Football Manager Data Lab
Football Manager Data Lab
  • 4
  • 7 531
FMDataLab Updates | Football Manager 2024
Sign Up To FMDataLab www.fmdatalab.com
View all changes on the changelog www.fmdatalab.com/changelogs/attribute-weights
Download FMDataLab Views from Here: www.mediafire.com/file/73j1o2vtd1gp8vx/FMDataLab_Views.zip/file
--------------------- SOCIALS ---------------------------
Twitter: FMDataLab
UA-cam: youtube.com/@FMDataLab
Instagram: FMDataLab
Tiktok: tiktok.com/@FMDataLab
----------------------------------------------------------------
Переглядів: 604

Відео

How to Calculate Role Scores in Football Manager with FMDataLab #fm24 #footballmanager
Переглядів 451Місяць тому
Sign Up To FMDataLab www.fmdatalab.com Learn how Role Scores are calculated in FMDataLab using attribute weights. Download FMDataLab Views from Here: www.mediafire.com/file/73j1o2vtd1gp8vx/FMDataLab_Views.zip/file SOCIALS Twitter: FMDataLab UA-cam: youtube.com/@FMDataLab Instagram: FMDataLab Tiktok: tiktok.com/@FMDataLab
Data Driven Football Manager 2024 Recruitment | FMDataLab | #fm24
Переглядів 7 тис.Місяць тому
Sign Up To FMDataLab www.fmdatalab.com Elevate your Football Manager Recruitment Strategy with FMDataLab to rank position roles for players from your Football Manager Save! Download FMDataLab Views from Here: www.mediafire.com/file/73j1o2vtd1gp8vx/FMDataLab_Views.zip/file SOCIALS Twitter: FMDataLab UA-cam: youtube.com/@FMDataLab Instagram: FMDataLab Tiktok: tiktok.com/...

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @macauleysmith1046
    @macauleysmith1046 18 годин тому

    Great work! Followed this step by step and getting a error - invalid config. Mac user here, any clues mate?

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 16 годин тому

      Where are you getting this error? Somewhere specfically on FMDataLab or within FM24?

    • @macauleysmith1046
      @macauleysmith1046 11 годин тому

      @@FMDataLab it was within FMDataLab but I’ve managed to sort it. Thanks. I do have another problem within DataLab where I’ve hidden several collums and can’t see how to un-hide them?

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 11 годин тому

      Glad to hear! What was the issue, if you don't mind me asking? I might be able to make a friendlier error message. Above the table, in the top right, there is a "View" button, if you click on it, it will show you all the columns, and you can toggle their visibility there.

  • @gammagogeta
    @gammagogeta 3 дні тому

    Thanks for adding a new way to play FM24, appreciate it.

  • @GodAtum
    @GodAtum 15 днів тому

    it would be great to do it the opposite way. make the best tactic with the players you have

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 15 днів тому

      I actually had something like that in my original spreadsheet, so is something I could potentially add in the future.

  • @Y15ARG
    @Y15ARG 15 днів тому

    Just came across your work through FM Arena My big question is whether or not your weightings take account of the in-game positional ability score (1-20)?

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 15 днів тому

      No, I don't believe that value is available in any of the table views, as that value is position-by-position basis for a player, and not a value on the player as a whole. I just use the `Position` column to determine which positions a player can play. So if a player only `Competent` at a position, I unfortunately don't have that information available.

  • @zvonimirbrekalo1291
    @zvonimirbrekalo1291 19 днів тому

    Love this video! Cured my insomnia

  • @shaunhoward7876
    @shaunhoward7876 20 днів тому

    This is totally awsome. Is there a way to search for wonder kids?

  • @Echoes-kx2sz
    @Echoes-kx2sz 21 день тому

    Followed this tutorial and using the Squad view, yet getting the error: Missing the following Required columns for processing: Left Foot, Right Foot. (and no column has prefered foot and if i add it i still get the same error).

