Broadly Specific
Broadly Specific
  • 6
  • 774 661
How this film warned us about AI Art
Be our UA-cam Supporter: broadly-specific.com/UA-cam
Consider supporting us on Patreon for bonus content, early access, shout-outs and more:
www.patreon.com/broadly_specific
Visit Our Website broadly-specific.com/
Instagram:
broadly_specific
Twitter: @broadlycinema
Discord: discord.gg/Q8XSA868dq
Written, Directed and Edited by Bondan Syamsu (IG: @bondansyamsu)
Narrated by Sei Violette ( @seiviolette ).
Email: editorial@broadly-specific.com
SUMMARY
Discourses on the exploitative nature of generative AI and its effect on the art and entertainment industry are prevalent, with arguments on both sides stating not only whether AI art is ethical in its usage of artists' artworks as training data, but also whether they can be considered "art" at all. In our video, we recontextualize Brian De Palma's 1974 cult classic Phantom of the Paradise, a film which satirizes the exploitative music industry into a cautionary tale folktale on generative AI and its exploitative nature.
CHAPTERS
0:00 - Intro
2:25 - Folklore, Myths, and Film as Modern Folklore
4:09 - Phantom of the Paradise Introduction & Summary
7:17 - Phantom of the Paradise's Parallels With AI Art Exploitation
12:12 - Art as content, Commodity Fetishism, Walter Benjamin's The Aura
16:39 - Final Words
18:50 - Outro
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Benjamin, W. (1936). The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction.
Davison, A. (2018). Deals with the Devil: Faust, Contracts, and the Dangers of Mechanical Reproduction in Brian De Palma’s Phantom of the Paradise (1974). The Opera Quarterly, 34(2-3), 201-220. doi:10.1093/oq/kby013
This wonderful short writing on AI art by Ivan Schneider: ivantohelpyou.com/2022/10/27/thoughts-on-ai-art/
Professor Paul H. Fry from Yale University: oyc.yale.edu/english/engl-300/lecture-17
SOME LINKS
www.reuters.com/world/us/actors-hollywood-studios-still-odds-ai-other-issues-union-says-2023-11-02/
www.theverge.com/2023/1/16/23557098/generative-ai-art-copyright-legal-lawsuit-stable-diffusion-midjourney-deviantart
www.theverge.com/2023/7/13/23794224/sag-aftra-actors-strike-ai-image-rights
www.npr.org/2023/05/18/1176876301/striking-hollywood-writers-contemplate-ai
gizmodo.com/ai-video-game-voice-actors-fear-voice123-writers-strike-1850466949
www.thewrap.com/animated-films-cost-ai-jeffrey-katzenberg/
MUSIC (Order of Appearance)
Song 1: "Vibing Over Venus" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Song 2: "Samba Isobel" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Song 3: Never thought I’d get to meet the devil (From Phantom of the Paradise)
Song 4: "Bossa Antigua" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Song 5: "Coriolan Overture, Op. 62", a free-use public domain song by Ludwig van Beethoven, courtesy of Musopen: musopen.org/
Song 6: String Quartet No. 15 in D minor, Mov. 1, K. 421", a free-use public domain song by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, courtesy of Musopen: musopen.org/
Song 7: "String Quartet No. 1 in A Major, Movement 1", a free-use public domain song by Alexander Borodin, courtesy of Musopen: musopen.org/
Song 8: Live From The Moon - Action Bronson (Live at NPR Tiny Desk Concert)
Thank you to Pexels for the stock footage used in this video.
FILMS/SERIES SHOWN (Order of Appearance)
Phantom of the Paradise (1974) dir. Brian De Palma
The Tale of the Dead Princess and the Seven Knights (1951) dir. Ivan Ivanov-Vano
Godzilla (1954) dir. Ishiro Honda
Night of the Living Dead (1968) dir. George A. Romero
The Terminator (1984) dir. John Cameron
Blade Runner (1984) dir. Ridley Scott
Pluto (2023- ) dir. Toshio Kawaguchi
Frankenstein (1931) dir. James Whale
Interstella 5555 (2003) dir. Leiji Matsumoto, Kazuhisa Takenouchi, Hirotoshi Rissen, Daisuke Nishio
Doctor Who (Series 5, Episode 10)
The 400 Blows (1959) dir. Francois Truffaut
Close-up (1990) dir. Abbas Kiarostami
Memories: Cannon Fodder (1995) dir. Katsuhiro Otomo
THANK YOU TO OUR PATRONS
OFFICIAL SPONSORS
Sei Violette
In my element
PATRONS
Jordan Walters
Andhika Pielaat
Zed Orchard
Umi Hoshii
Keywords:
Phantom of the Paradise, Generative AI, Brian De Palma, Cult Film, AI Art, Cinema, Film, why ai art is bad, ai art controversy, ai art debate, ai art is art theft
#phantomoftheparadise #videoessay #cinema #filmanalysis #movieanalysis #generativeai #generativeaiart
DISCLAIMER
The use of film scenes and music in this video is fair use for commentary, criticism and analysis. I do not own the rights to any of the footage shown. All rights go to the copyright owners and no infringement is intended.
Переглядів: 1 572

