HELLO, I hope everyone enjoyed! A few things! The fan art credited to Ninchu is actually by StylishFish, my mistake! Also, as promised, here's the missing dialogue: Eddy: “Remember how Cartman got a weird, supernatural side-effect from using the Monosauce? You guys said there were even more items like that with weird effects, right?” Dib: “Yes, there’s hundreds actually. Though I’m not sure where you’re going with this.” Eddy: “Jackpot! Then here’s the way I see it:” Eddy: “The killer ordered another item from that microwave. One that could turn them invisible!” Charlotte: “Oooooo, more magic!” Eddy: “That way, they could get the drop on Star and avoid being caught!” Jenny: “I don’t know. Doesn’t that explanation seem a little…too convenient?” Vendetta: “Use your head, stumpy one! There is no invisible food in the kitchen. We would have seen it during the investigation!” Eddy: “Well, duh, of course you didn’t see the food. Because they ate it!” Mabel: “GASP!” Eddy: “With all the crazy things we’ve seen so far like magic portals and truth-telling ketchup, it ain’t that hard to believe. The killer left behind all this evidence, but ate the one piece of evidence that would’ve linked them to this crime. That would be whatever mystery item can cause a guy to turn invisible! Maybe even slipped Star some too after they killed her so she could be hidden from butterball over there.” Dipper: “But we already know the killer used a black sweater and ski mask to hide in the darkness of the cafeteria. Why prepare this as well?” Mabel: “Maybe as a backup plan? If they were spotted by someone, they could’ve turned invisible to keep them from figuring out who they were by their body shape!” Dib: “This idea is ridiculous! The Monosauce was the only experimental item that was even on the list! You need a code for the rest of them and the only people who know even a few of those codes are Gaz and I!” … Dib: “Huh? Why is everyone looking at me like that?” Gaz: “...” Dipper: (Inner thoughts) Agh! And why is she looking at me like that?! Eddy: “Ha! Caught like a mouse in a rat trap!” Charlotte: “Then…did they eat the cheese?” Ed: “Invisible cheese?!” Cartman: “Well, I’ll be damned. That’s a pretty neat twist.” Jenny: “Wait, so if this theory is correct…then it has to be one of the Membranes…” Bubbles: “T-that can’t be true…can it?” Dib: “...” Gaz: “...” Dipper: “Guys, what are you doing? You have to defend yourselves! If you don’t, then everyone will think-” Monokuma: "DEFEND, YOU SAY?" Monokuma: “Oh what a twist of fate. All eyes are locked on just two people! And they don’t know how to defend themselves? That just makes this all the more exciting! Monokuma and Hope’s Peak Academy are proud to announce our newest game of torture…” … Monokuma: “...The Funbox.” Explanation: Funbox, oh Funbox. Small and square and dark. Looks like Dib and Gaz have been put into the hot seat thanks to an interesting theory. Now they’ll be forced to defend themselves against everyone else! In this segment, you’ll actually get to play as whoever is locked in the Funbox. You’ll control the Funbox by moving it up and down. Dodge opposing arguments and statements that come your way until Dipper comes in with a golden statement. Once he does, you can choose a Truth Button to prove him wrong! Do this three times and suspicion will be off of you. Got it? Alright! Let’s get it! [Gameplay] Dipper: - “Neither of you have an alibi for the time of the murder…” TRUTH BUTTON USED: Gaz's Account Dib: - “We established that Star went through Gaz’s room purely through Gaz’s statement. That means Gaz never went downstairs!” Gaz: - “It’s not like anyone else has an alibi either. There’s like, what, 5 people that’ve been cleared so far?” [Gameplay] Dipper: - “Dib has black hair! This lines up with the hairball we found at the crime scene!” TRUTH BUTTON USED: Small Hairball Dib: - “The hair was dyed black by Cupcake’s stomach acid. That hair could belong to anyone, not just people with black hair!” [Gameplay] Dipper: - “You two are the only ones who know about Memwave codes! If the killer was invisible, you’re the most likely suspects!” TRUTH BUTTON USED: Black Sweater Gaz: - “This hinges on the existence of a snack that grants you invisibility, which has never been seen. Plus, it’s pointless.” Dib: - “The black sweater being prepared defeats the purpose of invisibility. Why would either of us create something to hide in the shadows, only to throw away that plan entirely?” BREAK!
Ahhhhh... That would actually be really fun to watch, I personally think It would be "easy" to make, at least easier than you envisioned It to be. I can understand your limitations though
But I bet they won't do the next logical step and have everyone turn on their MonoKaller to prove that it is in fact theirs, after all; just because the HAVE a MonoKaller on hand, doesn't mean it's theirs. heck they should go a step further and show who was messaging who in the last 24 hours
@@JP_Loco_93 just have them use the killers monokaller to call someone else, and the name that pops up is the killer. why hasnt anyone mentioned that yet?
In midst of “it’s so over” I found there was within me, an invincible feeling of “we’re so back”. After so long, we finally get the trail. It’s such a shame I won’t be able to watch this live since I’ll be at work.
Cartman is basically kokichi An asshole liar that despite seemingly being not that smart in the first trial after that he is WAYYYYY smarter than he looks and will pull the heavy lifting in the next trials
Not really. He isn't a compulsive liar like Kokichi, nor is he lying for the betterment of the group. He's just a terrible person. Probably more similar with Byakuya.
I fully believe Jenny was the one who had killed Star First of all, I believe that Star was actually the one to wear the ski mask at the very least, and possibly the sweater, too I mean, why would there be blood on the *inside* of the mask if we know Star didn't fight back against her killer, meaning they would have no reason to be bleeding. This does mean that Jenny can still be a suspect, despite not being able to bleed in the ski mask Now, my biggest reason for believeing it was Jenny is everything surrounding the mysterious Momokaller. First of all, given the tone of the person using the Monokaller, we can immediately rule out people like Morty, Kyle, Dib, Gaz, Vendetta, etc. The person using the Monokaller: 1. Knew Star well 2. Is portrayed as a friendly individual who speaks clearly 3. Was one of the people aiding in the attempts to escape 4. Was busy with something that went "quicker than expected" Those last two details immediately point to Jenny, and the first two help solidify it, considering we know that Jenny and Star have been good friends up to this point Next, what's really odd is how the Monokaller doesn't require a fingerprint to access. The only way that would make sense is if the person it belonged to doesn't have any fingerprints in the first place. Maybe a robot? A few smaller details worth pointing out. The black smudges could easily be oil, Jenny has a clear motive considering her own mother is one of Monokuma's hostages, and, even if the costume was worn by the killer, she is one of the few people I could see it fitting So far, the evidence seems heavily stacked against Jenny
Y'know, I noticed something peculiar... The ones that interrupted Gaz were Mabel AND Jenny, both attempting to redirect the conversation somewhere else... Is it possible the two of them worked together?
I don't think so. While the evidence does point to Jenny, there's many things that don't add up. For one thing, Jenny has an alibi. Assuming that she and the Powerpuffs were being depowered at the time the message was sent to Star, there's no way she could have sent it. Plus, the killer used a knife to slit Star's throat. Why would Jenny kill Star with such a mundane weapon when she could have used one of the weapons she has built into her? Of course, we could say she can't access them due to being depowered by Monokuma, but who's to say she can't still access some of her weapons. Assuming that she has little things like knives and stuff in her body, why not use that instead of the kitchen knife? And there's also the fact that the killer wore a black sweater and ski mask. Why would Jenny bother wearing a disguise if she was going to meet Star? Star would already know who she is, so there'd be no real point. And again, she's a robot, so if she got any blood on her, she could just wash it off. Why wear something that could easily be stained? And there's the fact that Cupcake clearly attacked the killer, if the blood inside the ski mask is anything to go off of. The fact that it's on the inside means that it's likely the killer suffered an injury to their head, likely as a result of being bitten by Cupcake. Jenny is a robot made of metal and bolts, not a flesh and blood human, so she wouldn't even bleed at all, nor would she leave behind any of the hair which Cupcake had in her stomach. The damage would have been obvious too; Jenny would be missing a chunk out of her head. There's also the fact that Jenny and Star seemed to be close with each other. Not like super close best friends or anything, but it's clear that Jenny cared about her, so I doubt she would have been able to craft a plan to kill Star very easily without being heavily conflicted. My theory is that Jenny is being framed by whoever the real killer is. They stole Jenny's Monokaller during the gym scene, then while she and the Powerpuffs were being depowered, the killer texted Star and lured her downstairs.
@@jorienwachukwu466 Wait if what you said at the last part is true. Then it doesn't matter on who didn't bring the Monokaller, so everyone (except some) could be the murderer now (which means back to square one)
I'm calling it now, it's Mabel. I'm gonna operate off of Danganronpa 69 logic right now and say it's Mabel. For no other reason other than I read Danganronpa 69.
Logically it fits. The first case would feel pretty weak without an important or unexpected death. DR, DR2, DR3, and DRV3 all followed that trend and it’s what helps leave a strong impression. The only characters close enough to Dipper would be Mabel, Dib or maybe Gaz. Both of the two Membrane siblings have been cleared. That just leaves Mabel.
I really like how Bubbles stands between Kyle and Cartman and interacts specifically with Cartman. But at the moment when it is necessary to show the monopad (sorry, I’m used to calling it that) Kyle was so cutely proud that he brought the monopad with him and the Bubbles next to him was also so cutely proud of it❤
Thank you all for 100K views in just 10 days, that's never happened before 😭 I'm very thankful for the support and attention this series has been getting as of late, it's been wild
The Trial is the most interesting part, and I'm aware that a lot of people enjoyed it. You got all eyes on ya, lots of people will be present when the next part comes out for sure.
1:00:51 Isn’t it a little morbid that Dipper drew Star’s dead body in his new journal for his notes lol. He could’ve just drawn Star. But no he sat there and looked at her body and perfectly recreated it. When did he time to do that
Yeah, not even the DR cast weer that far. I mean they hade a stick figure representing the body but not to the point of recreating the exact way the body looked. What the heck Dipper!
It's morbid yes but I think it's what detectives etc sometimes used to do before cameras/photos to preserve crime scene details. They don't exactly have access to photos here so this is the best way of preserving details.
@lutethemage5053 Yeah regular detectives/police do that. It's just messed up for Dipper to do that. Since the only other murder case he solved prior to this, is of his wax uncle, and he didn't draw the body of the wax figure then. Plus Shuichi was a detective and he never drew the Corpse in exacting detail, his lab had those but Shuichi didn't draw them.
I got a lot of things to say here: 1: The wait was so worth it! The interactions between These many different characters were fun, the Story kept me infested and i just loved how it managed to keep a Balance between good comedy and serious story. 2: After this Video, i have a weird Feeling that gas will either become the REAL antag of the game, replacing cartman or become the one to Lead the class trials. 3: I think the culprit is mabel: Jenny had an Alibi for the murder, so this leaves only mabel. Plus it whould make narrativly sense for someone close to the hero to die so early in this type of story.
@@jessicasmith5655 the alibi was that she was with bubles and blossom all night together to Monokuma who was experimenting on them to weaken their powers
Except it's way too obvious to be Mabel. Plus, isn't it weird for her to discard the sweater and tab in her ultimate lab? She of all people would know how much it would stand out amongst the sea of bright pastel colours.
And it will be predictable and boring I have seen the same case in many more fan mades and is boring to see always the most relationship of the protagonist die boring
After unlocking my inner danganronpa nerd I think 1000% it's still Jenny but framed to be Mabel because of a few reasons, hear me out Star was called down to the cafeteria after the killer said "they finished up early than expected", which seems like a blanket statement but Star wasn't as a close with Mabel as she was with Jenny, and when you look at the evidence we have, the sweater from HER lab, she has a motive for murder, my bet was it was going to be a Jenny framing the murder onto Mabel BUT There's an inconsistency in my own logic and MAN THIS IS SO GOOD THIS IS BY FAR MY FAVORITE FAN DE
There are a couple fanfics with Jenny in the cast. One even had her as the culprit of chapter 2 where in a break from pattern involved a double murder.
Also I think that Jenny is being set up. If she was the culprit then she wouldn’t have hid it in the lab or anywhere else. She would have known anyone could open and find the message which established important information that wouldn’t otherwise be revealed. The More believable explanation is that somebody picked it up after she dropped it in the gym incident and found out they could use it to send star the message without incriminating themselves.
@@JadenExists I imagine that her being awake during that time while the other two were unconscious could create some doubt, but I don’t think it’s her either. It’s too obvious; if she was the culprit she wouldn’t have hid her phone where someone could find it and find the message. I think she dropped it during the event in the gym. That’s why the event in the gym is part of the truth buttons. someone must’ve found it and learned they could use it to set Jenny up.
I'm very glad that this is fully voice acted, since it's rare for fangans to do that.. but I think it adds a lot to the trial itself, and is very good for background noise. I use it for drawing so i've probably seen this trial like 12 times
I have a good feeling that it's neither of them and here's why: I believe during the gym fiasco Jenny lost her tablet and the culprit picked it up. Why? The way the message was typed to Star implies it was Jenny or the powerpuff girls, but they were busy with Monokuma at the time. Now for Mable it's more of a feeling that it's the big red herring this case, but the way she acted during the trial looks like she REALLY doesn't know what happened and is trying to find the culprit. I feel like it will point to her, but Dipper will save her and find the true culprit. There is the hair that the fiend threw up which was short, not long like Mable's and combined with the blood on the mask could very well mean that the culprit was bit enough to draw blood. (Though more probably, it could just be the mask was bit itself, but the culprit was bit through it still, so they have a small head wound!) I really feel this is the culprit pinning it on Jenny and Mable.
I mean... did you see Mabel's facial reaction at one point? 1:00:19 I get that she might have been overwhelmed by Dipper's explanation but what if she realized something at that moment?
@CheeseTheWhistle yeah I noticed it, but I really don't see what she could have supposedly figured out. How I see it, that was an extra reaction to make the scene look better and convey that basically nobody else is able to follow Dipper's logic so Monokuma has to jump in. But there does exist a possibility that could be true, just that it's not tied to that current topic but something else.
This is the most stylish, most creative Fangan I’ve ever seen. Everything from the style to the minigames to the character interactions just slap so hard
Spoilers: I do believe that the MonoKaller belongs to Jenny, but I don't think either she or Mabel made that text on it. It's likely just someone trying to frame either of them, Mabel most likely. The reason I believe the MonoKaller belongs to Jenny is because you need a thumbprint to access it, right? Well, Dib was able to do so no problem, which means this MonoKaller doesn't need one. And since Jenny is robotic, she practically has no way for her thumbprints to be analyzed at all. It also goes by the first part of the text, where it says, "We finished up earlier than expected." This would obviously have to be the killer tricking Star into believing that Jenny, Blossom, and Bubbles were done being depowered by Monokuma. Now then, the MonoKaller was indeed found in the yarn egg in Mabel's lab, that much is obvious. But I believe that's all a trap the killer wants us to believe. Anyone could have gotten in and out of Mabel's Ultimate Lab, where they took the spray paint, painted one of the big sweaters black, and hid the MonoKaller inside the yarn egg. Because it all happened in Mabel's Ultimate Lab means that the killer is likely trying to frame Mabel and drive us all down the wrong path. Furthermore, we know for a fact that both the black sweater and the ski mask were worn by the killer, correct? If you take a good look at the sweater, you'll notice how it is WAY too big for Mabel to fit in. It's unlikely that Mabel would use the black spray paint on a sweater too big for her, and commit the crime while doing so. The only three people tall enough to fit into one of those bigger sweaters is Jenny, Morty, and Star. Jenny was being depowered with Blossom and Bubbles all night long, so that gives her a solid alibi. And, obviously, Star couldn't have done it, as she would have no reason to go to Mabel's lab after getting that text, for who she THOUGHT was from Jenny. Which means that the only other remaining suspect is Morty. He knows a thing or two about portals, and has a bit of a temper. Furthermore, he's close to Star's height AND would have the easiest way of killing her with the knife. Thus, the only conclusion is that Morty Smith is the one who killed Star Butterfly. Sure, Mabel has a motive, but knowing her, I highly doubt she'd risk it if it meant sacrificing Dipper, especially due to how the "Mystery Twins" are always together. Plus, Mabel's pretty extroverted and similar to Star, so I would have to say its even MORE unlikely that Mabel would want Star of all people dead.
w theory I know Morty also stutters often, but I felt his reaction after pulling out his MonoKaller was “questionable”. as much as I also hate to admit it, I think Jenny may still possibly be the culprit. We can’t forget about the black liquid near Star that could be oil. I also suspect Jenny feeling sad Star was murdered was actually the guilt she felt when killing her.
I agree plus Morty has shown from time to time that he's just like his grandpa and is willing to easily throw Innocent/Guilty people under the bus as shown here: ua-cam.com/video/kBQpBCiS9Cs/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/9WGSdzhsxjU/v-deo.html, Plus let's not forget Evil Morty exists: ua-cam.com/video/7JXomLN8YUU/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/AHuRDYVpad4/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/PlLcZ5VRegg/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/Hc2qHFa6u1w/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/OA7jF9mD3PI/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/U2XjH27TWRc/v-deo.html and I know that he's a variant of our Morty but again it shows that he can be just as deadly should he grow tired of Rick's Bull S**t.
