- 5
- 22 488
This Review Kills Fascists
Приєднався 12 кві 2020
It has to start somewhere.
It has to start some time.
What better place than here?
What better time than now?
This channel is for video essays that tell the stories of musical artists whose work features prominent political and/or LGBTQ+ messages. Videos made by Fiendly (they/them pronouns).
Header + icon by Nat Lacuna
It has to start some time.
What better place than here?
What better time than now?
This channel is for video essays that tell the stories of musical artists whose work features prominent political and/or LGBTQ+ messages. Videos made by Fiendly (they/them pronouns).
Header + icon by Nat Lacuna
Death Atlas - Cattle Decapitation and the dangers of eco-fascism | This Review Kills Fascists
Cattle Decapitation are among the best known and most beloved names in modern extreme metal. From their humble beginnings, they built a reputation as "the vegetarian metal band," and eventually earned tremendous success by highlighting progressive causes like trans rights and environmentalism with their music. However, as the state of the environment has worsened, the misanthropy that has permeated their work since the beginning has lead them down the dark path of genocide apologia, and it has become necessary to discuss some of the profoundly incorrect things their latest album has to say.
Patreon: patreon.com/fiendly
Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/fiendly
Credits for the song that plays from 9:43 through 12:42:
Horizons by Scott Buckley | www.scottbuckley.com.au
Music promoted by www.chosic.com/free-music/all/
Creative Commons CC BY 4.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Citation for the article referenced at 17:32:
Brian Hughes, Dave Jones & Amarnath Amarasingam (2022) Ecofascism: An Examination of the Far-Right/Ecology Nexus in the Online Space, Terrorism and Political Violence, 34:5, 997-1023, DOI: 10.1080/09546553.2022.2069932
Patreon: patreon.com/fiendly
Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/fiendly
Credits for the song that plays from 9:43 through 12:42:
Horizons by Scott Buckley | www.scottbuckley.com.au
Music promoted by www.chosic.com/free-music/all/
Creative Commons CC BY 4.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Citation for the article referenced at 17:32:
Brian Hughes, Dave Jones & Amarnath Amarasingam (2022) Ecofascism: An Examination of the Far-Right/Ecology Nexus in the Online Space, Terrorism and Political Violence, 34:5, 997-1023, DOI: 10.1080/09546553.2022.2069932
Переглядів: 3 348
Відео
Radical - Taking politics personally with Every Time I Die | This Review Kills Fascists
Переглядів 1,5 тис.3 роки тому
Every Time I Die have been masters of their niche since the turn of the century, and their lyrics have always added a unique layer of humor and insight to their music. With their latest release, those famous lyrics tackle the dire state of global politics and what to do about it. Patreon: patreon.com/fiendly Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/fiendly #EveryTimeIDie #Radical #Metalcore
Someday This Could All Be Yours - the pAper chAse's apocalyptic anxiety | This Review Kills Fascists
Переглядів 2,8 тис.3 роки тому
Experimental rock band The pAper chAse specializes in making concept albums about scary, uncomfortable subjects. In 2009, they set their sights on the topic of natural disasters, seemingly in reference to the looming climate crisis, but what they were actually tackling is the root cause of that crisis. A bonus text review can be read for free here: www.patreon.com/posts/47733249 Ko-Fi: ko-fi.co...
Lost On You - The mainstream breakthrough of queer pop singer LP | This Review Kills Fascists
Переглядів 1,3 тис.4 роки тому
Note: UA-cam may eat comments that pertain to sexuality and LGBT subjects without warning. Apologies in advance if that happens, there's nothing I can do about it because UA-cam is the worst. LP was discovered in the 90s, but her sexuality and gender presentation made the major labels unsure of what to do with her. When they let her loose to do exactly what she wanted, she scored a mega hit and...
