Nicholas Villeneuve
Nicholas Villeneuve
  • 35
  • 125 728
An Overdue Double Feature of The Callisto Protocol and the Dead Space Remake
I realize that this video has arrived long after Callisto and Dead Space have been figuratively dead and buried in the discourse, but better late than never!
Survival horror has had many pioneers and icons in the relatively short history of video games, and the enduring popularity of the subgenre is due in no small part to the original Dead Space from 2008. Their successes helped Visceral Games make their mark on history, and although they ultimately failed to find the blockbuster success that Electronic Arts wanted to have, their influence have long outlived the trilogy. And after a decade of radio silence, we astonishingly have a remake from a young EA studio and a spiritual successor from a reformed studio of veterans. Both games coming out at around the same time, and both of them wanting to claim the legacy of Dead Space as their own. In this video essay, I want to give a comparative review of The Callisto Protocol and the Dead Space remake, analyzing their presentations, gameplay systems, worldbuilding, and narratives, all the while comparing and contrasting them with the original Dead Space.
Introduction 0:00
The Callisto Protocol 4:01
Dead Space Remake 18:34
Conclusion 30:55
----------------------------------
Sources:
* Hafer, Leana, "Dead Space Needs 'Around Five Million' Fans To Survive, According to EA", PC Gamer, Jun. 15, 2012, www.pcgamer.com/dead-space-needs-around-five-million-fans-to-survive-according-to-ea/.
* Nutt, Christian, "A Distinct Vision: Nick Earl And Visceral Games", Gamasutra, Feb. 22, 2010,
web.archive.org/web/20100225121845/www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/4285/a_distinct_
vision_nick_earl_and_.php.
* Paget, Mat, "How Resident Evil 4 Led To Visceral Making Dead Space - Instead Of System Shock 3",
PC Gamer, Jan. 15, 2017, www.pcgamer.com/how-resident-evil-4-turned-system-shock-3-into-dead-space/.
* Peppiatt, Dom, "The Making Of... Dead Space", Play, no. 256, 2015, pp. 76-79. archive.org/details/
Play_Issue_256_2015_UK/page/n75/mode/2up.
* Schreier, Jason, "EA Shuts Down Visceral Games", Kotaku, Oct. 17, 2017, kotaku.com/ea-shuts-down-visceral-games-1819623990.
Soundtrack features tracks from The Callisto Protocol by Finishing Move Inc., and the Dead Space remake by Trevor Gureckis and Jason Graves.
All gameplay footage is original unless otherwise noted.
Переглядів: 325

