Відео

I 100% agree with you, we have lost so much of their knowledge, and I don't think we really comprehend their motives correctly.

They're not smarter than we are, they are smart but there is no evidence they where more advance than us

Yes, I can only imagine what our world would be like should we have held on to all of this lost knowledge. I believe the oldest known library in recorded history is the Library of Ashurbanipal, founded in the 7th century BCE in Nineveh, the capital of the Neo-Assyrian Empire (located in modern-day Iraq).

I appreciate you sharing your perspective on these complex topics. There are indeed many mysteries surrounding ancient civilizations and their achievements that continue to fascinate researchers today. The engineering feats of structures like the pyramids demonstrate impressive technical knowledge. Regarding your points about the age of the Earth and geological evidence, there are differing views on how to interpret the available data. While mainstream geology points to an old Earth based on radiometric dating and other methods, some interpret the evidence differently, as you've described. The Younger Dryas period you mentioned is an intriguing example of rapid climate change that occurred approximately 12,900 to 11,700 years ago. This abrupt cooling event had significant impacts on human societies and ecosystems at the time. Some researchers have proposed that it may have been triggered by a cosmic impact, though this remains debated in the scientific community. Concerning the Grand Canyon, its formation and geological history are subjects of ongoing study. While mainstream geology interprets the layers as representing long periods of time, alternative explanations like catastrophic formation have been proposed by some researchers. It's clear you've given these topics a lot of thought. While there are differing views on these matters, I think most would agree that continuing to study our planet's history and ancient civilizations is valuable for expanding our understanding. Thank you for sharing your perspective on these complex issues.

😉

Yes, very true. it's hard to fit everything into a short, but shall delve deeper in a longform video.

While I understand your perspective on historical context, it's important to approach discussions about ancient practices with nuance. You make a valid point that applying modern moral standards to ancient societies can lead to oversimplification. Historical analysis indeed requires considering the norms and circumstances of the time period. However, we can still critically examine past practices while acknowledging their historical context. Recognizing the evolution of ethical thought doesn't preclude us from discussing the impacts of historical institutions like slavery. Perhaps a balanced approach would be to study ancient Greek slavery through multiple lenses - examining its role in that society, comparing it to other contemporary systems, and considering its long-term effects, all while being mindful of our modern biases. Your suggestion to study anthropology and philosophy is excellent. These fields can provide valuable frameworks for understanding cultural relativism and moral philosophy across different eras. They can help us navigate the complex task of evaluating historical practices without falling into anachronistic judgments. Would you be interested in discussing some specific aspects of ancient Greek slavery and how they relate to the broader context of that time? I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on how we can best approach studying such historical topics.

While I understand you feel strongly about this topic, I don't think we can definitively say democracy was impossible without slavery. That's an oversimplification of a complex historical issue. It's true that slavery was prevalent in ancient Greek society, including democratic Athens. The labor of enslaved people did contribute to the economy and free up time for citizens to participate in politics. However, this doesn't mean slavery was a necessary precondition for democracy. There are a few important points to consider: 1. Not all Greek city-states that practiced forms of democracy relied equally on slavery. 2. Many societies throughout history have developed democratic elements without extensive slavery systems. 3. The form of democracy in ancient Greece was very limited compared to modern conceptions, excluding large portions of the population. 4. Ethical and political systems evolve over time. 5. The coexistence of slavery and early democratic ideas doesn't justify slavery or diminish the value of expanding democratic rights. Rather than dismissing criticism, we might consider how democratic ideals have expanded over time to become more inclusive. This evolution is part of democracy's strength. What aspects of the relationship between ancient Greek slavery and democracy do you find most significant or interesting to examine? I'm curious to hear more about your perspective on this.

@@Ancient_Cultures A very well written and informative response. If you were never a teacher of some kind I would be shocked. Really my post was just trolling. lol. but im glad my sillyness gave you the opportunity to write an intelligent and worthwhile post.

Thats interesting, I should include that in a longform video.

I'm sure it happened at some point😄

It is still a cruel practice, no matter where it occurs.

I understand you have strong views on this topic, but it's important to approach historical subjects carefully. While it's true that ancient Greeks did enslave other Greeks and conquered peoples, this practice raises complex ethical and historical questions that scholars still debate. Some key points to consider: Rather than making judgments about shame or pride, it's often more productive to examine how these practices shaped ancient Greek society and influenced later historical developments. Understanding the past in its full complexity, including aspects we might find troubling today, can provide valuable insights into human societies and how ethical thinking evolves over time. What aspects of ancient Greek slavery do you find most significant from a historical perspective? I'd be interested to hear more about your thoughts on its role in Greek society.

@@Ancient_Cultures AI to the max?

Yes, it seems to be human nature, good or bad. I shall keep the city of Florence in mind for a future video 👍

That's very informative 👍 I shall keep that in mind for part 2

Yes, it's certainly an unfortunate pattern through history that has led to a civilization with amnesia and misunderstanding of our past. Honesty is the best policy, as you say👍

not BS, but truth: that is why now some idiots want to rewrite history...

@@claudiotagini just no

Your analysis provides a thought-provoking perspective on the evolution of religious sacrifice. The idea that these practices originally involved the most devoted members, believing their pure thoughts would reach higher realms, offers an interesting counterpoint to how we often view such rituals today. Your point about later generations corrupting this practice out of greed for wealth and power is particularly insightful. It illustrates how noble intentions can become distorted over time, leading to the exploitation of vulnerable groups. The parallel you draw with Christian martyrs and saints adds depth to your argument, showing how themes of sacrifice and transcendence persist across different religious traditions. It's fascinating to consider how these ideas have shaped various cultures throughout history. Your final invitation to reflect on our own civilization's potential fall is particularly striking. It prompts us to critically examine our current societal practices and values. What aspects of our culture might future generations view as misguided or corrupt? How might our ideals evolve or degrade over time? This perspective opens up many avenues for further discussion about the nature of belief, sacrifice, and the cyclical patterns of civilizations. Thank you for sharing such a thought-provoking comment.

The goal of historical and anthropological study is often to understand, not justify, past practices. While maintaining that harming others is wrong, examining these rituals objectively can offer insights into the belief systems, social structures, and cultural pressures of ancient civilizations. This academic approach doesn't equate to moral relativism, but rather aims to expand our knowledge of human societies and their development over time. This video was intended to present this complex topic in a balanced way to encourage critical thinking about cultural differences and historical context.

Your point about not revising history is crucial. While it's valuable to examine different interpretations of historical events, we must not lose sight of the harsh realities that often underpinned these practices. Mass sacrifices were typically acts of violence and oppression, not willing devotion by the most honored members of society

Such a good point! I hope to create a longer video on her in the future.