Відео

Grammar is like music theory... You can totally learn to jam without it, but if you want to explain what you are doing and why, then you need it. But, let's be honest, most folks just speak and couldn't care less the theory behind why they say what they do. I might go so far as to say that grammar isn't really there to help you speak but to show you how much smarter your teacher is than you are...

Hey can I get help 😢

His English is quite comprehensible, his method of explanation is also very lucid. An ideal speaker of international fame.

I know each words don't enough to thank you About this incredible presention.. I feel a proud to myself because as one of your students to study and read your different hypothesises Dr. Stephen krashen Thanks alot our shining professor. 💙🌏

This was a great interview that clarified the hypothesis between learning and acquisition, regarding the doubts many latins have about this approach. On the other hand, reading for pleasure enhance other linguistic areas, Thanks so much.

my left ear, loved it

31:20 Grammar

How can one make an interview with Krashen

Good video! Thanks to the author for his good work! I'd like to recommend Yuri Ivantsiv's practice book Polyglot's Notes: Practical Tips for Learning a Foreign Language. This book has many useful methods for learning a foreign language, how to develop your memory, how to memorize words, learn grammar, quickly learn to speak, read and write. All recommend this excellent book! Good luck to everyone in learning a foreign language!

Que bello 🥺

What a brilliant lecture! Every word is worth it! Thank you, Doctor

Thank you!

Comments by Lewis made sense. One needs to know the rules of grammar as well as reading to acquire any languages well. Dr Krashen is pursuing his thesis that comprehensive input is all important - a lopsided view.

This guy doesn't know what he's talking about - full of hot air. It should be obvious to anyone that grammar rules are needed to be able to speak correctly from the very start and that, like anything we learn, whether it be how to swim or how to cook, the more often we repeat an action or say something, the less we have to think about the rule. Do you really think that Michael Phelps won dozens of Olympic gold medals by thinking about each and every movement his body was amking in the pool? No, it just becomes automatic after a while and you no longer need to think about it. Resorting to the rule when you make a mistake is too late - it's far easier to ensure that a student starts off on the right foot than to correct engrained mistakes. If people learn to speak languages proficiently as he suggests they do, migrants all over the world would become fluent L2 speakers because they are continually exposed to L2, but we all know that is far from the truth. Making an active effort to understnad the mechanics of whatever we're leaning can help us make progress more quickly.

Awesome. Life changing. Thank you.

Mr. Krashen, I'm NOT well read and I know, with zero trouble, the difference between it's and its; what say you good sir?

OMG. I so enjoy your lectures, and keep you in my prayers I (we) want you to be around dor a long, long time because we need you! God bless you and keep you with us healthy and strong!!

what does this have to do with language acquisition?

Mario soy Irma Salazar como sabes mi mama acaba de morir y estube platicando con tus hermanos y me dijeron que hacias, que te podia buscar en internet y me da muncho gusto ber y que a as triunfado y quien eres soy subtitute teacher y trabajo para Pasadena ISD y algo de lo que dises en este video lla lo se y te entiendo perfectamente felisidades

I have a question, how deaf people get comprehensible input? How they learn the language?

I think he sets up a straw man when he discusses grammar. Personally I enjoy grammar and use it in language learning. He characterises grammar as the real-time processing of rules, which we can all agree is impractical. But surely the useful way to use grammar is to use it to identify useful and reusable patterns and play with them with writing and speech till they become automatic. No-one would argue that this is a substitute for massive input, but I find that it can accelerate the internalisation of the basic communicative patterns - patterns that would be much slower to develop through pure induction.

My colleagues are off to an English Teaching Conference this week. Instead of that I watched this plenary and saved myself the whole weekend and $500.

La mejor :)

MArio, que bueno verte, los años no te hacen daño, saludos desde Venezuela, quisiera poder contactarte

La que habla 1ro es mi prima

He seems arrogant with her,

I am learning so much from him...wow. Awesome.

Hey, it sounds like he is taking about writing. I clicked on the link because it says Controversies and Issues in Language Teaching. Hmm. Anyway, I am happy I did. I am still learning something valuable.

i am doing what he says and i found his hypothesis are really working and extremely good. he has changed my life he has given me the right direction. he is my exampler.

Excellent job.. Jabarjust

He has a great sense of humor, but it took his audience almost half an hour to figure it out. Great presentation!

Donde puedo informarme de los precios?? o si me pueden decir por este medio, gracias...

Clear as a bell, lucid as a visionary.

That's freaking awesoooooooooooooome!!