Somewhat Scientific
Somewhat Scientific
  • 24
  • 20 297
Machiavelli to Modernity: The Evolution of Power and the State
Today, as we navigate a world of complex institutions, financial power, and technological influence, we are left to question whether we have truly advanced or merely found new, more sophisticated ways to be ruled. Machiavelli’s insights remain as relevant as ever: power is an eternal force, evolving, but never relinquished, always adjusting to new forms, new systems, and new technologies.
If you enjoyed this, please like and subscribe.
Переглядів: 218

Відео

The Cycles of Cultural Revival: Lessons from the Renaissance
Переглядів 55521 годину тому
The Renaissance was a reminder that when societies focus too heavily on collective identity and restrict individual expression, they stifle the very creativity and innovation that drive them forward. The revival of classical values and the emphasis on individualism wasn’t merely a philosophical exercise; it was a cultural necessity that allowed Europe to break free from intellectual stagnation....
Camelot and Myth Making: The Role of Image in Politics
Переглядів 801День тому
Camelot’s enduring appeal as an ideal of just, noble governance reminds us of the allure of myth and the dangers of political fantasy. Political myths can inspire, but they can also distort, shielding leaders from the necessary scrutiny that a functioning democracy demands. If we are to engage in politics meaningfully, we must see our leaders not as mythic heroes but as fallible individuals, su...
The Collapse of Empire and the Rise of Identity Politics
Переглядів 1,6 тис.День тому
Rome’s decline is a sobering reminder of what can happen when internal divisions outweigh the forces that hold a society together. Today, the rise of identity politics presents a new version of this age-old challenge. Will the West find a way to balance diversity with cohesion, or are we witnessing the early stages of fragmentation similar to that which led to the fall of Rome? Only time will t...
Memento Mori: Death in Philosophy, History, and Modern Society
Переглядів 1,6 тис.14 днів тому
What can we take away from historical perspectives on death? Perhaps it’s a reminder that we need to reconsider how we handle mortality, both as individuals and as a culture. Instead of hiding from death or relegating it to the sterile halls of a hospital, we might benefit from integrating it more thoughtfully into our lives. This doesn’t mean glorifying death or obsessing over it; it means ack...
Halloween Folklore and the Power of Storytelling
Переглядів 72014 днів тому
Halloween’s storytelling traditions reveal something fundamental about human nature: our need to make sense of the world through stories. We use Halloween to explore the boundaries of life and death, safety and danger, order and chaos. As long as we continue to grapple with these themes, Halloween’s storytelling will remain a vital part of our cultural fabric. What stories will we tell in the f...
Medieval Feudalism and the Modern Gig Economy
Переглядів 1 тис.14 днів тому
Whilst modern society has evolved in many ways since the medieval period, the structural similarities between feudalism and the gig economy are hard to ignore. Both systems rely on a class of workers who have little power, are subject to the control of a central authority, and lack the rights and protections needed for long-term stability. In both cases, the promise of security or flexibility o...
The Eclipse of Tradition by Commercial Media: The Impact on Culture and Fear in Modern Society
Переглядів 7421 день тому
The shift from communal storytelling to commercial media domination has fundamentally altered the way we engage with the world. Whilst modern technology has made information more accessible than ever before, it has also created a media ecosystem that thrives on fear and sensationalism. The constant exposure to negative news has a significant psychological toll, leaving many feeling anxious and ...
Halloween: Pagan Rituals to Pop Culture Phenomenon
