![Scholastic Answers](/img/default-banner.jpg)
- 980
- 1 560 228
Scholastic Answers
United States
Приєднався 29 кві 2021
An apostolate run by Christian B. Wagner seeking to defend the glorious Catholic Faith using the Scholastic method.
To learn more about using the Scholastic method to defend the faith: www.christianbwagner.com/post/what-online-catholic-apologists-are-missing
Follow me on Twitter or instagram: @MilitantThomist
To learn more about using the Scholastic method to defend the faith: www.christianbwagner.com/post/what-online-catholic-apologists-are-missing
Follow me on Twitter or instagram: @MilitantThomist
Catholicism: IRREFUTABLE Proof
Contents:
00:00 - Intro
01:15 - Scholastic Section
02:12 - Dogmatic Section
03:12 - What is a Magisterium?
04:35 - Motives of Credibility
05:55 - Ends and Means
06:46 - Physical and Moral Necessity
08:09 - No Magisterium is physically possible
09:14 - Protestant Objection
10:35 - Things that are Epic
11:32 - The Necessity of the Magisterium
13:12 - Threefold Conditions
15:15 - The Necessity of a King
18:45 - Three Offices
19:50 - Messengers need help
23:50 - The Problem with Most Apologists, Infallibility
28:10 - Three Messages
32:40 - Biblical Proof
50:10 - Outro
#ScholasticAnswers #Catholic #Magisterium
00:00 - Intro
01:15 - Scholastic Section
02:12 - Dogmatic Section
03:12 - What is a Magisterium?
04:35 - Motives of Credibility
05:55 - Ends and Means
06:46 - Physical and Moral Necessity
08:09 - No Magisterium is physically possible
09:14 - Protestant Objection
10:35 - Things that are Epic
11:32 - The Necessity of the Magisterium
13:12 - Threefold Conditions
15:15 - The Necessity of a King
18:45 - Three Offices
19:50 - Messengers need help
23:50 - The Problem with Most Apologists, Infallibility
28:10 - Three Messages
32:40 - Biblical Proof
50:10 - Outro
#ScholasticAnswers #Catholic #Magisterium
Переглядів: 7 873
Відео
James White LOST Against a Catholic
Переглядів 24 тис.14 днів тому
This is the second half of my review of James White's debate with Alex from Voice of Reason. In the first half, I gave my thoughts on Alex's arguments, now I will review James White's arguments. White did a terrible job. If you would like to see the whole stream, go to patreon.com/militantthomist or become a member of the channel. I hope you enjoy.
This BIBLE Canon Position is INSANE
Переглядів 2,7 тис.21 день тому
This BIBLE Canon Position is INSANE
Eastern Orthodox Apologists DEBUNKED Themselves…
Переглядів 13 тис.28 днів тому
Eastern Orthodox Apologists DEBUNKED Themselves…
William Lane Craig is NOT a Molinist
Переглядів 4,7 тис.Місяць тому
William Lane Craig is NOT a Molinist
NEVER Dissent (Popesplainers are WRONG)
Переглядів 9 тис.Місяць тому
NEVER Dissent (Popesplainers are WRONG)
How the Eastern Orthodox REWROTE Trinitarian Dogma
Переглядів 7 тис.Місяць тому
How the Eastern Orthodox REWROTE Trinitarian Dogma
Thomistic View of Papal Deposition and Heresy
Переглядів 3 тис.Місяць тому
Thomistic View of Papal Deposition and Heresy
Every MODERN CATHOLIC Got this WRONG.
Переглядів 5 тис.2 місяці тому
Every MODERN CATHOLIC Got this WRONG.
This VIRAL Video is EVIL and DANGEROUS.
Переглядів 6 тис.2 місяці тому
This VIRAL Video is EVIL and DANGEROUS.
The West did NOT Err on Infant Communion
Переглядів 4,4 тис.2 місяці тому
The West did NOT Err on Infant Communion
If Predestination TERRIFIES You...
Переглядів 2,9 тис.2 місяці тому
If Predestination TERRIFIES You...
