Testing in Nutshell
Testing in Nutshell
  • 156
  • 1 271 387
Tutorial #1 | Components in Jira | How to Create Components | Benefits of Components in Jira
This video tutorial series is about "Atlassian JIRA Software". This series will help learner's to understand advance options of Jira Software to be used in there day to day work.
In this video we have covered
Jira Tutorials,
Components in Jira,
Learn More about Testing
ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions
Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam.com/channels/hsU7ZAMRLPkMTpkGgya1fQ.html
Blogger - testinginnutshell15.blogspot.com/
Follow me at
Facebook - rajtheburningdesire
LinkedIn - www.linkedin.com/in/neeraj-kumar-singh-0643998/
Quora - www.quora.com/profile/Neeraj-Kumar-Singh-90
Twitter - @NutshellTesting
#jira #jirasoftware #jiratutorials #testinginnutshell
Переглядів: 901

Відео

Tutorial #21 | Document Generator in Xray | Generating Reports in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 11 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Test Reports in Xray, Document Generator in Xray, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam.com/users/TechnicalVocabulary Bl...
Tutorial #20 | Xray Dashboard | Testing Dashboard in Xray | Jira Dashboard for Testing Progress
Переглядів 14 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Xray Reports, Testing Dashboard in Jira, Xray Dashboards in Jira, Testing Status Dashboard, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary...
Tutorial #19 | Test Coverage Report | Test Plan Metrics | Traceability Report in Xray | Xray Reports
Переглядів 9 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Test Coverage Report, Test Plan Metrics Report, Traceability Report in Xray, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam.com/u...
Tutorial #18 | Test Plan List, Test Runs List, Tests List, Test Set List in Xray | Xray Reports
Переглядів 8 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Xray Reports, Test Plan List, Test Set List, Tests List, Test Runs List, Test Executions List, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabul...
Tutorial #17 | How to Import Test case to Xray | Xray Test Case Importer | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 16 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Import Tests from CSV, Importing Test Cases to Xray, Test Case Importer in Xray, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam.c...
Tutorial #16 | Custom Fields in Xray | User Defined Fields for Test Cases in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 6 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered User Defined Fields in Xray, Custom Fields in Xray, Adding a Field in Test Cases, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam....
Tutorial #15 | Test Environment in Xray | Using Environment for Coverage | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 7 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Xray Test Environment, Adding Test Environment, Using Test Environment, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam.com/users/...
Tutorial #14 | Defect Mapping in Xray | Defect Coverage in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 10 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Xray Defect Management, Defect Mapping in Xray, Defect Coverage in Xray, Linking defects with story, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical V...
Tutorial #13 | Test Coverage in Xray | Requirement Coverage in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 13 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Test Coverage in Jira, Requirement Coverage in Jira, Measuring Coverage in Jira, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam.c...
Tutorial #12 | Test Repository in Xray | Managing Tests in Xray | Test Management | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 13 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Xray Test Management, Test Management in Xray, Test Repository in Xray, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabulary - ua-cam.com/users/...
Tutorial #11 | Executing a Parametrized Test | Parameters in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 10 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Xray Test Management, Test Management in Xray, Parameters in Xray, Executing Parametrized Test, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical Vocabu...
Tutorial #10 | Test Parameters in Xray | Parameterizing a Test | Data Driven Testing | Xray Tutorial
Переглядів 15 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Test Parameters in Xray, Parametrizing a Test, Creating a Test Parameter, Using Parameters in a Test, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users/TMSquareTechnologySolutions Technical ...
Tutorial #9 | Test Plan in Jira Xray | Linking Test to Test Plan | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 22 тис.2 роки тому
This video tutorial series is about "Jira Xray". This series will help learner's to understand the concepts of Xray and allow them to use test management in Jira. In this video we have covered Xray Test Management, Test Management in Xray, Creating Test Plan in Xray, Linking Tests to Test Plan, Linking Test Executions to Test Plan, Learn More about Testing ISTQB Certification - ua-cam.com/users...
Tutorial #8 | Creating Test Set in Xray | Executing a Test Set in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 20 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #8 | Creating Test Set in Xray | Executing a Test Set in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Tutorial #7 | Create a Test Execution in Xray | Running a Test in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 34 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #7 | Create a Test Execution in Xray | Running a Test in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Tutorial #6 | Preconditions in Xray | How to Create Precondition in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 21 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #6 | Preconditions in Xray | How to Create Precondition in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Tutorial #5 | Calling a Test in Xray | Calling an Existing Step in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 28 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #5 | Calling a Test in Xray | Calling an Existing Step in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Tutorial #4 | Creating Test in Xray | Writing Test Case in Xray | Test Steps in Jira | Xray Tutorial
Переглядів 50 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #4 | Creating Test in Xray | Writing Test Case in Xray | Test Steps in Jira | Xray Tutorial
Tutorial #3 | Issue Types of Xray | Xray Issue types | Test Management in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 39 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #3 | Issue Types of Xray | Xray Issue types | Test Management in Xray | Xray Tutorials
Tutorial #2 | Configure Xray in Jira | Installing Xray | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 51 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #2 | Configure Xray in Jira | Installing Xray | Xray Tutorials
Tutorial #1 | Introduction to Jira Xray | Xray in Jira | Xray Tutorials
Переглядів 90 тис.2 роки тому
Tutorial #1 | Introduction to Jira Xray | Xray in Jira | Xray Tutorials
Tutorial #20 | Checkpoints in UFT | File Content Checkpoint | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 2,5 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #20 | Checkpoints in UFT | File Content Checkpoint | UFT Tutorials
Tutorial #19 | Checkpoints in UFT | XML Checkpoint | XML Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 2,2 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #19 | Checkpoints in UFT | XML Checkpoint | XML Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Tutorial #18 | Checkpoints in UFT | Bitmap Checkpoint | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 2,2 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #18 | Checkpoints in UFT | Bitmap Checkpoint | UFT Tutorials
Tutorial #17 | Checkpoints in UFT | Text Area Checkpoint | Text Area Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 2 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #17 | Checkpoints in UFT | Text Area Checkpoint | Text Area Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Tutorial #16 | Checkpoints in UFT | Text Checkpoint | Text Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 2,8 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #16 | Checkpoints in UFT | Text Checkpoint | Text Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Tutorial #15 | Checkpoints in UFT | Standard Checkpoint | Standard Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 4,2 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #15 | Checkpoints in UFT | Standard Checkpoint | Standard Output Value | UFT Tutorials
Tutorial #14 | Comparing Shared Repository | Merging Shared Repositories | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 2,7 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #14 | Comparing Shared Repository | Merging Shared Repositories | UFT Tutorials
Tutorial #13 | Working with Shared Repository | Editing Shared Repsository | UFT Tutorials
Переглядів 2,7 тис.3 роки тому
Tutorial #13 | Working with Shared Repository | Editing Shared Repsository | UFT Tutorials