Переглядів 3,5 тис.Місяць тому
Today, Halloween is a global event, celebrated in various forms across the world. From North America to Europe and even parts of Asia, the holiday has spread far beyond its Celtic and Christian roots. At the heart of Halloween’s enduring appeal lies its ability to tap into something deeply human-the desire to confront our fears, explore the unknown, and celebrate life in the face of death. Whil...
Aristotle's Ethics and Today's Moral Dilemmas
Переглядів 874Місяць тому
Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics provides not just a set of moral rules, but a way of thinking about ethics as a practical and lived experience. It calls us to reflect on what kind of people we want to be and what kind of society we wish to create. In the face of today’s most pressing moral dilemmas - whether in the realm of technology, biology, or economics - Aristotle’s pursuit of the virtuous ...
Cicero on Rhetoric and the Art of Persuasion in Modern Life
Переглядів 58Місяць тому
Cicero’s views on rhetoric emphasize the power of language to shape society, whether through political discourse, media, or social platforms. His framework for persuasion offers timeless lessons on the need for a balanced approach to rhetoric - one that values reason, engages emotions responsibly, and builds trust through integrity. In today’s media-saturated world, where the battle for attenti...
Can Democracy Survive the Social Media Era?
Переглядів 32Місяць тому
The survival of democracy in the social media era will depend on our ability to strike a balance between digital innovation and the preservation of rational, informed discourse. Democracy has always been a fragile system, requiring not just participation but thoughtful, deliberate engagement. While social media has the potential to enhance democratic participation, it also carries the risk of e...
The Philosopher King in Modern Leadership
Переглядів 19Місяць тому
Plato's idea of the philosopher king remains a powerful metaphor for the qualities we hope for in leaders: wisdom, virtue, and a commitment to justice. While modern leaders may not fully embody this ideal, the philosopher king’s principles still offer valuable guidance. In a world that demands both moral clarity and pragmatic action, perhaps the time has come to adapt Plato’s vision into a new ...
More Than Our Triumphs: The Lasting Value of Helping Others
Переглядів 20Місяць тому
We may remember our victories, but those that care about us, will never forget our kindness.... today we have my musings on our perception of achievement compared to those around us. I hope you find something interesting in this today. Music by Yurii Kohut from Pixabay
Philosophy of Justice: From Plato’s Republic to Modern Courts
Переглядів 1352 місяці тому
Plato’s Republic offers a vision of justice rooted in the moral order of society and the soul, while modern courts focus on legal frameworks and the protection of individual rights. Both approaches, however, share a common goal: creating a society in which harmony and fairness prevail. As we navigate contemporary debates on justice, reflecting on Plato’s ideas reminds us that justice is not jus...
The Fall of Empires: Lessons from Rome for Modern Superpowers
Переглядів 1002 місяці тому
The Fall of Empires: Lessons from Rome for Modern Superpowers
The Origin of Beer
Переглядів 422 місяці тому
The Origin of Beer
The Scriptoriums and Medieval Monks
Переглядів 847 місяців тому
The Scriptoriums and Medieval Monks
The Mystery of Olmec Writing
Переглядів 4018 місяців тому
The Mystery of Olmec Writing
The Evolution of Chinese Writing
Переглядів 2818 місяців тому
The Evolution of Chinese Writing
The History of Libraries
Переглядів 938 місяців тому
The History of Libraries
The Decipherment of Cuneiform
Переглядів 7 тис.8 місяців тому
The Decipherment of Cuneiform
The Evolution of Writing
Переглядів 5408 місяців тому
The Evolution of Writing
The Development of Silent Reading or Reading in Your Head.
Переглядів 1789 місяців тому
The Development of Silent Reading or Reading in Your Head.