Відео

Why you hear this Indonesian song everywhere | Bengawan Solo
Переглядів 770 тис.Рік тому
Bahasa Indonesia subtitles are available! (Ada subtitle Bahasa Indonesia!). Bengawan Solo is a song that you can hear everywhere in Asia, watch this video to learn about the little known history of this song by Indonesian Kroncong musician Gesang Martohartono. Be our UA-cam Supporter: broadly-specific.com/UA-cam Visit Our Website broadly-specific.com/ Instagram: broadly_specific ...
Akira Kurosawa's Self-Sacrificial Doctors
Переглядів 2,1 тис.Рік тому
Thank you for watching our first-ever video essay. Consider leaving a like, commenting and subscribing to support our channel. Be our UA-cam Supporter: broadly-specific.com/UA-cam Visit Our Website broadly-specific.com/ Instagram: broadly_specific dontlookawaycinema Consider supporting us on Patreon for bonus content, early access, shout-outs and more: www.patreon....
If Tampopo Was a Thriller
Переглядів 908Рік тому
An editing experiment by our contributor Troy Vimalasatya Edited by Troy Vimalasatya Visit our website broadly-specific.com Follow us: Instagram: broadly_specific Twitter: broadlyfilms #tampopo #criterioncollection #movieedits #cinephile #cinephilecommunity #mubi #japanesefilm #japanesemovie

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @Bubbles-od2tv
    @Bubbles-od2tv 8 днів тому

    Indonesians are a very musically talented people, the most talented in South East Asia. In Singapore, there are beautiful Malay songs like Tanjung Katong, Geylang Sipaku Geylang, ChanMaliChan, and of course Dayung Sampan which i learnt in school. I thought it was Malaysian, but now i realise it's Indonesian.

  • @CheeseHamSandwich
    @CheeseHamSandwich 9 днів тому

    Lemme ask something, why does old Indonesian feels more... epic. Like all the wars and the songs they made are more epic than nowadays things here

  • @edhofiko3168
    @edhofiko3168 17 днів тому

    came for bengawan solo, got a history lesson instead

  • @jashinsamael
    @jashinsamael 17 днів тому

    im indonesian and i never knew this song was this famous.

  • @m.febriansyahdwiputra4355
    @m.febriansyahdwiputra4355 25 днів тому

    And then there is this country who claimed indonesian culture

  • @QQCC-zq8zk
    @QQCC-zq8zk 25 днів тому

    yeah... that damn europe colonial thiefing

  • @onlysound4832
    @onlysound4832 29 днів тому

    13:20 history is repeated. nowdays, many singer didnt write their own song, they covering somones song.

