Clear Cut Talks
Clear Cut Talks
  • 443
  • 26 902 705
J Sai Deepak on Re-contextualizing Indian History: Identity, Nationhood & Aryan Invasion Theory
Video Credit : SAMVAAD
💰 kindly consider supporting our YT Team - pages.razorpay.com/supportclearcutt
Your contributions help us Fund in Spreading the Word to More people ! 🙏
🚀 Don't Want to miss any Video updates ?
💬 Join WhatsApp & Telegram Community -
✅ WhatsApp Channel Link -
whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaJ3N2vBVJlAKI1Z2p3b
✅ Telegram Community Link -
t.me/clearcuttalksdiscussion
1. "History is not just about the past; it's about understanding who we are today."
2. "Can you crudely equate history with identity?"
3. "A country is a landmass, but a nation is built on shared history and aspirations."
4. "Without a common view of our past, there is no concept of a single nation."
5. "India is more like the 'United States of India' with distinct identities coming together."
6. "Past plus present equals nation."
7. "Is history where you come from and how you arrived at where you are today?"
8. "Understanding history is crucial for shaping our future."
Introduction :
J Sai Deepak begins by sharing his personal background and passion for history, emphasizing his love for the subject despite not being a trained historian. He explains his commitment to reading and understanding history, highlighting its relevance to everyday life and personal identity. Despite his enthusiasm, he questions the broader utility of history for the average person, particularly from a practical or financial standpoint.
**The Importance of History**
Deepak delves into the significance of studying history, arguing that it goes beyond academic or policy-making interests. He questions the common utilitarian approach to education, which prioritizes fields like engineering, medicine, law, and accountancy over history. He challenges the audience to consider the deeper value of history, proposing that it can be crudely equated to identity. History, he suggests, is fundamental to understanding who we are, where we come from, and how we have arrived at our current state.
**Defining Country and Nation**
Deepak explores the difference between a country and a nation, using simple English definitions. He references Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's work, particularly his book "Pakistan or the Partition of India," to explain these concepts. According to Ambedkar, a country is merely a landmass, while a nation is a more complex entity formed by a people with shared history and aspirations. Deepak underscores the importance of a common historical perspective and overlapping future goals in forming a cohesive nation.
**Diversity and Unity in India**
Addressing the challenge of unity in a diverse country like India, Deepak acknowledges the distinct identities of various states and regions. He cites Dr. Ambedkar's view that India is akin to the "United States of India," with multiple states coming together under a shared idea of Bharat Varsh. He questions what unites vastly different groups, such as a Peshawari Pathan and a Tamilian, and examines whether physical features, language, or race can define a nation.
**Common Historical Perspective**
Deepak stresses the need for a shared view of the past to foster national unity. He presents a hypothetical division where half the country views historical figures like Aurangzeb as tyrants, while the other half sees them as role models. This divergence, he argues, highlights deep societal fault lines and hampers the formation of a unified national identity. A nation, he concludes, requires both a common historical perspective and a shared vision for the future.
[Disclaimer] ⭐
This video has been reposted for educational and informational purposes . All credit for the creation of this content goes to its original owner . We do not claim ownership of any materials used in the making of this video . If you are the rightful owner of the content and wish for it to be removed or credited differently, please contact us immediately. Thank you for your understanding and cooperation .
Переглядів: 475