"HOLD IT" On the idea of that message being thought of as from Jenny it feels off. Yeah it could have been but wouldn't star have known something is up the moment she passed through blossom and bubbles room? She would have noticed they were gone and thought something was off. But I can see star as not thinking about it but it's just a thought. Also, I feel like morty has less a motive than Mabel would. Maybe I remember the scene wrong but Morty's motive was just Rick's portal gun on the floor. And morty seemed more concerned on how they stole one from rick, which I feel implies that he thinks rick is safe. Even with a temper Mabel has more of a reason to murder. She has been shown to be really brash like in the season final. She was pretty willing to give up the real dipper for a fantasy world with a fake dipper. Theres a chance she did it for waddles over dipper. To be fair Mabel could have glossed over alot of stuff which is why she hadn't thought about any of her placements like the hoodie. This is just an added statement of my opinion, love your theory still and I see it being plausible. I see mine having holes so if theres anything just mention it
You're actually on the right track with everything you've said regarding your MonoKaller theory, I've spoken at length numerous times in past videos why I firmly believe Mabel is the Killer and yes the MonoKaller plays a big role in that. Your theory about Jenny and the MonoKaller are based on very sound logic, Jenny's MonoKaller would naturally be the only MonoKaller that would only require a simple turn on switch due to Jenny being a robot, but I think THIS is the red herring. I've mentioned in the past how I think Jenny being Star's killer feels a tad obvious, I mean Star treated Jenny like her best friend, and Jenny seemed to like her too, and I just feel like the Killer turning out to be the Victim's best friend to be too predictable, making it less likely that Jenny is the Killer. I mentioned time and time again how I think Mabel is actually the Killer, and the MonoKaller is actually the reason I'm so firm on my stance. What if we consider the possibility that the MonoKaller is damaged? This COULD explain why Dib was able to turn on the MonoKaller AND why the person's ID was not shown when activated, and whoever it was that contacted Star, it had to be someone she considered a friend AND trusted, that narrows it down to Jenny, Blossom, Bubbles & Mabel. Not only that, but we already witnessed when exactly the MonoKaller was damaged, I think I might be the only person who caught it. Anyway; the MonoKaller that was discovered, despite the fact Dib was able to activate the MonoKaller by a simple turn on switch, which would incriminate Jenny, since every MonoKaller is activated via fingerprint recognition, something Jenny and by extension her MonoKaller wouldn't have since she's a robot, and even IF it was Jenny's MonoKaller, that still doesn't explain WHY Jenny's ID or name is not displayed anywhere in the MonoKaller, unless we consider the possibility that the MonoKaller is damaged. No more stalling; the MonoKaller was damaged by the BZT to the Principal's Office when Mabel attempted to enter, the BZT likely short-circuited the MonoKaller for a short amount of time, Dib even said as much when explaining what BZT does, however the BZT must have also left some lingering damage, like not needing fingerprint recognition AND why the MonoKaller's owner's name and ID is not displayed. Something else worth noting, if Jenny is the Killer, some decision she made wouldn't make sense if you think the perspective of a Killer. First off: the murder weapon, assuming the murder weapon is indeed the knife they found, why would Jenny of all people use a knife of all things? Jenny already has access to a wide range of weapons, even if downgraded by Monokuma, I doubt he would take away ALL her weapons. Plus I think its possible that Cupcake may have attacked our Killer, as it does seem strange to highlight a gooey crumple of hair, but if this is what happened, then Jenny couldn't be the Killer, she doesn't have hair. Finally there's the overall state of the kitchen, it's a bit of a mess, but a lot of it could be cleaned up and quite quickly if the Killer was indeed Jenny, I mean why wash the knife but leave the crime scene a complete mess? There's also the fact that when Dipper woke up, where was Mabel? Why wasn't Mabel in the nurses office watching over Dipper? Granted Maybe Monokuma wouldn't have allowed it, I think there was a rule that you can't sleep in any room but your own room, but I think Mabel would have been too worried about Dipper, Waddles and the Hostages to even sleep. Dib also brought up a good point, why wasn't Dipper targeted? Dipper was unconscious and alone in the Nurses Office, he would have an easy kill, that is unless we consider that Mabel is the Culprit, I don't think Mabel would have it in her to directly kill her own brother like that. The only two things I cannot make sense of is that message to Star, specifically the line you mentioned "We finished way earlier than we expected" the wording implies it's referring to Blossom, Bubbles & Jenny getting weakened by Monokuma, but then there's the line "We're cooking up another plan to get us out of here, and I need your help" the key word being 'I', but considering Star used her scissors to pass through 3 rooms, 2 of those rooms belonging to Blossom & Bubbles, but if Blossom & Bubbles had returned to their rooms, Star would have been spotted by them and likely questioned, but the fact this didn't happen, would mean Blossom, Bubbles & Jenny hadn't yet returned, thus Mabel had to have been the one to call Star out. As for the Ski-Mask & Sweater? Well I... have no idea how it aids us or how it connects to the case.
@@jeremiahbluehot4571I think that black smudge is black spray paint. Maybe the killer had to be small enough to fit in there. Obviously jenny couldn't fit I'm the cabinet. She would have a hard time getting out. Meanwhile mabel would fit in perfectly. Because when you are small you can fit into more places than meets the eye. Plus wouldn't a robot know to put the murder weapon back where it properly was after cleaning it? That's not the mindset of an AI. That is the mindset of someone rushing. Let's say you were up and you were late. Rushing to get things done. That fits with someone rushing. Not an AI
It's gotta be Mabel. Everything lined up too perfectly for it to be Jenny. The sweater, the fact that there is a reasonable explanation as to why Jenny doesn't have hers (She dropped it when fighting Monokuma) but none for Mabel, and the fact that the body seem to be dragged. With the amount of sheer strength Jenny has why would she even need to drag it and leave evidence when she can simply lift. Plus we found evidence in Mabel's lab. Mabel's the kind of ditzy person who would make MAJOR mistakes like this after killing because they panicked. And would Jenny really have sent a suspicious text messages right next to the superheroes?
Plus she hasn’t seem like she is hesitant to get the truth? If she made such a big mistake her body language with be screaming she did and dipper of all people would notice it
@@sailingthemwebslmao but wait... I have a theory... there is black smudges in the cabinet so mabel sat in there. Possibly making a mark so the large sweater would have acted like a dress
Well... I remember that chessy said that he was interested in make an sequel if this ends well... He haves already characters in mind.. So... Yeah, Timmy could definitely be an option that the far future
I can tell she's going to be the annoying type of person who lets everyone spend a large amount of time sorting through all the complex factors of the situation and then decides to bring up the one bit of info that they overlooked just so she can make everyone feel dumb while she acts all smug.
"Dipper's been doing most of the heavy lifting in this trial. Show him a little bit of respect" Aw Jenny standing up for Dipper was really sweet, it's moments like these that have me hoping and praying Jenny isn't the Killer, I'll be devastated if she is, I want her to make it far so that we get more scenes with Dipper & Jenny, they have an adorable dynamic, and I mean that in a platonic sense.
I mean it makes more sense for her then Mabel. Mabel has dipper, and she was all about solving the murder, jenny doesn't know any of them, she have the most to lose.
@@Christian-gr3gu - If anything Jenny has the best motive to kill, I think most people would commit a murder if it meant saving a parent. Granted I stand by the fact that I believe Jenny is innocent, some pieces of evidence don't allign properly if we believe Jenny is the Killer. Just because Mabel has Dipper doesn't mean she wouldn't still sacrifice him to save Waddles, Mabel can be incredibly selfish and entitled at times in the show, often expecting others to give up what makes them happy for her sake, so while I couldn't see her killing Dipper directly, I could see her willingly sacrifice Dipper through killing someone else.
Half of Kyle's new sprites, like his previous ones, make him look absolutely adorable, and I love it. Only gonna make it hurt even more once he dies because I do not see that kid surviving this thing. Sigh. Ah well. Nice job with the trial so far, though, guys! Certainly took me by surprise a good few times, love when that happens.
I think we all know Dipper's innocent. He was knocked unconcious and had to rest in the infirmary for crying out loud. How could he have murdered anyone while incapacitated?
@@dragonman2168 well, finding out who didn't do it I as great step forward... Let's discard dipper who was knocked out. Bubbles trigger the body discovery announcement and also was getting nerfed.. The other two also have alibis.. Jenny couldn't done it becuse alibi, and also we know that the killer have hair thanks to the hair found in the skie mask... Gaz witness something impotmat, and she haves no motive. Kyle was talking to cartman and cartman went down to the dining hall.. He along with cupcake are the other two people who trigger the body discovery announcement, so get disqualified.. Many people say Mabel could be.. But she would never do it if it meant killing her own brother, that's stupid Unless self-defense.. So we can't completely rule her out.. Dib is helping investigate, so I really doubt.. Ed and eddy have no motive to care about double D, since they are not in good terms at the moment.. And also they wouldn't sacrifice one to save the other.. So.. Is not: 1dipper 2:bubbles 3blosom 4jenny 5: cartman 6cupcake(is I theory that I saw unironcilcly) 7 star 8kyle 9gaz 10ed 11eddy. Vendeta, Charlotte, morty and possibly dib Mabel and Zim could of..
@frangolles It's unlikely that Dipper committed the crime, I agree with that. Bubbles, Blossom, and Jenny all have alibis as they were getting "depowered" by Monokuma during the night. I know a lot of people suspect Mabel, but I have my doubts. For two reasons: 1. She wouldn't ever sacrifice Dipper for her freedom. 2. There's that huge black sweater in Mabel's lab that shows signs of being used and sprayed with black paint. Anyone could have entered Mabel's Ultimate Lab, so that doesn't point to just her. Plus, that black sweater looked pretty big for most of the cast. Only three people would be able to fit into it, being Star, Jenny, and Morty. I can't see what Star would want with a black sweater, and Jenny, as I said, has an alibi. So that means only Morty could be the one to fit into that sweater, which makes him my prime suspect. Bubbles was one of the three people who found Star's body, so that makes her double safe. Neither Dib, nor Gaz have a hostage, nor reason to want Star dead. Charlotte's too naive, though she could be easy enough to manipulate and trick into killing someone. We already know Kyle's innocent. And though Cartman SEEMS suspicious, well...... we all know how mysteries work. It's NEVER the one first accused or seems the most suspicious.
this is buchard but im tired and want to put this out there, Both mabel and Jenney are not the culprits its Ed and Eddy. Phone text- "Hey! We finished way earlier than we expected. We're cooking up another plan to get us out of here and I need your help before we reveal it tomorrow." We’re Cooking up another plan bit feels out of character for jenny and is implied that maybe there were more than 1 person meeting with star. They were able to use the phone since Jenney dropped it when avoiding Mookuma and since Jenny has no fingerprints her phone is free to use making Eddy the scam artist scam Star out of her life . 3 people to discover body- its stated a body discovery announcement will be played when 3 non-Blacked find it. Cupcake and Bubbles are known. And Cartman can't be it cause he never saw Star so it would be left with the killer and the accomplice. Black Hoodie and ski mask- the hoodie was mentioned that it was too big to fit Cartmen so it would assume someone tall can only fit in so that would be Jenney, Morty,Ed & Star. the hoodie would fit Ed’s hight and the ski mask blood would match with the head injury Ed gotten. Black Stain in cabinet and on star-wet spray paint on the hoodie. The killer was in the cabinet with the spray painted hoodie left residue under them and they popped behind Star lightly bumping behind her to stain their dress or in some other events she had to be hidden in the cabinet after being killed due to cartmen and she got the stain from in the cabinet. Hair ball-a red Herring as it could be just hair from Vendetta Knife placement-someone was in a rush or a big Dummy to leave the knife in the drawer wet rather than drying it and putting it back on the knife rack. Cupcake involvement- cupcake must have attacked the intruders which would end up wasting time and there wouldn't be much show of an attack due to the clothes being completely black. Blood placement- the way how blood is spread is not natural with a throat slit , no way blood would spread like that with a body dragged and could be a rouse of Mono sauce to try and pin the blame on Cartman, also with the sweater being clean in the end could be that they spray painted it again to cover up the blood. Why kill Star rather than Dipper?-to risky and there can be a chance of someone checking up on Dipper from time to time, star was easy cause they could get her faraway alone at night. What took them so long?-eddy had everything planned out but he didn't suspect Cartman and Ed’s stupidity to throw things off. Eddy was smart to put back the hoodie and the phone in mabel’s lab to pin the blame on her but did not suspect Ed to take the long route to the stair and to return the ski mask back in the storage room making dipper see ed’s shadow leaving. Also minor thing Eddy tried to accuse Dib and Gaz. @Flummarington did a better explanation/summary "What i think happened was Eddy got ahold of Jennys phone in the gym and came up with the plan, he spray painted a disguise for Ed to use and they hid in the kitchen cabinet together to wait for Star. After cartman makes his snack and leaves the kitchen, star arrives. Ed sneaks out of the cabinet behind her and grabs her so tight she can't move her arms and also smudges the back of Star's shirt with the spray painted sweater, and then he kills her. Cupcake sees this and attacks Ed prompting Eddy to come out of the cabinet, witness Star dead, and help restrain cupcake. As Eddy is holding her back Ed wastes time washing the knife and they leave, Eddy returns the sweater and dumps jenny's phone in the yarn ball, and Ed being the idiot he is, takes the long way around and returns the bloody ski mask back to the storage room."
So, i have a small theory. It's all right for you guys to judge me based on it but whatever. I think Morty is the culprit. Why simple. Everybody else was completely shown on the hostage screen but Rick was nowhere to be seen. All that was left was is portal gun... Even Monokuma made a weird comment about it. That makes Morty's hostage way more valuable than he realizes, Because he doesn't even know if Rick is really alive or not. That gives him much more unintensive to kill and try and frame someone else for it
That’s an interesting theory-I also think that maybe it could also be pointing to Morty being the possible mastermind and is actually one of the evil Morty clones from the show
Plus he has a good motive. I remember a comment in the class trial debate preview stating that could it be very well Multiverse Theory. Basically morty is taking a gamble to ensure his survival and victory.
The only thing that makes me suspicious of Morty is how he said "Star's no pushover", but how would he know that? He spoke as if he knows she's strong, but we haven't witnessed Star show off any real feats of strength, so why would Morty say "she's no pushover"?
@@JP_Loco_93 plus he was the one that suggest the body was dragged towards the kitchen and the kitchen wasnt orginally where the murder took place. Why would he even suggest that? Its obvious his "theory" is simply not true, pointed out by blossom.
Also, looking back on the evidence folder, Cupcake apparently coughed up a ball of hair, which most likely involved her attacking whoever came into the kitchen to kill Star. Unless I'm missing something, Jenny would be ruled off in this case since she doesn't have hair. Morty has been acting far more odd with his weird theories, and could definitely be more effective at murder than Mabel if it came down to it.
Everyone remember that episode of South Park, where Cartman makes someone eat their own parents and is able to predict every single move that he makes and that his own friends make I feel like we’re forgetting this I’m 90% sure if Cartman is alive to the end he’s the mastermind.
I'm not gonna lie, when I saw this premiere in my subscription, I dropped everything I was going to do. Homework be damned! 😂 I am super hype for this!!!❤
Okay wow, you blew this trial right out of the park, that ending left my JAW to the floor. SPOILERS AHEAD I'm gonna be honest i suspected Mabel for a while now and I personally think she's the first culprit. But goddamn what a twist ending, I really hope Gaz survives cuz she just became my instant new favorite character, even though I loved her originally with me being an OG invader zim nerd.
39:33 I like how Cartman is just having a mental breakdown over not being able to lie However at 1:00:13 look at Mabel's face. I dont think shes a killer, but i think she knows what happened and was quite literally a witness to the murder.
I've been waiting for this for over 2 years now (damn.) and gotta say, it's been a absolutely worth it, everyone did a stellar job in this, I can't wait to see where it goes now.
THEORY: I'm not sure if i missed anything, but the Monokuma file said the slice on Star's throat is "PRESUMABLY" the cause of death, so it's possible that she died a different way, and the throat slice was to throw everyone off the trail.
@@OwainGundy - String actually, not rope, and if she was strangled by string, that would actually make more sense, as rope would leave more obvious marks than string would. Then again they could've attacked her from behind, using the string to strangle her into unconsciousness, used that same string to tie her hands behind her back, and then slit her throat with the knife. Plus is it just me, or does the string look like someone's shoelaces?
Maybe the real cause of death is poison. After Star entered the kitchen, the killer gave her either poisoned food or a poisoned drink, and sliced her throat afterwards to make an obvious fatal wound. After all, if they saw her throat slit, why would they bother checking if she was poisoned?
A round of applause for this team putting together an awesome experience. Shout out to the voice cast for what you’ve done in bringing these characters to life, for lack of a better term.
WAIT! I just realized something about them scissors! If they can be used to phase through walls, then they could be used to phase through the door to the Principals Office.
So after watching the video, i came up some theories of who might be the culprit... And it might not be Jenny nor Mabel... 1: Jenny has an alibi. She is with the two Powerpuff girls due to their powers are being taken by Monokuma at that time... And i think that she might've really dropped her monokaller considering the scene at the gym when Dipper arive that day. It also gives the culprit the chance to steal it... 2. I also think Mabel is not the likely culprit. I mean, yes, she could've made that black sweater since her ultimate is related to that stuff... But isn't it's also a possibility that the culprit entered Mabel's lab and took one of the sweaters from the cabinet. then sprayed it with the black sprayer from the cabinet also?... The culprit might've also put the sweater back in Mabel's lab leaving it there after the murder to pin the evidence to Mabel... Mabel also says that she might've left her monokaller upstairs, so i think she might've left it in her lab. But what is she lied about that? What if she also lost it? Or more like... Someone stole it... I like to think when the culprit entered Mabel's lab, they saw Mabel's monokaller inside there... So what if they stole Mabel's monoksller and decided to leave the monokaller they stole from Jenny in Mabel's lab? To pin the evidence to Mabel?... 3. I think someone smart enough is the culprit. Someone smart enough to be able to alter some of the functions of the mystery monokaller. Like someone that can bypass the fingerprint function of the monokaller, like someone that can temper the monokaller making it barely useable except for messaging, someone that can hide their name/identity on the monokaller, including in the contacts... So my best bet of who's really the culprit is a nerd of science or technology and my guess is Morty... But i don't know... This is just a theory of mine... Yep, a Danganronpa theory!