Skeletons - The anarchist radicalization of Nothingface | This Review Kills Fascists
Переглядів 13 тис.4 роки тому
Nothingface was an extremely unlucky band that was around from day 1 of nu-metal all the way to the bitter end and never quite made it. In many ways, the world wasn't ready for them, and is only catching up now. Patreon: patreon.com/fiendly Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/fiendly #Nothingface #NuMetal #Anarchist
This was great. While I love pretty much every Nothingface song, I thoroughly enjoyed your breakdown of Skeletons. I just relistened to the entire album whole way through first time since before Oct 7, 2023 and the lyrics were the first thing that struck me. I was able to pick up critiques of the West from almost every track off Skeletons. In fact the lyrics off that album are some of the most poignant critical descriptions of the West I have ever seen. "Hate is nothing new, Murderers watching every step, Ignorance oblivious to all the evidence, Repent for all that were the innocent, Forget so we can all rest" is basically America's prayer. I was also delighted to discover that my favorite band not only made some of the absolute best nu metal to ever be played, but they also had such an incredible perspective that I resonant with so deeply. I definitely noticed their lyrics were more on the progressive side when I was a teenager but I was still such a baby back then. 20 years later I have a deep appreciation for how corrupted and evil our androcratic world is, the various subsystems that have been birthed from it like capitalism, patriarchy, etc. they are the things destroying our world. God I wish Matt was still with us. I think he and I would have gotten along well, would have at least been able to have an interesting conversation with him. I hope he's at peace. Matt, you are a legend.
You said it, Matt was so much more sharp and observant than I'd ever given him credit for, it really would have been great if he'd had the opportunity to do more. Walking On Bodies is an underappreciated masterpiece of imperialist criticism.
@ThisReviewKillsFascists totally agree man. Thanks so much for doing this review and for continuing to bring awareness to this band despite them being broken up almost 20 years now. I think Matt would have written some absolutely scathing and brilliant stuff if he was still here watching what was going down.
Incredible review dude. I’ve been on a serious Nothingface kick the past couple weeks and so happy I found your channel. Excellent work!
Holy crap, a Nothingface video essay? Is it my birthday?
Do you plan on making anymore videos any time soon? I absolutely love all of your videos and think you have some of the best unbiased insight out of all of the music video-essay channels out there and would love to continue supporting this great channel I wont rush greatness. This and your videos on nothingface and ETID are absolutely fantastic
Thanks so much! Working slowly on a few new ones, i may or may not have something to show relatively soon. Now's the time let people know about more powerful, conscientious music I think
Extreme metal is generally not about love and flowers. It's about frustrations let free, sometimes to the extreme, to increase emotions. CD does this the best. Not a religion though....
I have loved nothingface since the first time i heard them i have pacifier singed by all of them from ozzfest in 2003 skeltons is top 10 albums of all time r.i.p i even have the same exact birthday as matt holt
While I very much disagree with your uncharitable interpretation of their lyrics, it was still an interesting video.
Honestly I felt the same way I didn’t like the loud sound and vocals years ago but man it’s so fucking good
I’ve been friends with Travis and Cattle D. since 2001, and there is nothing fascist about any of his beliefs. This video analysis has completely missed the concurrent theme in his lyrics: destroying each other,themselves, and their environment is part of the human condition. We can objectively agree that the world would be a better place without humans, however, it would be self-sabotaging to advocate for humanity’s extinction considering we all have people we love and care about (Travis included), and our survival is codependent on one another. In death metal, you’re able to express morbid thoughts and ideas without being taken literal, as it’s an art form, not an instruction manual or manifesto. Ozzy Osbourne “Suicide Solution” Judas Priest “Better by You, Better Than Me” Slayer “Postmortem” and “Dead Skin Mask” All those bands (those songs in particular) were blamed for horrific crimes and/or tragedies conducted by fans of said bands. It is nothing new for metal bands to receive blame for something they had nothing to do with. As unfortunate as it is (as even pointed out in Cattle D.’s lyrics), many people are fucked up, and will do fucked up things to each other (as mentioned earlier regarding the human condition). I highly recommend you at least try to contact the people discussed within your subject matter, as it will add credibility obtaining information from a primary source.
Taking as read that human nature is to destroy and human extinction would objectively be a good thing is exactly the sentiment that prompted me to make this video, and is addressed as the foundation of the point I'm making. Many have taken what I've said in this video as my failure to comprehend that satire can be an extreme exaggeration of what the satirist would actually like to see happen, comparing what's said on this album to other works where horrors are depicted so as to state an argument or just have a fun creepy time with art. I promise that I understand why people put violent and cruel themes into their creative output, and I celebrate those who do it well, which often includes Cattle Decapitation, but it's also crucial to explore where the basis for those violent fantasies lies. In the case of Death Atlas, that basis is "humans bad," which extrapolates to the logical extreme of "genocide has a bright side," which is an extremely dangerous, evil mindset that many hold sincerely. I truly believe that neither you nor Travis directly support any fascist agendas, but that doesn't contradict anything I said in the video. Your suggestion to attempt to contact primary sources is a good one, and although I try to fill that void with direct quotes in appropriate context, I will endeavor to improve my future work in that way.
