dx7tnt
dx7tnt
  • 8
  • 4 162
Wittgenstein and The Problem of Other Minds (including his Beetle in a Box)
This video was made for PHIL241 at the University of Liverpool. It focusses on the problem of other minds, and whether it's a real problem at all. It first considers the epistemological problem of other minds, responses to it including the argument from analogy, and the inference to best explanation. Then the presentation moves on to the phenomenological approach, leading on to Wittgenstein's "Beetle in a Box" formulation of an answer from the Philosophical Investigations (1953).
He shows that the problem isn't one of knowledge, but one of being - that of our intersubjective world with others, and so the game the Cartesian sceptic wants to play is a pseudo-problem, and our intuition is correct. He highlights the meaningless of private sensations when labelled as a thing or a noun being one root of the problem. I then consider some questions and highlight a zen approach to other minds, better thought of as nonduality.
Comments and questions may be directed to me at syhr.co.uk
Переглядів: 1 546

Відео

Bad Present Day
Переглядів 448 років тому
Bad Present Day by The Living Brain Recorded at the Zanzibar, Liverpool, UK
The Living Brain - Burnout 2000 - Live in Liverpool
Переглядів 51110 років тому
Burnout 2012! The classic Burnout 2000 from the even more classic "Life Sentence on Planet Earth LP" Live from the Zanzibar, Liverpool, Friday 13th August 2012. Video with new and improved sound. Full recording for anyone who wants it. Talk to thelivingbrain.bandcamp.com Thanks to Delboy (I think) for the video and everyone else who recorded videos of the gig, and everyone who came and made it ...
Dominoes - All in All (just the video version) Watch in HD
Переглядів 26913 років тому
Dominoes and the amazing psychedelic colourfield of his being entirely All in All.
Dominoes - Love Exists - Watch in HD
Переглядів 33213 років тому
Song, music and instruments by Dominoes. Drums by Percy Cubical. Sound recording by Rhys Jones at meem, Duke St, Liverpool. Produced by the Universe in 2007. Video by Dominoes and Rhys No animals were harmed by us in the making of this video. One pig was harmed (seriously) by someone else. (C) 2007-2011 All Rights Reserved, and Reversed.
Carly Collingwood - Killing Time (Basement) Watch in HD
Переглядів 39814 років тому
Carly Collingwood plays "killing time" in an underground carpark, 1.30am, August 2010, Liverpool. Recording and video by Rhys Jones. see flavours.me/carlycollingwood for more information. Album due for release early 2011.
Dominoes - All In All - Watch in HD
Переглядів 83414 років тому
The video will commence after a short message from The Brown Shadow.
The Brown Shadow and The Robin
Переглядів 22814 років тому
Domino enjoying spring in his Liverpool garden. A handsome robin comes to watch his ode. Captured on film by Rhys.

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @hahathatsgood
    @hahathatsgood 2 роки тому

    Thanks so much for making this video! It's exactly what I was looking for. You bring together many authors with great clarity, summary, and analysis.

    • @dx7tnt
      @dx7tnt 2 роки тому

      Thank you so much for your kind comments.

  • @fr.hughmackenzie5900
    @fr.hughmackenzie5900 2 роки тому

    thanks, helpful. Nice to see the link between phenomenology and Wittgenstein. Not acknowledged enough. In this regard Edith Stein's idea of empathy, and Levinas' approach are interesting - though they argue that it shows the reality of distinct persons - a move away from yourself and Heidegger.

    • @dx7tnt
      @dx7tnt 2 роки тому

      Thank you for your comment. There's a philosopher called Soren Overgaard who wrote a good paper and book on Wittgenstein's phenomenal approach to the problem of other minds.

  • @thebrownshadowrecords7966
    @thebrownshadowrecords7966 2 роки тому

    Classic

  • @thebrownshadowrecords7966
    @thebrownshadowrecords7966 2 роки тому

    Classic

  • @brianlynn4738
    @brianlynn4738 6 років тому

    Still sound good young bro

  • @jamespagella3959
    @jamespagella3959 10 років тому

    the living brain - yes please

  • @gianthumbug
    @gianthumbug 13 років тому

    it sure does man, love it all

  • @AlbertBroughton
    @AlbertBroughton 13 років тому

    I've seen Carly sing this live in a busy rock music venue, and it was serene ... Al.

  • @dx7tnt
    @dx7tnt 14 років тому

    Phresh!

  • @zukalor
    @zukalor 14 років тому

    are the authorities aware that this man is at large?