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @tyan3029
    @tyan3029 6 днів тому

    Hello! Thank you for the detailed explanation. I have a question regarding to the migration of existing test cases. If I join the project and the migration hasn't been done during the Xray installation. Is there any ways to migrate the existing test artifacts on the existing project?

  • @jamegarbage9785
    @jamegarbage9785 7 днів тому

    bro this help me alot , not notice any that this tools are exist until my boss told me lol.

    • @TestinginNutshell
      @TestinginNutshell 7 днів тому

      Ha ha Thats why we have this channel for all unique tools. Glad it helped you.

  • @jegathajk
    @jegathajk 12 днів тому

    hi. am new to xray. i was creating a issue type "Test Case" and i was creating a issue under that. it says " you must enter section id value to complete this issue". what is that?

    • @TestinginNutshell
      @TestinginNutshell 7 днів тому

      Section Id is not a standard field of Jira. Pls check with your admin once it’s a custom field. They made it mandatory for one issue type but became mandatory for all issuetype

  • @abdo3754
    @abdo3754 22 дні тому

    Thank you for your great tutorial, it's really well structured. i like it . Could you please perhaps provide a tutorial on token based login and show us each steps in detail. thanks in advance

  • @tarlokdhaliwal7237
    @tarlokdhaliwal7237 22 дні тому

    very easy and good explanation. 🤗🤗

  • @nissivarghese2459
    @nissivarghese2459 25 днів тому

    Thank you for the video! I have a question about the Manual test type. What is the internal difference between the Manual and Generic test types? Is the following process correct? Create tests (with steps) and link them to the requirements. Create a test plan and add all the tests to the test plan. Add test executions to the test plan, where we can then track the test results. I’ve used the Generic test type before but haven’t worked with the Manual type. Could you please explain the key differences briefly?