Відео

Defining Immersion in the S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Trilogy
Переглядів 44 тис.2 роки тому
United24 - Funds transferred directly to the National Bank of Ukraine for military equipment, humanitarian aid, and reconstruction u24.gov.ua/ UNICEF - Funds directed towards providing safe water, healthcare, education, and protections for children www.unicef.org/emergencies/war-ukraine-pose-immediate-threat-children UNHCR - Funds directed towards providing essential items, shelter, and financi...
Cyber-Literature 210 Video Review - BioShock Infinite
Переглядів 594 роки тому
Video review project for Cyber-Literature 210 Fall 2019.
Gearing Up
Переглядів 10110 років тому
This is our last film with the Film Studies 35 group and at Jasper Place High School. Thanks for the memories! Perry Eugene Smith is a student who has yet to do the most important thing in his lifetime, but is beaten down by ridicule, discouragement, and thoughts of inadequacy. But this time, he finds the courage and the strength to do what everybody else has done a thousand times over.
Stigma
Переглядів 4910 років тому
This is our first film made with the Film Studies 35 group to create a film that conveys a dominant mood or impression. The film revolves around the most popular guy in school. A football star with a wide group of friends and a loving girlfriend. But he wrestles with coming to terms with his bisexuality and the prejudices and stigmas of our society push him towards a lethal path.
Diverge
Переглядів 3410 років тому
This is our submission to the International Baccalaureate (IB) at the Standard Level with our Film Studies 25 group. It tells the story of a young man whose mistakes in the past have brought him a life of sadness and misery. Now, he tries to track down his long-lost son to find some happiness and perhaps purpose.
Game of Chess
Переглядів 6411 років тому
Shot on location in Jasper Place High School in Edmonton, AB. Game of Chess is an experimental film in my Film Studies 25 to present a game of chess for a minute, but show only a single move. This was meant to express "Soviet Montage Theory", which is an approach to rely heavily on editing and the sequencing of shots rather than dialogue to express an idea or evoke an emotion. To better underst...
I Do VooDoo
Переглядів 11811 років тому
Shot on location in Jasper Place High School in Edmonton, AB. This is merely an experimental film we were assigned in Film Studies 25. We had to utilize annoying laughter, POV shots, a magical item, two spiral shots, and chickens in our film while presented in a recognizable genre.
The Red Tie
Переглядів 9511 років тому
Shot on location in Jasper Place High School in Edmonton, AB. This was my first independant film I did with my Film Studies 15 group. A horror-thriller movie about a series of murders at a high school and one man is trying to piece together the story to solve the mystery of the Red Tie.
The Truth About Modern Warfare 3 and the Future for Call of Duty: Ghosts
Переглядів 2911 років тому
Given that Call of Duty: Ghosts is steadily approaching and Infinity Ward is back on the scene in full force, I want to do a little introductory video to the lawsuit fiascos between Infinity Ward and Activision over the past four years and my own opinion of Modern Warfare 3 and how I feel about it so far.
The Deaths of Isaac Clarke - All Dead Space Death Scenes
Переглядів 81111 років тому
LYRICS BELOW! Isaac Clarke seems to have the worst luck. Trapped in deep space, surrounded by Necromorphs and haunted by the omnipowerful Brethren Moons. Thankfully, we have creative death scenes and unlimited continues to enjoy our mistakes. "Ready To Die" by Andrew W.K. This is your time to pay, This is your judgement day, We made a sacrifice, And now we get to take your life. We shoot withou...
Still Alive with a Calculator! - A Portal Tribute
Переглядів 37212 років тому
I present to you, the song that has inspired millions: Still Alive. Stop thinking third-dimensionally and start thinking with portals.... This video is a tribute to one of the greatest video game songs ever made, written by Jonathan Coulton, sung by Ellen Mclain, survived by gamers like us.
Stop Internet Censorship: A Brief History of PIPA and SOPA
Переглядів 13112 років тому
As time on Earth went on, land was soon owned and even oceans were taken. There were no longer free ranges owned by no one, but the trees and the rocks. Alas, this does not exist anymore, but new technologies and innovations paved way for a new, open-range world we know today as the internet. By the end of the twentieth century, the internet had become a universal hub for games, movies, videos,...
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call Of Duty Tribute / Part Four
Переглядів 15312 років тому
"History is written by the victor." - General Shepherd When Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare released, it was regarded as one of the best games of the year and revolutionized not only the FPS genre, but popular culture itself. It has captured the imaginations of millions worldwide, expanded the fanbase of video games, and integrated a very, very compelling storyline that has spawned two sequels t...
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call Of Duty Tribute / Part Three / Segment Two
Переглядів 30912 років тому
"History is written by the victor." - General Shepherd When Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare released, it was regarded as one of the best games of the year and revolutionized not only the FPS genre, but popular culture itself. It has captured the imaginations of millions worldwide, expanded the fanbase of video games, and integrated a very, very compelling storyline that has spawned two sequels t...
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call Of Duty Tribute / Part Three / Segment One
Переглядів 27812 років тому
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call Of Duty Tribute / Part Three / Segment One
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call of Duty Tribute / Part Two / Segment One
Переглядів 53412 років тому
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call of Duty Tribute / Part Two / Segment One
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call of Duty Tribute / Part Two / Segment Two
Переглядів 40412 років тому
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call of Duty Tribute / Part Two / Segment Two
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call of Duty Tribute / Part One
Переглядів 4,7 тис.13 років тому
The Modern Warfare Storyline - A Call of Duty Tribute / Part One
Love Is Blind, But Aliens Have Vision - A FAVA Production
Переглядів 42613 років тому
Love Is Blind, But Aliens Have Vision - A FAVA Production
LEGO Wars: Beasts Reborn / Teaser
Переглядів 7413 років тому
LEGO Wars: Beasts Reborn / Teaser
Jurassic Park: The Game - New Nocturnal Dinosaur
Переглядів 17 тис.13 років тому
Jurassic Park: The Game - New Nocturnal Dinosaur
The Artifact / Trailer
Переглядів 10113 років тому
The Artifact / Trailer
Peter's Toys: Showoff
Переглядів 9014 років тому
Peter's Toys: Showoff
Peter's Toys: Race Day
Переглядів 46214 років тому
Peter's Toys: Race Day
The Armored Crusader / Trailer
Переглядів 11314 років тому
The Armored Crusader / Trailer
ROBLOX Attack of the Dogs
Переглядів 29214 років тому
ROBLOX Attack of the Dogs
EPIC Ant Win [UPDATED]
Переглядів 4214 років тому
EPIC Ant Win [UPDATED]
How to Fold a Burrito
Переглядів 98614 років тому
How to Fold a Burrito
BIONICLE Battles: Axonn vs. Thok
Переглядів 45 тис.14 років тому
BIONICLE Battles: Axonn vs. Thok

