I'm no expert, but
I'm no expert, but
  • 19
  • 218 293
Ballscrews vs leadscrews for a DIY CNC
I've upgraded my hobby DIY CNC mill to use ballscrews, and haven't looked back.
Переглядів: 23 987

Відео

Online Feeds & Speeds Milling Calculator
Переглядів 1,2 тис.2 роки тому
cutcalculator.xyz/ Give it a try! Hope it helps.
Milling a Battery Enclosure
Переглядів 1,4 тис.3 роки тому
CNC milling an HDPE enclosure for a 14.4V 95Wh battery pack to use as a DIY v-mount camera battery. SAFETY NOTE: if you're not comfortable with the failure modes of these types of batteries, don't build one!
Milling Quietly: Tips and Tricks
Переглядів 3,2 тис.3 роки тому
Tool stickout and workholding can help you mill more quietly, but also important are the mounting of the mill on your bench and the speeds and feeds you're using. Sometimes a deeper, more aggressive cut is quieter! The software I'm using is custom built, but it's similar to software called "Millalyzer." UPDATE: it's now hosted at cutcalculator.xyz Sorry for the poor audio quality, I was using t...
Squaring and Tramming a DIY CNC Mill
Переглядів 16 тис.3 роки тому
When you've built your own mill, you need to square it up beyond what most mill owners need to do. Here's my set of steps to ensure all axes and surfaces are sufficiently square and parallel. Table of Contents: 0:00 - Intro 1:19 - X perpendicular to Y 3:36 - Align table to XY 5:29 - Z perpendicular to XY 8:08 - Tool parallel to Z 9:41 - Outro
Milling Aluminum: Cutting Fluids Tested!
Переглядів 18 тис.3 роки тому
Testing out various cutting fluids on 6061-T6 aluminum on my DIY hobby mill, and evaluating surface finish. Table of Contents: 0:00 - Intro 0:25 - The Mill 1:03 - The Tool 1:39 - Speeds and Feeds 2:03 - Dry 3:14 - Ethanol 4:35 - Mineral Oil 5:33 - A-9 Cutting Fluid 6:43 - WD-40 8:16 - Breakfree CLP 9:05 - Air Blast 9:43 - Conclusion
DIY CNC Bearing Failure
Переглядів 6 тис.4 роки тому
The X axis bearings constraining the lead screw failed in an odd way. I replaced one with a double angular contact bearing that I've used successfully elsewhere. Most ballscrews you buy come with a fixed side and a floating side. The floating side allows axial motion, the fixed side does not. The fixed side is implemented on those by machining the end of the ballscrew with a shoulder plus a bol...
CNC Milling a Camera Tripod Plate Adapter
Переглядів 1,6 тис.4 роки тому
CNC milling a DIY camera tripod quick release adapter shift plate for my Canon EOS-M.
CNC Milling Circuit Boards
Переглядів 1,5 тис.4 роки тому
Here are my steps for bCNC (units are inches): * zero out axes just above the pcb * probe down to zero * zero out z * jog up on z 0.1 * go to autolevel * click margins * change N resolution * change z min max to -0.1 0.1 * set probe feed to something like 1 * click scan * go to probe * enter WPOS x and y into probe pos entry * click probe * zero z * in autolevel, click zero * jog up on z 0.1 * ...
Aluminum DIY CNC Mill: Parts and Cost
Переглядів 34 тис.4 роки тому
Parts list is here: pastebin.com/raw/qTwZPJzE Note that the base width in the video isn't what I used. My base is 7 inches wide, not 6, because I got a good deal on an off-cut. I wanted to show prices for building it new, so that's why I put 6 inches width for the base; the supplier I looked at didn't have an option for 7 inches wide.
More Mill Upgrades: No More Aluminum Extrusions
Переглядів 8 тис.4 роки тому
More Mill Upgrades: No More Aluminum Extrusions
3D Printing vs CNC Milling electronics cases
Переглядів 2,1 тис.4 роки тому
A comparison of an FDM PLA 3D printed electronics case versus the exact same case CNC milled out of plastic.
TiCN Endmill Aluminum Chatter Mystery
Переглядів 1 тис.5 років тому
WARNING: loud obnoxious chatter sounds! Other stuff I tried that didn't make the video: * higher/lower RPM * higher/lower feedrate * conventional milling This is the source of the text excerpt about coatings: www.radical-departures.net/articles/understanding-the-elements/
Making a flight sim panel with a CNC router
Переглядів 10 тис.5 років тому
Creating a 737-800 navigation radio panel out of 3/16" opaque white acrylic on a CNC machine. No lasers necessary!
OpenBuilds Minimill: The Final Upgrade
Переглядів 19 тис.5 років тому
Upgrading my modified OpenBuilds MiniMill into something that isn't really a MiniMill anymore. Improved rigidity for higher material removal rates. Larger work area.
CNC Machining a Delrin Anti-backlash Nut
Переглядів 9 тис.5 років тому
CNC Machining a Delrin Anti-backlash Nut
WEN 3970 4x6 Metal Cutting Bandsaw Review
Переглядів 7 тис.5 років тому
WEN 3970 4x6 Metal Cutting Bandsaw Review
CNC Milling Aluminum Angle Brackets
Переглядів 4,2 тис.5 років тому
CNC Milling Aluminum Angle Brackets
OpenBuilds MiniMill Review (mostly for cutting aluminum)
Переглядів 50 тис.5 років тому
OpenBuilds MiniMill Review (mostly for cutting aluminum)