Відео

J Sai Deepak on Nehru's Policy, Missionaries in North-East, Hindu Demographic Shift in Manipur
Переглядів 4,6 тис.12 годин тому
J Sai Deepak on Nehru's Policy, Missionaries in North-East, Hindu Demographic Shift in Manipur
Who Can Learn the Vedas? J Sai Deepak on Brahmins, Arya Samaj & Tradition
Переглядів 52 тис.21 годину тому
Who Can Learn the Vedas? J Sai Deepak on Brahmins, Arya Samaj & Tradition
J Sai Deepak on India's Growth - Culture & economics don't operate in silos ; civilizational issues
Переглядів 1,9 тис.День тому
J Sai Deepak on India's Growth - Culture & economics don't operate in silos ; civilizational issues
J Sai Deepak on Modi's digital revolution - Empowering rural India, Democracy & Economic Growth
Переглядів 2,2 тис.День тому
J Sai Deepak on Modi's digital revolution - Empowering rural India, Democracy & Economic Growth
J Sai Deepak on Renaming India to Bharat: Podcast on Historical Truths , Middle Eastern Colonialism
Переглядів 9 тис.День тому
J Sai Deepak on Renaming India to Bharat: Podcast on Historical Truths , Middle Eastern Colonialism
Anand Ranganathan on Kashmir Policies & Need for Action "Money minted from tourism funds terrorism"
Переглядів 1,9 тис.День тому
Anand Ranganathan on Kashmir Policies & Need for Action "Money minted from tourism funds terrorism"
J Sai Deepak on Revival of Sanatana Dharma: Unified Dharma Sansad , Bharat & North-South Unity
Переглядів 2,7 тис.14 днів тому
J Sai Deepak on Revival of Sanatana Dharma: Unified Dharma Sansad , Bharat & North-South Unity
J Sai Deepak on Hindu , Article 370, Ram Temple & Kashmiri Pandits | History & Demographics changes
Переглядів 1,6 тис.14 днів тому
J Sai Deepak on Hindu , Article 370, Ram Temple & Kashmiri Pandits | History & Demographics changes
" Historic Reclamation " J Sai Deepak on Ram Janmabhoomi Mandir, Hindu Unity & International Opinion
Переглядів 54314 днів тому
" Historic Reclamation " J Sai Deepak on Ram Janmabhoomi Mandir, Hindu Unity & International Opinion
J Sai Deepak on Hindutva, Propaganda & Bharat: Tamil Brahmin , Dravidianism & Historical Identity
Переглядів 49014 днів тому
J Sai Deepak on Hindutva, Propaganda & Bharat: Tamil Brahmin , Dravidianism & Historical Identity
J Sai Deepak Podcast on Judiciary, Constitutional Law & Hindutva: Ideology & Institutional Integrity
Переглядів 2,3 тис.14 днів тому
J Sai Deepak Podcast on Judiciary, Constitutional Law & Hindutva: Ideology & Institutional Integrity
J Sai Deepak on Vote Jihad, Hindutva & India's Future , Discussing National Identity & Legal Issues
Переглядів 43 тис.21 день тому
J Sai Deepak on Vote Jihad, Hindutva & India's Future , Discussing National Identity & Legal Issues
J Sai Deepak on Podcast " I want Tamil Nadu to be fully conquered by Hindutva " | Dravidian Movement
Переглядів 12 тис.21 день тому
J Sai Deepak on Podcast " I want Tamil Nadu to be fully conquered by Hindutva " | Dravidian Movement
J Sai Deepak on Hindu Religion, Culture & Caste - Hindutva & Indian Society | Sushant Sinha Podcast
Переглядів 3,5 тис.21 день тому
J Sai Deepak on Hindu Religion, Culture & Caste - Hindutva & Indian Society | Sushant Sinha Podcast
J Sai Deepak on Awakening Hindu Identity - Protecting Family , Traditions & Education Reforms
Переглядів 3,2 тис.21 день тому
