Nickkyboy99
Nickkyboy99
  • 86
  • 818 427
Panther Tank Comparison - War Thunder vs IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew
Panther D Comparison - War Thunder vs. IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew - Clash at Prokhorovka. Which is more realistic?
Both War Thunder and IL2 Great Battles have done an incredible job bringing the Panther tank back to life! Each game captures the essence of this legend in its own way, with amazing attention to detail, sound design, and gameplay mechanics.
In this video, we're going to compare how these two games recreate the Panther D variant, focusing on 3D models, engine sounds, suspension and track physics, and the main cannon!
~~Let me know in the comments which game nails the Panther tank best! And don't forget to like, subscribe, and hit the notification bell 🔔~~
Song used in video: "Behind the Enemy Lines" - War Thunder Soundtrack
Subscribe -- www.youtube.com/@nickkyboy99
Join my Discord server -- discord.gg/dauf2fGq48
#il2sturmovik #warthunder #panther
0:00 Intro
0:13 3D Model
0:48 Details Comparison
2:17 Engine Sound
4:22 Suspension & Track Physics
5:32 Main Cannon Sound
6:56 Coaxial Gun Sound
8:31 Smoke Grenade Sounds & Effects
Переглядів: 23 239

Відео

Panzer 4 Comparison - War Thunder vs IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew
Переглядів 4,8 тис.14 днів тому
Panzer IV Ausf.G Comparison - War Thunder vs. IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew - Clash at Prokhorovka. Which is more realistic? In this video, we’ll compare the models, physics, and audio to see which one comes out on top! If you enjoyed this video, please like and subscribe for more content! Song used in video: "Behind the Enemy Lines" - War Thunder Soundtrack Subscribe www.youtube.com/@nickkyboy99 J...
M4A2 Sherman Comparison - War Thunder vs IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew
Переглядів 8 тис.21 день тому
M4A2 Sherman Comparison - War Thunder vs. IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew - Clash at Prokhorovka. Which is more realistic? In this video, we’ll compare the models, physics, and audio to see which one comes out on top! FYI, the Sherman in IL-2 Tank Crew is a lend-lease Sherman, which is why it has a Soviet crew. Also, the M4A2 in War Thunder is based on the late-production Sherman, while the one in IL...
Tiger Tank Comparison - War Thunder vs IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew
Переглядів 132 тис.Місяць тому
Tiger 1 Comparison - War Thunder vs. IL-2 Sturmovik: Tank Crew - Clash at Prokhorovka. Which is more realistic? Both games feature a beautifully designed Tiger tank, complete with intricate details and impressive sound effects. In this video, we’ll compare their models, physics, and audio to see which one comes out on top! If you enjoyed this video, please like and subscribe for more content! S...
Ta 152 H-1 vs P-47D High Altitude Dogfight | IL-2 Great Battles
Переглядів 5 тис.Місяць тому
The German Ta 152 faces off against the American P-47 Thunderbolt at nearly 10 km altitude! The Ta 152 is an absolute beast at extremely high altitudes. I felt completely in control throughout the entire dogfight. Seconds into the fight, I instantly noticed that the P-47 couldn’t keep up, even though it’s a capable high-altitude fighter in its own right. The 152 is a joy to fly! She handles ext...
Realistic Shootdowns & Crashes Part 4 | IL-2 Sturmovik
Переглядів 6 тис.5 місяців тому
IL-2 Realistic Shootdowns & Crashes PART 3 Another compilation of the most realistic and satisfying crashes in IL-2 Sturmovik: Great Battles! Subscribe www.youtube.com/@nickkyboy99 Join my Discord server discord.gg/dauf2fGq48 If you enjoyed this compilation, be sure to like and subscribe! Bf 109: (0:00) Ar234: (0:40) P-47: (1:59) CG-4A Glider: (3:12) Ta 152: (4:09) Spitfire: (5:31) P-40: (6:29)...
Realistic Shootdown Compilation Part 3 | IL-2 Sturmovik
