- 30
- 3 894
A Genteel Black Hole
United Kingdom
Приєднався 30 гру 2023
I'm Ally (they/he), a BookTube newbie with passions for sci-fi, fantasy, murder mystery, Shakespeare, old Hollywood, weird music, puns, footnotes, and keeping obsessive lists. I'm disabled so I have no plans to stick to a schedule. Videos will appear when I manage to make them. Panda companion*.
"A good bookshop is just a genteel Black Hole that knows how to read." ~ Terry Pratchett
(*Bear with me.)
"A good bookshop is just a genteel Black Hole that knows how to read." ~ Terry Pratchett
(*Bear with me.)
Discworld, Cadfael, and more... November 2024 Reading Wrap-up
After a month on the Struggle Bus, I finally seem to have regained my reading equilibrium. Here's a review of all the books I read in November, plus my most-played bands and most-watched shows.
Music used is available from bugprentice.bandcamp.com/
00:00 - The intro bit
00:52 - The Sanctuary Sparrow
04:00 - Feet of Clay
08:14 - Of Mice and Men
11:22 - The Dark is Rising
14:21 - Other media
16:45 - The outro bit
Music used is available from bugprentice.bandcamp.com/
00:00 - The intro bit
00:52 - The Sanctuary Sparrow
04:00 - Feet of Clay
08:14 - Of Mice and Men
11:22 - The Dark is Rising
14:21 - Other media
16:45 - The outro bit
Переглядів: 52
Відео
Why I DNFed Evelyn Waugh's Scoop
Переглядів 4621 годину тому
I recently started reading Evelyn Waugh's Scoop. The first two chapters were hilarious, but I ended up DNFing after 100 pages. Here's why. Music used is available from bugprentice.bandcamp.com/ 00:00 - The intro bit 00:16 - Scoop 06:14 - The outro bit
How To Start Reading... Some rambling thoughts
Переглядів 5614 днів тому
The other day I watched a video with advice on how to get into reading. The advice didn't connect with me at all, so I felt compelled to make my own video on the subject. If my own advice doesn't fit your needs, please disregard it! Music used is available from bugprentice.bandcamp.com/ 00:00 - The intro bit 02:17 - Book length 03:45 - Familiar stories 08:16 - Familiar genres 13:45 - DNFing 19:...
Used Bookstore Tag (created by @booksimnotreading)
Переглядів 7021 день тому
This tag was created by Kelly @booksimnotreading. Thanks for tagging me! Kelly's original video: ua-cam.com/video/-vrGD8maL8E/v-deo.html If you want to take part, consider yourself tagged. Music used is available from bugprentice.bandcamp.com/ The questions: 1. What is your favorite (or most often visited) used bookstore, and what sets it apart or makes it special? 2. Does your used bookstore t...
All aboard the struggle bus... October 2024 Reading Wrap-up
Переглядів 58Місяць тому
A little chat about the books I read (or tried to read!) in October, plus my most-played bands and most-watched TV shows. Music used is available from bugprentice.bandcamp.com/ 00:00 - The intro bit 02:08 - Maskerade 04:31 - Troilus & Cressida 11:00 - Howards End 14:06 - DNF: Chekhov plays / The Road to Roswell 18:18 - Other media 21:13 - The outro bit Other channels mentioned: @ReadBecca @step...
Reluctant TBR Tag... Books I kinda sorta wanna read
Переглядів 145Місяць тому
This tag was created by @ChloeFrizzle, and I was invited to participate by @booksimnotreading. Thanks Kelly! Chloe's original video: ua-cam.com/video/anOCno6BEMc/v-deo.html Kelly's video: ua-cam.com/video/IB8ubeRW8sA/v-deo.html Other channels mentioned: @noteworthyfiction @AaronReadABook Music used is available from bugprentice.bandcamp.com/ The questions: What is a book you want to read, but.....
Maskerade review... Pratchett does Phantom!