Pope Francis OBLITERATES Female Deacons
Переглядів 33 тис.2 місяці тому
Pope Francis OBLITERATES Female Deacons
Protestants: YOU MUST GOON, YOU MUST HAVE SEX, PRIESTS MUST HAVE SEX, MARY CANNOT BE CONTINENT. Some Protestant is eventually going to say something really disgusting about Christ 🤢🤢
Thank God for Bishop Williamson 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
The most natural reading of scriptures is that Jesus was the firstborn of Mary and that she had other children later. There is no reason to think that such would not be the case. Other suggestions came much later, long after the apostles and the apostolic fathers had passed. It is to the Lord Jesus that we look for all things pertaining to salvation and in him do we trust. Glory to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit, now and forever, amen.
The most natural reading of scripture is that she was an everlasting virgin.
James white will die but cant destroy the catholic church that Jesus founded....just like Luther.
Our Lady is Semper Virgo!
Sorry what's gooning? 😂😂
Did Wagner discuss about Revelation 12?
This debate was just confusing. The topic of this debate was: "The Bible Teaches Catholic Authority, not Sola Scriptura." Voice of Reason have to proof this point. Instead, Voice of Reason started and Dr. White most of the time had to defend Sola Scriptura. If the Bible really confirms Roman authority, why are the Church Fathers, councils or other secondary topics constantly being discussed? The discussion has simply missed the point. It is simply embarrassing how rome fanboys get excited about this discussion as if the whole of Protestantism has been argued to the ground on the basis of Scripture. The Bible provides enough evidence that Rome is not a church in the sense of God's word. Let's just take the “sinlessness of Mary.” Let's take a look at what the Bible actually says: In his letter to the Romans, Paul clearly states that no man is righteous. In Romans 3:10-12 (ESV) he writes: “As it is written: 'None is righteous, no, not one; no one understands; no one seeks for God. All have turned aside; together they have become worthless; no one does good, not even one.” These words make it unmistakably clear that all people are sinful, without exception. This also includes Mary, who, according to Catholic dogma, is supposed to have been spared from original sin. However, this dogma is in direct contradiction to Holy Scripture, which emphasizes that no human being, including Mary, is without sin. Paul goes even further in Romans 3:23 (ESV) and says: “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” Here, too, it is emphasized that all have sinned. When Paul speaks of “all”, there are no exceptions - not even for Mary. The idea that Mary was without sin directly contradicts this fundamental biblical teaching. Paul continues in Romans 5:12 (ESV): “Therefore, just as sin came into the world through one man, and death through sin, and so death spread to all men because all sinned-”. This statement emphasizes that sin came into the world through Adam and that all men, without exception, are affected by it. The dogma that regards Mary as “perfectly righteous” and without original sin contradicts this universal principle of sinfulness as set out in the Bible. After all, Jesus himself affirms in Mark 10:18 (ESV): “And Jesus said to him, 'Why do you call me good? No one is good except God alone.” Here Jesus emphasizes the fundamental truth that only God is good. The rich young man has tried to testify to his own righteousness and goodness and Jesus makes clear the distinction between the perfect goodness of God and the fallen nature of man. This alone proves that no one, not even Mary, can be considered “always pure” and “righteous”. The Roman Catholic veneration of Mary as sinless thus contradicts the clear teachings of Jesus.
Any hatred of Our Blessed Lady is a sign of reprobation as Saint Louis De Montfort said. Pray the rosary and fast for Mike Winger.
Here to remind, “NO GOONING”
Stream starts at 0:00. That's right, the intro is mandatory.
One does not simply skip the Song of Kings
I'm surprised that Mike does not account the historical and geographic reality of Jesus' time. The intimacy and closeness of cousins and distant relatives in Middle Eastern communities is so common even to this day. When he tried to make "isn't that Jesus' mother and cousins" sound obscure, he doesn't seem to realise that a person with Semitic roots will have no issue with such statement.
I like to take the stance that St Joseph was young and made a vow of Virginity as well. I remember reading once I think in Numbers 30 that a woman is allowed to keep her virginity even when Married to her husband, but the husband is allowed to break the Vow if he wishes, and God will forgive the woman. I always think about Joseph being described as a "just" man in the bible. A just man would be devoted to God, and I would think that a just man would also allow his wife to keep her vow of Virginity with God. Another reason why I take that stance is that I can't imagine that a 70 year old man would be able to travel from Nazareth > Bethlehem > Egypt by foot and would have to defend his Wife and Son from robbers and Idol worshippers in Egypt.