J Sai Deepak on Awakening Hindu Identity - Protecting Family , Traditions & Education Reforms
J Sai Deepak Latest Podcast on India's Political Challenges : Caste, Secularism & Hindutva Explained
Переглядів 2,7 тис.21 день тому
J Sai Deepak Latest Podcast on India's Political Challenges : Caste, Secularism & Hindutva Explained
J Sai Deepak on NRC , Shaheen Bagh Protests , Eco-System Against Bharat & Hindus & Yogi Model in UP
Переглядів 10 тис.21 день тому
J Sai Deepak on NRC , Shaheen Bagh Protests , Eco-System Against Bharat & Hindus & Yogi Model in UP
J Sai Deepak on the Importance of Identity , Hindutva, Dharma, Hindu Philosophy & Economic Strength
Переглядів 3,9 тис.21 день тому
J Sai Deepak on the Importance of Identity , Hindutva, Dharma, Hindu Philosophy & Economic Strength
J Sai Deepak on Dharma or Constitution | Preserving Indian Languages - Importance of mother Tongue
Переглядів 2,5 тис.28 днів тому
J Sai Deepak on Dharma or Constitution | Preserving Indian Languages - Importance of mother Tongue
J Sai Deepak on Hindu Secularism , Demographics Challenges of Illegal Immigration & CAA on Podcast
Переглядів 3,7 тис.28 днів тому
J Sai Deepak on Hindu Secularism , Demographics Challenges of Illegal Immigration & CAA on Podcast
J Sai Deepak Exposing Myth of North-South Divide by Politicians | Dravidians & Tamil Brahmin exodus
Переглядів 2,8 тис.Місяць тому
J Sai Deepak Exposing Myth of North-South Divide by Politicians | Dravidians & Tamil Brahmin exodus
J Sai Deepak on The Battle for Temple Freedom From State Control : Legal & Social Views #jsaideepak
Переглядів 1,9 тис.Місяць тому
J Sai Deepak on The Battle for Temple Freedom From State Control : Legal & Social Views #jsaideepak
Who is J Sai Deepak ? Education Qualification ? Latest Podcast Lawyer Challenges & Hindutva Ideology
Переглядів 2,1 тис.Місяць тому
Who is J Sai Deepak ? Education Qualification ? Latest Podcast Lawyer Challenges & Hindutva Ideology
J Sai Deepak on Reservation , Muslim Reservation & Caste based infighting among Hindus #reservation
Переглядів 1,9 тис.Місяць тому
J Sai Deepak on Reservation , Muslim Reservation & Caste based infighting among Hindus #reservation
J Sai Deepak Explains Ambedkar on Pakistan, Ahmediya Muslims, exposing Communists, & Hindus Refugee
Переглядів 30 тис.Місяць тому
J Sai Deepak Explains Ambedkar on Pakistan, Ahmediya Muslims, exposing Communists, & Hindus Refugee
J Sai Deepak on Truth Behind Indian Muslims' Decision to Stay - Maulana Madani & Asaduddin Owaisi
Переглядів 200 тис.Місяць тому
J Sai Deepak on Truth Behind Indian Muslims' Decision to Stay - Maulana Madani & Asaduddin Owaisi
J Sai Deepak Reply on India to Bharat Civilizational , Spiritual Reawakening & Rediscovering Dharma
Переглядів 5 тис.Місяць тому
J Sai Deepak Reply on India to Bharat Civilizational , Spiritual Reawakening & Rediscovering Dharma
J Sai Deepak on Reviving Bharat's Spiritual Legacy Role of Dharma, Samskara & Guru-Shishya Tradition
Переглядів 548Місяць тому
J Sai Deepak on Reviving Bharat's Spiritual Legacy Role of Dharma, Samskara & Guru-Shishya Tradition
Anand Ranganathan Exposing Media Bias : Dhruv Rathee , Political Hypocrisy & Systemic Flaws in India
Переглядів 227 тис.Місяць тому
Anand Ranganathan Exposing Media Bias : Dhruv Rathee , Political Hypocrisy & Systemic Flaws in India

