I saw her play this song... stripped down like this, opening for Robyn Hitchcock in Seattle before I ever knew who she was (I think it was late 1990's)-- only time I've ever been moved to tears listening to someone play live. You could have heard a pin drop in the Seattle Opera House. Robyn Hitchcock wouldn't let her leave the stage, after she said "goodnight, that's all I know". He literally pushed her back out on stage, so someone yelled "Play Free Bird".... And she DID. Every last note.
This song is an anchor to what I did and what happened. It’s very important to me and I listen to it and cry when I need to remember. Thanks Cat! You’ve kept me on the right track…
I have seen her perform twice and keep on coming back to listening her music. I wish her happiness, peace, fulfillment and everything else her heart desires.
+slint69 For me this song is all about accepting eachother for who you are and what you went thru. I instantly forgave my woman for what she might have done in the past (even if I knew it or not) and she did the same for me.We both excepted that there was only the here and now and the two of us together.When you fall in love you just erase the tape of your previous life and start recording like it is day one.I still love my woman and for me she is more than a Good Woman for me she is the Best and Only Woman.She did change me for ever and she did make me a good man (at least in her eyes, and that is all that matters).
I want to be a good woman And I want for you to be a good man. This is why I will be leaving And this is why I can't see you no more. I will miss your heart so tender And I will love this love forever. I don't want be a bad woman And I can't stand to see you be a bad man. I will miss your heart so tender And I will love this love forever. And this is why I am leaving And this is why I can't see you no more. This is why I am lying when I say That I don't love you no more. Cause I want (to) be a good woman And I want for you to be a good man.
I should add-- I also cried when the song came out on album, only this time because it was all distorted and played with a full band... It wasn't the same. So happy to find this version. Thanks!
..the lioness roars Like a purr Our hearts melt Once like steel Now putty for artist Painter Melted hearts Opened to the light It's ok have no fright With Opened light From mysterious night Somewhere a comet Flys across the sky To catch the eye And free the heart It's all allright
When you say 'Dave Grohl of Nirvana and The Foo Fighters plays the drums and Eddie Vedder of Pearl Jam provides backing vocals on this track' - what drums, and what backing vocal?
a touching song of "other woman" who decided to be a good woman and not a home wrecking whore. The world desperately needs more good women and men. peace.
"This is *NOT* why I am leavin..." :-D It's cat $hi1t... :-D although it's still a great song. If you don't believe me, just listen to Caramel from Susan Vega. That sounds much more sincere :-D
@asbiichle this sound like the beginning of an american romantic movie. soon you're going to meet a bakery alternative girl and to a rock and roll show with her, or something like that
I saw her play this song... stripped down like this, opening for Robyn Hitchcock in Seattle before I ever knew who she was (I think it was late 1990's)-- only time I've ever been moved to tears listening to someone play live. You could have heard a pin drop in the Seattle Opera House. Robyn Hitchcock wouldn't let her leave the stage, after she said "goodnight, that's all I know". He literally pushed her back out on stage, so someone yelled "Play Free Bird".... And she DID. Every last note.
What a beautiful anecdote.
ua-cam.com/video/3jKqp9iATJY/v-deo.html
Wow
Amazing. She is 1000% soul, must have been incredible to witness.
The song just kills me. It reminds me of the biggest losses I've ever suffered and the complexity, the agony, the sorrow of love.
Same. Absolutely stunning but destroys me every single listen all these years later...
Same here 🥺❤
This song is an anchor to what I did and what happened. It’s very important to me and I listen to it and cry when I need to remember.
Thanks Cat! You’ve kept me on the right track…
I’ll fold the pages of his memory so I can always go back and remember what it feels like to be alive.
literally one of the most devastating/introspective songs ive ever heard. deep.
I seen her play live in 2008 and was totally taken by her emotional performance. Her voice is very special.
Never met her, but this lady is one of my favorite people in the world. Big love from Detroit, we live crossbone style out here, too.😎
The best version of this great song imo. Draws serious blood.
Simply beautiful.
We will be loving you always
Damn, right in the feels...
one of her best songs! thanks for uploading this version!!
I concur
Her voice and that picture at 0:43. This woman is perfection.
I have seen her perform twice and keep on coming back to listening her music. I wish her happiness, peace, fulfillment and everything else her heart desires.
This version of this song hits me so fucking hard
Chan Marshall makes life good.