My guess is actually Dib. He could’ve changed his Monokaller because it’s technology he’s familiar with, and he was the one who found the one that messaged Star in the first place. If Mabel’s MonoKaller was stolen, he could just present it and say it’s his, thus elminating him from the list of suspects and pinning even more evidence on Mabel, who he was clearly trying to frame in the first place. Plus, it’d get rid of one of the 3 invader zim (the only franchise in this with 3 players) characters, and also split up the gang that had already been forming between the Pines twins and the Membranes.
It is impossible that the culprit is Mabel or Jenny, there are two crucial pieces of evidence that prove it. Mabel is too small to wear the sweater and Jenny was undergoing surgery to diminish her power, not to mention that the blood on the mask may be the killer himself and Jenny is a robot. My theory is that the culprit is someone who has a Monokaller, however it is not his own, it is possible that the culprit stole one to replace the one he abandoned. If we get together with people who have some kind of alibi, we can narrow down the suspects. Jenny, Blossom and Bubbles were together with Monokuma. Kyle and Eric were arguing at the time of the murder, not to mention that Eric can't lie. Gaz and Dipper witnessed suspicious movements before and after the murder. The remaining suspects are: Zim, Dip, Ed, Eddy, Vendetta, Charlotte and Morty. Now, a tall person must be responsible in order to wear the sweater. Therefore only three of them are the most likely: Ed, Eddy and Morty. We can rule out Ed, well because he is Ed, he is not very smart to carry out a premeditated plan. So our main suspects are Eddy and Morty.
My guess is someone grabbed Jenny's while she wasn't around. Also, as you mentioned, the person needs to be taller, and most of the cast has at least one solid alibi per character. I have suspected Morty sense the beginning, but I do agree that Eddy is a pretty capable suspect as well. Best of luck in solving this stuff, though!
i think it's plausible that the culprit stole jenny's monokaller since it doesn't need a fingerprint to turn on, it's obviously jenny's, but the trial would end far too quickly if jenny were simply the culprit, plus, she does have that alibi.
I always knew this moment will arrive, great job team! And specially you chessy.. This is a great project and we all are so exited to see the fruits of your hard work
I got a feeling it could be the ed duo and here’s my essay on why: 1. They were in the gym when the commotion with Jenny and the PP’s happened, and so had a chance to take the monokaller 2. The monokuma files says “it is presumed the cause of death is a deep laceration” PRESUMED (we all know how monokuma love to screw around with vague things like that) so the actual cause of death could be strangulation (by hand) and then stabbing to cover up the strangulation, explaining the lack of bloodied hands 3. Scam artist Ed could replicate a SCAM message to send and dispose of the Monopod in the UL while muscle Ed stays downstairs to commit the crime directed by scam Ed 4.they got motive in the form of eddy 5. The very small amount of blood on the mask indicates that the culprit had blood on them before they put on the mask, as per muscle Ed’s head banging session. Muscle Ed is also big enough for the sweater, would explain muscle Ed being a goofball enough to put the mask back. Also the black stains could be wet paint where muscle Ed restrained star under the cabinet while Cartman was in the kitchen 6. If cupcake attacked the culprit, they would have been incredibly hostile to them once everyone was investigating, and the Ed’s never went into the kitchen and Muscle Ed has short hair. 7. Muscle Ed’s goofiness could explain why he washed the knife and didn’t put it back with the other knifes, a smart calculated killer like morty or Jenny would have immediately thought to dry and return the knife to cause more confusion So timeline: Muscle ed takes the sweater and mask and waits downstairs. Then Scam Ed signals Star using a fake message in Jenny’s format which lures star. He tries to dispose of the monokaller, maybe in a place downstairs but Kyle and Cartman block the path so that’s a no-go. He resorts to putting it in the ultimate lab instead. Meanwhile Scam Ed let’s Muscle Ed know that Cartman is going to the kitchen using their monokallers, so Muscle Ed restrains Star under the cabinet, staining the cabinet and Star until Cartman is gone. He chokes her to death with bare hands before being instructed to stab Star and move the body. Muscle Ed does that, cleans the knife lazily and neatly puts his cloths back after the South Park Bros leave. That completes the crime
I pieced together if the black sweater was too big for Cartman then it had to be Ed with the blood cap too. Also noticed Ed had a couple sharp moments which is uncharacteristic. Now if this is the case, would Eddy or Ed be the blackened? They had this dilemma in DR2 case 2. Is Ed the weapon used by Eddy? Or Ed decided to go through with it on his own
@@rndamas7082thinking about how the characters work, I believe it’s more likely that eddy got Ed to do the killing and is therefore the blackened, there were some things (like cleaning the knife) that Ed probably wouldn’t have done without the direction of eddy. But who knows? Maybe Ed was some secret mastermind or took some experimental food that made him much smarter?
I agree. I'm even more confident after watching this 1st half of the trial. Morty is so far acting the most sus. The first to be refuted by Dipper and he tries to brush off a lot of clues and clutching onto other people's theories that don't make too much sense. Leon did a similar thing in his trial, as well as Teruteru. Plus the culprit can't be Jenny or Mabel. Mabel isn't tall enough to fit into the sweater(they already proved so) and Jenny doesn't have hair that Cupcake could chew off. While Morty is both tall and has hair that Cupcake could've biten off.
Maple pine could have easily made the black sweater they say it was all of their first time seeing it she is known for making over size sweaters and the mono pad was found in her Lab she also has a motive and in the show has been shown to show some selfish side remember when she stayed in her dream bubble in the literal apocalypse
@@JamorrisTysonbut web that the pad was in her lab that could easy be an incrimination and I don’t think Mabel will do such a big sweater for her we now Mabel use oversize sweaters but in the class trial they said the sweater was big like big big
@@JamorrisTyson nothing proves she's the killer though. Yes, Mabel is selfish sometimes but she wouldn't sacrifice her brother, she's selfish not selfish centered(there's a difference) Besides she didn't know what the rift was and wasn't in the best mental state when that deal was made. Bill used that to his advantage. Plus Ford was the one to make the rift and chose not to tell anyone but Dipper, if Mabel knew of what the rift was she wouldn't have handed it over to who she thought was Blendin. Mabel and Jenny are red herrings, set by the true culprit and I will stand on that. There's no proof Mabel made the sweater(though I don't see a reason she would if she couldn't use it) and I don't see a reason she'd help the killer commit the murder(There's no proof that's There's accomplices this case)
@@JamorrisTyson The problem with Mabel is that Star died via strangulation. We need someone large enough to reach Star's neck and have the ability and willpower to pull off a clean kill. In regards to those factors, Morty is both the same height as Star and is one of the most lethal characters in the roster. [EDIT] In regards to the sweater, you must remember that it was only sloppily dyed black, and is not a piece created on the spot. Any character could have dyed it to blend in.
From what I seen, I think it’s Morty. I can’t exactly piece together on why, but I believe that with his portal gun, he took Jenny’s phone from her room and text it through there since Star was close with her so she would have trusted Jenny to meet her at the kitchen. As for the sweater and mask, the killer probably used them to keep star’s body concealed so no one can see her, especially how dark it gets at night. Idk, thats what I have for now. Also, can’t wait for part 2. 😊
Well, we know morty doesn't have his portal gun, becuse that is actually his hostage, but I still belive it can only be him.. He didn't have to use his portal gun, he had another way to create portal, the scissors... Or maybe he also haves an hidden lab like dipper were he have an spare one.. But I really like the idea of morty using star's portals becuse he is already pretty familiar at using portals. Morty did used the skies mask, but in himself, he hid star bodues in the cabinet... And took it out near morning.. I believe..
@@frangolles yeah, I was thinking he also could of use Star’s scissors since it would be more convenient. I’m not too sold on another hidden lab part but I see it as a possibility. Hmm, I’m gonna have to review the investigation video again, it been so long.
I have a theory that someone somehow stole Mabel’s monocaller and hoped someone called out that the killer is the one that is missing their monocaller. Mable actually being the killer would be disappointing because almost everyone predicted it and I want the pine twins to stick together at least until chapter 4
I sadly feel like Mabel's the culprit because the 1st motive were the loved ones of the characters being held hostage, one of them being Waddles. And we all know damn well how much that big chunk means to her.
36:51 omg crashbox ref hooray! Ok, the editing in this is absolutely phenomenal!! Like, the characters squash and stretch and bounce around like an average cartoon during trial discussion. And the mini games are very creative. The layout for the truth buttons is also very neat. In fact, the layout for everything is fun and interesting.
This series was way more funny than I was expecting. Like actual laugh out loud moments that caught me hecka off guard. What brilliant cartoon writing! ^^
Most people accusing Mabel or Jenny are probably falling into the creators trap rn. In murder mysteries when the killer can only be one of X amount of people, it's either none of them or all of them. Jenny using the (alleged) murder weapon knife when she probably has a plethora of built in weapons, the blood on the inside of the ski mask, the fact that the body was dragged when Jenny is still really strong, the fact that Blossom was probably with Jenny during the murder and hasn't spoken up, the small hair ball despite Jenny... you know, and the perfect opportunity to steal Jenny's Monokaller during the Gym Scene is all evidence that Jenny isn't the killer. Mabel helping the investigation and trial throughout without pushback, the oil/smudge in the empty cabinet, the too large sweater (large crease be damned), the fact that most of the evidence was found in her own lab, and the fact that making a super important character to the protag being the victim/killer of the first case is already overdone (Sayaka and Kaede) is all evidence that Mabel isn't the killer. If I had to choose between the 2 Mabel is more likely to me, however, I do have some theories. Throughout ALL of this Monokuma has never said that accomplices aren't allowed, which could come into play with two killers. Maybe Jenny and Mabel worked together or an entirely different pair worked in conjunction. Ed bashed his head against the wall until he bled, if he was the one to bleed inside the ski mask it would make sense. However, Ed is dumb, which means he could've worked with Eddy who was calling the shots and Ed didn't know what he was doing. Now that I think about it... Eddy as the ultimate scam artist would be able to silently steal from Jenny in the Gym and fake a text as her to lure Star. (I haven't watched his show so tell me if this seems out of character of him) Spreading the evidence all around and making it seem it's either Mabel or Jenny could be a tactic of misdirection. Eddy did (or at least in the cut accusal) accuse Dib and Gaz of making experimental foods to commit the crime. Maybe he's projecting? Another classic tactic. Maybe he gave smth to Ed to tie up the loose end of him confessing everything, maybe smth the opposite of Monosauce. The more I think about it, the more the Eddy theory makes sense, maybe there's smth i missed that disproves all this? Pls let me know lol
Something i just realized! We're now missing someone from body discovery announcement! Since we thought Cartman was one of the people, but if he never saw Star then who is the other person alongside Bubbles and Cupcake who discovered Star's body!?
I think I know what could had happen to that.. What if.. Enter someone who tried to kill star, they believed star was just asleep and stab her neck, but, they didn't know star was already dead?. That would mean there's someone who belive they are the killer, and that's why they haven't come forward with the information, but is actually just the fort one to find the body?
@frangolles maybe, though I'm not sure if that'd happen 1st ch. My theory is that the bda will help prove one of suspects innocence. Possibly Mabel, since Jenny has an albi Monokuma just needs to back it up, so if the bod helps one of them it'll probably be Mabel. I'm not sure why Mabel wouldn't say she found the body, though maybe someone(maybe the killer as well) told her come to the kitchen.(maybe a reason she left her monokalller behind) Or she came down to check on Dipper but ended up hearing something from the kitchen and went to investigate. Though it honestly could be anyone, I'm mainly thinking of how the bda would help in the trial. I feel if the bda helps in any way, it would be clearing one of suspects and getting closer to the true killer. That's my opinion though, we'll just have to wait and see.
I saw your comment last night, and it stuck with me for some reason, I finally have an answer! The Body Discovery Announcement only goes off when three non-blackened witnesses discover the body, we know Cupcake & Bubbles are two of the witnesses, Bubbles being the last. I originally thought Cartman was a witness AND tampered with the crime scene, this seems unlikely now, however Cartman had to have done something to earn Cupcake's affection, but even Cartman admitted that Cupcake wasn't in the kitchen when he arrived, which suggest the Killer must have moved Cupcake after killing Star, and having witnessed someone murder Star, that could explain why Cupcake has been so antagonistic. Also based on Cartman's confession, it seems nothing was out of place when he arrived in the kitchen, he said he didn't see Star, Cupcake or anyone else, but then this would imply the kitchen was not yet in a mess, but if so, the murder had to have happened in those 10 minutes before the deadline, but if Cartman was in the kitchen from say 12:00 to 12:10 (Kyle said they argued for a good 10 minutes), maybe Morty was right about the body being moved, Zim also suggested Star's hands were tied up and that actually tracks with the string that Dib found in the trash in the hallway, AND explains why Star didn't clutch her slit throat. My guess is that Star was killed between 11:50 & 12:00, her body was then moved, perhaps shoved and hidden in the cupboard, however the Killer could have hidden in there too, which would explain the black smudge, but I doubt both the Killer & Star's body could fit into that one cupboard. Also regarding Cupcake, it's possible the Killer attempted to move Cupcake but was attacked, thus the gooey crumpled up hair AND why their was some blood inside the mask, only issue is, why would the Killer not have been wearing the Ski-Mask in that moment? Anyway the Killer must have hastily cleaned up the mess before Cartman arrived, which means the 'blood trail' and the knife must have been pieces of evidence added later, since Cartman never mentions the state of the crime scene, and if the Killer had attempted to move Cupcake, thus startling her, Cartman might have seen that Cupcake was distressed, and Cartman having a soft spot for cats, must have calmed her down, maybe giving her some food and patting her, hence why she's so affectionate toward Cartman, but if Cupcake had seen the Killer without the Ski-Mask, that still does not explain why Cupcake is so antagonistic toward everyone else. Whatever the case, the 'blood trail' which I still believe is Monosauce, the knife, the string, the MonoKaller and Ski-Mask, all must have been later additions to the crime scene, since again; Cartman didn't mention the blood trail, the knife was still wet by the time Dipper & Dib found it, we know the String & Ski-Mask were discarded around the same time since Dipper witnessed a shadowy figure enter/exit the storage room, they probably hid the MonoKaller in Mabel's Ultimate Lab around that time as well, keep in mind; Dipper woke up at 12:20, meaning our Killer had just 10 minutes to manipulate the crime scene, wash the knife, discard the MonoKaller, String & Ski-Mask, also I just realized; the 'string' looks a lot like shoelaces. Turns out I might be wrong about Cupcake NOT being hidden and Cartman gaining her affection like I suggested he did because Cartman admitted he didn't see Cupcake, but then how did Cupcake end up back on the kitchen counter? Damn it! Just when I think im onto something. Maybe Cupcake was always affectionate toward Cartman and we just never witnessed it, Cartman has always had a soft spot for cats in the show. Given everything we know, this means; that the murder happened between 11:50 & 12:00, Cartman was came into the kitchen but saw no sign of Star, Cupcake or anyone else, it's also safe to say there was no crime scene by this point. Thus Star's Body & Cupcake must have been hidden before Cartman arrived, the Killer must have also cleaned up whatever small mess they made before Cartman arrived too, then once Cartman left, they had from 12:10 to 12:20 to add the 'blood trail', wash the knife? Honestly this could have done immediately after using them, finally the Killer discards the String & Ski-Mask, and hides the MonoKaller in Mabel's Ultimate Lab, however this could've also happened whenever, maybe even before the murder even occurred. The Killer was seen by Dipper likely as they were discarding the String & Ski-Mask, while the Killer was discarding the String & Ski-Mask, this is likely the only time someone else could have stumbled across Star's body, and Bubbles would then discover the body only minutes later, meaning Cupcake was the first witness, the second witness is unknown, and the BDA went off when Bubbles discovered the body, but why would the second witness be keeping quiet, especially with there being no chance of them being the Killer? Sorry my comment is so long, once I start theorizing & speculating, it's hard for me to quit.
@@lavenderrose82 - The only issue with dismissing Blossom, Bubbles & Jenny as potential suspects, or Jenny at the very least, is that Blossom & Bubbles apparently were put to sleep for the procedure, while Jenny admitted to being awake. There's also nothing stopping Jenny from simply telling Monokuma that she wants to commit a murder, Monokuma would immediately hault the procedure on her and allow her to go off and commit her crime. Granted I don't think Jenny is the Killer, everything pointing to her comes across as being more of a red herring than anything.
I have a feeling this is wrong, but is the begging of the Channel Chaser's segment (36:49 this intro) a reference to HBO's Crashbox where the show began the exact same way, with a TV falling out of the sky and landing on a podium (or whatever it was, I can't remember what exactly the TV landed on.)
So, this was the first I watched of any of this and I just wanted to say that it is INCREDIBLE all around! And, personally, it was relatively easy to get into the story and murder mystery even though I wasn't coming into this with context as it explained itself overtime! Very good writing!
kinda bugs me a little bit when people say that either Mabel or Jenny did it, but my heart tells me that it is probably Morty...which will be saddening, but it could also be Ed, since the mask has a drop of blood inside, and i am sure Ed hurt his head to the point of bleeding when he tried to break the walls in a few chapters back, so...i dunno, but it can't be Mabel or Jenny, but everyone's free to discuss on that!
