Відео

One bitter experience is the layoffs when many state owned companies privatized.

YES HOPEFULLY SO

Comparing with China - India.Yes India ahead of China by growth of population .India gives much importance to developing army rather overall development. Try hard never catch China,sorry. Way behind India unfortunately in reality

Professor R Ramakumar is the hero of this show. Perhaps Ambassador Mabubani may need to do more homework to say more than “open more open more”

How would India be stronger than China. Don't fool yourself. Modi visited the White House and was brainwashed easily. When America suck you, that will be the end of India. Pls regulate the human rights issues in your country. You're very racists.

in ur dreams kishore.

with a large number of low i.q. idiots like the sabzi and fruits wala in my street its really impossible for india to surpass china 😁😁😂😂😂

whether india ever becomes stronger than china or not is not the main point. the main point is as long as our white masters shower heaps of fake praises on us we are on cloud nine. rest is seconday. what greater glory than times magazine, new york times, washington post giving fake praises to us. what greater glory than any u.s. president says india is better. that's all we need 😂😂😂😂😂

Vietnam, Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan and some of Asean Country including Singapore altogether are a greater picture of the Confucius Culture Circle. They share the same working culture which is hardworking, consistent, precise, obey (etc: the rules and regulations of the companies). etc The essence of their success is actually the 5000 years culture.

What I want to ask is how can India not cooperate with or even become hostile to China, the second largest (and perhaps the largest soon) economy while opening up to the world?

Chinese here. Any country has the potential to achieve drastic change in 30 yrs.

Yes. Keep talking and discussing why India can overtake China. Talk and more talk..........

competition is and is not the key to development. What's more important is that the government should invest more in R&D of key sectors and that's what china did in the last four decades. Without the protection and support of government, it's amlsot impossible for a nation to have its own core competitiveness. Competion is just like exercise which can bring you improvement. But if you just go to the battlefield without proper preparation, it's suicide.

As soon as India's GDP reaches 60% USA GDP,it will start containing India through legal and illegal means.

India greatst obstacle is not china . if india have to find some one to over take then germany or janpan would be next closer ( you have to over take no.3 before no.2) . But think about it careful is india's greatest enemy is itself ? is it better to become more hygienic and every house have toilet and no rapist and less corruption more import than over taking germany japan china usa ? is it a necessary step to acheive before it over take other naturally if you can do better in these area ? One more thing . Have you heard china challeneging Jpan and german or USA before china reach today or you think china would be better if USA + japan start to block china 20 yrs ago ? or did china try to work and learn from them even when USA japan try to block china ?

I have been following Prof Kishore Mahbubani's video on UA-cam for a number of years, and have great respect for his views and deep insight of today's geopolitical situation. But I have to disagree with him on 2 points he brought up in this particular forum : 1) the high income levels of Indian ethnic in US. I don't have actual statistics but from what I can gather, many of those Indians in US are professionals, working as doctors, lawyers, IT professionals, CEOs of some of the biggest American companies. Hence their income levels are high compared with others. So it's not a very fair or realistic comparison. 2) India will be the biggest economy in the world. I am not saying it's impossible. The potential is there but the way Prof Mahbubani put it, it is as if India grow while others remain stagnant. I agree that India will grow, per capital income will grow, but China which has about the same population will also grow further. So unless some major disruption happened in or to China, it's quite difficult to overtake China. I saw the reports from Standard Chartered Bank, and I tend to agree that India may overtake US, probably by 2050, to become the 2nd biggest economy. But to overtake China is another different story all together. In a way, I tend to agree with Prof R Rama Kumar's view that in this forum, some of Prof Mahbubani's views are too over simplified.

India is a democracy.

I concur strongly with Prof. Kishore that Indian media are "atrocious" and antagonist towards. By beating up Indian sentiments against China is doing a great disservice in mending relations between India and China. But this scenario has in part caused by adversarial stance of the Indian government towards China. The Indian government is always taking China as a challenge, rather than an opportunity for economic collaboration and development. Look at draconian measures taken the Indian government towards Chinese apps and enterprises like the recent checks on Realme and Oppo and you will know how anti-China it is.

To say tht India's economy will be more powerful than that of China is more or less a wishful thought. To catch up with China economically, India needs major changes, if not overhauls, to its social, political, bureaucratic, governance and education systems. But to do so is a mammoth task for the Indian government considering its social and cultural fabrics, and historical and economical backgrounds.

yes. will it? no. not in your life time.