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @atevensnderson5827
    @atevensnderson5827 4 дні тому

    enjoyed! Your voice and pacing is calming, but your background is distracting and busy. I'd recommend cutting up the face time with some relevant historic filler images. Dense subjects need visual stimulation. Also maybe an introduction to channel? Great channel name!

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 4 дні тому

      Thank you for the feedback. I will look into making the area less chaotic.

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 4 дні тому

    As always, thank you for watching. Please, let me know what you think.

  • @KyleMaxwell
    @KyleMaxwell 5 днів тому

    Given that current events involve the power of a group of people who castigate and demonize others for their ethnic identities and explicitly want to go back to a time when things were supposedly "great" in the past, denying the freedom of individuals to be who they truly are, then perhaps you might consider the direction of your disdain.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 5 днів тому

      This was written and recorded prior to a certain foreign election taking place. Your point is both valid and agreed with.

    • @dagon99
      @dagon99 3 дні тому

      Have fun losing.

    • @KyleMaxwell
      @KyleMaxwell 3 дні тому

      @ What’s the alternative here? Should I give up on loving my actual family and neighbors because other people hate them? That would be no kind of love at all.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 2 дні тому

      I couldn't agree more. Some of the responses I've seen posted on X and Reddit have been ridiculous.

  • @LiquidLanyard
    @LiquidLanyard 5 днів тому

    The right to fart in an elevator vs the right to not be stuck I a farty elevator.

  • @Jerbert-qn4in
    @Jerbert-qn4in 5 днів тому

    This channel is cool, i subscribed

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 5 днів тому

      Thanks! I appreciate that. Hopefully you'll also enjoy the upcoming content.

  • @intelligencecube6752
    @intelligencecube6752 5 днів тому

    Yeaahhh, no. A great deal of our understanding of the Middle Ages is a characterization that wasn’t really prevalent until much later in time. Medieval Europe underwent an extensive period of growth in the economy and societal norms that was unprecedented in the region. A great deal of what we think of when we say “Medieval Europe” is frankly not found in western half of the continent, although the absolutism and more rigid social structures were prevalent in Eastern Europe and especially the Russian States that developed after the Mongol invasions. The church was the only thing that kept literacy up to any standard at all in Europe after the fall of Rome, and was as well as still is a major funder of scientific endeavors in the world. It was not a particularly ossified societal structure! Although it worked differently depending on where you were, the majority of Medieval European Peasants could see substantial growth in status, sometimes becoming Ennobled. It worked the other way too, Noble families falling out of favor and becoming townsmen or merchants, sometimes falling farther depending on circumstances. Medieval Europe was not what we think it to be, a lot of what we attribute to the time period either didn’t exist there yet, or existed much later in the Early Modern Period.

    • @intelligencecube6752
      @intelligencecube6752 5 днів тому

      Also Kings were not absolute monarchs, Absolutism developed in France and was between roughly 1550-1800’s

  • @rstefan250
    @rstefan250 6 днів тому

    Well said

  • @mannygutierrez7654
    @mannygutierrez7654 6 днів тому

    This is an infantile analysis, one completely expecting conquered peoples to abandon their identities to embrace the power of an empire, of a people who never treated them as equal until maybe the past few decades, even then it's not like it's been an easy road. Our diverse identities need to be cohered into one American identity if we want to survive intact I'm not sure if you're educated on the history of race or class struggle in the US, but racism plays a role in so many areas of life in this country it's hard to describe I was born and raised in the US, I have perfect command of the English language and have been told more than once "WOW, you speak English well" I didn't even speak Spanish until I was in my teens I've been called racist names and told to go back to Mexico more than once You expect people to embrace an identity that we've always been told doesn't belong to us

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 5 днів тому

      I can see where you’re coming from, and I empathize with the challenges of integrating into a broader identity while facing such hostility. I lived in San Antonio, TX for many years, and I saw firsthand the reality of these tensions. But I don’t think my analysis is superficial. While it's fair to question how well it fits modern society, history suggests that internal division, rather than external conquest, is what often weakens empires. Rome’s collapse was largely driven by internal cultural fragmentation and loss of a shared identity. If we want a cohesive society, then fostering a sense of unity around shared values is essential."

  • @scottfoster3548
    @scottfoster3548 6 днів тому

    HELLO what I have been saying for some time look at any urban center ( was born here in My LA in 60 BUT any modern city will do) AND there are thousands of homeless barbarians that were not there when I was young. The growing homeless barbarians are gathering for seems like their enlightenment as we (our culture) enter our new Middle Ages and we await for WHAT is Our modern Renaissance. You get 2-points my friends AND remember VIva Roma but don't forget your Ostrogothic(homeless) barbarian taxes HUH.