Yes! I agree with you. And there's a logical reason for that... And i will explain it, in game mechanics! You see, remember how near the end of this part cheesy says there was a part that was cuted off? Were eddy accuses gaz and Dib? Well.. The pin comment left by him also mentioned fully what the idea was.. The minigame was called "the funbox" this minigame was based around two people getting accused at the same time, flying in boxes.. Dodging the other people's accusations.. And after dodging a little.. The protagonist makes an reffitable point.. The two suspects have to defend themselves with evidence against the protagonist.. The protagonist will make a total of 3 refutable remarks before ending the minigame... And yeah.. This minigame was cuted off this part.. We didn't get to see the membranes defending each other from suspicions. But... Don't you think the fun box concept is such a good concept that cheesy probably wouldn't just put it just once? Don't you think the concept of two suspects defending themselves is perfect for this situation? I will make this prediction, the next part will open up with Mabel's and Jenny's fun box.. And it will go like this: Dipper: "it really pains me to suspect you... But is true that the sweater and monocaller were found on your lab, that makes you a suspect Mabel" Mabel: "woah whoah, hold it right there, t-the green man over there said that the sweater was too big that just very few could fit in it, didn't he? I am too much of a shorty to pulled that off" Dipper: "well, taking the height consideration... I will have to suspect you Jenny" Jenny: "wait.. That doesn't make any sense, I have an airtight alibi, at the time of the murder I was getting my powers stripped away by monokuma at the time, bubbles, blossom and.. Even if it's weird, monokuma himself can testify about that right?" Gaz: "why are you wasting time listening to them dipper? Don't listen to their excuses.. Only them could had pulled off the murder, only them could had send the message! How can you explain the monocaller and the fact that both of you don't have one!?" Mabel: "well.. If we go from. The terms of saying that we aren't the killers then... That means someone stoled our monocaller right? That monocaller is one of ours.. But that doesn't mean we killed star.. Jenny:" B-but, I left mine in my room, there's no one who could had taken it!" Mabel:"inside your room?.. Well, then. I think I might know what could had been used for that.." Jenny: "n-no..." Mabel: "star's scicors... She was the only one who could had taken anything from anyone's room"
The culprit has to be Ed, with Eddy working as an accomplice and the one who hatched the plan. The main reason for this is what was said at the very start of the trial, Stars hands are clean meaning either instant death or restraint. Who is strong enough to hold down someone so they cant fight back at all? Additionally, who would be dumb enough to spend time WASHING the murder weapon and leaving it to dry instead of just taking it with them to their room. This would also explain why the killer took the time to return the ski mask to the storage room and basically do a whole lap around the first floor. Because he is dumb and returning the bloodstained ski mask makes the most sense to him. I saw someone else bring up a theory that cupcake attacked the killer leading to the small amount of blood on the mask and the hairball, this would also align with the timeline assuming Ed spent about 10 minutes tussling with the cat that would be enough time for cartman to finish eating and for Ed to return the ski mask just before 12:20 And the most damn9ng evidence of all is something everyone in the comments seems to have forgotten, the 3 witness rule. Bubbles was the third witness and was the one to trigger the announcement and cupcake obviously had to be a witness too. The rules state that the culprit doesnt count as a witness and cartman really didnt see anyone so that means there has to be at one more "innocent" person involved. What i think happened was Eddy got ahold of Jennys phone in the gym and came up with the plan, he spray painted a disguise for Ed to use and they hid in the kitchen cabinet together to wait for Star. After cartman makes his snack and leaves the kitchen, star arrives. Ed sneaks out of the cabinet behind her and grabs her so tight she cant move her arms and also smudges the back of Star's shirt with the spray painted sweater, and then he kills her. Cupcake sees this and attacks Ed prompting Eddy to come out of the cabinet, witness Star dead, and help restrain cupcake. As eddy is holding her back Ed wastes time washing the knife and they leave, Eddy returns the sweater and dumps jennys phone in the yarn ball, and Ed being the idiot he is, takes the long way around and returns the bloody ski mask back to the storage room.
I have the same theory as you but put the killer as Eddy. The main question will be how can they tell which is the killer or accomplice? Seems like a coin flip
All things considered, I think the plan is similar but Eddy was the killer rather than Ed. I'd imagine Eddy would throw Ed under the bus if the latter was the one to kill. But Ed was seen with the body, prompting Cupcake to attack. The main difference being Ed would be easy enough for Eddy to manipulate into thinking they'd both walk, when in reality only Eddy would escape if he wins the trial.
For some reason I still feel like it was Ed The oversized sweater, the blood on the inside of the hat? Ed was literally bleeding from his head. Anyway it sucks getting into a series like this that isn't finished yet because now I have to wait forever to see more
Loving every second of it. Although a small recommendation for part 2? Pitch up Kyles's lines so it sounds more in tune with the show? Because while Eric's voice actor can nail it, I feel like Kyle's voice actor can't.
Nobody gonna talk about the fact that Zim’s likely to die next in Chapter 2 because he made the first rebuttal against the protag (like Mahiru and Ryoma).
SPOILERS!! : Gaz jumping in and trying to clock Dipper pissed me off, because girl. You waited THAT long, complain about your time being wasted, when YOU could have EASILY asked everyone to whip out their Kallers, weed out the suspects, and then the trial would have been as easy as that?? Omfg do NOT be a Kokichi Ouma for the love of us all. Also I was OH SO THANKFUL when I found out Bubbles & Blossom were innocent.. but I get the feeling that they won't be so innocent later on down the lines. Also, if Star was killed before she could even react, I feel like it'd be Jenny. Though, we have seen Mable sacrifice an entire town just for her own gain ( Weirdmageddon ). But I don't think Mable could reach that high to slit Star's throat, it seems more plausible if it were Jenny, especially since she came into the beginning of the trial feeling guilty and attempting to confess something. There's more logic pointed towards Jenny, rather than Mable. Although, if anyone wants to discuss this and leave a theory, I'd love to see it! :3
Yeah idk why she is getting upset over. She should be the last person talking trash. Being a detective investigating a murder within a time limit and told to solve it in another time limit isnt easy Plus wasnt she literally asleep during the whole investigation. She literally been complaining about wanting to leave till she mentioned the monotalker.
EXACTLY. Everyone else had been talking and speaking their mind, including her own BROTHER. Your brother, Dipper, and Blossom did most, if not, all the main talking during the trial. Blossom literally had to come up with a place to start just to kick the trial off, and then you have the utter audacity to go ahead and start shit talking everyone. Girl go back to sleep, you did genuinely nothing good besides side eye Dipper with your Tootsiepop headass. 😭
I hate people like that. They try to act all smart because they noticed one little thing, yet they don't say shit when it's needed. Like, as soon as you realize something you should speak up. Don't fucking wait nearly an hour or so and then talk shit like you're the smartest person here. Something tells me she's gonna be doing that a lot. Withholding info that she picked up while she lets everyone sort through all the hard stuff, then she'll come out with the simple things just so she can make everyone feel stupid. And you just know that this is gonna affect Dipper's confidence. He's gonna be doubting himself and questioning his abilities, which will make things harder down the line.
SAMEEE IT LIKE GIRL YOU COULD'VE DONE THAT FROM THE GET GO AND WASTE NO ONES TIME THAT'S ON YOU and she didn't even investigate and people think she gonna be mvp of the trial while I'm like BRO DIPPER LIGIT IS DOING THE CARRYING OF THIS TRIAL I'm with my girl Jenny
Okay so- I don’t think it’s either Mable or Jenny. Mostly because the monocaller is broken (and since the trial is split up into parts, it’s a little too early to call in the killer). Why is the monocaller being broken proves their innocence? Well- I stole this theory from someone in the comments of a different video. The killer gave Cupcake the monocaller which broke it, allowing them to access the caller without needing to sign in. They used it to hide their identity. However, if it does get proven to be either those two, then it has to be Mabel (unfortunately, that’s the last person who I want to see die, but tropes exist for a reason. And Dib is definitely the support). Reasons: Jenny has an alibi and the sweater is something she would definitely use. However, the cons is that the sweater has been labeled as BIG. Big as in “most people can’t fit in it” the killer could’ve used an oversized hoodie which fits with Mabel’s character, but still- from how it was described, I’d say Ed, Jenny, Star (rip), Morty, or someone I forgot would’ve been able to fit. Also, Mabel helped during investigations and the trial, why would she do that if she was the culprit? Did she regret it? Does she want to get caught? Regardless, this an amazing series that is high quality in every little thing. Can’t wait to see if Mabel is proven innocent (Please. I don’t want her to die)
Finally, it’s here!!! I remember that when they mentioned the MonoKallert thing, I was like “Cool, make everyone take theirs out.”, but it was brushed off so quickly that I actually abandoned my original idea! Clever, really. I’m still really confused over how Star was killed at the same time Eric was cooking. It’ll probably be explained in details later, but if it already was, I really didn’t catch it 😅 Now, I have to remark the humor in this. Incredibly creative and loved the forth wall breaking. Had me rolling. I’m here to support til the end of this project. I know as a perfectionist myself that ambition doesn’t always work well with that trait, but let me just say that you’re doing great. Keep going
@@nobodys_here07 Sounds like a good idea. What’s troubling me is that Cartman was there from 11:50 til 12:10, and Dipper saw a shadow during 12:20, so the culprit killed Star between those hours, right? Cuz I think that in one moment they mentioned that Star must have been killed during another period or smth like that, I don’t remember correctly
@@firopi7901 Here's how I see the timeline of events: Before 11:50: The culprit began to set up all the necessary tools needed to pull off the murder. Including Jenny's tablet which they swiped from her during the second motive. 11:50: Star went to the kitchen and met up with the culprit . The culprit ambushed Star and incapacitated her immediately so she wouldn't fight back. And since there are no other visible wounds, I'm inclined to believe they used cleaning supplies to create chloroform. They then heard someone coming a few minutes later and hid inside the kitchen's cupboard until Cartmen left. 12:10: They then proceeded to grab a nearby knife and slit Star's throat, hoping that they made it in time before the motive's deadline. 12:20: The culprit began hiding/implanting evidence.
@@firopi7901 By process of elimination: - Jenny and the Powerpuffs were being depowered - Gaz and Dib don't have any motives - Mabel seems to be a red herring since even she wouldn't be dumb enough to hide incriminating evidence in her own lab (plus the fact that Dipper would've been executed if she wins) - Eric and Kyle can vouch for each other That leaves: Zim, Ed, Eddy, Charlotte, Vendetta, and Morty However, I'm not inclined to believe Ed or Charlotte could perform something like this, and Eddy wouldn't murder anyone since it would put Ed at risk of getting executed via class trial. And if we go by the sweater, it'd probably be too big to fit Vendetta So it's between Morty and Zim The glue on the table storage room reminded me of Zim's weakness to water. As his alien biology couldn't handle getting wet, he applied a layer of glue on his skin which was able to protect him from water. And since we know the knife used was washed, it's possible Zim is the culprit. However, I forgot if Dipper commented on whether the glue was used or not so if it wasn't used, then it's Morty.
Alright my fello detectives we are close to solving this mystery. The blackeneds are either mabel or jenny and to solve this mystery we will have a evidential discussion basically were discussing evidence about each person that could prove theyre the killers anyone can give a piece of evidence but do point out which piece of evidence is pointing to whom. With that ill start the monokaller was inside of mabels ultimate lab inside her giant yarn ball its assumed nobody except dib could cut through it but theres another person who couldve possibly cut through the yarn. Jenny could have done it because of her pick tails since shes made of metal her picktails couldve been very sharp and when dipper said he heard footsteps he couldve heard jenny because again shes made of metal and robots trying to sneak around wouldnt exactly work well.. since her feet are made of metal they would obviously make noise with those peices of evidence it makes me think that jenny is the blackened.
@@Braylon.Hargrave maple is also suspicious she could have easily made or dyed the sweater using her Lab she also could've hid her mono pad in the yarn it is her Lab and she said she left her mono pad in her room why would she do that if she did she wouldn't be able to get back in
I don't think Mabel is the killer. The monopad was found in her lab not to mention the ski mask and sweater also came from her lab. It would be too obvious for Mabel.
My guess is that the murderer probably stole either Jenny or Mabel’s MonoKaller to send the text. Probably Gaz. Another thing the trial hasn’t discussed is how the killer also got out of their room without being seen along with Star. Deb probably was not actually asleep, but was waiting on Star and went through the portal with her to go to the kitchen together.
i agree, just because in order for mabel to get away with it, dipper would be killed w/ everyone else. would she really kill her own brother for this? doubtful
HELLO, I hope everyone enjoyed!
A few things!
The fan art credited to Ninchu is actually by StylishFish, my mistake!
Also, as promised, here's the missing dialogue:
Eddy: “Remember how Cartman got a weird, supernatural side-effect from using the Monosauce? You guys said there were even more items like that with weird effects, right?”
Dib: “Yes, there’s hundreds actually. Though I’m not sure where you’re going with this.”
Eddy: “Jackpot! Then here’s the way I see it:”
Eddy: “The killer ordered another item from that microwave. One that could turn them invisible!”
Charlotte: “Oooooo, more magic!”
Eddy: “That way, they could get the drop on Star and avoid being caught!”
Jenny: “I don’t know. Doesn’t that explanation seem a little…too convenient?”
Vendetta: “Use your head, stumpy one! There is no invisible food in the kitchen. We would have seen it during the investigation!”
Eddy: “Well, duh, of course you didn’t see the food. Because they ate it!”
Mabel: “GASP!”
Eddy: “With all the crazy things we’ve seen so far like magic portals and truth-telling ketchup, it ain’t that hard to believe. The killer left behind all this evidence, but ate the one piece of evidence that would’ve linked them to this crime. That would be whatever mystery item can cause a guy to turn invisible! Maybe even slipped Star some too after they killed her so she could be hidden from butterball over there.”
Dipper: “But we already know the killer used a black sweater and ski mask to hide in the darkness of the cafeteria. Why prepare this as well?”
Mabel: “Maybe as a backup plan? If they were spotted by someone, they could’ve turned invisible to keep them from figuring out who they were by their body shape!”
Dib: “This idea is ridiculous! The Monosauce was the only experimental item that was even on the list! You need a code for the rest of them and the only people who know even a few of those codes are Gaz and I!”
…
Dib: “Huh? Why is everyone looking at me like that?”
Gaz: “...”
Dipper: (Inner thoughts) Agh! And why is she looking at me like that?!
Eddy: “Ha! Caught like a mouse in a rat trap!”
Charlotte: “Then…did they eat the cheese?”
Ed: “Invisible cheese?!”
Cartman: “Well, I’ll be damned. That’s a pretty neat twist.”
Jenny: “Wait, so if this theory is correct…then it has to be one of the Membranes…”
Bubbles: “T-that can’t be true…can it?”
Dib: “...”
Gaz: “...”
Dipper: “Guys, what are you doing? You have to defend yourselves! If you don’t, then everyone will think-”
Monokuma: "DEFEND, YOU SAY?"
Monokuma: “Oh what a twist of fate. All eyes are locked on just two people! And they don’t know how to defend themselves? That just makes this all the more exciting! Monokuma and Hope’s Peak Academy are proud to announce our newest game of torture…”
…
Monokuma: “...The Funbox.”
Explanation:
Funbox, oh Funbox. Small and square and dark. Looks like Dib and Gaz have been put into the hot seat thanks to an interesting theory. Now they’ll be forced to defend themselves against everyone else! In this segment, you’ll actually get to play as whoever is locked in the Funbox. You’ll control the Funbox by moving it up and down. Dodge opposing arguments and statements that come your way until Dipper comes in with a golden statement. Once he does, you can choose a Truth Button to prove him wrong! Do this three times and suspicion will be off of you. Got it? Alright! Let’s get it!
[Gameplay]
Dipper:
- “Neither of you have an alibi for the time of the murder…”
TRUTH BUTTON USED: Gaz's Account
Dib:
- “We established that Star went through Gaz’s room purely through Gaz’s statement. That means Gaz never went downstairs!”
Gaz:
- “It’s not like anyone else has an alibi either. There’s like, what, 5 people that’ve been cleared so far?”
[Gameplay]
Dipper:
- “Dib has black hair! This lines up with the hairball we found at the crime scene!”
TRUTH BUTTON USED: Small Hairball
Dib:
- “The hair was dyed black by Cupcake’s stomach acid. That hair could belong to anyone, not just people with black hair!”
[Gameplay]
Dipper:
- “You two are the only ones who know about Memwave codes! If the killer was invisible, you’re the most likely suspects!”
TRUTH BUTTON USED: Black Sweater
Gaz:
- “This hinges on the existence of a snack that grants you invisibility, which has never been seen. Plus, it’s pointless.”
Dib:
- “The black sweater being prepared defeats the purpose of invisibility. Why would either of us create something to hide in the shadows, only to throw away that plan entirely?”
BREAK!
Ahhhhh... That would actually be really fun to watch, I personally think It would be "easy" to make, at least easier than you envisioned It to be. I can understand your limitations though
@@vitorgamesdaterrafinal5579 When you make most of the assets nothing is easy.
@@KairiMorin Understandable
Is it true that part 2 will be released in 2032, because I can’t wait that long
Please tell me you were joking when you said that part 2 would be in 8 years😢
Waiting for a sprite of Dipper during the trial where he takes off his hat and reveals he has an ahoge.
I mean that little stub was kinda an ahoge
Well, he did have an ahoge in his home series when he removed his hat.
*V3 flashbacks*
And the ahoge is also in the shape of the Big Dipper
the fact that he does actually have an ahoge
53:15 Im obsessed with the rebuttal animation, its so unique and charming
Same omg
@@_-drowsy-_we interrupt this program to bring you
Zim: *IMPOSSIBLE!*
And the rebuttal counter phrase and sprite also unique
can we talk about the fact that gaz told everyone to take out their phones and everyone, even cartman were like "wow it was that easy?"
But I bet they won't do the next logical step and have everyone turn on their MonoKaller to prove that it is in fact theirs, after all; just because the HAVE a MonoKaller on hand, doesn't mean it's theirs.
heck they should go a step further and show who was messaging who in the last 24 hours
@@JP_Loco_93 just have them use the killers monokaller to call someone else, and the name that pops up is the killer. why hasnt anyone mentioned that yet?
@@slimgrim3607 the UI dosnt show up so they cant do that
Its jennys monokaller because It doesnt need a fingerprint
@@faforito1651 but that logic it’s easy to assume someone stole it
Okay using the Courage The Cowardly Dog News fellas as a transition into an interruption has me rolling
Gaz: "Do I have to?"
Dipper: **"Y E S"**
GAZ: tf? how bro do that?
@@Blueartist246 Dipper: "Magic."
@@ultnovelist (himiko silently approves)
56:13
In midst of “it’s so over” I found there was within me, an invincible feeling of “we’re so back”.
