Peter Dutton has ‘no answer’ for the challenges behind nuclear plan

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 252

  • @oldgeezer1234
    @oldgeezer1234 17 годин тому +40

    Labour has no idea Australian manufacturing is dead and cheap power is a pipe dream wind is a waste of money. Once again mouth pieces with no experience

    • @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1
      @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 17 годин тому +2

      Yet Labor are rolling out an advanced manufacturing plan for Australia? Renewables are proven cheaper than nuclear by organisations with no preconcieved ideas either way. Are you sure you know what you are talking about?

    • @Diponty
      @Diponty 17 годин тому +9

      @@Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 Solar panels are destroying the atmosphere and are 6500 times worse than CO2. But keep the dream alive until it turns into a nightmare.

    • @kelgusthart1789
      @kelgusthart1789 17 годин тому

      ​@Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 That's a complete load of BULLSHIT.
      Nuclear is proven to be way cheaper in the long run and 1000%more reliable.
      Labor have NO PLAN for manufacturing in this country. It's all smoke and mirrors and another pre election pipe dream from Labor to try deceive the australian voters.
      Pretty sure we heard the same rot and lies when Albo promised us all $275.00 deductions in our power bills. Now we are paying a third and some extra.
      Albo,Chalmers ,Wong and Blackout Bowen are a disgrace. It's time to give Dutton a go and kick these WOKE out of touch Labor clowns to the Kirb.

    • @vijayendranvijay457
      @vijayendranvijay457 17 годин тому +1

      @@Diponty Source?

    • @martintran7837
      @martintran7837 16 годин тому

      @@vijayendranvijay457 say, censorship. We will wait a real data when Google surrender. No, rust!

  • @Beachlife4567
    @Beachlife4567 17 годин тому +64

    This nuclear plan has got Labor in a panic.

    • @JackRichardsonM8
      @JackRichardsonM8 17 годин тому +7

      Canavan has admitted that the nuclear plan is a political fix and that nuclear power isn't the cheapest energy.

    • @awc900
      @awc900 17 годин тому +17

      @@JackRichardsonM8 Matt Canavan stated that coal was a cheaper option if you want reliable non intermittent power but if you have to meet net zero targets, nuclear has a place in the grid.

    • @dfor50
      @dfor50 17 годин тому +10

      @@JackRichardsonM8 It's not the cheapest but given we are not supposed to use gas or coal it is the next best baseload power to provide adjustable, reliable power. It's been shown that windmills and glass can't do it.

    • @lokai7914
      @lokai7914 17 годин тому +14

      @@JackRichardsonM8 You might want to look into the actual numbers. According to overseas' experience wind + solar + transmission lines + storage is TWICE the cost of nuclear.

    • @keeganlane1685
      @keeganlane1685 17 годин тому

      ⁠@@dfor50show me the data that says that
      Also batteries are fast becoming a very viable option and is cheaper then nuclear

  • @martinvanderhoek4363
    @martinvanderhoek4363 16 годин тому +16

    What is this guy talking about when Labour hadn’t disclosed any of their policies during the election!

  • @sallycent6598
    @sallycent6598 17 годин тому +15

    The Labor party does always insult the Australians intelligence, because we know very well that the Labor climate policy is bringing up the cost of living especially the electricity.

  • @awc900
    @awc900 17 годин тому +12

    This guy is more negative than the blunt end of a battery. If he looked at his own party from a similar viewpoint, he'd come with similar conclusions. Trying to rely on renewables is never going to cut it.

  • @richardrogers7339
    @richardrogers7339 17 годин тому +24

    Stop blaming the war

    • @douglaswasley1461
      @douglaswasley1461 13 годин тому

      Russia invaded Ukraine in Feb/2022...election May/ 2022 and they still promised a $275 REDUCTION

  • @Sam-sj4pd
    @Sam-sj4pd 17 годин тому +18

    in Layman's terms.. Westinghouse have already said they would give Australia a quote on nuclear but they can't because of the ban. Lift the ban and we'll know exactly the costs.

    • @footbru
      @footbru 16 годин тому +1

      Where did Westinghouse say this?
      Why would the LNP's legislative ban on nuclear stop Westinghouse from giving a quote??

