Відео

I don't want a black Hermione or a gay Ron Weasley, hope they truly stick faithful to the books and don't try to preach their woke shit down our throats.

If I actually cared about Harry Potter enough, I'd say the best they could do is take the Animated style of deathly hallows story and tell a new story for a new generation.

HBO is based af

I’ve deconstructed and then reconstructing my beliefs. My views have really shifted. I follow Jesus teachings, parables and principles that were confronting the Churches teachings and belief. Today’s church is a self serving enterprise changing as it serves their narrative. I can worship at a concert now if the songs are song that connect me to Gods Spirit. My music choices are base on Worship… Not about my deliverance. My view of salvation is almost non existent. God already exists within me… I didn’t need salvation , I needed realization… I left Church and God left with me… I can sit in nature and feel that same connection or look into eyes of happiness human or animal and feel that love, goodness and acceptance…

This is gonna be so bad. Gonna end up doing more harm than good to the franchise, just like Fantastic Beasts

Gee. I wonder why Hans Christian Andersen's and the Brothers Grimm's fairy tales weren't taken apart like the Harry Potter series have been?

Watch the playlist "if Harry Potter was in Slytherin". THAT story should be made into a series.

This was such a great video. I personally I'm not gonna watch it. It feels like a cash grab and I just hate that jk is involved. Anything related to jk I'm not interested to support. Is just so disappointing to see how much worse she has become over the years. Thanks for the video.

Calling JK Rowling a one-hit wonder is just not true. I know she's bigot and all , it's so easy to discredit her achievements. But she wrote 7 best sellers , all in the top 20 best-selling book of all time. It's not an easy feat.

All I will say is as a 32 year old that loved and grew up with Harry Potter and I still love it. I don't care for a reboot a animated series maybe but a full reboot it's a no for me I agree it's a very bad idea they will ruin a lot of peoples childhoods older and younger. As for politics I don't take sides I am staying very far far away from it same with religion.

“No precedent for a reboot of a huge franchise this soon” The Amazing Spider-Man would like to have a word with you 😂

It isn't bigoted to say women don't have penises my dude. I'm out.

The timing is fine as it is 25 years since the first movie was released. The problem is the familiarity we have with the movie franchise, it is too well known too copy and a bad adaptation will be compared to it

Girl, you were not comprehensively reading a Harry Potter novel (hundreds of pages long) at 7 years old...the age in which kids are being taught their most introductory level reading skills. Even if you were reading these books at 10, you were an advanced reader for your age. This whole story seems WILDLY unlikely...

For me if i call Harry potter bad I'm doing it because as someone who has loved reading my entire life and read so many things, its just pretty alright, it's mean spirited and wears it's fantasy elements as a coat of paint, but for so many people the magic that is reading became the magic that is Harry Potter because they just didn't keep going and find other stores worth investing themselves into

I always love how all the "problematic" parts of the story only became a thing after the author became insane It's so obvious that the outrage is just virtue signal that it's actually hilarious😂😂

Some poor kids are going to get Wil Wheatoned into playing characters in this series and it’s going to be so sad.

Honestly as bleh as it is to do this so soon after the movies, if it's good or bad it doesn't matter so much because we will always have the movies to fall back on as the good version.

I am considering giving up my youtube habit because of the advertisements. They are not just irrelevant to me they are becoming misleading and untruthful or just mindless rubbish. I can subscribe directly to my favourite content providers on their own sites.

idk about you but I want this

13:30 Haha Good one 😂 man Tyler is just an awful name. What _were_ your parents thinking?!

I just re-read Harry Potter, and I find the books more enjoyable bc I get more of the day to day life of the protagonists, and it makes me feel like I’m a student right there with them. BUT, I noticed several things that were left out for good reason, as well as some minor changes in the movies that actually increased the tension, humor, or mystery of the scene. That being said I would not be mad at a remake of goblet of fire bc that was a let down. I also feel like the death of Sirius could be made more meaningful to the viewer if they made his relationship with Harry truer to the books. Non readers like my husband also really did not like Dobby, and I was sad that he was less of a character in the movies, and I liked Kreacher’s part in the book as well. I think it’s too soon for a remake, and not to be disturbing or rude, but at least some of the greatest actors and actresses who have passed away wont have to see their iconic roles recast.

I found the fantastic beasts pitch meeting videos on UA-cam much more entertaining than the actual fantastic beast movies.

Wait, do people not like fantastic beasts?

I NEEED someone from hbo to reply to this and they really need explain themselves bc you cooked them

Why on earth do you only have 2000 subs?! Instant new sub from me. Best of luck to you and keep on the good work!

Stop trashtalking JK Rowling. She is a great woman and her opinion are in FACT correct. You are just an idiot robot parroting what these degenerates parrot because all of you just NEED to virtue signal. But there is no virtue in what you say. You are wrong factually, biologically, socially and by gods word. Im so tired of all these idiots like you talking shit about this great woman who stands up for real women, and who filled your dumbass childhood with magic. Show some respect, be humble, sit down and shut up.

