Everything about this band’s perfomance is why I watch Tiny Desk. Unique and theatrical with an 11-piece band in a small space. Dahl was enthralling and bewitching. It’s “out there”, but that’s exactly what they’re going for. Can’t wait to check them out on the road!
Knowing the story of how Hailey Dahl was attacked and robbed really makes Madison even more emotional and impactful. So glad I found out about Sloppy Jane and the beautiful chaos they bring.
I love how uncomfortable people are with this band. It makes me love them more. Good art makes people react, and based on the very unkind and unthoughtful comments, they really succeeded! I’m so happy I checked this out and found my new favorite band!
Haley Dahl and Sloppy Jane have managed to do what few; if any, band has managed to do. Take the band 180 degree musically. From a punk band to the Avant Gard Art Rock of Willow to the ethereal sounds of Madison. And she doesn't disappoint. I thought I would miss the raw punk power of songs like "Glitte rSpitt" and "King Mitis" but the fragile melody of Madison are quite charming and beautiful on their own. Haley Dahl will be famous some day for something. A very creative young woman who's star will shine.
I'm just imagining how Tiny Desk fans would react to Lingua Ignota after this performance, and jeez I don't think that'd go well for the audience (but I know I'd love it).
it's really funny seeing people say this performance is disturbing, because 1) that's the exact sort of feeling they're going for, and 2) this might be the most refined and focused performance I've seen from them lol
I think the negative comments stem from a place of creative undernourishment. Having an outlet to express and communicate your emotions lead to some weird and wonderful conceptions! This is my first time listening to Sloppy Jane; I'm intrigued and can't wait to check out their other stuff.
I said this in a comment somewhere else but I think you hit the nail on the head. I truly believe not having a creative outlet to take pride in leads to that type of anger. They could literally move on without being negative, but they stop and put their unhappiness into words for a reason.
I keep searching and can't find any negative comments....Never heard of this band and almost bailed out when I first clicked on this, but I started reading comments and now I'm like 7 minutes in and the strings and pedal steel guitar have securely wrapped around my inner core and are pulling me closer and closer. I can now see a light in the distance, slowly expanding in a kaleidoscopic paisley explosion of pure expression. I have forgotten who I am and no longer feel part on this world
That was the weirdest Tiny Desk I’ve ever watched but it was one of the absolute best!! I really enjoyed her vocals and her mannerisms in addition to how her guitarist(blonde lady) was able to work with her in addition to piano and strings! I’ll be buying the Madison album and adding to my collection in addition to adding this performance to my playlists!
@@RobertSlover I think people who spent this much time honing their skills can definitely hear for themselves whether they like the music or not. So calling it a shame it a bit arrogant to say the least.
@@RobertSlover What's hard to understand? You call it shame that these people play in this band. They are skilled enough to know what they like and don't like musically.
I only learned of Sloppy Jane less than a week ago, by way of a NYTimes piece where the writer spent time with the band, while they recorded Madison in a cave. I was very intrigued by the story and loved the idea of recording an album inside a cave. Then I listened to the Madison album here on UA-cam. Words that came to mind were: dark, 'original', disturbing, witty, beautiful.... I've listened to the album now, a few times, and...there seems to be a 'story'....the mention of a policeman on her bumper (if I recall correctly)...the young girl that was murdered...and then she (the album protagonist) hiding from the man she killed with her car. And then there's the song about the horses, as well as the blue horse on the album cover. Very intrigued about the overall storyline... In any case, when I first listened to this album in my apartment, instead of it just playing in the background while I, say, washed dishes (lol) ...and which is typical for me, as I listen to music CONSTANTLY...with Madison, I found myself planting myself in front of my PC, sitting there, and really LISTENING. I imagined myself in a performance space, listening to this, Live. And I was just dumbstruck at the genius of this music... I would describe the album as an aural work of art, from start to finish. Now having said that, after listening to Madison, I checked out other Sloppy Jane music. It's hard to categorize (as I suppose Madison would be), but the other music I heard was dark, frenetic, and while with a cursory listen it may seem like 'garbage' to some, it was clear to me that the sometimes off-sounding chords were all very intentional. I'm not a fan of 'weird' or in-your-face music or bands and who are this way, just for the sake of it. Sloppy Jane is not 'simply' strange. There is a clear intelligence, forethought and creative genius behind it. I am now officially obsessed. ;-) I only came across this literally just-posted-today Tiny Desk concert by Sloppy Jane (which, BTW, I was elated to see) only because I was on UA-cam, yet again, trying to find more videos of Sloppy Jane and their other works...
