“Because some roads you shouldn’t go down. Because maps used to say, “There be dragons here.“ Now they don’t. But that don’t mean the dragons aren’t there.”
I have so many reasons for not loving Ned stark, tywin was a far better father than Ned ( Tywin never considered Tyrion his son, rumours has that he's a Targaryen)
Spoken as someone who knows little about the use of a sword. As someone who has trained for 20 years I can tell you that yes an expert depending on preference and situation might do exceedingly well wielding two blades. In fact there were entire fighting styles and techniques developed specifically for the use of twin blades. So you are solidly wrong.
@@rayne_brownOther than the Japanese Musashi fighting style….can you name me a single other style or form that uses 2 blades? The Japanese use only 1 full length sword & 1 half length. You try blocking a 2 handed, overhead strike with 1 hand and your own blade is getting driven into your face or neck. Literally every sword expert who’s ever commented on the subject agrees 2 swords is a useless form & only exists to look good in movies. If you can find a single example of an expert saying otherwise….please post the link.
@@Ben-no4lz not a matter of blocking. Its a matter of turning the blade turning requires much less defensive energy. Done wrongly its a useless technique. Done right in many situations and with training plus the right sword (not all swords due to blade shape will be as effective) and it becomes very useful. As with any fighting styles and weapon choices there are trade offs some weapons//styles are not as effective depending on the situation you are in or the weapon your opponent has. Take boxing boxing as a martial art sucks because it is very non-adaptive. Best way for a non-boxer to beat a boxer? Easy DON'T box them. Don't play by their rules. Boxers are trained to fight and be adaptive only within a narrow combative field. Go outside that field and most of that training becomes either mostly useless or worse puts the boxer at risk. Don't box a boxer when you aren't a boxer yourself. Don't grapple a grappler unless you are the same. Make them play your game don't allow them to make you play theirs. Same with weapon styles. Every culture that has developed its own martial fighting style has at some point come up with a system that allows for duel wielding weapons successfully. It's much harder and often situational meaning there are instances where the second blade is less likely to be used and normally that isn't due to it not being able to work it is due to it being unnecessary. In Europe for example during the middle ages duel wielding a one handed sword with another one handed sword was not common. However wielding a one handed sword with a long heavy bladed dagger that was basically a middle ages equivalent (albeit slightly shorter) to the ancient Greek Xiphos was practiced it was techniques such as this that later gave rise to the rapier and short sword combinations that were popular during the European renaissance period. Often the much weaker short sword would be used not to block but to turn and glance an opponents blade away from you.
@@rayne_brown So you can’t name a single sword form that uses 2 full size swords? Like I said. “It’s not about blocking” - yet he blocked multiple times in this scene…..which is why he would have gotten killed almost immediately as the other commenter said. As I said - the 2 handed “forms” shown in movies & TV are fantasies & would never work as depicted.
Nah, the minute he beat all those guys and it turned into a 1v1, I’d have just walked away because apparently like 5 guys couldn’t take out this one dude, time to come back with like 15-20😂
I like Taylor aka Asia. Larry. Well. On. Paper. He does work for. Blackrock. But let’s be real. He’s not in charge Thu. He deserves jail. But. He’s out. Taylor. Always had a spark 🔥 about here. I seen it
young ned start doens't look anything like the old ned stark which is why this scene wasn't that powerful i think. this was the first time i kind of lost it with the show.
How did they get the detail of Oswell Whent sharpening his sword, but not having Gerald Hightower there, and having The sword of the morning using TWO swords.
No.1 fight in A Song of Ice and Fire history. The only fight that can top this one is the 'Rogue Prince' Deamon Targeryan and Caraxes the Blood Wyrm vs. Aemond 'One-eyed' Targeryan and Vhagar in the Battle above the God's Eye.
Say what you want about Aerys Targeryan. The man had the greatest Kingsguard of all time. The Sword of the Morning, the White Bull, Barristen Selmy, just to name a few. If they stayed in Kings Landing during its sacking, Jamie would've been killed, Aerys would still be breathing, Tywin would've been executed, the Lannister army would've failed, Viserys and Deanearys wouldn't fled from Kings landing with Rhaella, and Elia Martell and her children would still be alive with the Mountain killed by Arthur of Gerold.