  • @3tri2Go
    @3tri2Go Місяць тому

    Teruskanlah budaya Indonesia wahai pemuda

  • @gracefullyhis6965
    @gracefullyhis6965 Місяць тому

    There's also a Fijian version brooo

  • @wisnuandre2038
    @wisnuandre2038 Місяць тому

    old money aura

  • @jarkapedz9961
    @jarkapedz9961 Місяць тому

    Aside from agus meme this is another song that played a lot aboard huh😂

  • @OfficialKerangkaBerfikir
    @OfficialKerangkaBerfikir Місяць тому

    Legendary ❤

  • @L444NG
    @L444NG Місяць тому

    I think because so many people of JAVA go everywhere and The song go with them, the song is friend for java people when go everywhere.

  • @pakjoko508
    @pakjoko508 Місяць тому

    Malingsia 🇲🇾 means this song from Malaysia

  • @retro0019
    @retro0019 Місяць тому

    As an "INDONESHIT"🤓

    • @HOK4FUN
      @HOK4FUN Місяць тому

      INDONESIA ❤

    • @retro0019
      @retro0019 Місяць тому

      Wow wow just wow As an Indoneshit cock Country this shit hit hard

  • @prikaayudiahrahmasari2977
    @prikaayudiahrahmasari2977 Місяць тому

    Musik keroncong sangat digemari dari yang tua sampai muda . Dengan tiupan suara suling , genjrengan ukulele dan gitar , hingga gesekan biola yang indah banyak disukai dari dahulu hingga sekarang. Alfatihah buat sang maestro Gesang! Karyamu akan tetap abadi....

  • @monanggodang
    @monanggodang Місяць тому

    Halo, baru nemu video ini. Suka sekali ama video2 dokumentary tentang Indonesia yg di jaman awal Jepang masuk seperti video propaganda Asia Timur Raya. Jarang banget bisa nonton yg spt itu.

  • @Shyousm
    @Shyousm Місяць тому

    Lah baru tau wak🙂

  • @christofell
    @christofell Місяць тому

    Why does the narrator sounds like shes on the verge of tearing up??? 😭😭

  • @tuckloe5108
    @tuckloe5108 Місяць тому

    Begawan Solo is another one of those songs that evoke nostalgia, for example my young self, like Sukiyaki.

  • @racist2708
    @racist2708 Місяць тому

    ok

  • @Boxing_Now
    @Boxing_Now Місяць тому

    This song is "DIFFERENT"

  • @hengkieporawouw3691
    @hengkieporawouw3691 Місяць тому

    What a story...very true...Gbu.

  • @Wlimvee
    @Wlimvee Місяць тому

    I don't know if it's just me being too young to know, but i've never really heard of bengawan solo. I really loved learning the song and and the history and i hope my peers get to see this amazing video too!! love from Indonesia

  • @amiremangjong866
    @amiremangjong866 Місяць тому

    pls make a skin or smth that makes them happy

  • @abditooy8096
    @abditooy8096 Місяць тому

    Mind blowing.. Indonesian here, great to know.. 😮😮

  • @ThePineapples-hg9jl
    @ThePineapples-hg9jl Місяць тому

    I think I can't watch it🙈

  • @ThePineapples-hg9jl
    @ThePineapples-hg9jl Місяць тому

    Yes, Bengawan Solo and Selendang Sutera are reminiscing of colonial era and proving the fighting of our elders made Indonesia be independent free from colonial. Thank you for brought this history to internet Broadly Specific Team ❤

  • @BhchfgJbbcjvj
    @BhchfgJbbcjvj Місяць тому

    Im an Indonesian, but i've never heard of this song

    • @mjpMALIK
      @mjpMALIK Місяць тому

      Bergaul dek

    • @AlfonsiaArnoldia
      @AlfonsiaArnoldia Місяць тому

      lagu legend itu, tahun brapa ditahun lu emaklu masih muda lu blm lahir

  • @lavienelle
    @lavienelle Місяць тому

    i see in the mood for love, i click

  • @kvnrey
    @kvnrey Місяць тому

    Yeah you dumbass Indonesian. Youre too focused ranting your own people you thought youre smart enough dumbing down your own people

  • @cintaneysa
    @cintaneysa Місяць тому

    I'm from Surakarta, so proud of Mr. Gesang🤍🥹

  • @cooljosh2307
    @cooljosh2307 Місяць тому

    As an Indonesian, I'm surprised this didn't come up in the history books - or perhaps it used to back when Soekarno was still the president? The idea of the Pan Asian seems good though, seeing how the western nations exploit their colonies (even to this day). I wonder how Indonesia would've been right now had Japan won against the allied forces then?