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @Aanderan
    @Aanderan 6 днів тому

    "first major block buster title" Cossacks exists haha

  • @johnny1599
    @johnny1599 10 днів тому

    a few years late, but PLEASE play the trilogy vanilla if you can. Just ZRP installed. The slavic jank is worth it.

  • @xavierdecharpe3288
    @xavierdecharpe3288 22 дні тому

    Most of my prefered game from remedy or eastern europe. CDproject red and GSC made momerable games

  • @BH-vh3iu
    @BH-vh3iu Місяць тому

    The Stalker community became insufferable with all the pro-NATO and pro-US ass-kissing. Spelling it "Chornobyl" is as cringe as using neutral pronouns. Ukrainians who weren't slaughtered in battle already at this point are the whiny types going around virtue signaling through their pc spelling.

  • @afgh1408
    @afgh1408 2 місяці тому

    TV brained video

  • @Bartolomeo.93
    @Bartolomeo.93 3 місяці тому

    When you discovered and enjoyed STALKER, you were affected a little bit with Slavic soul, that's why this game is so immersive....

  • @thewall5540
    @thewall5540 3 місяці тому

    I like how you called it eurojank while we in europe call it slavjank😁 It is usually games from the slavic countries that have this kind of jank, and i love it.

  • @real_mitya
    @real_mitya 3 місяці тому

    Thank you so much for taking such an in-depth look into the historical context behind the game, it is such a crucial part of its identity that is so often overlooked. As someone with a personal connection with the tragedy, I've wondered for years whether using Chornobyl as a setting was a morally correct decision from the developers. However, at its core, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. is a game about people surviving among the ruins of an empire, facing an uncertain future, and forging their own identity in the process. The game is by no means some masterful sociopolitical reflection, but it is so good at capturing the air of uncertainty that defined life in Ukraine in the 90s and 00s. And Chornobyl is the perfect symbol for the downfall of the USSR and the traumatic legacy it left Ukraine with: just like the nuclear particles left by the disaster, the lasting effects of repression and colonialism will take many generations to truly decay.

  • @Lgnzzz
    @Lgnzzz 3 місяці тому

    How this video has only 40k completely baffles me

  • @KernKlassman
    @KernKlassman 4 місяці тому

    Didn't expect so much support and depth, warms my Ukrainian heart ❤

  • @ryszakowy
    @ryszakowy 4 місяці тому

    you are in underground complex emergency light still works and spins seueaking water somwhere drips and echo goes through entire complex something heavy fell/stepped on a catwalk THAT'S immersion and there's not a single mutant there if stalker 2 is made for wide audience that will forget about it in a year then it will be trash the jank has become a core experience of the zone stalker 2 must be exactly like previous trilogy

  • @randalthor6872
    @randalthor6872 4 місяці тому

    nice vid bro! sad that Stalker 2 is still not out :( oh well, replaying the trilogy right now! sad about the war, too. Even worse when there was a peace deal on the table months and months ago but the western elites scuttled it to keep the conflict going.

  • @la912
    @la912 6 місяців тому

    Brilliant video!

  • @inxendere
    @inxendere 7 місяців тому

    You need to make more videos dude. You got talent and you're already far better than most. Just make sure to decrease the bg music volume next time :)

  • @InVacuo
    @InVacuo 7 місяців тому

    Great video!