Переглядів 83Місяць тому
I re-read Terry Pratchett's Maskerade recently, and I have thoughts... Other channels mentioned: @TheBookThing 00:00 - The intro bit 01:28 - What's it all about? 05:53 - What I could do without 08:02 - Here be spoilers 10:28 - And in conclusion 11:30 - The outro bit
My best book of the year... September 2024 Reading Wrap-up
Переглядів 602 місяці тому
A little chat about all the books I read in September 2024, including my favourite book of the year so far! 00:00 - The intro bit 01:26 - A Room with a View 06:44 - Ashenden (DNF) 09:05 - Cymbeline 11:21 - The Enchanted April 15:26 - All's Well That Ends Well 18:06 - Still in progress: 3 Shades of Blue / Maskerade 19:15 - The outro bit Storygraph link: app.thestorygraph.com/profile/genteelblack...
Cymbeline: Mess or Masterpiece? (Shaketember 2024)
Переглядів 993 місяці тому
Cymbeline: Mess or Masterpiece? (Shaketember 2024)
What Is It About Books? Tag... Why do we love these things?
Переглядів 923 місяці тому
What Is It About Books? Tag... Why do we love these things?
Shakespeare Journey Tag (Shaketember 2024)
Переглядів 443 місяці тому
Shakespeare Journey Tag (Shaketember 2024)
All My Reads in August 2024... Passing, Solaris and more!
Переглядів 493 місяці тому
All My Reads in August 2024... Passing, Solaris and more!
Medical Grade Music book review... Steve Davis & Kavus Torabi on their favourite prog rock!
Переглядів 533 місяці тому
Medical Grade Music book review... Steve Davis & Kavus Torabi on their favourite prog rock!
A Trip to the Bookshop... Found an intriguing sci-fi anthology!
Переглядів 4294 місяці тому
A Trip to the Bookshop... Found an intriguing sci-fi anthology!
My First Book Haul... Comedic classics, Le Carré and cryptic crosswords!
Переглядів 1444 місяці тому
My First Book Haul... Comedic classics, Le Carré and cryptic crosswords!
Mid-Year Reading Breakdown 2024... Comedy, Cadfael and more!
Переглядів 484 місяці тому
Mid-Year Reading Breakdown 2024... Comedy, Cadfael and more!
I'm So Annoyed Tag... Bookish things that get right on me proverbials!
Переглядів 789 місяців тому
I'm So Annoyed Tag... Bookish things that get right on me proverbials!
Reading Hopes for 2024... My TBR for the year ahead: Pratchett, Hobb, Christie and more!
Переглядів 6310 місяців тому
Reading Hopes for 2024... My TBR for the year ahead: Pratchett, Hobb, Christie and more!
Reading Wrap-up for 2023... Best and worst books I read last year!
Переглядів 8911 місяців тому
Reading Wrap-up for 2023... Best and worst books I read last year!
Booktube Newbie Tag... Well it's something to do, isn't it?
Переглядів 20311 місяців тому
Booktube Newbie Tag... Well it's something to do, isn't it?
Maybevember... and nice to see that the bus has been sent to the depot. Of Mice and Men is, as you say, potent. A brutal tale. A worthy book. And I made it that far but cannot re-subscribe. Best, Mark.
@@book-ramble You’ve already made number go up, for which you have my sincere thanks! I hope your month is Decembrilliant.
@@genteelblackhole 🤣
I must agree with you on Scoop's first two chapters. Definitely laugh out loud material. Racism-of-the-day aside, the story has too many characters and quickly becomes a tedious madcap farce. It's a bit of a slog to finish. A book badly in need of bowdlerisation and paring down and, as you say, might have worked much better as a short story. PS Have you ever read Flann O'Brien's The Third Policeman (a dark comic novel set in Ireland)? It's a little bit experimental but nothing too outlandish. One for the bookshelf in my opinion.
@@Raymond-d2l7n Thanks for commenting, I’m glad I didn’t miss much by DNFing Scoop. I haven’t read the Third Policeman yet, but it’s on my radar. I’ll bump it up my wishlist!
