- 24
- 22 295
Broken Banners
Приєднався 12 лют 2024
The official UA-cam channel for the A Song of Ice and Fire: The Miniatures Game (and other games) community, based out of the Tri-State Area. We release battle reports for ASOIAF weekly and host events frequently.
Got a list you want to see tested? Have an idea you think someone should turn into content? Tell us about it! Send us a message on discord, leave a comment on UA-cam, send a carrier pigeon! We love to give the community what it wants, tell us what you want!
discord.gg/NtQMfS7VDe
linktr.ee/singularityasoiaf
Cotter Helldivers v Rickard Karstark
Super Westeros. Our home. Baratheons. Lannisters. The Starks of Winterfell, our ruling houses. But the Iron Throne doesn't come free.
Prove to yourself, that you have the strength, and the courage, to be free (from being free). Join... the Night's Watch.
open.spotify.com/show/0BhpzebLeSZym7kH1aFTC0?si=MJiyxUS6RceBQDFfBHbxVw
Link to APC’s spotify.
Prove to yourself, that you have the strength, and the courage, to be free (from being free). Join... the Night's Watch.
open.spotify.com/show/0BhpzebLeSZym7kH1aFTC0?si=MJiyxUS6RceBQDFfBHbxVw
Link to APC’s spotify.
Переглядів: 483
Відео
Broken Banners Battle Report: Skahaz Vs Stannis OTK
Переглядів 79228 днів тому
Brotherhood of the Broken Banners Presents: Skahaz Vs Stannis. Can the motley crew fight through the heavily armored knights? Timecodes 0:00 - Intro 0:49 - Skahaz Army List 2:27 - Stannis Army List 3:45 - Deployment 4:32 - Round 1 7:48 - Round 2 14:05 - Round 3 19:03 - Round 4 23:12 - Round 5 24:56 - Recap
Brotherhood Without (Broken) Banners: A Rambling Review of the Renegade Rebels
Переглядів 477Місяць тому
Ever want to hear two idiots (poorly) analyze the newest mini-faction to release for the Song of Ice and Fire Miniatures Game? Then hit the play button! Tom and Esad provide analysis from a Baratheon and Stark perspective, diving into the details of the Brotherhood and making recommendations for how to turn your mini faction into a mega faction.
Broken Banners Battle Report: Alliser v Stannis OTK
Переглядів 1,1 тис.Місяць тому
Sixth time's the charm! After numerous technical difficulties and one particularly rude group of 40k players, we finally managed to put out a report with Jeor, the Sand Stag's Alliser Thorne list! Tune in to watch the prickliest Night's Watch soldiers face off against the fervent faithful, devoted to the One True King Stannis Baratheon!
Broken Banners Battle Report: Doran vs Mag S5
Переглядів 1 тис.2 місяці тому
Mag the Mighty has gone clump stumping into Dorne. Will Doran take this insult lying down? Stay tuned to find out!
Broken Banners Battle Report: Grey Worm V Howland Reed
Переглядів 8832 місяці тому
Season 5 is here and we're bringing you new lists! Today we try out some changes to the Targaryen faction and a spicy Stark List full of tricks
Renly 2 v MOD
Переглядів 9203 місяці тому
We're back with Season 5! There aren't many changes this time around but we're eager to test them all out. Mother of Dragons got some nice buffs and Renly 2 got some... nerfs? What? Well, that's alright, Riders of Highgarden are better than ever and the poor fools at the end of their mighty lances will be making an Inexplicable Return to their owner's reserves after they come charging down the ...
Broken Banners Battle Report: Vargo Hoat v Justin Massey
Переглядів 8104 місяці тому
The civil war divides even further as Stannis's own troops fight themselves. The sadistic mercenary, Vargo Hoat rebels and it's up to Justin Massey to set him straight. I sure do hope you like King's Men!
Broken Banners Battle Report: Styr vs Victarion Greyjoy
Переглядів 1,1 тис.4 місяці тому
Styr is furious that Victarion has stolen his toilet seat with warming functionality. He's here to take it back, but Victarion won't give it up so easily.
PA Qualifier FINALS: Benjen v Roose
Переглядів 1 тис.5 місяців тому
The final installation in our first Tournament Series, covering the 2024 Pennsylvania Qualifier Event.
Broken Banners Battle Report: Obara Sand vs Eldon Estermont
Переглядів 1,1 тис.5 місяців тому
Today's match is between Adam, and friend of the channel and Baratheon main Ryan. Footage was filmed at Rogue State Games, roguestate.gg/
Benjen Stark v Loras Tyrell: PA Qualifier
Переглядів 1,1 тис.5 місяців тому
Part 2 of our 3 part tournament series, covering the Pennsylvania Qualifier. Shoutout to GOT_Leamers and the Banish Zone for hosting and supporting a great event!