  • @Kneecap22
    @Kneecap22 7 днів тому

    Do you think they are more powerful than the global South. There are many nations in the global South that have nuclear weapons. They have leftist and socialist and transhumanist movements. We will borrow the useful things from the American revolution, in order to spread socialist transhumanism to the global South. The South vs America will race for the singularity. Our battle will be legendary. The revolution will live on. We told you the socialist revolution isn't over, just like we tell you the industrial revolution isn't over, just like we tell you the American revolution isn't over. The American revolution have it's merits, will we use it. some of it's merits are : 1)recognizing all humans are equal, this is to first approximation true, because all human brains are about the same order of magnitude in mass and complexity. 2)freedom of expression, this is good and useful for learning new ideas, and exposing corrupt people and bad people. This free expression can expose morally corrupt people and make sure the bad people don't slowly outnumber the good people in government and the army. 3)the rule of law, not rule of a human. If it's rule of a human, then you are just subject to his whims, so he can take whatever he wants, so why work, when powerful people just steal? This leads to a society where people just joust for power. This leads to factions and groupism and group interest where the nash equilibrium game is to just fend for the group. This leads to people wasting a lot of time in politics, instead of investing time in their businesses or their work or their dream. Because without rule of law, you are always busy looking for your groups shifting internal politics. With rule of law, people are no longer at cold war, so can focus on many things, leading to a productive society in the long run. We will incorporate these merits in our own revolution. The Atheist afterlife is in the prosperity and Utopia for the superorganism. We only need the future of humanity. As long as the future of humanity is happy, I can die happy.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 7 днів тому

      Appreciate the detailed response. It’s fascinating that you envision a 'South vs. America' struggle for ideological dominance, although I would argue that history shows us such utopian revolutions rarely deliver on their promises. Borrowing principles from the American Revolution, like rule of law and free expression, is indeed wise, as they’ve proven essential to stable governance. However, socialism and transhumanism may struggle to incorporate these values while preserving individual freedom and accountability. Grand visions of global utopia are appealing, but without addressing the practical, human complexities involved, such ideals often end in disillusionment rather than prosperity. The challenge, as always, lies in balancing ambition with realism.

  • @Lablovercomedy
    @Lablovercomedy 7 днів тому

    You’ve nailed it. DEI is toxic. People resent it. It corrodes social and work place cohesion. A successful pluralistic society is built on respecting our shared humanity and shared values: fairness, merit and equality!

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 6 днів тому

      Thank you, I couldn't agree more. DEI, as it's applied today, often undermines the very cohesion it claims to foster. By fixating on immutable characteristics over merit and shared values, it creates division rather than unity. True pluralism isn’t about amplifying differences but about building on common ground-things like fairness, hard work, and mutual respect. When we shift focus from the individual’s contributions to group identity, we erode the foundations of a successful society. A shared commitment to merit and equality before the law has built stronger, more resilient communities than any top-down program ever could.

  • @LennoxElgey
    @LennoxElgey 9 днів тому

    I fully agree with pretty much all that you said. And you laid it out very coherently and clearly without any confusing nonsense thrown in. Good vid man! Keep doing what your doing! 😁

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 9 днів тому

    As always, thank you for watching.

    • @Quartzite
      @Quartzite 8 днів тому

      You're welcome 🤗

  • @MarmiteMangoMachine
    @MarmiteMangoMachine 9 днів тому

    The clash of fundamental identity with abstract identity is irreconcilable. Dominance hierarchies will always exist both within and between groups. The mice can invite a few cats to join their mouse empire, and the cats can successfully integrate, but the moment the cats become a powerful enough group within the empire, they will turn on the mice. Biology > ideology.

  • @rhoetusochten4211
    @rhoetusochten4211 10 днів тому

    Are you starting to empathize with Cassandra of lore?

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 9 днів тому

      Starting? Unfortunately, I feel like this has been going on since long before the pandemic, which itself feels like a life time ago. Although, I feel like people are starting to wake up.

  • @marcv2648
    @marcv2648 10 днів тому

    People alive today do not have legitimate grievances for things that happened centuries ago. All those people are dead.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 6 днів тому

      Whilst I agree with you, I'm not sure I understand the context. Would you elaborate?

    • @marcv2648
      @marcv2648 6 днів тому

      @@Somewhat_Scientific There is a principle in common law known as the dead hand. It is foundational to the ethos of England and its offspring.