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @benji6b
    @benji6b Місяць тому

    Great video thank you

  • @Double0Civic
    @Double0Civic Місяць тому

    Awesome video, thanks man!

  • @AmericanMakerCNC
    @AmericanMakerCNC 2 місяці тому

    Wow, this is fantastic! Nice job. Thanks for sharing it with the machining community!

  • @-______-______-
    @-______-______- 2 місяці тому

    Lovely finish and beautiful router too.

  • @chawesspe3
    @chawesspe3 2 місяці тому

    I have a project that I need to use 8 mm leadscrews and I have been trying to find a tap for the screws. Could you pass on to me your suppliers information? Thanks Charles

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 2 місяці тому

      8mm trapezoidal 4-start (8mm lead, 2mm pitch). I found a tap on robotdigg: www.robotdigg.com/product/794/ACME-Trapezoidal-Lead-Screw-TAP-for-screw-thread

  • @GeraldFitzgerald-o7p
    @GeraldFitzgerald-o7p 3 місяці тому

    Planning on making a Coffee machine cart where the machine raises from it's lowest point to the working surface. What do you believe is the best ball screw to use considering the cart will be used over all types of terrains? e.g. transported inside a truck/van, pushed over grassy/muddy locations and towed on an e-bike over all terrains.

  • @Theranthrope
    @Theranthrope 3 місяці тому

    This is kinda a waste just to cut aluminum, as you can just use a miter saw with an ordinary wood cutting blade. I've cut extruded 2020 with my old Ryobi and it's stock blade without a problem (other than razor-sharp aluminum chips flying everywhere, but that's the fun of working with aluminum).

  • @ankithmistry
    @ankithmistry 3 місяці тому

    You should try kerosene and diesel

  • @nickle549
    @nickle549 4 місяці тому

    Can this be backlit?

  • @steran50
    @steran50 4 місяці тому

    Though I have not tried it myself I was told by an Engineer that kerosene is the best for aluminum.

  • @Raul28153
    @Raul28153 4 місяці тому

    WD40 is deoderized Kerosene with a wee skosh of hydrotreated light pump oil. Kero does the job too for a shit ton less $$

  • @TheXSpitfire
    @TheXSpitfire 4 місяці тому

    How loud is the machine while running ? I had a CNC router with a 2.2kw spindle and at max RPM my neighbors complained.