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @Mr_India....
    @Mr_India.... 14 хвилин тому

    Would any of those who are disagreeing with Sai Deepak sir like to tell me why women are not allowed in mosques with men??

  • @hellogamer95
    @hellogamer95 19 хвилин тому

    Absolutely true 👍 and we have experienced it

  • @Jm55964
    @Jm55964 20 хвилин тому

    Acharya Prashant ❤

  • @bhanusamuel1767
    @bhanusamuel1767 54 хвилини тому

    Look how he is dressed…hmm

  • @GlobalSecularism
    @GlobalSecularism Годину тому

    Why would the Portuguese destroy a temple? What is your evidence? Or is it from your WhatsApp University?

  • @Vkb128
    @Vkb128 2 години тому

    This guy is stupid. Bjp broker.

  • @md.sohailali7961
    @md.sohailali7961 5 годин тому

    Han is two nation theory me Kuch dongle bhi hone Chahiye Jo pehle Jina Bhai thakkar ke Saath religion based provisional governments banquet aur unhi ki aulaad age aakar ye two nation theory Ka Randi Rona kare hamara Mulk bat Gaya.

  • @adithyababu3217
    @adithyababu3217 5 годин тому

    This guy still living thinking about colonial life. 😂 Its wise to move on from the past and create a new history.

    • @AjayKumar-bi9jp
      @AjayKumar-bi9jp 2 години тому

      He is trying to the do the same what you have mentioned

  • @abdurrahimkhan1263
    @abdurrahimkhan1263 6 годин тому

    Yeh only jhooot boolta rahta hai 😮😮😮

  • @RasheedSyd
    @RasheedSyd 8 годин тому

    Inku chinta ye nahi ki India kahan jaa raha hai.. inku chinta ye hai ki musalmaan europe mein kya kar raha hai.. phati padi hai inki.. ye bhi sunlo .. not just europe we are in US, Russia, Japan, Australia.. increasing with awesome rate 😂

  • @Unfollowthem
    @Unfollowthem 8 годин тому

    I dont know what energy gave him by god.... If i think about Bharata, culture, Lang i cant sleep... How Sai and all constantly fight.... ❤❤❤

  • @sureshsetty2865
    @sureshsetty2865 9 годин тому

    ❤😊

  • @sarthakmehta5312
    @sarthakmehta5312 9 годин тому

    L h b u b....😊

  • @prashantmali8192
    @prashantmali8192 9 годин тому

    Salute to this man … I love his knowledge and speech.

  • @amishsurani4765
    @amishsurani4765 9 годин тому

    Bjp is cancer for india

  • @73vijay
    @73vijay 9 годин тому

    Spreading negativity

  • @sarthakmehta5312
    @sarthakmehta5312 9 годин тому

    O r ast b n n ....

  • @humansnotfromearth
    @humansnotfromearth 10 годин тому

    Next prime minister is on its way

  • @historiadegauda3740
    @historiadegauda3740 10 годин тому

    There isn't anything called Country . Where a nation's natural habitat and culture exists that is called country.

  • @Vkb128
    @Vkb128 10 годин тому

    Sai Deepak, bjp agent from Tamilnadu

  • @Vkb128
    @Vkb128 10 годин тому

    Sai Deepak, pl get out of UA-cam...irritating

  • @starxust3827
    @starxust3827 10 годин тому

    True

  • @Vkb128
    @Vkb128 10 годин тому

    Sai Deepak is bjp broker

  • @Vkb128
    @Vkb128 10 годин тому

    Sai Deepak, a great idiot but speaks like brilliant fellow

  • @ANIMEZTOWATCH
    @ANIMEZTOWATCH 11 годин тому

    Any sanatani laude is present here ? .

  • @prateekguleria
    @prateekguleria 11 годин тому

    For long i thought he is the guy who advocates for Hindu unity and Hindutva....But now I see he a cunning guy who advocates for Hindu division and Brahmin Supremacy.....Beware of this mf...

  • @prateekguleria
    @prateekguleria 11 годин тому

    Hahaha...ek to vakeel...upr se pandit.... On the name of Hindutva, Hindu Identity and culture this guy is charlatan...If these people are called nationalists..I am sorry but it doesn't fit....These are cunning people with agenda .. While criticizing abrahamic religions they themselves are trying to integrate Abrahamic ways into Sanatan...Sanatan is not a typical religion...It is the way of life,way of being.....people have done enough damage on the name of dogmas n superstitions... Last thing we need are these pseudo reformers who use the half truths and half facts to mislead Hindus in a very appealing way... Fortunately there are people is our Sanatan way of life who understand the essense of it rather than becoming prey to these mob minded buggers.....