  • @semird615
    @semird615 8 місяців тому

    Playing the original STALKER at 11 years old was the most emersive, confusing and terrifying gaming experience of my life. While all my friends were stuck on COD 4 Multiplayer I was grinding it out in the Chernobyl exclusion zone not knowing what I was doing and if all this weird stuff is actually happening in that place. It took me more than a year to beat and the feeling of the first playthrough will never be replicated. Such a unique series. I'm so excited for the sequel yet I'm dreading it at the same time. No game could really scratch that ich for me, not even Metro.

  • @KROVA_715
    @KROVA_715 9 місяців тому

    Propaganda covered as a stalkwr video i see

  • @aaronsmith4940
    @aaronsmith4940 9 місяців тому

    It wasn't mysterious he embezzled a ton of money and bailed.

  • @Alislamor
    @Alislamor 11 місяців тому

    Дякую за це відео і за підтримку України

  • @og_ice_freezer
    @og_ice_freezer Рік тому

    Hmm... Good quality content and so few views/likes? Strange, very strange

  • @jcd6618
    @jcd6618 Рік тому

    Great video, thanks

  • @ss0n0medaren0me
    @ss0n0medaren0me Рік тому

    The video would have turned out quite well if not for the political and pseudo-historical part. The author does not understand what he imposes on others, voicing the template theses of Western propaganda, presenting incomplete information from the wrong angle. I don't blame him for this, because in the so-called "democratic countries" the Western machine of imposing anti-Sovietism, anti-communism and Russophobia copes quite well. But nevertheless, it would be possible to make a video without this part, which is superfluous. I say this being a ukrainian (Slavic, Russian)

  • @Skikopl
    @Skikopl Рік тому

    You are infinitely underrated my man

  • @gomezwu
    @gomezwu Рік тому

    Poignant analysis. After this exposé, I am curious about playing it.

  • @Nicholas.Villeneuve
    @Nicholas.Villeneuve Рік тому

    CORRECTIONS: 23:13 Audio got cut off here, what I meant to say is "When it comes to the combat..." 25:32 Another abrupt cutoff in the music that lacked a smooth transition.

  • @Weighty68
    @Weighty68 Рік тому

    amazing video! glad i finally got around to watching it and here’s to more space horror to come 🎉

  • @asdtgh8895
    @asdtgh8895 Рік тому

    31:32 THIS. This is what so many fans just downright ignored or not realised how difficult it is to come up with a new game without getting called a clone or a rip-off, maybe even taken down for copyrighting. While also finding some level of familiarity that resembles the game they wanted to come back. Whereas Motive has a whole IP and homework/research given to them thanks to the very work done by the original team. And some of these people are the same fans who had completely forgotten the story and setting of Dead Space 2 and how Isaac is picked up by EarthGov. Thinking that the secret ending is the "canonical" ending when Isaac is never suppose to be on the side of the Necromorphs at all, only traumatised and mentally tortured by the ghost of Nicole. Thank you for bringing this unfair fact and the bias Dead Space Remake fans have.

  • @FurryPig
    @FurryPig Рік тому

    Great job, subscribed !

  • @griffithbae
    @griffithbae Рік тому

    Another great vid Nic 👌👌, getting better with each one

  • @MichalCieply44
    @MichalCieply44 2 роки тому

    Very nice video and story

  • @The_Cosmic_Navigator
    @The_Cosmic_Navigator 2 роки тому

    "I was ten years old when I first played CoD 4" Omg I feel old. When I was 10 I was begging my mom to order the full release of Doom and a fuckin SoundBlaster lol.

  • @vdagr8795
    @vdagr8795 2 роки тому

    makes me laugh every time westoids talk about things they dont understand like theyre experts. stay off politics and stick to your silly videogame reviews

  • @mikem.s.1183
    @mikem.s.1183 2 роки тому

    Nicholas, Be certain that you have created a very good essay and video. Good directing, great commentary, impacting use of the soundtrack. Yet another jewel by the STALKER fan community. Well done. Well done.