So much hate for this incredible band in the comments. One of the most interesting groups making music right now. So glad they're getting some recognition.
@@RobertSlover If that were the case then every band would be just sitting in folding chairs while they play, or standing motionless and unemotional. This seems obvious but apparently necessary to say, but performances have always had elements of performance. Sets, costumes, lighting, even just movement on stage.
Haley Dahl seems to be influenced by the pop theater approaches as performed by Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush, the band's style reminds me of the Hadestown concert at NPR tiny desk.
I keep searching and can't find any negative comments....Never heard of this band and almost bailed out when I first clicked on this, but I started reading comments and now I'm like 7 minutes in and the string section and pedal steel guitar have securely wrapped themselves around my inner core and are pulling me closer and closer. I can now see a light in the distance, slowly expanding in a kaleidoscopic paisley explosion of pure expression. I have forgotten who I am and no longer feel part on this world. Tell my Dearest Stella that I love her and please look after my cat. Goodbye
Hard to understand why there so much bad opinion on this. Might not be your taste as a performance but they is so much Music in these and so much personal involvement At least people should recognize this
The crazy thing about opinions is that people can choose to not recognize the musicianship or effort or anything, for that matter. What you find valuable in this performance is not something other people have to recognize. There is no objective truth to music. I happen to agree with you that this performance has value, though.
@@upsdelft Do get your point but I would just rather quit looking but not leaving a negative feedback but as you say everyone is untitled to his own opinion
Not heard of this band before, but I'm definitely feeling it. Wonderfully bonkers performance from the lead singer. I'll be catching up on their back catalogue.
@@RobertSlover Do you feel the same about artists like Alice Cooper? Plenty of artists turn their music into a full experience. There's nothing wrong with it. I love artists like this. Just because you don't doesn't actually make it bad.
Omg sloppy Jane has evolved alot i remember it was a girl surf punk band i saw at the church of fun and she had a teddy 🧸 bear with her . Now this! Still very great! Wow its been 8 year's 😳 😊😩
I see some Amanda Palmer influence for sure. If Dresden Dolls go back on tour (possibility), you should figure out how to get in touch with her. She would love you. I don't hear what everyone else hates so much I guess. It's unique and interesting so far. Some people turn a live show into an actual show. This is a great example of that. Just because it's not your thing, doesn't mean it's bad. It's just not your thing. The end of the second song is supposed to sound like chaos, for instance.
@@codylatimer29 She's on lock down in New Zealand right now and getting a bit stir crazy. I love that I see her out in the internet wild, though. She made an announcement recently that Dresden Dolls will go on tour again. I think she's waiting to be out of lock down before she makes any official announcements that are less vague though.
Recorded in a cave in Virginia!!?!😳 Super Cool!😝4:20 I felt that😔pulled at my heart strings. Page to page door to door.🎶 Jesus' in your living room floor. Madison is gonna be great!📀🥀
@@RobertSlover What makes you think Frank would hate this? The man was a musical innovator who loved craziness and whimsical elements in music. Is that not present here?
@@RobertSlover you must think that just because you’re a jazz aficionado anything you make is automatically better. I’m a jazz musician as well and I’m enough of a mature musician to realize that it’s all valid regardless of if it bothers you or not. Get with the times.
Welcome to DC. Thanks for the art Jane.🎶💕 begining reminds me of myself beatboxing yesterday, and the band is uniquely amazing!💃darn do I miss working at Tower Records.