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 21 день тому

      This has been the 2nd time this has been raised, not sure what the issue is and have been unabled to recreate. It seems that exported .html have the "Left Foot" & "Right Foot" columns as "Left" & "Right" but the cells for those rows have no data, where it should have values like "Very Strong", "Weak", "Reasonable" etc. My suggestions would be; - Ensure you are using FM24 (If you have an FM23 save ported over to FM24, that might potentially cause an issue?) - Delete the view and redownload the view and import it again (The columns in the list should have "Left Foot" & "Right Foot", you can also check the exported .html file and ensure it's not just "Left" & "Right") - Customise the view, remove the "Left" & "Right" columns and replace with "Left Foot" & "Right Foot" (Click on view > Custom > Customise Current View, then in the "Filter" tab select "General" and "Left Foot" & "Right Foot" should be there, if not then that will be the issue) - If you are using a custom skin, revert back to the default skin (and repeat the above steps if necessary) - Check if you create a new save and repeat the steps above, does the issue persist. - Use the English (UK) language before export. And for all of the above, be sure that you clear you cache afterwards (Preferences > Reset > Clear Cache) and double check if the issue persists. And a few questions to see if i can find the source of this issue and find a fix or suggest a solution; - Do you have attribute masking enabled? - Are you using a custom database? - Do you have a custom skin? (especially when you initially imported the view) - Do you have the in-game editor enabled? - What version of the game is your save? (are you using the base version or the 24.3.0 update) - What game mode are you using? (Career, Create-a-club etc.) - By default, what is your in-game language? - Is this an issue on all views or a specific view? - Don't think this should really matter, but which store did you purchase FM24 from (Steam, Epic Store etc.)?

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 21 день тому

      Also, think I found your file, and it seems that the attribute values also weren't exported correctly (all the cells for those columns for all players were empty)

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 21 день тому

      Hey, I have added a quick fix to work with the "Left"/"Right" columns if the "Left Foot" & "Right Foot" columns are missing. However, as mentioned in my previous comment, the attribute values are all missing, so you may need to try another export and double check the exported .html that is has all the expected data before uploading.

  • @john_connerson
    @john_connerson 21 день тому

    This is a really cool app! I think it would enhance the experience if I could customize the default table that appears after uploading my files. I often delete unnecessary columns and would like to save this layout for future uploads. It would be a nice time-saver to not repeatedly delete columns every time.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 21 день тому

      Yes, I've had that on my roadmap, hopefully will get to this feature soon. Thanks for the suggestion.

  • @user-me5xs7nq8r
    @user-me5xs7nq8r 22 дні тому

    I allways get the error message: Missing the following Required columns for processing: Left Foot, Right Foot. Please ensure when exporting data that you use the "English" language, when exporting in another language, FMDataLab cannot parse the column names from the table in the .html file. Please, also ensure you are using the correct views as provided by FMDataLab when exporting data from Football Manager. Ensure there is players within your file and that you've used the provided views before exporting your data from Football Manager. If you are using a custom skin within Football Manager, that can also causes issues, so try reverting to the default skin when exporting data.. And in View squad is no data of prefer foot.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 22 дні тому

      Thanks for raising this. I think I found your file, looks like your exported file has the column names for "Left Foot"/"Right Foot" as just "Left" & "Right" This could be an issue if you are using a custom skin, or you may need to clear your cache. I have double checked the squad view, on a new save, and it should have the columns as "Left Foot" & "Right Foot". If there no data ever, then that might be an issue in your save/game/skin, but there is sometimes no data if you have attribute masking enabled. A few things to check; You are using FM24 You are exporting while using the English Language You are using the default skin Try deleting the fmdatalab_squad_view, redownload and import again (while using the default skin) You could also try and remove the "Left" & "Right" columns by customising the view, and try to add them back manually, this may bring back the correct names and values? You have cleared cache (Preferences > Reset > Clear Cache)

    • @user-me5xs7nq8r
      @user-me5xs7nq8r 21 день тому

      @@FMDataLab I tried the default skin and 2 skins Mustermann, Statman but only the Statman skin shows Left Right foot but all View save files still have the error as above.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 21 день тому

      Hmm, at a bit of a loss here, this is the first instance where I've come across this issue in over a thousand different files. I will look into handling just `Left` & `Right` column names, but if they never have any values it seems like there is some depper issue that needs resolved in your game, if you have already tried all the solutions above and clearing the cache each time.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 21 день тому

      Hey, I have added a hot fix so you can now view your file if you reload FMDataLab, obviosuly, the caveat being that there will not be any details on each players strength with either foot as the cells for Left/Right are empty in your file. But at least now you can see the table without the error message. But there still seems there is a problem with your export, and not just the "Left Foot"/"Right Foot" columns being replaced with "Left" & "Right", but without any data in the cells. While the column for Nationality exists, all the cells are empty, where you would expect it to always have data for that column. (2nd Nationality works fine) So it's most likely some of issue with the export in your game in general/your save, rather than the view. Could be as something as simple as using an older machine that doesn't handle the exports very well.