Переглядів 1,5 тис.5 місяців тому
IL-2 Realistic Shootdowns PART 2 Here's another IL2 shootdown compilation! Join my discord server: discord.gg/dauf2fGq48 Follow me on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@nickkyboy99 I hope you enjoy Don't forget to like and subscribe!
Ta 152 H-1 - Startup & Takeoff | IL-2 Sturmovik GB
Переглядів 6 тис.5 місяців тому
Update 5.204 was released today, introducing the Ta 152 H-1. As expected, it flies superbly well at high altitude, feels light and fast, and has amazing maneuverability! Be sure to check it out: il2sturmovik.com/store/collector-planes/ If you enjoyed the video, don't forget to like and subscribe! Join my discord server: discord.gg/dauf2fGq48 Follow me on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@nickkyboy99 Modi...
SU-122 Indirect Fire | IL-2 Tank Crew Multiplayer
Переглядів 6 тис.5 місяців тому
The real way to play the SU-122 This was my first time using the SU-122 as indirect artillery in multiplayer, and it was a success! Honestly, it's really difficult to do it on your own, especially without someone telling you where your shots land. With no kill indicator, I had no idea how close or far my shots were from hitting something, lol. If you enjoyed the video, don't forget to like and ...
Realistic Shootdowns & Crashes Part 2 | IL-2 Sturmovik
Переглядів 8 тис.5 місяців тому
Realistic Shootdowns & Crashes Part 2 | IL-2 Sturmovik
Intercepting Japanese Bombers! | IL-2 Sturmovik
Переглядів 1,9 тис.6 місяців тому
Intercepting Japanese Bombers! | IL-2 Sturmovik
Destroying a Tiger 3.6km away | IL-2 Sturmovik
Переглядів 1,9 тис.6 місяців тому
Destroying a Tiger 3.6km away | IL-2 Sturmovik
Realistic Shootdown Compilation | IL-2 Sturmovik
Переглядів 3 тис.6 місяців тому
Realistic Shootdown Compilation | IL-2 Sturmovik
Realistic Shootdowns & Crashes | IL-2 Sturmovik
Переглядів 2,4 тис.7 місяців тому
Realistic Shootdowns & Crashes | IL-2 Sturmovik
Outplayed by a bf109
Переглядів 9257 місяців тому
Outplayed by a bf109
P-51B Mustang Takes on TWO German Bf 109s
Переглядів 7649 місяців тому
P-51B Mustang Takes on TWO German Bf 109s
CG-4A Glider - Startup, Takeoff & Landing | IL-2 Sturmovik GB
Переглядів 13 тис.11 місяців тому
CG-4A Glider - Startup, Takeoff & Landing | IL-2 Sturmovik GB
Lisunov Li-2 - Startup & Takeoff | IL-2 Sturmovik GB
Переглядів 2,3 тис.Рік тому
Lisunov Li-2 - Startup & Takeoff | IL-2 Sturmovik GB
Massive Dogfight Over the Pacific | IL-2: GB
Переглядів 3,5 тис.Рік тому
Massive Dogfight Over the Pacific | IL-2: GB
100 AA Guns vs German Ar234 Jet Bomber
Переглядів 708Рік тому
100 AA Guns vs German Ar234 Jet Bomber
Bf 109 K-4 vs P-47D-28 | IL-2 Great Battles
Переглядів 3,7 тис.Рік тому
Bf 109 K-4 vs P-47D-28 | IL-2 Great Battles
Protecting Rommel's Panzers | IL-2 Sturmovik: Great Battles
Переглядів 2,3 тис.Рік тому
Protecting Rommel's Panzers | IL-2 Sturmovik: Great Battles
P-47D Train Station Attack | IL-2 Sturmovik: Battle of Normandy
Переглядів 988Рік тому
P-47D Train Station Attack | IL-2 Sturmovik: Battle of Normandy
C-47s Intercepted by an Me-410 | IL-2 Great Battles
Переглядів 1,1 тис.Рік тому
C-47s Intercepted by an Me-410 | IL-2 Great Battles
Battle of Britain | Intercepting Bomber Formation | IL-2: GB
Переглядів 23 тис.Рік тому
Battle of Britain | Intercepting Bomber Formation | IL-2: GB
StuG III Ausf.G - Showcase | IL-2 Sturmovik GB
Переглядів 7 тис.2 роки тому
StuG III Ausf.G - Showcase | IL-2 Sturmovik GB
P-38 Lightning vs Ki-61 | IL-2 Great Battles
Переглядів 22 тис.2 роки тому
P-38 Lightning vs Ki-61 | IL-2 Great Battles
V-1 Flying Bomb Test | IL-2 Battle of Normandy
Переглядів 108 тис.2 роки тому
V-1 Flying Bomb Test | IL-2 Battle of Normandy
Carpet Bombing Stalingrad - 1942
Переглядів 9 тис.2 роки тому
Carpet Bombing Stalingrad - 1942
Fw 190 D-9 vs P-51D | IL-2 Great Battles
Переглядів 50 тис.2 роки тому
Fw 190 D-9 vs P-51D | IL-2 Great Battles