After so long, we finally get the trail. It’s such a shame I won’t be able to watch this live since I’ll be at work.
Dw bro me neither 🤝
Cartman is basically kokichi
An asshole liar that despite seemingly being not that smart in the first trial after that he is WAYYYYY smarter than he looks and will pull the heavy lifting in the next trials
This is what happens if you toss miu and kokichi in the blender
Cartman: HEY! Don't compare ME to that lame twink ya a$@#%&$!
That’s why’s he’s perfect for this
Not really. He isn't a compulsive liar like Kokichi, nor is he lying for the betterment of the group. He's just a terrible person. Probably more similar with Byakuya.
@@floofycupkim1197 and give it Teruteru’s body type
“Go on, tell ‘em Nae-I mean-Dipper.”
Dipper has more personality than that guy.
@@KingOfMumbles485...Shush don't diss my boy naegi like that
@@AndyCr4ftYThe’s right makoto has the personality of wet cardboard
@@Sijinxand no character development..
@@Sijinx*dry
"Shhh, were reading the rules right now, Eddy... "
"Reading the WHAT?"
Dialogue : *STOP INTERRUPTING ME*
35:44 Fucking classic lmfao
Classic Eds
I fully believe Jenny was the one who had killed Star
First of all, I believe that Star was actually the one to wear the ski mask at the very least, and possibly the sweater, too
I mean, why would there be blood on the *inside* of the mask if we know Star didn't fight back against her killer, meaning they would have no reason to be bleeding. This does mean that Jenny can still be a suspect, despite not being able to bleed in the ski mask
Now, my biggest reason for believeing it was Jenny is everything surrounding the mysterious Momokaller.
First of all, given the tone of the person using the Monokaller, we can immediately rule out people like Morty, Kyle, Dib, Gaz, Vendetta, etc. The person using the Monokaller:
1. Knew Star well
2. Is portrayed as a friendly individual who speaks clearly
3. Was one of the people aiding in the attempts to escape
4. Was busy with something that went "quicker than expected"
Those last two details immediately point to Jenny, and the first two help solidify it, considering we know that Jenny and Star have been good friends up to this point
Next, what's really odd is how the Monokaller doesn't require a fingerprint to access. The only way that would make sense is if the person it belonged to doesn't have any fingerprints in the first place. Maybe a robot?
A few smaller details worth pointing out. The black smudges could easily be oil, Jenny has a clear motive considering her own mother is one of Monokuma's hostages, and, even if the costume was worn by the killer, she is one of the few people I could see it fitting
So far, the evidence seems heavily stacked against Jenny
Y'know, I noticed something peculiar...
The ones that interrupted Gaz were Mabel AND Jenny, both attempting to redirect the conversation somewhere else...
Is it possible the two of them worked together?
@@S1lliest_Beanz I dunno... an accomplice murder on the first case? That'd be kinda odd
@@S1lliest_Beanz I think that's just the game foreshadowing because,
Monokuma: "Daddy loves some foreshadowing"
I don't think so. While the evidence does point to Jenny, there's many things that don't add up.
For one thing, Jenny has an alibi. Assuming that she and the Powerpuffs were being depowered at the time the message was sent to Star, there's no way she could have sent it. Plus, the killer used a knife to slit Star's throat. Why would Jenny kill Star with such a mundane weapon when she could have used one of the weapons she has built into her? Of course, we could say she can't access them due to being depowered by Monokuma, but who's to say she can't still access some of her weapons. Assuming that she has little things like knives and stuff in her body, why not use that instead of the kitchen knife?
And there's also the fact that the killer wore a black sweater and ski mask. Why would Jenny bother wearing a disguise if she was going to meet Star? Star would already know who she is, so there'd be no real point. And again, she's a robot, so if she got any blood on her, she could just wash it off. Why wear something that could easily be stained?
And there's the fact that Cupcake clearly attacked the killer, if the blood inside the ski mask is anything to go off of. The fact that it's on the inside means that it's likely the killer suffered an injury to their head, likely as a result of being bitten by Cupcake. Jenny is a robot made of metal and bolts, not a flesh and blood human, so she wouldn't even bleed at all, nor would she leave behind any of the hair which Cupcake had in her stomach. The damage would have been obvious too; Jenny would be missing a chunk out of her head.
There's also the fact that Jenny and Star seemed to be close with each other. Not like super close best friends or anything, but it's clear that Jenny cared about her, so I doubt she would have been able to craft a plan to kill Star very easily without being heavily conflicted.
My theory is that Jenny is being framed by whoever the real killer is. They stole Jenny's Monokaller during the gym scene, then while she and the Powerpuffs were being depowered, the killer texted Star and lured her downstairs.
@@jorienwachukwu466 Wait if what you said at the last part is true. Then it doesn't matter on who didn't bring the Monokaller, so everyone (except some) could be the murderer now (which means back to square one)
I'm calling it now, it's Mabel. I'm gonna operate off of Danganronpa 69 logic right now and say it's Mabel. For no other reason other than I read Danganronpa 69.
What a sigma bro
that’s a pretty good reason
Logically it fits. The first case would feel pretty weak without an important or unexpected death.
DR, DR2, DR3, and DRV3 all followed that trend and it’s what helps leave a strong impression.
The only characters close enough to Dipper would be Mabel, Dib or maybe Gaz. Both of the two Membrane siblings have been cleared. That just leaves Mabel.
They also found the black sweater in Mabel's place
@@eladi7636 You're forgetting about the details hidden within some of the evidence that Dipper presented.
I really like how Bubbles stands between Kyle and Cartman and interacts specifically with Cartman. But at the moment when it is necessary to show the monopad (sorry, I’m used to calling it that) Kyle was so cutely proud that he brought the monopad with him and the Bubbles next to him was also so cutely proud of it❤
Thank you all for 100K views in just 10 days, that's never happened before 😭 I'm very thankful for the support and attention this series has been getting as of late, it's been wild
Congrats on the 100k views, keep up the good work! Your series is extremely underrated and definitely deserves more views
awesome stuff bro cant wait for part 2 but where is the bloody gir dude
The Trial is the most interesting part, and I'm aware that a lot of people enjoyed it. You got all eyes on ya, lots of people will be present when the next part comes out for sure.
WE ARE (kinda) SOLVING THE CASE WITH THIS ONE
Edit: Time to wait 8 years
i pray that was a joke
Nah, more like 10 years, so see you in 2034
cya in 10 years
@@mingotproductions1335Same here, but I feel like the second part is gonna release around next month or September
Zim is next victim, the first who makes a rebuttal showdown always dies in the next chapter (Mahiru Koizumi and Ryoma Hoshi)
It will hurt be who would killed him I wonder.
"Your reasoning is out of focus!"
"The fog has lifted."
Rip to my boy Ryoma.
But then again, this isn't a Rebuttal Showdown, it's Channel Surfing. Here's hoping that the rules work differently now.
If Zim is a victim, I see Gaz or Dib as a culprit.
1:00:51 Isn’t it a little morbid that Dipper drew Star’s dead body in his new journal for his notes lol. He could’ve just drawn Star. But no he sat there and looked at her body and perfectly recreated it. When did he time to do that
While being an atom I think?
It is kind of messed up now that you mention it....
Yeah, not even the DR cast weer that far. I mean they hade a stick figure representing the body but not to the point of recreating the exact way the body looked.
What the heck Dipper!
It's morbid yes but I think it's what detectives etc sometimes used to do before cameras/photos to preserve crime scene details. They don't exactly have access to photos here so this is the best way of preserving details.
@lutethemage5053 Yeah regular detectives/police do that. It's just messed up for Dipper to do that. Since the only other murder case he solved prior to this, is of his wax uncle, and he didn't draw the body of the wax figure then.
Plus Shuichi was a detective and he never drew the Corpse in exacting detail, his lab had those but Shuichi didn't draw them.
39:42 Love how Cartman reacted to himself telling the honest true by force!
That part was so funny
I got a lot of things to say here:
1: The wait was so worth it! The interactions between These many different characters were fun, the Story kept me infested and i just loved how it managed to keep a Balance between good comedy and serious story.
2: After this Video, i have a weird Feeling that gas will either become the REAL antag of the game, replacing cartman or become the one to Lead the class trials.
3: I think the culprit is mabel: Jenny had an Alibi for the murder, so this leaves only mabel. Plus it whould make narrativly sense for someone close to the hero to die so early in this type of story.
But what is the alibi?
@@jessicasmith5655 the alibi was that she was with bubles and blossom all night together to Monokuma who was experimenting on them to weaken their powers
@@Quelis-mz5ge but Mabel as the culprit would be too obvious,I think it's Morty as he was strange during the first part of the trial
@@matthewfuyukawa His plan is super smart, nobody suspects him at all and they are about to blame Mabel
Except it's way too obvious to be Mabel. Plus, isn't it weird for her to discard the sweater and tab in her ultimate lab? She of all people would know how much it would stand out amongst the sea of bright pastel colours.
Mabel being a main suspect, I think Dipper is absolutely going to lie to prove his sister innocent in part 2, calling it now. Perjury moment is coming
And it will be predictable and boring I have seen the same case in many more fan mades and is boring to see always the most relationship of the protagonist die boring
@@Bunny200x5 r u a only child?
I could see it being Jenny actually, that weird interruption is a bit suspicious
@@Bunny200x5Ok asshole then don’t watch it💀
Also, why would Mabel leave her Monokaller semi broken in her own lab?
55:15 I will forever appreciate any Kick Buttowski reference that gets shown. So glad people still remember that show to this day.
36:52 am I not the only one who wants to see each channels conversation fully or...
Nah my dude, I'm also curious about it lol
After unlocking my inner danganronpa nerd I think 1000% it's still Jenny but framed to be Mabel because of a few reasons, hear me out
Star was called down to the cafeteria after the killer said "they finished up early than expected", which seems like a blanket statement but Star wasn't as a close with Mabel as she was with Jenny, and when you look at the evidence we have, the sweater from HER lab, she has a motive for murder, my bet was it was going to be a Jenny framing the murder onto Mabel BUT
There's an inconsistency in my own logic and MAN THIS IS SO GOOD THIS IS BY FAR MY FAVORITE FAN DE
There are a couple fanfics with Jenny in the cast. One even had her as the culprit of chapter 2 where in a break from pattern involved a double murder.
Also I think that Jenny is being set up. If she was the culprit then she wouldn’t have hid it in the lab or anywhere else. She would have known anyone could open and find the message which established important information that wouldn’t otherwise be revealed. The More believable explanation is that somebody picked it up after she dropped it in the gym incident and found out they could use it to send star the message without incriminating themselves.
The issue is that Jenny was being depowered at the time of the incident. So it can't be her.
@@JadenExists I imagine that her being awake during that time while the other two were unconscious could create some doubt, but I don’t think it’s her either. It’s too obvious; if she was the culprit she wouldn’t have hid her phone where someone could find it and find the message. I think she dropped it during the event in the gym. That’s why the event in the gym is part of the truth buttons. someone must’ve found it and learned they could use it to set Jenny up.
I'm calling it, the mastermind was Peter Griffin. The joke to get us to like and subscribe was not a meta joke, it was a clue
No, it was Homer Simpson!
No its belos
Quick! Think of a cartoon series where it was unexpectedly cancelled!! That must be the motivation….
@@The1andonlysharpshooter
Hmmm.
The only one that comes to mind is Grojband, so maybe Trina Riffin?
She does got Junko tendencies.
It was clearly Elmo guys
I'm very glad that this is fully voice acted, since it's rare for fangans to do that.. but I think it adds a lot to the trial itself, and is very good for background noise. I use it for drawing so i've probably seen this trial like 12 times
I have a good feeling that it's neither of them and here's why:
I believe during the gym fiasco Jenny lost her tablet and the culprit picked it up. Why?
The way the message was typed to Star implies it was Jenny or the powerpuff girls, but they were busy with Monokuma at the time.
Now for Mable it's more of a feeling that it's the big red herring this case, but the way she acted during the trial looks like she REALLY doesn't know what happened and is trying to find the culprit. I feel like it will point to her, but Dipper will save her and find the true culprit.
There is the hair that the fiend threw up which was short, not long like Mable's and combined with the blood on the mask could very well mean that the culprit was bit enough to draw blood. (Though more probably, it could just be the mask was bit itself, but the culprit was bit through it still, so they have a small head wound!)
I really feel this is the culprit pinning it on Jenny and Mable.
Morty, I am still looking at you as the killer, you are smart enough to do this!
This was my thoughts exactly. I've been looking at Morty the whole trial and really think it might be him.
I’m leaning towards Morty.
I mean... did you see Mabel's facial reaction at one point?
1:00:19
I get that she might have been overwhelmed by Dipper's explanation but what if she realized something at that moment?
@CheeseTheWhistle yeah I noticed it, but I really don't see what she could have supposedly figured out.
How I see it, that was an extra reaction to make the scene look better and convey that basically nobody else is able to follow Dipper's logic so Monokuma has to jump in.
But there does exist a possibility that could be true, just that it's not tied to that current topic but something else.
This is the most stylish, most creative Fangan I’ve ever seen. Everything from the style to the minigames to the character interactions just slap so hard
Spoilers:
I do believe that the MonoKaller belongs to Jenny, but I don't think either she or Mabel made that text on it. It's likely just someone trying to frame either of them, Mabel most likely.
The reason I believe the MonoKaller belongs to Jenny is because you need a thumbprint to access it, right? Well, Dib was able to do so no problem, which means this MonoKaller doesn't need one. And since Jenny is robotic, she practically has no way for her thumbprints to be analyzed at all.
It also goes by the first part of the text, where it says, "We finished up earlier than expected." This would obviously have to be the killer tricking Star into believing that Jenny, Blossom, and Bubbles were done being depowered by Monokuma.
Now then, the MonoKaller was indeed found in the yarn egg in Mabel's lab, that much is obvious. But I believe that's all a trap the killer wants us to believe. Anyone could have gotten in and out of Mabel's Ultimate Lab, where they took the spray paint, painted one of the big sweaters black, and hid the MonoKaller inside the yarn egg. Because it all happened in Mabel's Ultimate Lab means that the killer is likely trying to frame Mabel and drive us all down the wrong path.
Furthermore, we know for a fact that both the black sweater and the ski mask were worn by the killer, correct? If you take a good look at the sweater, you'll notice how it is WAY too big for Mabel to fit in. It's unlikely that Mabel would use the black spray paint on a sweater too big for her, and commit the crime while doing so.
The only three people tall enough to fit into one of those bigger sweaters is Jenny, Morty, and Star. Jenny was being depowered with Blossom and Bubbles all night long, so that gives her a solid alibi. And, obviously, Star couldn't have done it, as she would have no reason to go to Mabel's lab after getting that text, for who she THOUGHT was from Jenny.
Which means that the only other remaining suspect is Morty. He knows a thing or two about portals, and has a bit of a temper. Furthermore, he's close to Star's height AND would have the easiest way of killing her with the knife. Thus, the only conclusion is that Morty Smith is the one who killed Star Butterfly.
Sure, Mabel has a motive, but knowing her, I highly doubt she'd risk it if it meant sacrificing Dipper, especially due to how the "Mystery Twins" are always together. Plus, Mabel's pretty extroverted and similar to Star, so I would have to say its even MORE unlikely that Mabel would want Star of all people dead.
w theory
I know Morty also stutters often, but I felt his reaction after pulling out his MonoKaller was “questionable”.
as much as I also hate to admit it, I think Jenny may still possibly be the culprit. We can’t forget about the black liquid near Star that could be oil. I also suspect Jenny feeling sad Star was murdered was actually the guilt she felt when killing her.
I agree plus Morty has shown from time to time that he's just like his grandpa and is willing to easily throw Innocent/Guilty people under the bus as shown here: ua-cam.com/video/kBQpBCiS9Cs/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/9WGSdzhsxjU/v-deo.html, Plus let's not forget Evil Morty exists: ua-cam.com/video/7JXomLN8YUU/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/AHuRDYVpad4/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/PlLcZ5VRegg/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/Hc2qHFa6u1w/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/OA7jF9mD3PI/v-deo.html, ua-cam.com/video/U2XjH27TWRc/v-deo.html and I know that he's a variant of our Morty but again it shows that he can be just as deadly should he grow tired of Rick's Bull S**t.
"HOLD IT"
On the idea of that message being thought of as from Jenny it feels off. Yeah it could have been but wouldn't star have known something is up the moment she passed through blossom and bubbles room? She would have noticed they were gone and thought something was off. But I can see star as not thinking about it but it's just a thought.
Also, I feel like morty has less a motive than Mabel would. Maybe I remember the scene wrong but Morty's motive was just Rick's portal gun on the floor. And morty seemed more concerned on how they stole one from rick, which I feel implies that he thinks rick is safe. Even with a temper Mabel has more of a reason to murder. She has been shown to be really brash like in the season final. She was pretty willing to give up the real dipper for a fantasy world with a fake dipper. Theres a chance she did it for waddles over dipper.
To be fair Mabel could have glossed over alot of stuff which is why she hadn't thought about any of her placements like the hoodie.
This is just an added statement of my opinion, love your theory still and I see it being plausible. I see mine having holes so if theres anything just mention it
You're actually on the right track with everything you've said regarding your MonoKaller theory, I've spoken at length numerous times in past videos why I firmly believe Mabel is the Killer and yes the MonoKaller plays a big role in that. Your theory about Jenny and the MonoKaller are based on very sound logic, Jenny's MonoKaller would naturally be the only MonoKaller that would only require a simple turn on switch due to Jenny being a robot, but I think THIS is the red herring. I've mentioned in the past how I think Jenny being Star's killer feels a tad obvious, I mean Star treated Jenny like her best friend, and Jenny seemed to like her too, and I just feel like the Killer turning out to be the Victim's best friend to be too predictable, making it less likely that Jenny is the Killer. I mentioned time and time again how I think Mabel is actually the Killer, and the MonoKaller is actually the reason I'm so firm on my stance.