The video was strong before the end. Talking about how much you agree with the anarchist/anti establishment views of the band yet you only throw shade against the bands who symphatize with Trump Implying to me you don't complain about guys like Green Day endorsing guys like Sanders and Biden is a cuck move buddy and far from being anti establishment
It's weird seeing someone understand that the band's early lyrics were hyperbolic and cathartic, but not realize that the band's newer songs are the exact same way. Obviously, the band doesn't want to kill all humans. Be real.
10/10 album, still listen to it amongst my gojira, messugah, and devin townsend
Opening your video with Same Solution? You got my forever sub!!! Kickass content. Stupid underrated band that belongs at the top
✊🏾
Dunno dude, I feel like you are thinking this way too hard. I've personally never cared much about the environment, until I listened to death atlas. It was the first album of theirs that I actually listened with thought and it made me think that maybe we should do something, and I'm not talking about a genocide. Also, didn't "bring back the plague" release before the pandemic?
I never got into these guys. Its just too political and i do hate politics. I like to be taken away with music to places that politics doesn't exist personally....
Sweet baby LP is originally from Brooklyn 😊 (not Long island).......
So how are those leftist politics working out for you? Turns out they were the more of the two evils. Turns out they are the war mongers. Not saying the right is any better but the only ones trying to stop this massive decline in society is some republicans and they are demonized by the democrat media. The left are trying to brainwash children. They are trying to destroy everything that makes america such a good place. Your political beliefs and voting have lead us to a dementia patient in the white house. Congrats. You really played yourself.
He was singing clean vocals when you said he wasn't.
"But hes white so its not a crime" dude seriously? You have a warped view of reality.
An Audio Guide to Everyday Atrocity is still to this day one of my favourite albums. Every song rules.
Violence and skeletons are my absolute 2 favorite CDs.... just Perfect
There are good bands that were never really nu metal but often get mistaken for it (soad, ratm, helmet) good bands that are legitimately part new metal but do something different too like punk or thrash elements (snot, deftones, soulfly). But there are very few good pure nu metal bands. I'm going to throw up sevendust.
This band was SO talented and underrated. Amazing video, my guy.
Boo-urns
Just want to state for the record, I whiffed the analysis of what The Lightning was about pretty hard. Not to say it's NOT about what I say in the video, lyrics are always open to interpretation and mean many things, but I failed to recognize the meaning that is referenced in the title of the song, What Should We Do With Your Body? This element of the lyrics is taken from the perspective of the owning class, looking at the working class and salivating at the potential to exploit and use up their lives ("all of their beautiful bodies") to produce value. Lines like "Oh the views you'll see over cross danglings" and "The willing whore is the hand of the Lord" are propagandistic efforts to convince people to celebrate this exploitation, and the recitation of "God is everywhere" instills an acceptance in this being the natural order of things (echoed later in the album when The Blizzard turjs into "He's got the whole world in his hands"). If you'd like the hear a Congleton song that much more directly talks about how unlikely it can be to find companionship and human connection, check out Put Your Teeth In by The Nighty Nite (a personal favorite of his discography)
Your entire take on TPC is bad! You are bias to 440hz A4! You can't understand a song more complicated than the Blitzkrieg Bop!
I'll never forget the first time I saw/heard of Nothingface. 1998 in Raleigh NC opening for Soulfly, and another unheard of band at the time..... System of a down. I knew almost instantly that Nothingface was going to be huge. They were amazing live, but huge never came. Instead they have the much better position of being loved by the few that really appreciated what they were doing. Time has only made their work much more appreciated to us few that knew who they were!
I loved all those bands
"At the dawn of agriculture 10,000 years ago, humans, livestock, and pets constituted about 0.1% of terrestrial vertebrate biomass. Today, this figure is 98%." (Dan Dennet, 2024 see here: ua-cam.com/video/DFQhTOpHxNA/v-deo.html) If it can be eaten or used for something, destroy it so something consumable can replace it 🤔?
Nothingface was and still is amazing, and I love the leftist perspective.
