Відео

The only bad harry potter book is the cursed child

the basilisk was kinda lame ngl

Marauders fans getting to read Prisoner of Azkaban from Sirius and Lupin’s povs in fanfics 🥰

By changing endings, we are changing continuity. One thing I would change is that Dumbldore dies not by the hand of Snape in sixth book, but rather by the hand of Voldemort in fifth book. I would change ending to the Order Of Phoenix. Dumbledore dies at the hands of Voldemort. Harry is believed to be dead. Voldemort while victorious is heavily injured and retreaves. Hardest part is to make Harry's death believable, especially to the reader or viewer. Nevertheless, the most important thing is that the cast believes Harry to be dead and that all hope is basically lost. Sixth book would be from the perspective of Ron and Hermione and not untill the end of sixth book Voldemort is fully healed and Harry comes back.

Hermione is the main character. We're told throughout the books that she is "the brightest witch of her generation" where as Harry has "no magical fortitude whatsoever." In Book 1 he doesnt even cast a spell. And its the women who defeat 90% of the death eaters and solve problems. As Ron himself says "She solves like 90% of our problems. We're useless without Hermione." edit: typos

Do scenes from each movie

🔥🔥🔥🔥

Personally I would only want little snippets from these characters in pivotal moments and not a full book POV. A lot of what people (myself included) love about Harry Potter are the mysteries. I think that following these characters would make it far too easy to put pieces together. It would be cool to see certain scenes from their perspectives, but ultimately it would be like being spoon-fed.

Sirius for Prisoner of Azkaban would be better as a movie but when you're talking about books Lupin is definitely better. Edit: I would even say this would be better than the existing Prisoner of Azkaban because for the whole book Harry is just kind of just speculating while everybody else actually does something about the events of the book

Great Video, I would love to see you make a video about Hogwarts Legacy, either playing it or just doing a review of it, just a suggestion. Again amazing video

Philosopher’s Stone would be so interesting from Dumbledore’s perspective! There’s even theories that basically everything in that book was Dumbledore’s way of testing Harry and his friends. Chamber of Secrets I could see also being really cool from Ginny’s perspective, particularly as she doesn’t really know what she’s doing. Azkaban from Remus’ pov would’ve been SO GOOD! I love the marauders so I feel like this would’ve given us so much more insight, and would’ve kept the twist ending as even he doesn’t know that Sirius and Peter switched places. Goblet of Fire I think would’ve been interesting from lots of different characters, I think Snape could’ve been interesting, or each of the other champions. Order could’ve been interesting from the perspective of Snape, as he’s rebuilding Voldemort’s trust in him, working for the Order and is obviously at Hogwarts too. I think Mad eye would’ve also been interesting as we don’t really get to know him during Goblet and he’s not only in the order but he’s also an Auror. Half Blood would’ve obviously been super interesting from the perspective of either Draco or Snape, since they’re both being torn between the dark and the light. I also think it would’ve been interesting to watch Draco fixing the vanishing cabinet and all of his attempts to kill Dumbledore. I also think this would’ve been interesting from Dumbledore’s perspective as he’s constantly going out searching for horcruxes and delving into Voldemort’s past, and knowing he doesn’t have much time left. As for deathly hallows, I think seeing it from the perspective of Neville would’ve been amazing, he’s leading the resistance at Hogwarts right under the noses of two death eaters which would’ve been cool to see more of. And of course Snape would’ve been really fascinating to see.

All the books have a "deuteragonist" (second main character) to fits Harry's POV In PS, we have both Ron and Hermione In COS we have Ginny and Tom Riddle In POA we have Lupin and Sirius In GOF we have Moody/Crounch Jr and Cedric In TOOF we have Luna and Neville In HBP we have Dumbledore and Malfoy And DH we have Snape and Voldemort All of these characters are there to support the story Harry is in, they are there to make Harry grown as man, wizard and hero, but if we really see the context of story, everything was about Dumbledore's big plan to Harry defeat Voldemort, he was the one that helped the most Harry to grow strong and prepare him to the sacrifice and the final battle. It's pretty different from Hogwarts Legacy where the Mc is clearly the solo MC, nobody is more important than them, while in HP Snape and his sad background and rivalry with Harry and Dumbledore with his plan and being Harry's master made them almost as important as Harry himself to Voldemort's fall.

The Problem with seeing book 7 from Snape's point of view is, that it would have a rather abrupt ending.

3:44 I do agree with you that Lupin would be better than Sirius because if Sirius was the main character it would remove a fair amount of the great twist in the book. 6:09 I completely agree with this except for one issue, and it's the same as the first I brought up with Sirius, if this book was told was Barty Crouch Jr.'s perspective we would know all of the twists immediately, and not get to discover all the amazing foreshadowing that there was whenever we reread the book. 6:45 Some people say it's a plot hole that Barty Crounch Jr. teaches Harry's class the three unforgivable curses. Still, I disagree because Barty Crounch Jr. is doing exactly what Mad-Eye Moody would do in this situation. Mad-Eye Moody would've taught the four years about the three unforgivable curses, and Barty Crouch can't take any chances whatsoever because he knows Dumbledore can't be easily tricked and knows Mad Eye Moody very well, so if Barty Crouch does even one thing that Mad-Eye Moody wouldn't have done then his cover is blown. 10:11 I think we can all agree that Draco gets so much love and sympathy because Tom Felton is the definition of a thirst trap.

great video! i think it would have been cool to see nevilles perspective in deathly hallows as he leads Dumbledore's army and everything.