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @DarkDweller-13
    @DarkDweller-13 День тому

    In my opinion, I prefer war thunder. But IL-2 it's really great tho, and way more customizable

  • @Brooksie997
    @Brooksie997 День тому

    If ur looking for accuracy and detail. Go to IL-2. If ur looking for 4K graphics and ease of use, go to WT.

  • @danteogilery7948
    @danteogilery7948 День тому

    Il-2 Better for me

  • @Nova-ro5by
    @Nova-ro5by 2 дні тому

    WT arcadifies suspension so much for a lot of vehicles, though I can't fault Gaijin too much in this case as both for gameplay reasons and historical accuracy it would be very difficult getting such niche details correctly for hundreds of vehicles. IL-2 wins the comparison for me

  • @Ultramarinedude
    @Ultramarinedude 2 дні тому

    I had a great grandfather fight from inside a Panzer MkIV in the Russian Front. Let's just say, my father never met him...

  • @isaiahfistler1753
    @isaiahfistler1753 2 дні тому

    You should compair the games to call to arms

  • @icy5619
    @icy5619 3 дні тому

    Modelled interiors got me sold

  • @FRforcing
    @FRforcing 3 дні тому

    Dear people, Il2 is a flying sim not a tank game, now let that sink in 😊

  • @denissokolov387
    @denissokolov387 3 дні тому

    WoT - Acade! WT - Sim! WT - Arcade! Il2 - Sim!

  • @vladgabigov4336
    @vladgabigov4336 3 дні тому

    Should i buy this game ?

  • @Mechanized85
    @Mechanized85 3 дні тому

    Shitthunder

  • @jerryreyes7752
    @jerryreyes7752 3 дні тому

    War thunder actually did a full scan of the real tiger from a museum

  • @flyiny_sqiurrel
    @flyiny_sqiurrel 3 дні тому

    think of war thunder was like il 2 what a game it would be love love love

  • @Phoenix_6211
    @Phoenix_6211 4 дні тому

    War thunder = Russian bias

  • @vladgabigov4336
    @vladgabigov4336 4 дні тому

    is the game worth it ? i am wondering if i should buy it

  • @Polon_210
    @Polon_210 4 дні тому

    WT is arcade, ił-2 is, a Simulator

  • @4strokenicolaus
    @4strokenicolaus 4 дні тому

    IL2 is quite the best tank simulator so far. I spent 30 or 40 hours playing it. But what was making me very unhappy at the end, are this kind of "20 year old" environment graphics and bad off road simulation (mud is not existing). It feels like driving around with a great tank in battlefield 1942......

  • @itzdarke6131
    @itzdarke6131 4 дні тому

    War thunder is a great reallistic game, IL-2 is a great simulator, they’re different but both are great in their category

  • @stfuiknowbetter4474
    @stfuiknowbetter4474 4 дні тому

    The models in WT is more realistic Il 2 look like a toy model or the tank just came out of the production line and never seen action ,wt has great attention to details Some rust, faded paint, scuffs and dents I love ear thunder

    • @nickkyboy99
      @nickkyboy99 4 дні тому

      The Panther in IL-2 also has its fair share of paint peeling off and dirt, giving it a more realistic appearance, considering that tanks spent more time driving than actually engaging in battle. In my opinion, it’s too excessive in War Thunder. The dents, especially on the sideskirts and frontal guards, make it look as if it was ripped off a destroyed tank and reused.

    • @thecsr2944
      @thecsr2944 4 дні тому

      @@stfuiknowbetter4474 Not necessarily. IL2 has hundreds of weathered community skins to download on its body and tracks, and very importantly, historical skins, historically detailed in proportions and best modeled tanks and damage physics and model, not only fictional or "for fun" as in WT. Those do look like toys.

    • @Darkclaw86
      @Darkclaw86 3 дні тому

      that's bullshit, I can only speak for the German Army, but the germans maintained there tanks properly, even between their tasks/missionen on in the frontline. No german tank looked that worn as in War Thunder.