    • @davewise7419
      @davewise7419 15 годин тому

      What a load of rubbish. Any firm can do a quote regardless of our current ban on nuclear. That could not and would not stop any firm that was serious in quoting numbers. If what you are saying has any truth to it, then any costing that the Liberals have come up with must also be bogus because apparently according to you, no-one can do a quote because of the ban.

    • @terryhudson2370
      @terryhudson2370 14 годин тому +2

      @@footbru Westinghouse would need to know all the red, green, native title claims and the rest of the BS that will be placed in the way of any build.

    • @footbru
      @footbru 14 годин тому

      @@terryhudson2370 You specifically stated that "Westinghouse have already said they would give Australia a quote on nuclear but they can't" ... so I'm asking, when did Westinghouse make that offer?

    • @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER
      @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER 14 годин тому

      Man Made Climate Change is a hoax

  • @EducationWillSetYouFreeCOOKER
    @EducationWillSetYouFreeCOOKER 17 годин тому +19

    🙄
    Every couple of days with this line from Labor...
    Don't want people to opt for nuclear? *Build something else then!*
    Want to see a "sloppy burrito" (other than *LB's Mom* that is). Look at the last 3 years of Labor's attempt at government.
    Nothing achieved: nothing good for the people, none of what Labor wanted. Just 3 years of squealing and making money of you.

    • @Waynothebrute
      @Waynothebrute 15 годин тому

      @@EducationWillSetYouFreeCOOKER There has been a lot achieved by the ALP since taking power but this channel with all the comments have been of an unnecessary attitude. I can tell heaps of positives but have always been deleted by Sky because it’s a positive.

    • @Martinoconnor-du6lc
      @Martinoconnor-du6lc 32 хвилини тому

      @@Waynothebrute bullshit. sky is not deleting you. you just don't have anything and you know it.

  • @daniell6394
    @daniell6394 13 годин тому +5

    I'm really over the gaslighting and lies. Get em out.

  • @malcolmhector2641
    @malcolmhector2641 17 годин тому +12

    When has Labor put Australia before anything , not once since being elected . This guy has always used scare campaign & misinforming & doesn't use data .every time he is on news interview. .have you bought your 4 million retirement home yet .

    • @trg9765
      @trg9765 17 годин тому +1

      No ministers have 2 settle for
      3 Million mansions

    • @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1
      @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 17 годин тому +3

      Trillion dollar deficit, Morrison's ministries, RoboDebt, late supply of vaxes......Yeah great job Libs.

    • @Waynothebrute
      @Waynothebrute 16 годин тому

      @@trg9765Every one living on the East side of the Harbor Bridge are living in 4m dollar houses plus. Don’t forget HE Is the PM of Australia. Don’t be so jealous Malcolm

    • @trg9765
      @trg9765 16 годин тому

      @Waynothebrute
      There's NOTHING to
      B jealous about
      "ELBOW"

    • @Waynothebrute
      @Waynothebrute 16 годин тому +1

      @ Why carry on then? It’s Dutton and his mob doing the scare campaign.

  • @speedymccreedy8785
    @speedymccreedy8785 14 годин тому +3

    Albo importing 2 million people in a little over 2 years, I wonder what that did to the 'supply gap'.

  • @arthurlongshanks
    @arthurlongshanks 17 годин тому +20

    These Labor muppets are unwatchable

  • @martinscrapp7166
    @martinscrapp7166 17 годин тому +11

    Just do the maintenance/upgrades on the coal-fired power stations, and lets turn the lights back on! Same with gas-fired power stations.
    Voting LNP or ALP won't save Australia...we need a 3rd political party that doesn't bow at the 'climate change' altar, that doesn't bend the knee to the WEF/EU/UN/WHO.

    • @davewise7419
      @davewise7419 15 годин тому

      Keep living in your dreamworld - one day you'll wake up to the truth about climate science

    • @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER
      @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER 14 годин тому +1

      Agreed, man made climate change is a hoax and scam.

    • @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER
      @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER 14 годин тому +1

      ​@@davewise7419these scientists are being funded by the government, so of course they're going to go along with the scam.