Everything about this band’s perfomance is why I watch Tiny Desk. Unique and theatrical with an 11-piece band in a small space. Dahl was enthralling and bewitching. It’s “out there”, but that’s exactly what they’re going for. Can’t wait to check them out on the road!
Knowing the story of how Hailey Dahl was attacked and robbed really makes Madison even more emotional and impactful. So glad I found out about Sloppy Jane and the beautiful chaos they bring.
I love how uncomfortable people are with this band. It makes me love them more. Good art makes people react, and based on the very unkind and unthoughtful comments, they really succeeded! I’m so happy I checked this out and found my new favorite band!
I completely agree! I'll take unique over boring anyday!
I honestly can't find one negative comment
Amanda Palmer vibes
@@nicolem9251 yes!! She absolutely does 💖
@@jeremysmith9694 oh good, then the positive comments have far surpassed the negative ones 😁💖
Haley Dahl and Sloppy Jane have managed to do what few; if any, band has managed to do. Take the band 180 degree musically. From a punk band to the Avant Gard Art Rock of Willow to the ethereal sounds of Madison. And she doesn't disappoint. I thought I would miss the raw punk power of songs like "Glitte rSpitt" and "King Mitis" but the fragile melody of Madison are quite charming and beautiful on their own. Haley Dahl will be famous some day for something. A very creative young woman who's star will shine.
Agree! They reached a point where the most ‘ out there’ envelope pushing thing they could do was make an unabashedly pretty album. And they nailed it!
I'm just imagining how Tiny Desk fans would react to Lingua Ignota after this performance, and jeez I don't think that'd go well for the audience (but I know I'd love it).
I love lingua ignota, and I'm just getting in to sloppy jane!
Thanks for posting this, this sent me down a lovely rabbit hole of musical discovery! :)
@@mlbman242 Of course 👍! Always a great feeling getting people into Lingua Ignota.
Omg a Lingua Ignota tiny desk would be magical
it's really funny seeing people say this performance is disturbing, because 1) that's the exact sort of feeling they're going for, and 2) this might be the most refined and focused performance I've seen from them lol
cant the music be enough why the silly theatrics? the music is all that matters!
@@RobertSlover if the music was all that mattered, no one would go to concerts-- they could just put on some headphones and close their eyes
@@5ystemError utterly silly and not applicable. no content bot.
@@RobertSlover huh?
@@5ystemError exactly....
I love this band - 11 people in one of the smallest spaces on Tiny Desk! Great vocals, sound and the commitment - Bravo
I think the negative comments stem from a place of creative undernourishment.
Having an outlet to express and communicate your emotions lead to some weird and wonderful conceptions!
This is my first time listening to Sloppy Jane; I'm intrigued and can't wait to check out their other stuff.
I said this in a comment somewhere else but I think you hit the nail on the head. I truly believe not having a creative outlet to take pride in leads to that type of anger. They could literally move on without being negative, but they stop and put their unhappiness into words for a reason.
I think it’s because their music sucks
0:00 / 0:09 - *Party Anthem* (3:26)
4:09 - *Jesus and Your Living Room Floor* (9:42)
9:47 - *Wilt* (12:50)
[13:03 - Tiny Desk team]
Thanks 💙
It’s nice to see an artist actually doing a home concert where they live.
I love the visual motifs that have developed in this project.
Everyone's talking about negative comments but all I'm seeing is a whole lotta love! One of my fave records of the year, and great performance! ❤️
I keep searching and can't find any negative comments....Never heard of this band and almost bailed out when I first clicked on this, but I started reading comments and now I'm like 7 minutes in and the strings and pedal steel guitar have securely wrapped around my inner core and are pulling me closer and closer. I can now see a light in the distance, slowly expanding in a kaleidoscopic paisley explosion of pure expression. I have forgotten who I am and no longer feel part on this world
i love sloppy jane so much i was blown away when i first saw them live. so talented and doing something totally unique. so excited for madison!