What if we consider the possibility that the MonoKaller is damaged? This COULD explain why Dib was able to turn on the MonoKaller AND why the person's ID was not shown when activated, and whoever it was that contacted Star, it had to be someone she considered a friend AND trusted, that narrows it down to Jenny, Blossom, Bubbles & Mabel. Not only that, but we already witnessed when exactly the MonoKaller was damaged, I think I might be the only person who caught it.
Anyway; the MonoKaller that was discovered, despite the fact Dib was able to activate the MonoKaller by a simple turn on switch, which would incriminate Jenny, since every MonoKaller is activated via fingerprint recognition, something Jenny and by extension her MonoKaller wouldn't have since she's a robot, and even IF it was Jenny's MonoKaller, that still doesn't explain WHY Jenny's ID or name is not displayed anywhere in the MonoKaller, unless we consider the possibility that the MonoKaller is damaged.
No more stalling; the MonoKaller was damaged by the BZT to the Principal's Office when Mabel attempted to enter, the BZT likely short-circuited the MonoKaller for a short amount of time, Dib even said as much when explaining what BZT does, however the BZT must have also left some lingering damage, like not needing fingerprint recognition AND why the MonoKaller's owner's name and ID is not displayed.
Something else worth noting, if Jenny is the Killer, some decision she made wouldn't make sense if you think the perspective of a Killer. First off: the murder weapon, assuming the murder weapon is indeed the knife they found, why would Jenny of all people use a knife of all things? Jenny already has access to a wide range of weapons, even if downgraded by Monokuma, I doubt he would take away ALL her weapons. Plus I think its possible that Cupcake may have attacked our Killer, as it does seem strange to highlight a gooey crumple of hair, but if this is what happened, then Jenny couldn't be the Killer, she doesn't have hair. Finally there's the overall state of the kitchen, it's a bit of a mess, but a lot of it could be cleaned up and quite quickly if the Killer was indeed Jenny, I mean why wash the knife but leave the crime scene a complete mess?
There's also the fact that when Dipper woke up, where was Mabel? Why wasn't Mabel in the nurses office watching over Dipper? Granted Maybe Monokuma wouldn't have allowed it, I think there was a rule that you can't sleep in any room but your own room, but I think Mabel would have been too worried about Dipper, Waddles and the Hostages to even sleep.
Dib also brought up a good point, why wasn't Dipper targeted? Dipper was unconscious and alone in the Nurses Office, he would have an easy kill, that is unless we consider that Mabel is the Culprit, I don't think Mabel would have it in her to directly kill her own brother like that.
The only two things I cannot make sense of is that message to Star, specifically the line you mentioned "We finished way earlier than we expected" the wording implies it's referring to Blossom, Bubbles & Jenny getting weakened by Monokuma, but then there's the line "We're cooking up another plan to get us out of here, and I need your help" the key word being 'I', but considering Star used her scissors to pass through 3 rooms, 2 of those rooms belonging to Blossom & Bubbles, but if Blossom & Bubbles had returned to their rooms, Star would have been spotted by them and likely questioned, but the fact this didn't happen, would mean Blossom, Bubbles & Jenny hadn't yet returned, thus Mabel had to have been the one to call Star out.
As for the Ski-Mask & Sweater? Well I... have no idea how it aids us or how it connects to the case.
@@jeremiahbluehot4571I think that black smudge is black spray paint. Maybe the killer had to be small enough to fit in there. Obviously jenny couldn't fit I'm the cabinet. She would have a hard time getting out. Meanwhile mabel would fit in perfectly. Because when you are small you can fit into more places than meets the eye. Plus wouldn't a robot know to put the murder weapon back where it properly was after cleaning it? That's not the mindset of an AI. That is the mindset of someone rushing. Let's say you were up and you were late. Rushing to get things done. That fits with someone rushing. Not an AI
It's gotta be Mabel. Everything lined up too perfectly for it to be Jenny. The sweater, the fact that there is a reasonable explanation as to why Jenny doesn't have hers (She dropped it when fighting Monokuma) but none for Mabel, and the fact that the body seem to be dragged. With the amount of sheer strength Jenny has why would she even need to drag it and leave evidence when she can simply lift. Plus we found evidence in Mabel's lab. Mabel's the kind of ditzy person who would make MAJOR mistakes like this after killing because they panicked. And would Jenny really have sent a suspicious text messages right next to the superheroes?
But with how careful this killer as behind why she leave evidence in her own ultimate lab?
Plus she hasn’t seem like she is hesitant to get the truth? If she made such a big mistake her body language with be screaming she did and dipper of all people would notice it
Tbh I agree that its mabel. Her hiding the black sweater amongst the others is definitely sneaky.
Honestly I can't see it being Mabel. If she's a suspect this early on, then she's a red herring for sure
@@sailingthemwebslmao but wait... I have a theory... there is black smudges in the cabinet so mabel sat in there. Possibly making a mark so the large sweater would have acted like a dress
I know the culprit, it was Timmy Turner. I am a great detective
Well... I remember that chessy said that he was interested in make an sequel if this ends well... He haves already characters in mind..
So... Yeah, Timmy could definitely be an option that the far future
No, you're wrong! It was obviously Eugine Crabs!
Objection! It was of course Crocker! His motive? FAIRY GODPARENTS!
hey don't really ruin surprising new people still watch it also they're swearing
LOL he's the 17th student laying beneath the school. Watch out for him.
Everyone being dumb
Meanwhile Gaz just knows the answer
"Everyone is stupid except me"
She’s gonna be the maki kirigiri of the group
I can tell she's going to be the annoying type of person who lets everyone spend a large amount of time sorting through all the complex factors of the situation and then decides to bring up the one bit of info that they overlooked just so she can make everyone feel dumb while she acts all smug.
@@jorienwachukwu466 she already does that in the show so that tracks
If zim dies his death would probably then be something with water
bro zim calling star an earth child hurts my soul, they coulda bonded over both being alieeens
55:15 YOU STAY OUT OF THIS DIPPY FRESH!!
(Did not expect to see him lmao)
Dude calm down dippy fresh didn’t do anything to you dawg
@@Hat_Man494I think it's a Gravity falls reference.
@@Случайнаясвечаyeah.
What they said was *also a reference*
@@Случайнаясвеча they are quoting what soos says after dipper
@@Bluekittencosplay Oh,sorry.
bro this is too good to be this low of views, the references, the dialog, the passing, the twists and flips its just like the games
True
It took too much time for updates.... People lost the interest.
@@korman5442 people just are too impatient for actual good and talented videos like this to come out
the way i said "OH MY GOD IT'S HAPPENING!!" when i saw this on my recommended
"Dipper's been doing most of the heavy lifting in this trial. Show him a little bit of respect" Aw Jenny standing up for Dipper was really sweet, it's moments like these that have me hoping and praying Jenny isn't the Killer, I'll be devastated if she is, I want her to make it far so that we get more scenes with Dipper & Jenny, they have an adorable dynamic, and I mean that in a platonic sense.
I mean it makes more sense for her then Mabel. Mabel has dipper, and she was all about solving the murder, jenny doesn't know any of them, she have the most to lose.
@@Christian-gr3gu - If anything Jenny has the best motive to kill, I think most people would commit a murder if it meant saving a parent. Granted I stand by the fact that I believe Jenny is innocent, some pieces of evidence don't allign properly if we believe Jenny is the Killer.
Just because Mabel has Dipper doesn't mean she wouldn't still sacrifice him to save Waddles, Mabel can be incredibly selfish and entitled at times in the show, often expecting others to give up what makes them happy for her sake, so while I couldn't see her killing Dipper directly, I could see her willingly sacrifice Dipper through killing someone else.
Half of Kyle's new sprites, like his previous ones, make him look absolutely adorable, and I love it.
Only gonna make it hurt even more once he dies because I do not see that kid surviving this thing. Sigh.
Ah well.
Nice job with the trial so far, though, guys! Certainly took me by surprise a good few times, love when that happens.
Kyle will make it..... trust me.... Kyle will survive.......... please 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺😨😭
Nope. It's always the most trustworthy people that die.
WE'RE SO FUCKING BACK GUYS
We eating well tonight my bros and sisters 😊❤
WOOOOOOO!
LETS GO
Yesterday I saw a video essay about the Danganronpa series and now this?
Man, that’s some timing!
Dipper walks so Gaz can run in the class trial.
I'm think Gaz is antagonist
@@matthewfuyukawa i think she Will be the new support when Mabel dies
@@pepelagarto8110 we don't know if Mabel dies next plus Gaz being an antagonist would be better than Eric being antagonist
@@matthewfuyukawa Mabel IS dying next. I assure you
@@pepelagarto8110 how would you know? I know Mabel is prime suspect,but culprit can't be that obvious
THAT WAS SO FUCKING AWESOME 53:16
Calling it, Dipper is NOT guilty. 100%
plot armor
I think we all know Dipper's innocent. He was knocked unconcious and had to rest in the infirmary for crying out loud. How could he have murdered anyone while incapacitated?
@@dragonman2168 well, finding out who didn't do it I as great step forward...
Let's discard dipper who was knocked out.
Bubbles trigger the body discovery announcement and also was getting nerfed..
The other two also have alibis..
Jenny couldn't done it becuse alibi, and also we know that the killer have hair thanks to the hair found in the skie mask...
Gaz witness something impotmat, and she haves no motive.
Kyle was talking to cartman and cartman went down to the dining hall..
He along with cupcake are the other two people who trigger the body discovery announcement, so get disqualified..
Many people say Mabel could be..
But she would never do it if it meant killing her own brother, that's stupid
Unless self-defense.. So we can't completely rule her out..
Dib is helping investigate, so I really doubt..
Ed and eddy have no motive to care about double D, since they are not in good terms at the moment.. And also they wouldn't sacrifice one to save the other..
So..
Is not:
1dipper
2:bubbles
3blosom
4jenny
5: cartman
6cupcake(is I theory that I saw unironcilcly)
7 star
8kyle
9gaz
10ed
11eddy.
Vendeta, Charlotte, morty and possibly dib Mabel and Zim could of..
Better not be Mabel too like 😭😭😭😭
@frangolles It's unlikely that Dipper committed the crime, I agree with that.
Bubbles, Blossom, and Jenny all have alibis as they were getting "depowered" by Monokuma during the night.
I know a lot of people suspect Mabel, but I have my doubts. For two reasons:
1. She wouldn't ever sacrifice Dipper for her freedom.
2. There's that huge black sweater in Mabel's lab that shows signs of being used and sprayed with black paint. Anyone could have entered Mabel's Ultimate Lab, so that doesn't point to just her. Plus, that black sweater looked pretty big for most of the cast. Only three people would be able to fit into it, being Star, Jenny, and Morty. I can't see what Star would want with a black sweater, and Jenny, as I said, has an alibi. So that means only Morty could be the one to fit into that sweater, which makes him my prime suspect.
Bubbles was one of the three people who found Star's body, so that makes her double safe.
Neither Dib, nor Gaz have a hostage, nor reason to want Star dead.
Charlotte's too naive, though she could be easy enough to manipulate and trick into killing someone.
We already know Kyle's innocent. And though Cartman SEEMS suspicious, well...... we all know how mysteries work. It's NEVER the one first accused or seems the most suspicious.
2 YEARS OF WAITING ITS FINALLY HAPPENING
this is buchard but im tired and want to put this out there, Both mabel and Jenney are not the culprits its Ed and Eddy.
Phone text- "Hey! We finished way earlier than we expected. We're cooking up another plan to get us out of here and I need your help before we reveal it tomorrow." We’re Cooking up another plan bit feels out of character for jenny and is implied that maybe there were more than 1 person meeting with star. They were able to use the phone since Jenney dropped it when avoiding Mookuma and since Jenny has no fingerprints her phone is free to use making Eddy the scam artist scam Star out of her life .
3 people to discover body- its stated a body discovery announcement will be played when 3 non-Blacked find it. Cupcake and Bubbles are known. And Cartman can't be it cause he never saw Star so it would be left with the killer and the accomplice.
Black Hoodie and ski mask- the hoodie was mentioned that it was too big to fit Cartmen so it would assume someone tall can only fit in so that would be Jenney, Morty,Ed & Star. the hoodie would fit Ed’s hight and the ski mask blood would match with the head injury Ed gotten.
Black Stain in cabinet and on star-wet spray paint on the hoodie. The killer was in the cabinet with the spray painted hoodie left residue under them and they popped behind Star lightly bumping behind her to stain their dress or in some other events she had to be hidden in the cabinet after being killed due to cartmen and she got the stain from in the cabinet.
Hair ball-a red Herring as it could be just hair from Vendetta
Knife placement-someone was in a rush or a big Dummy to leave the knife in the drawer wet rather than drying it and putting it back on the knife rack.
Cupcake involvement- cupcake must have attacked the intruders which would end up wasting time and there wouldn't be much show of an attack due to the clothes being completely black.
Blood placement- the way how blood is spread is not natural with a throat slit , no way blood would spread like that with a body dragged and could be a rouse of Mono sauce to try and pin the blame on Cartman, also with the sweater being clean in the end could be that they spray painted it again to cover up the blood.
Why kill Star rather than Dipper?-to risky and there can be a chance of someone checking up on Dipper from time to time, star was easy cause they could get her faraway alone at night.
What took them so long?-eddy had everything planned out but he didn't suspect Cartman and Ed’s stupidity to throw things off. Eddy was smart to put back the hoodie and the phone in mabel’s lab to pin the blame on her but did not suspect Ed to take the long route to the stair and to return the ski mask back in the storage room making dipper see ed’s shadow leaving.
Also minor thing Eddy tried to accuse Dib and Gaz.
@Flummarington did a better explanation/summary
"What i think happened was Eddy got ahold of Jennys phone in the gym and came up with the plan, he spray painted a disguise for Ed to use and they hid in the kitchen cabinet together to wait for Star. After cartman makes his snack and leaves the kitchen, star arrives. Ed sneaks out of the cabinet behind her and grabs her so tight she can't move her arms and also smudges the back of Star's shirt with the spray painted sweater, and then he kills her. Cupcake sees this and attacks Ed prompting Eddy to come out of the cabinet, witness Star dead, and help restrain cupcake. As Eddy is holding her back Ed wastes time washing the knife and they leave, Eddy returns the sweater and dumps jenny's phone in the yarn ball, and Ed being the idiot he is, takes the long way around and returns the bloody ski mask back to the storage room."
this is actually a pretty nice theory!
I think Kyle was second one to find star body as he probably went down after Cartmen and found Star body making him believe it was him 100%.
So, i have a small theory. It's all right for you guys to judge me based on it but whatever. I think Morty is the culprit. Why simple. Everybody else was completely shown on the hostage screen but Rick was nowhere to be seen. All that was left was is portal gun... Even Monokuma made a weird comment about it. That makes Morty's hostage way more valuable than he realizes, Because he doesn't even know if Rick is really alive or not. That gives him much more unintensive to kill and try and frame someone else for it
That’s an interesting theory-I also think that maybe it could also be pointing to Morty being the possible mastermind and is actually one of the evil Morty clones from the show
Plus he has a good motive. I remember a comment in the class trial debate preview stating that could it be very well Multiverse Theory.
Basically morty is taking a gamble to ensure his survival and victory.
The only thing that makes me suspicious of Morty is how he said "Star's no pushover", but how would he know that? He spoke as if he knows she's strong, but we haven't witnessed Star show off any real feats of strength, so why would Morty say "she's no pushover"?
@@JP_Loco_93 plus he was the one that suggest the body was dragged towards the kitchen and the kitchen wasnt orginally where the murder took place.
Why would he even suggest that? Its obvious his "theory" is simply not true, pointed out by blossom.
Also, looking back on the evidence folder, Cupcake apparently coughed up a ball of hair, which most likely involved her attacking whoever came into the kitchen to kill Star. Unless I'm missing something, Jenny would be ruled off in this case since she doesn't have hair.
Morty has been acting far more odd with his weird theories, and could definitely be more effective at murder than Mabel if it came down to it.
56:18 I love how Gaz is like "what just happened????"
Wouldn't you? If the person who is standing in front of you out of reach taps you on the head from above, that's pretty shocking
@@notzombie3703 yeah, I would have the same reaction as Gaz
Everyone remember that episode of South Park, where Cartman makes someone eat their own parents and is able to predict every single move that he makes and that his own friends make I feel like we’re forgetting this I’m 90% sure if Cartman is alive to the end he’s the mastermind.
Those 2 culprits were my 2 choices so I'm happy I was on to something
Yeah, those were my top 2 as well. Weirdly enough, I'm kinda bummed that my list wasn't narrowed any further
I'm not gonna lie, when I saw this premiere in my subscription, I dropped everything I was going to do. Homework be damned! 😂 I am super hype for this!!!❤
fr, like CiDR's chapter 1's trial Part 1 won't watch itself!
Okay wow, you blew this trial right out of the park, that ending left my JAW to the floor.
SPOILERS AHEAD
I'm gonna be honest i suspected Mabel for a while now and I personally think she's the first culprit.
But goddamn what a twist ending, I really hope Gaz survives cuz she just became my instant new favorite character, even though I loved her originally with me being an OG invader zim nerd.
39:33 I like how Cartman is just having a mental breakdown over not being able to lie
However at 1:00:13 look at Mabel's face. I dont think shes a killer, but i think she knows what happened and was quite literally a witness to the murder.
I've been waiting for this for over 2 years now (damn.) and gotta say, it's been a absolutely worth it, everyone did a stellar job in this, I can't wait to see where it goes now.
THEORY: I'm not sure if i missed anything, but the Monokuma file said the slice on Star's throat is "PRESUMABLY" the cause of death, so it's possible that she died a different way, and the throat slice was to throw everyone off the trail.
Good catch! Dib even says "She has a deep cut on her neck which is LIKELY the cause of death"
Dib found a rope in the trash bin at the end of the investigation. I think she was strangled.
