Відео

If u want it fast go watch Megadeth play

Newsted só se comprara à Cliff Burton!

The boys had been around forever by this point.....and they were still only 37

1:01 for those looking for that OOUUU moment joel talked about

CLIFF...METALLICA AS A CHILD JASON...METALLICA AS A TEEN ROB..METALLICA AS AN ADULT...ALL OF THEM EQUAL TALENT...

JASON NEWSTED.... !,,!,

Jason ♥️♥️♥️♥️

I think Lloyd Grant should get some credit (which I do see in your follow up video). There is a good interview that Lloyd gave in 2012 where he explains his involvement which I will leave below. He was essential to the Metal Massacre album...which was huge at the time. Lloyd met Lars through the LA Recycler (in the same way that Lars met James). Then James came into the mix after responding to a different ad in the LA Recycler. Ron McGovney was already living with James at the time. After James and Lars met, all sought studio time to record "Hit the Lights" and "Jump in the Fire". Then once this was completed, Dave Mustaine came in and recorded "Phantom Lord" etc, then he too was replaced by Kirk (whom at the time was with the band Exodus). Then finally they met Cliff only after seeing him play live as a member of Agents of Misfortune (without a pick...which was odd at the time for metal). There was a lot of history of Metallica, before there was even a name. Check out this interview with Lloyd Grant which does explain a bit of the sequence. I saw the follow-up video you did, but maybe a bit more context may give some depth. Hope this helps! :) ua-cam.com/video/ckm7HRKVbHk/v-deo.html

It's sad neither one of them can really play and it's not that hard of a bass line.

I enjoyed the chemistry they had with Jason more than Rob. Cliff was obviously the undisputed best (R.I.P. Cliff)but I wish Jason never left.. Robert looks stupid as fuck when he crouches and crawls around the stage like a Neanderthal trying to shit

It's no knock on Jason but in my opinion Rob has a better flow but cliff was better than both

I like Robert, but I like Jason better

How the hell you can compare the bass skills basing on two different ways of playing? Jason played with pick and Rob with fingers. Rob's version is more fluid and funky, while Jason's has more attack and sounds more straightforwarding. It depends on what you prefer. You can hear the real Jason in his days in Voivod and he is a kickass badmuthfckr there.

I'll take Jason every day of the week . R.I.P. Cliff though

Robert has a more skill compared to jason.... But the tune of jason bassistt has a is better sound for mettalica ....

I guess Rob is a virtuoso, while Newsted is just an average bass player, nothing prominent. But who cares.

It's a case of technical skill(rob) being inferior to tone and attitude(jason). Sorry, I grew up listening to ST and IG but the attitude and tone just isn't there. Not to mention the backup vocals.

The Tallica' were infinitely better with Jason..

Jason le metía mucha energía pero hay que aceptarlo Rob es más virtuoso para tocar que Jason yo creo que Jason no da el ancho con esa rola por eso nunca la pudo tocar completa al contrario de Rob el toca cualquier rola que le pongan sin pedos y muy similar a como lo hacía el buen cliff que la neta era el mejor ....

Jason! I like he plays the song on his own. I can't say Rob played it weakly, but Rob played like a robot. And I don't like his crabwalk.

I prefer Jason but I have much respect for Robert and can NOT hate him at ALL he’s amazing but on another level

Jason newsted by miles

that sucks that they always skip the break, before the solo, that's such an awesome slow part,, I understand for Woodstock they probably had limited time as always, but they still skip it either way

Kirk was in his prime that night!

if i had a dollar for every pixel in this video i would have 25 cents

0:49 for 2 seconds did I hear halo on fire or am I trippin?

Rob without a doubt better.

si quieres un bajista de funk, elige a trujillo.. yo me quedo con newsted, un sonido para metal y con propias excelentes bases melódicas, en cambio Trujillo gana a veces porque dicen que toca bien el anesthesia, ocupando bases melódicas de cliff, no vale

I vote jason i like his playing better but robert is amazing to but jason is just a better bassist in my opinon

jason

Jason is a great bass player but Rob is out of this world. Metallica sounds (and looks) better with him.

"You want it fast, or slow!?" *starts playing Until It Sleeps "then what the fuck they playin" "DID YOU SAY FAST!?" *goes into Thrash. This should have happened when they started recording Load, instead of releasing 2 albums that basically ruined Metallica. I go for St. Anger anyday over Shit 1 and Shit 2, at least Metallica played METALlica

Cliff was such a beast,... I'm actually suprised now that Newsted was actually recruited when I compare his skill to Cliff. Rob is definitely the man for the job.

so Fast!

Rob!!

Damn, Robert is amazing!!!

jason the best

Jason

Robert le da su paliza

when play live..Jason is solid clear and consistence .. and he Badass showman

los tres legendarios de Metallica nunca le dieron un lugar en la familia a Jason, eran como un viudo que descargó la culpa y el sufrimiento de haber perdido a su pareja(C. Burton) en la nueva esposa jejeje hasta que esta se canso y se fue ,cuando llego Trujillo se sentían tan culpables del daño que le habían hecho al otro pobre chico , que lo recibieron con bombos y platillos hicieron un gran esfuerzo para tratarlo como uno de ellos, tanto que se lo creyeron pero en el fondo saben que por mas técnico y talentoso que sea Rob, el publico extraña a Jason era el alma, la segunda voz y la fuerza de la banda, ahora es tarde para retroceder y tienen que tratar de recuperarse como sea .igual siguen siendo buenos .

I can close my eyes and imagine Cliff when Rob played. Damn I miss Cliff...

metallica con jason fueron los mejores tiempos, para mi jason le dio a metallica lo que ahora le falta...

Jason better show man

Robs version was better...too bad Lars's drumming ruined the song on that live performance!

Love u Metallica,James H;)*

tenia mejor sonido y efectos jason...

Rob is better, guys

Every bassplayer (or musican as well) has his own style, his trademark. Jason plays Orion in his style (and he plays with a plec). Whats's wrong with that? Nothing. Sounds great. Robs version is a 1:0,9 copy of Cliff. 0,9 because Cliffs plays with another feeling, another style, doing a lot of hammer'on's and pull'offs. Actually Rob fits 'tallica as well cause their selling their soul. Clean sound and making money. Business as usual. I don't wanna see 'tallica with Jason 'cause the spirit of trash metal isn't in the mind, in the soul of James & Lars anymore.

Cliff Burton forever