I think the rule was that if a husband doesn't immediatly strike down and reject a vow of virginity when he sees or hears it made by his wife, then the vow is valid and the husband can't anull it. Fathers could also do this if the girl makes it before marriage, so it seems either Mary's parents allowed it or Joseph had no problem with it, or maybe both
*I remember reading once I think in Numbers 30 that a woman is allowed to keep her virginity even when Married to her husband, but the husband is allowed to break the Vow if he wishes, and God will forgive the woman.* Yes, and Joseph was a good man and considerate of Mary's wishes when He thought of divorcing her, but the Angel reminded him it wasn't necessary and encouraged him to stay married, and Joseph did.
Husband: "I would like to stay chaste", Wife: "me too", Mike WInger: "isnt there someone you forgot to ask??"
Mike Winger: YOU MUST GOON, YOU MUST HAVE SEX
I can handle someone that's clueless. And I can handle someone that's smug. I find someone that's both clueless and smug to be pretty unbearable. But when that ignorant smugness is then used to blaspheme the Theotokos, that's when my blood boils.
You should have “Wacky Winger Wednesday”.
God hardened the heart of Pharaoh as part of His plan to lead the Jews out of bondage to Egypt. Pharaoh saw the miracles, saw his own magicians fail, and only became more obstinate. After seeing James White continuing to remain totally unmoved in his opposition to Catholicism (and his ever-growing capacity to act like a jackwagon in debates), and going in circles for 30+ years with the exact same talking points… I almost imagine that God is hardening the heart of White to lead protestants out of bondage to error and into the Church. He’s just so bad, and yet he never learns his lesson to stop agreeing to public debates, there’s no other explanation than Providence at this point.
Missed the Stream :(
Winger is a sad heretic🤡. With that said an argument I never hear is the following. If the Blessed Mother would have given birth to other children why aren't the alleged siblings of Jesus called the children of Mary, the Gospel clearly says Jesus is the son of Mary. Second, in Luke 2 we have the only account of Jesus as a Teen, and notice how when he was 12 years old him and his parents went to the Passover feast, yet there is no mention of siblings, "41 Every year Jesus’ parents went to Jerusalem for the Festival of the Passover. 42 When he was twelve years old, they went up to the festival, according to the custom. 43 After the festival was over, while his parents were returning home, the boy Jesus stayed behind in Jerusalem, but they were unaware of it." If the Blessed Mother had other children would they have traveled with them to Passover? Did she waited 12 years or more to have other children? "44 Thinking he was in their company, they traveled on for a day. Then they began looking for him among their relatives and friends." Relatives and friends but no mention of other children of Mary. I challenge all Prots to tell me where were all the alleged siblings of Jesus in the account of Luke 2. I'm all ears, also please point out where does the gospel say that Mary bore other children . I'm all ears.
The bigger question is why the actual heck believing Mary slept with someone is a heresy.
@@clay8546 do you understand what heresy is?
@@sonsofpolaris6102 heresy in Catholicism is a rejection of a orthodox doctrine, and more importantly a sin. You believe someone is actually commuting a sin by thinking Mary has some action lol.
@@clay8546 do you understand what blaspheming is?
@@sonsofpolaris6102 it’s showing disrespect to something holy. Which ties into Catholics super weird view of sex. Somehow a women having sex with her husband is dirty and corrupting It’s just so freaking bizarre. Its ok if a woman has sex with her husband, it’s actually a good thing. It’s not disrespecting her
Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich saw in her visions that Our Lady did have an older sister who was called Mary, and there’s a medieval tradition that St Anne had three daughters, all of which were named Mary
Excellent work on the video. The effort and thoughtfulness is impressive and obvious. However, I a moving more towards orthodoxy away from Rome as the dependence on the charism seems more a substitute for Faith than a convincing argument. Christ gave us the priesthood and the bishops lead the faith but the Holy Spirit guides and inspires that church. In modern times, it is a readable idea that one man can run the faith but to those before the internet age the idea that you couldn’t rely on your jurisdiction for orthodoxy and that the Holy Spirit was confined to Rome is far more ridiculous and far fetched than the idea that God couldn’t guide the faithful and protect his Church without an earthly king. The presumption you work on is that God can only reveal truth through a single man but that smacks special pleading and a lack of faith. Also, the innovation of doctrine and the papal negligence in child chrismation and communion are absolute proof from my perspective that he is not solely infallible. The first see, yes, but that does not excuse the disaster that ultimate power has brought. The Protestant reformation is a direct result of the supremacy of the papacy and it’s because of the convenience of ex cathedra which is an unmitigated disaster. The apostolic church that has changed how they pray, changed what they believe and changed what they practice has unshockingly descended into absolute chaos with thousands of heretical or schismatic splinter groups. Also, there is no evidence or examples in the first millennia that even remotely justify the power grab of Vatican 1. Plus, look at the fruits of the west vs the east since the schism. The west was more successful in both spreading the faith and scattering it to the wind.