    • @Martinoconnor-du6lc
      @Martinoconnor-du6lc 25 хвилин тому

      @@davewise7419 start naming the climate alarmist predictions that have occurred. that's right, you can't. not one. your "scientists" are flawed and liars.

  • @lokai7914
    @lokai7914 17 годин тому +8

    The ALP will NOT set the 2035 target before the election. Thus, there's no reason for the LNP to do so.

    • @connorduke4619
      @connorduke4619 16 годин тому

      There will be no 2035 Net Zero Nonsense target from either party... as Trump has already killed off that while Socialist Fascist charade.

    • @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER
      @DEPORTER_SUPPORTER 14 годин тому +1

      There shouldn't be any target, we have zero affect on the worlds climate.

  • @Didigetitwrong
    @Didigetitwrong 14 годин тому +2

    Well that's not true Mr Dutton has said he is aiming for 2050 and the National party wants the target scrapped altogether.
    So Labor is the only party looking at a 2030 target..

  • @Hardwick989
    @Hardwick989 15 годин тому +4

    Nothing wrong with the climate. A waste of time and money.does one country go clean while the rest of the world doesn't. Ridiculous

  • @Michaeldoust
    @Michaeldoust 13 годин тому +3

    Labor are becoming increasingly desperate, spending more time talking about Dutton rather themselves

  • @Suzukiweekend
    @Suzukiweekend 17 годин тому +19

    Labour has no answer

  • @ditzyfifi
    @ditzyfifi 13 годин тому +3

    What planet do these stupid Labor Politicians think they are living on. Vote them out, I will never vote for Labor again.

    • @countyorga764
      @countyorga764 12 годин тому

      Think,stupid and you in the same sentence ✅✅✅.

  • @peterkehoe481
    @peterkehoe481 17 годин тому +7

    I heard this on Sky News Radio this morning and Tim Ayres has to be along Chris Bowen as the biggest dopes in parliament.

    • @ZELJKO472
      @ZELJKO472 15 годин тому

      They are all dopes. That's why Australia is headed to Argentina 🇦🇷 2.0. FACT.

  • @tomjones5338
    @tomjones5338 17 годин тому +12

    Peter Dutton has the answer for nuclear power Albo and Labor wish the Madi gra people would stop calling cheerio boys 🤣🤣🤣🤣😆😆😆😆

  • @GG-rq3yj
    @GG-rq3yj 17 годин тому +14

    Oh my god all he’s fixated on is Dutton 😂😂. He’s the Democrat version of the USA. What a thug of a man ! Labor are the lowest of low

  • @Arthurbracegirdleesq
    @Arthurbracegirdleesq 17 годин тому +15

    Mr dutton has the right to defend himself from censorship

  • @Aussie-Nan
    @Aussie-Nan 15 годин тому +2

    What Australian manufacturers , who can afford to run factories here, get rid of Labour your the only one increasing bills

    • @ZELJKO472
      @ZELJKO472 15 годин тому +2

      Equatorial Guinea has more productivity. Australia doesn't even make plastic or tins. Everything is imported

  • @connorduke4619
    @connorduke4619 16 годин тому +5

    Correction: The Assistant Minister for Narcissistic Gaslighting, Inflation and Poverty.

    • @ZELJKO472
      @ZELJKO472 14 годин тому +1

      Anyone who criticises him he calls far right, a cooker or conspiracy. There isn't anything more cooked than what we have now.

  • @Lanes1122
    @Lanes1122 15 годин тому +3

    What a load of rot.

  • @stancraigie601
    @stancraigie601 15 годин тому +3

    And Labor say they are against misinformation! Labor must be so happy for the war in Ukraine, they can blame on their failings on it!

    • @MrElwood78
      @MrElwood78 12 годин тому

      And that war is about “critical minerals”. All of this climate change/renewables agenda is causing chaos throughout the world, just like the wars for oil has done for decades!

  • @grantfrost9157
    @grantfrost9157 14 годин тому +3

    Tim Ayres "WEF MUPPET" this tool needs to GO!!