Great Video, you should do a UA-cam Colab with movie flame it would be cool to see your opinions (I think you guys have similar opinions)

nice beat bro 👊

This is so creative love it

Excellent video! I wonder how it would be like seeing Hagrid's perspective in Chamber of Secrets. The chamber reopening, going to Azkaban knowing he was innocent, helping the trio hoping they'd work it out.

Also, did Tom help Ginny with the poem to Harry? 🫢😏

I think it’d be interesting to see Goblet from Cedric’s perspective. How he felt with all the pressure to bring glory to Hufflepuff and getting overshadowed by Harry

I was so hoping for Kreacher - AND YOU DELIVERED!

awesome video, I have similar taste. My 2 fav books are 1) prince 2) goblet, least fav are 8)prisoner 7)order but definately 2 fav movies are 1) prisoner 2) order 😆

You should play hogwarts legacy

Loved the vlog!

Who thinks when they should have done it as a TV show originally because the new one they're going to do isn't going to have the same feel because certain characters and actors won't be there

I think so many peoples favourite of the movies is Prisoner of Azkaban but I’m always so curious whether it’s because that’s the one Alfonso Cuaron directed and has such a different style or if it’s regardless of that and just their favourite storyline, characters etc. Maybe you should do a video about the directors styles but as different movies and which combination would’ve been strongest. I can’t imagine David Yates doing the first two or Chris Columbus doing deathly hallows but I wonder if it’d be better/worse 🤔 I think I’d have liked to have seen Alfonso Cuarons take on Goblet of Fire though. Btw love your videos!

I was born in 1996 and was very fortunate to be able to see all most all the movies in theaters as a kid and it was so incredible!! Growing up with these movies and books has changed my life and I currently am listening to the audiobooks again for the second time! The place potter holds in my heart is so special

I love your content bro. I’d love to listen to an HP podcast from you

20 years I feel old now. I remember getting the dvd when it first came out I was 7 and it kinda spooked me but I loved it and still do. The 3rd book was my favourite and the movie wasn’t a bad adaptation. Also kinda related but unrelated. If Disney was for an anniversary put The Hunchback of Notre Dame back in the cinema I’d go and watch it because it is my favourite movie of all time. Yeah I’ve seen it hundreds of times since I was a kid to adult I’ve loved it all my life and I’d kill to get the chance to see it on a massive screen and hear the music and the Latin choir on the surround sound speakers. My thoughts are why not. Does it even matter if one’s favourite movie is already on dvd and streaming no, not if you enjoy it. If presented with the chance take it. I know they did it for Hocus Pocus and I wanted to see it in cinemas but unfortunately I couldn’t find the time around my schedule as it was for one day only. Same with when Titanic was put back in the cinema. The only showings were late in the evenings on two weekends days or something like that and I didn’t fancy being out in the streets gone midnight by the time it finished but hopefully someday I’ll get the chance to see at least one of my favourite films when it’s rereleased in cinema.

I would love to see visiting filming locations!!!

One thing I hate about the books, is the overuse of polyjuice potion, in the whole wide world of potions, they use the same one constantly

The worst scene in DH Part one isn’t Ron’s over the top lines, although that is the second worst scene. The absolute worst is Harry and Hermione dancing and acting all romantic, which is the complete opposite to what happened during that time in the book.

For Book 1 I think Neville is a good choice, but one could also consider Firenze, the centaur who saved Harry and gave him important hints.

Isn't there a thing about Quirell having had accepted a voluntary possession which means that when the possession ends he dies too?

In Book 4, I think Frank Bryce - the old Muggle murdered in chapter 1 - makes a better unsung hero by far than Peter Pettigrew. I think Lily Potter is the unsung hero of the first book, as her sacrifice saves Harry. Otherwise I agree with your list.

The LOTR films are *much* better for being available in an extended version - I wish all the HP films were available in extended form.

Again you should do videos like this for the fantastic beasts and the Harry Potter video games as well! :-)

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏Even though it’s not dead last, so glad to see someone who acknowledges DH2 as one of the worst movies in the franchise, let alone one of the worst made movies ever made. There is hope for our species after all after! :-)

Great content.. new sub here. If possible, make some longer content as well - I usually love to play something Harry Potter related in the background while going to sleep. Would love such content from you!

Harry Potter. Fan. Julie

149. Points. ,😊🎉❤gryffindor. Hogwarts. House

Loved how you explained everything that you said!

I’d say barty crouch would be in the forth book because he taught Harry how to stop the imperious curse

For PoA I say Fudge. He’s the one who gave Sirius the paper so he could see Wormtail with Ron

Cedric digory

I think for Chamber of Secrets I would’ve gone with Moaning Myrtle. I don’t think anyone’s as unsung as she is

Love your tik tok video’s, but these UA-cam videos are so good. I love your knowledge about the books, I listen to the books 2 times a year, right know I am at Azkaban. Love your content keep it up!