  • @voidfalse
    @voidfalse 5 місяців тому

    I use canola oil for milling, drilling, turning and tapping

  • @davemurphy3813
    @davemurphy3813 5 місяців тому

    Is that your CAM software with the chip load graphing, or is it an app or online tool? I like that.

  • @shonnr
    @shonnr 5 місяців тому

    I am using your dimensions and material list to make a mill like yours. I am a trade machinist 20 years. You could buy a bench mill but retro fitting a bench mill has limitations also. # 1 they have ways not linear bearings. The RPM is also limited due to gearbox. I will be substituting aluminum for steel and I am making it thicker. 3" Cold rolled for frame and column. I want it heavy to dampen vibration.

  • @ThoCoKhi181
    @ThoCoKhi181 5 місяців тому

    Noise has decreased. Do you think it comes from upgrading Ballscrews or high speed spindles? Thanks!

  • @EXPERIENCETRIP
    @EXPERIENCETRIP 6 місяців тому

    HI ! Can I ask you what tip do you use for engraving the words?

  • @arbjful
    @arbjful 6 місяців тому

    Does the feed rate affect the finish quality? I don’t get very clean looking finish, although it’s very smooth to touch, but one can see the scuff marks on the surface. The material is 6061 aluminum, 6.35 dia carbide end mill, 2 flute. Feed is F120. The coolant is cutting oil mixed with water, flood type with air blower.

  • @emc3895
    @emc3895 6 місяців тому

    Hi, It’s a magnificent piece of work, really very clean! Quick question: Isn't your panel too thick and too opaque, I mean can you use your cockpit in the dark and use a backlight?

  • @MrNeelthehulk
    @MrNeelthehulk 6 місяців тому

    Cool video .. very informative.. but are those chips on you lead screw when you were facing the table ... I have to call the cops on you

  • @Manokanalasify
    @Manokanalasify 6 місяців тому

    Many years ago kerosene was used as a coolant in surface grinding

  • @Noxoreos
    @Noxoreos 7 місяців тому

    The typical WD40, that you can get pretty much everywhere isn't actually a lubricant at all. It's the opposite and should not be used as such. That's why you notice it doesn't hold up as much for things like squeeky doors. Over time it removes every lubricant, that was on there before and makes it worse. It is supposed to loosen up rust and to clean parts and it removes thicker grease. Yes it does work very well as coolant on aluminium parts. For that purpose it is fine and is therefore used by many people for that purpose. You also can also use WD40 to clean parts, without making them vulnerable to rust (or actually protect them from rust), but never use it as lubricant. For lubrication the WD40 should be removed with alcohol, acetone or brake fluid (or similar) beforehands and then you can use a suitable lubricant afterwards. However WD40 is actually a brand name and not the name of a specific product. They also make a few other products, that appear to look very similar on first look, but some of these other products are actually lubricants for various purposes.

    • @Motorman464
      @Motorman464 2 місяці тому

      You do a lot of aluminum milling?

    • @Noxoreos
      @Noxoreos 2 місяці тому

      @@Motorman464 I wouldn't call it a lot. Why?

    • @Motorman464
      @Motorman464 2 місяці тому

      @@Noxoreos Because after reading your dissertation, it's evident you haven't done a lot of anything. WD-40 "water displacement, 40th formula" is indeed a lubricant, rust preventative and penetrating oil. When I see someone comment with statements like "should not be used as such" and "but never as a lubricant", it tells me that you have no idea what you are talking about. I'm sure this part was a typo but no one uses "brake fluid" to remove WD-40. I'm sure you meant brake cleaner. Although WD-40 is a brand name, it is also a specific product and the formula is still a trade secret. You gave rather a lengthy spiel to be so incorrect. Good luck.

