Відео

While I don't hear any of the false notes that you're referring to, I think that the biggest difference of the singing between the movie and the musical is the style. In the musical the singing is more operatic, there is a much bigger focus on projection and - how I hear it - the use of vibrato. In the movie on the other hand, the style is - how I would describe it - more pop sounding. Much less vibrato, a different choice of how to pronounce the vowels. They could use a prerecording and adjust volume of both voice and music in the after production. (That is not to say that they don't use any technical stuff in the musical too, the actors are wearing mics and the title song is prerecorded.) Having seen the movie first, it will always be my favourite. But while the style is different, the musical is lovely and there are some amazing actors/singers out there whose performances have made it to my playlists.

I used to think this. I saw the movie first and always preferred the singers/actors in that. Since seeing the show a few times and being able to play the role of Christine myself, it’s all about perspective - voices, facial expressions, movement needs to be so much bigger onstage to make sure that every audience member can see/hear you. This isn’t the case in a movie. Everything onstage has to be a bigger projection. Though I totally get your preference, these performers are just projecting ☺️ if you listen to Amy Manford sing in front of a camera, it’s a lot more like the style you prefer. She has an outstanding tone to her voice, very emotional and personal 👏🏼

Because they’re actually singers?

That’s just more operatic… which is more expressive

I’m leaving phantom of the opera concert At my house on the first of October I’m a fully trained natural high soprano

She has a sweeter,m less mature note to her voice than Sierra (they're both outstanding!) but I think it lends Amy her own take/interpretation and spin on Christine that's totally separate from Sierra's.

@@blissinchains Totally agree, I don't think she sounds much like Sierra at all - Amy sounds more youthful and vulnerable.

Gigi Parker literally no

In which nobody can sing? I suppose when hearing actual talent, it must seem on a different level.

Of course no. The original Show is better with live singing.

Like everything does beat the movie lol

Maybe is they had used Ben Lewis it would have been except able

epins 84 Amy’s my favourite Christine and sierra’s my second favourite so I guess you could say I have a type sbskdbdkdb

Silver54ful I think Ben Lewis is a heldentenor. He's really loud.

TheMsiaddict- Ben Lewis has proclaimed he is a baritone. You think that he mis-classified his own voice? Not to say it has never happened before. Broadway star Kelli O'Hara once cited herself as a Coloratura soprano. When a fan asked her at the stage door of one of her shows about being closer to a Lyric soprano. Ms.O'Hara started analyzing her own voice. She later admitted her voice had in fact developed from a Coloratura (what is was in her university years) to a Full Lyric.

Silver54ful He sings the high version chorus, but interestingly he chose low "angel" in the end. His voice is like Lauritz Melchior's. Melchior started as a baritone too. The less known performer that has similar voice is Matt Cammelle. His brother, Alexander Lewis was a lyric baritone, now he's a lyric tenor. Ben himself said that there's no danger that his voice would be changed like his brother's.