Відео

Why

Because you're following an idol not God. Throw away this false prophet to the trash & repent please

He's the biggest heretic of our time

It can become grating, but I don't think it's a put-on affect. I just think when you combine what seems like his awkwardness with his erudite smugness (and I say that as an admirer), it comes across this way.

sounds like you don't know what you're talking about... Still, good for you.

Everything you said is nothing but your invention as well. Everything political theorists say, everything literature professors say, everything the humanities say, everything logicians and mathematicians say. Hell, throw out all the humanities and just stick with your 'observational science'. Oh wait. Science can't exist without them. Go back to living in the caves and eating moose.

You are what we technically refer to as an idiot.

You are what we technically call a myopic robot spam bot.

Spoken like a true reductionist. While that may seem like a good argument against David Hart or any study of theology. It simply attempts to do something that is very limited in its nature and makes unscrupulous claims about logic. One can only take reductionism so seriously. As it uses logic to disprove or wittle down those things that are purely logical. In other words, you provide no refutation of David Hart's arguments. But merely a straw man of the entire field of logic and metaphysical investigation from an extreme empiricist perspective. Which can be used in all fields of study.

Produce your god, honey bunny boo.

What a load of waffle. This guy needs to work on his exposition, to put it mildly. Is he being deliberstely obscure to impress? And this is an eminant theogan and philosopher?

It will be easy for you to slink back to the hole you came from, since you can just retrace the path your knuckles dragged in the earth. Absolute ignorance on display from you and the other detractors

@@tylerlynch2849 Thank you for that charitable interpretation, probable non-judgmental ,loving and forgiving Christian. Haha.

​​@@nigelpalmer347☦Exactly, people here are getting mad that we true Christians exposing their false prophet & blasphemer for what he really is: an emperor with no clothes? Yes, this elitist talks gibberish to sound smart, and there's nothing "Orthodox" about him, so they need to repent for following idols like this arrogant one

It’s not hard to grasp the basic idea if youre familiar with the topic of the philosophical history of the soul, from antiquity to cartesian dualism, even if he is struggling to give an account of his thought as a syllabus. this is an overview of a course, not a thesis statement.

Theology is apart of the humanities. It's is the study of the history of religious beliefs, practices, cultures, and philosophy. It is far from baseless. Christianity, islam, judeism, hinduism, buddism, taoism, etc, are all historically infulential faiths that are still practiced today. Weather these faiths are true or not.

How cute. You want to parse it out until it intersects with something real. Try googling definitions for theology, Forest. Like these, for instance the·ol·o·gy (thē-ŏl′ə-jē) n. pl. the·ol·o·gies 1. The study of the nature of God and religious truth; rational inquiry into religious questions. 2. A system or school of opinions concerning God and religious questions: Protestant theology; Jewish theology. 3. A course of specialized religious study usually at a college or seminary. If people did not believe a god existed, there would be n o theology. The problem with asserting the existence of as god isn that it coincides with a non-functioning brain. if you assert a god, then you are clueless, and you will waste this entire incarnation. Theology is a complete sham

That is exactly what I said. Theology is the study of ideas and beliefs regarding the trascended. You are treating theology like a science it s not. Theology, once again, is of the humanities. Like liturature, philosophy, art, music, history. These fields of study deal mainly with society and culture. "If nobody believed in God, there would be no theology" thats real rocket science right there. Thats with all fields of study. If said thing was not apart of human experience it would not be studied by humans.

You are officially nuts.

Lol more ad hominems.

My OpenMind nice assertion with zero objective value. Just a personal opinion of your own psychological state. Troll back to your cave now.

Jotun Heim don’t like the truth much. Can you define “god”?

My OpenMind God is the source of ALL reality outside himself. Not that I'm waiting you to understand it but just for the record.

Jotun Heim be a little more specific.

sad to waste a life studying mechanical bullcrap with no purpose when the universe is going to end up all the same and nothing really matters. You can't get more delusional than that

Plain as horseshit.

@@nigelpalmer347 care to share your viewpoint?

The soul is NOT spirit - the spirit of life injected to it is, which gives it life. The soul is not material yet CORPOREAL, a substance, which forms the flesh & all its organs & gives it orders as a computer program, and flows by the blood throughout the flesh. While David Bentley Hart is just a blasphemer false prophet

what are you even saying? He's perfectly comprehensible

Don't tell an Olympian gymnast to simplify their routine for the sake of popular appeal. He's not gifted as a popular appeal theologian, he is gifted as a world-class, scholarly theologian. Let him be what he is.

@@chanting_germ. You know what is funny in these comments, just about everyone says basically, well just smarten up, and listen I get it that Harr is a PHD, with a great vocabulary, in more than 1 language, the guy is brilliant, but what about the student who is just coming into their own, right, they probably, or possibly might give up on Hart before giving him a chance, with the way that he goes out of his way to use difficult terms, and it could even hurt him in book sales, so all of you geniuses who are taking up for him, remember his editors might be telling him that he could be more ecsesable to more people if he just reeled it in a bit. Having said that though, the guy is flat out brilliant, I love the guy.

​@@ericday4505Hope after one year you learnt the correct spelling of accessible...

@@PC-vp2cg Spelling aside, what do you think of my other points?

@A P Hart is too good to be alone. I say he should start leaning in more

@@st.mephisto8564 He is married

bananimal45 Yes, but how to understand _him_? Not very approachable at times, most times (disclaimer: am not trained philosopher :)

That's because just like him, you don't believe in God, so repent

tabrizi79 yeah I was think that too - it would be good for him and may even make him sharper. Lots of amazing thinkers let their bodies go and they waist away early

Stephen, waste*

He was a very independent Thomist. He also was a very historicaly minded. And thus was able actually to see and draw on the metaphysics of St. Thomas, rather than that of his commentators seeing for instance the primacy of "esse" in the thought of Aquinas. There are reasons why he was an ally with De Lubac who recovered the doctrine of the Fathers and of the real St. Thomas on nature and grace.

It is orthodox philosophy. The philosophy in the book is least ignored by orthodox vs other Christian sects, but none is uncorrupted. He’s pretty clear in the intro why or why not-regarding what he wanted included in the book.

He was hospitalized for complications due to black mold inhalation in his home. His mother was ill too.

What a heretic you mean