    • @Noxoreos
      @Noxoreos 2 місяці тому

      @@Motorman464 As a matter of fact, what you're stating has nothing to with milling, so your first question doesn't even matter in that regards. Nor does my answer to it. So I'm not sure how you think to know what I did or didn't do. I work as an engineer in germany and I have a lot of experience with products from WD40. Of course I'm not talking about break cleaner. Break cleaner does not prevent rust. I'm talking about the product from WD40 that is used incorrectly in a lot of cases because it lubricates only temporarily. I have to fix a lot mechanics due to improper use of lubricants and WD40 is by far the most common reason for early wear on sliding surfaces. The reason for that is because it lubricates for a rather short period of time and then dries up after a day or so, depending on how open it is to the air. As I said the do also create proper lubricants that are made for this purpose but there product they sell most is not that.

    • @Motorman464
      @Motorman464 2 місяці тому

      @@Noxoreos Ok Maryanne, go change your pad now.

  • @jjjbossjjj
    @jjjbossjjj 7 місяців тому

    I'm a big fan of your diy mill. What spindle are you using (kw, diameter, er16?)

  • @jjjbossjjj
    @jjjbossjjj 7 місяців тому

    Great video! How much of alignemnt can be adjusted via the linear rails themselves? Thx!

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 7 місяців тому

      It's important for the two rails on an axis to be perfectly parallel, so after you spend a lot of time dialing that in you don't want to loosen them again.

    • @jjjbossjjj
      @jjjbossjjj 7 місяців тому

      @@imnoexpertbut I see! Makes sense... So we set that up first and don't touch it again while we go on to tramming the other axes.

  • @Jptoutant
    @Jptoutant 7 місяців тому

    great info, i like your mills setup

  • @Dude_Slick
    @Dude_Slick 8 місяців тому

    I used 3/8-8 4 start lead screws for my router build, and I'm quite satisfied. But then I only cutting wood so I don't need a powerhouse of a machine. I run a good size work area at 24"X46" So I'm contemplating adding a second screw to the Y axis, as I am currently running a single center screw.

  • @wh0tube
    @wh0tube 8 місяців тому

    90 degrees is overrated 😁👍 Imagine how much better the world would be f x, y, and z axis were at 84 degrees to each other.

  • @BruceWSims
    @BruceWSims 8 місяців тому

    Not altogether sure what problem is being solved here. AFAIK ball-screws originated as a solution to backlash. I'm left to wonder what tolerances you are working at that "backlash" with ball-screws is a problem. Thoughts?

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 8 місяців тому

      I don't think backlash is the only advantage, but sure, that's an important one. For a hobbyist, the reason to avoid backlash isn't just precision, but rigidity and avoiding vibration. Cutting forces during climb cuts will pull the work piece into the cut and away from one side of the backlash to the other, which, if you couple it with a small DIY machine that's lightweight, is going to spell trouble. You're going to break a lot of endmills, unless you're extremely careful about always taking cuts from specific directions, which isn't too hard on a big manual bridgeport, but becomes very difficult on a small CNC machine.

    • @BruceWSims
      @BruceWSims 8 місяців тому

      @imnoexpertbut Ahhhh....OK...got it. I think I was mistaking what you were identifying as "backlash". My bad. Apologies all the way around. My own work is on a mini-mini-lathe (see: Sherline) so that was my frame of reference. However, if you are talking about a full-size lathe I can definitely that. Sorry for the fuss......

  • @markbunyan3078
    @markbunyan3078 8 місяців тому

    Great video, thanks for sharing! I found this while looking to confirm the calculation for Torque, where did you find the calc in the video? It seems to be different to most that I have found which show T= PL/2Pi e, where the calc in the video shows T = PL e / 2Pi. Where should the efficiency be? Thanks!