I can see the pretext of Jamie's and Ned's fight here. Ser Dayn is stabbed in the back just like Ned was. He looks up and sees Ned in disbelief just the way Ned does to Jamie. Both Ned and Jamie are not happy to see the way their adversery fall to ground.
I just realized, when it finally becomes a 1v1 between Ser Arthur and Ned, Arthur adjusts his stance and then mimicks Neds movement. Ned swings his sword around and gets set first with Arthur getting set half a second after him. Arthurs right sword doesn't move, this shows that if Arthur had really wanted to kill Ned he could have done it at any time. I don't think Arhurs intention was to kill Ned, I think he wanted to subdue Ned and explain what had really happened with his sister. Neds rage and Howland Reeds intervention prevented Arthur from completing the task that was given to him by Reaghar.
Got memories of the sword experts saying this scene wasnt realistic?. Also that this fight wasnt like in the books with drama in the air and all that medival stuff. UA-cam was fill of buffons in those days xD
The amount of people that fight in melee with a 1handed sword no shield and no helmet is staggering ... that shit always bothered me because its so stupid
I have so many reasons for not loving Ned stark, tywin was a far better father than Ned ( Tywin never considered Tyrion his son, rumours has that he's a Targaryen)
Inhale, exhale.❌ Inhale, Lord Stark. ✅
Prequel of Ned Starks
Reed: “thunder buddies?” Stark: “thunder buddies for life!”
Good swordsman only ever used one sword, while this is fun looking, he would have got his shit rocked
Spoken as someone who knows little about the use of a sword. As someone who has trained for 20 years I can tell you that yes an expert depending on preference and situation might do exceedingly well wielding two blades. In fact there were entire fighting styles and techniques developed specifically for the use of twin blades. So you are solidly wrong.
@@rayne_brownOther than the Japanese Musashi fighting style….can you name me a single other style or form that uses 2 blades? The Japanese use only 1 full length sword & 1 half length. You try blocking a 2 handed, overhead strike with 1 hand and your own blade is getting driven into your face or neck. Literally every sword expert who’s ever commented on the subject agrees 2 swords is a useless form & only exists to look good in movies. If you can find a single example of an expert saying otherwise….please post the link.
@@Ben-no4lz not a matter of blocking. Its a matter of turning the blade turning requires much less defensive energy. Done wrongly its a useless technique. Done right in many situations and with training plus the right sword (not all swords due to blade shape will be as effective) and it becomes very useful. As with any fighting styles and weapon choices there are trade offs some weapons//styles are not as effective depending on the situation you are in or the weapon your opponent has. Take boxing boxing as a martial art sucks because it is very non-adaptive. Best way for a non-boxer to beat a boxer? Easy DON'T box them. Don't play by their rules. Boxers are trained to fight and be adaptive only within a narrow combative field. Go outside that field and most of that training becomes either mostly useless or worse puts the boxer at risk. Don't box a boxer when you aren't a boxer yourself. Don't grapple a grappler unless you are the same. Make them play your game don't allow them to make you play theirs. Same with weapon styles. Every culture that has developed its own martial fighting style has at some point come up with a system that allows for duel wielding weapons successfully. It's much harder and often situational meaning there are instances where the second blade is less likely to be used and normally that isn't due to it not being able to work it is due to it being unnecessary. In Europe for example during the middle ages duel wielding a one handed sword with another one handed sword was not common. However wielding a one handed sword with a long heavy bladed dagger that was basically a middle ages equivalent (albeit slightly shorter) to the ancient Greek Xiphos was practiced it was techniques such as this that later gave rise to the rapier and short sword combinations that were popular during the European renaissance period. Often the much weaker short sword would be used not to block but to turn and glance an opponents blade away from you.
@@rayne_brown So you can’t name a single sword form that uses 2 full size swords? Like I said. “It’s not about blocking” - yet he blocked multiple times in this scene…..which is why he would have gotten killed almost immediately as the other commenter said. As I said - the 2 handed “forms” shown in movies & TV are fantasies & would never work as depicted.
60fps looks horrible. Can people PLEASE STOP especially anime
Why would Dayne wish Ned good fortune in the wars to come? Did he really want to kill Ned? 🤔
probably bcuz Dayne knew that his side lost the war, and the Lord Stark was cleaning up the remainder of the Targayen forces
Good scene but I wish they spent an extra couple minutes to include more of the dialogue from the book. Keep it 7 vs 3 and introduce everyone there.