Love Feet of Clay. The City Watch books are really the high watermark for Discworld. If you want more Steinbeck, Grapes of Wrath is a fantastic book, that being said, like Of Mice and Men it’s also pretty short on chuckles. I remember that Columbo episode
@@TheBookThing I have a soft spot for the Witches, but the City Watch books are probably the benchmark for Discworld, yeah! I’ve seen the film of Grapes of Wrath, that’s a heart-rending couple of hours - Henry Fonda was amazing as Tom Joad. It’s definitely on my list of Steinbeck books to try. When I feel sufficiently brave to read it! 😅
@ I love the film. Watched it many times before finally reading the book. The book is probably more of an emotional assault. If that’s even possible
@ MORE of an emotional assault? I’m impressed, and maybe a little terrified.
@ oh yeah! Reading Steinbeck is the emotional equivalent of going up to Conor McGregor in the pub and calling him a twat
I agree Feet of Clay is a great book, I love all the ones to do with dwarfs.
@@AaronReadABook Same here - I’m excited to reread the Fifth Elephant when I get there, I loved that one a lot too.
Oh dear. I was planning on reading some Waugh soon for the first time, I’ll go in a little more cautiously now. 👍
@@TheBookThing I’ll keep my fingers crossed for you. Maybe the other books aren’t quite so… waughful. 🤞
@@genteelblackhole badum tss!
Yeah Scoop was the most racist and anti-semitic book I've ever read, I found it very unpleasant and I have a pretty high tolerance for that in old books. Waugh was a horribly nasty man by all accounts, his books set in England I think are less problematic, I read Decline and Fall when I was a teenager and I don't remember anything like that in there.
@@AaronReadABook Honestly, I saw your Goodreads review of it after I DNFed it, and wished I’d seen it sooner! 😅
@@genteelblackhole The lovely woman at the bookstore I used to go recommended it to me, probably because I used to buy Murial Spark and Nancy Mitford books. I think I would really like him generally so I am going to give Brideshead a go at some point.
OMG! Of all the reasons I thought you were going to give I was not expecting this one! Good to know about this book. I must admit, I laughed when you said "he hadn't even gotten to Africa yet." (Gotta find humor somewhere). Thanks for the heads up! I had a similar experience with Jerome K Jerome in Three Men on the Bummel. Loved his first book and then halfway through the second one it took a turn.
I'm glad it gave you a laugh at least! Ooh no, I didn't know about Three Men on the Bummel. I must admit I've DNFed the first book twice already - not out of anything objectionable, just boredom. I start off loving it, but once he goes on tangents about the Magna Carta my interest wanes considerably!
@genteelblackhole there were definitely highs and lows in the first book.
I love the intro, how you said it as if having thoughts is ominous 😂
@@ReadBecca “Uh-oh, he’s been thinking again!” 😅
I guess big books might be inimidating but at the same time they do immerse you more than short books, look at Brandon Sanderson, loads of people have been turned onto fantasy by him, and Robert Jordan before him, although I don't consider either of them great writers. I completely avoided all TV related books till about 3 years ago, now I wish I read more of them when I was younger because I love Star Trek books, and again loads of people get into read through them. Yeah, reading completely at random is not good advice, 90% of everything is rubbish, but I do think people should try more genres generally once they are established readers. Force yourself to finish things even if you hate it sounds like Jordan Peterson or one of those type of idiots advice.
@@AaronReadABook That’s a very good point about longer books. For me, a longer book has more opportunities to bore or frustrate me, but when I find a good one I really cherish it. And some genres (such as fantasy) do thrive on longer books. Yeah, I always used to avoid tie-in books too. I’ve read a bunch of Doctor Who ones now, and they’re lovely for giving you a Whovian fix when 40 series of telly isn’t enough for you! Absolutely, it’s good to step outside your established comfort genres once you’re an established reader. I’ve been attempting that more this year, with mostly positive results.
I read Martin Caidin’s _Cyborg_ novels after watching _The Six Million Dollar Man” as a kid - and found them so much more developed and rewarding ultimately.
@@davidnovakreadspoetry I had no idea that show was based on books! You live and learn.
It IS what works for you - what resonates, whatever it be.
@@book-ramble Yep! Finding the reading habit that works for you, and finding the books that inspire you to keep reading them, that’s what it all boils down to.
Great video! I absolutely agree on the dnf point. Why equate books with torture? And, how about a book rec for someone who likes King of the Hill (animated TV show).
That's gonna take some thinking, I tell you whut!