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 8 місяців тому

      I took it from this page, where they should both a drive torque and holding torque equation. For driving, a low efficiency should be higher drive torque is required. For holding, it seems like the same relationship should follow: lower efficiency should mean high holding torque. So now that you point it out, I'm also confused. www.nookindustries.com/resources/general-technical-references/ball-screw-design-considerations/

    • @markbunyan3078
      @markbunyan3078 8 місяців тому

      Thanks@@imnoexpertbutthat's helped, i had not previously found the two equations together. I ran some numbers through the equations and i think it makes sense - you need more torque to drive the same amount of load as the motor has to overcome the frictional forces of the ballscrew (efficiency), whereas the holding torque is in a static state, resulting in less torque being required, but having said that, why does the efficiency need to be included in the static state?

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 8 місяців тому

      @@markbunyan3078 OK yeah, your explanation made it click for me. The T in the holding torque equation is the motor torque needed to prevent backdrive, in which case it makes sense that lower efficiency would make the needed holding torque lower, because lower efficiency is mostly due to higher friction.

  • @paradiselost9946
    @paradiselost9946 8 місяців тому

    seems legit... noticed that the el-cheapo ballscrews seem to come with the seals/wipers. being metric is the icing on the cake. the lack of wipers, along with the imperial 5TPI of the screws i got with the CNC kit for my little X2 mill? think it was "robson" brand? no end of troubles! stripped them at least 5 times getting chips out... along with the old "forget to throw g21 in code" on every power up... ouch. yeah, one day i might actually finish scraping and get it back together with the new screws sitting on the shelf.. in hindsight, linear rails and build from the ground up would have been a far better approach than convert chinese dovetails to cnc. that has been a journey! might STILL be a better option... even if i just hack the dovetails out altogether! at that point though, the beds still too small... sigh..

  • @lohikarhu734
    @lohikarhu734 8 місяців тому

    Interesting discussion...I was looking at some rather precise "stages" used in drilling PCBs ( about 400 x 400 mm), and they were driven with ball screws, I think a pair of them, one per side of each axis, with tooth belt drive between them. Motion control is always interesting... Strange that so much in these CNC systems is open loop?

  • @Taseden
    @Taseden 8 місяців тому

    What precision cast aluminum plate did you end up using? Same size as the 6061 flat bar you initially used? Thanks for the update on your machine. I plan on using 1204s as well.

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 8 місяців тому

      Yep. I bought from "USA Metal Online" on ebay, and the plates are G.AL C250, which is "Medium Strength Precision Milled Plate, Alloy: EN AW-5083." Machined just fine.

  • @GoPaintman
    @GoPaintman 8 місяців тому

    Happy to see another video! I watched your series on the mini mill before I bought my first CNC.

  • @3dkiwi920
    @3dkiwi920 8 місяців тому

    What type of coupler did you end up using there? Looks slightly more complex than the spiral specials.

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 8 місяців тому

      It's called a "diaphragm coupler," you can find them on amazon.

  • @OnGodd_
    @OnGodd_ 8 місяців тому

    Great vid.

  • @DDDengineer
    @DDDengineer 8 місяців тому

    Hello, Recently got interested in making a small CNC mill for Aluminum. Was almost ready to start Milenium Milo v1.5 and then found your channel. I go your metric Fusion project. I will finish the CAD with bolts and whistles, I plan to make it Duet-based ( I think wifi will handle the steppers just well) Are you OK if I publish it as an open-source

  • @john_duncan
    @john_duncan 9 місяців тому

    they make a thing called a drill mill, it has the start of a drill and the flutes of an endmill.

  • @dadoVRC
    @dadoVRC 9 місяців тому

    Ethanol is good to keep everything cool, to avoid aluminium to stick on the cutter because of heat. The issue with aluminium is that a little bit of material tend to stick on the tip of the cutter during the cutting, so it leaves marks during the rest of the rotation. Best choice is the flood coolant with a % of 5~10% oil. If you can't, light oils like WD40, but also plain kero, diesel fuel and so on are good, but they make fumes and they're quite flammable. I'm a professional metalworker but also a hobbyist, since after work I'm playing with metals, so I have some experience in both the fields. In last months I'm playing with a DIY CNC to make alu molds for injection molding, on a small milling machine without flood coolant. For those I tried various fluids, especially because I'm working in recesses (so I can flood the recess with fluid) and since the process is long I need something who stays in the recess while the machine is working and I'm drinking a beer with friends. 😉 It turned out that ATF fluid is a very good cutting fluid for aluminium. It's quite messy to clean out after the work, but it give good surface finish and it avoid totally material sticking on the cutter. Cheers from Italy!

