Відео

mojang should honestly take notes. Or just hire you tbh

24:15 THAT VOICE CRACK SO EPIC

I'm 6 minutes in and I had to pause to comment how brilliant of an idea it is to make curses increase an items "Enchantability", That's the kind of smart trade offs that make creating a "build" in other games interesting, combined with the other ideas from your previous video and maybe a few more niche unique enchantments it could really create a diverse and interesting decision process in picking your gear. Great suggestion. I haven't finished the video but another idea that some modpacks use (and you touched on a little bit with your gold armor suggestion in your previous video) is to make armor sets have unique advantages and disadvantages to using them so everyone isn't just walking around in different degrees of Netherite. Maybe Netherite could have the highest base defense and the immunity to being destroyed by lava, but have the lowest base enchantablity or significantly reduce swim speed (heavy) Or Gold can have highest enchantability and no enchantment limits (Highly valuable under the new proposed enchantment system) + increased health regeneration, but have middling defense, lowest durability and apply "glowing" to yourself when you take damage making it harder to escape encounters. This is taken from RLCraft to a certain extent- but Leather could be the only armor that goes fully invisible when used with Invisibility Potions. Maybe even have it hide sprint particles to encourage a sort of hit and run invisibility build. With its obvious trade off being the lowest base defense in the game and middling enchantability. Combined with unique enchantments this could go on to create "psuedo-classes" similar to Terraria encouraging different playstyles.

Honestly a Let's Play using this mod would be really worth watching as it would show how you intend all these features to work and play like

great video 👍

modpack when

The Ender Dragon changes are mostly bad ideas. The original fight being a PvE experience with a dragon centrepiece is fine. Bed cheesing is fine, its a very difficult strategy for newbies to employ successfully, as the explosion damage from beds also endangers the player. I don't think speedrunners will find any fight more engaging - look at speedruns of other games with elaborate bosses, its like an autoscroller for runners. The dragon being summoned on the island is good. An optional Ominous fight is good (provided the other means of obtaining Elytra are intact).

I think Mojang should change the elytra. They should make that you can't put mending on it, put make a new enchant called "easy fix" that allows the player to fix the elytra for less phantom membrane.

Regarding early game progression: We run a datapack on our server that disables stone tools and chainmail, and replaces them with copper gear. wood pickaxes become capable of mining copper, and finally iron can only be found at Y20 and below (though is found in larger and more abundant veins. We also made a change to where the recipe for charcoal is removed, but in return coal drops 2-5 pieces. we also made animals and mobs drop significantly more resources (not food, but things like leather or gunpowder) however the catch is that players have to actually perform the kill, mobs drop nothing if they die without a player hitting them. the players on my server have reported that this datapack has made the game more fun than they ever remember early game being prior.

Great series, You gotta have a conversation with white light too y’all would cook

37:00 You don't need to skip the night to avoid phantoms; you just need to rest your eyes for a bit and/or die once an hour. Phantoms spawn per player based on the "time since last rest/death" stat.

Im not going to talk abt the discord incident but when do you think the discord server will be back up?

12:50 I've always thought things with more enchanting power should have lower work costs on the anvil.

For the most part I agree with much that you say, especially since it’s primarily related to the mid-late game or simple / reasonable improvements like with ores / underground biomes; though regarding the early game progression I think it’d be better to leave things as they are or possibly implement a hybrid system, like you throw away wood / stone tools, but must use the smithing table to go from Iron to Diamond and finally Netherite. I just don’t think it logically makes sense to use wood tools to craft stone and then stone for iron since they’re pretty different materials. Though another reason is it could over complicate things, so overall I think the current progression system is the ideal. The only changes I would make though is bumping iron up to 800 durability and add in copper tools/armor at the 250 point, then make copper a requirement to mine iron and some other ores (similar to iron being a requirement for diamonds/emerald). Then maybe a special quality about gold to make it more useful is to be an alloy metal, similar to how it’s used to craft netherite another tool/armor progression could be copper + gold = rose gold with 600 durability and similar faster mining speed / enchantability to make it on par with iron. Other than that I’d like backpacks / knapsacks added to the early-mid game, so I can have a shulker-box-like inventory without the endgame material requirement.

Wandering trader: Only spawn on natural blocks because he scares you VS Skyblock is no longer viable 🤔 Further, only spawning on natural blocks is confusing to the player. If they replace their ground with mycelium they will just never see him.

So did you fix these things or just identify ways to fix them? Clickbait edit: "How I would fix..." is the honest title

People talking about how much time they spent on their video is the worst. You either wanted to make it or not. I'm here to generate you revenue, don't complain you had to work for it

its not that safe but HOLY SHIT this is SO SATTISFYING HOW DOES THIS HAVE ONLY 60 LIKES??? this is soooo cool (but plz dont make anymore of these im so hyped for the minecraft survival balancing mod, i cant wait)

"... Or not using the elytra" laughs in playing since 2009 and not having used elytra once

I saw what happened in the discord and just know I don't support you at all man. Your actions speak for themselves. Also TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS!~

i saw what happened in the discord and just know i still support you man.