Mike Whinger
Yeah, cause no1 from africa or the Mediterranean ever called their close relatives brother. Its just unheard of cause some guy 2000 years later adopts a strict english reading. He is using his white privlage again.
It's also disingenuous in the current societal norms to act as though close friends don't call each other "brother," or those sort of things would never be recorded in scripture to show the close relationship between the two men. Strict literal reading for the sake of annulling context is just as good as lying, because it's deliberately misunderstanding the point in an effort to undermine it.
Never goon
The “brothers” argument is really bad. Protestants will say “the plain meaning is brothers” but that’s the problem. They are forgetting that the Bible is not in plain English.
I have discovered over my lifetime that what I thought originally was dogma is now logical when understood from a Divine perspective.
Mike Winger can syngenes balls
You’re the next Michael lofton I pray you get 100k
Is that an insult?
How will he ever recover?
Gooners always taking L's
what is the chant in the begining before the stream?
Song of Kings - Clamavi de Profundis
Song of Kings by Clamavi de Profundis. They are a family of singers with a healthy mix of sacred music and epic fantasy and Tolkien-inspired stuff. And they're Catholic.
@@Nate-ri5lzthe trinity of Christ-pilled goodness 😊
Misunderstandings id say, we need to bury the hatchet with this girl. Set things right. see, she took it the wrong way. so we gotta be even more charitable, benefit of the doubt amiright? help each other if we can, pray for each other if we can’t . You guys with me?
Mike winger helped me leave the Jehovah's witnesses behind, but he did not help me overcome my sexual perversions. Only our Lady helped me with that. Total Catholic victory over my soul.
God bless you
Beautiful testimony! I presume it was praying the rosary that did that, wasn't it?
The 5 blasphemies against the Immaculate Heart of Mary: Blasphemies against the Immaculate Conception. Blasphemies against Her Virginity. Blasphemies against Her Divine Maternity, in refusing at the same time to recognize Her as the Mother of men. The blasphemies of those who publicly seek to sow in the hearts of children indifference or scorn, or even hatred of this Immaculate Mother. The offenses of those who outrage Her directly in Her Holy Images.
I feel like someone would have to be influenced by demons in order to say these things.
This is your brain on gooner:
*it’s spelled ‘yuor’
Let’s pray and fast for Mike Winger’s conversion.
Based and fasting-pilled
Blessed and christ-pilled
Happy feast day of saint bernard
Mike Wigner more like Gay blasphemer
Gooner mike can't stop taking Ls
The Blessed Ever Virgin will be vindicated and the calumniators will be silenced!
Total Mike Gooner Destruction
Billions must be chaste
Wagner said to comment, thus i will comment, for that which Wagner says, we do, Wagner said to comment, therefore we comment.
3 hours runtime and the Spanish Crusader Kings are not mentioned. Dissapointment 😢
God bless Bishop Williamson. If there were only more like him.
God so loved the world. Not condemning it.
Traditions are stuck in the past glory of the church. Ichabod is written, and they have no vision to the changing times of the world.only social issues and the internet .
Alex goes to my parish! What a blessing to us all.
Your argument for the papacy from the REINSTATEMENT of Peter is just a bad argument. Peter denied Jesus three times, Jesus asked him three times. This is clearly referencing that fact.
funniest pwoplw i enjoy watching
I love your intro