    • @user-me5xs7nq8r
      @user-me5xs7nq8r 19 днів тому

      @@FMDataLab Thank you very much, I have been able to load data files such as squad or player search, but the short list file still has the case of left and right feet.

  • @TheArccam
    @TheArccam 23 дні тому

    This is insane, and will help a lot of people out with their squad building. I was hoping you'd make views for previous versions (it seems like if I try and use this for my FM21 save, the view doesn't show. I am attached to that save in particular and still play it to this day). If you can, hopefully allow other people who haven't got the newer version to use your website.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 22 дні тому

      I could add this feature to the roadmap, could be useful.

  • @dinz7719
    @dinz7719 28 днів тому

    Stumbled on to this the other day randomly and I really like the way it is laid out, colour scheme the fact I can default my weightings and tactic roles to be readily available. I'd be interested to know for your colouration of the scores, what thresholds are you using? Is it something arbitrary or have you looked at existing players to determine the thresholds? As a side note I think making an easier way to copy the information across to a spreadsheet would be useful. I tend to use a spreadsheet to whittle down these scorings on my scouting list to my shortlist and direct targets. It also would help with a pet project I have for myself. I know from your previous videos, you have seen squirrel making his python app but one thing that he has also recently done is his trajectory piece which I really liked and so I've been crunching the numbers (he released the data he used) and integrating the weightings from this app into that trajectory piece for different roles that I use as opposed to his own tactic. I'd love to be able to just lift the details off of this straight into the spreadsheet to generate the trajectory but they paste in a really odd way with the name in a different line. Just makes it awkward to handle the data, not sure if there is something in the app that could be tweaked to adjust that copy pasting or even to generate a table that is easily pasted/saved. Will continue to use the app after all I have to support someone who sounds pretty local to me.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 28 днів тому

      Thanks for checking out FMDataLab! The colours are mostly just a gradient going from red to green. So it goes from shades of red, to orange, to yellow, to green. 1 - 5.49 is shades of red 5.5 - 9.49 is shades of orange 9.5 - 12.49 is shades of yellow 12.5 - 20 is shades of green (bit more of wider range as the highest score you'll really see is 17) Yes, an export of the table has been on my roadmap, for the reason you've explained, think it will be helpful for further analysis! Funnily enough, I've also been working on an algorithm to predict players trajectories for a few weeks now, so you'll be able to view each individual players role trajectory based on the median trajectory of other players at that age, for that role that my algorithm has calculated (will have a video on how I've gone about this). This will be in the next release you'll be happy to hear!

  • @bentaygaxx3452
    @bentaygaxx3452 28 днів тому

    the hero we didn t know we need..

  • @Boubben
    @Boubben 29 днів тому

    This is sooo awesome! I have been using this all day. Makes it so much easier for me to find the right players. Easy to use and easy to understand. Thank you!!!

    • @mrslotved
      @mrslotved 25 днів тому

      is it fun to cheat ?

    • @Boubben
      @Boubben 25 днів тому

      @@mrslotved nope

  • @Cianfss
    @Cianfss 29 днів тому

    Great job man, I’m subscribing

  • @felix597
    @felix597 29 днів тому

    Hi, looks really cool. Unfortunatlly it doesnt work for me.. I allways get the error message "Missing the following Required columns for processing: Sec. Position, Height, Weight, Inf, Club, Division, 2nd Nat, Pros, Cons, Transfer Value, Personality, Media Handling, Age, Caps, Goals, Wage, Left Foot, Right Foot, Acc, Aer, Agi, Bra, Cmd, Cnt, Com, Cmp, Cro, Dec, Det, Fin, Ecc, Fir, Han, Hea, Jum, Kic, Ldr, Lon, L Th, Mar, Nat, OtB, Pac, Pen, Pos, Pun, Sta, Str, Thr, TRO, Vis, Wor, Cor. Please ensure you are using the correct views as provided by this web application when exporting data from Football Manager. If you are using a custom skin within Football Manager, that can also causes issues, so try reverting to the default skin when exporting data. Ensure there is players within your file and that you've used the provided views before exporting your data from Football Manager. If you are using a custom skin within Football Manager, that can also causes issues, so try reverting to the default skin when exporting data." I changed my skin to the default one and also tried different lists from Shortlist to Players in Reach (obviously with the imported views). Have you got an idea what the problem can be? Really cool project!