Weird structure suggestion, but I think it has potential (in a similar vain to being able to find old terrain gen features rarely): An updated Brick Pyramid, turned into an actual, enormous structure rather than literally just a pile of bricks stretching to world height.

I love the series and ideas but I hate how you call it “fixed” I would prefer something like improved or say you fixed your issues with it I just hate when people say their opinions so objectively

I hope the mod releases soon and i hope to see more videos like these, the quality is supreme. Keep it up and gl on the mod :)

Sucks that differences in personal views got in the way of this project. You’re one of the only channels that really gets what Minecraft needs. Really wish that the drama blows over because I need to see this get finished. Best of luck man

SO FUCKING UNDERRATED

You'll make a modpack for this right?

It's nice to see someone not afraid of their faith (also a Christian) Also, a good change for beds that I saw is in the mod "better than adventure" which changes the recipe of beds to have to be crafted with wool and cloth. cloth is dropped by zombies, meaning to make bed you either need to survival at least one night on your own, or craw into a cave right away. I think taking this idea even father would be interesting perhaps you need to find a bed-frame in a abandoned village or something like that

i personally think a better idea for adding more to the treasure pool for fishing is instead of just adding the heart of the sea, add a buried treasure map in a bottle

for consoles they should give them a more updated version of the legacy console editions (it ran better and works better on controllers than bedrock)

48:40 eyyyyyy I suggested that (or at least was one of the people who did, idk if anyone else also suggested that)

You know, now that you reminded me that parrots exist, I think it would be very cool to play into the shoulder mechanic that they have. My ideia would be so that they can attract mobs, similarly to holding wheat near cows, but without the need of a "feeding/breeding item", that could make relocating some mobs way easier and more enjoyable, like villagers, since they dont have a "feeding item" and the only way to attract them is to tediously open and close the trade menu. That would also fit thematically since parrots are known for mimicking sounds that they hear, so you could imagine that they are talking to the villagers in their own language(since we dont understand it). This also can obviously be applied to other mobs, but the most relevant one really is the villager I think.

Any way this could be made much smaller? Say, 4x6? Ive been looking for exactly this kind of door! Im just not red stone knowledgeable. Thanks!

Very good ideas

Thank u for bringing up how op beds are I remember so well how controversial they were first added I got an idea why don’t we take some inspiration from TFC and make wool only sheerable

Can you make this for bedrock?

I really like your enchanting changes, although I would probably make "maxAnvilLevel" a gamerule of its own, so you can set it to infinity if you want to Just about everything else you put forward I would make no changes to

Ahhh, you went with making Insomnia a true potion effect. Good choice! I had thought of that a while back but at the time I decided against it since I felt using milk to cancel it was too cheesable. Now that I know you can just lay in bed to cancel it, I'm much more lax on also being able to use milk to cure it. My only issue is eating Phantom membranes to cause it manually, that still means you have to get Insomnia normally at least once or deal with cat drop rng. Personally, I think instead you should just be able to brew a Potion of Regeneration with a Fermented Spider Eye to make a Potion of Insomnia, now it's a somewhat lategame way to take control of Insomnia rather a strange, somewhat unintuitive method. My other issue is the Mining Fatigue-like effect upon first getting Insomnia, I think it would get annoying to see that effect every hour after not sleeping, perhaps a more subtle and less intrusive effect would be better.

You could.make it so certaintrims increse the potency of certain types of enchants. Also make the wandering trader sell sponges. Call the map book atlas.

Why you gotta put religion in your vids bro, this is about minecraft not Jesus. It would be like putting alphabet flag on a discord logo of minecraft server SMH

1:01:53 Christian confirmed. Nice.

Nice write up. Many, many interesting mechanics especially night and moon phases. About the tailpiece. The hint word is "sand box game". Not mechanically but conceptually. The game does give some sets of content of its own but player need to come up with their own rules, aesthetic, role play and objective or any combinations of those after some play through. That is obviously not easy. Minecraft is more of world painter/builder in its core and anything lore related content it comes with is merely a frame. Player interprets that frame and paint the picture.

Having watched all your videos, your enchanting system inspired me about a different component of magic; potions. Maybe you could introduce a new bottle, possibly obtained by smelting Soul Sand to make Soul Bottles that could store multiple potion effects in a single potion, but with a cap on the total score dependent on which effects and how much glow stone you’ve added to the potion.

My honest opinion is that quasi-connectivity is a major detriment to new players trying to use pistons for the first time. Mojang should literally just make a new piston that is quasi-connective and fix the classic piston. They could even use amethyst in the recipe and market it as some sort of wireless Redstone tech.