That's interesting, 4in-1out seems like a much more favorable system than most I've experienced. I've all but given up reselling because the returns are so poor, I just put my books into a little free library now.
@@ReadBecca That’s a shame you don’t have access to a more favourable system. Little free libraries are lovely too though, at least you get to feel like someone will find and love those books. Thanks for watching! 😊
Awesome, thanks for sharing.
@@alohm Thanks so much for watching! I’m glad you enjoyed it.
Furniture and stuffed animals at your used bookstore? That’s wild! But it sounds really fun! They definitely should the space more accessible however. You aren’t the only one in a wheelchair. Thanks so much for doing my tag! 💛
@@booksimnotreading It’s a great shop, I’m very lucky to live so close to it! But yeah, the awkward access is frustrating sometimes. Thanks so much for making the tag, I was delighted to be tagged! 💜
Your bookstore sounds like a real cave of wonders! I agree, the one thing I don't like about used bookstores is the frequent inaccessibility. They're often in these rickety old buildings with stairs, and that makes it tough. I've only been to one used bookstore in my new city, and sadly it's closed thanks to a fire, but I will need to keep searching so I can do the tag myself.
@@nymeria941 Absolutely - I’m very thankful this bookshop is at least all on the ground floor. Oh no, I’m sorry to hear about the fire! I hope you find more great bookshops in your new city, and I look forward to hearing your answers to this tag too! Thanks so much for watching.
Some months just don’t get off the ground. I think November might be a bit like that for me. In the words of Kurt Vonnegut ‘so it goes’
@@TheBookThing Sorry to hear your November is like that. (But yay for the Vonnegut reference! The song I used a snippet of for my theme tune is named after a line from Sirens of Titan.)
It's always slight awkward giving a Shakespeare play a relatively low rating. Must do better Mr Shakespeare.
Greatest writer in the English language? Well *I* didn't think much of bleedin' Troilus and blinkin' Cressida! (Hamlet was none too shabby, mind you.)
I haven’t looked at Shakespeare’s _T&C_ in a hundred years, and don’t recall any satisfactory feelings having come of it. Was the introduction or supplemental material in your edition any good? I’m just saying because I wonder what was Shakespeare’s source material, so far as anyone can tell? I would have assumed he knew Chaucer’s _T&C…_ did the rest come from Ovid or something? Just curious because I don’t think of Shakespeare as someone who scrambled around trying to get a comprehensive picture from a diversity of sources, but rather fell back on something at hand. I haven’t been reading at all. As you said, there’s a lot of slumping going around. (Slumping I said, not slumming. 😉) 🗳️No, don’t stick to your lane. Make the video.
The supplements were good in my copy of T&C. It was the RSC edition, with essays and notes by Jonathan Bate and Eric Rasmussen. There's details on the themes, source material (yep, definitely Chaucer! I can't recall now what other sources were cited), performance history, interviews with some directors. Plenty of good stuff, and useful footnotes. I really rate the RSC editions. Ahh sorry to hear you're slumping too. There's a lot of it going round! Thanks for the vote of confidence, re: lane jumping!
Complete clown shoes would be a great pair to own! And three books completed in one month is very good by my own reckoning - and great titles too. Thanks!
Ya know what they say about a man with big shoes! This is true, three books is nothing to be sneezed at. I do feel like such good books (especially Howards End) deserved a more receptive brain, but I'll definitely revisit that in the future.
I just sent an email with the title Struggle Bus yesterday! 😃
@@booksimnotreading Beep beep, all aboard! 😅
I'm sure I've probably said it before, but Discworld operates in the same realm as pizza... Even poor Discworld is still worthwhile because its Discworld 😄 I'm working on a cows theme, Roswell was a potential (US cover has a cow abduction) so I'd thought of including it, but decided not to. So perfect timing for you to be the guinea pig and feedback in the negative. I've yet got plenty of her greatest hits to get to before diving into weaker stuff. Glad you included other media, I definitely love hearing about stuff outside books from the folks who I consider trusted reviewers on taste. I think that is most of how I hear about media anymore.
