Відео

This is not music This is better than music

Are yall slow? There literally isn't a single comment that says this isn't music. SMH, this is why people dont like you guys.

8:45 is what i imagine sex with someone you truly love feels like😻

Black metal

this piece IS music because i am unable to refute the definition i was taught in high school music class ( early 1970s) That is to say it is organized sound, as I was taught, organized I might add, by some kind of creative intelligence. Bu that is a very broad definition and covers even Cage's "4 minutes 33" Whether it is good or great music is entirely another question I have a composition degree, I was an orchestral double bass player for 25 years and I have a trained ear. So i understand this piece HOWEVER I am now over 60. I am old and tired. life is too short to be bombarded by Shostakovich's angst. I gorged on it in my 20's now 40 year ago. but now no longer. If poor Shostakovich were a happy man who composed not a note he would have been much better off

Interesting comment section here My 2 cents.. if it's making everyone think this much, then I think regardless if you consider this music or not, it has effectively done its job. 👍 I do agree that Shostakovich's style changed over time as he distanced himself from some of his earlier compositional tendencies

Penis music at its finest

2:14 cello concerto no 1 cadenza final section

I’m not sure what all the fuss is about. I thoroughly enjoyed listening to this. The score is beastly!

Those who believe this isn’t music will explode when they hear Michel Finnissy

This recording is astounding. Fight me🔥

A complex piece that needs an attuned ear. If I watched a Spanish TV show, the dialogue would mean little to me because I've not learned Spanish. This is a piece that makes sense, if you are familiar with the idiom and have developed listening stamina.

İlk dəfə qulaq asdim əla əsərdir. Muasir dovr ucun yazib dahi Sostakovik👏👏

I like this-the opening reminds me of the Prokovief 3rd sonata.

Whats the time signature of the first part of this piece

so much more personality than his first sonata

Insane <3

shostakovich's first sonata or prokofiev's last?

I love Shostakovich, in general, but this isn’t one of his best works.

4:10 A wild shark appeared

Me struggling to find the people who say “this isn’t music”

there are so many similarities between this guy and anthheil that it's crazy, such a thought provoking avante-garde piece composed at the mere age of 19!

Despite the "this is not music" comments, I still do believe this is music.

Musica stupefacente! Adoro Shostakovich.

Not a part of the "this isn't music" comments lol. Saying some shit like that is crazy at this day and age. It isn't even that radical. There are a bunch of contemporary pieces I don't consider music. There IS indeed a line where it stops being music. But this obviously is music lol, but it doesn't mean it's "good". My problem with it is not the language used. But it does feel directionless to me on a first hearing. Tonal ambiguety can lead to adding too much fat to the music and making the form hard to follow. Also some stuff really seems forced. Him trying to show off how "modern" he could be for the time. To me it just seems pretentious. I much more prefer Prokofiev.

Personally, I find it enthralling !

Love Shostakovich. What a fearless and genuine composer.

So good

Это-Прокофьеву)

Sounds like Prokofiev's 3rd sonata

he must have liked what he composed here because you can hear his 2nd piano concerto throughout and that came 14 years later.

For all those who think this isn't music you definitely need to hear more than Liszt... I can't even imagine what will happen if you hear Schoenberg or even Ligeti.

Seems like he had already been through a lot

Wow, it sounds so modern, sometimes jazzy too

Wild, dark, and beautiful!

This is so much better than the 1st Sonata, Shostakovich really matured

Sounds like a Prokofiev sonata to me

If I recall correctly, the "Living Presence" recordinga were all made usinf 35 mm. magnetic film, rather than conventional magnetic tape. This made a HUGE difference in the quality of the finished product. The legendary Virgil Fox (a pupil of Dupre) made some of his finest recordings using this technology, under the direction of the late band leader Robert Fine. Not until Fox made his last two commercial recordings for Crystal Clear Records, using both digital and direct-to-disc technology, did Fox equal, let alone exceed, the quality of such recordings as this one!

Nice production. These extraordinary historic organ performances by legendary artists give quite a perspective on different interpretations of the pieces performed, especially this well-known concert piece.

Plot twist: Everyone was just mad that he said UA-cam's ContentID engine can be beneficial.

The music starts around 5:44

This is music

sounds like what i play when i’m bored

Brilliant composition brilliantly preformed. This dude is the world’s all time greatest Grieg interpreter.

ua-cam.com/video/KFldZhjWBxY/v-deo.html&ab_channel=freddyurbina

CEO of Music here: this is music.

I would believe those who say this isn't "music" give the word limited meaning. I personally feel the attempt to explore the essence of sound. Music is sound, but is sound music too? Then, regarding atonality, I do agree this isn't atonal. I definitely like it. I would not place Beethoven on the other side because there's no opposite side. Shostakovic wouldn't have been Shostakovic without LvB, JSB, WAM and all. Thanks for posting, looking for more!

Every time I went on exam I play this musix

It's so sad that Shostakovich was restrained mainly to the requirements of the Soviet Union during his career, and while he was a fantastic composer, he had to walk a fine line of expression and keeping to the party's demand, which if not walked correctly could've literally meant his death. A beautiful bird caged

I don't know how anyone could think this isn't music without also admitting that they have the artistic intellect of a 16th century noble who believes himself an authority of music but is really a bloated and harmonically miserly snob. This stuff makes perfect sense to me and, at points absolutely beautiful.