  • @marcomalziotti2411
    @marcomalziotti2411 27 днів тому

    Thanks for the video. By accessing my home page (url=X) I am redirected to another address (url=y) for login (NTLM authentication) via a pop-up. Why in recording phas, by setting X in "Url Address" filed in the registration options, the pop-up, where I can indicate the access credentials, does not appear? I cannot continue with the registration. Thanks.

  • @JayaseelanM-j4h
    @JayaseelanM-j4h Місяць тому

    Sir how can i validate a Page like ifi click any button it leads to the another page or dialog or window ,tab so how can i validate those thing please help me with this it would be a Great help Thanks

  • @MuhammadUsman-lx6ye
    @MuhammadUsman-lx6ye Місяць тому

    Can they also be run through xray

  • @manithkumar5287
    @manithkumar5287 Місяць тому

    Thank you for your Time and excellent explanation detail in topics helped a lot. in debt🙇

  • @JayaseelanM-j4h
    @JayaseelanM-j4h Місяць тому

    So for Check point if the dropdown field has 5 option so we can verify all the options in single action or we have to verify this with one by one like 5 times?

  • @Genusik
    @Genusik Місяць тому

    10x!

  • @soukainaibaline
    @soukainaibaline Місяць тому

    I have one question. In the test case, I added some fields that are mandatory and needed for reporting purposes. For example, I want to track all test cases that have passed by stream. However, my testing team finds it impractical to mark a test as 'failed' or 'passed' in the test execution and then update the workflow separately. Could you suggest a more efficient approach?

  • @VpAmis
    @VpAmis Місяць тому

    yes, The connection between Acceptance Criteria and Requirements in a project is closely intertwined, with both elements working together to define the expectations and quality of the final product. Below is a description of their precise relationships and connections: 1. Defining Role Requirements describe the general functional and non-functional properties that a system or product must meet. They form the framework of what needs to be built. Acceptance Criteria are more specific, measurable conditions that must be met to confirm that a Requirement has been fully and correctly implemented. They clarify when a Requirement can be considered complete. 2. Level of Detail Requirements are often written at a higher level of abstraction, focusing on overall system functionality or business objectives. Acceptance Criteria detail exactly how a Requirement should be tested or verified, for example, by describing specific scenarios, edge cases, or acceptable results. They provide more concrete guidelines for what needs to be delivered to meet the Requirements. 3. Validation versus Specification Requirements state what needs to be done or delivered. Acceptance Criteria specify how to verify if the result is acceptable, i.e., whether the Requirement has been met. Acceptance Criteria form the basis for validation, often carried out in the form of tests or reviews. 4. Guiding the Development Process Requirements serve as a guide for the entire development process, including design, construction, and implementation. They form the basis for planning and prioritization. Acceptance Criteria are a key part of the Definition of Done (DoD) in agile projects. They ensure that developers and testers clearly understand when a piece of work can be considered finished and approved. 5. Communication with Stakeholders Requirements are often aimed at a broader group of stakeholders, such as product owners, clients, and development teams. They communicate the overall goals of the project. Acceptance Criteria are frequently used by developers and testers to communicate with product owners or clients about what exactly needs to be tested to ensure that the Requirement is considered "done" and executed to satisfaction. 6. Quality Assurance Requirements define which functionalities or properties the product must have. Acceptance Criteria act as a quality assurance mechanism by explicitly describing the conditions under which a feature or functionality is considered successful. This helps prevent bugs and misunderstandings. In summary, Requirements provide the foundation for what needs to be built, while Acceptance Criteria are the concrete metrics used to verify if those Requirements have been met. The Requirements indicate the 'what,' while the Acceptance Criteria specify the 'how' in terms of verification and validation. A failing testcase should lead back to the requirements. It should be visible to see indeed.

