Відео

Браво🎉🎉🎉🎉

beautiful song... I haven't digged into Roger's solo work...but I just found out I should have done so...

Humanity feels the pain of the Palestinians

Respect Roger for consistent opposing war. Can we at least start there - we want peace? Without been called an anti-semite or some other bullshit

i watched this concert sitting next to someone i was madly in love with, that was the first time we held hands, to the sound of the second part of this song. That was one of the happiest moments of my life, everything felt like a movie. I'm not someone who cries often, but when I felt her fingers circling around my arm and her head resting on my shoulder, I couldn't help but shed a tear. Our love didn't last long, we both made mistakes and learned from them. This is the first time i hear this since she left, and I realize that even though I dated girls before and after we dated, I've never loved anyone as much as I loved her.

Zo mooi gezongen🙂👍

Quel merveilleux artiste si humaniste il fait du bien dans ce monde de brutes

Tremendo!!! El mejor tema del album y hasta ahora la mejor version en vivo

It is horrifying to see that a person of such influence on eager young minds as roger waters has become such a hate-filled anti-Semite, intoxicated by the fallacious and arrogant notion of his own staggering expertise, pseudo-nobility and relevance in an arena where his lack of knowledge is truly embarrassing and his assumptions are so vividly defective. waters clearly delights in holding to, embellishing upon and passionately contaminating the minds of any who are sufficiently naïve and gullible to give him an ear (especially his young fans, who, in their trusting, youthful exuberance exalt him as a genuine champion of the oppressed and voice of enlightenment) with his unsubstantiated falsifications, anti-Semitic images and scandalous fabrications against Israel and the Jewish people. Regardless of waters’ own white, Anglo-Saxon, birth and ancestral origins being firmly and safely nestled away in the distant and altogether quite unrelated rural setting of southern England, waters nonetheless orates ‘commandingly’ and with well-rehearsed persuasive passion about Middle East matters in general and Israel in particular with such a forceful and brazen pretence of ‘experiential authority’, that if you didn’t know better, you might consider that waters must either have been a true-born native of the Middle East, or that he has been somehow supernaturally endowed with a divine-like revelation granting him and him alone full and unique access to exclusive, secret, restricted and privileged insights into ‘facts-on-the-ground’ in a global region for which his understanding is horribly lacking. waters appears to believe that his uniquely acquired mystical foresight, bolstered by his past history of sundry musical exploits entitles his gratuitous ‘hate-fest’ to be inviolate and above reproach, which, in ‘waters’-world’ offsets his own spectacular irrelevance and ignorance, and further establishes that in his ‘elevated state’, the universe must have also endowed him with… 01. His life’s highest purpose - demonising, delegitimising and applying double-standards to the Jewish State. Falsely portraying Israel as an unrelentingly malevolent colonialist invader and perpetrator of murder, apartheid, repression, injustice and tyranny, whilst categorising all Arabic people in general and ‘palestinians’ in particular in and around Israel as the innocent, misunderstood, mild-mannered, defenceless and down-trodden, remnants of the ancient and once proud, original natives of the Jewish homeland. 02. Flawlessly deep personal insight into all Jewish, Arab, Israeli and Middle Eastern issues and dynamics, which, being a boy from rural Cambridgeshire is, in and of itself quite miraculous. 03. The ‘moral’ obligation as a self-styled ‘champion-of-the-oppressed’ to sermonise his perverted ‘gospel’ of groundless anti-Semitic hatred with unqualified impunity as he alone sees fit, deliberately disregarding the complete absence of evidence for any and/or all of his ridiculous claims. After all, for roger waters, why should THE TRUTH ever be permitted to spoil such a good story!!! * The Romans and the origin of the word ‘palestine’… ‘Palestine’, (or ‘Syria Palaestina’) was invented as a purely geographical term, by the Romans in the mid-late first century c.e... From 66c.e. until 73c.e., the Jewish people rebelled against the brutality of the Roman empire in their homeland and eventually managed to overwhelm and expel the entire Roman army from Jerusalem. Upon hearing of such a humiliating military defeat by a humble assembly of tribal shepherds, emperor Nero dispatched Vespasian to crush the Jewish rebellion, for having caused the Roman army to flee for their lives. On 29th August 70c.e., The Romans, under Vespasian prevailed, Jerusalem fell, the 2nd Temple was defiled and burned, and even though an ethnically Jewish presence continued to be maintained throughout the land from that time until today, Israel, as the sovereign Jewish State was finally overwhelmed by the Roman army. Following the sacking of Jerusalem, the Romans now set out to expel as many Jews from the area as they could and then re-name the Jewish homeland after Israel’s long-time arch-enemy, the ‘Philistines’ (‘Plishtim’ in Hebrew). By this two-pronged device, the Romans had hoped to eradicate all evidence that the Jewish people had ever even existed at all, and this re-naming by the Romans is the origin of the geographical term ‘palestine’. * The Philistines… Amongst the most widely held scholarly opinions regarding the origins of the Philistines, NONE holds to the belief that the Philistines were a Semitic people. All Arabic people, (who, like the Jewish people ARE all Semitic in origin) are automatically, therefore disqualified from claiming to be the offspring of these Mediterranean, sea-faring pirates and warriors. Even if we were to turn a blind eye to the non-Semitic origin problem, there is another huge problem… The Philistines were eventually conquered by the Babylonian King Nebuchadnezzer towards the end of the 7th century b.c.e., and by the 5th century b.c.e., the Philistines as a distinct and ethnically recognisable people group had entirely and vanished forever from history by assimilation. * The modern re-invention of the ‘palestinian people’… waters persists in being intentionally deaf and blind in the face of all inconveniently opposing historical facts, which are continually reinforced by the ever-growing archaeological mountain of indisputable, quantifiable and tangible proof of the continual Jewish presence in Israel for almost 4,000 years and the equivalently embarrassing absence of any evidence of a ‘palestinian people’. Even if we were to pretend that the vast array of compelling archaeological facts in evidence in the Middle East didn’t even exist, the awkwardly remaining requirements to verify the historical existence of an exclusively identifiable ethnic people group, the ‘palestinian people’ would need to, at the very least, present evidence to the world that they possess the required unique DNA markers, which would authenticate them as an entirely distinctive genetic category, separating them from all other Arabic or other Middle-Eastern peoples throughout the region as unique. No such DNA markers have been, are now, or are ever likely to be in evidence! * arafat, The Arab League and the former U.S.S.R… water’s ‘history’ of the so-called ‘palestinian people’, or ‘palestinians’ was, in his context completely unheard of until suddenly appearing one day in the mid-1960s, from a political strategy presented to the world for the first time by yet another history revisionist (and in this case also a murdering serial-terrorist) named yasser arafat. It was arafat, in conjunction with the Arab League and the former U.S.S.R., who in 1964, originally started a political group entitled the ‘palestinian liberation organisation’, or more widely known as the ‘plo’. The Egyptian born (non-‘palestinian’) arafat, as leader of ‘fatah’, subsequently invented (and included himself and his cronies in) the imaginary ‘palestinian people’ in 1967, along with their instantaneous, retro-actively applied, ‘proud-and-ancient-historic-owners-of-and-connection-to’ the land of Israel - but this, though germane, is yet one more discussion for another time. * waters - In conclusion… Baseless hatred, pseudo-intellectualism, racial vilification, history revisionism, bigotry, an inflated, arrogant belief in his own (clearly lacking) relevance and significance together with an obdurate litany of disinformation and falsifications of daily life in Israel have all fermented together at the core of waters’ repulsively depraved catalogue of indoctrination and plain, old fashioned ‘Jew-hatred’. It’s sickening to consider that waters’ growing malignant ugliness seeped into such a wonderful band as Pink Floyd - although, thankfully they seem to be going really well without him these days!!!