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 29 днів тому

      Hi! Are you using the English Language in Football Manager when exporting? The exported .html file has a table and the column headers are different for each language.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 29 днів тому

      Just had a look at what I think is your file, it looks like it's in German. But you've highlighted that I should probably add checking your in-game language to that error message, thanks for spotting :)

    • @felix597
      @felix597 27 днів тому

      @@FMDataLab yes mate, that should ne my data, so I have to switch the game to english language and it should work?

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab 27 днів тому

      Yeah, you can just switch to English before you export, then switch back to German after your export. At some point in the future I do plan on mapping all language columns to work for all in-game languages. But, sorry for the hassle in the interim.

    • @felix597
      @felix597 25 днів тому

      @@FMDataLab thanks mate, it worked out when changing the language :)

  • @tabletbrothers3477
    @tabletbrothers3477 Місяць тому

    Mega mega update! One slight thing to add for next time. In the "Roles" section of the detailed player screen, I would like for each position to be collapsible, and if they can't play the position it would be collapsed by default. I think this would help with readability/clutter. You most likely aren't going to the roles section and looking at roles a player can't play (unless you want to train them into a new position). Having only the positions that they can play be expanded by default would help with having to do lots of scrolling, especially for strikers.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab Місяць тому

      Thanks for the great suggestion! I'll implement this in the next update!

  • @tabletbrothers3477
    @tabletbrothers3477 Місяць тому

    The reason those players were all 1s is because the player export is finicky, and it sometimes decides that it will only export the attributes of the first 30 or so players

  • @tabletbrothers3477
    @tabletbrothers3477 Місяць тому

    Sweet!! Gonna take a look at it now!

  • @tabletbrothers3477
    @tabletbrothers3477 Місяць тому

    First!

  • @tabletbrothers3477
    @tabletbrothers3477 Місяць тому

    Very cool! As you pointed out, Squirrel Plays did beat you to the punch. Because of this, I will be comparing the two programs. And, after using both programs, here's some feedback: What I Found to be Better than Squirrel's: - I liked all the different sorting options within each column - I found the color coded grades to be much more readable than the plain white one on Squirrel's - I liked the tactics feature, even though it feels underutilized - The file save feature is new compared to squirrel's. I may not use it that much since I don't feel the need to come back to old files, but it's nice to have I guess. Bugs: - On your table tutorial, the text for the "Overall Best Role" is the same tutorial text as the "Best Role (Position(s))" - The individual player view screen tutorial didn't really work. The first box was halfway off-screen and when I clicked next it closed out the player and went back to the table. I could at least read the second box, but clicking finish closed the player tab again. Room for Improvement (more like a wish list): - The biggest turn off for me was not having editable weighting. I really enjoy the ability to adjust role attribute weighting, and that really is a dealbreaker for me to not have that. - I would really like a "replace file" button, so I don't have to delete then re-import - Is it not possible to detect what view the user is importing based on the types of columns? Then you could just use the system file name as your file name streamlining the process. - Just overall streamlining. In squirrels I only need 4-7 clicks on the website to get a new file imported. On your site I would need 9-14 clicks + typing in file name + deleting old file wait time + 2x page load wait time (I'm always on a table view from when I was last looking at a file) - The fact that EVERY TIME you sort the table you're sent to a new page makes your back arrow useless/clogs up your page history - Why not have the ability to sort "Best Role (Position(s))" and "Overall Best Role"? - The biggest selling point of this web app over squirrel's is the tactics feature, but I don't think you are making the best use of it. - I would love to see a "Best Role (Position(s)) in Tactic" column - I would like to have the ability to have the positions in the position column only show positions in your tactic. Yes, you can select positions at the moment, but there is still clutter. (Player has M(RC), but I only use M(C)

    • @tabletbrothers3477
      @tabletbrothers3477 Місяць тому

      If you want to save files for the web app I feel local storage would be much faster and I wouldn't need to sign in Hopefully, I haven't said too many negative things about your app. I do genuinely think it's a good app, and the many hours of work put into it are quite obvious.

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab Місяць тому

      Really appreciate the great feedback. You've made some really good points. I've already started work on the weighting feature you'll be glad to hear!

    • @tabletbrothers3477
      @tabletbrothers3477 Місяць тому

      @@FMDataLab I'll be weighting!... oh that was awful

    • @FMDataLab
      @FMDataLab Місяць тому

      @@tabletbrothers3477 The "weight" is over. I've just added the ability to edit attribute weights in the latest FMDataLab release. My recent video covers all the updates.

    • @TruongPham-wm1yf
      @TruongPham-wm1yf 29 днів тому

      Thank you for the amazing work and passion for the game mate!