  • @TobiasBlithe-r2h
    @TobiasBlithe-r2h Місяць тому

    Garcia Karen White Maria Martinez Paul

  • @AdellManey-c9j
    @AdellManey-c9j Місяць тому

    Lee Kenneth Perez George Williams Melissa

  • @AlcottKing-n2s
    @AlcottKing-n2s 2 місяці тому

    Allen Timothy Thomas Edward Martin Amy

  • @arunapasupula9329
    @arunapasupula9329 2 місяці тому

    Thank you for your time in making all this video's with great explanation.. greatly useful on performance center 🙏

  • @Uyghur118
    @Uyghur118 2 місяці тому

    Thank you, it's really interesting. Can we use this tool for testing a desktop application which communicate with a field device?

    • @TestinginNutshell
      @TestinginNutshell Місяць тому

      Thanks. Yes you can use it for desktop applications as well

  • @manasanagendra7917
    @manasanagendra7917 2 місяці тому

    Hi sir, when I open LR controller, it is asking for license..what to do next

  • @manasanagendra7917
    @manasanagendra7917 2 місяці тому

    When I try accessing website like facebook or google. The website doesn't get loaded. Just the recording events is getting increasing but not the website is getting loaded. please help. Also webtours application is not opening

  • @SudhakarVoleti-v9r
    @SudhakarVoleti-v9r 2 місяці тому

    I strongly feel that, in Test repository, we should keep tests based on the features/modules/functionality, These sprints & Releases has to be managed with TestExecution and TestPlans.

  • @arielsantangelo1658
    @arielsantangelo1658 3 місяці тому

    I don't have issue page on the board of my project, do i have to ask to the admin to enable that function?

  • @eray_dwg
    @eray_dwg 3 місяці тому

    Thank God, finally an Indian man who can speak understandable English

  • @amiraliansari9887
    @amiraliansari9887 3 місяці тому

    Thanks for the insightful tutorials, I would like to know if Load Runner is capable of conducting performance testing for desktop applications?

  • @kellyhochanadel2972
    @kellyhochanadel2972 3 місяці тому

    Do you have a separate video on importing cucumber feature files?

  • @AnuSunkavalli
    @AnuSunkavalli 4 місяці тому

    Hi Neeraj, I like your Tutorial. looking for some support at work-related things. can you provide your contact information? from USA

  • @chachatutorials3673
    @chachatutorials3673 4 місяці тому

    Hello Boss, thank you for the tutorial, however, I can't seem to figure out how to integrate the default issue types from X-ray. I get a message to manually add them. Please assist. @Testing

  • @jahnavium7211
    @jahnavium7211 4 місяці тому

    Can you give that practice URL

  • @ZacklFair
    @ZacklFair 4 місяці тому

    You need a new mic.

  • @saisruthimarreddi3222
    @saisruthimarreddi3222 5 місяців тому

    Hi, what is the difference between Test option and Xray Test option in Jira.

  • @sarakatsanosgr
    @sarakatsanosgr 5 місяців тому

    🙏🏼 Thanks again ( everytime I have a question you are always here helping)

  • @NeurodivergentTM
    @NeurodivergentTM 5 місяців тому

    Hi. I am a test manager in an agile program where the testers create test cases from their user stories. If the testers execute their test cases using executions on the test cases, i cannot see the result in test plans, where i have added the test cases. Do i have to add the test executions created by the user or should we add all test cases to the test plan and create a test execution on the test plan instead ? please advice on the right approach to this.

    • @TestinginNutshell
      @TestinginNutshell 5 місяців тому

      Yes you should add the test cases and the test executions in a Test Plan and you can see the summary and execution report by assignee in the reports and dashboards.

    • @NeurodivergentTM
      @NeurodivergentTM 5 місяців тому

      Thanks 👍

  • @NeurodivergentTM
    @NeurodivergentTM 5 місяців тому

    Thanks for a good video. I found out that there is a huge difference between Xray Cloud and Server versions. In cloud, you are very limited in JQL construction, so you cannot create advanced filters by using JQL. You are also limited on certain gadgets in Jira dashboard, e.g. you cannot create a widget with expandable views of issues. We needed to see the coverage of Epics and underlying user stories, and this can be done in the server version, but not in cloud.