Broken Banners Battle Report: Ser Jaime Lannister vs Ser Loras Tyrell
Переглядів 1,2 тис.6 місяців тому
A new and exciting, yet rushed ASOIAF battle report. Jamie lannister fights off Loras tyrell over some eggs. Maybe they want an omelette? I really don't know, and i did not ask.
Mallister v Jokin: PA Qualifier
Переглядів 9176 місяців тому
Part 1 of our 3 part tournament series, covering the Pennsylvania Qualifier. Shoutout to GOT_Leamers and the Banish Zone for hosting and supporting a great event!
Maege Mormont v Davos Seaworth
Переглядів 7106 місяців тому
The Lady of Bear Island takes on some poor fingerless smuggler, Davos Seaworth. He and his son fight for their very lives against the aggressive Northmen in the Winds of Winter.
Broken Banners: Going to Tournaments
Переглядів 2867 місяців тому
Broken Banners: Going to Tournaments
Broken Banners Interview - Adepticon Winner 2024 Kenny Ketner
Переглядів 6937 місяців тому
Broken Banners Interview - Adepticon Winner 2024 Kenny Ketner
Broken Banners Battle Report: Ser Gregor Clegane vs Victarion Greyjoy
Переглядів 2 тис.7 місяців тому
Broken Banners Battle Report: Ser Gregor Clegane vs Victarion Greyjoy
Broken Banners Battle Report: Kevan v Baelor
Переглядів 1,1 тис.8 місяців тому
Broken Banners Battle Report: Kevan v Baelor
Broken Banners Battle Report: Jorah Mormont Vs Harmen Uller
Переглядів 1,2 тис.8 місяців тому
Broken Banners Battle Report: Jorah Mormont Vs Harmen Uller
Broken Banners Battle Report: Eldon vs Theon
Переглядів 6448 місяців тому
Broken Banners Battle Report: Eldon vs Theon
Broken Banners Battle Report Roose Bolton Vs Ser Denys Mallister
Переглядів 1 тис.8 місяців тому
Broken Banners Battle Report Roose Bolton Vs Ser Denys Mallister
Broken Banners Battle Report: Eddard Stark v Stannis Baratheon
Переглядів 1,2 тис.9 місяців тому
Broken Banners Battle Report: Eddard Stark v Stannis Baratheon
You need some tags or call the video asoiaf battle report or something like that this video didnt show up when was searching for batreps
Curious, if you think this nice watchlist would perform well against the Targaryen army given the prevalence of cavalry that can react to this outflank
I think so. Targaryens are very mobile but they are also extremely fragile, plus the scorpion is much more threatening against cavalry. Being outflanked protects the ranger hunters from the token dump targaryens have become notorious for, and unless they can take two ranks off the ranger hunters in one go they still have a very significant threat against most everything. Especially with pyke aggression in the deck, dragons are at a high risk of getting one shot.
The spears should not have charged in. The outriders also didn't really do anything. If his units had stayed more clumped up and able to assist each other, the game would have gone better for him.
Thats great input, thank you! I think he might still struggle, between othell, the objective shots, and the scorpion I think he might have still gotten whittled away enough that cotter could break through the front door. But that would have probably been closer.
@@BrokenBanners yeah. And I just had a game this evening that I lost in part to being TOO clumped up so that my sentinel charges failed because there was no room! So it's possible to err too much the other way...
Most bang for buck position of Outriders is really in the center so that there is a higher chance you can pull off the Tactical Reposition shenanigans.
For super watch
The differences between free folk and terminids are surprisingly few
Love me some Cotter Pyke! Rough go for the Starks, but a good batrep nonetheless. No notes immediately come to mind, maybe the Stark player could’ve abandoned the side with the Scorpion and forced it to need 6’s?
I think thats probably a good start. The scorpion didnt really do anything but the threat of it helped get the ranger hunters into a dominant position.
Great battle report! Skahaz is a really fun commander when you get the right cards at the right moments. It looks like you pulled some of his cards right when you needed them. Double Brazen Beasts is a bold move but definitely a fun list to see in action. I felt bad for the Outriders, unable to do much pew-pew.
Yea I sent them off on their lonesome didn't I? double brazen beasts was definitely fun, I might try that in another shell, just maybe not with grey worm attachment.
"The Brazen Beast" is gonna have to be my porn alias
Great review. One thing, the situation you described where an archer unit shoots into an enemy engaged with Thoros, he passes morale, gains a token, and then spends it when the enemy fails their moral doesn't work as described. The friendly panic test for shooting into combat occurs at the end of the attack, so after the enemy resolves their panic test. In order to do what you described Thoros would need to already have a token when the attack starts
Thank you for clarifying. I did not make clear that firing into melee *when you have one token to start* is a replenishing loop.