  • @連戰鬥工兵
    @連戰鬥工兵 4 дні тому

    bro!i very love you video!😍

  • @agreeable4334
    @agreeable4334 4 дні тому

    But does il-2 have 2000 vehicles? something to keep in mind

    • @nickkyboy99
      @nickkyboy99 4 дні тому

      This video compares the Panther model between both games, nothing more. It is not a "which game is better" video

    • @agreeable4334
      @agreeable4334 4 дні тому

      @nickkyboy99 Yes i know but when you have that many vehicles its hard to make them all super high quality so its good to keep in mind like i said

  • @merino6260
    @merino6260 5 днів тому

    Rat kids game vs simulator

  • @thecsr2944
    @thecsr2944 5 днів тому

    Only see the riding physics… IL2 all the way.

  • @OsasQMP
    @OsasQMP 5 днів тому

    how to play ıl2?

  • @lilyfurley9833
    @lilyfurley9833 6 днів тому

    is this the Clash at Prokhorovka DLC

  • @renefarsky
    @renefarsky 7 днів тому

    WT: FINALLY, WORTHLY OPPONENT, OUR BATTLE WILL BE LEGENDARY! i am just kidding, but everyone just compares wot and wt, but it is different mechanics, wt is simulator, just like IL-2... so finally a good comparison of games focust at something similar, tanks, planes, realism

  • @democracy_enjoyer
    @democracy_enjoyer 7 днів тому

    war thunder for good art direction il2 for good sound design

  • @VOIDOFTOXIC
    @VOIDOFTOXIC 8 днів тому

    War thunder looks realistic Il-2 feels realistic

  • @OutrunRewind
    @OutrunRewind 8 днів тому

    the only thing IL-2 missed is track noise (notice how WT's tracks make a lot of creaking noises when the tank is moving) and the MG sound, but otherwise it holds up really well and is even better in many aspects

  • @Artoorg
    @Artoorg 8 днів тому

    In tank details, I prefer war thunder, but the texture of IL-2 is much better

    • @zeller2030
      @zeller2030 8 днів тому

      What do you prefer for the tank details in WT ?? lol

  • @_ChiLan_A
    @_ChiLan_A 8 днів тому

    Il2 panther mg sound like a skitle bic disnep toilet

  • @alexnem18
    @alexnem18 8 днів тому

    I would also like you to make a video about "Tiger 2". Thanks for the interesting video))

  • @TheHDReleaser
    @TheHDReleaser 8 днів тому

    problem with WT is how crappy BR is. like maus facing modern tanks etc.. they do everything they can, to make you pay for the grind

    • @BlackWolf9988
      @BlackWolf9988 8 днів тому

      I mean its balance. There is a reason some vics are so high or low in BR. Alternatively try playing ground sim.

    • @zeller2030
      @zeller2030 8 днів тому

      @@BlackWolf9988 Ground sim still has all the unrealistic teams and brs, it's no different other than locking you in zoom mode and removing name tags

    • @TransAmDrifter
      @TransAmDrifter 5 днів тому

      After reaching BR 5.3, grinding further has no sense.

    • @nonnodacciaio704
      @nonnodacciaio704 4 дні тому

      You do know that making tanks play against their contemporaries would be stupid right?

  • @janbrzeszczykiewicz6939
    @janbrzeszczykiewicz6939 9 днів тому

    Can't wait to see your TC2 comparison vids ;)

  • @YTdeletedmyhackedAccount
    @YTdeletedmyhackedAccount 9 днів тому

    War Thunder dont have love for Tanks look at their Models looks like the Tanks are sitting in dirt for 30 years even at 100% Cammo

    • @Darkclaw86
      @Darkclaw86 3 дні тому

      T(h)ank you, finally somebody who knows, what he talk about. I hate those "wAr ThUnDEr loOkEd mORe REaliSTic bECaUSe iT'S WAr tImE" comments. Because when a tank is on the frontline, that doesn't mean, that they didn't maintained or repair their vehicles between their missions and from the german army I know, the did it properly. No german tank looked that worn as in War Thunder.

