suport russia 🇷🇺 ❤
Zelensky looks like he hasn't slept much. You can tell he knows its all falling apart for him, which would likely mean death or prison for him
This presenter was all out reporting the war against Russia now tides have changed which has toned her down.
Moral: don't be overzealous when reporting
She was never pro of any side.
Nato plus America v One country, RUSSIA and still kicking they ass😂😂😂😂😂
its Russia vs Ukraine with some old NATO weapons
-3 Patriot PAC 2 batteries made in 1987
-less than 40 HiMars rockets
-around 100 older model tanks (mostly 1980s models)
-around 300 older model APCs (mostly 1980s models)
-hand held weapons like Javelin and Rifles
versus laterally the entire Russian military except Nukes, if this is all Russia can do against that then Poland will crush them, Poland has F-35s, F-16s, F/A-50s and advanced Abrams and K2 tanks, Russia cannot beat Poland
@@michaeld1170exactly! That's why this coward just made another nuclear threat that we either let him win or he starts a nuclear war. Would loveto see the look on these people's faces in their last seconds when they realize they've been tricked 🤣
Not a SINGLE NATO soldier is fighting against Russia bro. It's stil Russia (140 million) vs Ukraine (35 million) bro... It just so happens that Ukraine's weapons are artificially on par with Russian ones.
Now if you talk about economic battle, I agree that it indeed looks as if USA + Europe were both fighting a war against Russia. If you google EURO - Russia rouble exchange rate, then rouble lost only 30% of its value, which is extremely impressive.
@@michaeld1170 the Western media is controlled by your elites so ofc they like to make it as if Russia is useless...United terrorist of America....
@@kacperzimowski4626pentagon leaks clearly mention NATO special forces operating in Ukraine along with their numbers and country of origin. Check it out
They won long agoo 😅
what amazes me is the total ignorance of the News Mida. Unless something has changed, I was told in the 5th grade Russia was the largest Country on Earth.
Largest single country
@@zambiamypassionemmanuelmus2257 and what is the largest double country?
Dont matter its the biggest country. 77% of russia is inhabited with an economy smaller than the state of California
@@snakehater123But with this economy they can do a lot!
@@javastream5015 : It's cheaper to live there, if you know what I mean.
Love Russian forces❤💪🇷🇺
Go ahead.
Can war be fought and won on aid
Well ask the Vietnamese if that is possible... Ask Afghanistan if that is possible. The answer is yes in both cases. The USA and USSR both lost to small countries because of aide being given to the enemy..
That depends on who you're fighting against.
Hundrers billions aid and not enought weapons 😂
How is the Ukrainian-western counter-offensive going?
Looking at the stock market gains for US military contractors, I would say quite well. 😅
What kind of question is that? The obvious shouldn't be put in the form of a question.
Biggest win for Russian after bakhmut was their defense against summer offensive of Ukraine.
Justice will prevail. Slava Russia.
This just a test Mach for Ukraine president he never know putting is not to be defeated at all costs
Answer is yes
It's time for the USA to stop sending money to Ukraine. We did enough.
I love your energy,keep up the good work. Rather hear da truth than a lie
Thanks Ukraine for being the test pilots for the United States 🇺🇸. Showing America, Russian military might 😂😞 Ukraine stop fighting and rejoin your brothers.
Победа будет за нами🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺👍
Another Putin bullies
LOL 'aid to Ukraine' has nothing to do with this. This is just an inevitable step in Russia's path to victory
See the condition of a country who was once a power horse of nukes.
It does not make any sense to blame this setback on the bill being debated now in the US, what difference would it have made. Even if the bill passed in November, it wouldn't have made any difference, Ukraine is outnumbered and outgunned massively. The MIC in the west has to greatly improve to be able to fill this gap, their stockpiles are depleted. Ukraine burns more ammunition a day than the US manufactures in a Month.
All news agencies say that Avdiivka is Russia's first success after Bakhmut. And the failure of the Ukrainian offensive, which the West had high hopes for, is not Russia's success?
Actually RU's success after Marinka.
Actually RU's success after Marinka.
I called It a year a go they didnt pusj into Moscow when they had the momentum AND waited for Russia to get more soldiers During the winter tbh the way i see It ...It no longer really benefits me or the us for a Ukraine victory anymore
Люди, думайте когда выбераете президента...это не оолько ваше благополучие, но и ваша жизнь...думали клоун это весело....нет, это смертельно и не смешно.