That was the weirdest Tiny Desk I’ve ever watched but it was one of the absolute best!! I really enjoyed her vocals and her mannerisms in addition to how her guitarist(blonde lady) was able to work with her in addition to piano and strings! I’ll be buying the Madison album and adding to my collection in addition to adding this performance to my playlists!
I love the Madison album but was super concerned if it'd tame Haley but as made clear on this one, it hasn't and it's wonderful.
now this is chaos I can get behind
those strings!!!! literally so good, they way the second song explodes at the end into madness, it's amazing
the strings are solid. its a shame there wasted on sub par "music"....
@@RobertSlover don't you have anything better to do? I thought this "music" was great, personally. I'm sorry it seemed to offend you in some way
@@RobertSlover I think people who spent this much time honing their skills can definitely hear for themselves whether they like the music or not. So calling it a shame it a bit arrogant to say the least.
@@PelleKuipers your sentence/statement is unclear. not that it matters....
@@RobertSlover What's hard to understand? You call it shame that these people play in this band. They are skilled enough to know what they like and don't like musically.
they brought their own tiny desk
I only learned of Sloppy Jane less than a week ago, by way of a NYTimes piece where the writer spent time with the band, while they recorded Madison in a cave. I was very intrigued by the story and loved the idea of recording an album inside a cave.
Then I listened to the Madison album here on UA-cam. Words that came to mind were: dark, 'original', disturbing, witty, beautiful.... I've listened to the album now, a few times, and...there seems to be a 'story'....the mention of a policeman on her bumper (if I recall correctly)...the young girl that was murdered...and then she (the album protagonist) hiding from the man she killed with her car. And then there's the song about the horses, as well as the blue horse on the album cover. Very intrigued about the overall storyline...
In any case, when I first listened to this album in my apartment, instead of it just playing in the background while I, say, washed dishes (lol) ...and which is typical for me, as I listen to music CONSTANTLY...with Madison, I found myself planting myself in front of my PC, sitting there, and really LISTENING. I imagined myself in a performance space, listening to this, Live. And I was just dumbstruck at the genius of this music... I would describe the album as an aural work of art, from start to finish.
Now having said that, after listening to Madison, I checked out other Sloppy Jane music. It's hard to categorize (as I suppose Madison would be), but the other music I heard was dark, frenetic, and while with a cursory listen it may seem like 'garbage' to some, it was clear to me that the sometimes off-sounding chords were all very intentional. I'm not a fan of 'weird' or in-your-face music or bands and who are this way, just for the sake of it. Sloppy Jane is not 'simply' strange. There is a clear intelligence, forethought and creative genius behind it.
I am now officially obsessed. ;-) I only came across this literally just-posted-today Tiny Desk concert by Sloppy Jane (which, BTW, I was elated to see) only because I was on UA-cam, yet again, trying to find more videos of Sloppy Jane and their other works...
It's different, raw, far from perfect and a bit disturbing. Love it !
Im so in love with this band and this band. ALBUM OF THE YEAR!
So much hate for this incredible band in the comments. One of the most interesting groups making music right now. So glad they're getting some recognition.
cant the music be enough why the silly theatrics? the music is all that matters!
@@RobertSlover If that were the case then every band would be just sitting in folding chairs while they play, or standing motionless and unemotional. This seems obvious but apparently necessary to say, but performances have always had elements of performance. Sets, costumes, lighting, even just movement on stage.
@@kevinkelly3094 no content bot.
@@RobertSlover Nonsensical Answers for 1000, Alex?
@@kevinkelly3094 i very much doubt you watch jeopardy.....no content bot.
Haley Dahl seems to be influenced by the pop theater approaches as performed by Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush, the band's style reminds me of the Hadestown concert at NPR tiny desk.
Gorgeous. The arc of tension in the second song. The groove in the third!
jesus and your living room floor song of the year
Ya know, this was theatrical, however, it seems as if everyone was free and drifting in the beauty and chaos and art, together.
In a year that has been tumultuous and self destructive and transitional for me, this band is the best thing I've discovered this year.