@@OwainGundy - String actually, not rope, and if she was strangled by string, that would actually make more sense, as rope would leave more obvious marks than string would. Then again they could've attacked her from behind, using the string to strangle her into unconsciousness, used that same string to tie her hands behind her back, and then slit her throat with the knife.
Plus is it just me, or does the string look like someone's shoelaces?
Maybe the real cause of death is poison. After Star entered the kitchen, the killer gave her either poisoned food or a poisoned drink, and sliced her throat afterwards to make an obvious fatal wound. After all, if they saw her throat slit, why would they bother checking if she was poisoned?
A round of applause for this team putting together an awesome experience. Shout out to the voice cast for what you’ve done in bringing these characters to life, for lack of a better term.
WAIT! I just realized something about them scissors! If they can be used to phase through walls, then they could be used to phase through the door to the Principals Office.
Huh. Maybe Dipper and Dib will use it for this in the future
baggy sweater> Someone Star would trust EASILY> Someone who 'cooks up' plans?
totally is Eddy
So after watching the video, i came up some theories of who might be the culprit... And it might not be Jenny nor Mabel...
1: Jenny has an alibi. She is with the two Powerpuff girls due to their powers are being taken by Monokuma at that time... And i think that she might've really dropped her monokaller considering the scene at the gym when Dipper arive that day. It also gives the culprit the chance to steal it...
2. I also think Mabel is not the likely culprit. I mean, yes, she could've made that black sweater since her ultimate is related to that stuff... But isn't it's also a possibility that the culprit entered Mabel's lab and took one of the sweaters from the cabinet. then sprayed it with the black sprayer from the cabinet also?... The culprit might've also put the sweater back in Mabel's lab leaving it there after the murder to pin the evidence to Mabel... Mabel also says that she might've left her monokaller upstairs, so i think she might've left it in her lab. But what is she lied about that? What if she also lost it? Or more like... Someone stole it... I like to think when the culprit entered Mabel's lab, they saw Mabel's monokaller inside there... So what if they stole Mabel's monoksller and decided to leave the monokaller they stole from Jenny in Mabel's lab? To pin the evidence to Mabel?...
3. I think someone smart enough is the culprit. Someone smart enough to be able to alter some of the functions of the mystery monokaller. Like someone that can bypass the fingerprint function of the monokaller, like someone that can temper the monokaller making it barely useable except for messaging, someone that can hide their name/identity on the monokaller, including in the contacts...
So my best bet of who's really the culprit is a nerd of science or technology and my guess is Morty... But i don't know... This is just a theory of mine... Yep, a Danganronpa theory!
My guess is actually Dib.
He could’ve changed his Monokaller because it’s technology he’s familiar with, and he was the one who found the one that messaged Star in the first place.
If Mabel’s MonoKaller was stolen, he could just present it and say it’s his, thus elminating him from the list of suspects and pinning even more evidence on Mabel, who he was clearly trying to frame in the first place.
Plus, it’d get rid of one of the 3 invader zim (the only franchise in this with 3 players) characters, and also split up the gang that had already been forming between the Pines twins and the Membranes.
@@ThaCataBoi that's also a really good theory!... Though, I don't want Dib to die yet😓
@@Sonicexe-nm1vm both of your theories are good imo!
the first part of cidr's first trial starts on the same day as the megamix match track, i can't stop winning!
I like how they combined the New World Order theme from Danganronpa 3 and the original
It is impossible that the culprit is Mabel or Jenny, there are two crucial pieces of evidence that prove it. Mabel is too small to wear the sweater and Jenny was undergoing surgery to diminish her power, not to mention that the blood on the mask may be the killer himself and Jenny is a robot.
My theory is that the culprit is someone who has a Monokaller, however it is not his own, it is possible that the culprit stole one to replace the one he abandoned.
If we get together with people who have some kind of alibi, we can narrow down the suspects.
Jenny, Blossom and Bubbles were together with Monokuma.
Kyle and Eric were arguing at the time of the murder, not to mention that Eric can't lie.
Gaz and Dipper witnessed suspicious movements before and after the murder.
The remaining suspects are: Zim, Dip, Ed, Eddy, Vendetta, Charlotte and Morty.
Now, a tall person must be responsible in order to wear the sweater.
Therefore only three of them are the most likely: Ed, Eddy and Morty. We can rule out Ed, well because he is Ed, he is not very smart to carry out a premeditated plan.
So our main suspects are Eddy and Morty.
My guess is someone grabbed Jenny's while she wasn't around.
Also, as you mentioned, the person needs to be taller, and most of the cast has at least one solid alibi per character.
I have suspected Morty sense the beginning, but I do agree that Eddy is a pretty capable suspect as well.
Best of luck in solving this stuff, though!
@@primal1313Eddy is too short though
i think it's plausible that the culprit stole jenny's monokaller
since it doesn't need a fingerprint to turn on, it's obviously jenny's, but the trial would end far too quickly if jenny were simply the culprit, plus, she does have that alibi.
Honestly I think it could’ve be Eddy and Ed. Ed to hold her well eddy slit her throat.
@@calebray1834 We don't know how big the sweater is, but Eddy is taller than Mabel.
I always knew this moment will arrive, great job team! And specially you chessy.. This is a great project and we all are so exited to see the fruits of your hard work
I got a feeling it could be the ed duo and here’s my essay on why:
1. They were in the gym when the commotion with Jenny and the PP’s happened, and so had a chance to take the monokaller
2. The monokuma files says “it is presumed the cause of death is a deep laceration” PRESUMED (we all know how monokuma love to screw around with vague things like that) so the actual cause of death could be strangulation (by hand) and then stabbing to cover up the strangulation, explaining the lack of bloodied hands
3. Scam artist Ed could replicate a SCAM message to send and dispose of the Monopod in the UL while muscle Ed stays downstairs to commit the crime directed by scam Ed
4.they got motive in the form of eddy
5. The very small amount of blood on the mask indicates that the culprit had blood on them before they put on the mask, as per muscle Ed’s head banging session. Muscle Ed is also big enough for the sweater, would explain muscle Ed being a goofball enough to put the mask back. Also the black stains could be wet paint where muscle Ed restrained star under the cabinet while Cartman was in the kitchen
6. If cupcake attacked the culprit, they would have been incredibly hostile to them once everyone was investigating, and the Ed’s never went into the kitchen and Muscle Ed has short hair.
7. Muscle Ed’s goofiness could explain why he washed the knife and didn’t put it back with the other knifes, a smart calculated killer like morty or Jenny would have immediately thought to dry and return the knife to cause more confusion
So timeline: Muscle ed takes the sweater and mask and waits downstairs. Then Scam Ed signals Star using a fake message in Jenny’s format which lures star. He tries to dispose of the monokaller, maybe in a place downstairs but Kyle and Cartman block the path so that’s a no-go. He resorts to putting it in the ultimate lab instead.
Meanwhile Scam Ed let’s Muscle Ed know that Cartman is going to the kitchen using their monokallers, so Muscle Ed restrains Star under the cabinet, staining the cabinet and Star until Cartman is gone. He chokes her to death with bare hands before being instructed to stab Star and move the body. Muscle Ed does that, cleans the knife lazily and neatly puts his cloths back after the South Park Bros leave. That completes the crime
I pieced together if the black sweater was too big for Cartman then it had to be Ed with the blood cap too. Also noticed Ed had a couple sharp moments which is uncharacteristic. Now if this is the case, would Eddy or Ed be the blackened? They had this dilemma in DR2 case 2. Is Ed the weapon used by Eddy? Or Ed decided to go through with it on his own
@@rndamas7082thinking about how the characters work, I believe it’s more likely that eddy got Ed to do the killing and is therefore the blackened, there were some things (like cleaning the knife) that Ed probably wouldn’t have done without the direction of eddy. But who knows? Maybe Ed was some secret mastermind or took some experimental food that made him much smarter?
I still think it is Morty. Some of the pieces aren't lining up the way I'd suspected, but nothing that rules him out as the culprit.
I agree. I'm even more confident after watching this 1st half of the trial. Morty is so far acting the most sus. The first to be refuted by Dipper and he tries to brush off a lot of clues and clutching onto other people's theories that don't make too much sense. Leon did a similar thing in his trial, as well as Teruteru.
Plus the culprit can't be Jenny or Mabel. Mabel isn't tall enough to fit into the sweater(they already proved so) and Jenny doesn't have hair that Cupcake could chew off. While Morty is both tall and has hair that Cupcake could've biten off.
Maple pine could have easily made the black sweater they say it was all of their first time seeing it she is known for making over size sweaters and the mono pad was found in her Lab she also has a motive and in the show has been shown to show some selfish side remember when she stayed in her dream bubble in the literal apocalypse
@@JamorrisTysonbut web that the pad was in her lab that could easy be an incrimination and I don’t think Mabel will do such a big sweater for her we now Mabel use oversize sweaters but in the class trial they said the sweater was big like big big
@@JamorrisTyson nothing proves she's the killer though. Yes, Mabel is selfish sometimes but she wouldn't sacrifice her brother, she's selfish not selfish centered(there's a difference)
Besides she didn't know what the rift was and wasn't in the best mental state when that deal was made. Bill used that to his advantage. Plus Ford was the one to make the rift and chose not to tell anyone but Dipper, if Mabel knew of what the rift was she wouldn't have handed it over to who she thought was Blendin.
Mabel and Jenny are red herrings, set by the true culprit and I will stand on that.
There's no proof Mabel made the sweater(though I don't see a reason she would if she couldn't use it) and I don't see a reason she'd help the killer commit the murder(There's no proof that's There's accomplices this case)
@@JamorrisTyson The problem with Mabel is that Star died via strangulation. We need someone large enough to reach Star's neck and have the ability and willpower to pull off a clean kill. In regards to those factors, Morty is both the same height as Star and is one of the most lethal characters in the roster.
[EDIT] In regards to the sweater, you must remember that it was only sloppily dyed black, and is not a piece created on the spot. Any character could have dyed it to blend in.
From what I seen, I think it’s Morty.
I can’t exactly piece together on why, but I believe that with his portal gun, he took Jenny’s phone from her room and text it through there since Star was close with her so she would have trusted Jenny to meet her at the kitchen. As for the sweater and mask, the killer probably used them to keep star’s body concealed so no one can see her, especially how dark it gets at night. Idk, thats what I have for now. Also, can’t wait for part 2. 😊
Well, we know morty doesn't have his portal gun, becuse that is actually his hostage, but I still belive it can only be him..
He didn't have to use his portal gun, he had another way to create portal, the scissors... Or maybe he also haves an hidden lab like dipper were he have an spare one..
But I really like the idea of morty using star's portals becuse he is already pretty familiar at using portals.
Morty did used the skies mask, but in himself, he hid star bodues in the cabinet... And took it out near morning.. I believe..
@@frangolles yeah, I was thinking he also could of use Star’s scissors since it would be more convenient. I’m not too sold on another hidden lab part but I see it as a possibility. Hmm, I’m gonna have to review the investigation video again, it been so long.
I have a theory that someone somehow stole Mabel’s monocaller and hoped someone called out that the killer is the one that is missing their monocaller. Mable actually being the killer would be disappointing because almost everyone predicted it and I want the pine twins to stick together at least until chapter 4
I sadly feel like Mabel's the culprit because the 1st motive were the loved ones of the characters being held hostage, one of them being Waddles. And we all know damn well how much that big chunk means to her.
36:51 omg crashbox ref hooray!
Ok, the editing in this is absolutely phenomenal!! Like, the characters squash and stretch and bounce around like an average cartoon during trial discussion. And the mini games are very creative. The layout for the truth buttons is also very neat. In fact, the layout for everything is fun and interesting.
This was so incredibly well made, from the dialogue to the art to the elements of the game itself, it’s incredible! Great work!
This series was way more funny than I was expecting. Like actual laugh out loud moments that caught me hecka off guard. What brilliant cartoon writing! ^^
Most people accusing Mabel or Jenny are probably falling into the creators trap rn. In murder mysteries when the killer can only be one of X amount of people, it's either none of them or all of them.
Jenny using the (alleged) murder weapon knife when she probably has a plethora of built in weapons, the blood on the inside of the ski mask, the fact that the body was dragged when Jenny is still really strong, the fact that Blossom was probably with Jenny during the murder and hasn't spoken up, the small hair ball despite Jenny... you know, and the perfect opportunity to steal Jenny's Monokaller during the Gym Scene is all evidence that Jenny isn't the killer.
Mabel helping the investigation and trial throughout without pushback, the oil/smudge in the empty cabinet, the too large sweater (large crease be damned), the fact that most of the evidence was found in her own lab, and the fact that making a super important character to the protag being the victim/killer of the first case is already overdone (Sayaka and Kaede) is all evidence that Mabel isn't the killer.
If I had to choose between the 2 Mabel is more likely to me, however, I do have some theories.
Throughout ALL of this Monokuma has never said that accomplices aren't allowed, which could come into play with two killers. Maybe Jenny and Mabel worked together or an entirely different pair worked in conjunction.
Ed bashed his head against the wall until he bled, if he was the one to bleed inside the ski mask it would make sense. However, Ed is dumb, which means he could've worked with Eddy who was calling the shots and Ed didn't know what he was doing.
Now that I think about it... Eddy as the ultimate scam artist would be able to silently steal from Jenny in the Gym and fake a text as her to lure Star. (I haven't watched his show so tell me if this seems out of character of him) Spreading the evidence all around and making it seem it's either Mabel or Jenny could be a tactic of misdirection. Eddy did (or at least in the cut accusal) accuse Dib and Gaz of making experimental foods to commit the crime. Maybe he's projecting? Another classic tactic. Maybe he gave smth to Ed to tie up the loose end of him confessing everything, maybe smth the opposite of Monosauce. The more I think about it, the more the Eddy theory makes sense, maybe there's smth i missed that disproves all this? Pls let me know lol
That could explain why Ed has moments of intelligence in the trial
Calling it now: Either Mabel and Jenny’s monokallers were stolen by the blackened.
Something i just realized! We're now missing someone from body discovery announcement!
Since we thought Cartman was one of the people, but if he never saw Star then who is the other person alongside Bubbles and Cupcake who discovered Star's body!?
OH! Good point! I totally forgot about the bda
I think I know what could had happen to that.. What if.. Enter someone who tried to kill star, they believed star was just asleep and stab her neck, but, they didn't know star was already dead?.
That would mean there's someone who belive they are the killer, and that's why they haven't come forward with the information, but is actually just the fort one to find the body?
@frangolles maybe, though I'm not sure if that'd happen 1st ch.
My theory is that the bda will help prove one of suspects innocence. Possibly Mabel, since Jenny has an albi Monokuma just needs to back it up, so if the bod helps one of them it'll probably be Mabel. I'm not sure why Mabel wouldn't say she found the body, though maybe someone(maybe the killer as well) told her come to the kitchen.(maybe a reason she left her monokalller behind) Or she came down to check on Dipper but ended up hearing something from the kitchen and went to investigate.
Though it honestly could be anyone, I'm mainly thinking of how the bda would help in the trial. I feel if the bda helps in any way, it would be clearing one of suspects and getting closer to the true killer.
That's my opinion though, we'll just have to wait and see.
I saw your comment last night, and it stuck with me for some reason, I finally have an answer! The Body Discovery Announcement only goes off when three non-blackened witnesses discover the body, we know Cupcake & Bubbles are two of the witnesses, Bubbles being the last. I originally thought Cartman was a witness AND tampered with the crime scene, this seems unlikely now, however Cartman had to have done something to earn Cupcake's affection, but even Cartman admitted that Cupcake wasn't in the kitchen when he arrived, which suggest the Killer must have moved Cupcake after killing Star, and having witnessed someone murder Star, that could explain why Cupcake has been so antagonistic.
Also based on Cartman's confession, it seems nothing was out of place when he arrived in the kitchen, he said he didn't see Star, Cupcake or anyone else, but then this would imply the kitchen was not yet in a mess, but if so, the murder had to have happened in those 10 minutes before the deadline, but if Cartman was in the kitchen from say 12:00 to 12:10 (Kyle said they argued for a good 10 minutes), maybe Morty was right about the body being moved, Zim also suggested Star's hands were tied up and that actually tracks with the string that Dib found in the trash in the hallway, AND explains why Star didn't clutch her slit throat.
My guess is that Star was killed between 11:50 & 12:00, her body was then moved, perhaps shoved and hidden in the cupboard, however the Killer could have hidden in there too, which would explain the black smudge, but I doubt both the Killer & Star's body could fit into that one cupboard. Also regarding Cupcake, it's possible the Killer attempted to move Cupcake but was attacked, thus the gooey crumpled up hair AND why their was some blood inside the mask, only issue is, why would the Killer not have been wearing the Ski-Mask in that moment? Anyway the Killer must have hastily cleaned up the mess before Cartman arrived, which means the 'blood trail' and the knife must have been pieces of evidence added later, since Cartman never mentions the state of the crime scene, and if the Killer had attempted to move Cupcake, thus startling her, Cartman might have seen that Cupcake was distressed, and Cartman having a soft spot for cats, must have calmed her down, maybe giving her some food and patting her, hence why she's so affectionate toward Cartman, but if Cupcake had seen the Killer without the Ski-Mask, that still does not explain why Cupcake is so antagonistic toward everyone else. Whatever the case, the 'blood trail' which I still believe is Monosauce, the knife, the string, the MonoKaller and Ski-Mask, all must have been later additions to the crime scene, since again; Cartman didn't mention the blood trail, the knife was still wet by the time Dipper & Dib found it, we know the String & Ski-Mask were discarded around the same time since Dipper witnessed a shadowy figure enter/exit the storage room, they probably hid the MonoKaller in Mabel's Ultimate Lab around that time as well, keep in mind; Dipper woke up at 12:20, meaning our Killer had just 10 minutes to manipulate the crime scene, wash the knife, discard the MonoKaller, String & Ski-Mask, also I just realized; the 'string' looks a lot like shoelaces.