It sounded great with Ben singing with David during the verses

One of his best renditions from the tour. So glad I went!

Isn't it Broken Bones?

I can only imagine peak-voice Roger singing this. Wow, thatd be a doozy to hear.

And what a fucking solo !

Is he going to do a new album?

Funny. roger quotes Dylan in this song - the guy whom waters would gladly have killed by muslims.

I see the pain on his

Hühnerfell am ganzen Körper wenn ich das Meisterstück von RW höre!

I know who my brothers and sisters are, they are thouse who are crying listening to this masterpiece

Desde los 12 años sos mi terapia,hoy a mis 59 te amo más.

Masterpiece of Love ❤ thank you Roger...only you 😍

❤❤

È bella e somiglia ad altre sue canzoni...ma va bene o stesso!!!

This song was touching my soul watching it live. Roger is imo the best song writer and composer of our time

VERY BORING 🥱 A tuneless DIRGE that comes somewhere between Dylan and Cohen…Switch off and listen to another artist who is more interesting than this…you know it makes sense

Now this is Pink Floyd I love so much. I couldn't cry since I was 17 and I'm 44 now but this songs brings me as close to it as possible. You are unique and amazing person artist musician and poet Roger.

Shades of John Prine

needs to be louder ,volumes way too low ,amazing song

Prachtig kippenvel

yes this is fantastic good job 🙂

This is The bar

Maudlin tripe.

👂💯1️⃣🇦🇺❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💯👁❗️

The best song of last tweenty years....❤ So sad that so few lesting it...song with the soul...

life B4 the cops, is roger taking the piss out of big brother❣

Мощный Старик!

Sounds almost identical to Southampton Dock. “And still the dark stain spreads between their shoulder blades A mute reminder of the poppy fields and graves When the fight was over they spent what they had made But in the bottom of their hearts they felt the Final Cut. “

When he said “would you kindly get the fuck of my land” God said amen

Great lyrics. It is just more proof that Roger was the soul of Pink Floyd. He is authentic and genuine. The years have really separated the wheat from the chaff. Most of my idols proved to be cardboard cut-outs, fakes, and sell outs. Roger never lost his beautiful soul. A man on a mission. The muses are with him still. He's THE REAL DEAL.

I love his slight nod of appreciation at the beginning. I’m not sure, but it’s like he’s telling himself that he chose the correct note in the progression

This is one of the most beautiful songs i have ever heard🙂👍

"You are my sad-eyed lady Come lay across my big brass bed Maybe it is we who have been chosen, you and me To point out this don't make no fuckin' sense How many cannonballs must fly, Bob? How long and winding is the road? How many children pulling on how many mother's sleeves? Saying, "Look Ma, the man ain't got no fucking clothes" This song is pretty powerful ..

ua-cam.com/video/9vmO0YUHiaM/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared

Songwriting at its best. Waters is a modern day Mozart.