Ah man, this was a brutal list to go up against. It really helped convince me that my renly side list was in general, better equiped to deal with targ damage and ncus. I definitely misplayed a bit and was very much still learning where my kingsmen needed to be deployed. Aside from that charge that I should've done with stannis at the end there, wasting my S&S revive was a pretty goofy mistake too, gotta be more aware in the future. The amount of control this list dishes out is brutal. A great game as always Adam!
@@Alkeseltze one unit of Brazen Beasts is bad enough, two is just unethical lol.
Barristan Selmy can't cancel Selyse & Shireen's once per game as it doesn't target (because the ability doesn't let you choose a specific unit out of multiple possible targets, it's not a tactics card or order that mentions the unit or belongs to the unit, and the word "target" is not used). If Selyse & Shireen would be somehow canceled then you could use the ability later that round to save a unit because it also cancels the "once per game" part.
@@jpjankala3454 thanks! Yeah we figured it out after the fact in the BB discord. Been at this game for a year now and I'm still learning how different interactions work. At least I know for the future. Thanks again for taking the time to get into how that interaction works
Half of the challenge of using Barristan properly is knowing what Barristan can interact with! Thanks for the explanation, no one caught it until we started discussing that play much later.
I think this goes to show that if you can weaken an archer unit you absolutely should
It definitely makes my non-rerolling archer unit even less efficient, 100%.
Literally yelled at my phone when he melee attacked with the Lightbringers instead of charging with Stannis. One unit of Brazens is bad enough, two is just brutal lol.
For what it's worth, I'm yelling at myself too, not sure what I was looking at or thinking when I didn't just go for the charge there. 😅
I've been on the receiving end of double sentinel enough that I jumped at the chance to try it out for myself.
Cool batrep. Fun to see a targ list that’s not all cavalry and dragons! 😊
Glad you enjoyed. Part of the draw to Targs for me was the diverse cast of units, it was fun to try and showcase other units for a change.
The Shavepate!
As a Targ player, I need to give Skahaz a try. I have yet to field him as a commander.
He’s really good, played against him many times.
I've only played him once or twice before this, and I was pretty impressed after the game. Definitely will try and find more lists to run him in after this!
Get me my two starters now.
So much better than 3 Fails Gaming
Does the Stark player have hallow cards?
Great review, guys. Can’t wait to get my hands on this new faction!
Same here! - Esad
A great breakdown, didn't event think about the Pirates being an interesting choice for the Brotherhood. It's going to be great to see them on the table! I appreciate the deep dive.
Brotherhood has such an excellent, versatile toolkit, I think we're going to see a lot of awesome combinations with them.
Awesome video as always
Thank you! I hope the community is as excited for Brotherhood as I am! -Esad
I would love to play against such reckless bara player, like omg, charging counterstriking unit with weakened token and potential pathetic attempt to be played xD
I played against him last night as well and got blown up by some final strikes; the scales are balanced. Always fun to play with Ryan! -Esad
Are you able to use a NCU to take a table zone if the tactics board is full?
No, in the 2021 edition of the rules (current edition) an NCU MUST have a tactics board zone that they can claim. Even in Here We Stand, where an NCU can take a spot on the tactics board, they must have a spot on the Tactics Board available. -Esad
Nice game and fun comments. Even if i "hate" Martells (who doesn't?), I nearly find them friendly thx to you :D Solos count their HP when contesting an objective, not their number of ranks :) Lucky Derreck indeed !
Yes solos count wounds remaining for ranks. I’m very happy you enjoyed the game :)
KM need nerfs? No, people just need to take away the crowns from Baratheons, that's reduce the power of KM by 50%.
Funny enough I don’t think their offensive power is an issue. People often cite to that as the issue but they’re not the hardest hitting unit in the game, not by a long shot. I think the issue is To The Last is too much on them and is too big of a “list check.” That strong of a defensive ability on such an offensive unit is insane and I think with Brotherhood without Banners on the horizon we’ll truly see what King’s Men are capable of. I am adamantly of the opinion that To The Last should be replaced with Relentless. -Esad
@@BrokenBanners that TTL is there so KM wont get oneshoted. We have such aggressive meta (Victorian SM, Gregor CRHG, Pyke, Khal) that TTL is required, as they dont have any other defensive ability.
Hard to disagree with that. Season 5 may not be as bad as Season 3 and the Golden Company Swords meta but there are still so many commander-unit combos that consistently kill a unit in two attacks. Maybe I'm just bitter that Rose Knights still suck. -Esad
Very rough lists and good play on both sides, well done!