Pray for Russian, because they have the truth.
What a sad country Russia has become. It used to be OK, not good, but OK, but now, its just all bad and sad. I've been there many many times, but I know now I am never going to return.
U goes to war and depending on another country to defend you thats madness , better you just leave the war alone
''we don't have this we don't have that'' so WHY ARE YOU STILL FIGHTING? smh
😂😂
🤣🤣
Natio al boundaries in Europe have been redrawn hundreds of times over a thousand years. Ukraine was historically part of Russia. Military Khrusgchev was Ukrainian and he knew it was part of Russia.
If you’re reading this in 2090, 2023 and start of 2024 was horrible and bloody
Military changes at the top shows different views & strategy
As Zelenskyy promised to fight ‘till the last man’ So it went - no one left!! Only US mercenaries !!!
Welldone russia❤️❤️❤️❤️
Yes well done. You have achieved the following
- Ukraine is better armed now than at the start of the war
- Finland and Sweden joining Nato
Ukraine started on route to join EU
- Failing Russian economy (GDP of whole of Russia is less than New York)
- Thousands of intelligent Russians have left the country
- Tens of thousands of Russians dead
- Can’t travel abroad except for places no one wants to go
- Western brands and tech have left and now you are driving Ladas with 1990s technology or over priced Chinese cars
- Russian public and convicts being called up to fight
- Wagner coup
Russian flagship sunk
- Have lost 50% of territory gained
No real freedom of speech. Can’t protest or even stand on Red Square with blank piece of paper without being arrested
Government controlled media
Only Russia ‘friendly’ countries are either afraid of Russia or taking advantage to grow their own economy
Out of control inflation and interest rates
No democracy. You can vote for Putin or Putin. All of the competition is in jail or died in mysterious circumstances
Zelensky probably has never heard of Mussolini. He should read about the last days of that dictator.
That is 1.3 milion troops in total in the ukraine.
Afghanistan Iraq Vietnam the USA never learns from history
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Шойгу спрашивает .Откуда "жопы"ждать?Скажите всё прозрачно.
Isn't GREAT BRITAIN preparing an aid package for Ukraine?
Zelensky , the most idiotic president of all time
😂😂😂😂😂
Once comedian, always comedian. Sadly instead of comedy he prepared tragedy for Ukraine.
When will this war be considered as won?🤔
Yes. I thought by 2025, but if US doesn't give the $60B they will fall this year.
The west gave them around 200 billion. What did they do ? Nothing
I already knew they we're gonna lose (the photoshoot made it obvious)
Sure Russia will win....
Putin's short term special military operation seems to be more like a long term war
60 per day i thought they ren out of those years ago
Nato will send 1 million drones.
🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺👍
😂😂
Really you not shame Russia is a super power please
imagin whole west against russia and still no succes!? grazy
Russia had long-ago crossed the Rubicon, there is no going back.
Ukraine needs to kiss Putin's hand and thank him for not make them look like Palestinians
Grandiloquence of Zelensky will not carry any coal in the war of attrition. Try to reach in a settlement.
why Putin at war is understood . Bad luck for the Ukrainian to have the actor as their president.
Ukraine is fighting to the last man standing, what they were told by US/NATO ( as long as it takes for the last man standing )
Putin just said this is just the start
Zelensky seems to be suffering from the shortage of drugs (possibly cocaine) rather than lack of ammunition.
Too Manny life lost zinlinsky need to give up
Advantage russia
Looks like Zelensky is drinking too much. He speak like a third grade drama actor
Он подражает западным политикам.
More than 140 countries support Ukraine including Switzerland
Don't let Ukraine loose. Please help to Ukraine
Lol no. It's a waste of money and resources.
Even if Ukraine can have enough ammunition, Ukraine cant win this war it was mistake to underestimate Russia
More than 200 billion dollars aid and yet you don't have enough she'll, mis use of tax payer money
More it's more than $300b now
It should be over by June the way things are going
Ukraine can borrow to get weapons as most countries did in WW2
The problem is, that NATO doesn't have any spares. Their industrial output is in a rut.
@@prestonyoung3807 Asia, Africa & Australia can.assist
No, it can’t. They are essentially bankrupt for decades (they were held afloat exclusively by debt cuts from other countries - first Russia, now EU).
Nobody wants to borrow you anything, if they don’t know if your currency will be worth anything next months, or the government will be existing at all.