This needs to be a musical, i think it already is
Just recently found out about this band and artist. Truly an original and has fantastic vision! Cheers Y'all!!
always the bassist who take control in any chaos, love art in music
So refreshing, loved every second of it
I only listen to cape-wearers.
I keep searching and can't find any negative comments....Never heard of this band and almost bailed out when I first clicked on this, but I started reading comments and now I'm like 7 minutes in and the string section and pedal steel guitar have securely wrapped themselves around my inner core and are pulling me closer and closer. I can now see a light in the distance, slowly expanding in a kaleidoscopic paisley explosion of pure expression. I have forgotten who I am and no longer feel part on this world. Tell my Dearest Stella that I love her and please look after my cat. Goodbye
If you don't understand why people could enjoy this, you don't understand the point of music
I love this band.
i keep coming back to absorb this experience
still here. love the jam in the van performance aswell.
Glorious.
One minute in and I’m already intrigued. Interesting band, will check out more.
Madison is a masterpiece.
@@joaobbmmaia And the blue outfit is fabulous! 💙
This is really weird on an 80’s level, Like a creepy b movie, it’s efffing fantastic, what a unique well developed sound.
Haley reminds me a lot of Kate Bush in this video. Madison is absolutely a masterpiece through and through.
Kate Bush was the 1st thought I had when it started. (*first time hearing/seeing this band)
Glad I found this. Discovered Sloppy Jane through Bloodfeast Presents on adult swim and I've loved them ever since. One of a kind band
They are fantastic!!!
I need that jacket in my life.
Hard to understand why there so much bad opinion on this. Might not be your taste as a performance but they is so much Music in these and so much personal involvement At least people should recognize this
The crazy thing about opinions is that people can choose to not recognize the musicianship or effort or anything, for that matter. What you find valuable in this performance is not something other people have to recognize. There is no objective truth to music. I happen to agree with you that this performance has value, though.
@@upsdelft Do get your point but I would just rather quit looking but not leaving a negative feedback but as you say everyone is untitled to his own opinion
I honestly can't find one negative opinion
the pedal steel on jesus and your living room floor just ripped my heart out and stomped on it
best tiny desk performance I’ve ever seen. Just wall to wall art pop thrashing
This is the wildest comment I've ever read ...get outta here
Beautiful talented band
Not heard of this band before, but I'm definitely feeling it. Wonderfully bonkers performance from the lead singer.
I'll be catching up on their back catalogue.
Thank you. Very beautiful music. Made me feel things.
I just love their quirkiness 😊❤️
saw them live. they're amazing.
this is gold and i was 100% sure what the comments would say before scrolling down. yall basic.
i liked at the end how they all watched her to bow
HALEY OMG THIS IS SO GOOD
AOTY .
Give it a listen, remove all prior conceptions, lay in a dark room and let your mind absorb everything. Madison is 20/10.
cant the music be enough why the silly theatrics? the music is all that matters!
@@RobertSlover Do you feel the same about artists like Alice Cooper? Plenty of artists turn their music into a full experience. There's nothing wrong with it. I love artists like this. Just because you don't doesn't actually make it bad.
@@RobertSlover because it's a performance
@@TheShauNanigans please return to your utterly pointless junk food taste test videos and stay in your lane. thanks.
@@Aiur irrelevant.
SOO GOOOOOD
The name intrigued me and I'm glad I clicked it. Really enjoyed that, not everyone's cup of tea as the comments prove but I think they are awesome.
Every comment says they like it
@@jeremysmith9694 4 weeks ago it wasn't like that but I'm glad to hear its changed.
You all are so beautiful and inspiring and talented. The performance was really great, thank you thank you xoxo
Omg sloppy Jane has evolved alot i remember it was a girl surf punk band i saw at the church of fun and she had a teddy 🧸 bear with her . Now this! Still very great! Wow its been 8 year's 😳 😊😩
Was that when Phoebe Bridgers was playing bass with her?
Yes, It would’ve been around that time. Can’t speak on that show exactly but she had been playing with them around that time.
I love polarizing bands, LOL. I think Haley's musical vision is thoroughly unique, and it's exciting to see it come to fruition on Madison.
cant the music be enough why the silly theatrics? the music is all that matters!