  • @davidcarter4247
    @davidcarter4247 14 годин тому +2

    Labor is working on the basis that coal can be replaced megawatt by megawatt with renewables . The Climate Council says we already have enough renewable capacity to supply 25% of our needs. Despite that, it says renewables provide little more than 10% of actual demand. Most of that 10% is generated during the day in the summer months. We are not within cooee of meeting 98% of our year round energy needs from renewables. It may be impossible as most that will be installed by 2030 will need to be replaced by 2050. Renewables have a very short life compared with other generators.

  • @rozbailey6889
    @rozbailey6889 14 годин тому +2

    Is this bloke serious about an Australian Manufacturing? They are closing and moving o/s at an alarming rate because of Labour Policies. Pure bunkum mate

    • @ZELJKO472
      @ZELJKO472 14 годин тому

      Has occurred over decades. Now accelerator is on and driving in 6th gear. Pedal been pressed to the floor

  • @nedabo69
    @nedabo69 14 годин тому +2

    Yeah, after watching this for 1:11 I concluded that this guy is full of crap.

  • @johnrider7619
    @johnrider7619 16 годин тому +2

    So he's saying Labor has put our Industries in the strongest positions . Wow how blind can you be

  • @EducationWillSetYouFreeCOOKER
    @EducationWillSetYouFreeCOOKER 17 годин тому +12

    *Jack/Brains_Into_Monuments*
    You guys and the rest of you lefties here need to go on 'My Funny Addiction' 😂😂😂
    Remember what I said to you yesterday? You guys are hopeless 😅

  • @8101nevermind
    @8101nevermind 15 годин тому +3

    The Sky is falling,the sky is falling............. really.

  • @durv13
    @durv13 17 годин тому +3

    well at least dutton is standing up , what has labor done in 3 years ? wheres albo ? noone knows . ive seen dutton answer every question asked , even if the answer is , i dont know . but albo cant answer a single question , he gets his lap dog penny wrong to talk crap for him .

  • @Aussie-Nan
    @Aussie-Nan 15 годин тому +4

    First job for the Libs disband the Climate Change Authority, not required and get on with real business.

    • @countyorga764
      @countyorga764 15 годин тому +2

      You certainly aren’t required 👋👋.

    • @troywallace322
      @troywallace322 14 годин тому

      ​@@countyorga764Love your positive happy go lucky out look and your comments are never longer than 7 words ❤😂

    • @troywallace322
      @troywallace322 14 годин тому +1

      ​@@countyorga764Your just a little bubble of fun. 😂

    • @troywallace322
      @troywallace322 14 годин тому

      ​@@countyorga764😃

    • @countyorga764
      @countyorga764 12 годин тому

      @@troywallace322 Short is best. Even short is way beyond the comprehension of fox/sky ‘news’ viewers.

  • @patrickwakefield2297
    @patrickwakefield2297 15 годин тому +2

    this bloke is full of BS. is he sure he is talking about australia.

  • @Coastal603
    @Coastal603 17 годин тому +5

    Still blaming the war? 😂😂

  • @Lachlan124-b1n
    @Lachlan124-b1n 17 годин тому +7

    Whats his message? Very simple get out the way Labor!!

    • @countyorga764
      @countyorga764 15 годин тому

      Simple and you in the same sentence ✅✅.

    • @Lachlan124-b1n
      @Lachlan124-b1n 15 годин тому +1

      @countyorga764 Did I ask for your opinion?

    • @glennquagmire-o7w
      @glennquagmire-o7w 13 годин тому

      @@Lachlan124-b1n Count Yorga doesn't have opinions, just inane schoolyard stupidity

    • @Martinoconnor-du6lc
      @Martinoconnor-du6lc 18 хвилин тому

      @@countyorga764 wanker and you in the same sentence.

  • @davehad-enough2369
    @davehad-enough2369 11 годин тому +2

    Oh it's Tim Ayres turn to come out against Dutton again. He has a crack at this a couple of weeks ago. What a Loser. Back to sleep Ayres .... your rock is calling.

  • @ionbocse846
    @ionbocse846 3 години тому +1

    Setting the targets…blah, blah, blah…this guy has no idea…probably a Labour guy, what a nonsense looser

  • @chairmandan1794
    @chairmandan1794 17 годин тому +3

    Minister Uluru you are so far off the mark!!!