@@ReadBecca Ahh that’s so true! I do love Discworld… and pizza! 😄 Connie Willis’s greatest hits are definitely still worth reading, especially the time travel ones. This is the first one of hers that I’ve ever DNFed! Thanks again for inspiring me to include other media in my wrap-up. I hope you’ll find some fun stuff to try out! 😊
i'm here for any music-related vids, obviously!
That's good to know, thanks!
we have ajax and mr muscle (formerly Mr Muscolo) in romania too fyi. the joke should be EU-proof
That's a relief!
Excellent work, sir! I only follow two other booktubers, whom I can strongly recommend- @TheBookchemist and @outlawbookselleroriginal. A certain failed writer gets props on the latter, if you want to see the review of Deep Ends 2021!
Same here with “Never Let Me go” turn off. But “The Remnants of the Day“ is a masterpiece!
@@olgaotherstories8355 I’m glad it’s not just me!
Can you recommend any novels set in Penge?
@@JimLawrence-y1m You can’t go wrong with Penge & Prejudice.
House of Mirth is great, the only other book I've read by her was Ethan Frome and that is even more miserable but much shorter. I loved Remains of the Day, I agree it's much better than Never Let Me Go. Life of Pi, as I remember it, was one of the few books that lived up to the hype.
Oof yeah I've heard Ethan Frome is pretty miserable! (Unfortunately I've also heard how it ends.) At least House of Mirth isn't the *most* miserable of her books then. I'm glad I'm not the only person disappointed by Never Let Me Go. That is high praise indeed for Life of Pi. Maybe I'll end up thanking my past self for the impulse purchase when I eventually get a round to it!
'Ode to a Small Lump of Green Putty I Found in My Armpit One Midsummer Morning'!
That really counterpoints the surrealism of the underlying metaphor!
Yeah, I feel the exact same about Monte Cristo
@@TheBookThing I’m glad I’m not the only one!
Not sure what is up with the YT algorithm not showing me your videos until I watched the newest one, but hi, I’ve got some catching up to do! “Passing” is very good, and if you like it, I recommend “The Mothers” and “The Vanishing Half” by Britt Bennett. She’s a contemporary author whose work is very much in conversation with Larsen’s.
Jane Eyre is still my favorite classic, warts and all. And Green Gables is such a treat. There’s a whole series if you’re ever interested in following those characters’ stories further.
@@nymeria941 Ahh the pesky algorithm! I hope you have fun catching up. Thanks for the tip - I've been recommended the Vanishing Half so it's on my wishlist already, I'll have to bump it up a few places. Ooh yes and I might look into the rest of the Green Gables books after re-reading the first one. Thanks so much for the lovely comments!
Exceptional review! I've not read this one, but darn it I'm sold (admittedly doesn't take much to sell me on Pratchett tho). I've had quite a dearth of Discworld this year, what a travesty.
@@ReadBecca That’s so kind of you to say so, thank you! I will of course always advocate for reading more Pratchett, go for it! 😄
I love finding annotations in used books, but for some reason I HATE if the person used highlighter. Finding bookmarks and other ephemera in used books is the very best.
Good point! I never liked using highlighters, I always worried it was going to soak through the page. So finding someone else's highlights would annoy me too. Finding other ephemera is lovely though. I have some of my Mum's old books, and tucked into one poetry book I found a photo of my grandparents. That was a real treasure.
Yesssss Cadfael! I also picked up the first Gormenghast book this summer, but I haven’t started yet. I recently finished rereading “A Series of Unfortunate Events” by Lemony Snicket, which were my favorites as a kid. They hold up!
I do love Cadfael! I've slowed down on the series in the last few months, but I must be about due to read another one soon. I've never read the Lemony Snicket books but I've heard a lot of good things about them. (And I do have an album that Daniel Handler plays accordion on - 69 Love Songs, by Magnetic Fields.) And I still haven't started Gormenghast yet, but I have an ebook copy of the whole series now. Eventually!