@@RobertSlover The theatrical quality is part of the character of the music. It's over the top by design.
@@onefootsteve5919 and the design has crashed and burned.....
@@RobertSlover You're entitled to your opinion.
@@onefootsteve5919 iv been studying music for 17 years now. how bout you 'one foot steve'?.....
Love this
First time seeing this band I really hope I see them play sometime
all the untalented folks that never did anything worth remembering sure have a lot to say in these comments at the moment....
She isn’t a good singer though. She could be, if she had better form. This performance is hard to listen to.
genius
I’m watching this in the dark alone and I’m low key scared. It’s great though!
Can we get a Denzel Curry Tiny Desk ?
There's something about the way she reacts with the camera the reminds me so much about Gerard Way
I see some Amanda Palmer influence for sure. If Dresden Dolls go back on tour (possibility), you should figure out how to get in touch with her. She would love you.
I don't hear what everyone else hates so much I guess. It's unique and interesting so far. Some people turn a live show into an actual show. This is a great example of that. Just because it's not your thing, doesn't mean it's bad. It's just not your thing. The end of the second song is supposed to sound like chaos, for instance.
Random but I recently saw Amanda posting in a phoebe bridgers Facebook group so it probably wouldn’t be too hard to get in touch haha
@@codylatimer29 She's on lock down in New Zealand right now and getting a bit stir crazy. I love that I see her out in the internet wild, though. She made an announcement recently that Dresden Dolls will go on tour again. I think she's waiting to be out of lock down before she makes any official announcements that are less vague though.
@E R I don't see what's wrong with both of those statements, but okay.
never heard of sloppy jane but this is fire
They are definitely on something
What an amazing performance! Everything about this is is interesting.
I saw Sloppy Jane live once. It was... unique.
Me too,. and I'm going to see them next February supporting Iceage.
I think you mean life changing. I saw them open for boygenius on halloween. best opener I have evr seen like ever.
Recorded in a cave in Virginia!!?!😳 Super Cool!😝4:20 I felt that😔pulled at my heart strings. Page to page door to door.🎶 Jesus' in your living room floor. Madison is gonna be great!📀🥀
It's like a music video, live
They are the 2021 beatles AND I LIVE FOR ITTTTTTTTTT
Vampires made a band
WE NEED A BILLY STRINGS TINY DESK!
What a blasting performance, and a crew!
Im glad to see music getting wierd again
Well, that was pretty dope
So glad Sloppy Jane is getting the recognition they deserve
I love you too
Haley and Co comes back hard
I LOVE THEM
Very nice, thanks for the concert!
Society needs ScaryPoolParty and Emmy Meli on here. Both empowering artists to listen to. Seeing them perform their songs would be amazingggg
Zappa would be proud :,)
no.
@@RobertSlover Yes, he absolutely would
@@marshorner1573 well then you must be thinking of another zappa......chad zappa?
please return to your video games and stay in your lane. thanks.
@@RobertSlover What makes you think Frank would hate this? The man was a musical innovator who loved craziness and whimsical elements in music. Is that not present here?
@@RobertSlover you must think that just because you’re a jazz aficionado anything you make is automatically better. I’m a jazz musician as well and I’m enough of a mature musician to realize that it’s all valid regardless of if it bothers you or not. Get with the times.
this wasw lit af
I felt like i was going insane
Unique, for sure. I don’t get it but I can dig it!
Freakin Amazing
shoutout to my ex bf you're crazy but this goes off
?
Génial !!!
Great musicianship. Awesome sound.
It's giving me Portlandia, lots and lots of Portlandia.
Definitely live up to the name.
what a performance!
Saddest Factory 👻
absolutely enjoyed it. gonna check out more of them.
Welcome to DC. Thanks for the art Jane.🎶💕 begining reminds me of myself beatboxing yesterday, and the band is uniquely amazing!💃darn do I miss working at Tower Records.
Oh my dog
Her name is actually Haley Dahl.