"If Indians cannot get rid of their inherent thinking mode, they will lose development opportunities." - - - Singapore Founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew India’s historical path to independence from colonial rule is very different from China’s realization of national independence and liberation through revolution. After independence, India did not have a decolonization education, India has not made real social changes either. on the contrary, it almost inherited the legacy left by the colonists. . At the same time, India is a country where politics and religion are integrated, but religion is ubiquitous to influence all aspects of India, and it has brought reform and development resistance to India's modernization process. India’s own biggest problem is the lack of a truly strategic leader. The Modi government has now been kidnapped by Indian nationalism. In order to consolidate its dominant position, the Bharatiya Janata Party government will rely more on nationalist tools. In this case, the religious and ethnic conflicts in India will only become more intense.Similar to India’s own religious contradictions, caste system, etc. are structural problems faced by India. If India does not carry out a radical social change from the top down, India's development path will be full of twists and turns and difficulties.

It is useless to convince India to do something good for itself because India is smart and it has its own ideas.

Kishore Mahubani is so well informed and has the ability to talk about Asia as easily as the West

Brilliant Dr Ramkumar. Very well articulated and zeroed in on what ails India

Indian and China are English names. If THEN Great Britain called India, China, and Called China, India. Then Indian already was 6 times stronger than China.

Waste of time, stop trying to compare to China and make your own unque advancement. India doesn't need to be better than China in anyway.

The rise of India should be welcomed, just as the rise of other Asian, African, Middle Eastern, Latin American and other developing nations. For India, the leaders and people should be more rational and objective. A good dose of humility is also very good as it motivates you to do better. The problem with India is that they can be manipulated using emotions and hubris. They are currently feted with nice flattering words of being an incipient or neglected superpower etc but the fundanmentals are still weak. Look critically at your history of how India was colonized by the British through divide and rule. Each rajahs or sultans was used against each other because of greed, pride and vanity.

Nutrition is important to performance. India is religiously protecting its protein instead of consuming it. I don't know how much the economy can progress with a religious burden. The little milk man has limited byproducts.

Yes, probably about 50 years.

Kishore, you are a brilliant Indian Patriot, Singaporean Patriot and Global Citizen. I want to thank you for all the insights I learned from You. I wish the world leaders would listen more to your wisdom. Then we will have a better world for everyone.

One thing what I came to know from what Kishore mahbubani is trying to say in this video is, Indian's are indeed still not mature enough to deal with rest of the nations.

Well said. Land refrom, education, health and creation of large infrastructure laid a concrete foundation for development success. None of them was an easy job for both gov. or normal ppl.

I am Chinese, but I would like the Indians, and Africans, and people from all developing countries to catch up with China and the western countries, and everyone in this world should live a good life equally! It is not fair only the western people live a much better life than other people in the world!

Indians are too obsessed and perhaps jealous of China’s success. India has a lot of potential but most of talented Indians decide to leave India and migrate to other countries for good. That’s a pity. Indian government needs to do something to bring back these talents from overseas.

Please kishore be honest don't hype up India when there is nothing to be proud of

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

The only argument I would make to the lecture is SEA is heavily populated by Han Chinese, Singapore being the main one. The success is due to the culture and the mindset that comes with dealing in business.

It was excellent and highly informative sir

Very informative 👌🙏

Very informative talk by Dr.Basu 🥰🥰❤

India to number one economy must get rid of caste system land reform fight poverty when religion govern the people trouble start

India can become stronger in Bollywood movies.

Absolutely can - in an alternate universe.

Only if India eliminate corruptions permanently. China execute corruptors and India should do so.

Are you stupid? India has administered 25 Million covid vaccine doses in a single day. This means India already been a super strongest power in the world.India No.1.

Paid Chinese agents

I sincerely hope India can overcome its setbacks and join China in its economic race.

Bullshit, PM Gandhis in India history were assasinated bcos West Asian leaders were among the world worst corrupted dictators. SG is successful bcos its East Asia dominated by Chinese leaders entrepreneurs. But Singtel is Sg underperformer due to these crooked Idiots

Do Western Powers really wish to assist India growing into a new super power even stronger than China on the global platform? What share of the pie would be left for them then? One thing I am sure, when India and Japan come into a war with China, their media will support India and Japan, the longer the war goes on, the stronger their support would be.

Indian pride... cannot be denied. Embrace the China Belt and Road initiative and we are on our way!