    • @marcv2648
      @marcv2648 6 днів тому

      @@Somewhat_Scientific You do not hold the son responsible for the sins of the father. Not in a civilized English common law society.

  • @Jerbert-qn4in
    @Jerbert-qn4in 10 днів тому

    All politics are identity politics.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 10 днів тому

      I understand the perspective that identity often plays a role in politics, but ideally, politics should focus on policies and solutions that benefit society as a whole rather than dividing along identity lines. When political debate becomes primarily about identity, it risks overshadowing critical issues like economic stability, education, and security.

    • @Jerbert-qn4in
      @Jerbert-qn4in 10 днів тому

      @@Somewhat_Scientific i mean i agree with you, but the issue is that what is important to someone is also tied to their identity and our identities are tied to our environment. What we think about ourselves is not in isolation. We are all very emotional animals and psychology always plays a massive role. Furthermore you might reason that politics is always about distorting say markets or nature and this is always tied to groupthink and fear. You see stuff like this even in science and very smart people. Im not saying it's hopeless lol, but it's important to be mindful of such dynamics. I think in the west we were a bit too naive about human nature and our own shadow.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 5 днів тому

      You're absolutely right, and I completely agree. Our environments shape us profoundly, and the idea that we can separate ourselves from our identities is naïve, especially in the West where we’ve largely tried to ignore the complexities of human nature. We’re not just rational beings-psychology, tribalism, and emotions all play significant roles in shaping our beliefs and priorities, and we see this everywhere, even in supposedly ‘objective’ fields like science. The challenge, then, isn’t to pretend we can escape identity entirely, but to be aware of how it influences us and to avoid letting it dominate our political thinking. If we let identity take over, we risk making politics little more than a battle of tribes rather than a constructive path toward a stable society.

    • @Jerbert-qn4in
      @Jerbert-qn4in 5 днів тому

      @Somewhat_Scientific spot on

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 10 днів тому

    As always, thank you for watching.

  • @Sam-_-
    @Sam-_- 10 днів тому

    A society dies by suicide

  • @mikestone8461
    @mikestone8461 11 днів тому

    the rise of identity politics? more like the rise of uncontrolled diversity and replacement which was never asked for.

  • @wiseonwords
    @wiseonwords 11 днів тому

    Well, this is certainly the path we seem to be on in Canada!

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 11 днів тому

      Disappointingly, I feel you are right. I only hope the next election can go some way to changing course.

  • @villhelm
    @villhelm 11 днів тому

    This wasn’t a problem when we were a homogeneous population within our nation. It’s only since we’ve allowed members of other tribes (nations) into our borders and allowed them into the halls of power has this rot set in.

    • @Jerbert-qn4in
      @Jerbert-qn4in 10 днів тому

      Exactly, this is gaslighting of the dreamers who messed it up

    • @stephenmurray2851
      @stephenmurray2851 10 днів тому

      It.s being done on purpose. I work in the system. They are bringing in millions of immigrants and taxing the indigenous populace into poverty to transfer money in free benefits to millions of low IQ immigrants. Mainly non white.

    • @zaccht8464
      @zaccht8464 9 днів тому

      ​@Jerbert-qn4in I'm sorry but I have to disagree. It was the dreamers that gave us the ideas of a nation in the first place. As well as democracy. It's my believe that the conservatives (couldn't think of a better word, sorry) of today would have fought against the French revolution and the idea of nations in the first place etc. You would have called them 'dreamers' and 'idealists' back then. They would have told them it was the power of the king that made their nation so great. Not the people. Not to mention that our 'nations' were definitely NOT homogeneous to begin with. Unless you only consider race and language (as many do) and not common values. Feel free to call me naive, i know my historical knowledge can be lacking sometimes. Tell me why I'm wrong, I'll listen.

    • @stephenmurray2851
      @stephenmurray2851 9 днів тому

      @@zaccht8464 we were homogeneous. Don't lie. The country was practically 100 percent white prior to Blair opening the flood gates in 1997.