  • @supersubra421
    @supersubra421 11 годин тому

    Indians and Idiots has two I”s and start with an I. Just saying 😂. Only Indians will elect traitors like Nehru and continue to support Congress a party of traitors

  • @dtmmm
    @dtmmm 12 годин тому

    this manuwaadi comedian motormouth has only loyalty to his manuwaadi bamanism and will go to any extend to layer culture and tradition to motormouth baman superiority and use the non baman hindu majority as his weightage while never call them as equal to baman

  • @mohammadnisaar5832
    @mohammadnisaar5832 12 годин тому

    Without islam and without muslim no deabate will complete.sai deepak remembered in future just like swarkar.if you are right or wrong in today cant decide but in future people remembered this man as shit.

  • @zf2000
    @zf2000 12 годин тому

    ... and India is 144th on happiness index, whereas the top one are mostly western.

  • @user-sx8by6bn1y
    @user-sx8by6bn1y 12 годин тому

    Right❤

  • @user-sx8by6bn1y
    @user-sx8by6bn1y 12 годин тому

    Right sir

  • @user-sx8by6bn1y
    @user-sx8by6bn1y 12 годин тому

    J sai deepak sir you are Right

  • @harshith789
    @harshith789 12 годин тому

    Right on 🎯

  • @ramanaidub3083
    @ramanaidub3083 12 годин тому

    Hindu fundamentalist and Muslim fundamentalist will be same page to keep people in the dark.

  • @cutestar564
    @cutestar564 12 годин тому

    Why are people getting irritated by knowing the history,,,😢😢 did Portuguese not attack india??Its even in history books..

  • @sumanthkooloth8105
    @sumanthkooloth8105 13 годин тому

    This guy will only talk about Religion & Caste... nonsense ans no science..

  • @mercedesbenz3751
    @mercedesbenz3751 13 годин тому

    All christians in North East be it Naga or Mizo, they support Kukis, but why can't we hindus from Mainlamd India support our Meitei brothers and sisters? Shame on us hindus🤮

  • @Damakaentertainment
    @Damakaentertainment 14 годин тому

    I partially disagree with you sir. If that is true then Bangladesh never been come in to the existence. The point about partition was true but Religion alone can't hold us unite. There are lots of factors respecting others culture, traditions, language involved as well.

  • @MS-ov9sv
    @MS-ov9sv 14 годин тому

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @poppyji
    @poppyji 14 годин тому

    Very true. Congress has sawn a seed of differences between hindu community. You have said a very deep thing.

  • @prabhakarrao5024
    @prabhakarrao5024 14 годин тому

    He speaks too fast 👎

    • @Sawalisen
      @Sawalisen 10 годин тому

      Change your player speed to normal-its set to 1.5x

  • @clearCutTalks
    @clearCutTalks 15 годин тому

    💰 Support Us : pages.razorpay.com/supportclearcutt Subscribe Our Backup Channel - youtube.com/@veer2024?si=VcvyIOrkI3QyC88Y Your generous contributions help us expand our reach and spread the word to more people ! Thank you ! 🙏 🚀 Stay Updated : Don't want to miss any video updates? 💬 Join Our Community : WhatsApp Channel : whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaJ3N2vBVJlAKI1Z2p3b Telegram Community : t.me/clearcuttalksdiscussion

  • @dtmmm
    @dtmmm 15 годин тому

    😂😂😂manuwaadi at his best ,, always and at every stage has to keep bamanwaad alive

  • @narayanan26
    @narayanan26 15 годин тому

    😂😂😂

  • @RAJESHKUMAR-dq5os
    @RAJESHKUMAR-dq5os 15 годин тому

    Fk u😂...this useless bramanical nasty kid, licking tamilnadu people a****. All are fake half boiled stories...

  • @Mhmdwazpedo21
    @Mhmdwazpedo21 15 годин тому

    ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @coocoo-pe7yw
    @coocoo-pe7yw 16 годин тому

    A pleasure to listen to J. Sai Deepak. Informative and insightful, always!

  • @seanbellfort2298
    @seanbellfort2298 16 годин тому

    💪 Excellent insights. Thank you.