  • @Lenin_1919
    @Lenin_1919 9 днів тому

    IL-2 really needs to improve the mg sound from the outside. But besides that they win in every other category

  • @YTdeletedmyhackedAccount
    @YTdeletedmyhackedAccount 9 днів тому

    IL 2 is way ahead of Warthunder

  • @ĜØÔÑxĤØÜŠĚ
    @ĜØÔÑxĤØÜŠĚ 9 днів тому

    I wish war thunders vehicles were up to this detail because il-2 looks amazing side by side

  • @xWizardxRF
    @xWizardxRF 9 днів тому

    Horn feature is crazy

  • @Yarik_1866
    @Yarik_1866 10 днів тому

    Вартандер который мы потеряли

  • @U_Jelly
    @U_Jelly 10 днів тому

    il2 reminds me of classic war thunder the tanks felt more real back then

  • @zeller2030
    @zeller2030 10 днів тому

    Love the video! 0:39 and can someone tell me what that big thing is sitting in the middle in IL2?

    • @rolandhunter
      @rolandhunter 8 днів тому

      Additional Air intake for engine and/or antenna holder for commander panther.

    • @zeller2030
      @zeller2030 8 днів тому

      @@rolandhunter Thanks!

    • @rolandhunter
      @rolandhunter 8 днів тому

      @@zeller2030 You're welcome!

  • @gamertardguardian1299
    @gamertardguardian1299 10 днів тому

    Idk to me even with point tracking and a big screen the sims don’t feel super immersive to me. Maybe its my chair and setup

  • @hexpert6043
    @hexpert6043 10 днів тому

    Incredible as always

  • @manfredvonrichthofen1660
    @manfredvonrichthofen1660 10 днів тому

    0:42 Why is angle of the track so high in the right compared to the left?

    • @SturmPanzer43Brummbar
      @SturmPanzer43Brummbar 10 днів тому

      Different track tension I guess

    • @zeller2030
      @zeller2030 10 днів тому

      @@SturmPanzer43Brummbar The idler wheel (rear wheel) is sitting more behind the other wheel in IL2. For WT, it's more away from it with the whole wheel exposed. I'm pretty sure that's the early design version in IL2 while WT has the late panther d design (for tracks/wheels)

  • @Valery_Gerasimov
    @Valery_Gerasimov 10 днів тому

    in my opinion, the exterior for il2's panther looks better than war thunders

    • @xWizardxRF
      @xWizardxRF 10 днів тому

      Yes, it's newer

    • @everyonehastalent4309
      @everyonehastalent4309 10 днів тому

      @@xWizardxRF But IL2 is locked in first person, you like never see your exterior when playing

    • @slightlyskilledsfm5904
      @slightlyskilledsfm5904 7 днів тому

      @@everyonehastalent4309 What, no? You have full control in third person view??

    • @hasnotintel
      @hasnotintel 5 днів тому

      I'm war thunder it's more of like, the tank is what you found or been I'm the war, In il2 it's just out of the factory or something

    • @anshuldwivedi1919
      @anshuldwivedi1919 5 днів тому

      True but itnseems 'factory fresh'

  • @Viper-dk2xe
    @Viper-dk2xe 10 днів тому

    What's the point of removing sideskirts? Was that a thing?

    • @nickkyboy99
      @nickkyboy99 10 днів тому

      It was probably taken off while in very muddy or snowy terrain

    • @soap_off
      @soap_off 10 днів тому

      or not enough sideskirt to distribute to every tanker due to shortages ? idk i'm just asking

    • @Dazgir47
      @Dazgir47 10 днів тому

      It was not standart for panthers they addes those later becouse without side skirts at rifles could penetrate the side

    • @BlackWolf9988
      @BlackWolf9988 8 днів тому

      Side skirts were a later addition to the panther because soviet anti tank rifles kept penetrating the sides of the tank.

  • @CXar-25
    @CXar-25 10 днів тому

    Hey you should check out on enlisted It has the engine and models of wt but you can also play as infantry and when using tanks you can only use the vehicle periscopes and hatches to look around also the gunsigth reticle is histotic It doesn't really have modeled interiors but its better than war thunder

  • @CXar-25
    @CXar-25 10 днів тому

    Please make the next one with a soviet tnak like the kv1 or the t34

    • @nickkyboy99
      @nickkyboy99 10 днів тому

      Yeah, I'll probably do the T-34 next. But don't worry, I'll eventually get through all the tanks!

  • @leonardorodrigues827
    @leonardorodrigues827 10 днів тому

    Very good indeed, I like Il-2 mainly for showing the inside of the tanks, in the next video it could be Ferdinand or Stug iii please