I feel like an hbo series about hogwarts or the Wizarding world altogether would be more interesting. Like a show that could in theory go on indefinitely by just having a show un related that takes place in the world. Idk.

I get it, but the original movies don't even feel dated at all. Remake is not necessary.

M. Night’s Avatar movie actually fell short because he wasn’t given *enough* creative freedom. The entire reason he wanted to make it was because his kids were *huge* fans of A:TLA, and he wanted to make an *extremely* faithful adaptation. Instead, the studio refused to give him a big enough budget for his vision, forced him to make a significantly shorter movie than he actually wanted, and forced him to make a *ton* of changes. This is unfortunately what happens with pretty much every bad movie of his, if you actually bother to do any research. But you couldn’t even bother to research that everyone hated the live action Avatar show or that everyone loved the Harry Potter scholastic book, so I’m not surprised you didn’t bother to research M. Night either. Side note: Aang is an *actual* South Asian name that’s pronounced the way it’s pronounced in the movie. M. Night, being South Asian himself, wanted to fix that despite the mispronunciation from the original cartoon being the most iconic version.

My reaction was: Okay, but why?

unless they can do what fallout did. they're cooked

@44:00 who the fuck decided that we wanted to experience the MINISTRY OF MAGIC at a damn theme park 🤦🏽‍♂️🤦🏽‍♂️🤦🏽‍♂️ out of all of the interesting aspects of the HP world why would they build an entire them park around fucking bureaucracy 🤡🤡🤡

Too much to the left

While the term "pop music" may have always technically been a catch-all term, in the past, in practical terms, it usually meant the song had a white woman was singing without a country twang.

I disagree on statements in this video made at about 27:30 and the adjacent parts about House Elves. Hermione Granger, the unambiguously smartest character in the book apart from maybe Dumbledore, is constantly complaining she is the only one bothered by the situation of the house elves, their own acceptance of this situation, and often nagging how stupid that is. She is trying to build an activism group for house elves, but eventually forced to abandon the effort for reasons of public indifference towards it. Please check your research about this topic. You are clearly missing this because it was cut from the films. I´m not writing this to alleviate obvious conservative beliefs of the author, but because its just not correct. Also, searching for "toxic" or "conservative" agenda in the book is pointless and misappropriate. The opinions and situations of characters in fictional works do not need to correspond to the authors own beliefs. From my reading (I have the english original print despite coming from Germany) the book is generally benevolent. It also is often critical towards problematic political situations, but does not claim to have solutions to them, so they are only shown as problematic, not more. This is evident for example in the situation with "bugging" of R.Skeeter in book 4. Hermione obviously can´t prohibit the yellow press to work, so she is powerless to change the situation except for preventing R.Skeeter to publish more indecent revelations about herself and her friends. ed1. yeah, after continuing to about 33:00 you notice this yourself.

This has such a GOATed Rowling take. I'm projecting my liberal American politics onto her, but I can't convince myself she was ever worse than some milquetoast Blairite when she was writing the books. Being an empty headed moderate and kind of racist was not crazy by 90s/00s standards. From that POV, she's interesting as a cautionary tale. I have decent, socially acceptable politics now. Could something turn me into a bigot in the next 30 years? This possibility gets totally erased by the insistence that she was always obviously some foaming at the mouth bigot if you just read the books right.

They’re actually gonna make the teachers the right age as well lol no more old ass snape

Love your videos, keep them coming please!

Wow - just wow. This video was so deep & informative. Can't believe you only have 2.5K subscribers. I wish you continued success. Great work.

I've always felt rap was essentially do-si-do and swing your partner without a fiddle in back, anyway. Just sayin.

this video. weirdly white. like. weirdly. why did you open with post malone and then have every single fucking main part be about a white person in this sphere when they didn’t start or even perfect it. where is the country grammar mention. where is boosie badazz. why are we not talking about how a LARGE PERCENTAGE OF SOUTHERNERS are poc. and that directly correlates into what’s popular. do you think future has never heard trace atkins before my brother. please hang out with one black person ever and you’ll see “wHaT hApPeNeD” it EVOLVED NATURALLY IN THE PLACES IT WAS POPULARLY MADE. why is lorde even mentioned.