  • @stefan6941
    @stefan6941 2 роки тому

    I was playing STALKER in my dark room, and my cousin was sitting next to me. I was going through some basement that was pitch black, exept for my flashlight. It was quiet, and we thought we heard a snork running around in the dark. I was ill-prepared, with a shitty AK-74U and barely any armor, I walked slowly towards the sound, crouching down as I went... The silence was suddenly broken when my little brother (7 yr) had gone into the room through the open door and sneaked up behind us to ask "WhaT aRe yoU plAYing?!" Let me tell you that my soul left my body and I suddenly started shooting everywhere, screaming in unison with my cousin and not seeing where the fuck I was going anymore... Shit was crazy

  • @spellweavergeneziso
    @spellweavergeneziso 2 роки тому

    I remember when I was 11 years old and Shadow of Chernobyl came out. It was a love at first sight, I never played a game like this before. The head bob and weapon sway felt so real and immersive. Even shooting a 12 gauge gave a pleasurable feedback. I accidentally shot someone in the Sid's village and the whole camp went hostile. I barely put half of them down and got killed. At this very moment, I realized, this game is no walk in the park. Unlike most games, Stalker does not hold you by the hand throughout the whole game. It feels like you've been thrown into the lake not knowing to swim. When I got to the first underground level in Research Institute and encountered a Controller for the first time, I shit my pants and uninstalled the game. I thought I am done with it for good. Again, I was 11yo. Didn't I know they'd release a sequel year later, Clear Sky which made me give it another chance. I finished the first game and then the sequel and I loved every bit of it. Call of Pripyat was just a cherry on top. Modding community and a loyal player base has done wonders for this franchise and there has not been a single years since 2007 in which I did not play Stalker. I can without a doubt say that Stalker is the best game ever made... for the right audience. Nothing ever beats it. Anomaly and its branches are total pinnacle. Can't wait what modding community will do with an upcoming Heart of Chornobyl.

  • @animalmother9143
    @animalmother9143 2 роки тому

    What a great video man.

  • @Artem-so2ni
    @Artem-so2ni 2 роки тому

    Thank you for your support. I am staying in Kiev and playing now in Stalker, if have electricity

  • @raskolnikovsghost2701
    @raskolnikovsghost2701 2 роки тому

    Anomaly is the most fun I've ever had in a single player shooter.

  • @enriquecabrera2137
    @enriquecabrera2137 2 роки тому

    Hilarious that everyone is all about Ukraine this, Ukraine that without realizing that Russia and Ukraine have been at war for almost 2 decades and the Ukraine has violated the cease fire agreements like 2 times at least lol Sure shows how people who play video games all day and get all their info from pop culture are retarded as fuck.

  • @rkuper95
    @rkuper95 2 роки тому

    Ukrainian Stalker’s here!🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦💪🏻

  • @Trash_prince
    @Trash_prince 2 роки тому

    Played it for the first time in 2010 Been hooked ever since I'm glad people are finally starting to notice this game

  • @1CE.
    @1CE. 2 роки тому

    5:10 🙄 bye

  • @Jklopoppcorn
    @Jklopoppcorn 2 роки тому

    the music is a bit too loud in this video

  • @rifleshooterchannel208
    @rifleshooterchannel208 2 роки тому

    Wish I could've finished this video but you totally lost me around 5:15 when you go on your little BS rant about Ukraine. Thumbs down.

    • @Frille512
      @Frille512 2 роки тому

      Nobody is immune to propaganda And it's one hell of a drug

  • @flame7573
    @flame7573 2 роки тому

    Came for the analysis, stayed for the history lesson. Amazing work!

  • @kalebs6201
    @kalebs6201 2 роки тому

    A friend of mine just got me into the stalker series and its some of the best ive played

  • @Tobinzol
    @Tobinzol 2 роки тому

    O-Consuisness have heard you.

  • @Dmitrisnikioff
    @Dmitrisnikioff 2 роки тому

    Your conclusions on The Fall are incorrect.

  • @curtisnewton895
    @curtisnewton895 2 роки тому

    immersion ? S.T.A.L.K.E.R. is everything but immersive unless you mean immersive into boredom and empty openworld

  • @Usual_User
    @Usual_User 2 роки тому

    As a Ukrainian, thank you, and as fan of Stalker - thank you, im glad you didn't "forgot" about bugs, even if in this kind of videos i always feel like the reviewer get the most bugged version while i get last, you told about them fairly (and maybe even somewhat underestimated them). Anyway, again i want to say thank you, and also sorry for my bad English.