  • @billbubnis3128
    @billbubnis3128 9 місяців тому

    WD 40 is not a lubricant.

  • @arneminderman3770
    @arneminderman3770 10 місяців тому

    Thank you! Great pro test.

  • @oldfarthacks
    @oldfarthacks 11 місяців тому

    Thanks for the video. I am having fun turning a 90 dollar Cheap Chinese X-Y table into something useful and was looking at determining the squareness of the axis and top. Your video gives much the same methods for checking as I was thinking about using. Nice little mill you have built there, well done.

  • @ferrari2k
    @ferrari2k 11 місяців тому

    Hi, that looks really good, could you make a video about it being shown in the dark with backlighting or does that not work?

  • @Taseden
    @Taseden 11 місяців тому

    Not sure if you are still on here, but figured I would ask. I am planning on building one of these, but curious how you drilled the holes on the bottom of column? Most drill presses don't have room for the 17" or so inches the column is. Thanks!

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut 11 місяців тому

      I used a hand drill, with a drill guide to try and keep the holes perpendicular.

    • @Taseden
      @Taseden 11 місяців тому

      @@imnoexpertbut Awesome, thanks for replying. I would have never thought of the guide. I'll look into getting one.

  • @markoreilly3414
    @markoreilly3414 Рік тому

    I know I'm 2yrs late ~ Have you tried Methalated Spirit, in a hand held squirt bottle. It's what I grew up useing. It evaporates like the Ethanol but not as fast, it will stay pooled on the job for cooling, while having a mineral based lubricating action as well. I am impressed with the WD40 finish you got !

  • @maekeoz
    @maekeoz Рік тому

    Excellent 😃

  • @giuliobuccini208
    @giuliobuccini208 Рік тому

    Not perpendicular spindle?

  • @RCwallRaceTeamOfna
    @RCwallRaceTeamOfna Рік тому

    what is the dimensions of the aluminum bottom plate.?

  • @dencio1976
    @dencio1976 Рік тому

    How's the HGR15 holding up? I only ask cause I was thinking to get these cheap hgr15 as well for some aluminum cutting.

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut Рік тому

      They're holding up well so far, no rust despite the lack of heating & cooling in my garage.

  • @robertqueberg4612
    @robertqueberg4612 Рік тому

    Well…. You leave some issues uncovered. The 6061 aluminum is a large part of your problems. It is a rather gummy alloy, with any of its available tempers. A rather long endmill is not a friend. Using a stub length cutter with .01-.03” corner radius, or even a carefully ground micro-flat, slightly wider than your feed rate can help. K1 kerosene was a highly recommended drilling and tapping fluid in the early sixties, before the tap magic etc. were added to catalogues. So was a paste of white lead and sulphurised cutting oil. If you get a piece of 7075 T651, you may like the results. Painting oil on a surface ahead of the cutter doesn’t work well, as it moves away from the area of contact, either from heat, or air turbulence.

  • @dencio1976
    @dencio1976 Рік тому

    Do you have a link to that black cover thing to your rails and leadscrew? Thanks for the info. Ive only tried dried cutting and air blasted. Will try wd40

    • @imnoexpertbut
      @imnoexpertbut Рік тому

      On amazon it's called a "CNC Machine Black Rubber Accordion Pleats Shield Cover" www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0087ZCY86

    • @dencio1976
      @dencio1976 Рік тому

      @@imnoexpertbut OMG thanks! Been looking for this for a while now. Big help!