  • @alliswell2114
    @alliswell2114 12 годин тому +2

    Climate change authority LOL

  • @chrissyjones-major1557
    @chrissyjones-major1557 13 годин тому +1

    We’ve heard this guy before not too 0:05 long ago! He’s full of Labor BS. Why do you keep inviting him?

  • @IanBrasher-uq4te
    @IanBrasher-uq4te 16 годин тому +2

    How can we manu anything when we dont have 24 hr power supply because wind and sun wont supply you cant turn furnaces on and off in a whim

    • @alanb9337
      @alanb9337 10 годин тому

      .China is claiming to have developed a 'flash iron making' process that takes 3 to 6 seconds rather than the traditional 5 -6 hours in a blast furnace.

    • @IanBrasher-uq4te
      @IanBrasher-uq4te 10 годин тому

      @alanb9337 that a load of bullshit

  • @raymills4296
    @raymills4296 14 годин тому +2

    Why are we listening to this rubbish

  • @RaymondScaddan
    @RaymondScaddan 16 годин тому +1

    No mate the aust tax.payer paid the hex bill the gov only has taxpayer money

  • @BrettNorman-iu6wj
    @BrettNorman-iu6wj 16 годин тому +2

    Bring back cheap baseload power

  • @Gregpriestley-q4e
    @Gregpriestley-q4e 13 годин тому +1

    ALP go ask your cohort Greens, they seem to have all the answers 😂 That’s right, everyone can have everything without contributing 🎉 like your HECS accountability

  • @Didigetitwrong
    @Didigetitwrong 14 годин тому +1

    If nuclear power is so good why does Israel not have it?.

    • @alanb9337
      @alanb9337 10 годин тому

      Israel is alleged to have nuclear power in the form of nuclear weapons. Israel has 2 nuclear research reactors. Israel is using natural gas from a field 80km off their coast among the sources they use. 90 percent of homes in Israel have solar hot water heating. There is also wind & solar PV. Israel's neighbour, Egypt is building a nuclear power plant 320km northwest of Cairo.

    • @Didigetitwrong
      @Didigetitwrong 9 годин тому

      @alanb9337 So why did Israel no aquire nuclear power it has the technology.
      Answer : they are the same as us hot dry climate dwindling fresh water supplies and a small population.
      They use a lot of coal and oil aswell.

  • @brendensouth1067
    @brendensouth1067 13 годин тому +1

    Lot of empty space between his ears.!

  • @Peter-p5u8t
    @Peter-p5u8t 16 годин тому +2

    This guy needs to get out more😂

  • @thepetridish9380
    @thepetridish9380 14 годин тому +1

    ...Am I watching CNN? WTF.

    • @dennissandy5869
      @dennissandy5869 12 годин тому

      Don’t u like unbiased news from sky? 😂

  • @tonydcurrawong
    @tonydcurrawong 17 годин тому +3

    Come on Libs. Start selling this better.

    • @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1
      @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 17 годин тому +3

      Can't sell a pig in a poke. Look that up if you don't understand it.

    • @tonydcurrawong
      @tonydcurrawong 17 годин тому +1

      @@Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 - indeed. But you could secure a countries energy future.....not what your mates are doing

    • @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1
      @Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 17 годин тому +1

      @@tonydcurrawong Agreed, Greens and Libs torpedoed Labor and Rudd and we have had 10 years of drift from the clowns in the Nationals and Libs.

    • @Diponty
      @Diponty 17 годин тому

      @@Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 But can sell a cheap reliable renewable lemon. 🍋

    • @Martinoconnor-du6lc
      @Martinoconnor-du6lc 14 хвилин тому

      @@Dont_Gnaw_on_the_Kitty_1 i bet you poked a few pigs. and vice versa

  • @jasonhopkins7120
    @jasonhopkins7120 17 годин тому +2

    I don't believe anything this bloke says

  • @KellyLithgow-t3i
    @KellyLithgow-t3i 16 годин тому +3

    God help us all 💯🍌

  • @ianenglish123
    @ianenglish123 17 годин тому +3

    Matt Canavan knows, sell more coal, keep pouring subsidies into the old coal clankers. Thats Matts and Littleprouds solution he said so.