  • @adewolesamuel1311
    @adewolesamuel1311 5 місяців тому

    Hello, I hope this message finds you well. I would greatly appreciate a few minutes of your time for a constructive conversation regarding your Udemy course. If possible, would you be available for a quick call? Thank you in advance for considering my request.

    • @TestinginNutshell
      @TestinginNutshell 5 місяців тому

      Hi Which Udemy course are you referring to and what is this regarding. As it's really hard for me to find some time out to schedule a call. Let me know to discuss further.

    • @adewolesamuel1311
      @adewolesamuel1311 5 місяців тому

      @@TestinginNutshell where can I reach out to you sir?

  • @kopalrathore9617
    @kopalrathore9617 6 місяців тому

    Hi Sir, could you please let me know the answer for below query: In one of the application we have sequence number to be passed and we parameterized this value and have notepad with 10 sequence number and this value should be unique as this belongs to banking application and we are having 10 VU, so what is the value 5 VU is belong to? like in that case what setting we needs to do in it if we execute it in controller?

  • @santoshsubramani3588
    @santoshsubramani3588 6 місяців тому

    Can we have test coverage across multiple project , means different Jira project as requirement and single jira project set up only for test , test coverage report will give us out put

  • @bhumikanikumbh88
    @bhumikanikumbh88 6 місяців тому

    My script is failing always

  • @aashijain5494
    @aashijain5494 6 місяців тому

    Hi Neeraj, I had a quick question - I want to use XRAY in JIRA for testing but we have different applications and projects both of which are a part of each other. For example Application A, B, C can have Project 1, 2, 3 within them and vice versa. Can XRAY have 'many to many' mappings for test cases??

  • @craigharvey500
    @craigharvey500 6 місяців тому

    I’m moving into a change manager role for a large fintech firm soon and UFT is used to place trades, mergers, switch deals etc. these videos have been sooo helpful in understanding how scripts are created and run using UFT thank you!!!

  • @hamzaahmad549
    @hamzaahmad549 6 місяців тому

    I would like to know if this complete tutorial about desktop application testing or web application testing is also included?

  • @utsavpateriya9676
    @utsavpateriya9676 6 місяців тому

    Hello sir kindly share ur contact number.

  • @karunakerni2612
    @karunakerni2612 7 місяців тому

    Thanks, Neeraj for such elaborated videos. I have a question, regarding the Test list reports- When you said it would reflect all these in our repository. What does that mean? In another statement, you said if we do not define any filter then all tests of the specific project will be displayed. This is creating some confusion, are you trying to say that even if we do create a repository for the test cases, a default test repository gets created? waiting for the clarification, Thanks

  • @aratimanchekar7588
    @aratimanchekar7588 7 місяців тому

    Hi Sir, If suppose the one test case is marked as passed in Test execution then the same test case used in Regression Test execution but status should not be Passed, it should be 'To Do' because Regression testing is not started yet. In that scenario what should we do?

  • @SundeepChalivendra
    @SundeepChalivendra 7 місяців тому

    Hi Neeraj , Greetings of the day ! Can we parameterize the values of Login credentials with multiple sets of data

  • @syedarmaghanhassan4652
    @syedarmaghanhassan4652 8 місяців тому

    Is it available on mac?

  • @Bunny62893
    @Bunny62893 8 місяців тому

  • @MakoSk8er
    @MakoSk8er 8 місяців тому

    Thank you !!!

  • @JustHereHappening
    @JustHereHappening 8 місяців тому

    Hello, is it possible to Tag someone within the Steps Action? For some reason in the actual result, you can @ someone but it seems the user who is tagged is not notified. Please help

  • @user-pi3fn4ln7y
    @user-pi3fn4ln7y 8 місяців тому

    Small correction about Sub Test executions. These don't sit under a test, but under the requirement itself, making them available to show on the Agile board that the requirement belongs to. This also allows changing the workflow for the requirement's issue type, e.g. to enforce that the Sub Test Execution must be closed before the requirement itself can also be closed.