Відео

How can anyone consider themselves an impartial historian and use a term like "Naqba". Even the UN doesn't use that term.

As a historian, why does your talk use the anachronistic term "Palestinian" when discussing the Partion Plan? That word was completely unknown in its current meaning at that time. The word used then was "Arab". Using the word "Palestinian" to refer to events long before Palestinian Nationalism existed is to rewrite history. Sorry to say, but I think this is an intentional effort on your point, in order to forward your political agenda under the color of unbiased historical research

People who want to get a book into print often chose an Israeli issue. I know, I am a librarian.

reimberse me.

My grandmother worked as a governess in this villa from 1934-1936 and helped raise her two daughters, Ruth and Tina Abcarius. I wrote a book about it because letters and photographs have survived. She also met the Emperor of Ethiopia there. Karel Tichy

Wonderful Zachary Foster👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻⚘🔝🇵🇸

271k

Excellent discussion on the basis for the failure of Arab and Palestinian loss in 1948 as well as those figures on the Israeli side who managed the crisis to build and the icons of a failed resistance who may have been superseded by Arafat and the PLO but still have resonance

Lies, lies, lies, maghrebi means from the maghreb which is north africa, it has nothing to do with morocco alone.

Introduce bears, wolves and cannibals to contend with the invasive xionist species.

'Promo sm'

Jesus, this guy needs to prepare notes. What a mess.

Absorbing everything I can from Professor Pappe

Great interview, loved every detail especially the art of Gil Mualem-Doron. Hope I can find a physical copy of the book in Egypt. Thoughts and prayers for all innocent victims, all the sane voices are calling for a fast ceasefire so I hope that can happen soon in spite of all the pressure to escalate.

Jerusalem is the capital city of Palestine!! isr.ael has been AN ILLEGAL COLONIAL APARTHEID WHICH MUST NEVER EXIST!! The US established to colonize ALL MENA! AND IT FAILED to achieve this!! SO ENDING IT IS A NECESSITY TO SAVE Americans' lives & money and to create peace!!

Fadis passion is so infectious! Love this discussion

His mother dropped him on his head as a child.

Tell the truth are shut up

Great Britain created Israel from the ashes of British Palestine. Please let me know your opinions on such matters 😉

1918-1922

"You cannot be a benevolent racist, and you cannot be a progressive ethnic cleanser, and you cannot be an enlightened occupier, you can be one way or the other, you cannot be both" ILAN PAPPE Thanks Kristel and Robert, viva free Dutch people, viva free Italians, viva Beit Safafa & Palestine!! thanks for inviting Professor Pappe, hope to listen to more podcasts soon, I am a Palestinian in Poland for a while with my wife, I felt European people & European Media are sensitive about Jewish topic, this is why they don't dive deeper, they read Headlines, Israel vs X, we are with Israel against X, they don't even consider understand what X is.

Puppet. Of the left wing. I understand the Arabs. They wish to takeover everything. Not just in Israel, but Europe too. No excuses. By the way it is not ,, wailing wall,, he knows this 😮

Thank you Professor Ilan Pappe. Great interview.

Israel criminels supported by USA

No one cares .

נע

This Ilan Pappe is a moron. Typical assimilated euroacculturated type. And NOT Mizrahi ancient Yishuv who have had to put up with “Dhemmitude”. And by the way, “Palestinian” is an adherent to “Palestinianism”, the political movement chartered and ratified by the Arab League in 1964 with the declared objective of the destruction of Israel and Jew Killing, and still is. Arabs were and are the Colonizing People of the south Levant. This Moron Pappe let’s his ideologies overcome his credibility as a historian, and only people who know nothing about Levantine histories and Peoples don’t know he is a phony.

I love and admire professor Pappe, a man who believes in justice and humanity. I wished we had more leaders and people like him. The world would’ve been beautiful to live in.

A very good talk by Professor Katz.

Professor Ilan is an inspiration. His books keep me and many people still believe in the power of morals and conscience over the horrors of violence. Thank you for the amazing work, we need it tremendously in these days.

Fantastic interview. Makes me think the greatest hope for this seemingly intractable conflict is the Palestinian diaspora who who have become world wide ambassadors for Palestine. The greatest antidote to Israel fantastic propaganda machine.

Thank you for this wonderful interview. As someone who lived in Jerusalem for years, it is so refreshing to hear the authentic voices of Palestinian Jerusalemites. It is these stories that will help to resolve this terrible conflict.

Nazareth and Nazareth Illit (Hof Hagalil) would make a good case study of how apartheid will fall. Hof Hagailil is now 1/4 Palestinian from the original 100% Jewish colony.

Very interesting.

It’s always a great honor to listen/learn from profesor Pappe

There is no time limit in the definition of colonialism therefor the British will always be considered colonialists in Australia. And the Palestinian are no exception the Arabs occupied Palestine by force in the seventh century and brought a different language, a different culture and a different genetics. The origin of Arab culture is in the Arabian Peninsula The source of the Arabic language is in the Arabian Peninsula The source of the religion of Islam in the Arabian Peninsula. On the other hand, the Jews' cultural and genetic origin and the language of the Jews were all created in Levant (Palestine). They did not come from outside, but were created in Levant (Palestine). The Hebrew language is the only Canaanite language that survived. The Jews lived in the land continuously before the Arabs before Islam and Christianity. Jews are considered indigenous by definition because the origin of the Hebrew language, The culture and religion of the Jews originated in the Levant. True, Jews have been a minority among Muslims and Christians most of the years but the fact that they are a minority does not negate their seniority they are the oldest residents. And the fact that the Arabs are a majority does not make them natives they will always be colonialists like the British in Australia. The palestinian try to change the defenition of colonialism so that because it happened long ago in the seventh century they became natives. There is no time limit to colonialism and they are not considered natives under the definition.!!

Well done!

Professor Dorit Naaman is a professor at Queen's University (Canada), in the Department of Film and Media. She is a supporter of BDS. She advocates for the boycott of Israel, not just in Judea and Samaria, but the entire country. She signed a petition accusing Israel of perpetrating “atrocities” in Gaza and urging the United Nations to impose sanctions on Israel. She signed a petition calling on the European Council, Commission and the European Parliament to pressure Israel into surrendering to Hamas’ demands. (Hamas calls on the ethnic cleansing of Israel of Jews.) She uses the fact that she herself is Israeli as a legitimization of her attack of the Jewish state. Parents and students should know the people molding and poisoning the minds of young people into hating the only true democracy in the Middle East and the world's lone Jewish state. Naaman and many other Israeli professors ride the wave of unexamined, blind hatred for the Jewish State and inflate their status on campuses abroad and in Israel.

תודה רבה