  • @mahfudzdc
    @mahfudzdc Місяць тому

    damn, I dunno that this song was this recognizable

  • @chesteraliwinoto9456
    @chesteraliwinoto9456 Місяць тому

    Ketika denger berasa di tahun tahun 1900

  • @vincentdonothing
    @vincentdonothing Місяць тому

    YOU HAVE SUMMONED THE HORDES OF INDONESIAN PEOPLE

  • @fauzihazim5955
    @fauzihazim5955 Місяць тому

    RIP Gesang

  • @klewank2615
    @klewank2615 Місяць тому

    The Bengawan Solo River is not as beautiful as it used to be, there is a lot of batik factory waste. Many fish are dead.

  • @Kurokami300
    @Kurokami300 Місяць тому

    Never heard this bullshit

  • @MuhamadHudhud
    @MuhamadHudhud Місяць тому

    Is there a source of true love that shares the benefits of goodness with humanity on this earth?

  • @fmac6441
    @fmac6441 Місяць тому

    13:22 Antônio Carlos (Tom) Jobim, that is playing the guitar in other end is a prolific singer and songwriter that wrote both the portuguese (with Vinicius de Moraes) and the english version of Garota de Ipanema (girl from Ipanema).

  • @leopoldbroom7679
    @leopoldbroom7679 Місяць тому

    China and Japan may hate each other, but at least they agree that Bengawan Solo is a certified banger.

  • @アラ-t1j
    @アラ-t1j Місяць тому

    My granma's house is actually near bengawan solo in Bojonegoro, East Java. When i was around 4-5 y.o, everytime the water are calm enough(not that high/rising in the rainy season), i used to swim there with my granpa and cousin. This song brings those memories and hit me like a truck 😊 what a nice song~

  • @inlander311
    @inlander311 Місяць тому

    "Air Sungai Bengawan Solo Menghitam dan Bau Alkohol, Diduga Tercemar Limbah Ciu & Tekstil" (republika Dec 2023). Currently, all that remains of Bengawan Solo is the song , the river is badly polluted.

    • @a.p.raharjo1487
      @a.p.raharjo1487 Місяць тому

      Current pollution from RUM factory Sukoharjo

    • @AlfonsiaArnoldia
      @AlfonsiaArnoldia Місяць тому

      lagu legend itu, tahun brapa ditahun lu emaklu masih muda lu blm lahir mungkin,

  • @tytrack174
    @tytrack174 Місяць тому

    16:13 This is in Manila! I thought it may have been a scene from China or Hong Kong, but it’s actually from a scene in Manila during the 1940s 🤩

  • @watataenjoyer
    @watataenjoyer Місяць тому

    Melody reminds me of old school hokkien taiwanese enka songs

  • @jyotikhanspal1299
    @jyotikhanspal1299 2 місяці тому

    Oh my goodness Every song has a historical tale behind it, which is as fascinating as as the song itself It sounds so beautiful ( a very hackneyed cliche) even though incomprehensible Thanx Anu

  • @klalakomacoi
    @klalakomacoi 2 місяці тому

    Over here we call this song "Tagimoucia Ga"

  • @Psyopcyclops
    @Psyopcyclops 2 місяці тому

    I’ve never heard this song in my life. I’m surprised so many people have heard it. Clearly I’m living under a rock

    • @BhchfgJbbcjvj
      @BhchfgJbbcjvj Місяць тому

      im an Indonesian and i also have never heard this song

  • @SS-261
    @SS-261 2 місяці тому

    This mf is lying never heard this song before this vid liar lair pants on fire