    • @LondonMoneyCashEnterprise
      @LondonMoneyCashEnterprise 9 днів тому

      @@stephenmurray2851 the country wasnt close to 100 percent white in 1997 though? this is just false

  • @williamjones7249
    @williamjones7249 11 днів тому

    At last someone who can see history repeating itself as it always tries

  • @lukemacklin7557
    @lukemacklin7557 11 днів тому

    Whole heartedly agree, subscribed.

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 13 днів тому

    Hopefully people don't find this too controversial. Do I make a valid point or have I missed the mark?

    • @jakescott1571
      @jakescott1571 13 днів тому

      I think this had a great tone and this seems to be a call for reflection and discussion. Not too controversial for me!

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 13 днів тому

      Thank you. That was the tone I was hoping for.

    • @bradendocherty4816
      @bradendocherty4816 12 днів тому

      Good speech... I do, however, feel you were being a bit optimistic in your outro. The White Christian west is circling the drain into Whateverland. But hey, we had a good run... the world has just become too small for us.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 11 днів тому

      I do believe that you are correct, but hope and optimism are powerful, and I feel there's enough of us who feel this way and ifnwe just spoke out more often and more consistently, that would help everyone.

  • @LukeDickerson1993
    @LukeDickerson1993 15 днів тому

    this is why i watch youtube instead of tiktok. cause im an intellectual xD

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      Ha! I guess it can all be viewed as a race to the bottom...

  • @waxoman
    @waxoman 15 днів тому

    I feel like ai is going to have a huge impact on the gig economy.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      Absolutely. They'll call it 'streamlining' or something, but it will ultimately mean less pay for workers and more profit for corporations.

  • @ryan771211
    @ryan771211 15 днів тому

    not just gig workers, 9-5workers are not much better either

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      Unfortunately, all too true. All workers are getting squeezed.

  • @MH_Bikes
    @MH_Bikes 15 днів тому

    The Gig Economy is for those with poor math skills.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      You're not wrong, but times are hard for many people. And, I think the parallels are unfortunately all too accurate.

    • @MH_Bikes
      @MH_Bikes 15 днів тому

      @@Somewhat_Scientific My grandfather was a salesman during the Great Depression. Lower your standards once, and learn to live there.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      That's a powerful statement.

  • @Joe-sg9ll
    @Joe-sg9ll 15 днів тому

    those silly games where you collect virtual land seems symbolic for whats actually going on behind the scenes. big tech companies are digital spaces, the site is a carving out of an area, then you can participate by congregating. reminded also of the chappelle skit of a VR mall. the website or app is a place and the members are new serfs or merchants or visitors

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      I couldn't agree more! The Chappelle comparison is very appropriate.

  • @DrDanQ92
    @DrDanQ92 15 днів тому

    I think there's an argument for life under feudalism being better; the medieval peasants would know their lord personally and often dine at their table or in their hall. I will never know Bezos, Musk or Gates personally and I will never dine at their table or be able to influence their ideas and visions.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      You raise a valid point about the personal connections of the past. While it's true that feudal lords were more accessible, let's not romanticize the past - it was harsh and unrelenting. Today’s economy seems to be recreating many of the inequalities of medieval life, where so many workers lack security and autonomy, trapped in a cycle that benefits a few at the top.

    • @DrDanQ92
      @DrDanQ92 15 днів тому

      @@Somewhat_Scientific Not trying to romanticize the past - merely saying that our modern system in some ways is even worse than the feudal one which it gets compared to or that we are warned that we are headed towards.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific 15 днів тому

      Ah okay. I agree. It is, at least in my opinion, a very troubling path that we are on that could end up being far worse for many people.

  • @Autinond
    @Autinond 15 днів тому

    Cool, i love medieval castles and knights, thanks capitalism!

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 16 днів тому

    As always, thank you for watching. Please, let me know what you think in the comments.

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 17 днів тому

    As always, thank you for watching. Please, let me know what you think. Does Halloween still have a purpose beyond the commercial event it has become?

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 17 днів тому

    New style of video today. My webcam isn't the best and it's the first time I've recorded a video in this way, so it's a little rough in places, but please, let me know what you think.