The biome ambience is so important, i personally play a lot of the LOTR mod (legacy) and it just nail the ambience and biome feel perfectly there are to many examples to name them all but here are some Wind sounds when u are high up on a mountain Starring at Barrow-wight causes your fov to increase more and more as it gets closer ocean waves crashing agenst the beach Ambient animals like birds and butterflies depending on biome ex(seagulls on beachs) Ents attack you if u chop down a tree And some recomendation of biomes to look up (all these nail the atmosphere) Mirkwood Fangorn Dead marshes Dol Guldur Mordor Barrow downs Lothlorien Misty Mountains (Sorry for the long comment the tldr i would like base game biomes to get more of a unike identity and embrace the more fantacy styles the nether and caves got)

While I can see the game not being balanced at all, I never really want the villagers to change, and if they do, I'd like it to be toggleable, same with other changes. I just like how it is now, and its a game you can do whatever you want, however you want. Thats why I think changes like this should be optional (let alone when they are changed so long after being added.) All around the whole 'Minecraft balancing' has the issue with people like me, who don't like exploration and like things simple and easy. 45:30 tbh they just look goofy af. I wouldn't mind these changes, as I play on Peaceful 90% of the time

7:38 i have an idea instead of this. using the chisled bookshelfs with a certain book(sharpness IV example) will let the book be enchanted with that enchant only. however it requires more luck the rarer it is(Sharpness 1 is say 50% while IV is 10%). another idea adding on would be to add a more costly rare book that can be enchanted. the recipe could be a book and 9 diamonds to craft a rarer book that allows any enchant to be rolled with exceptions of bad ones

Absolutely kino tweaks, non invasive and always positive. The mod looks like it will become a common addition in many modpacks.

You know, it's really hilarious how you described your ideas for changes for the Wither. I'll get to that in a bit, but I'm first going to start with outdated information you have on the Bedrock wither. About it being worryingly hard: it's not. Not anymore. It definitely can still offer a challenge, but not one that is too hard for people to handle. The Bedrock Wither's reputation mostly comes from the broken state of Bedrock edition, where long ago, the wither effect it dished out ignored absorption hearts and could nullify regeneration, AND the Wither had a chance of becoming invisible AND invincible if you unloaded it by dying. And that's not even the end of it. The true core challenge was the fact that the Protection enchantment prior to 1.19.2 did not defend from potion effects. Meaning that the wither effect dished out by the boss dealt an accumulated 20 hearts (that's dying twice over) of damage every time it hit, unless you used a turtle master potion or an enchanted gapple or if you managed to keep a cow safeguarded during your *_entire_* fight. Add on the lack of saturation-boosted natural regen, and you have a monster that simply cannot be defeated in a war of attrition, but whose entire first phase is designed to discourage a blind charge. Taking on the Wither in a fight in this era required an entire inventory stuffed with potions, milk buckets, gapples and enchanted gapples, instant potions and regen potions and several totems even for experienced players. Unsurprising why recordings of actual Bedrock Wither fights were rarely ever recorded outside of Java-Bedrock comparison videos(i checked), too many ended in genuinely tragic failure. Now though, as long as you have at least ~12 points of protection(full Prot 3 armor) and at minimum iron armor, people can take it on with regular golden apples, some milk and fairly suboptimal weapons. TLDR: It was impossible in the past due to several bugs stacking, but now it's balanced. Speaking of phases, though (and this is why your suggestion is hilarious to me), the Bedrock Wither's phases are noticeably different from the Java edition's. To start off, though, I'll describe general properties: it doesn't heal itself and its fire rate is very slow at first but gets faster through the fight. - So in its first phase, It floats up quite high, and stands still to shoot a burst of skulls at the player before zooming off to another high-off-the-ground point. The player has no way of reaching it, making it very clear to the player that they are intended to attack if from range. _(Sounds familiar?)_ - Let's continue. As mentioned, it already doesn't heal. However, before the explosion that initiates its second phase, the Wither come crashing down to the ground, which gives solid ground for its wither skeletons to move on. From then on, the Wither stays vertically at around a block above the player's head, keeping it in reach of the player's melee attacks. _(Where have I heard this before??)_ - It doesn't typically fly around anymore but instead its infamous dash attack is now its foremost movement option. After two salvos of skulls, it initiates a dash attack. This reduces its general movement giving players clear opportunities to target it. _(What does this make me think of????)_ - It also always fires off a blue skull in a random direction during each of its volleys of skulls, freeing it from being trapped for too long by anything other than the unmovable, unbreakable bedrock blocks. _(OH NOW I SEE!!!!!1!!1!)_ yeah, you basically came to the same conclusion as pocket edition developers did 8 years ago. I kind of just beat this funny coincidence over the head with a cartoonishly oversized sledgehammer, but it makes sense that they came up with those ideas when the platform the Wither would be coming on was still laggy and considered unwieldy, especially with the much smaller screens of the time. Also don't discount mobile combat nowadays. While navigation is indeed tougher, and the typically smaller screen more challenging, they can land hits on whatever they see on the screen as long as they stay in range. With that and the longer reach of bedrock, things even out a lil bit. All in all, the Bedrock Wither, with its vastly different behaviour, really feels like a video game boss. It has readable patterns, it progresses in difficulty, and has clearly defined stages dramatically punctuated by powerful explosions. Its predicability, its lack of movement in the second stage, and the pauses between bursts of skull shots, means that when surviving the wither effect is easier, the boss fight comes out being kind of easier than the java fight even with the inflated health bar. Anyways, that's my lil rant about the Wither fully over. This is almost all from memory. I might have hyperfixated on the Wither for a few months, does it show?

the outro gave me shivers Tysm for this amazing series and I hope to try the mod pack soon