Well that’s it now, I’m Thing from TheBookMark. I dunno which is going to be harder to change, my UA-cam handle or my name by deed poll. I suspect the UA-cam handle. I may have to insist on you desisting from Discworld reviews, you’re far better at them than I am. I mean it’s obvious now when you say it but the Michael Crawford gag went straight over my head. I can see where you’re coming from with the fat jokes. But Pratchett spends a lot of time making gags at the expense of the physicality of his characters and as someone on the more corpulent side myself, personally I didn’t find it heavy handed. But that’s the beauty of books, we each get to have our own experience. …speaking of which, I will be replying to that tag from you soon. Great vid. 😁
@@TheBookThing Haha, I’m glad (and relieved) that gag gets your Mark of approval! The Michael Crawford gag is pretty oblique, I don’t blame you for not spotting it. (Terry Pratchett would’ve made a mean quiz question setter!) Anyway, I think your reviews are great so you really have nothing to fear. But I also don’t see plan on reviewing every book, I’m not great at keeping to schedules. 😅 Absolutely, we all have our own experience with a book, and a new experience each time. Like you say, Pratchett does make fun of all his characters’ appearances, so it’s not like he singled out Agnes. It felt to me like he went overboard this time, but I’m glad your experience was more positive. Whatever happens, it’s still a Pratchett book and that means I generally had a good time! Ooh I do look forward to your tag video! Thanks so much for the lovely comment. I really enjoy your videos so your compliments mean a lot!
@@genteelblackhole I think you mean my Thing of approval. Actually no, that sounds weird. Yeah, schedules are all well and good when you’re a dozen books ahead and filming them 4 at a time. But I’ve caught up now. …I feel like George R R Martin at the end of season 6 of Game of Thrones. And I really enjoy and look forward to your videos too dude and always appreciate your comments.
You didn't say this "the best stories chosen by its authors" .The editor sent letters to some of the best science fiction writers of the day asking them to send their favorite short story they had written, with an introduction. For me there, are many of my favorites but some I do not care to coment them. My favorites: "A small kindness" (Ben Bova) "There will come soft rains" (Ray Bradbury).
As a side note, regarding the theme of disunity, Jeanette Winterson’s “cover version” of The Winter’s Tale is called A Gap in Time.
The Gap of Time. Definite, not indefinite. Pardon me.
@@mergyeugnau You are pardoned. (And the pardon won’t even take 16 years!) I haven’t read Winterson’s “cover version” of the Winter’s Tale (or indeed any Winterson at all, yet!) - that does sound intriguing. Thanks for the tip! 💜
You are in for such a treat when you finally get to her! She is one of my all time favorite authors. I’m happy to give recs if you ever want to dive in.
My father has insisted I read Maugham and forced a copy of 'Of Human Bondage' on me which I'll get to soon I reckon. Can I just say I'm impressed with myself for putting the word 'of' twice in a row in a sentence and still be grammatically correct 🙂 I've also never read Forster so I'll have to get to him soon as well. So many books so little time. Great to see Maskerade making the cut. Cool vid man
If that's the effect "of of" had, just imagine the effect "had had" had had. 😉 I hope you enjoy Forster when you get to him. I definitely know the feeling - no matter how much I read, the TBR never seems to get any shorter! It's lovely to get back to Pratchett after a couple of months off. Maskerade is a damn good one! Thanks for watching! 😊
@@genteelblackhole had had had had eh? Bravo
Never read any Forster, I think I own at least one of his. I recommend The Moon & Sixpence by Maugham if you ever want to have another go. I recently got Enchanted April because a character in a book I was reading recommended it. Glad September went well, classics tend to be a safer bet.
@@AaronReadABook I’ve seen a few Forster adaptations that were all very good, and based on what I’ve already read I’m very excited to try more. Ooh I’m not familiar with that Maugham book, I’ll keep that in mind once the memory of Ashenden has faded a bit. I hope you enjoy Enchanted April too! Yeah, I think I’ve started to find some of my go-to genres a bit too samey and predictable. While there’s comfort in that to some extent, my brain has been craving more sustenance. Classics seem to be the way to go right now.
Very nice!
@@davidnovakreadspoetry Thanks very much, I’m glad you enjoyed it! I plan to post more sonnets on subsequent Sundays.
Yep, it sure looked as if you ran out of -. 😂 Well done, hats off! 🎩
I thank thee! 😄
"To Let it Be, or not to Let it Be" is genius.
@@Murdo2112 My ten year old self thanks you!