I hate Martin. He screwed up what could have been the best series ever.
hello Sir . Can we see the robbert barathen rebellion in house of the dragon web series ....?
Actually the case is ned stark lost arthur dayne won. Stabbed in the back by coward who was far out of war zone
Miyamoto Musashi would have been honored
How did he magically sheath his sword he stabbed in the dirt?
Impressive Swordsmanship👏👏👏
Back when the King's guard were of some use.
Does howland reed survive this fight? Cause if not then mira should be older than John and she doesn’t look like it in the show
Eddard: "Noh."
Why are they even fighting here? There’s no point. Why wouldn’t they just let him see his sister?
Nah, the minute he beat all those guys and it turned into a 1v1, I’d have just walked away because apparently like 5 guys couldn’t take out this one dude, time to come back with like 15-20😂
Who was the man that backstabbed arthur dayne
Son of the Morning
The other guy with sir dayne died easily 🥴
I like Taylor aka Asia. Larry. Well. On. Paper. He does work for. Blackrock. But let’s be real. He’s not in charge Thu. He deserves jail. But. He’s out. Taylor. Always had a spark 🔥 about here. I seen it
young ned start doens't look anything like the old ned stark which is why this scene wasn't that powerful i think. this was the first time i kind of lost it with the show.
Master Jedi Arther Dayne
Yoooooooo I just realized Young Ned Stark is ROB from the Netflix show Behind Her Eyes !!!! DAMN!!!
How did they get the detail of Oswell Whent sharpening his sword, but not having Gerald Hightower there, and having The sword of the morning using TWO swords.
How did Ned wield Ice with one hand?
Arthur Dayne lost because he was true to his word by wishing ned stark good fortune
And that's why you confirm your kill
this isnt 60fps
Souka,, ,
If the rest of the Aery's Kings Guard were at Trident with Rhaegar, I doubt Robert will win at Trident.
Good fortune is what save Ned that day.
I wish GRM would do a Robert's rebellion story, just so we can see young Ned & Rob
No.1 fight in A Song of Ice and Fire history. The only fight that can top this one is the 'Rogue Prince' Deamon Targeryan and Caraxes the Blood Wyrm vs. Aemond 'One-eyed' Targeryan and Vhagar in the Battle above the God's Eye.
ez
The chad "woe to the usurper if we had been" vs the virgin "your friend the usurper would lie blah blah blah".
Say what you want about Aerys Targeryan. The man had the greatest Kingsguard of all time. The Sword of the Morning, the White Bull, Barristen Selmy, just to name a few. If they stayed in Kings Landing during its sacking, Jamie would've been killed, Aerys would still be breathing, Tywin would've been executed, the Lannister army would've failed, Viserys and Deanearys wouldn't fled from Kings landing with Rhaella, and Elia Martell and her children would still be alive with the Mountain killed by Arthur of Gerold.
Rule #2: Double Tap
Remember when GOT was amazing? Yesh, good times
I don't blame Ned, Arthur was OP
One day this will be ME and My Daughter ONLY. Anyone else is a short visit guest on SURVEILLANCE
I can see the pretext of Jamie's and Ned's fight here. Ser Dayn is stabbed in the back just like Ned was. He looks up and sees Ned in disbelief just the way Ned does to Jamie. Both Ned and Jamie are not happy to see the way their adversery fall to ground.
If they will show Ser Arthur Dayne in Hotd I hope it’ll be the same actor.
Arthur Dayne had Ned beat, but all is fair in love and war...... smh
Whyyy arent they together?
I just realized, when it finally becomes a 1v1 between Ser Arthur and Ned, Arthur adjusts his stance and then mimicks Neds movement. Ned swings his sword around and gets set first with Arthur getting set half a second after him. Arthurs right sword doesn't move, this shows that if Arthur had really wanted to kill Ned he could have done it at any time. I don't think Arhurs intention was to kill Ned, I think he wanted to subdue Ned and explain what had really happened with his sister. Neds rage and Howland Reeds intervention prevented Arthur from completing the task that was given to him by Reaghar.
Got memories of the sword experts saying this scene wasnt realistic?. Also that this fight wasnt like in the books with drama in the air and all that medival stuff. UA-cam was fill of buffons in those days xD
The amount of people that fight in melee with a 1handed sword no shield and no helmet is staggering ... that shit always bothered me because its so stupid