Thank you! Always happy to get a game in against Ryan. Good luck to everyone who gets him at Nationals! -Esad
Man oh man I definitely will chase the high of making a 6 up charge for the remainder of my days. I can fortunately say i do make some charges, but i definitely have a tendency to roll below average for 4+ charges. This game was 100% closer than it had any right to be, but one of the things i have learned from our play group is how to keep pushing when behind, which brings up something I haven't gotten down just yet, other factions' base tactics decks. Nightswatch is definitely one of the match ups i havent had a lot of games into until recently. It's why i made that early charge into the vets with my stag knights, i thought with the stannis card buff, I'd make an impact, maybe survive another turn, sadly I didn't anticipate the clapback. This is a lesson I plan on remembering. Either way, a great battle, I always enjoy our matches, you provide a lot of insight afterwards and I feel like I always learn something new! Can't wait for the next match and the next battle report!
You are notorious for failing charges; even 2+ charges are (generally) a challenge for your Baratheons so it was great to have a game where you nailed so many charges. I think this game, and the way you played it, is a great lesson for anyone interested in competitive play. Everyone will make "that" mistake, or miss "that" roll and put the game in a losing position. Being able to pull it back and at least make it a closer game is huge for tournament scoring. I've seen many a player edge out the difference between third and second based on that kind of play, and a few times even the difference between first and second! -Esad
Your tight and substantial batt reps are the best in this game system man. Love your work! Keep it up!
Glad you like them! We will keep on making them! 😎
Jet powered vets at 20:00
How dare you “eh” the one true king?! But real talk cool nights watch
Thank you! I'd like Stannis a lot better if he wasn't Stannis, but was instead the better (surviving) brother. No rose knights, no interest. -Esad
There is always something special on a game ending on that last dice roll. What an intsense battle!
Gameplay begins at 10:54
Thank y’all so much! Y’all look like you’re having so much fun when you’re doing battle reports.
I was waiting for you to see this. I hope it’s everything you wanted!
super roll dice!🤩👍
good to hear your voice you sexy polish fuck. love you jan.
Sadly, the Shadowcat does not deploy like regular outflank. Your opponent should not have been able to put him on outflank during deployment (he would have had to deploy a different unit normally).
Upon further review, you are correct. Thank you!
@@BrokenBanners Sure thing. There were also some charging alignment issues, but I don't think they impacted the outcome of the game. Fun battle report -- well done!
Wow that was one of the tightest games I’ve ever seen! Can’t believe that roll at the end!
I was like, there is no way it could happen. Insane stuff
Great video!
Really enjoyed the video. I would tone the music down though.
This was great I really enjoyed the commentary
I appreciate it!
Mother of Dragons went from a competitive list to bonkers good. I don't know why the devs felt the need to buff her to the extend they did. I say this as a Targaryen Player myself. I have used her a handful of times since the patch and have crushed my opponents every time. Between, Threaten, Xaro, Tycho, and Fire made flash, it's almost impossible to kill a dragon. You would literally have to one shot them, which is possible but highly unlikely if the Targ player is positioning them well. I suspect she will be toned back down in the future, I just hope they don't nerf the dragons again.
Its an interesting dynamic. Threaten and some other tools available to targ drastically improve the survivability of a dragon, especially when fire made flesh is factored in. They bring a lot of unmitigatable damage on a unit that essentially doesnt take panic damage. But I think we’re seeing a lot of tools coming out with other factions that help keep it in check. Baratheons have gained some mobility and damage consistency, combined with the infamous final strike. Starks have a lot of alpha strike still and with their mobility I think even with one of (but not multiple) of a targ player’s tools a dragon can get beat up. I agree that with all of the tools available its very difficult to kill a dragon. I think control elements are going to become more and more important as factions, including targs with MOD, gain access to some really powerful and hard to deal with units. I want to get some more games in against dragons with not-Renly 2 and see how it fairs, as well as some nights watch. I think MOD buffs are nice but I dont think they pass drogo… yet
The stark Player should get two points at the end of the Round Right? Middle objektive plus the trackers
Yes! fortunately that doesn't affect too much, but you're right. Good eye!
When you shoot you should measure from centre of tray not corner. At 9.29 there was a wrong shoot
Yup, that's a good catch!
9:22 you measure the distance for long and short range shots from the tip of the arrow on the tray, not from every point of the tray
Yup, the bowmen needed to slide a bit closer probably. Good catch!
Wow! Amazing detail with your description and gameplay! Would be awesome to make this a mobile game!? Think about talking with some mobile-app game developers! I would be down to play! 🎉
Thanks for the kind words! That would be fun, and would sure make it easier to get more games in.
Great game🎉
I was edging in my seat to the very end great game gents
Great job as always! Maybe some Skahaz or Belwas list for the future battle reps? :)
Great video, great battle. I'm going to have to watch out for the Howland bowmen combo in the future! Can't wait for the next one!
Superior flanking goddamnit
IM SORRY I KEPT FORGETTING ILL BE BETTER
Bog devil's charged the flank and forgot Howlands ambush order for tokens