    • @RealLuciferBlack
      @RealLuciferBlack 17 годин тому +3

      Duhhh really duhhhhhh
      Build something else then, you born whinger.
      People are tired of endless complaints from the left. And you wonder why Trump won in a landslide.

    • @countyorga764
      @countyorga764 15 годин тому +1

      @@RealLuciferBlackKeep sucking up to your orange turd boyfriend. Shame you have competition from muskturd😢. Maybe a threesome 💋💋💋.

  • @Poorlineforeva
    @Poorlineforeva 16 годин тому +4

    Dutts plan is to complain about flags and gingerbread

  • @mikespike2099
    @mikespike2099 15 годин тому +3

    Dutton is a bit of a dud tbh … 😅 … also secretly removing immigration caps reeks of WEF subservience

  • @martintran7837
    @martintran7837 17 годин тому +1

    Censorship is finest

  • @elladorth
    @elladorth 11 годин тому

    the whole nuclear debate is just a sideshow, we need cheap reliable power now, we cannot wait 5 to 10 years, gas is there by the bucket load, but we can only export it to others for a low cost, and let them emit the co2, yet charge our own citizens a bomb, and we give our exports priority. these guys are sold out, both parties. sick of all of them.

  • @franciscoparra3818
    @franciscoparra3818 11 годин тому

    WTF does reducing HEX debts have to do with energy. WTF has the foreign war have to do with energy prices when we are allowed to access our own gas reserves. Seriously, what an idiot.

  • @steverogers9507
    @steverogers9507 11 годин тому

    OFS . Tim Ayers? How many times will he mention Dutton or opposition. Setting targets by Labor is a futile exercise.

  • @TAVOAu
    @TAVOAu 11 годин тому

    And just when will they have enough weather dependent generators running, to be able to wean off coal and gas? Umm... since 2021, I'm having to find hundreds of extra $$ to pay my "$275 less" power bill.

  • @MichaelMeilech
    @MichaelMeilech 16 годин тому

    I have a question if the opposition gets shared power what action steps do they have to bring any cist of living fosn the government has s no control off the taxes that come ine into pay debts cheaper to import from France,Uk Italy with all delivery cost etc talk sbout experience so Australia will never be competitive 3:10 😊

  • @0401412740
    @0401412740 11 годин тому

    Well do you want Albanese as PM? Whats the alternative? Budget deficits, migrant invasion, cost of living pressure and inflation????? Labor and Albanese is gone next election.

  • @tamimrktz6966
    @tamimrktz6966 17 годин тому

    He has plenty of answers.

  • @RaymondParnell-f6y
    @RaymondParnell-f6y 11 годин тому

    I dont expect Peter to have all the answers . I know the nuclear science guys snd builders do. I dont see a problem with nuclear. No to doomsday preppers renewable profits.

  • @steverogers9507
    @steverogers9507 11 годин тому

    Please tell where Anal has passed 1 test of leadership?

  • @frederickmarsh798
    @frederickmarsh798 13 годин тому

    Sorry! Your judging a book by its cover once again! I repeat! “READ IT” FIRST!

  • @SOz-uf5yq
    @SOz-uf5yq 17 годин тому +1

    👉May your Christmas be filled with good times and the best wine 👈Cheers.
    👉I wish you and your family a season full of light and laughter. 👈 Cheers.

  • @rodshephard3837
    @rodshephard3837 14 годин тому +2

    ayres is a total clown.......not one ounce of intelligence or real knowledge-NONE....

    • @ZELJKO472
      @ZELJKO472 14 годин тому +1

      He did an arts degree, then a union extortioner then politics.

  • @TitchTheWonderDog-rp1pf
    @TitchTheWonderDog-rp1pf 16 годин тому +2

    Labor commentators on power are FOS

    • @countyorga764
      @countyorga764 15 годин тому

      FOS - you and your orange turd boyfriend.

  • @ObeyOurMasters
    @ObeyOurMasters 17 годин тому

    We will just build more solar and wind farms when he gets in.