Thank you for this video. There’s a certain mystique surrounding this band for me. They weren’t the first band I listened to or anything but they were that one band I could never get enough of. I think the saddest band art of all is that their sound just got better every album. Mostly kidding with this statement but shame on you for putting down I am him. That’s one of my all time favorites. There is no bad song on Skeletons. It’ll go down in my book at the best metal album of all time
Amazing band.
it's an interesting perspective on their lyrics! I always considered Cattle Decapitation as an outlet for the rage you feel when dealing with humans: you see them destroy the planet for greed, so you want them to die. It's as simple as it is cathargic. They became my go-to band after watching the news for that reason. Just like a depressive suicidal black metal band doesn't really condone suicide, they just use that topic to release those thoughts. It's just frustration and rage. I don't think their aim is to tell people what to do or to solve a problem, they are PISSED because we are most likely doomed.
What movie does the unopened email to god sample?
The sample is from a movie called The Empty Mirror from 1996, and the character who speaks those lines is Hitler. Full credit to Remember_A_Day on Reddit for finding that source
It’s one of the great disappointments in Metal that two amazing bands like Mudvayne and Nothingface produced something so gingoistic and vapid as Hellyeah. Great video btw, learned a lot!
Hellyeah did put out one good song on their final album at least. Black Flag Army rules, Tom Maxwell just can't stop accidentally playing in bands with anarchist singers.
I actually really like the composition of "I am Him". His spoken word with the sparce instrumental really lends to the emotion in the vocals!
You gonna shityourself when you find out that bring back the plague was released before the pandemic😂
why didnt you mentioned their last album? their self titled album that came out in 2010?
That was a remaster and reissue on their 1995 debut, which I talk about before Pacifier
Dumb.
The 90's early 2000's was an amazing time for rock/metal music.
NF will forever be my favorite band. I had been a fan since Pacifier. RIP Matt. I got to talk to all of them after a small show in TN right before it all fell apart for them. All awrsome guys
Limp Bizkit is dog shit. So many better nu metal bands at that time. Nothingface was so amazing. Violence is in my top 5 favorite albums. That first singer sounded like Axel Rose.
Dude, this was a sick video that has little views? Great job
After watching this video, all I can say is that Travis's lyrics are NOT meant to be taken as seriously or literally as you've taken them, and that if you know who, specifically, With All Disrespect was written about, that person deserved every bit of the ire in those lyrics.
I love Nothingface, I even got to see them open for Pantera on their last tour before breaking up back in 2001. That said, I'm glad to see another big Nothingface fan publicly say that Pacifier is not really that good or indicative of the band's trademark sound. In fact, I'm pretty tired of hearing "fans" say that was their best album and 'after that one, they sold out, man'. /eyeroll
I remember my pal Joseph gave me a promotional disc with "Bleeder" on it. I ended up buying the censored version of "Violence" and I know every single edit on that album. Love it. The drums, the heaviness, it's like a monstrous heartbeat.
Yeah...... Nah. Sorry, I think this video takes Cattle Decap fans to be fools and is a little patronising. Perhaps useful to the very young getting into this metal style, but most people understand that this is art, theatre and all its inherent contradictons. You can debate whether or not it's good or bad art, but to basicly call Cattle Decap eco-fascists and putting them on the same bus as real eco-fascists who commited racialy motivated massacres is about as ridiculous as Christian parents in the early 80s who dragged Judas Priest through the courts. This video made one fair point though - that Cattle Decaps messages should be taken as warnings about the future. That's exactly how the fans take them, including warnings about bigotry and false narratives around over-population etc. The fans are a bit smarter that what's premised here. We get it and don't need a lecture.
Man, this was some far stretching bs... so what now we're claiming anyone who hates humanity for its blatant transgressions on not only themselves but the natural order as a whole is a fascist? Get out of here with that shit. Also, the part about phil is particularly telling of what you're trying to push. You said it yourself he pulled that stunt after their collab... are we accusing robb flynn of it too since he was on stage? Should anyone who's ever pissed next to the man at a urinal publically apologize? Fuck no... the guy did what he did and thats on him have they dobe shit with him since? No, they haven't... This conspiritoral nonesense is ridiculous. travis has stated how much he despises humans as a whole, not in specific regions, not any one group over the other, no all of it. Insinuating that he is some closet facist is laughable and beyond nonsense.
Fascists and anti-fascists are nowadays one and the same. Both spread hatred and lies, just like the creator of this video.
Respectfully, I think his lyrics are a (certainly ignorant and irresponsible) way of saying "fuck the world" out of frustration with very real problems. I'm not denying or downplaying the harm that could come from someone taking everything literally and taking it to heart but truly outside of the unsavory but i believe intentionally hyperbolic lyrics, this guy comes across as if his heart is in the right place.