  • @zacktherrien7010
    @zacktherrien7010 18 днів тому

    Great video !!!!

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 21 день тому

    As always, thank you for watching. Please, let me know what you think in the comments. Feedback is greatly appreciated!

  • @neilgillespie7435
    @neilgillespie7435 25 днів тому

    Well done

  • @kavikv.d.hexenholtz3474
    @kavikv.d.hexenholtz3474 Місяць тому

    Halloween is _not_ a holiday that has close ties to the ancient past, nor does it have some ‘pagan’ antecedent, nor is it a continuation of several ancient pre-Christian customs. To say that Halloween’s connections to Samhain or anything “ancient” are, at best, extremely tenuous, would be grossly overstating the facts. Virtually all of the customs associated with the modern secular celebration of Halloween developed only in the past 500 years and have no connections to ancient pagan religious practices. When we celebrate Halloween, we are definitely participating in a tradition with deep historical roots. But those roots are firmly situated in the medieval Christian past, not an ancient pagan one.

    • @LeslieWitton
      @LeslieWitton Місяць тому

      It's fascinating how Halloween has evolved over time, and while many of its modern customs emerged during the Christian era, it’s hard to ignore the echoes of Samhain. Even early Christian practices seem to have built upon elements of this ancient festival, blending traditions as cultures intersected.

    • @Somewhat_Scientific
      @Somewhat_Scientific Місяць тому

      I agree that the links between Halloween and ancient traditions like Samhain can be definitely be considered tenuous, especially when we examine the specifics of modern customs. However, it's hard to overlook the broader cultural influences that seem to carry forward. Samhain, as a festival marking the end of harvest and a time when the veil between worlds was thought to thin, shares considerable thematic elements with both early Christian and modern Halloween traditions. Granted, whilst the customs themselves may have evolved significantly/separately, there seems to be a somewhat linear progression that reflects an ongoing blending of pagan and Christian influences. I think I missed the point with this video, the transformation over centuries is what makes Halloween such a rich and layered celebration today and something I think I should explore further and be more clear about.

    • @kavikv.d.hexenholtz3474
      @kavikv.d.hexenholtz3474 Місяць тому

      @@LeslieWitton All three holidays, Halloween, All Saint’s Day, and Samhain share a common date and perhaps a “feeling”, but that’s really about it. Indeed, so much of Halloween “feels” Pagan that attempts to connect those things to ancient Samhain simply feels right.

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific Місяць тому

    As always, thank you for watching. Please, let me know what you think.

  • @jeanattali4005
    @jeanattali4005 Місяць тому

    Captivating. Thank you.

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific Місяць тому

    Do you think there's still a place for Aristotle's concept of a good life in the modern world? And as always, thank you for watching. I hope you enjoyed this video.

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific Місяць тому

    In today’s world of quick tweets and viral videos, do you think Cicero’s emphasis on logos, pathos, and ethos is still achievable in political discourse? Or has social media made emotional appeal (pathos) dominate the conversation?

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific Місяць тому

    Can democracy truly function when social media algorithms push content designed to provoke outrage rather than foster meaningful debate? What role do you think personal responsibility plays in this?

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific Місяць тому

    What do you think, is there scope for a 'Philosopher King' leader in politics today?

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific Місяць тому

    I’m curious - do you think society puts too much emphasis on personal success over kindness? Let me know what you think.

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 2 місяці тому

    Do you think Plato’s ideal of justice from The Republic still holds value today? What’s your opinion on how modern courts deliver justice compared to the ideals discussed in The Republic?

  • @Somewhat_Scientific
    @Somewhat_Scientific 2 місяці тому

    Does history really repeat itself? After watching, do you think modern superpowers are destined to fall like Rome, or can they change course?

  • @mikejones-go8vz
    @mikejones-go8vz 5 місяців тому

    I just started to watch a documentary on Mesopotamia, the narrator was too dramatic, I decided to watch one on Cuneiform as I finished a hieroglyphic one last night. Yours is so much better, easier on the ear. So many are over dramatised. Thank you and I have subscribed 👍🏽