I have found a good woman, I love her more than anything. I used to be a bad man. But finding a good woman will change a man for ever.
+slint69 For me this song is all about accepting eachother for who you are and what you went thru. I instantly forgave my woman for what she might have done in the past (even if I knew it or not) and she did the same for me.We both excepted that there was only the here and now and the two of us together.When you fall in love you just erase the tape of your previous life and start recording like it is day one.I still love my woman and for me she is more than a Good Woman for me she is the Best and Only Woman.She did change me for ever and she did make me a good man (at least in her eyes, and that is all that matters).
My problems is worrying about not finding her.
Okay, but try therapy, too. 💓
I want to be a good woman
And I want for you to be a good man.
This is why I will be leaving
And this is why I can't see you no more.
I will miss your heart so tender
And I will love this love forever.
I don't want be a bad woman
And I can't stand to see you be a bad man.
I will miss your heart so tender
And I will love this love forever.
And this is why I am leaving
And this is why I can't see you no more.
This is why I am lying when I say
That I don't love you no more.
Cause I want (to) be a good woman
And I want for you to be a good man.
Amazing heartbreaking song.. Thanks Chan
i agree. it breaks my heart every time i hear it.
I should add-- I also cried when the song came out on album, only this time because it was all distorted and played with a full band... It wasn't the same. So happy to find this version. Thanks!
Same!
Stunning performance in a stunning film. Ty for sharing this (!!)
Masterful. ❤
Beautiful!
..the lioness roars
Like a purr
Our hearts melt
Once like steel
Now putty for artist
Painter
Melted hearts
Opened to the light
It's ok have no fright
With Opened light
From mysterious night
Somewhere a comet
Flys across the sky
To catch the eye
And free the heart
It's all allright
Lydia 💔 "I will love this love forever"
I'm in a new city. Boxes are all around. I can't find my toothbrush. I'm stealing internet, and Chan is my only friend.
asbiichle did things get better? What were the past six years like? ✌️
so relaxing
Allison, I will miss your heart so tender...
Amazing ❤
Chills
I lie when i say, i dont love no more...
If a woman sang this to me, I'd probably break down in a million pieces.
If Chan sang this to me, I'd die.
True story.
Que c’est beau❣️Que j’aime sa voix veloutée. Ce texte a été écrit pour moi. C’est mon histoire🌹Bel accent italien. ANNE🥀🇫🇷...1.9.2022.
Very nice song ...
glad you ended in italian :) love you
😭 lagu yang indah
Aku mencintaimu charlyn marie marshall 🙏🙏🙏
Was this performed in Italy? At the end of the song she says: “Auguri a tutte le donne”!
It must’ve been on a 8th of March :)
This is why I am lying when I say
That I don't love you no more.
Cause I want to be a good woman
And I want for you to be a good man.
NICE NAME MATADOR RECORDS. WHERE DID YOU GET THAT ONE FROM.
Nice.
beautiful. Xx
Nice song. Really relaxing
Kaftann
❤🥰
wow.
perfecto cat!
When you say 'Dave Grohl of Nirvana and The Foo Fighters plays the drums and Eddie Vedder of Pearl Jam provides backing vocals on this track' - what drums, and what backing vocal?
Not in this version
Wow
a touching song of "other woman" who decided to be a good woman and not a home wrecking whore. The world desperately needs more good women and men. peace.
brasil representa essa grande cantora, grande igual Elis Regina - Como nossos pais
clarity
this is definitely 1998 not 2008
I heard no drums or backing vocals...... Wheres Dave and Eddie?
Only Eddie is on the studio version. He's playing guitar & about halfway through listen to it closely, Can't miss him
@prostakuk On this song - Album version !
I looked up "a gonri le tu el la don i" and it means "has inflated the you and the gift I" in French.
It's Italian, 'auguri a tutte le donne', which means: best wishes to all women
@@franciscocastrovidela9007 Thanks! I thought that was a bit odd. She speaks with a French accent.
ouch to the heart.
"This is *NOT* why I am leavin..."
:-D It's cat $hi1t... :-D although it's still a great song.
If you don't believe me, just listen to Caramel from Susan Vega. That sounds much more sincere :-D
I don't want to see the picture I want to see your lips singing
hope you found your toothbrush...
@asbiichle this sound like the beginning of an american romantic movie. soon you're going to meet a bakery alternative girl and to a rock and roll show with her, or something like that
Where's the booze
@prostakuk On this song - Album version !