My personal and looong opinion on harry potter as a whole (and the reboot) is: I am a fan of hp, I grew up with it and I will always love the world of harry potter. I don't agree with this new sentiment that just because of jk rowling (who I don't like either and I don't care about at all) people are now "Actually hp was really bad" "grow up/move on" "If you dare buy anything hp related that makes you a transphobe and a bad person"... If you want to distance yourself from the franchise because of jkr that is totally understandable but at the same time it does not mean that everyone that chooses not to should be berated? People do not like the series because they like jkr herself or agree with her views. I understand someone from a moral stance not wanting to fund a person actively working against trans rights but at the same time..hp same with other ips like star wars is too big and widespread, jkr is financially set for life just by owning the name, so no need to accuse people of directly supporting her by playing a game or buying a wand (that is just my opinion) Also adults can revisit a story they love and grew up with as much as they want and should not be shamed for it. And to completely deny anything good about it is a very biased and untrue take, there's a reason it became so popular, stood the test of time and is beloved by many people even today! Of course that does not make it perfect, I am very open to discussing and acknowledging any flaws, that doesn't change my love for hp but it does bother me when it solely comes from a place of resentment and bad faith. And I have critisisms of my own! that mainly comes from the books actually.. I don't think the writing is the best, as a children book it works but reading them as an adult it does not hold up as well, the world building of the wizarld world is not fully realised and that is because everything mainly revolves around hogwarts, some of jkr views does come off that rub me the wrong way for example the fatphobia is apparent and the misogyny as well in the way some female characters are portrayed and the other female characters treat them badly for no reason, I don't mind the house elf concept actually but I don't like the whole storyline of Hermione trying to advocate them and being ridiculed as a result, all the romances are baaad as well and do not work for me and the characters imo come off more unlikable than they do in the movies (except Ron maybe but even then I don't find him as egregious as many hp fans do in the movies) That's why the harry potter movies work so well for me (and in my unpopular opinion) are better than the books! They highlight the best parts of the books and the heart of the story, they don't show some other problematic parts, they make the story more fun with witty dialogue and all the character interactions. The casting is PERFECT and the characters are iconic. I wont understate how much good music and good direction plays a role in a succesful adaptation and the harry potter movies succeed in both in my opinion. Something does not have to be "book accurate" to be good and I feel a lot of book fans are too focused on the differences they forget to consider other aspects that make a movie/tv show good. Of course I'm not saying the movies are perfect either, there are some inconsistencies here and there and lack of information about the world and the characters that you should read the books if you are a big hp fan to get the full experience. But the positives still outweight the negatives in a big way imo. That's the reason I am not a fan of a this reboot idea.... It takes a lot to pull off a successful adaptation and the original has set such a high stake when it comes to style, direction, music, casting I am fairly certain they wont be able to recreate something as good in all those categories.. It may be more "book accurate" and that will automatically make it better in some fans eyes but that does not work on me. And as it is already stated, it is toooo early!!! The movies hold up just fine today and the actors are so closely associated with the characters no replacement will feel right... It feels unessesary and a cash grab and no amount of book purists is going to convince me otherwise cause as stated above the movies were never bad in the first place.

At the point we’re at now I don’t think it’s necessarily true anymore that no one has been pushed further right by HP. It’s probably a lot easier for a cis person to draw that conclusion but as someone who’s personally been harassed by more than one person with a deathly hallows tattoo, I can only disagree. I’ve actually heard people say out loud that people talking about ‘cancelling’ JKR or boycotting her video game has pushed them away from supporting trans rights, and while I’m not stupid enough to think their ally ship was ever worth a damn or that we can change the minds of people so shallow and morally insipid, it’s hard not think that she’s pushing people to the right, or at least encouraging anti-trans rhetoric in regular people. Harry Potter definitely did help me personally develop my moral compass. Honestly it even helped me develop my gender identity; I used to pretend to be Harry when I was a kid, but I just really and truly think that it’s incorrect to claim that this series hasn’t pulled anyone into a bigoted mindset at this point in time. It’s definitely a small minority of HP fans, but it does happen. That aside, for me it’s tainted beyond the ability to enjoy it anymore for me, which I realise is personal, but anyone supporting any official HP merch or property is actively funding anti trans political activity in my country.

Found your channel today and really enjoying your videos. Cheers to you and looking forward to more of your thoughts and takes!

30:19 - you've just blown my mind. Think of slaves after the American Revolution. Notably, there was a huge reactionary "revival" a generation later that closed off progress in women's rights and rights of minorities. Or the colonized peoples appealing for justice after WWI (and the myth that Wilson, dying of influenza, actually cared). In fiction, the last acts of the LOTR trilogy provide one of the more realistic tasks on war, when the greater conflict comes home to the hobbits.

My bias: the piece of literature that I got life lessons from in adolescence and felt gratitude towards was "The Book of Three" by Lloyd Alexander. It actually did get an obscure animated adaptation that sucks, but you can pretend it doesn't exist. Just read the 5 books. They just get better and don't suffer from "too famous to be edited-itis".

You kinda look like a brother of synyster gates. I enjoyed the video but the whole time I couldn't get it out of my head lol

Idc if pop rappers do pop country. If I want authentic country rap I'll listen to JamWayne.

6 mins in he still isn't talking about country