Turns out I might be wrong about Cupcake NOT being hidden and Cartman gaining her affection like I suggested he did because Cartman admitted he didn't see Cupcake, but then how did Cupcake end up back on the kitchen counter? Damn it! Just when I think im onto something. Maybe Cupcake was always affectionate toward Cartman and we just never witnessed it, Cartman has always had a soft spot for cats in the show.
Given everything we know, this means; that the murder happened between 11:50 & 12:00, Cartman was came into the kitchen but saw no sign of Star, Cupcake or anyone else, it's also safe to say there was no crime scene by this point. Thus Star's Body & Cupcake must have been hidden before Cartman arrived, the Killer must have also cleaned up whatever small mess they made before Cartman arrived too, then once Cartman left, they had from 12:10 to 12:20 to add the 'blood trail', wash the knife? Honestly this could have done immediately after using them, finally the Killer discards the String & Ski-Mask, and hides the MonoKaller in Mabel's Ultimate Lab, however this could've also happened whenever, maybe even before the murder even occurred. The Killer was seen by Dipper likely as they were discarding the String & Ski-Mask, while the Killer was discarding the String & Ski-Mask, this is likely the only time someone else could have stumbled across Star's body, and Bubbles would then discover the body only minutes later, meaning Cupcake was the first witness, the second witness is unknown, and the BDA went off when Bubbles discovered the body, but why would the second witness be keeping quiet, especially with there being no chance of them being the Killer?
Sorry my comment is so long, once I start theorizing & speculating, it's hard for me to quit.
@@lavenderrose82 - The only issue with dismissing Blossom, Bubbles & Jenny as potential suspects, or Jenny at the very least, is that Blossom & Bubbles apparently were put to sleep for the procedure, while Jenny admitted to being awake. There's also nothing stopping Jenny from simply telling Monokuma that she wants to commit a murder, Monokuma would immediately hault the procedure on her and allow her to go off and commit her crime. Granted I don't think Jenny is the Killer, everything pointing to her comes across as being more of a red herring than anything.
I have a feeling this is wrong, but is the begging of the Channel Chaser's segment (36:49 this intro) a reference to HBO's Crashbox where the show began the exact same way, with a TV falling out of the sky and landing on a podium (or whatever it was, I can't remember what exactly the TV landed on.)
So, this was the first I watched of any of this and I just wanted to say that it is INCREDIBLE all around! And, personally, it was relatively easy to get into the story and murder mystery even though I wasn't coming into this with context as it explained itself overtime! Very good writing!
I love how the UI STILL shows the old art, really lets you see how the art evolved in a side by side preview. Gobless.
Can't help but still feel a bit suspicious of Morty
Honestly, with how he's starting to become like his grandpa in recent episodes, wouldn't be suprised.
kinda bugs me a little bit when people say that either Mabel or Jenny did it, but my heart tells me that it is probably Morty...which will be saddening, but it could also be Ed, since the mask has a drop of blood inside, and i am sure Ed hurt his head to the point of bleeding when he tried to break the walls in a few chapters back, so...i dunno, but it can't be Mabel or Jenny, but everyone's free to discuss on that!
Yes! I agree with you.
And there's a logical reason for that... And i will explain it, in game mechanics!
You see, remember how near the end of this part cheesy says there was a part that was cuted off? Were eddy accuses gaz and Dib?
Well.. The pin comment left by him also mentioned fully what the idea was..
The minigame was called "the funbox" this minigame was based around two people getting accused at the same time, flying in boxes.. Dodging the other people's accusations.. And after dodging a little.. The protagonist makes an reffitable point.. The two suspects have to defend themselves with evidence against the protagonist..
The protagonist will make a total of 3 refutable remarks before ending the minigame...
And yeah.. This minigame was cuted off this part.. We didn't get to see the membranes defending each other from suspicions.
But... Don't you think the fun box concept is such a good concept that cheesy probably wouldn't just put it just once?
Don't you think the concept of two suspects defending themselves is perfect for this situation?
I will make this prediction, the next part will open up with Mabel's and Jenny's fun box.. And it will go like this:
Dipper: "it really pains me to suspect you... But is true that the sweater and monocaller were found on your lab, that makes you a suspect Mabel"
Mabel: "woah whoah, hold it right there, t-the green man over there said that the sweater was too big that just very few could fit in it, didn't he? I am too much of a shorty to pulled that off"
Dipper: "well, taking the height consideration... I will have to suspect you Jenny"
Jenny: "wait.. That doesn't make any sense, I have an airtight alibi, at the time of the murder I was getting my powers stripped away by monokuma at the time, bubbles, blossom and.. Even if it's weird, monokuma himself can testify about that right?"
Gaz: "why are you wasting time listening to them dipper? Don't listen to their excuses.. Only them could had pulled off the murder, only them could had send the message! How can you explain the monocaller and the fact that both of you don't have one!?"
Mabel: "well.. If we go from. The terms of saying that we aren't the killers then... That means someone stoled our monocaller right? That monocaller is one of ours.. But that doesn't mean we killed star..
Jenny:" B-but, I left mine in my room, there's no one who could had taken it!"
Mabel:"inside your room?.. Well, then. I think I might know what could had been used for that.."
Jenny: "n-no..."
Mabel: "star's scicors... She was the only one who could had taken anything from anyone's room"
The culprit has to be Ed, with Eddy working as an accomplice and the one who hatched the plan. The main reason for this is what was said at the very start of the trial, Stars hands are clean meaning either instant death or restraint. Who is strong enough to hold down someone so they cant fight back at all? Additionally, who would be dumb enough to spend time WASHING the murder weapon and leaving it to dry instead of just taking it with them to their room. This would also explain why the killer took the time to return the ski mask to the storage room and basically do a whole lap around the first floor. Because he is dumb and returning the bloodstained ski mask makes the most sense to him. I saw someone else bring up a theory that cupcake attacked the killer leading to the small amount of blood on the mask and the hairball, this would also align with the timeline assuming Ed spent about 10 minutes tussling with the cat that would be enough time for cartman to finish eating and for Ed to return the ski mask just before 12:20
And the most damn9ng evidence of all is something everyone in the comments seems to have forgotten, the 3 witness rule. Bubbles was the third witness and was the one to trigger the announcement and cupcake obviously had to be a witness too. The rules state that the culprit doesnt count as a witness and cartman really didnt see anyone so that means there has to be at one more "innocent" person involved.
What i think happened was Eddy got ahold of Jennys phone in the gym and came up with the plan, he spray painted a disguise for Ed to use and they hid in the kitchen cabinet together to wait for Star. After cartman makes his snack and leaves the kitchen, star arrives. Ed sneaks out of the cabinet behind her and grabs her so tight she cant move her arms and also smudges the back of Star's shirt with the spray painted sweater, and then he kills her. Cupcake sees this and attacks Ed prompting Eddy to come out of the cabinet, witness Star dead, and help restrain cupcake. As eddy is holding her back Ed wastes time washing the knife and they leave, Eddy returns the sweater and dumps jennys phone in the yarn ball, and Ed being the idiot he is, takes the long way around and returns the bloody ski mask back to the storage room.
I have the same theory as you but put the killer as Eddy. The main question will be how can they tell which is the killer or accomplice? Seems like a coin flip
All things considered, I think the plan is similar but Eddy was the killer rather than Ed. I'd imagine Eddy would throw Ed under the bus if the latter was the one to kill. But Ed was seen with the body, prompting Cupcake to attack. The main difference being Ed would be easy enough for Eddy to manipulate into thinking they'd both walk, when in reality only Eddy would escape if he wins the trial.
For some reason I still feel like it was Ed
The oversized sweater, the blood on the inside of the hat? Ed was literally bleeding from his head.
Anyway it sucks getting into a series like this that isn't finished yet because now I have to wait forever to see more
Loving every second of it. Although a small recommendation for part 2? Pitch up Kyles's lines so it sounds more in tune with the show? Because while Eric's voice actor can nail it, I feel like Kyle's voice actor can't.
Nobody gonna talk about the fact that Zim’s likely to die next in Chapter 2 because he made the first rebuttal against the protag (like Mahiru and Ryoma).
I hope that in Chapter 2 dare to break the Rebuttal Showdown curse.
SPOILERS!! :
Gaz jumping in and trying to clock Dipper pissed me off, because girl. You waited THAT long, complain about your time being wasted, when YOU could have EASILY asked everyone to whip out their Kallers, weed out the suspects, and then the trial would have been as easy as that?? Omfg do NOT be a Kokichi Ouma for the love of us all. Also I was OH SO THANKFUL when I found out Bubbles & Blossom were innocent.. but I get the feeling that they won't be so innocent later on down the lines. Also, if Star was killed before she could even react, I feel like it'd be Jenny. Though, we have seen Mable sacrifice an entire town just for her own gain ( Weirdmageddon ). But I don't think Mable could reach that high to slit Star's throat, it seems more plausible if it were Jenny, especially since she came into the beginning of the trial feeling guilty and attempting to confess something. There's more logic pointed towards Jenny, rather than Mable. Although, if anyone wants to discuss this and leave a theory, I'd love to see it! :3
Yeah idk why she is getting upset over. She should be the last person talking trash. Being a detective investigating a murder within a time limit and told to solve it in another time limit isnt easy
Plus wasnt she literally asleep during the whole investigation. She literally been complaining about wanting to leave till she mentioned the monotalker.
yeah my thoughts about gaz exactly then chat goes “she’s popping off” “she’s cooking” she had like HALF AN HOUR TO DO SO LMAO
EXACTLY. Everyone else had been talking and speaking their mind, including her own BROTHER. Your brother, Dipper, and Blossom did most, if not, all the main talking during the trial. Blossom literally had to come up with a place to start just to kick the trial off, and then you have the utter audacity to go ahead and start shit talking everyone. Girl go back to sleep, you did genuinely nothing good besides side eye Dipper with your Tootsiepop headass. 😭
I hate people like that. They try to act all smart because they noticed one little thing, yet they don't say shit when it's needed. Like, as soon as you realize something you should speak up. Don't fucking wait nearly an hour or so and then talk shit like you're the smartest person here.
Something tells me she's gonna be doing that a lot. Withholding info that she picked up while she lets everyone sort through all the hard stuff, then she'll come out with the simple things just so she can make everyone feel stupid.
And you just know that this is gonna affect Dipper's confidence. He's gonna be doubting himself and questioning his abilities, which will make things harder down the line.
SAMEEE IT LIKE GIRL YOU COULD'VE DONE THAT FROM THE GET GO AND WASTE NO ONES TIME THAT'S ON YOU and she didn't even investigate and people think she gonna be mvp of the trial while I'm like BRO DIPPER LIGIT IS DOING THE CARRYING OF THIS TRIAL I'm with my girl Jenny
Okay so- I don’t think it’s either Mable or Jenny. Mostly because the monocaller is broken (and since the trial is split up into parts, it’s a little too early to call in the killer). Why is the monocaller being broken proves their innocence? Well- I stole this theory from someone in the comments of a different video. The killer gave Cupcake the monocaller which broke it, allowing them to access the caller without needing to sign in. They used it to hide their identity.
However, if it does get proven to be either those two, then it has to be Mabel (unfortunately, that’s the last person who I want to see die, but tropes exist for a reason. And Dib is definitely the support). Reasons: Jenny has an alibi and the sweater is something she would definitely use.
However, the cons is that the sweater has been labeled as BIG. Big as in “most people can’t fit in it” the killer could’ve used an oversized hoodie which fits with Mabel’s character, but still- from how it was described, I’d say Ed, Jenny, Star (rip), Morty, or someone I forgot would’ve been able to fit. Also, Mabel helped during investigations and the trial, why would she do that if she was the culprit? Did she regret it? Does she want to get caught?
Regardless, this an amazing series that is high quality in every little thing. Can’t wait to see if Mabel is proven innocent (Please. I don’t want her to die)
Love the concept and execution of this project! Also I'm pretty sure I heard the wayside theme song somewhere in the background
32:40 sounds like someone doesn't like the 3rd case of game 2 lol
CHEESY, DROP THE SECOND EPISODE OF THIS AMAZING CLASS TRIAL AND MY LIFE IS YOURS 🧎🧎🧎🧎🧎
Finally, it’s here!!!
I remember that when they mentioned the MonoKallert thing, I was like “Cool, make everyone take theirs out.”, but it was brushed off so quickly that I actually abandoned my original idea! Clever, really.
I’m still really confused over how Star was killed at the same time Eric was cooking. It’ll probably be explained in details later, but if it already was, I really didn’t catch it 😅
Now, I have to remark the humor in this. Incredibly creative and loved the forth wall breaking. Had me rolling.
I’m here to support til the end of this project. I know as a perfectionist myself that ambition doesn’t always work well with that trait, but let me just say that you’re doing great. Keep going
Remember the black stain in the cupboard? The culprit and star probably hid inside when Cartman came in
@@nobodys_here07 Sounds like a good idea. What’s troubling me is that Cartman was there from 11:50 til 12:10, and Dipper saw a shadow during 12:20, so the culprit killed Star between those hours, right? Cuz I think that in one moment they mentioned that Star must have been killed during another period or smth like that, I don’t remember correctly
@@firopi7901
Here's how I see the timeline of events:
Before 11:50: The culprit began to set up all the necessary tools needed to pull off the murder. Including Jenny's tablet which they swiped from her during the second motive.
11:50: Star went to the kitchen and met up with the culprit . The culprit ambushed Star and incapacitated her immediately so she wouldn't fight back. And since there are no other visible wounds, I'm inclined to believe they used cleaning supplies to create chloroform. They then heard someone coming a few minutes later and hid inside the kitchen's cupboard until Cartmen left.
12:10: They then proceeded to grab a nearby knife and slit Star's throat, hoping that they made it in time before the motive's deadline.
12:20: The culprit began hiding/implanting evidence.
@@nobodys_here07 Woah, that actually makes a lot of sense! You really just cleared all my doubts hahahaha. Who do you think is the culprit?
@@firopi7901
By process of elimination:
- Jenny and the Powerpuffs were being depowered
- Gaz and Dib don't have any motives
- Mabel seems to be a red herring since even she wouldn't be dumb enough to hide incriminating evidence in her own lab (plus the fact that Dipper would've been executed if she wins)
- Eric and Kyle can vouch for each other
That leaves: Zim, Ed, Eddy, Charlotte, Vendetta, and Morty
However, I'm not inclined to believe Ed or Charlotte could perform something like this, and Eddy wouldn't murder anyone since it would put Ed at risk of getting executed via class trial.
And if we go by the sweater, it'd probably be too big to fit Vendetta
So it's between Morty and Zim
The glue on the table storage room reminded me of Zim's weakness to water. As his alien biology couldn't handle getting wet, he applied a layer of glue on his skin which was able to protect him from water. And since we know the knife used was washed, it's possible Zim is the culprit.
However, I forgot if Dipper commented on whether the glue was used or not so if it wasn't used, then it's Morty.
Everyone is talking about who the culprit could be but am I the only one trying to find the bloody gir? 54:02 for reference
Same, I'm commenting so I get notified if someone does find her
@@ItsJustValHere if I find it I will let you know
I cant see it
@@xIV3_the_w4rd0x its hidden somewhere (2 months later and I still can't find it 😭😭)
30:05 Morty! It’s because we can see the teleporter by Mabel’s pig!
"Hey Eric, what's your angle?"
"Obtuse obviously!"
BRO WHY TF R THEY COOKING CARTMAN SO HARD
its mabel its mabel its mabel its mabel, the kaller was found in HER room and chapter one always has someone the protagonist is close to dying
Alright my fello detectives we are close to solving this mystery. The blackeneds are either mabel or jenny and to solve this mystery we will have a evidential discussion basically were discussing evidence about each person that could prove theyre the killers anyone can give a piece of evidence but do point out which piece of evidence is pointing to whom.
With that ill start the monokaller was inside of mabels ultimate lab inside her giant yarn ball its assumed nobody except dib could cut through it but theres another person who couldve possibly cut through the yarn. Jenny could have done it because of her pick tails since shes made of metal her picktails couldve been very sharp and when dipper said he heard footsteps he couldve heard jenny because again shes made of metal and robots trying to sneak around wouldnt exactly work well.. since her feet are made of metal they would obviously make noise with those peices of evidence it makes me think that jenny is the blackened.
@@Braylon.Hargrave maple is also suspicious she could have easily made or dyed the sweater using her Lab she also could've hid her mono pad in the yarn it is her Lab and she said she left her mono pad in her room why would she do that if she did she wouldn't be able to get back in
Good theory, except she and the Powerpuff girls had solid alibis since they were being drained of their powers when the murder occured
Holy moly we’re so back I gotta catch up on the investigation quick
WE ARE SO BACK 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
THE CARTMAN TRUTH THING IS DEF A PLAY ON THE EPISODE LE PETITE TOURETTES ITS MY FAVORITE EPISODE
I Just Realized, Everyone in This Fangan's Are Teenangers/Kids
I don't think Mabel is the killer. The monopad was found in her lab not to mention the ski mask and sweater also came from her lab. It would be too obvious for Mabel.
My guess is that the murderer probably stole either Jenny or Mabel’s MonoKaller to send the text. Probably Gaz. Another thing the trial hasn’t discussed is how the killer also got out of their room without being seen along with Star. Deb probably was not actually asleep, but was waiting on Star and went through the portal with her to go to the kitchen together.
Damn! Great video! Trial seems pretty well thought through. Waiting patiently for part 2!!
The Gaz faces😭😭
It couldn’t be Mable she’s the obvious choice. Jenny could’ve done it. It’s more Jenny than Mable.
Your in denial but same for me too
Its possible its neither of them.
@@sliceninja4546It could be Morty
@@CGFillertextprobably not Mabel
i agree, just because in order for mabel to get away with it, dipper would be killed w/ everyone else. would she really kill her own brother for this? doubtful